Drawing A Tree As An Exploratory Medium PDF
Drawing A Tree As An Exploratory Medium PDF
Drawing A Tree As An Exploratory Medium PDF
1. INTRODUCTION
Koch (101, 24) takes the growth of a healthy tree as the point of
departure for the tree drawing as an exploratory medium and
stresses especially the spatial symbolism the drawing expresses. Van
Lennep (291, 28), who has expanded on Koch's work, also views the
tree as a symbol of a person and, in particular, assumes that the
roots, the trunk and the crown, as inseparable parts, can be related
to the human figure. These parts can symbolize the following:
Easier than most other objects, for a child, a tree can acquire a
"face" in which case it then really is "humanized" by him.
2. IMPLEMENTATION
149
The emotional inhibition that might exist in the situation of drawing
the first tree, for the most part, is not lived experienced while
drawing the last two trees. Also, a stronger appeal is directed to the
child, via imagining and fantasizing, to loosen himself from the
intention to remain as faithful as possible to reality and not rely as
much on memory as with drawing an ordinary tree.
After he finishes the fantasy and dream trees, allow him to tell a
"little story" about them.
How long it takes the child to complete each drawing is also noted.
3.1 Orientation
150
In particular, attention is given to anything conspicuous. Often a
child will draw a face in the tree or a spider, a birds nest, a little
house, etc. In addition, attention is given to such accessories as
damage, the structure of the trunk, the type of tree, e.g., a weeping
willow.
3.2 Observation
3.3 The position of the drawing on the paper (see 291, 151;
101, 28)
Younger children usually draw objects that are on the ground on the
bottom of the paper while older children and adults mostly choose
151
the middle of the paper. A person always stands in the middle of his
world and therefore he also chooses the middle of the paper.
By only drawing on the left part of the paper, the child does not use
the space available. In everyday intercourse we often hear that
someone is "left of the government" and left is interpreted as
wrong. The drawing on the left of the paper also can be viewed as
placed on the wrong side.
Large trees on the left of the paper can indicate his strong feeling to
apply himself but not being able to do so in everyday relationships.
Thus, this really refers to passivity and there is mention of an
onlooker rather than an active participant.
A tree placed in the upper left on the paper also has no possibility of
becoming larger and in this sense it indications an unwillingness to
explore and a weak future perspective, especially on the basis of
feelings of inadequacy.
152
perseveration that is evidence of an inability to distance oneself to
an adequate gnostic-cognitive level.
3.3.2 Trees right on the paper (see 291, 176; 101, 30)
Right refers to a striving to close the other off. However, when the
trees are placed on the extreme right side, this might indicate that
there is no place allowed for another and that the child really will
not allow the other into his world.
Most children do not use the entire sheet of paper. Statistics show
that the dispersion regarding the height and breadth of drawn trees
are approximately between 5 and 9 inches and 4 and 7 inches,
respectively. Large trees, then, will be those that are bigger than 9 x
7 inches and small trees those less than 5 x 4 inches.
A little tree might indicate that the child is modest and shy and
would rather follow than take the lead. There is mention of a
feeling of inadequacy and the belief that others are better than he is.
He does not take the initiative easily and prefers rather to be told
what to do. There also is mention of an unwillingness to explore.
Also it can be that he tries to shirk his responsibilities by displaying
153
his own ineffectiveness and incompetence. However, the drawer of
a little tree also can feel himself wronged and this feeling can
manifest itself in aggressive or depressive ways.
In general, children who draw little trees can be viewed as quiet and
turned inward. This might indicate affective neglect and a search
for emotional security.
As a rule, the roots are not drawn but where they appear this
indicates a clear feeling of uncertainty and dependence and a
seeking of support. This strongly suggests the possibility of
defective affective guidance in the primary educative situation.
154
155
156
b)
157
158
159
160
161
162
163
164
165
166
167
168
169
170
171
172
3.5.4 The coherence of roots, trunk and crown
Van Lennep (291, 180) calls attention to the fact that if a child does
not take into account the coherence of the trunk and crown, usually
one or another problem is present. Unless there are conspicuous
motor problems noted that can influence the harmony, it can be
accepted that a child who ignores the general coherence has to
contend with problems in actualizing his psychic life.
