2008xmachining Compressed 161102023930
2008xmachining Compressed 161102023930
2008xmachining Compressed 161102023930
008x
Machining
MIT 2.008x
CNC Tools
Drill bit s et v ia Pixabay.
This work is in the public domain.
2.008x
Terraced CNC housing to hold 30% more battery v olume; s ingle PCB
2.03 pounds, 0.51 thick (max), 9hrs using wifi at 75% brightness
http://www.apple.com/macbook/design/
What is machining?
2.008x
Watch m echanism
https://pixabay.com/en/watch-
time-gears-clock-time-clock-
932693/
Brass fittings
Image from Pixabay. This work is in the public domain.
Machining is good at flat and curved surfaces,
threads; tolerances ~0.001 2.008x
Brass fittings
Image from Pixabay. This work is
in the public domain.
0.5 m m
2 mm
Agenda:
Machining 2.008x
Tool-material interaction
Cutting mechanics
Geometry and motion
Forces
Energy and power
Demonstration experiments!
Cutting forces
Tools, finish, and wear
Machining:
2. Basics of
tool-material
interaction
A lathe
2.008x
Cutoff
(with saw)
Boring
(internal turning)
MRR = D1 Nfd = Vc fd
Va
f = = 0.067 cm/rev
N
Do D f
d= = 0.05 cm
2
Example: cutting speed and MRR
2.008x
MRR = D1 Nfd = Vc fd
Va
f = = 0.067 cm/rev
N
Do D f
d= = 0.05 cm
2
MRR = Vc fd = 1----
0.3 cm 3 /min
correct:
6.3 cm3/min
Material removal = controlled failure
2.008x
Force
Motion (sliding, vibration)
Heating
Step I:
Motion &
Deformation
Step II:
Forces
Step III:
Energy &
Power
2.008x
Machining:
z
x
y
x
Oblique (3D)
Realistic, yet difficult to analyze
y
Orthogonal (2D)
Provides insight for understanding
2D model: angles and assumptions
2.008x
Tool
Assumptions:
The tool is perfectly sharp
Workpiece The tool moves at a
constant V and t0
A continuous chip is
Shear plane produced
What type of deformation do you see?
2.008x
tc
Chip
tc
Tool
t0
Workpiece
x bc + cd
= =
A ac
= cot ( ) + tan ( )
Analysis of shear strain
2.008x
- +
Shear plane
Tool
What do we learn?
= or =
2-4 (very large!) Workpiece
Here, digital image c orrelation (DIC) is used to map the s train field
NIST high s peed v ideos of tool/chip/material interaction: http://www.nist.gov/el/isd/sbm/hsds-machining-videos.cfm
2.008x
Machining:
4. Cutting forces
Why do we study
cutting forces? 2.008x
Chip
- +
FC
Workpiece
Demo #1: Measuring cutting force
2.008x
Measuring cutting force
2.008x
Cutting force data from
Chip
video 2.008x
- +
Tool
Workpiece
Here too, cutting force depends strongly on feed (f) but not on speed (Vc)
Gokkaya, The Effects of Machining Parameters on Cutting Forces,Surface Roughness, Built-Up Edge (BUE) and Built-Up Layer
(BUL) During Machining AA2014 (T4) Alloy, J ournal of Mechanical Engineering 56(2010)9, 584-593
Merchants relationship: relating the angles
(reference slides to be posted) 2.008x
[radians]
= +
4 2 2 = friction angle ( = tan )
is derived assuming that the shear angle () self-adjusts to
minimize the required cutting energy
= +
4 2 2
Key assumptions:
Slow, orthogonal cutting
Constant material properties
with temperature
Chart adapted from: Metal Cutting Theory and Practice, Simple sliding friction
Stephenson and Agapiou
No strain hardening
2.008x
Machining:
Machining:
max
Crater
Crater wear wear
Flank wear
Flank
wear
Crater Wear W
Thermal
on the Rake t
Cracking
Face
Wear on Deposition
the Flank causing a
Face Built Up
Edge
Depth of cut
Images from Figure 23.2 Fundamentals of Modern Manufacturing (4th Edition) by Groover. (c) Wiley (2010).
