Scribd Logo
Upload

Welcome to Scribd!

  • 386 views

    Lyari Expressway Rehabilitation Project

    Uploaded by

    Kamran Khan
    The document discusses the Lyari Expressway Resettlement Project (LERP) in Karachi, Pakistan. It provides background on the project's objectives to resettle families affected by the construction of the Lyari Expressway. Key issues that have caused delays include insufficient compensation amounts, resettlement sites being too far from original homes, and socioeconomic impacts on resettled populations. Recommendations are made to fully address residents' concerns and expedite completion to minimize costs and hardship.

    Copyright:

    Attribution Non-Commercial (BY-NC)
    Download as PPTX, PDF, TXT or read online from Scribd

    Lyari Expressway Rehabilitation Project

    Uploaded by

    Kamran Khan
    386 views32 pages
    The document discusses the Lyari Expressway Resettlement Project (LERP) in Karachi, Pakistan. It provides background on the project's objectives to resettle families affected by the construction of the Lyari Expressway. Key issues that have caused delays include insufficient compensation amounts, resettlement sites being too far from original homes, and socioeconomic impacts on resettled populations. Recommendations are made to fully address residents' concerns and expedite completion to minimize costs and hardship.

    Original Description:

    case study on Lyari expressway rehabilitation project, karachi

    Original Title

    Lyari expressway rehabilitation project.pptx

    Copyright

    © Attribution Non-Commercial (BY-NC)

    Available Formats

    PPTX, PDF, TXT or read online from Scribd

    Did you find this document useful?

    Is this content inappropriate?

    The document discusses the Lyari Expressway Resettlement Project (LERP) in Karachi, Pakistan. It provides background on the project's objectives to resettle families affected by the construction of the Lyari Expressway. Key issues that have caused delays include insufficient compensation amounts, resettlement sites being too far from original homes, and socioeconomic impacts on resettled populations. Recommendations are made to fully address residents' concerns and expedite completion to minimize costs and hardship.

    Copyright:

    Attribution Non-Commercial (BY-NC)
    Download as PPTX, PDF, TXT or read online from Scribd
    Download as pptx, pdf, or txt
    386 views32 pages

    Lyari Expressway Rehabilitation Project

    Uploaded by

    Kamran Khan
    The document discusses the Lyari Expressway Resettlement Project (LERP) in Karachi, Pakistan. It provides background on the project's objectives to resettle families affected by the construction of the Lyari Expressway. Key issues that have caused delays include insufficient compensation amounts, resettlement sites being too far from original homes, and socioeconomic impacts on resettled populations. Recommendations are made to fully address residents' concerns and expedite completion to minimize costs and hardship.

    Copyright:

    Attribution Non-Commercial (BY-NC)
    Download as PPTX, PDF, TXT or read online from Scribd
    Download as pptx, pdf, or txt
    of 32

    NATIONAL INSTITUTE OF MANAGEMENT, KA A!

    "I
    16th MCMC

    Syndicate B LYARI EXPRESSWAY RESETTLEMENT PROJECT


    Sponsor A S! A"#ad I$%a& S"a" Date: 4th November, 2013

    Gro#$ !om$o%&t&o'
    Sr' Na#e ( 2( M( Fa&%a, Kho3har 4( 5( Dr( Na)eeb U,,ah a'a 6a0ar A,&

    Sr' Na#e ( 1( A&)a* A'+ar !hoha' 2( M#a*am A,& Marr& 3( M( Kamra' Kha' 4( M%( Shahee' -( .#ba&r S&//&0#e 1( M#hamma/ Am&r

    10( Sam&#, "a0 11( Ah%a' Kha' 7a%&r

    e0#&reme't%
    )' isc*ss t"e c*rrent stat*s o+ LERP and critica&&y e,a&*ate t"e process at p&annin- and i#p&e#entation sta-e' .o/ +ar it #et its o%0ecti,es and co#p&ied /it" Nationa& Resett&e#ent Po&icy' 1' Identi+y t"e resett&e#ent areas /it" pec*&iarities and ana&y2e t"e i#pact o+ LERP on socio3econo#ic conditions o+ t"e resett&ed pop*&ation /it" specia& re+erence to co#pensation po&icy and re&ated iss*es /"et"er t"ose "a,e %een addressed4

    e0#&reme't% 8(( 9o't/(


    5' Identi+y and e,a&*ate #ain iss*es6 +actors /"ic" ca*sinde&ay in t"e co#p&etion o+ t"is pro0ect and s*--est t"e /ay +or/ard +or nonco#p&iance o+ t"e pro0ect so +ar7 and "o/ %est t"e pro0ect co*&d %e i#p&e#ented s#oot"&y to address t"e concerns o+ t"e sta8e"o&ders6 sett&ers4

