Art Parlog Collocations
Art Parlog Collocations
Art Parlog Collocations
HORTENSIA PRLOG
In memoriam Mioara Avram
Abstract. In order to speak a language correctly, one must know what words may
combine or collocate with what other words. A combination or collocation that is
semantically correct and acceptable in one language may not be so in a different
language. The paper focuses on the translation into Romanian of English collocations in
which one of the terms denotes a part of the body. Some of the collocations are
translated literally, particularly if the the term is used in its primary sense. Very often,
however, various changes take place in the translation of each of the items that form a
body collocation.
1. INTRODUCTION
326
Hortensia Prlog
night and dark: one of the meanings of night is its collocability with dark and of
dark, of course, its collocation with night. This kind of mutuality may be paralleled
in most languages (Firth 1958: 196).
Some words have a broad collocational range, while others have a more
limited one. For example, auburn typically occurs with the noun hair, thus forming
a unique or specific or frozen collocation. The adjective ugly, on the other
hand, can combine with a great number of nouns (e.g., building, child, drawing,
face, insinuations, mood, rumours, scar, threats, wound, etc.), forming so-called
free combinations of words, also known as irrelevant, multiple or common
collocations (Banta 1986, Srbu 1987, Hill and Lewis 1997). In free combinations
of this type, the lexical items are not necessarily linked from a semantic point of view.
There is also a distinction to be made between collocations proper and
idiomatic phrases. In a collocation, each lexeme preserves its semantic
independence, while in an idiomatic phrase, the combination has a new meaning,
different from the meanings of its component elements. For example, fresh, salted,
dried herring are collocations, because fresh, salted, dried and herring are
semantically independent, while red herring is an idiomatic phrase, meaning
something intended to divert attention from the real problem or matter; a
misleading clue (mijloc de diversiune, de abatere a ateniei).
We use collocations (more or less) correctly in our own language, because
they are part of our linguistic competence, even if sometimes we are not aware of
their existence and importance. On the other hand, even if we had perfect
knowledge of collocations in our native language, this would not facilitate the
correct use of collocations in a foreign language. In teaching a foreign language,
attention is usually paid to grammatical problems and core vocabulary. But in order
to speak a foreign language correctly, we must know, besides words and
grammatical structures, whether two words can be used together in a way that
sounds natural to a native speaker, i.e. we must know whether the words collocate
or not. Thus, while one can speak of a slight/ minor error, one can only speak of a
minor crime, but not of a *slight crime; one can speak of great shame, but not of
*large shame or *big shame.
Various works on this topic, especially dictionaries of English collocations,
monolingual (e.g. Benson, Benson, Ilson 1986; Kozlowska 1991; Kjellmer 1994;
Hill, Lewis 1997; Oxford Collocations 2002) or bilingual (e.g., Benson, Benson
1993, Prlog, Teleag 1999, 2000), are meant to facilitate the work of translators or
the acquisition of English as a foreign language. Unfortunately, no monolingual
dictionary of Romanian collocations has been compiled so far.
2. TRANSLATION PROBLEMS
The translation of collocations from one language into another is not always
easy; the difficulties that may occur are determined by semantic, grammatical or,
sometimes, cultural differences between the two languages. The translation
327
problems vary from very simple ones, caused by the word order typical of each
language, to more complicated ones, caused by lexical gaps in the target language
or by the absence in the target language equivalent of some semantic feature
present in one of the terms of the English collocation.
Of the many types of collocations that exist in English, attention will be paid
in what follows to the problems raised by the translation into Romanian of the
collocations in which one term is a word denoting a part of the body.
2.1. Some of these collocations are translated literally into Romanian; they
roughly convey the same meaning in the two languages, and consist of equivalent
lexical items, whose linear arrangement is identical. Examples of such collocations
can be easily given: eyes blink / ochii clipesc (Noun + Verb); to lose an eye / a
pierde un ochi (Verb + Noun); a heart of gold / o inim de aur (Noun + preposition
+ Noun); from head to foot / din cap pn n picioare (Phrase).
2.2. Very often, however, the body collocation structures are dissimilar in the
two languages and their Romanian translations represent departures from formal
correspondence or shifts (Catford 1965: 73-82). Several such departures will be
discussed at word level, in connection with some of the terms that form English
body collocations.
