Think On Your Feet (PDFDrive)
Think On Your Feet (PDFDrive)
Think On Your Feet (PDFDrive)
The guide was developed for Jacqueline’s clients and her particular audience (in
Canada). So we encourage you to take from this what is useful, and then
customise for your group.
If you have any questions or contributions, please let us know. We would love
your feedback.
(Note – if you want to recreate many of the visuals in the guide you will need to
flipchart them. (Better get in early!). Some visuals are from the TOYF® slides, but
many are customised.)
Think on Your Feet®
WELCOME TO
TF-01
• Clarity
• Brevity Ideas
• Impact™
TF-02
Brevity – Because getting to the point and presenting key arguments has impact – too much
information usually hurts rather than helps.
Impact – You have impact when you create movement. When you’ve caused a shift in
perspective and opinion. With movement comes persuasion.
Clarity, Brevity and Impact are essential for most professionals today, and especially for those
within an adversarial system.
You already have tools to help you in these areas. Think on Your Feet is intended to augment
your toolkit. Some of what we cover may feel familiar. That’s good. What we want to do is
heighten your awareness so we can raise the skill level as well.
• Analyze
• Organize Ideas
• Present
TF-03
These are core competencies for many professionals but especially for lawyers.
INTRODUCTIONS
• An interest or hobby
TF-04
ASSESSMENT RESULTS
TF-05
ASSESSMENT RESULTS
TF-06
OPENING ACTIVITY
TF-07
• Analysis
• get to the core
• Separation
• keep ideas distinct
• Movement
• make your argument flow
TF-08
So,
Broad Applications
• Persuade
• Negotiate
TF-09
Legal Applications
• Court appearances
TF-10
Let’s look at typical applications for lawyers: How does this concept apply to these scenarios?
Think about the need for clear thinking, key messaging and the ability to move people in court,
during conference calls, client meetings & negotiations as well as internally with clients and
colleagues.
Court appearances
TF-11
TF-12
Increase your credibility – Credibility is only established when you sound like you know what
you talking about.
Which leads us to our next point that – People believe when they understand.
For example, with interest based negotiation it’s critical that you be understood; otherwise,
common interests are never clear and negotiations break down.
• “Beauty Contests”
• Partner updates
• Client meetings
TF-13
Working at the senior level, the infamous “beauty contests” are an obvious example of the
importance of Clarity, Brevity and Impact: if they believe you can do the job, you win. Where
does that confidence come from? Being understood, Being persuasive. Being credible. All of this
depends on communications.
At the junior level, remembering that your client is also the partner or senior associate. It’s a
moment of truth for any junior lawyer or clerk standing in the doorway of a partner’s office
giving an update on the status of a file or receiving instructions.
• One-to-one
• Meetings
• Presentations
TF-14
100000000
TF-15
100000000
100,000,000
TF-16
What the difference with the before and after picture here?
The question is: How much do we want to make our listeners work? And, what are the risks, if
they don’t bother to even try to make sense of our words?
Structure helps us sort and filter for our listeners (We do the work for them. We present our
thinking in a way that is easy for someone to receive it.) and it helps us assert our message when
there is competition or push back.
• Practice-practice-practice
TF-17
TF-18
Review the Six Main Plans – Mention: icons as part of an accelerated learning technique.
We divide these plans into two categories: Basic and Assertive.
In the first instance, we use what we call Basic Plans (meaning structures): These are excellent
for communicating key messages and to persuade subtlety or to diffuse a difficult situation.
In the second instance, we use Assertive Plans: These are excellent when you want to push
back, assert another perspective or want to maintain control.
TF-19
CLOCK PLAN
TF-20
DEMO
We work internationally as well as in Canada and you might be surprised to discover that there
are even more consultants than lawyers “out there”. It’s key to distinguish ourselves. So, when
clients ask “Why you?” We need a good answer. I often use the Clock Plan to focus on
fundamentals. For example, I might say:
Why us? Our clients will testify that our approach gets results from start through to finish.
At the start of a project, we educate to transfer knowledge and empower our clients. We want our
clients to know what we know.
At the peak of implementation, we listen and adjust to ensure we are on the best course.
Accuracy and efficiency are key.