    Metho/o,o:;
    Pri#ary So*rces
    Mr' Ras"eed A"#ed Me#on 9enera& Mana-er Nort" N.A

    Secondar y So*rces
    Artic&es and ne/s papers

    Tasnee# A"#ed Siddi$*e 9*est Spea8er

    Case st*dy Materia& o+ NIM

    A9ro';m%
    LERP Lyari E:press/ay Resett&e#ent Pro0ect NRP Nationa& Resett&e#ent Po&icy TC; T"e Citi2en<s ;o*ndation N.A Nationa& .i-"/ay A*t"ority ROW Ri-"t O+ Way C 9= City istrict 9o,ern#ent o+ Pa8istan

    OPP Oran-i Pi&ot Pro0ect

    S9heme o< =re%e'tat&o'


    Introd*ction

    Way ;or/ard

    C*rrent Stat*s o+ LERP

    Main +actors ca*sin- de&ay

    Critica& E,a&*ation o+ p&annin- and i#p&e#entatio n

    I#pact ana&ysis o+ LERP

    Resett&e#ent areas

    e0#&reme't > 1

    isc*ss t"e c*rrent stat*s o+ LERP and critica&&y e,a&*ate t"e process at p&anninand i#p&e#entation sta-e' .o/ +ar it #et its o%0ecti,es and co#p&ied /it" Nationa& Resett&e#ent Po&icy'

    I'tro/#9t&o'

    Current Status of LERP

    Current Status of LERP


    )' No +*nds "a,e %een re&eased since 1>>?3>@'
    e,' /or8s stopped +or non c&earance o+ &ia%i&ities' Sc"oo&in- discontin*ed +or AB>> st*dents d*e to non3pay#ent o+ sa&aries to teac"ers =ESC iss*ed disconnection notices No sa&ary paid to Pro0ect sta++ +or t"e &ast ) year

    1' Re$*ests to 9o,t +or pro,ision o+ +*nds *nresponded' 5' More t"an B>> a++ectees "a,e +i&ed Petitions &' S&'/h "! a:a&'%t Fe/era,, =rov&'9&a, ? !DGK <or 'o'@ re9e&v&': o< the 9om$e'%at&o' mo'e;

    LERP process at Planning Stage


    )' Nationa& .i-"/ay A*t"ority CN.AD
    e#arcation o+ EROWF to assess re$*ired area +or constr*ction o+ LEW'

    1' Re,en*e 5' Pro0ect


    epart#ent o+ C 9= irectorate o+ LERP

    S*r,ey &ists o+ a++ected +a#i&ies

    P&annin- G e#arcation Ci,ic *ti&ities G A#enities Mana-in- Ser,ices Land e,e&op#ent S"i+tin- ;aci&itation Carin- Resett&e#ent

    LERP process at #mplementation Stage


    Survey and Compensation
    1st Stage: Initial Surveys by the Revenue Dept. of CDGK 2nd Stage: Verification of Survey Lists by Team of Revenue Dept in collaboration with public representatives. rd Stage: Re verification by the Committee comprisin! of lar!er !roup of Revenue officers " public representatives. !th Stage: #ayment of cash compensation an$ allotment of %& s' y$s plot to the affectees as per verifie$ survey lists of Revenue Department( CDGK in open )atchery by the L*R#. "th Stage: #ayment of compensation of lease$ property un$er the law by the Revenue Department CDGK.

