Review of Rheumatology and Homoeopathic Management (Part-1: General Principles)
Review of Rheumatology and Homoeopathic Management (Part-1: General Principles)
Review of Rheumatology and Homoeopathic Management (Part-1: General Principles)
HOMOEOPATHIC MANAGEMENT
(PART-1 : GENERAL PRINCIPLES)
PRELOGUE
The term ‘rheumatism’ is derived from the Late Latin ‘rheumatismus’, ultimately from
Greek meaning ‘to suffer from a flux’, with the term ‘rheum’ meaning ‘bodily fluids’. Before
17th century, it was always referred to as ‘gout’ (commonly called ‘Gathiya Baye’ in India)
instead of the present day specific terms. ‘The meaning of a disease of the joints is first
recorded in 1688, because rheumatism was thought to be caused by an excessive flow of
rheum into a joint thereby stretching ligaments’ (H.W. Wilson Co. 1988 Quote, Barnhart Dictionary of Etymology).
Rheumatism is a term applied to a wide variety of diseases, which include muscle ache,
pain, stiffness and joint swelling occurring in the extremities and vertebral column. The
discomfort encountered can range from mild, poorly defined and vaguely localised
discomfort to pain of such an intensity that severly affects the patient’s general condition.
These joint symptoms may be varying from minor swellings or stiffness to severe destruction
and deformity , which prevent the affected joint or joints from functioning normally.
The understanding of the joint diseases has undergone a sea change with the advancement
in the medical science. It is insufficient to establish that a patient is suffering from
rheumatism, but needs further clarification. The modern physician is an alert clinician who
anticipates the problems beforehand and institutes intervention planning on sound clinical
footings, incorporating latest developments in the medical science. The emphasis is on
prompt institution of appropriate therapy (along with all available secondary care measures)
before irreversible joint damage has occurred.
The aim of this series is to adapt to this transition in the field of rheumatology so as to
abridge the gap in a meaningful manner. The amalgam of prevalent medical applications,
when incorporated in the light of homoeopathic principles, brings about an uniformity in the
treatment planning of each individual case. This facilitates the smooth interaction among
medical professionals on a rational and scientific basis, with uniformity in expression. At the
same time it maintains our great tradition of healing art in the purest form, and provides an
ample room and flexibility for every homoeopathic physician in his individual professional
judgement in every individual case in question.
The scope of rheumatology has increased to such an extent that it is becoming increasingly
difficult to mainatain a fundamental grasp on concepts. Moreover, the ever increasing
demands of time of a busy practioner add to these constraints. Therefore, we have adhered to
common conditions that a physician encounters at a primary care level providing relevant
information for day-to-day practice. This review series is not intended as an alternative to
other texts on rheumatology and homoeopathy as detailed descriptions are outside the scope
of this series. This represents a concise clinically oriented pattern specifically focussing on:
Review of joint anatomy, physiology, pathology, genesis of symptoms and signs, and
investigations with their significance and utility. It also includes a short case-taking
plan which emphasises the symptomatic as well as diagnostic approach, with a bedside
ready reference to important drugs.
Review of important arthritic conditions and each disease is dealt in terms of aetiology,
clinical features, investigations, prognosis and then adapting to homoeopathic
conceptual disease diagnosis. Treatment planning includes general management and
suggestions for important ready references to a few drugs, which should not to be taken
as a complete therapeutic index for that particular disease.
We have taken deliberate liberty to put certain chronic diseases in distinct clinical stages
while describing their classical presentation to fit in the conceptual homoeopathic progression
of the disease. It represents the core of the basic underlying concept and deals with an
orientation in adapting and processing joint complaints according to the guidelines of
homeopathic philosophy and miasmatic ideology which is the basis for the assessment,
prognosis and intervention planning for each individual case in question.
Small catalogue of few commonly used drugs has been added as a ready reckoner, with
therapeutic hints on constitutional, miasmatic, clinical, keynote and palliative prescribing.
However some of the drugs discussed are not very well proved and needs to be further
clinically verified.
JOINT ANATOMY
Joint is an articulation between two or more bones or cartilages. These are functionally
classified as immovable, slightly movable and freely movable joints:
SYNOVIAL JOINT
Bony Articulation
Articular bony ends are covered by hyaline cartilage. Articular cartilage is devoid of
vascular, nerve, and lymphatic supply. It receives nutrition from the synovial fluid. It is
not covered with the synovial membrane.
Articular cartilage has a wear resistant, low frictional, compressible, elastic, lubricated
surface ideally suited for easy movement over a similar surface and absorption of large
forces of compression and shear generated by gravity and muscular power.