At the finish, we evaluate and measure success to prepare for the next intervention.
So from start to finish we ensure our clients keep learning and keep getting results.
This plan is also good to help you think through your competitive advantage.
CLOCK PLAN
• Calms listeners
TF-21
Time can be used to structure almost any response or explanation as it is so much a part of how
we think and organize.
It’s calming because it places a sense of control over a situation – George Bush
George Bush when he spoke after the September 11th disaster consistently used the Clock
Plan as he had to calm a nation and show he was taking action. One example is after the
Pennsylvania crash. He held a press conference and said the following:
It has a forward dynamic because the Clock Plan is often a high level action plan – George Bush
example also does this.
CLOCK PLAN
TF-22
CLOCK PLAN
TF-23
CLOCK PLAN
TF-24
LOGICAL INTUITIVE
LEFT SIDE RIGHT SIDE
TF-25
CLOCK PRACTICE
TF-26
Before court
During court
After court
Last Year
This Year
Next Year
Before negotiations
During negotiations
After negotiation
CLOCK FEEDBACK
CLARITY
TF-27
Time can be used to structure almost any response or explanation as it is so much a part of how
we think and organize.
It’s calming because it places a sense of control over a situation – George Bush
It has a forward dynamic because the Clock Plan is often a high level action plan – George Bush
example also does this.
• Persuasive
• Rhythmical
• Memorable
TF-28
TF is founded on certain key principles that prevent us from falling into communication traps
while supporting our essential communication needs. What’s the foundation of TF? Structure &
Patterning.
• Found in traditional logic (for example, Hegel – thesis, antithesis, synthesis) as well as other
logics-based disciplines, such as geometry (proving equilateral triangles and the hypotenuse).
• Rhythm – storytelling – What are some examples of threes in story-telling? This maintains
interest, suspense and fun. What would the Three-Little Pigs have been like if there’d only
been 1 Little Pig?
offer
acceptance
consideration
STANDARD FORMAT
Headline
TF-29
GLOBE PLAN
TF-30
GLOBE PLAN
TF-31
DEMO
Visual impact – plants a picture in the listener’s mind’s eye. Example: Take the statement:
Lawyers must be persuasive advocates for clients. Now compare this to: Lawyers must be
persuasive advocates for clients in court, at the negotiating table and media scrum.
Calms tense situations – When would lawyers want to calm things down?
Supporting big topics – helps people understand by getting them to visualize like in the above
example of persuasive advocacy.
GLOBE PLAN
TF-32
GLOBE PRACTICE
TF-33
GLOBE FEEDBACK
CLARITY
• Did you hear three pegs?
• What were the pegs?
• Was the Standard Format used?
BREVITY
• Too much information?
• Too little?
• Just right?
TF-34
TRIANGLE PLAN
TF-35
TRIANGLE PLAN
• Suggests objectivity
• Shows thoughtfulness
TF-36
DEMOS
Henry Mintzberg of McGill University uses the Triangle Plan to structure his speeches on Talent
Management. He encourages all CEOs to ensure their managers have three key skills –
interpersonal skills, informational skills and decision-making skills. And, he gets a few thousand
dollars for saying this!
Journalists, might use the Triangle Plan to present a balanced report by showing three
perspectives on an issue. So, in covering…
TRIANGLE PLAN
TRIANGLE PRACTICE
TF-39
Lawyers hate getting quick responses I’m told. Why is that? (Appears that the answer hasn’t
been thought through.) How do clients and partners perceive lawyers who give quick answers?
So here’s where the Triangle Plan can help us out.
PRACTICE
Let’s say, we’re asked by a partner, why should we take on this case?
If you give one reason, that’s often perceived to be only an opinion. But if we follow the rule of
threes and apply it to the Triangle Plan, then three reasons gives us an argument. We appear
objective and thoughtful.
TRIANGLE FEDBACK
CLARITY
• Did you hear three pegs?
• What were the pegs?
• Was the Standard Format used?
BREVITY
• Too much information?
• Too little?
• Just right?
IMPACT
• Did the answer flow?
