The 5 Best Silicone Spatulas of 2024, Tested and Reviewed

Our Favorite Silicone Spatulas

For a variety of head shapes, comfortability, and heat resistance, the U-Taste Silicone Spatula Set ticks all the boxes, giving you four tools specialized to various situations. The KitchenAid Bamboo Handle Scraper Spatula earned our best value pick for its solid scraping ability at a great price.

Our Silicone Spatula Tests

We tested seven spatulas and spatula sets for this roundup, in various sizes and shapes, and with various handle materials and designs. We paid particular attention to how versatile, comfortable, heat resistant, and easy to clean each spatula was. We considered the construction, pliability, shape, and size, and put them through a set of identical tests.

• Brownie Test: We used each spatula to mix a batch of boxed brownie batter in a standard round mixing bowl, recording how comfortable the spatula felt to hold and effectively it mixed the thick batter. We then scooped the batter into a square baking pan, noting if the spatula designs were able to get every bit of batter out of the bowl.
• Measuring Cup Test: To asses the usefulness of different shapes and levels of flexibility, we filled a measuring cup with brownie batter and used each spatula to scoop it back out. We paid special attention in this test to how well the spatula maneuvered in the corners, as well as how easy and comfortable it was to use.
• Caramel Test: To test out heat resistance, we made homemade caramel over the stove, stirring with the spatula and noting whether the handle got too hot to hold comfortably. We also looked at the manufacturer's recommended temperature limit and noted whether the tools warped or melted at all during testing.
• Cleaning Test: After the brownie and caramel tests, we washed each spatula following the manufacturer's directions. We ran dishwasher-safe spatulas through the dishwasher but also hand-washed them at least once to see how easily sticky ingredients washed off by hand. We noted any warping or damage to wooden handles, and whether any food was especially difficult to remove.

After we finished our other tests, we revealed the retail prices of the spatulas to consider value. At the time of testing, the prices ranged from $9 to $25, with an average cost of about $15. Interestingly, the most and least expensive items we tested were both multi-spatula sets, with all the single spatulas settling in the middle.

Factors to Consider

Comfort

When it comes to a tool you'll want to reach for over and over again, comfort is a major factor. Consider the handle material: wood or silicone? Size also comes to play. Longer spatulas might feel unwieldy while smaller ones sometimes require a little more elbow grease depending the task at hand.

Heat Resistance

Depending on how you're planning to use your spatula, you may not have to consider this. However, the best spatula is a multi-tasker that can seamlessly integrate into whatever you like to do in the kitchen. Not all spatulas react well to heat and may even burn, melt, or warp when exposed to extreme temperatures. If you know you're going to be mixing up batches of homemade caramel, tossing freshly deep fried food, or flipping a steak while you reverse-sear, look for a spatula with a high maximum temperature.

Shape and Versatility

Spatulas can be used to mix batter, stir in hot pans, scrape bowls, and much more. Some shapes are better for particular tasks. For example, spatulas with a curved and tapered edge are optimal for scraping and mixing, whereas spatulas with a flatter head are more ideal for scooping. Although the best spatula is one that is versatile and can be used for more than just one type of task. Another thing to keep in mind is the size of the head. If it's too big, it may be difficult to maneuver around small bowls or scrape tight corners. Spatulas with smaller heads or mini spatulas can't stand up to large volume bowls the way their larger counterparts can.

Ease of Cleaning

If you are looking for dishwasher-safe kitchen tools, then silicone tools are a good bet. (Many wooden ones, for example, must be hand-washed.) Some spatulas have removable silicone heads that you can pop in the dishwasher with a wooden handle that needs to be hand-washed, though this may not be suitable for some people, as food can easily get stuck in the space in between. Generally, silicone is a very slick material that's easy to clean, but some brands use silicone with a more shiny or more matte finish which can impact how easy it is to clean.

Other Spatulas We Tested

Cuisinart Flex & Flip ($17 at Walmart)

The long handle would work well for mixing in a big bowl or stand mixer and it had a comfortable grip but unfortunately, it did not take the heat well and came out discolored and even melted in some parts after the caramel test.

Cuisinart Mini Spatulas ($9 at Amazon)

Since this is a mini set, we wouldn't recommend these for your everyday baking needs though they held up against the heat.

Our Expertise

Lauren Musni is a Food & Wine fellow with an associate's degree in culinary arts from the Culinary Institute of America. She wrote this piece based on our test results, her personal experience working in restaurants, and her love for baking and cooking.