2.2.1. Parts of the body
2.2.1.1. The translation of the noun denoting a part of the body sometimes
involves a change of morphological class, called class shift by Catford (1965: 7879); in their categorization of translation procedures, Vinay and Darbelnet
(1958/1995: 30-41) call it transposition. The noun denoting a part of the body
becomes a different part of speech in Romanian, most frequently an adjective: e.g.:
heart murmur / murmur cardiac; have a heart / fii milos [be compassionate];
head work = munc intelectual ; eye contact / contact vizual; eye witness / martor
ocular; eye strings / fibre oculare; eye ball / glob ocular; bone tissue / esut osos;
ear cornet or ear tube / cornet acustic; face ache / nevralgie facial; flesh wound /
ran superficial, uoar; flesh glove / mnu aspr (de baie), etc. (Comments on
the word order in the two languages will be made under 2.2.3.1.).
2.2.1.2. A more complex modification occurs in the case of what the above
quoted Vinay and Darbelnet (1958/1995: 30-41) call modulation, i.e. a variation
of the form of the message obtained by a change in the point of view. They state
that such a change occurs when, although a literal or even transposed translation
results in a grammatically correct utterance, it is considered unsuitable, unidiomatic
or awkward in the TL.Very often, particularly when the English part of the body
occurring in a collocation has a figurative meaning, it is translated into Romanian
by a different part of the body or by an abstract word.
328
Hortensia Prlog
Thus, the Romanian equivalent of heart may be the Romanian words for
eyes, legs, chest/breast, stomach: e.g., sob, cry, weep ones heart out / a-i
seca ochii de atta plns; my heart fails me / mi se taie picioarele (de fric); press
to ones heart / a strnge la piept; heart burn / arsuri la stomac. In certain structures
head is translated as ureche ear, frunte forehead, gur mouth, gt neck,
nas nose, ochi eyes, falc jaw (i.e. some part of the head is used for the
whole) or as mn hand, palm palm, talp sole of the foot, piele skin,
and even snge blood: e.g., off / out of ones head / ntr-o ureche; the head of a
queue /(cei din) fruntea cozii; the head of a cave / gura unei peteri; to crane ones
head / a-i ntinde gtul; throw oneself at sbs head / a se arunca de gtul cuiva, a-i
face ochi dulci; two heads are better than one / patru ochi vd mai bine dect doi;
to sit upon sbs head / a tia cuiva nasul; have a long head / a avea nas bun; the
head of an axe / talpa toporului; to risk ones head / a-i pune pielea n saramur; to
have (got) a swollen head, get the swollen head / a nu-i mai ncpea n piele, a se
umfla n pene; to knock sbs head off / a trage cuiva o palm, a muta flcile cuiva;
let sb have his/ her head, give sb his/ her head / a da mn liber; to keep ones
head / a-i pstra sngele rece; cool, level head / snge rece, etc. English structures
with eye correspond to Romanian structures containing words like ureche ear,
gur mouth, cap head, fa face: the eye of the needle / urechea acului; the
eye of a mine / gur de min; up to the eyes / pn peste cap; eyes right! / capul
spre dreapta; eyes front! / capul nainte; in the eye of the law / n faa legii. Other
examples are: belly dance / dansul buricului; troubled breast / inim tulburat,
chinuit; the womb of the earth / mruntaiele pmntului; the jaws of death /
ghearele morii; to hold ones jaw / a-i ine gura; to lie on ones stomach / a sta pe
burt; fed to the teeth / stul pn peste cap, pn-n gt; glib tongue / bun de gur;
a shoulder of lamb / picior de miel; to have sb. on the hip / a avea pe cineva la
mn; to rap sb. over the knuckles / a lovi peste degete, etc.
Examples of Romanian abstract words used as equivalents of only three
English parts of the body (heart, head and eye) are suflet, contiin, curaj,
ndrzneal, gnd, mil, nclinaie, gust, interes, atitudine, mijloc, centru, miez,
esen, etc. for heart; minte, inteligen, gnd, judecat, nelegere, iniiativ,
via, presiune, titlu, nucleu, punct culminant, ef, etc. for head; vedere, privire,
atenie, observaie, prere, perspicacitate, centru, mijloc, etc. for eye. Sometimes,
however, modulation parallels the literal translation. Here are some collocations
with these words: to bare, open, pour out, uncover, unlock ones heart / a-i
deschide inima, sufletul; to search ones heart / a-i cerceta inima, contiina; have
a heart / fie-i mil; to have heart / a avea curaj; the heart of the matter / miezul
problemei; a change of heart / o schimbare de atitudine; clear head / minte, cap
limpede; above, over ones head / depind nelegerea cuiva; to keep a cool head /
a-i pstra calmul, cumptul; the head of a river / izvoarele rului; head loss /
pierdere de presiune; head word / cuvnt titlu; head of state / ef de stat; to risk
ones head / a-i risca viaa, capul; sharp eyes / privire ptrunztoare; good eyes /
329
vedere bun, ochi buni; in the public eye / n atenia public; camera eye / memorie
vizual; in, to sb.s/ones eye(s) / dup prerea cuiva; bulls eye / centrul intei, etc.