Ageing results in thinner, less cellular, firmer and more brittle cartilage, as commonly
seen in degenerative arthrosis.
Fibrous Capsule:
It is attached to the articular ends of the bones. It is made-up of white connective tissue. It
is pierced by the blood vessels and nerves. It may form localised thickening, forming
ligaments and separate accessory ligaments.
It is tough but flexible. It checks excessive or abnormal movements. It is protected from
excessive tension by the reflex contraction of the appropriate muscles. Continued and
excessive strain results in the loss of resilience of the capsule.
Synovial Membrane:
It lines the inner surface of the fibrous capsule.
It secrets a fluid ‘synovia’ which lubricates and provides nourishment to the articular
cartilage.
Blood Supply:
Periarticular plexus: Arteries near the joint give articular and epiphyseal branches, and
supplies the capsule, synovial membrane and epiphyseal union.
Nerve Supply:
Capsule and ligaments have rich nerve supply, and are sensitive to pain. Synovial
membrane has least nerve supply, and is mildly sensitive to pain. Articular cartilage has
no nerve endings, and is insensitive to pain.
Nerve which supplies the joint also supplies the group of muscles acting on the joint and
the skin covering the joint. Therefore, in joint diseases, muscles reflexly contract and fix
the joint in a comfortable position, and also there may be referred pain in the skin
overlying the joint.
VERTEBRAL JOINT
The two vertebrae are joined by the intervertebral discs. These discs are semi-elastic in
nature and act as shock absorbers when the load on the vertebral column is increased.
Intervertebral disc consists of two parts:
JOINT PATHOLOGY
SYNOVIAL JOINT
The synovial joint pathology can be grouped in reference to the involvement of the joint
structure (along with the most suitable organopathic clue to few drugs) which may be
grouped as under:
1. ARTICULAR COMPONENT
It comprises of the bony ends along with the articular cartilage, synovial membrane and joint
capsule. Disorders affecting the articular joint components are of two main varieties:
Degenerative Arthrosis Inflammatory Arthritis
Features It is characterised by focal cartilage It is dominated with the inflammation of
loss, subchondral bone retraction, the synovial membrane, followed by loss
with simultaneous proliferation of of articular cartilage and subchondral
new bone and cartilage, remodelling bone damage.
of joint contour and mild synovitis.
Clinical -Pain in joint. -Pain in joint.
Features -Limitation of joint function. -Limitation of joint function.
-Bony swelling, with local tender -Soft tissue swelling, with marked
spots. tenderness.
-Morning stiffness of less than 1 -Morning stiffness of more than 1 hour
hour duration. duration.
-Stiffness after rest of less than 5 -Stiffness after rest of more than 5
minutes duration. minutes.
-Stiffness increases with use and -Stiffness improves with activity.
weight bearing. -Signs of inflammation, warmth, effusion
-Crepitus present but signs of and joint crepitations are present.
inflammation are lacking. -Laboratory evidence of inflammation,
-Laboratory evidence of e.g. elevated ESR, elevated CRP,
inflammation, e.g. ESR, CRP, etc. hypoalbuminaemia, normochromic
may be normal. normocytic anaemia, thrombocytosis.
Common Osteoarthrosis, spondylosis, Immune mediated (SLE, RA), Reactive
Examples traumatic conditions (reactive arthritis), Infectious (gonococcal
arthritis, pyogenic arthritis), crystal
induced (gout, pseudogout).
Common Angustura vera, Baryta muriaticum, Actaea spicata, Alfalfa, Apis, Belladona,
Drugs Calcarea fluorica, Conium, Bryonia, Chininum sulphuricum, Formic
Gettysburg water, Kali hydroidicum, acid, Formica rufa, Gaultheria, Rhus
Lycopodium, Mercurius, toxicodendron.
Phosphorus, Phytolacca, Radium
bromide, Selenium, Syphilinum,
Thuja, X-Ray.
2. PERI-ARTICULAR COMPONENT
It comprises of structures surrounding articular components. Disorders affecting the peri-
articular joint components are of two main varieties:
Synovial Insertional
Features Synovial lining of the bursae and the It includes affection at the point of
tendon sheaths are involved. The insertion of the ligaments and tendons into
common pathology involving these the bone. The common pathology
structures is inflammatory synovial involving these is tendinitis which occurs
disease (e.g. rheumatoid arthrotis) at the site of tendon insertion, or within
and repetitive trauma. the tendon sheath along the tendon’s
course. Common cause is repetitive strain.
