COMPARISON OF RUBRIC IN KENT, BTPB AND BBCR

DR.AJESH.V
LECTURER DEPT OF REPERTORY.
SVRHMC NEMOM
 COMPARITIVE STUDY OF RUBRICS

RUBRIC KENT BTPB BBCR

Hydrophobia Mind hydrophobia S&C water dread of Mind hydrophobia

S&C hydrophobia

Hysteria Mind hysteria S&C hysteria Mind hysteria

S&C hysteria and
hypochondriasis

Ailments from joy Ailments from joy Agg excitement joy a)Mind gaiety
Mind joy ailments joyfulness effects of
from b)<&> emotions joy
excess agg
 COMPARITIVE STUDY OF RUBRICS
RUBRIC KENT BTPB BBCR

Jealousy Mind jealousy Agg excitement Mind jealousy

jealousy S&C jealousy

Delirium tremens Mind mania a potu Intellect delirium Mind delirium tremens

Illusions of touch Gen- touch illusions of S&C touch illusion of -----

Aversion to touch Mind touch aversion to -- S&C touched aversion Mind touched aversion
to to being

Delirium Mind delirium Intellect- delirium Mind delirium

 COMPARITIVE STUDY OF RUBRICS
RUBRIC KENT BTPB BBCR

Vertigo Vertigo-vertigo Intellect – vertigo Vertigo

Falling of hair from Face - falling of Skin – hair falling Head ext-hair- falling
beard whiskers from beard out from beard

Both in eye and vision,

Photophobia Eye- photophobia Vision- photophobia but more medicines in
vision

Photomania Eye photo mania Vision- photo mania Both in eye and vision

Short sight Vision myopia Vision- short sighted Vision myopia

 COMPARITIVE STUDY OF RUBRICS
RUBRIC KENT BTPB BBCR

Epistaxis Nose epistaxis Nose nosebleed Nose bleeding

Illusions of smell Nose odor Smell illusions of Nose smell illusions of

Circumscribed Face- discoloration Face- circumscribed Face red circumscribed

redness of cheeks red circumscribed redness of cheeks on cheeks

Comedones (black Face eruption Face comedones Face acne comedones

heads) comedones

Risus sardonicus Face risus sardonicus Face drawn Face risus sardonicus
 COMPARITIVE STUDY OF RUBRICS
RUBRIC KENT BTPB BBCR

Exophthalmos Eyes protrusion – Face eyes protruding Eyes protruding

exophthalmos

Oily face Face greasy Face oily Face glistening greasy

Open mouth Mouth open Face open mouth Mouth open

Toothache Teeth pain toothache Teeth- toothache Teeth pain simple

Hot breath Respiration hot breath Mouth breath hot Respiration hot breath
 COMPARITIVE STUDY OF RUBRICS
RUBRIC KENT BTPB BBCR

Cold breath Mouth cold Mouth breath cold Resp cold breah

Tonsillitis Throat inflammation Throat tonsils + S&C Mouth throat and gullet
tonsils glands tonsils inflammation tonsils

Aversion salt Stomach aversion salt Hunger and thirst Appetite aversion salt
aversion salt

Burnt taste Taste empyreumatic Taste burnt Taste burnt

Taste empyreumatic

Loss of taste Mouth taste wanting Taste lost Taste lost

 COMPARITIVE STUDY OF RUBRICS
RUBRIC KENT BTPB BBCR

Heartburn Stomach heartburn Eructation heartburn Waterbrash and

heartburn – heartburn

Hiccough Stomach hiccough Eructation hiccough PBO, hiccough- hiccough

Waterbrash Stomach eructation Eructation waterbrash Heartburn and

waterbrash waterbrash water collects
in mouth waterbrash

Haematemesis Stomach vomiting blood Nausea and vomiting- Nausea and vomiting-
vomiting bloody vomiting blood

Hernia Abdomen hernia Internal abdomen Inguinal and pubic region

hernia hernia
 COMPARITIVE STUDY OF RUBRICS
RUBRIC KENT BTPB BBCR

Incarceration of flatus Abdomen-Flatus Flatulence- Flatulence flatus

obstructed incarceration of incarcerated
flatus

Diarrhea * Rectum diarrhea Stool diarrhea Stool diarrhea

Worms * Rectum worms Stool worms Stool worms

Haemorrhoids Rectum haemorrhoids Stool haemorrhoids Anus and rectum

haemorrhoids

Diabetes mellitus Urine sugar Urine glycosuria Urine saccharine

 COMPARITIVE STUDY OF RUBRICS
RUBRIC KENT BTPB BBCR
Nocturnal eneuresis Bladder urination Micturition involuntary Urine- micturition-
involuntary night in at night urination involuntary
bed night in bed