A child who is unwilling to draw also will not complete his drawings.
3.5.5 Wounds
3.6 Accessories
4. SYNTHESIS
173
________________________________________
Particular contents of the tree drawings and possible
indications regarding the actualization of the psychic life
INTELLIGENCE
poor ability: lead trunk and branches after 13 years.
more practical: T-trunk; base of trunk wide; crown vine
formed.
good ability: three-dimensional.
underactualization:
general: shakily formed lines.
trunk: T-trunk; interrupted trunk lines; thick;
grows narrow; trunk open at bottom;
perseverations; stereotypic; break in trunk
and limbs.
crown: chaotic lines; centrifugal; foliage and
other "accessories"; slopes down.
174
general: blossoms.
trunk: lead trunk and branches after 13 years.
crown: leans to left; chaotic lines.
concrete-visual thinking:
general:
trunk: base wide (in puberty), T-trunk.
crown: spherical form.
abstract thinking:
general: three-dimensional.
trunk: open, pipe-form; straight and parallel
after 12 years.
crown: vine formed.
175
crown: flat; empty spaces.
wants to impress:
general: heavy lines; shaky.
trunk:
crown:
dependent on mother:
general:
trunk: base wide to left.
crown:
little persistence:
general:
trunk:
crown: fruit after 12 years.
quarrelsome, undisciplined:
general:
trunk:
crown: chaotic branches which cross.
shuns authority:
general:
trunk: base wide to right.
crown:
directed to orderliness:
general: sharp, precise lines.
trunk:
crown: vine formed.
ambivalences:
general:
trunk:
crown: branches cross.
tense:
general: bent (crooked), round, wavy lines (after
12 years).
trunk:
crown: spherical form with abundant branches
and foliage.
stubborn:
general: three-dimensional.
trunk: interruptions; irregular left or right;
straight and parallel (after 12 years), straight;
angled forms.
crown: centrifugal.
arrogant, impudent:
general: three-dimensional.
176
trunk:
crown: emphasis to right; centrifugal; branches
become thicker.
decisive:
general: wide lines; dark, black (after 12 years).
trunk: upper level crude (round and curved or
bowed lines).
crown: centripetal; branches in crown; chaotic
lines; centrifugal.
indecisive:
general: thin lines.
trunk: interruptions.
crown: falling under; open; pipe-formed
branches; interruptions in branches; branches
cross; landscape.
bodily experiences:
general: line roots (experiences difficulty
moving).
trunk: node; curved; thinning.
crown:
absent-minded:
general:
trunk: open below.
crown: interruptions in branches; centrifugal;
open; pipe-formed branches.
successful interpersonal relationships:
general:
trunk: upper level crude (curved, round or
bowed lines)
crown: wavy contour, branches end in ball of
clouds.
problems with interpersonal relationships:
general: tree low and to left.
trunk: curved lines.
crown: sawed-off branches.
polite, charming, considerate, diplomatic:
general:
trunk:
crown: branches end in ball of clouds; bowed
characteristics in crown.
extratensive (outgoing):
general:
trunk:
177
crown: falling under; emphasis to right;
centrifugal; branches become thicker; wavy
contour.
introvertive:
general:
trunk: nuances to left; thickening or thinning.
crown: leaning to left; bark covered branches.
shy, bashful:
general:
trunk:
crown: branches end in ball of clouds.
mistrusting, suspicious:
general: tree drawn left and below.
trunk: base broad to right; sloping ground line.
crown: palm tree branches.
quick-tempered:
general:
trunk:
crown: pointing up.
cautious:
general:
trunk:
crown: palm tree branches.
proud:
general: drawn left and above.
trunk: T-trunk; stands on an island or hill.
crown:
feels guilty:
general:
trunk: curved lines.
crown:
passive:
general: drawn left and above.
trunk: ground line above base.
crown: falling down.
active, restless, enthusiastic:
general: drawn right and above.
trunk:
crown: drawn as curls; points up.
aggressive:
general: hard, dark lines; changes position of
paper.
trunk: pointed lines.