TF-40
TF-41
ADDITIONAL PRACTICE
TF-42
BENEFITS OF BRIDGING
• Show respect
• Buy time
TF-43
BRIDGING TECHNIQUES
TF-44
BRIDGING
ACKOWLEDGE
• That’s an astute question.
• Thank you for raising that point.
• Your comments raise important
issues.
• I can see you are frustrated by this
situation.
TF-44
BRIDGING
ASK
• If I understand your question, you are
asking me if … is that correct?
• Could you give me a specific
example?
• When you say “better”, what does that
mean to you?
TF-45
BRIDGING
ADAPT
• That is not my area of expertise;
however, I can tell you …
• I agree that _____ is an important
issue. Our goal is to focus on _____
to ensure …
• I would be happy to research that for
you. Shall I call you tomorrow to
further discuss?
TF-46
TF-47
TF-48
• Zoom Lens
• via perspectives
• Pendulum
• via extremes
• Benefits
• via advantages
TF-49
Small
Medium
Large
TF-50
Move our listeners from the small to medium to large view and vice-versa.
Think of how a camera moves from a close-up shot to a medium shot to a long-shot.
• Handle sensitive or
confidential information
TF-51
First of all, we signal to our listeners when we move from one idea to the next by using key
words and often gestures. Listen for them in the following demonstrations. And think about how
they function.
DEMOS
In the early 80s, SAS Airlines President, Jan Carlzon, developed a concept called The
Moments of Truth and he illustrated it by using the zoom out plan. He wanted employees to see
the importance of paying attention to details, such as coffee ring stains on food trays. But let’s
put it in the context of your profession…
SPECIFICALLY: If a client is surprised by their bill, that’s a moment of truth. A moment when
the client makes a judgment.
MOST BROADLY: Such impressions left with clients can eat away at the success of our firm.
ZOOM OUT
• Specifically,…
TF-52
ZOOM OUT
TF-53
ZOOM OUT
Client Question: “So what? If X. Co. breaches
the agreement, we’ll just sue him, right?”
TF-54
• Focus on specifics
TF-55
Example 4: Focus on specifics. We want to leave the listener thinking about a detail, a single
item not the big picture.
CBC recently interviewed a director of an Energy Company regarding the natural gas facility
they intend on building. When challenged about community safety and environmental dangers,
the director said:
However, we have conducted multiple studies that carefully examine the safety issues as well as
environmental risks.
Specifically, our audit team has carefully reviewed the recommendations and every
recommendation has been implemented. There are no unresolved safety or environmental issues.
ZOOM IN
• Generally,…
• However,….
• Specifically,…
TF-56
ZOOM IN
TF-57
PENDULUM PLAN
TF-58
PENDULUM PLAN
TF-59
PENDULUM PLAN
• As a middle ground
TF-60
PENDULUM PLAN
Previous indemnity example “repackaged”:
TF-61
Quotes
1. “With a view to striking the right balance between innovation and protecting the values of
Canadians, the government will widely consult the public.” – Allan Rock on patenting high
life forms.
Two parliamentary committees separately reviewing the status of foreign investment rules
governing the communications sector in Canada have landed on the opposite ends of the
policy spectrum, generating directly conflicting recommendations and thereby tossing a
political hot potato squarely back in the lap of the Chretien cabinet. “Our Cultural
Sovereignty: The Second Century of Canadian Broadcasting versus Opening Canadian
Communications to the World.”