Labor like pains Gen female- pains S&C labor like pains Genitalia female
labor like pains Sexual organs organs labor like pains

Impotency Gen male, erection Sexual organs Sexual impulse-

wanting impotency impotency impotency and
weakened power

Abortion Gen female abortion Menstruation abortion Genitalia female organs

abortion

Delayed first menses in genitalia female menses Menstruation delayed Menstruation -tardy at
girls delayed first menses in girls puberty
 COMPARITIVE STUDY OF RUBRICS
RUBRIC KENT BTPB BBCR
Acrid leucorrhoea Gen female Leucorrhoea acrid Menstruation leucorrhoea
leucorrhoea acrid

Salty expectoration Expectoration taste Cough- taste of Cough- expectoration taste of

salty expectoration salty salty

Hoarseness of voice Larynx and trachea Air passages voice Voice and speech- hoarse
voice hoarseness hoarse

Goiter* Ext throat- goiter External throat and a)Neck and external throat
neck thyroid gland+ glands goiter
S&C glands swelling b) neck and external throat
thyroid gland goiter

Palpitation Chest palpitation Chest palpitation Fever and circulation palpitation

 COMPARITIVE STUDY OF RUBRICS

RUBRIC KENT BTPB BBCR

Eruption in axilla Chest eruption axilla S&C skin eruption Chest – axial eruption
Upper extre axilla+

diaphragm Chest –diaphragm(not diaphragm Abdomen diaphragm

as separate rubric but as Hypochondrium
sub locations under
some rubrics)

Desire for open air Gen – air open desire for S&C in general air S&C in general air open
open desire for desire for

Apoplexy Generalities apoplexy S&C apoplexy S&C apoplexy

Tendency to take cold Generalities - cold S&C in general- cold S&C in general- cold
tendency to take tendency to take tendency to take
 COMPARITIVE STUDY OF RUBRICS

RUBRIC KENT BTPB BBCR

Awkwardness Extreme- awkwardness S&C in general- Mind awkward
clumsiness

Convulsions without Generalities – S&C convulsions S&C epilepsy

consciousness convulsions without consciousness consciousness without
consciousness without

Jaundice Skin discoloration- Skin yellow Skin colour yellow

yellow jaundice

Inclination to lie down Generalities Lie down S&C Lie down inclination S&C Lie down inclination
inclination to to to

Malaise Generalities Lassitude S&C malaise S&C fatigue

 COMPARITIVE STUDY OF RUBRICS

RUBRIC KENT BTPB BBCR

Diagonal affections Generalities Side S&C side cross wise S&C direction diagonal
like upper right and
lower left etc
Sprain Generalities Lifting S&C sprain Agg and amel in gen
lifting and over lifting

Hot patient Generalities Heat S&C warm feeling S&C warmth sense of
sensation of

Caries of bones Generalities Caries bones S&C bones- caries S&C bones caries

Healing of broken Generalities Slow- repair S&C bones healing of S&C bones – fracture slow
bones slow * of broken bones broken bones slow union or formation of
callus
 COMPARITIVE STUDY OF RUBRICS

RUBRIC KENT BTPB BBCR

Bloody sweat Perspiration blood S&C Skin blood sweat bloody
sweating+ fever Fever sweat bloody

Corns Extremities corns S&C skin corns Skin corns

Scabies Skin eruptions scabies S&C skin- itch scabies S&C skin- itch scabies

In growing nails Extr- ingrowing Skin nails growing Skin nails ingrown
inward

Bed sore Skin sore becomes Skin sore becomes Skin soreness excoriation
chafing
 COMPARITIVE STUDY OF RUBRICS

RUBRIC KENT BTPB BBCR

Ring worm Skin eruption herpetic Skin tetter ringworm Skin tetter ringworm
circinate

Somnambulism Mind somnambulism Sleep somnambulistic Mind- somnambulism

SLEEP during

Pulse imperceptible Generalities Pulse Fever and circulation Fever- circulation pulse
imperceptible pulse imperceptible imperceptible