2.2.1.3. Sometimes Romanian adverbials replace the source language body
parts altogether: e.g., set ones heart on sth / a-i dori ceva foarte mult [want sth.
very much]; work ones head off / a munci pe rupte [work very hard]; sit upon
sb.s head / a pune pe cineva la locul lui [put sb. in his/her place]; eat ones
head off / a mnca ct apte [eat enormously]; snap sb.s head off / a vorbi cuiva
brutal, grosolan, a i-o reteza scurt [speak rudely, abruptly].
2.2.2. Determiners
2.2.2.1. The articles
English and Romanian have, in broad lines, a formally corresponding
systems of articles: in both languages one may distinguish zero, definite and
indefinite articles: e.g., to make_ eyes at / a face_ ochi dulci, to have_ heart / a
avea_curaj, a change of_heart / schimbare de_atitudine (zero article), the heart of
the city / inima oraului, (in) the eyes of the world / (n) ochii lumii (definite
article), cast an eye (over) / a arunca un ochi, o privire (peste), have an eye in
ones head / a avea un ochi ager (indefinite article).
While in both languages, the indefinite article precedes the noun it
determines, the English definite article, which has an invariable form, always
precedes the noun it determines and the Romanian definite article is, in most cases,
enclitic, has no formal independence, being attached to the word that it determines,
and is variable (depending on number and gender). For example, not to have the
heart (to) / a nu avea inima (s) (inim is a feminine noun); the head of the table /
capul mesei (cap is a neutre noun); (in) the eyes of the world / (n) ochii lumii (ochi
is a masculine noun), etc.
There are many collocations where the equivalent of an article in the source
language is not the corresponding word in the target language system.
The English definite article may correspond to the zero article in Romanian:
e.g., disease, condition of the heart / boal de _ inim; to beat out of the head / a
scoate din_ cap, minte; to leap to the eye / a sri n_ochi, sparkle in the eye /
strlucire n_ochi. On the other hand, the English zero article may correspond to a
Romanian definite article: e.g., to lose_heart / a pierde curajul; to put, plant, set_
foot (in, on) / a pune piciorul (n, pe); to shake_hands / a da mna, while the
English indefinite article turns sometimes either into a Romanian definite article or
into the zero article: e.g., have a (good) head on ones shoulders / a fi cu capul pe
umeri; have a head / a-l durea capul; turn a blind eye (to sth.) / a nchide ochii (la
ceva); have a head (for) / a avea_ cap (pentru); have a heart / ai_ mil. These are
examples of what Catford calls intra-system shifts, where the shift occurs
internally, within a system (1965: 80). They are cases where SL and TL possess
systems which approximately correspond formally as to their constitution, but
when translation involves selection of a non-corresponding term in the TL system.
(Catford 1965: 80).
330
Hortensia Prlog
331
translated collocation contains not only a structure shift, but also a class shift. For
example:
the premodifying adjective may become a prepositional noun phrase: e.g.,
human heart / inim de om; human head / cap de om; departmental head / ef de
secie, de catedr; nominal head / ef de form, cu numele; gappy teeth / dini cu
strungrea; wise tooth / msea de minte; manly shoulders / umeri, spate de
brbat;
a pre-modifying noun may become an adjective e.g., block, cabbage head /
cap prost, sec; bedroom eyes / ochi seductori; mustard eyes / ochi galbeni, glbui;
saucer eyes / ochi mari i rotunzi; body clock / ceas biologic; body guard / gard
personal; body search / percheziie corporal; stomach muscles / muchi
abdominali; stomach pump / pomp stomacal;
the adjectival nature of the English participles makes it easily possible for
them to have Romanian adjectives as equivalents: e.g., greying head / cap crunt;
loving heart / inim iubitoare; piercing, penetrating eyes / ochi ptrunztori;
shining, sparkling eyes / ochi strlucitori;
the participle may even be translated as a (prepositional) noun phrase: e.g.,
bulging eyes / ochi de broasc; a sinking heart / o strngere de inim.