Clinical -Tenderness over the bursa which -Affected tendon is tender to pressure.
Features can be pointed by a finger tip. -Pain aggravates when the affected part is
-If the bursa is superficial it may actively used against resistance. Pain is
appear as superficial and local comparatively less on the passive
swelling. movement.
-Pain is aggravated on moving the -Joint movements are not restricted.
ligament or soft tissue covering the -Commonly involved sites are:
bursa. Usually the pain is absent if supraspinatus, biceps, triceps, tendo-
the nearby joint is moved passively. achilles.
Common Subacromial bursitis, olecranon Golfer’s elbow (common flexors at medial
Examples bursitis, trochanteric bursitis, pre- epicondyle), Tennis elbow (common
patellar bursitis (housemaid’s knee), extensors at lateral epicondyle), Achilles
retrocalcaneal bursitis, infra-patellar tendinitis (insertion of tendo-achilles on
bursitis (clergyman’s bursitis). calcaneum).
Common Apis, Arnica, Benzoicum acidum, Arnica, Causticum, Cereus bonplandii,
Drugs Bryonia, Formic acidum, Ledum palustre, Phytolacca, Ruta.
Phytolacca, Rhus toxicodendron,
Ruta, Sticta.
3. NEUROGENIC COMPONENT
Nerve Root Affection Peripheral Nerve Entrapment
Features Compression is the common cause The common pathology involved is the
of irritation to the nerve roots at the compression to nerves subsequent in their
intervertebral foramen or subsequent course.
in their course.
Clinical -Location and character: Local pain -Location and sensation: Shooting pain or
Features and stiffness in the spine. paraesthesia distal to the nerve
Asymmetrical paraspinal muscle entrapment.
spasm causes compensatory -Radiation: Distally.
scoliosis. -Aggravation: At night.
-Radiation: Characteristic -On examination: Sensory loss usual,
dermatomal distribution. occasionally hyperaesthesia; does not
-Sensory-motor changes: Sharp correspond to the nerve root distribution.
pain, hyperaesthesia, anaesthesia,
paraesthesia. Motor weakness in the
innervated muscles.
-Deep tendon reflexes: Diminished
or lost.
-Aggravation: On turning the neck
or lumbar spine. Straight leg raising
test increases the symptoms in the
nerve root distribution.
Common Prolapse intervertebral disc, cervical Carpal tunnel syndrome (median nerve
Examples and lumbar spondyloses. compression at wrist), ulnar nerve
entrapment at elbow.
Common Arnica, Causticum, Gnaphalium, Calcarea fluorica, Causticum, Cereus
Drugs Hypericum, Rhus toxicodendron. bonplandii, Gnaphalium, Hypericum,
Phytolacca.
VERTEBRAL JOINT
The vertebral joints or the intervertebral discs most commonly affected are those where a
mobile part of the vertebral column joins a relatively immobile part, i.e. cervico-thoracic
junction and lumbo-sacral junction.
GENDER
Category Common Examples Common Drugs
Females Rheumatoid arthritis Caulophyllum, Pulsatilla, Sepia
predominate Rheumatic fever Apis, Belladona
Males Ankylosing Spondylitis Lycopodium, Mercurius, Thuja
predominate Gout Lycopodium
Boys only Haemophilic arthritis Phosphorus
Males = Females Degenerative arthrosis Calcarea carbonica, Lycopodium, Sulphur
ONSET
Type Common Examples Common Drugs
Acute Rheumatic fever Aconite, Apis, Belladona, Eupatorium perfoliatum
Gout Formic acid, Ledum palustre, Urtica urens
Sub-acute Rheumatoid arthritis Actaea spicata, Causticum
Ankylosing spondylitis Bryonia, Rhus toxicodendron
Psoriatic arthropathy Antimonium crudum, Natrum arsenicosum
Insidious Degenerative arthrosis Calcarea carbonica, Lycopodium, Sulphur, Thuja
Neuropathic arthritis Syphilinum
PRECIPITATING CAUSES
Cause Common Examples Common Drugs
Trauma; Rheumatoid arthritis Caulophyllum: after abortion or child birth
mental or Pyogenic arthritis Arnica
physical Haemophilic arthritis Arnica
Psychogenic Rheumatism Ignatia, Natrum muriaticum
Sore throat Rheumatic fever Streptococcin
Lowered Tubercular arthritis Iodium, Phosphorus, Tuberculinum
vitality Rheumatic fever Sulphur, Tuberculinum
Altered Rheumatoid arthritis, SLE, Thuja
immunity connective tissue disorders
Hormonal Rheumatoid arthritis Pulsatilla: at the time of puberty or
disturbance menopause; Sepia: at the time of menopause
Exposure to Soft tissue rheumatism Dulcamara, Natrum sulphuricum
cold, humid
conditions
RHEUMATOLOGICAL SYMPTOMS
PAIN:
Pain is the most common symptom in rheumatology and most vague and subjective both
in description and severity.