BENEFITS PLAN
TF-62
BENEFITS PLAN
TF-63
BENEFITS PLAN
TF-64
Notes
BENEFITS PLAN
Topic: Conference
Listener: Colleague / Managing Partner /
PD Coordinator
Headline:
Benefit #1:
Benefit #2:
Benefit #3:
Recap
TF-65
BENEFITS PLAN
Benefit #1:
Benefit #2:
Benefit #3:
Recap
TF-66
BENEFITS PRACTICE
TF-67
TF-68
TF-70
TF-71
TF-72
BRAIN-SCAN GRID
Listeners
Background
Knowledge
Hopes/
Advantages
Fears/
Disadvantages
TF-73
SUB-PLANS
• Picture
• Opposites
• Domino
• W5
TF-74
PICTURE SUB-PLAN
TF-75
PICTURE SUB-PLAN
TF-76
OPPOSITES SUB-PLAN
TF-77
DOMINO SUB-PLAN
TF-78
3 Causes, 1 Effect
Chain Reaction
1 Cause, 3 Effects
TF-79
W5
• Who
• What
• Where
• Why
• When
TF-80
WELCOME TO
TF-01
• Clarity
• Brevity Ideas
• Impact™
TF-02
• Analyze
• Organize Ideas
• Present
TF-03
INTRODUCTIONS
• An interest or hobby
TF-04
ASSESSMENT RESULTS
TF-05
ASSESSMENT RESULTS
TF-06
OPENING ACTIVITY
TF-07
• Analysis
• get to the core
• Separation
• keep ideas distinct
• Movement
• make your argument flow
TF-08
Broad Applications
• Persuade
• Negotiate
TF-09
Legal Applications
• Court appearances
TF-10
Court appearances
TF-11
TF-12
• “Beauty Contests”
• Partner updates
• Client meetings
TF-13
• One-to-one
• Meetings
• Presentations
TF-14
100000000
TF-15
100,000,000
TF-16
• Practice-practice-practice
TF-17
TF-18
TF-19
CLOCK PLAN
TF-20
CLOCK PLAN
• Calms listeners
TF-21
CLOCK PLAN
TF-22
CLOCK PLAN
TF-23
CLOCK PLAN
TF-24
LOGICAL INTUITIVE
LEFT SIDE RIGHT SIDE
TF-25
CLOCK PRACTICE
TF-26
CLOCK FEEDBACK
CLARITY
TF-27
• Persuasive
• Rhythmical
• Memorable
TF-28
STANDARD FORMAT
Headline
TF-29
GLOBE PLAN
TF-30
GLOBE PLAN
TF-31
GLOBE PLAN
TF-32
GLOBE PRACTICE
TF-33
GLOBE FEEDBACK
CLARITY
• Did you hear three pegs?
• What were the pegs?
• Was the Standard Format used?
BREVITY
• Too much information?
• Too little?
• Just right?
TF-34
TRIANGLE PLAN
TF-35
TRIANGLE PLAN
• Suggests objectivity
• Shows thoughtfulness
TF-36
TRIANGLE PLAN
TRIANGLE PRACTICE
TF-38
TRIANGLE FEDBACK
CLARITY
• Did you hear three pegs?
• What were the pegs?
• Was the Standard Format used?
BREVITY
• Too much information?
• Too little?
• Just right?
IMPACT
• Did the answer flow?
TF-39
TF-40
ADDITIONAL PRACTICE
TF-41
BENEFITS OF BRIDGING
• Show respect
• Buy time
TF-42
BRIDGING TECHNIQUES
TF-43
BRIDGING
ACKOWLEDGE
• That’s an astute question.
• Thank you for raising that point.
• Your comments raise important
issues.
• I can see you are frustrated by this
situation.
TF-44
BRIDGING
ASK
• If I understand your question, you are
asking me if … is that correct?
• Could you give me a specific
example?
• When you say “better”, what does that
mean to you?
TF-45
BRIDGING
ADAPT
• That is not my area of expertise;
however, I can tell you …
• I agree that _____ is an important
issue. Our goal is to focus on _____
to ensure …
• I would be happy to research that for
you. Shall I call you tomorrow to
further discuss?
TF-46
TF-47
TF-48
• Zoom Lens
• via perspectives
• Pendulum
• via extremes
• Benefits
• via advantages
TF-49
Small
Medium
Large
TF-50
TF-51
ZOOM OUT
• Specifically,…
TF-52
ZOOM OUT
TF-53
ZOOM OUT
Client Question: “So what? If X. Co. breaches
the agreement, we’ll just sue him, right?”
TF-54
• Focus on specifics
TF-55
ZOOM IN
• Generally,…
• However,….