2.2.3.3. The English pre-modifier expressed by a noun in the common case is
frequently translated as a post-modifying prepositional noun phrase; the noun
governed by the preposition is in the accusative case. We deal therefore with a
change of word order and of modifier structure. The most frequent preposition is
de, but other prepositions are also possible. Here are some examples: heart beat /
btaie de inim; heart attack / criz de inim; head hunting / vntoare de capete;
head loss / pierdere de presiune; eye operation / operaie de ochi; glass eye / ochi
de sticl; wisdom tooth / msea de minte; heart surgery / operaie pe inim; heart
burn / arsuri la stomac; head injury / ran la cap; head sea / valuri din prova; eye
signal / semn cu ochiul.
2.2.3.4. The pre-modifying English noun, used in the common case, may
correspond to a Romanian post-modifying noun in the genitive case: e.g., heart
beat / btaie a inimii; family head / capul familiei, cap al familiei; head cold /
rceal a capului; eye injury / leziune a ochiului; eye infection / infecie a ochiului.
The nouns in the genitive case take the definite article, and are sometimes preceded
by the possessive article as well (a for feminine singular nouns, al for masculine
and neutre singular nouns).
2.2.3.5. The pre-modifier may undergo a function shift, turning into a
Romanian head noun (while the English head noun naming a part of the body
becomes the Romanian post-modifier): e.g., a sinking heart / o strngere de inim;
camera eye / memorie vizual.
2.2.3.6. Sometimes, especially when one of the terms of the English structure
does not have a single lexeme as an equivalent in Romanian (i.e., when the target
332
Hortensia Prlog
333
scapr plini de mnie [eyes give an angry look]; eyes twinkle / ochii scnteiaz,
licresc amuzai [eyes shine in an amused way];
duration of the action: ones heart skips, misses a beat/ inima se oprete o
secund/o clip [ones heart stops for a second/ moment];
instrument of the action: to hold, clutch ones head / a se ine, a se lua, a se
apuca cu minile de cap [hold ones head with ones hands];
place of the action: show ones head / a scoate capul n lume [show ones
face in public];
duration + manner of the action: eyes dart / ochii se ndreapt o clip,
brusc, pe neateptate, [eyes look briefly and suddenly].
Dimitriu (2002: 35) points out that Vinay and Darbelnet (1958) were the first to
mention this technique of explicitation, later on referred to as addition by Nida
(1964), by means of which one explains in the target language translation what is
implicit in the source language text.
2.2.6. The whole collocation
2.2.6.1. It very often happens that the English collocation is translated into
Romanian by one word only.
This may be a verb (often a reflexive one), e.g.: touch sbs heart / a
impresiona, a mica (pe cineva) [impress, move sb.]; give heart to sb. / a
ncuraja, a sprijini [encourage, support]; lose heart / a se descuraja [become
discouraged]; cross ones heart / a se jura [swear]; ones heart sinks / a se
dezumfla, a se potoli [feel, be flat, deflated]; make head / a progresa, a nainta
[(make) progress, advance]; gather head / a crete, a se umfla, a (se) coace
[grow, swell]; make head or tail of sth. / a pricepe, a nelege [understand];
bite sb.s head off / a se repezi la [attack verbally]; keep an eye on / a observa, a
urmri [watch]; give sb. the eye / a flirta [flirt]; dust sb.s eyes / a deruta, a
nela, a mbrobodi [mislead, cheat]; draw, pull the wool over sb.s eyes / a
orbi, a mbrobodi (pe cineva) [hoodwink, twist sb. round ones little finger].
The English collocations made up of nouns (noun + noun or noun + of +
noun) often have a Romanian noun as equivalent: e.g., heart specialist / cardiolog
[cardiologist]; heart burning / gelozie, invidie [jealousy, envy]; heart break
/ mhnire, suprare [grief, sorrow]; head count / recensmnt [census];
head band / cordelu; head dress / coafur, frizur [hairdo]; head scarf / batic,
fular; head of hair / chic [long, thick hair]; head of a flower / inflorescen,
capitul [capitulum]; eye doctor / oftalmolog [ophthalmologist]; eye socket /
orbit; eye wink / ochead [(sidelong) glance]; eye sore / urcior [sty]; the eye
of a door / vizor, ferestruic [peep hole, peep window]. A whole phrase may be
translated as one noun: all my eye (and Betty Martin) / prostii, fleacuri
[nonsense]. The noun may be a substantivized adjective: e.g., dear, sweet heart /
scumpule, scumpo, dragule, draga mea.
