Unit 2 The allocation of resources: Unit 2 The allocation of resources: how the market works; market failure

how the market works; market failure

Activities: Guidance and answers
Activity 2.1 Tropical trouble
Your groups may have discussed the following problems and solutions.
1 Scarcity of resources relative to the needs and wants of the survivors.
2 This activity involved deciding how best to allocate resources to different
uses. For example, is shelter a priority or is finding and storing more food of a
priority? Therefore, it also involves deciding which needs and wants to satisfy
with the available resources.
At one extreme you could rely on survival of fittest. Those able to gather the
most food and resources will survive while the old, sick or injured are unlikely to.
Alternatively, resources can be gathered by the able-bodied and then shared out
equally between all the survivors or on the basis of need. Decisions on how best
to use resources and whose needs and wants to satisfy first can also be taken by
a committee.

Activity 2.2 Problem solving

This activity involves completing a table of decisions on what, how and for whom
to produce using scarce resources based on your discussions in activity 2.1.
Together these activities should illustrate that decisions on how best to allocate
scarce resources can be centrally planned or left up to the market (i.e. survival of
the fittest), or some combination of these systems.

Activity 2.3 An introduction to the workings

of a market system
1 The main aim is profit.
2 Firms decide what to produce by asking: for which product is consumer
demand rising? Which product is the most profitable?
3 Firms decide how to produce goods and services by combining available
resources in the most efficient way possible so as to maximize output and
minimize production costs.
4 Teenagers without sufficient money could not satisfy their wants for shoes.
5 They will be unemployed.

Activity 2.4 Mustard

1 Planning decisions were poor and did not take account of consumers’ needs
and wants.
2 Most consumers do not want to buy mustard in such volumes. The mustard
would also perish before they had consumed it all.
3 Instructions should also have been given on size of jars that consumers
wanted to buy.

1
© Brian Titley 2012: this may be reproduced for class use solely for the purchaser’s institute
 Unit 2 The allocation of resources: how the market works; market failure

4 Government planners had to provide millions of different instructions to

many thousands of different firms. Planners decided what goods and services
should be produced but often failed to give clear instructions on what types,
sizes, qualities, etc. were required. Because firms in planned economies had
no profit motive there was no incentive for them to minimize waste to reduce
their costs and/or improve product quality to generate revenues.

Activity 2.5 Freedom of choice in a market economy

1 People with the greatest ability to pay for these goods and services.
2 People with high incomes or wealth, like those in the first photograph, have
more freedom to choose in a market economy. This is because private sector
firms will produce the goods and services they are willing and able to buy if it
is profitable to do so. The people in the second photograph are unemployed
and are unlikely to have sufficient income or wealth to buy many goods
and services.

Activity 2.6 Mixing it up

Article Problems with a mixed economic system
Veterinary surgeons accused of overcharging Some firms acting together can abuse their market power
Corporate tax on the profits of local businesses is Taxes can distort markets and reduce incentives
too high
New employment regulations and taxes will impose Laws and regulations can increase production costs, reduce the supply
costs on business of goods and services and increase prices
Customers warned energy bills are to stay high The profit motives of private sector firms may result in high prices,
especially if consumers have few substitutes to choose from
Supermarket suppliers Some producers and consumers may ignore the harmful effects of
‘helping destroy Amazon rainforest’ their decisions and actions

Government policies Firms will only supply products to consumers who are able to pay for
failing the poor them. Public sector organizations may also be inefficient and produce
poor-quality goods and services
Turks and Caicos PM quits after corruption inquiry Some governments may take actions that are for political or even
personal gain

2
© Brian Titley 2012: this may be reproduced for class use solely for the purchaser’s institute
 Unit 2 The allocation of resources: how the market works; market failure

Activity 2.7 A taxing time

1

Article Winners? Losers?