The estimation of severity is required in assessing the progress of the disease or the
response to treatment.
The patient is asked to mark the severity on an analogue scale of 1–10, with 1 being mild
and easily ignored and 10 being totally unbearable. However, patients are not able to
differentiate between 1, 2, 3 or 8, 9, 10.
A simpler gradation is as follows:
SWELLING:
DEFORMITY
WEAKNESS:
Generalized weakness is a feature of all chronic illness, and any prolonged joint
dysfunction will inevitably lead to weakness of the associated muscles.
Gradation of muscle power:
Grade Description
0 No contraction or muscle movement
1 Visible muscle contraction, but no movement at the joint
2 Movement at the joint, but not against gravity
3 Movement against gravity, but not against added resistance
4 Movement against external resistance, but with less strength than usual
5 Normal strength
DISABILITY:
Gradation of disability at the time of examination:
Class-I Active
Class-II Restricted yet self care possible
Class-III Marked restriction, self care impossible
Class-IV Confined to bed
GAIT:
OTHERS:
Fever, lymphadenopathy, lassitude, malaise, vasomotor disturbances, numbness, weight
loss or weight gain, general debility (common associated symptoms with inflammatory
and menopausal arthritic affections)
PAST HISTORY
RHEUMATOLOGICAL SIGNS
Signs which are frequently encountered in the joint diseases are as:
SWELLING:
MUSCLE WASTING:
Painful joint affection is associated with the atrophy of the adjacent muscles, and occur as
a result of disease or reflex phenomenon.
DEFORMITY:
Abnormal shape or size of a structure; may result from bony hypertrophy, malalignment
of articulating structures, or damage to periarticular supportive structures.
It is applicable to central as well as appendicular skeleton.
Common Drugs: Calcarea fluorica, Causticum, Radium bromide, Syphilinum, Thuja, X-
Ray.
CREPITUS:
It is an important sign and points to the nature of the underlying joint disease:
STABILITY:
Diseased joints can be moved into abnormal positions, due either to the joint surface
damage or laxity of the periarticular ligaments.
MOVEMENTS:
TENDERNESS:
REDNESS:
Redness, which occurs as a diffuse erythema overlying the joint, is a feature of acute
synovitis, associated with the crystal deposit synovitis, e.g. gout, pseudogout.
Common Drugs: Apis, Belladona, Bryonia, Formic acid, Guaicum, Ichthyolum,
Mercurius, Phosphorus, Rhododendron, Rhus toxicodendron, Silicea.
LOCAL HEAT:
RASH:
SYSTEMIC REVIEW
INVESTIGATIONS IN RHEUMATOLOGY
DISEASE ACTIVITY MARKERS
These help in the assessment of the acute phase of the disease and to determine the
response to the treatment. These include:
AUTOANTIBODIES
DIAGNOSTIC IMAGING
The availability and imaging technology has advanced tremendously in recent years. It
aids in diagnosis and objective assessment of disease severity and progression. It provides
historical record of anatomical changes, which are often disease specific.
The modalities used include conventional radiography, computed tomography, magnetic
resonance imaging, ultrasonography, arthrography, angiography, radionuclide imaging, and
bone densitometry.
CONVENTIONAL RADIOGRAPHY:
Conventional radiography is the initial imaging choice for most rheumatic conditions,
especially at the primary care level. It demonstrates fine bone details but lacks sensitivity to
distinguish soft tissue structures.
Following are the important features seen on the plane radiograph of the joint:
MRI is now the modality of choice for evaluating potential internal joint derangements. It
has specific utility in the:
Assessment of the integrity of peri-articular components.
Detection of the extent of injury to the synovium, joint cartilages, ligaments, tendons,
muscles, bone marrow and other soft tissues.
Detection of joint effusions, popliteal cysts, ganglion cysts, meniscal cysts, and bursitis.
Evaluation of the extent of the intervertebral disc herniation and spinal cord compression.
Patients who continue to have symptoms following surgery for back pain. Post-operative
scarring can be accurately distinguished from the disc herniation by obtaining the contrast
enhanced images following intravenous administration of gadolinium.