334
Hortensia Prlog
10
11
335
refer to an instance of harm to somebodys eye in The tennis ball hit me in the eye /
Mingea de tenis m-a lovit n ochi, or it may indicate that something is very
obvious, noticeable in The graffiti hit me in the eye / Atenia mi-a fost atras de
graffiti; Graffiti mi-a srit n ochi. To open ones eyes wide / a deschide ochii mari
may refer to a movement of the organ of sight, but in the sentence I hope her words
have opened your eyes / Sper c spusele ei i-au deschis ochii/ te-au fcut s
nelegi, the meaning is a figurative one [make sb. understand, realize the truth
about sth].
A collocation like to go to ones head may have two figurative meanings: to
get dizzy, slightly drunk, as in The plum brandy went straight to my head / Mi s-a
urcat uica la cap, and to make one conceited or too confident, in The success of
her speech went to her head / Succesul cuvntrii i s-a suit la cap. The eye of the
storm may denote a relatively calm spot in the centre of a hurricane and the
middle of a difficult situation, etc.
The meaning of a collocation is dictated sometimes by the way in which the
word collocates not only lexically, but also grammatically. An example is offered
by the co-occurrence of the verbs have and lose and the noun heart: in have heart,
the noun is determined by the zero article, and its metaphorical meaning is
courage; in have a heart, the determiner is the indefinite article, and the
metaphorical meaning changes to pity, sympathy; have a heart for [sth.],
where heart takes an indefinite article and is followed by a preposition, suggests
inclination, liking; not have the heart to (do sth), where heart is determined by
the definite article and followed by the long infinitive, suggests kindness, lack
of cruelty. Lose heart (zero article) means feel disappointed and stop believing
that you can succeed, while lose ones heart (to sb.) (possessive determiner
preceding the noun and a possible prepositional noun phrase following it) means
start to love someone, fall in love.
At the same time, I am also aware that this analysis is far from being
complete and that one might come across many more ways of translating body
collocations and other types of shifts as well. The important thing to bear in mind is
that, even if equivalence is not perfect, it is always possible to translate the
meaning of a source language body collocation into another language, and that a
good translation involves a good knowledge of both source and target languages,
down to their minutest details.
REFERENCES
Avram, M., 2001, Gramatica pentru toi, Bucureti, Humanitas.
Banta, A., 1986, Noiunea de colocabilitate i aplicaiile ei lexicografice, Studii i cercetri
lingvistice, XXXVII, 3, 215220.
Benson, M., E. Benson, 1993, The Russian English Dictionary of Verbal Collocations, Amsterdam,
John Benjamins Publishing Company.
336
Hortensia Prlog
12
Benson M., E. Benson, R. Ilson, 1986, The BBI Combinatory Dictionary of English. A Guide to Word
Combinations, Amsterdam/ Philadelphia, John Benjamins Publishing Company.
Catford, J.C., 1965, A Linguistic Theory of Translation, London, Oxford University Press.
Dimitriu, R., 2002, Theories and Practice of Translation, Iai, Institutul European.
Firth, J. R., 1958 (1957), Modes of Meaning, Papers in Linguistics. 19341951, London, Oxford
University Press, 190215.
Hill, J., M. Lewis (eds.), 1997, Dictionary of Selected Collocations, Hove, Language Teaching
Publications.
Kjellmer, G., 1994, A Dictionary of English Collocations, Oxford, Clarendon Press.
Kozlowska, C. D., 1991, English Adverbial Collocations, Warszawa, Wydawnictwo Naukowe PWN.
Prlog, H., M. Teleag, 1999, Dicionar de colocaii nominale englez romn, Timioara, Editura
Mirton.
Prlog, H., M. Teleag (coord.), 2000, Dicionar englez-romn de colocaii verbale, Iai, Polirom.
Porzig, W., 1934, Wesenhafte Bedeutungsbeziehungen, Beitrage zur Geschichte der deutschen
Sprache und Literatur, 58, 7097.
Srbu, R., 1987, Colocaie i coligaie n sintagmatica lexico-semantic, Filologie, XXX,
Timioara, Tipografia Universitii, 5364.
Vinay, J. P., J. Darbelnet, 1958/1995, Stylistique compare du franais et de langlais. Mthode de
traduction, Paris, Didier; trans. and ed. By J.C. Sager and M.-J. Hamel (1995), as Comparative
Stylistics of French and English: A Methodology for Translation, Amsterdam and
Philadelphia, John Benjamins.
***, 2002, Oxford Collocations Dictionary for Students of English, Oxford, Oxford University Press.