Cuba to cut 1 million public sector jobs Increase in labour supply for private Public sector employees who lose their
sector firms may help lower wages jobs
Food shortages and higher prices Taxpayers may benefit from cuts in Farmers who lose subsidies; consumers
taxes as subsidies are reduced; Or other faced with higher food prices
sectors benefit if government spending
is redirected
Sharp cuts to public spending Other taxpayers will benefit from Consumers pay higher prices due to
reduced government debt and interest increase in VAT; banks will have to
payments – this will reduce the need to pay more tax from their profits; public
raise taxes again sector workers lose their jobs; people
on welfare lose their benefits or have
them cut
Microsoft threatens to move jobs Other taxes may be cut or government Companies pay more tax on their
overseas spending may increase to benefit other profits; jobs may be cut as firms try to
sectors reduce their costs
Increase in taxes on electricity Producers of solar energy panels and Energy users pay higher prices
power will benefit; cleaner energy
will also benefit the environment and
reduce health problems
Additional tax measures Public sector workers benefit from Taxpayers must pay more
increased pay; people on welfare will
receive more support

2 All the articles highlight conflicts of interest. This is because public

expenditures must be paid for from tax revenues. Increasing public sending,
for example to benefit public sector workers, people or welfare payments,
or to provide subsidies to private sector firms to boost output and jobs, will
mean higher taxes for taxpayers, for example for consumers if sales of value
added taxes are increased, for companies if taxes of their profits rise, or for
employees if incomes taxes are raised. Similarly, cuts in public spending may
hurt people on welfare and public sector employees but can lower taxes from
many other people and firms.

Activity 2.8 Food for thought

1 The market for food products consists of all those producers willing and able
to supply food products and all those consumers willing and able to buy them.
2 Consumer wants for healthier, organic food products are rising and they are
falling for less-healthy options.
3 Consumers are becoming more health-conscious and concerned about the
impact of intensive farming methods on the environment and about the
maltreatment of animals.
4 The prices and profitability of many organic food products is rising.
5 More resources are being allocated to the production of organic food products.

3
© Brian Titley 2012: this may be reproduced for class use solely for the purchaser’s institute
 Unit 2 The allocation of resources: how the market works; market failure

Activity 2.9 What is your individual demand?

1 Your demand schedule may be similar to the following.

Possible price of a chocolate bar (cents) Your demand per month

200 1
150 2
100 3
50 5
25 6

2
PRICE OF A CHOCOLATE BAR (cents)

200

150

100

50

0
1 2 3 4 5 6

QUANTITY OF CHOCOLATE BARS PER WEEK

3 a, b and c apply.

Activity 2.10 Market demand curve

1

50
Price ($)

40

30

20

10

0
50 100 150 200 250 300 350 400 450
Quantity of orange light bulbs (thousands) per month

2 a around 170,000 b around 300,000

3 a around 27 cents b around 8 cents
4 The market demand curve slopes downwards because as prices rises
consumers cannot afford to buy as many.
5 A market demand curve shows the total quantity all consumers of the
product would be willing and able to buy at different prices. An individual
demand curve only shows what one consumer would be willing and able
to buy. A market demand curve for a product is therefore the sum of all
individual demand curves for the same product.

4
© Brian Titley 2012: this may be reproduced for class use solely for the purchaser’s institute
 Unit 2 The allocation of resources: how the market works; market failure

Activity 2.11 What causes a shift in demand?

1

Article 1a Factor that has changed 1b Impact on demand

Income tax cut in Malaysian Income after tax has Increase in demand for many
Budget increased products
World population growth Increase in number of Increase in demand for many
consumers products
Demand for online music Fall in price on personal Increase in demand for music
services soars music players downloads
Australia raises interest rate Increase in cost of borrowing; Fall in demand for many
increase in return to saving goods and services as
demand for loans falls and
people also save more
India tries to keep its cool Hot weather Increase in demand for ice
cream and soft drinks

2
Price per can of fizzy drink

D D1

D D1

Quantity of cans per day

DD = market demand curve before hot weather; D1D1 = market demand

during hot weather

Activity 2.12 Competing or complementary?