Wear schematics from: http://www.sandvik.coromant.com/en-us/knowledge/milling/troubleshooting/tool_wear
Chips from demo: carbide tool, 385 RPM
Examine both sides 2.008x
Crater
wear
Flank
wear
Chip types (selected)
2.008x
Continuous chip (narrow primary shear zone)
Ductile materials @ high speed
Entanglement bad (use chip breakers)
Discontinuous
Continuous with BUE
Continuous chip
Kalpalkian and Schmid, Manufacturing Engineering and Technology.
What determines surface roughness of
machined parts? 2.008x
Surface
roughness 2.008x
Figure 7.44 from "Product Design for Manufacture and Assembly (2nd Edition)" by
Marinescu, Boothroyd. Marcel Dekker Publishing (2002)
2.008x
Machining:
Step I:
Motion &
Deformation
Step II:
Forces
Step III:
Energy &
Power
A simple estimate of cutting force
2.008x
FC
Material UTS* (MPa)
Wax 0.86
Workpiece
Aluminum 110
Aluminum 6061-T6 310
Steel (high strength alloy) 760
ASTM A-514
Titanium alloys 900
*UTS = Ultimate Tensile Strength
Shear strength ~0.5*UTS
What other forces are present?
2.008x
Thrust: Ft
Ff
Cutting: Fc
Fs N Friction: Ff ( = Ff/N)
Tool normal: N
Fn Shear: Fs
R Ft
Chip Normal: Fn
Fc
Estimating the cutting power
2.008x
Power input = Power out + Power dissipated
Power input:
Machine: Pc = Fc * V
Plastically Fc
Power dissipation: Deformed Chip
Shear: Ps = Fs * Vs
Friction: Pf = Ff * Vc - +
Not deformed Vc
NOTE
Vc = velocity of chip
V = cutting velocity
Fc
(denoted VC earlier) Fs
Vs V
Contributions to cutting energy Plastically
Deformed Chip
Fc
*Kalpakjian
neglects Units =
Power/(volume/time)
[W*s/mm3]
Lets estimate the cutting power and force
2.008x
A SS rod is initially 2.0 cm diameter, and
becomes 1.9 cm in a single cut (full rotation).
The spindle rotates at N=400 rpm, and the tool
is traveling at an axial speed of 20 cm/min.
The specific cutting energy is 4.0 W-s/mm3.
p
d
Kalpakjian and Schmid, Manufacturing Engineering and Technology C
Lets estimate the cutting power and force
2.008x
A SS rod is initially 2.0 cm diameter, and
becomes 1.9 cm in a single cut (full rotation).
The spindle rotates at N=400 rpm, and the tool
is traveling at an axial speed of 20 cm/min.
The specific cutting energy is 4.0 W-s/mm3.
P = 0.6 kW
with efficiency = 0.7
p
d
Kalpakjian and Schmid, Manufacturing Engineering and Technology C
Lets estimate the cutting power and force
2.008x
A SS rod is initially 2.0 cm diameter, and
becomes 1.9 cm in a single cut (full rotation).
The spindle rotates at N=400 rpm, and the tool
is traveling at an axial speed of 20 cm/min.
The specific cutting energy is 4.0 W-s/mm3.
p
d
Kalpakjian and Schmid, Manufacturing Engineering and Technology C
Material-dependent cutting energies
2.008x
Machining:
8. Milling
How are milling and turning different?
