With all due respect to Anthony Vargas, the subject of this AdExchanger article mistargets blame. We cannot be passing the buck by chastising ad verification vendors for missing an MFA fraud edge case. And even Media.net's likely complicity isn't where we should be pointing fingers. The perpetrator is the publisher, who created this MFA garbage dump and duped advertisers and agencies that trusted their brand for its quality and accountability. Since last week, has any SSP or DSP removed Forbes from their programmatic auctions? Have brands placed Forbes in the penalty box? Is Forbes still earning tens (hundreds?) of thousands in programmatic revenue every day? We all love the adtech punching bag. But in this case, redirecting blame because a watchdog failed to catch an unusual edge case misses the point that a trusted publishing brand breached its social contract and nobody seems to be doing anything but pushing its nose into the shit on the carpet and saying "bad dog." If we leave the incentives for fraud in place, it'll just keep happening.
Isn't the real problem bad/lazy incentives from the buy-side where verification serves to "check the box" rather than convey any real measure of value?
David…the reason we blame the adtech is because they told us to hire them to catch this exact thing. If they cannot catch the “simplest form of ad fraud” then maybe we should be scrutinizing all their other claims — and the certifying bodies that have “accredited” those claims. The blame is appropriate.
Great points. Forbes is not alone. So many "reputable" publishers have become cesspools of sludge as programmatic partners, advertisers and publishers have enabled this for a long time before MFA became MFA. All parties have degrees of responsibility.
With no respect. if adtech doesn’t do anything, whats the business? Takes people money and use it and complain on LinkedIn when people want accountability? Ad quality is trash and is wild to see how much money is wasted when regular people are going thru a hellish experience
Co-Founder at Check My Ads Institute / The Adtech Watchdog 🐾
7moAlso how is blaming Forbes going to do *anything* to stop the thousands of other publishers doing the same exact thing? If I wanted to be ineffective and change nothing, I guess I would go around blaming Forbes!!