Products Possible substitutes Products Possible complements
Electric oven Gas oven Flat-screen televisions Video players
Woollen jumpers Fleeces Fountain pens Ink
Gas supplies Electricity Guitars Strings
iPods Other digital music players Toothbrushes Toothpaste
Rail journeys Bus travel Computers Software

5
© Brian Titley 2012: this may be reproduced for class use solely for the purchaser’s institute
 Unit 2 The allocation of resources: how the market works; market failure

Activity 2.13 The market supply curve

20
PRICE PER TANKARD($)

16

12

0
100 200 300 400 500 600 700 800 900 1000 1100 1200 1300 1400 1500 1600
QUANTITY OF TANKARDS PER MONTH

1 Supply extends as price rises and supply contracts as price falls.

2 A fall in price will cause an extension in supply.
3 A rise in price will cause a contraction of supply.
4 a Around 1,000 per month b Around 500 per month.
5 a $12 b $12 × 700 = $8,400 per month
6

Output of tankards per Total cost ($) Total revenue ($) Profit ($)
month
100 600 600 0
300 1,800 2,400 600
700 4,000 8,400 4,400
1,100 6,200 17,600 11,400
1,600 9,000 32,000 23,000

The market supply curve for tankard slopes upwards to the right – i.e. market
supply extends as price rises – because producers can make more profit as
price rises.

Activity 2.14 What causes a shift in supply?

• The most profitable crop to grow is cabbages.
• Farmers should grow more potatoes; the supply of cabbages will fall.
• Farmers should grow more cabbages; the supply of potatoes will fall and the
supply of cabbages will rise.
• The farmer can grow more potatoes and cabbages because of the fall in the
cost of land.
• The supply of cabbages will fall.
• Factors affecting supply are market prices, costs of production, cost and
availability of resources, productivity of resources and weather conditions.

6
© Brian Titley 2012: this may be reproduced for class use solely for the purchaser’s institute
 Unit 2 The allocation of resources: how the market works; market failure

Activity 2.15 Finding the market price

Price of chocolate bars (cents)

50 D S

40

30

20

10
D S

0
100 200 300 400 500

Quantity (thousands) per month

1 30 cents.
2 a Market price is found where the market demand curve crosses the market
supply curve.
b
200,000 per month.
3 a There is excess demand at 5, 10 and 20 cents per unit.
b
There is excess supply at 40 and 50 cents per unit.
4 a Market price should rise.
b
Market prices should fall.
c 
There will be no excess demand or supply when the price is 30 cents
per unit.

Activity 2.16 : A fall in demand and market price

Price per pen (cents)

300 D S

250 D1

200
P

150
P1

100
S D1 D

50

0
100 200 300 400 500
Q1 Q
Quantity (thousands) per week

5 Supply has contracted from 300 pens per week to 200 per week.
6 Fountain and felt-tipped pens fall in price; consumer tastes change to favour
pencils; unemployment rises; income taxes rise.

7
© Brian Titley 2012: this may be reproduced for class use solely for the purchaser’s institute
 Unit 2 The allocation of resources: how the market works; market failure

Activity 2.17 A fall in supply and market price

Price per tonne ($)

600
S1 S

D
500

400
P1

300
P

200
S1

100 S D

0
100 200 300 400 500
Q1 Q
Quantity (thousands of tonnes) per year

4 Market demand has contracted from 300,000 tonnes per year to 200,000
tonnes per year.
5 Poor weather conditions cause crops to fail; farmers grow other crops because
their prices rise and they become profitable; wages and other production
costs rise; the government withdraws farm subsidies; there are labour and
land shortages.

Activity 2.18 A flat-out market

1 Demand increased.
2 Market demand for other televisions fell and supply contracted.
3 Market supply increased and market prices fell.
4 Quantity traded will rise.
5
600
D D1 S
Price of f lat-screen TVs ($)

S1
500

400
P1

300
P

200
P2
S
100

S1 D D1

0
100 200 300 400 500
Q Q1 Q2 Quantity of TVs per period

8
© Brian Titley 2012: this may be reproduced for class use solely for the purchaser’s institute
 Unit 2 The allocation of resources: how the market works; market failure

Activity 2.19 A problem to ‘stretch’ you

Product Small or large change in Price elastic or Why?
quantity demanded? inelastic?
Electricity Small Inelastic Essential, few substitutes
Luxury holiday Large Elastic Expensive, non-essential item
Bread Small Inelastic Essential
A Toyota car Large Elastic Luxury, expensive item with many close substitutes
A newspaper Small Inelastic Low-cost item

Activity 2.20 Using the formula

1 PED = (500/1000)/(10/40) × 100 = 2
2 Demand is relatively price elastic.
3 The demand curve will be gently downward sloping, as shown below.
Price

40

30

0
1000 1500

Quantity per period

Activity 2.21 What happens to total revenue?