2.008x
Fly$cutter$ Face$mill
(single$point$for$making$
smooth$surfaces)
End$mill
iPhone 6 teardown
2.008x
Logic board
Front-facing
camera
Housing
Battery
Type
of
joint Number
Camera
Bolted 44
Adhesive 5
Screen
(flipped) ClipiPhone 6 chassis assembly
8
Faceplate Threaded inserts 46
Counted from teardown s equence
Straight
tool path T-slot
endmill
Press-fit
threaded
insert
Curved
tool path
Plastic insert
2.008x
Feature sizes
2.008x
0.5 mm
0.5 mm
6 mm
2 mm
Tool paths
2.008x
Begin with offset elements Select reference line and mill along
of the contour to generate parallel lines
cutting paths
Zig milling: Feed along spindle
Step inwards or outwards direction
for subsequent passes
Zig-zag: Both directions (includes
significantly fewer tool retractions)
Diagrams from M. Held, O n the Computational G eometry of Pocket Machining; Lecture Notes in Computer Science; Springer Berlin Heidelberg: Berlin,
Heidelberg, 1991; Vol. 500.
Optimization for
cost or time? 2.008x
Cost of machining =
Machine use ($/time)
Tool cost
Taylors equation
V*(Tool_life)n = Constant
Tool change cost ($/time)
Nonproductive cost ($ for
load/unload operations
etc)
3-axis 5-axis
Machining:
9. Design guidelines
for Machining
2.008x
Design for
Manufacturing (DFM):
Dont Difficult to
fixture
From Otto and Wood, Product Design: Techniques in Reverse Engineering and New Product Development
DFM: whats wrong with this part?
2.008x
also
Minimize the number of tool changes, while considering overall
machining time (e.g., rough removal versus fine finishing).
Know the limits of tooling available (e.g. minimum size, maximum depth)!
Consider fixturing (how you will hold the part, and reference it if re-
fixtured)
2.008x
Machining:
10. Conclusion
How is machining
advancing now? 2.008x
% to
Heat generated
tool
50% % to
chip
0
Excerpt from: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=8Lh600hVyt8 Low High
Cutting speed
Figure adopted from 20.31, Degarmo, Materials and Processes in Manufacturing
Conclusion: performance of machining
2.008x
Machining
Rate Low-Medium
Quality Good!
Photo of CNC Mill by Roland Josch on Pixabay. This work is in the public domain.
Photo of Machine Shop in DC Printing Office by National Photo Company from U.S. Library of
Congress. This work is in the public domain.
Photo of CNC Machine Shop by Kim Becker v ia Flickr (CC BY) 2.0
Photo of Drill Bit Set by Michael Schwarzenberger on Pixabay. This work is in the public domain.
Machining Processes: Figure 1.5e "Manufacturing Engineering & Technology (6th Edition)" by
Kalpakjian, Schmid. Upper Saddle River; Pearson Publishing (2010).
Photo of Mechanical Watch Mechanism by User: tookapic on Pixabay. This work is in the public
domain.
Photo of Brass Fittings by Ingbert Merz on Pixabay. This work is in the public domain.
Machined Part: Figure IV.3 from "Manufacturing Engineering & Technology (7th Edition)" by
Kalpakjian, Schmid. Upper Saddle River; Pearson Publishing (2014).
References
2.008x
2 Basics of Tool-Material-Interaction
Lathe Picture: Figure 23.2 from "Manufacturing Engineering & Technology (7th Edition)" by Kalpakjian,
Schmid. Upper Saddle River; Pearson Publishing (2014).
Lathe Cutting Operations: Figure 23.1 from "Manufacturing Engineering & Technology (6th Edition)"
by Kalpakjian, Schmid. Upper Saddle River; Pearson Publishing (2009).
Turning Schematic: Figure 21.2 from "Manufacturing Engineering & Technology (7th Edition)" by Kalpakjian,
Schmid. Upper Saddle River; Pearson Publishing (2014).
Video of Titanium machining example, by NIST of the U.S. Dept. of Commerce 2009.
Photo of CNC Mill by Roland Josch on Pixabay. This work is in the public domain.
References
2.008x
4 Cutting Forces
Graphs by Gokkaya, The Effects of Machining Parameters on Cutting Forces, Surface Roughness, Built-Up
Edge (BUE) and Built-Up Layer (BUL) During Machining AA2014 (T4) Alloy, Journal of Mechanical
Engineering 56(2010)9, 584-593
Shear Angle Chart adapted from: Metal Cutting Theory and Practice, Stephenson and Agapiou
Lathe Cutting Tool: Figure 21.10 from "Manufacturing Engineering & Technology (7th Edition)" by Kalpakjian,
Schmid. Upper Saddle River; Pearson Publishing (2014).