178
crown: centrifugal; thorns.
possible traumas:
general:
trunk: narrows or thickens.
crown: branches narrow or thicken.
independent, resolute (firm):
general:
trunk:
crown: centripetal.
takes initiative, diligent:
general: three-dimensional
trunk:
crown: centrifugal.
self-conscious:
general:
trunk:
crown: emphasis to right.
self-satisfied:
general:
trunk:
crown: concentric.
reserved:
general: tree drawn in lower left.
trunk:
crown: flat; falling down.
eager to achieve:
general:
trunk:
crown: leans to the right.
reluctant:
general:
trunk: sloped ground line (after 12 years).
crown:
willing:
general:
trunk:
crown: leans to the right.
playful, teasing:
general: accessories (birds, etc.).
trunk:
crown:
_______________________________________
179
The following drawings were done by children restrained in
becoming adult.
180
181
182
183
Branches cut off: feelings of inadequacy; bodily experiences;
feelings of not being understood; feelings of guilt.
Coarse upper trunk: sensitive to other's opinions about himself
in interpersonal relationships.
Use of dark lines: feelings of aggression, anxiety and insecurity.
Centrifugal crown: extrovertive; aggressive.
"Axis" around which tree rotates: feelings of uncertainty,
inadequacy and a seeking of support.
Frontal view: orientation problems; obstinate; pigheaded;
impudent; presumptuous.
Pointed branches: critical; sensitive; aggressive.
Falling leaves: feelings of uncertainty and depression.
___________________________________
184
Drawings 5, 6 and 7 were completed by Gary, 14 years 6 months and
in 8th grade (IQ = 95, V = 74, NV = 124).
185
He is extremely unhappy at home. His parents divorced when he
was 5 years old. His father is remarried and he did not meet his
stepmother for several years and they do not get along with each
other. There are continuous heated family quarrels. Also, he lived
experiences his father as not paying any attention to him.
Gary wet his bed until he was 13 years old; he tells many lies and
repeatedly "steals" objects from his stepmother; his progress in
school is extremely poor and he has already fail one examination;
this year he has played hooky a number of times. He has an intense
desire to get away from his present situation, and already he has
explored many ways of getting away from the house. He continually
urges his father to send him to another school in another city.
During the previous term he avoided almost all tests.
186
187
188
___________________________________
189
Drawings 5, 6, 7
In his drawings Gary very clearly represents his desire to escape his
current educative situation. The ladders (see summer and fantasy
trees) suggest a search for an escape-route and the fact that he
withdraws into his own world of imagination and fantasy. The
intense threat that his home situation has for him also is clearly
represented in his house drawing (drawing 8) that, on the one
hand, represents a "flat building" with a lot of rooms represented,
and, on the other hand, a number of red bolts of lightning. The
bolts of lightning aimed at the house also represent very clearly his
aggression toward his primary educators (parents). The closed
190
gate at the end of the circular driveway also represents his lived-
experienced failures to escape his currently threatening situation.
191
There are conspicuous signs of “normative neglect” and the
establishment of an experiential world-in-opposition. She is
rebellious about the “pain: she believes is her calling and feels that
she really is “crucified”.
192
There are conspicuous signs of "normative neglect" and the
establishment of an experiential world-in-opposition. She is
rebellious about the "pain" which she believes is her calling and
feels that she really is "crucified".
There is an intense search for happiness and she then escapes into
an unreal world where she hopes that she can escape her feelings of
loneliness and uncertainty and find security. However, the faces are
all tense and strained and do not agree with her own comments
about happiness. "An immortal spirit. She's happy. I can see it in
her eyes. She tore loose some place and is drifting through space.
She tore loose before the beginning of time. She's good and evil--it
depends upon her mood. She may be thinking about evil that she is
going to commit."
193
Her seeking sexual warmth also is prominent in her intentional
going out to the world (see the main figure and the emphasis on the
mouths of the figures in the crown of the tree).
194