    LERP process at #mplementation Stage 7 cont


    Land %llocations 6 Planned Plots
    $ame of Resettlement site +a,-s.ay Scheme/!2 Sectors/ 60 1 2 1) 3aiser 3o,n Scheme/!" Sectors/ "0 60 6/% 2 part of Sector ")0"1 5aldia 3o,nship Scheme/21 Sector/215 Lastly added areas at 3aiser 3o,n for accommodating revised ))11/ family units &under development' & Less' 3otal %rea &%cres' 21( 664 1!! 2)" 12 ! -&2)' 121! Planned Plots &() S* yrd' "1(! 161" 212! ""2) )"(1 /&"")' )) 1

    LERP process at #mplementation Stage 7 cont


    Revision of Survey Report : RE%S8$S
    +ffecte$ family units from ,-(%,, ./ri!inal #C,0 to 1-(-,2 .Revise$ #C,0 an$ 3&(&,, .Re revise$ #C,0 were revise$ $ue to 4 19 3he decision of +igh Court to count each Level of Multi/storied 5uilding as a Separate :nit9 29 ;ifference in #nitial 2 <inal Surveys .y counting no9 of families per premises =one family> instead of treating them as Single :nit9 9 Changes in the R8? of LE? .y the $9+9% 9 !9 Commercial units not compensated9 ?hile Religious 5uildings Relocated &"6/Mos*ues0 6/#mam 5argahs 2 1/Churchs 2 1/ 3emple'

    LERP has $ot completely met its 8.@ectives

    ISSHES C&earance o+ re#ainin- B'5 8# ROW o+ LEW G &ia%i&ities' C&earance o+ t"e Co#pensation Per#ission +ro# t"e 9o,t to "and Pac8a-e' o,er roads7 sanitation7 /ater s*pp&y7 etc Per#ission o+ t"e 9o,tse/era-e7 to preparesc"oo&s EStat*s to re&e,ant epts' so t"at pro0ect PositionF G ECo#p&etion ReportF can %e /ind *p'

    $ational Resettlement Policy &March 2))2'


    A,oid or #ini#i2e ad,erse i#pacts in a pro0ect /"ere,er possi%&e7 and /"ere ad,erse i#pacts cannot %e a,oided7 t"e #iti-ation #eas*res G resett&e#ent acti,ities s"o*&d %e concei,ed and e:ec*ted as de,e&op#ent pro-ra#s and t"e a++ected persons %e pro,ided opport*nity to s"are t"e pro0ect %ene+its' Pro0ect A++ected Persons %e pro,ided /it" s*++icient co#pensation G assistance +or &ost assets7 t"at /i&& assist t"e# to i#pro,e or at &east restore t"eir &i,in- standards7 inco#e earnin- or prod*ction capacity to t"e pre3 pro0ect &e,e&s'

    So#e o+ t"e re&e,ant Po&icy O%0ecti,es

    %$%LAS#S
    Biolation of $ational Resettlement Policy

    No e++orts /ere #ade to #ini#i2e t"e socia& T"e resett&e#ents "a,e %een esta%&is"ed +ar3 i#pacts' a/ay +ro# t"e sett&ers< /or8p&aces' So T"ose /"o /ere s#a&& %*siness additiona& cost"a,ino+ transportation "as in to t"eir %e e,icted p&aces %y /ere depri,ed o+ t"eir inc*rred t"e a++ectees' Rs B>7>>> /as not a ES*++icientF co#pensation &i,e&i"ood' a#o*nt +or t"e constr*ction o+ "o*se on a ?> s$ yards p&ot'

    e0#&reme't > 2

    Identi+y t"e resett&e#ent areas /it" pec*&iarities and ana&y2e t"e i#pact o+ LERP on socio3econo#ic conditions o+ t"e resett&ed pop*&ation /it" specia& re+erence to co#pensation po&icy and re&ated iss*es /"et"er t"ose "a,e %een addressed4

    e%ett,eme't area%
    o/nstrea# o+ Lyari ri,er a&&otted .a/8s%ay Hpstrea# o+ Lyari ri,er a&&otted Taiser to/n Midd&e area peop&e a&&otted Ba&dia to/n

    "a+3%ba; re%ett,eme't
    Land area P&ots Occ*pa No o+ Mos$* ncy Sc"oo& es s6 co&&e-e s -100 14 02 Par8s Co##e .ospit rcia& a&s Area

    214 A9re%

    -,434

    21

    11

    31

    Ta&%er To+' re%ett,eme't


    Land area P&ots Occ*pa No o+ Mos$* ncy Sc"oo& es s6 co&&e-e s 1-,000 41 21 Par8s Co##e .ospit rcia& a&s Area

