Make Big-Batch Drinks in Advance for the Easiest Holiday Cocktail Hour

This bartender-approved trick is key to a stress-free holiday happy hour.

Cranberry Punch with Sumac
Photo:

Chris Simpson / Food Styling by Julian Hensarling / Prop Styling by Thom Driver

No matter how carefully you compose your grocery lists, curate your recipes, or tailor your run of show, there inevitably will be an “oh, hell” moment during the holidays at some point before guests arrive. But with a bit of advance planning, and, crucially, by making a big batch of cocktails a few days ahead, you can throw a great, chaos-free happy hour — and enjoy it, too.

Choosing the right kinds of cocktails to batch and storing them properly is key. Not all cocktails can be premade equally. “Alcohol doesn’t freeze, but mixers do,” says Vancouver-based bartender Kaitlyn Stewart. “Any batched drink that is primarily spirit-forward, like a Martini, Negroni, or Manhattan, can easily be stored in the freezer.” 

The lower the alcohol content of a given ingredient, the higher the water content, making it more likely to freeze. That can adversely affect a cocktail’s flavors and textures: “Any drink that is mixer-heavy, like a margarita or punch, should be stored in the fridge, not the freezer,” says Stewart.

And while cocktail ingredients often have more longevity than, say, the dairy you’re mixing into mashed potatoes, some last longer than others. “Fresh citrus juice is ideal for making drinks, but it does have a shelf life,” says Stewart. As citrus juices oxidize, they lose their fresh, punchy flavors; if you make batched cocktails with them, enjoy them within a week. 

Here are 9 recipes for batched cocktails that make holiday happy hours a breeze.

01 of 09

Spiced Apple-Bourbon Punch

Bushels and Barrels

Frederick Hardy II / Food Styling by Emily Nabors Hall / Prop Styling by Risha Carnes

The combination of tangy apple cider, sweet apple brandy, and cinnamon syrup creates a warming, autumnal bourbon cocktail that has the aroma of fresh apple pie.

02 of 09

Bottled Manhattan

Bottled Manhattan
Greg DuPree

Pre-mixing batches of this rye-forward Manhattan in bottles means no more stirring drinks at the last minute or fussing with ice and strainers. When your guests arrive, you can spend time being a good host rather than a frazzled bartender. 

03 of 09

Cranberry-Sumac Punch

Cranberry Punch with Sumac

Chris Simpson / Food Styling by Julian Hensarling / Prop Styling by Thom Driver

This nonalcoholic punch from chef Mashama Bailey leans on a tart and sweet blend of sugar, fresh cranberry, and sumac, a tangy Middle Eastern spice. Sparkling water adds spritzy effervescence to this holiday-ready red-hued drink.

04 of 09

Little Lebowski

The Little Lebowski

Frederick Hardy II / Food Styling by Emily Nabors Hall / Prop Styling by Risha Carnes

The White Russian, a boozy, caffeinated cocktail made with cream and coffee liqueur, was popularized by the 1998 feature film The Big Lebowski. Stewart’s playful and aptly named Little Lebowski subs in velvety eggnog for heavy cream, giving this holiday-ready cocktail a custard-like richness that’s countered by bittersweet notes of cold brew coffee, coffee liqueur, and amaro. 

05 of 09

Pomegranate-Tequila Punch

Spiked & Spiced

Frederick Hardy II / Food Styling by Emily Nabors Hall / Prop Styling by Risha Carnes

Piquant and slightly lemony, ginger tea gives this sweet-and-sour tequila and pomegranate cocktail an underlying soothing, warming spiciness. The crisp, clean flavor of blanco tequila allows the tart pomegranate juice and sweet maple syrup to shine. 

06 of 09

Tom and Jerry

Tom and Jerry

Chelsea Kyle / Food Styling by Drew Aichele

Typically made around Christmastime, the Tom and Jerry is a classic Cognac and rum-spiked cocktail that looks and tastes a lot like eggnog and can be batched the night before serving.

07 of 09

Sparkling Elderflower Negroni

High & Dry

Frederick Hardy II / Food Styling by Emily Nabors Hall / Prop Styling by Risha Carnes

Much like a Negroni, this cocktail draws on the citrusy flavors of Campari and the herbaceous notes of gin. Building on the flavors of a classic Negroni, the High and Dry calls for orange blossom water which gives the drink powerful floral citrus flavor with just a few drops.

08 of 09

Datu Datu Martini

Datu Puti Martini
Victor Protasio / Food Styling by Chelsea Zimmer / Prop Styling by Claire Spollen

The strong juniper flavor of London Dry Gin is balanced by the warming spices, gentle fruity sweetness, and acidity of the Datu Puti vinegar in this martini recipe that can be stored in the freezer for up to a month for ready-in-seconds batched cocktails. 

09 of 09

Sparkling Citrus Punch

Mother's Ruin

Chelsea Kyle / Food Styling by Drew Aichele

A celebration of citrus season, this vibrant punch recipe features fresh grapefruit and lemon, and orangey sweet vermouth and citrus-scented Champagne.

Was this page helpful?

Related Articles