1 Loaf of bread: PED = (500/10,000)/(5/25) = 0.25
Airline ticket: PED = (800/1,000)/(100/500) = 4
2

Price per loaf (cents) Quantity demanded per month Total revenue ($)
25 10,000 $2,500
20 10,500 $2,100

Price per airline ticket ($) Quantity demanded per month Total revenue ($)
500 1,000 $500,000
400 1,800 $720,000

9
© Brian Titley 2012: this may be reproduced for class use solely for the purchaser’s institute
 Unit 2 The allocation of resources: how the market works; market failure

3 a No, because revenue will fall. The cut in the price of bread is
proportionately more than the increase in demand.
b 
Yes, because revenue will rise. The increase in demand for tickets is
proportionately greater than the cut in price.
4 a Demand is price elastic when the percentage change in quantity demanded
is more than the percentage change in price. A fall in price will cause a
large extension in quantity demanded so that total sales revenue rises. If
price is increased, total revenue would fall.
b 
Demand is price inelastic when quantity demanded changes by a smaller
percentage than price. A fall in price will cause a small extension in
quantity demanded so that total sales revenue falls. A rise in price therefore
causes total revenue to rise.

Activity 2.22 Elastic brands

1 Flu vaccinations help to prevent a dangerous virus that makes people ill and
can cause deaths. Demand for flu vaccinations is therefore likely to be highly
price inelastic, i.e. PED will be much below 1. In contrast, although meat is a
basic foodstuff for many people we do not need to eat meat to survive. That
is, not only does each type of meat have many close substitutes because there
are many different types of meat from different animals, we can also choose
to eat vegetarian foodstuffs instead. Demand for each type of meat is therefore
likely to be price elastic, i.e. PED will be greater than 1.
2 The existence of close substitutes in consumer demand means several
products can satisfy a similar want. If the price of beef rises, consumers may
choose to buy lamb instead to satisfy their want for meat.
3 PED for Toyota cars = 41%/10% = 4.1. Demand is price elastic because cars
are a luxury item, are expensive so their cost will account for a significant
percentage of many people’s incomes, and Toyota cars have many close
substitutes, such as cars made by Ford, Hyundai, Peugeot and Volkswagen.
PED for a newspaper = 0.27%/50% = 0.0054. Demand is highly price inelastic.
Newspapers are a low-cost item and many consumers remain loyal to one or more
daily newspapers even when their relative prices change.

Activity 2.23 Stretching supply

1 PES for natural rubber = (100/1,000)/(20/80) = 0.4
PES for man-made rubber = (800/2,000)/(20/80) = 1.6
2 Natural rubber takes a long time to grow. Supply will therefore be price inelastic
in the short run. In contrast, the supply of man-made rubber is more responsive
to price because production of the synthetic material can be increased relatively
quickly by firms using their existing capital, labour and materials.

Activity 2.24 Not painting a pretty picture

1 The company only takes into account its own private costs, such as wages and
rents, and its private benefits, namely revenues from the sale of its paints.
2 From society’s point of view the firm should take into account the external
costs paint production could give rise to, including air and water pollution,
noise and visual intrusion, and the negative impact these could have on
people’s health. For example, the activity suggests increased health-care costs
will be $4 million a year.

10
© Brian Titley 2012: this may be reproduced for class use solely for the purchaser’s institute
 Unit 2 The allocation of resources: how the market works; market failure

3 a i; b i
4 a $1 million b The social costs of paint production are $11 million and exceed
its social benefits of $9 million. Paint production in this case is therefore an
uneconomic use of resources and not worthwhile for society.

Activity 2.25 Belt up!