    12 A9re%

    21,000

    31

    -4

    Aa,/&a To+' re%ett,eme't


    Land area P&ots No o+ Mos$*e Sc"oo&s6 s co&&e-es 04 04 Par8s Co##er .ospita& cia& Area s

    4- A9re%

    2,524

    04

    21

    02

    L&<e &' L;ar&


    Ed*cationa& opport*nities /ere &i#ited .ea&t" +aci&ities /ere ins*++icient Co##*nity depended on +is"in- and -ar%a-e co&&ection Wo#en /ere /or8in- in "o*ses as #aids and e#%roidery /or8 Li,in- conditions /ere *n"y-ienic No proper /aste disposa& .ot %ed o+ cri#es &i8e dr*- a%*se6tra+ic8in-

    Sa,&e't Feat#re% o< !om$e'%at&o' $a93a:e


    Cas" co#pensation Rs B>7>>>6I ?> S$*are yards p&ot S*r,ey cond*cted %y Re,en*e eptt

    No care ta8en o+ disa%&ed7 /o#en and e&der&y persons Ba&dia To/n co*&d not attract resett&es Taiser To/n occ*pancy is a%o*t A>J

    Im$a9t%
    Loss o+ e#p&oy#ent especia&&y +or /o#en istant +ro# /or8 p&ace isassociation +ro# pre,io*s co##*nity7

    Loss o+ nei-"%o*r"ood Ne/ ed*cationa& en,iron#ent +or 8ids Lac8 o+ e#otiona& attac"#ent /it" ne/ p&ace .*rd&es in econo#ic acti,ities

    e9omme'/at&o'%
    Co#p&ete "o#e /or8 s"o*&d %e done prior #a8in- po&icy o+ re&ocation Ti#e&y co#p&etion o+ pro0ect #ay %e ens*red to sa,e reso*rces and re&ocation cost Ti#e&y re&eased o+ +inance to co#p&ete t"e pro0ect Concerns o+ t"e sta8e "o&ders %e addressed En,iron#ent i#pact assess#ent #ec"anis# %e ens*red

    e0#&reme't > 3

    Identi+y and e,a&*ate #ain iss*es6 +actors /"ic" ca*sinde&ay in t"e co#p&etion o+ t"is pro0ect and s*--est t"e /ay +or/ard +or nonco#p&iance o+ t"e pro0ect so +ar7 and "o/ %est t"e pro0ect co*&d %e i#p&e#ented s#oot"&y to address t"e concerns o+ t"e sta8e"o&ders6 sett&ers4

    Ma&' I%%#e%
    Socio 3 Econo#ic iss*es
    Rs'B>7>>> is ins*++icient +or constr*ction o+ a "o*se Resett&e#ent sites too +ar +ro# /or8p&aces o+ sett&ers ca*sin- ,ario*s di++ic*&ties' .i-" transport costs7 increased tra,e&&in- ti#e and &ac8 o+ p*%&ic transport

    Socia& depri,ation
    Peop&e "ad a++i&iation /it" t"eir "o#es /"ere t"ey /ere &i,in- +ro# a-es' Socia& press*re o+ &osin- &i,e&i"ood7 0o%s7 sc"oo&s o+ c"i&dren etc' Peop&e resist to c"an-e CP"ysio&o-ica& a++ectD It "as %een a&&e-ed t"at Land Ma+ia and Po&itica& e&e#ents are a&so in,o&,ed

    Po&itica& inter+erence 6 Land #a+ia

    30

    6a; For+ar/

    Ta8in- a&& t"e sta8e "o&ders on %oard I##ediate re&ease o+ Con+idenc +*nds Ens*re Pro,ision o+ %asic e %*i&din%y "ea&t" and ed*cation +aci&ities Constr*ct "o*ses instead o+ -i,in- #oney

    31

    6a; For+ar/

    Pro,ision o+ p*%&ic transport

    Pro,ision o+ e#p&oy#e nt opport*niti es

    Brin-in,ario*s N9Os into t"e resett&e#ent pro0ect

    Or-ani2ations &i8e TC; Ced*cationD7 OPP C"o*sin- and in+rastr*ct*reD7 Ed"i C"ea&t"D can "e&p de,e&op ,ario*s sectors

    Tha'3 7o#
    Fee/ba93 B C?A

    You might also like