• Specifically,…
TF-56
ZOOM IN
TF-57
PENDULUM PLAN
TF-58
PENDULUM PLAN
TF-59
PENDULUM PLAN
• As a middle ground
TF-60
PENDULUM PLAN
TF-61
BENEFITS PLAN
TF-62
BENEFITS PLAN
TF-63
BENEFITS PLAN
TF-64
BENEFITS PLAN
Topic: Conference
Listener: Colleague / Managing Partner /
PD Coordinator
Headline:
Headline:
Benefit #1:
Benefit #2:
Benefit #3:
Recap
TF-65
BENEFITS PLAN
Benefit #1:
Benefit #2:
Benefit #3:
Recap
TF-66
BENEFITS PRACTICE
TF-67
TF-68
REVERSE BENEFITS PLAN
TF-71
TF-72
BRAIN-SCAN GRID
Listeners
Background
Knowledge
Hopes/
Advantages
Fears/
Disadvantages
TF-73
Dear Associate,
I look forward to meeting you in October during our Think on Your Feet® workshop. In the meantime, I would
appreciate your help in tailoring the program to meet your needs.
Thank you,
Jacqueline Throop
1. Please select the 5 items that best represent your interests. Also, rank them 1 to 5. 1 representing your top
priority and 5 representing your lowest.
2. List two work-related questions you are asked but don’t like to answer (e.g., awkward, sensitive, or negative
questions).
•
•
3. List two frequently asked questions you would like to answer more skillfully (e.g., “How will your firm ensure
it meets my needs?”).
•
•
4. List two topics that often cause debate either within the firm or within the legal community (e.g., flexible-work
options).
•
•
2. List two work-related questions you are asked but don’t like to answer (e.g., awkward, sensitive, or negative
questions).
3. List two frequently asked questions you would like to answer more skillfully (e.g., “How will your firm ensure
it meets my needs?”).
4. List two topics that often cause debate either within the firm or within the legal community (e.g., flexible-work
options).
McInnes
Cooper
Additional
Practice
Activities
©2003 Think on Your Feet International, Inc.
Think on Your Feet®
_____________________________________________________________________________________________
Zoom Out
1. What is your salary / bonus?
2. Why did you spend X hours on this?
3. Why can’t you give me an answer now?
4. What is your hourly rate?
5. What is your specialty (expertise)?
6. What are your area(s) of practice?
7. How come you are not a partner?
8. Is private practice worth it?
9. How much will this cost me?
10. Why is your firm better than another firm?
Zoom In
1. That’s kind of long, isn’t it?
2. Why can’t you handle this? (Tell a client you have to refer them to another firm because of a conflict.)
3. Are you busy?
4. What are the risks?
5. Do you like it at this firm?
6. Why do so many women leave the profession?
7. Lawyers’ fees are too high!
8. Why do I need a lawyer?
9. You're a lawyer; you must be making a pile of money.
10. What’s the fastest way to get this resolved?
Pendulum Topics
1. Compensation
2. Performance Management
3. Work / Life Balance
4. Communications
5. Internal Relations
6. Equal Opportunity
7. Workload Allocation
8. Client Development
9. Parental Leave
10. Flexible Work Options
General Issues
1. What do you think about the municipal election & plebiscite results?
2. What do you think about our minority government situation?
3. Can you summarize the two sides of the same-sex marriage debate?
4. What are your thoughts on same-sex marriage?
5. How does E-mail affect your work?
6. Should business ethics be taught in all Canadian workplaces?
7. What do you think about the UN’s role today?
8. What are your thoughts on “The War on Terrorism?”
9. What do you think about the American election?
10. What’s your view of the influence of the media today?
Legal Issues
11. CCRA appropriately included lawyers as tax advisors in its civil penalties legislation.
12. Why is the USA more litigious than Canada?
13. How should lawyers prepare for CCRA’s auditors?
14. How would you define psychological harassment?
15. What steps are being taken to reform copyright law?
16. What are the pitfalls and problems of valuing intellectual property?
17. The biotech industry is right to demand of the federal government the right to table a new law to make higher
life forms patentable.