1 Opportunity cost is the benefit of the next best alternative foregone.
2 Amiya has not included the external costs of her decision not to wear a seat
belt. This included the costs of the services of police and medics who attended
her accident, the cost of her treatment in hospital, and the loss of her
contribution to productivity and revenues at the bank she works for during
her time off recovering from her injuries.
3 An economist would not agree. This is because the driver is thinking only
of his or her own satisfaction, costs and benefits. Driving without a seatbelt
can affect others if there is an accident. There are many other potential costs
on others including the costs of police, health care and lost output. Car and
accident insurance premiums will also be higher for all drivers if there is a
greater risk of accidents and injuries occurring. Similarly, family members and
friends may suffer emotionally seeing a loved one injured or even worrying
that they may get injured in an accident. They may also lose income if they
have to give up work to care for their loved one following an accident. All of
these costs should be taken into account before reaching a decision.

Activity 2.26 Smoking

1 Private costs will include wages, purchase of tobacco and other materials,
insurance premiums, any loan repayments, rents, electricity and telephone
charges, etc.
2 The total revenue is calculated by multiplying the number of packets sold by
the price per packet.
3 They will have to breathe in his smoke. This could damage their health. The
smoke will also make their clothes and hair smell.
4 The government would have to pay for inspectors, police and the legal system.
5 a The opportunity cost is lower taxes or the benefit of other public
expenditures foregone, for example a new school, more police, higher
welfare payments or more farm subsidies.
b 
The cost will be met by taxpayers or the beneficiaries of other public
expenditures which are subsequently cut to pay for the increased cost of
health care.
6 a The volume of cigarettes consumed is likely to fall.
b 
Revenue may fall but this will depend on how responsive demand is to
price. Cigarette smoking for many people is habitual so a rise in price may
only produce a very small fall in demand. Overall revenues will rise but
some of that revenue has to be paid in tax to the government. After tax,
therefore, cigarette producers may still suffer a small fall in revenue.
c 
If consumers start buying fewer packets of cigarettes, producers may cut
their output and the size of their workforces. Some workers in cigarette
factories may lose their jobs.

11
© Brian Titley 2012: this may be reproduced for class use solely for the purchaser’s institute
 Unit 2 The allocation of resources: how the market works; market failure

Activity 2.27 Living on borrowed time

The article provides the following examples.
• Resource allocation: we are consuming non-renewable resources at an
increasing rate. We are not allocating enough resources to developing
alternative methods of production, to the conservation of natural resources
and environmental protection.
• Opportunity cost: increased consumption today means fewer resources will be
available to consume in the future.
• Social costs and benefits: deleting natural resources, irreversible damage to
the environment, pollution and climate change, and the impact these are
having on farm yields, are all examples of external costs of our production
and consumption decisions.
• Economic conflicts of interest: these exist between people who want to
conserve resources for future generations and those who want to use up more
resources to meet the growing needs of a expanding global population; and
between those countries and people that have more resources than others.
Actions consumers, firms and governments could take to conserve resources
and reduce the external costs of their individual production and consumption
decisions might include the following.
• They could reduce waste in production and consumption.
• They could recycle more waste or unwanted products.
• They might change their tastes and buying habits, for example, buy more
organic vegetables and less meat products.
• They might invest in the development and use of alternative production
methods and products, for example more renewable energy or electric vehicles.
• Governments could encourage activities that conserve resources through
the provision of subsidies. They could tax more heavily activities that waste
resources or harm the environment.
• Governments could pass laws that limit or outlaw certain activities, such as
dumping untreated waste.

Activity 2.28 Conserve or consume?

Many of your answers will depend on your own views and value judgements.
For example, some of you may attach more weight to using resources to eradicate
poverty than conserving resources for the future. All of these actions involve
trade-offs and because opinions will differ it will be difficult to prove who is right
and who is wrong unless it is possible to value and compare all the social costs and
benefits of each and every action. This will be difficult to do.

Activity 2.29 Where have all the polar bears gone?

(This is your own study.) You should investigate how climate change will affect
weather patterns and therefore the production of goods and services such as food
and drink products, and tourism. Will climate change also mean that producers
and consumers have to spend more on protecting their businesses and homes
from extreme weather conditions? Remember that government action can also
have costs and benefits that will affect different groups in society and also distort
behaviours. Your report should also explore these conflicts and trade-offs.

12
© Brian Titley 2012: this may be reproduced for class use solely for the purchaser’s institute