Tooling with Insert: Figure 22.3 from "Manufacturing Engineering & Technology (7th Edition)" by Kalpakjian,
Schmid. Upper Saddle River; Pearson Publishing (2014).
Temperature Distribution: Figure 21.12 from "Manufacturing Engineering & Technology (7th Edition)" by
Kalpakjian, Schmid. Upper Saddle River; Pearson Publishing (2014).
Hardness Chart: Figure 22.1 from "Manufacturing Engineering & Technology (7th Edition)" by Kalpakjian,
Schmid. Upper Saddle River; Pearson Publishing (2014).
References
2.008x
Crater Wear: Figure 23.2 from "Fundamentals of Modern Manufacturing (4th Edition)" by Groover. John
Wiley & Sons Inc. (2010)
Chip Types: Figures 21.5 from "Manufacturing Engineering & Technology (7th Edition)" by Kalpakjian,
Schmid. Upper Saddle River; Pearson Publishing (2014).
Machining Time: Figure 22.6 from "Manufacturing Engineering & Technology (7th Edition)" by Kalpakjian,
Schmid. Upper Saddle River; Pearson Publishing (2014).
Coating Cross-Section: Figure 22.8 from "Manufacturing Engineering & Technology (7th Edition)" by
Kalpakjian, Schmid. Upper Saddle River; Pearson Publishing (2014).
Insert: Figure 21-8 from "DeGarmo's Materials & Processes in Manufacturing (10th Edition)" by Black and
Kohser, John Wiley & Sons, Inc. (2008).
Turning Schematic: Figure 21.2 from "Manufacturing Engineering & Technology (7th Edition)" by Kalpakjian,
Schmid. Upper Saddle River; Pearson Publishing (2014).
Cutting Energies: Table 21.2 from "Manufacturing Engineering & Technology (7th Edition)" by Kalpakjian,
Schmid. Upper Saddle River; Pearson Publishing (2014).
References
2.008x
8 Milling
Parts Produced by Milling: Figure 24.1 from "Manufacturing Engineering & Technology (7th Edition)" by
Kalpakjian, Schmid. Upper Saddle River; Pearson Publishing (2014).
Milling Operation Parameters: Figure 24.3 b) from "Manufacturing Engineering & Technology (7th Edition)"
by Kalpakjian, Schmid. Upper Saddle River; Pearson Publishing (2014).
Conventional vs. Climbing: Figure 24.3 a) from "Manufacturing Engineering & Technology (7th Edition)" by
Kalpakjian, Schmid. Upper Saddle River; Pearson Publishing (2014).
Milling Operations: Figure 24.2 from "Manufacturing Engineering & Technology (7th Edition)" by Kalpakjian,
Schmid. Upper Saddle River; Pearson Publishing (2014).
Image of T-Slot End Mill Cutter 2003 Bewise Inc. All Rights Reserved
Pocket Machining: Figure 1.3 from "On the Conceptual Geometry of Pocket Machining" by Held Springer-
Verlag (1991).
References
2.008x
Toolpaths: Figure 1.4 from "On the Conceptual Geometry of Pocket Machining" by Held Springer-Verlag
(1991).
Cost Optimization: Figure 25.17 from "Manufacturing Engineering & Technology (7th Edition)" by Kalpakjian,
Schmid. Upper Saddle River; Pearson Publishing (2014).
Diagrams of Advantages of 5-Axis Milling Machines AWEA Mechatronic Co. LTD. 2016. All Rights
Reserved.
DFM Practice Diagram: Figure 14.10 from "Product Design: Techniques in Reverse Engineering and New
Product Development" by Otto and Wood, Upper Saddle River; Pearson Publishing (2001)
10 Conclusion
Heat vs. Speed Diagram: Figure 20-31 from "DeGarmo's Materials & Processes in Manufacturing (10th
Edition)" by Black and Kohser, John Wiley & Sons, Inc. (2008).