18. In such a language-driven profession, how do we open doors for deaf lawyers?
19. How do you decide whether a judge is biased or not?
20. How or when do you decide to have the judge recuse him/herself from a matter?
21. How do you decide to make an application to withdraw as counsel?
22. Under what circumstances would you bring a matter to appearance day?
23. What is the value of mediation over litigation?
24. How relevant are ethics for a lawyer? Explain your answer.
25. What are the most important elements of trial preparation?
Internal Questions
26. Why did “Joe/Jane” leave the firm?
27. What’s the proportion of women to men at the partner level at your firm?
28. What do you think about the firm’s marketing strategy?
29. Why are there more female associates than female partners?
30. What’s the role of mentorship at your firm?
31. What do you think about the professional development opportunities at your firm?
32. Is work fairly allocated?
33. How effective is the Policy Board?
34. How would you rate our communications?
35. Tell me about your job satisfaction.
“Lightning Round”
When it’s your turn, choose a category, your team chooses a question from the category. Answer the
question using a Bridge and a Plan. Try to keep your answer between 30 seconds and a minute. Time each
other for fun!
A FIRM QUESTIONS
B SOCIAL QUESTIONS
27 Do you believe in love at first sight or is it just something that happens in the movies?
28 You have been hired by a major airline to come up with a plan to give their airplane food a boost.
What recommendations would you make?
29 What was your best ever holiday and why?
30 Is rap music a bad influence on today’s teens or is it just a form of expressing themselves that
teenagers will outgrow?
31 If you could meet any one person in the world, who would you choose and why?
32 Are shopping malls a convenience or a consumer cash grab that is leading to the deterioration of
the ‘downtown’ in many communities?
33 In what ways could having a pet be good for you?
34 Who is your favourite talk show host? What makes them outstanding in your mind?
35 What would your ultimate dream house or holiday home look like?
36 What type of program would you recommend to a friend who is trying to get in shape and lose
weight?
D LAW
37 “Why doesn’t your client just put the money in escrow so we can close this deal and go home?”
38 “Why don’t we just sue them?”
39 “Why is your bill double the estimate you gave us?”
40 Your client calls and complains that you are holding up Closing by refusing to give the Opinion
requested by the other side.
41 The Partner in charge of the file wants you to account for the large amount of your time.
42 A Judge says, “If I accept your client’s position, won’t that open the floodgates of litigation?”
43 Counsel requests a Chamber Application and you want to oppose it.
44 Your client is resisting giving a personal guarantee on a business loan. What are her alternatives?
45 Your client wants to lay off 200 non-unionized workers ASAP. (It is the week before Christmas.)
46 Your client tells you she has not been filing her Insider Trading Reports.
47 Is the level of proof required for convicting corporate criminals too tough?
48 How can a jury in a complex case realistically consider the evidence and reach an appropriate
verdict?
49 Do you think the buyer of a business is at a disadvantage? Explain your answer.
50 The adversarial process in the courts means that the better performer is the more likely winner,
which makes a mockery of the idea of justice?
51 Don’t you agree our court system is a legal system, not a system of justice?
52 Should more and longer jail terms be imposed on those convicted of criminal corporate activity?
53 What do you think of the idea of eliminating juries to speed up court proceedings and make the
courts more efficient?
54 If a client complains to you about your performance, how do you respond to the client?
55 A partner tells you a complaint has been made about your performance. What’s your response?
56 You are invited to join the partnership at your firm.
57 On discovery, how do you respond when opposing counsel instructs his/her client not to answer a
question?
58 Respond to this comment: Litigators (“Type As”) have more fun than corporate lawyers.
59 What factors influence whether a case settles before trial?
©2003 Think on Your Feet International, Inc.
Think on Your Feet® Legal Groups - Exercise with Articles
1. Find three or four one-page legal articles that are applicable for the client and
participants.
2. At lunch on Day Two, ask get everyone to read one of the articles (Everyone
at a one table has to read the same article. Try to have at least two tables to
read the same article for comparison purposes).
This exercise works very, very well because lawyers have to summarize complex
arguments all the time.
TRIANGLE
Opposing Counsel objects to the qualification of your witness
as an expert.
Your Response:
BENEFITS
Situation: Your client reneges on an agreement because their
Board did not pass the deal but the terms of settlement were
already agreed to and sent to the Opposing Counsel whose
client has agreed. You need to convince your client/Board to
proceed.
Benefit #1: You’ll have the matter resolved and no further time
will be spent on it.
Benefit #2: You’ll spend no further money on fees.
Benefit #3: Your business reputation will be preserved
within the community.