Diagnosis of microfractures due to trauma or stress, often referred to as ‘bone bruises’.
Early detection of osteomyelitis due to alterations in marrow signals.
COMPUTERISED TOMOGRAPHY:
ARTHROSCOPY:
ULTRASONOGRAPHY:
It can be used in detection of rotator cuff tears, Achilles tendon and patellar tendon tears.
It is also used for assessing fluid collections, such as joint effusions, popliteal cysts, and
ganglion cysts, and is used to guide aspiration of fluid.
BONE DENSITOMETRY:
Bone densitometry is used primarily for evaluating osteoporosis. Two precise, accurate,
and widely available techniques are and.
Normal synovial fluid is an ultrafiltrate of plasma that contains small amounts of high
molecular weight proteins (fibrinogen, complement, globulin), acting as a lubricant and shock
absorber for the joint. It identifies the cause of the joint effusion and aids in the differential
diagnosis of arthritis. Classes of Synovial Fluid are:
SYNOVIAL BIOPSY:
Synovial biopsy should be done only if the diagnosis cannot be made using traditional,
less invasive procedures. The synovial biopsy is useful in differentiating inflammatory
arthritis. Typical changes are seen as:
Clinical Condition Features
Rheumatoid arthritis Multilayered synovium, infiltration of subsynovial layer with
plasma cells and lymphocytes
SLE Massive superficial fibrin loss of synovial lining cells,
infiltration with lymphocytes and plasma cells
Tuberculous arthritis Caseating granuloma in superficial synovium, scattered chronic
inflammatory cell infiltration, and acid-fast stain or culture
evidence of Mycobacterium tuberculosis in synovial tissue
Gout Hydroxyapatite deposits in synovial tissue appear as clumps of
material that stain with alizarin red S and have a typical
appearance on electron micrography
Pseudogout Tophus like deposits of pyrophosphate crystals in the
subsynovial tissue
References:
1. Allen H C. Allen’s Keynotes Rearranged and Classified with Leading Remedies of the
Materia Medica and Bowel Nososdes. 10th Ed. New Delhi: B. Jain Publishers; 2006
2. Boericke William. Boericke's New Manual of Homeopathic Materia Medica with
Repertory. 3rd Revised & Augmented Ed. based on 9th Ed. New Delhi: B. Jain Publishers;
2010
3. Boger C M. Boger Boenninghausen's Characteristics & Repertory: With Corrected &
Revised Abbreviations & Word Index. 1st Ed. New Delhi: B. Jain Publishers; 2009
4. Duckworth T, Blundell C M. Lecture Notes Orthopaedics and Fractures. 4th Ed. Oxford:
Wiley-Blackwell, John Wiley & Sons, Ltd. Publication; 2010
5. Fauci Anthony S. Fauci, et al. Harrison’s Rheumatology. 3rd Ed. New York: McGraw-
Hill Education, LLC; 2013
6. Firestein Gary S, et al. Kelly’s Textbook of Rheumatology. 9th Ed. Philadelphia: Saunders
Elsevier Inc.; 2013
7. Hamblen David L, Simpson Hamish R W, Raby Nigel. Adams’s Outline of Orthopaedics.
14th Ed. Edinburgh: Churchill Livingstone Elsevier Limited; 2010.
8. Kahl; Leslie E, et al. The Washington Manual Rheumatology Subspecialty Consult. 2nd
Ed. Philadelphia: Lippincott Williams & Wilkins; 2012
9. Kent J T. Lectures on Homoeopathic Materia Medica. 1st Ed. New Delhi: B. Jain
Publishers; 2007
10. Kent J T. Repertory of the Homoeopathic Materia Medica. 1st Ed. New Delhi: B. Jain
Publishers; 2007
11. Klippel John H, et al. Primer on the Rheumatic Diseases. 13th Ed. New York: Springer
Science+Business Media, LLC; 2008
12. Luqmani Raashid, et al. Textbook of Orthopaedics, Trauma and Rheumatology. 2nd Ed.
Missouri: Mosby Elsevier Ltd.; 2013
13. Solomon Louis, et al. Apley’s System of Orthopaedics and fractures. 9th Ed. Florida: CRC
Press Taylor & Francis Group, LLC; 2010
14. Swales Catherine, Bulstrode Christopher. Rheumatology, Orthopaedics and Trauma at a
Glance. 2nd Ed. Oxford: Wiley-Blackwell, John Wiley & Sons, Ltd. Publication; 2012
15. Watts Richard A, et al. Oxford Textbook of Rheumatology. 4th Ed. Oxford: Oxford
University Press; 2013