Varicose veins Generalities Varicose Circulation blood Circulation blood vessel

veins vessels varicose varicose
Fever,
Nevus Nevus Skin neavus Circulation blood Skin nevus, maternus
vessels like a network pigmentosus
 COMPARITIVE STUDY OF RUBRICS

RUBRIC KENT BTPB BBCR

Sweat staining Perspiration staining Fever sweat staining Fever sweat yellow
yellow yellow yellow staining

Burns Generalities Burns Agg- burns a) Skin burns

b) agg & amel burns

Grief Mind grief Agg- excitement grief Mind grief

Mortification Mind mortification Agg- mortification Mind mortification

New moon agg Generalities Periodicity- Agg- moon new Agg and amel moon new
28 days agg
 COMPARITIVE STUDY OF RUBRICS

RUBRIC KENT BTPB BBCR

Nursing children Generalities Nursing Agg nursing children S&Cinfants affections of
children

Aggravation Mind thinking Agg – thinking of his Agg& amel thinking of

thinking of disease his disease agg
complaint

Illusion Mind delusion Intellect imagination Mind illusion

Insanity Mind insanity Intellect insanity Mind insanity

Weak memory Mind memory weakness Intellect memory weak Mind memory poor
of forgetful
 COMPARITIVE STUDY OF RUBRICS

RUBRIC KENT BTPB BBCR

Cataract* Eyes cataract Eyes lens Vision cataract

Half vision Vision hemiopia Vision half vision Vision, illusion of form
size distance, hemiopia

Muscae volitantes Vision colour black Vision muscae Vision illusion flies
spots floating muscae muscae

Parotid Face inflammation parotid Ear parotid gland Ear glands auricular
gland parotid etc
Face- parotid gland

Desire for tobacco Stomach desire tobacco Hunger and thirst- desire Appetite desires tobacco
tobacco
 COMPARITIVE STUDY OF RUBRICS

RUBRIC KENT BTPB BBCR

swelling of inguinal Abdomen- swelling , Ext abdomen, inguinal Inguinal and pubic
glands inguinal region glands glands+ S&C glands region, glands inguinal
of swelling swollen

round worm Rectum worms Stool round worm Stool worms

lumbricoides lumbricoides

Pin worm Rectum worms Stool thread worm Stool pinworm

ascarides

Tenesmus Rectum pain tenesmus Stool after stool Stool urging to ineffectual
tenesmus fruitless

Dysuria Bladder urination dysuria Micturition dysuria -------

 COMPARITIVE STUDY OF RUBRICS

RUBRIC KENT BTPB BBCR

After pains Genitalia female pains Sexual organs after Genitalia female organs
after pains pains childbed , after pains

Long lasting menses Gen fem- menses Menstruation menses Menstruation menses
protracted too long duration too long duration

Tachypnoea Respiration
accelerated Respiration rapid Respiration quickened

Chlorosis Generalities chlorosis S&C chlorosis S&C chlorosis

Aneamia Generalities Aneamia S&C chlorosis Blood Circulation congestion

aneamia anemia
 COMPARITIVE STUDY OF RUBRICS

RUBRIC KENT BTPB BBCR

Faintness Generalities Faintness S&C faintness Sensorium faintness

Obesity Generalities Obesity S&C obesity S&Cobesity corpulency

Gouty nodosities Extermitities- arthritic S&C gouty nodes Lower extremities

nodosities podagra

Chicken pox Skin eruption chicken pox Skin eruption chicken pox Skin varicella

Measles a)Skin eruptions measles Skin eruptions measles Fever pathological types
b) fever exanthematous measles
fevers measles
 COMPARITIVE STUDY OF RUBRICS

RUBRIC KENT BTPB BBCR

Herpes zoster Skin eruption herpetic Skin eruption zoster Skin zoster
zoster zona zona

typhoid Fever continued fever ----- Fever pathological types

typhoid typhoid fever

Nettle rash Skin eruption vesicular Skin eruption nettle Skin eruption Urticaria
sudamina rash nettle rash
Skin eruption Urticaria

Pulse Generalities Pulse Circulation pulse Circulation pulse

Amaurosis Eye paralysis of optic Vision paralysis of Eyes vision- paralysis

nerve optic nerve