The 15 Best Quarterbacks In The NFL This Season

denver broncos peyton manning
Doug Pensinger/Getty Images

The NFL is at the beginning of a changing of the guard at the quarterback position.

Advertisement

Manning and Brady are aging, and a crop of young guys led by Luck and Griffin are hoping to fill their shoes.

But the 2012 NFL season proved that the old guys are still the best.

By averaging three very different statistical metrics — traditional QB rating, ESPN's Total QBR, and Football Outsiders' DYAR — we came up with our own ranking of the best 15 QBs in the league in 2012.

Advertisement

15. Cam Newton, Carolina Panthers

cam newton
AP

Average ranking: 15.00

QB rating: #15

Total QBR: #16

DYAR: #14

Advertisement

14. Matthew Stafford, Detroit Lions

detroit lions stafford
AP

Average ranking: 14.66

QB rating: #22

Total QBR: #15

DYAR: #7

Advertisement

13. Matt Schaub, Houston Texans

Matt Schaub
AP

Average ranking: 11.66

QB rating: #9

Total QBR: #14

DYAR: #12

Advertisement

12. Eli Manning, New York Giants

eli manning super bowl stats new york giants
Screenshot via NBC

Average ranking: 11.00

QB rating: #14

Total QBR: #10

DYAR: #9

Advertisement

11. Ben Roethlisberger, Pittsburgh Steelers

Ben Roethlisberger
Wikimedia Commons

Average ranking: 9.66

QB rating: #7

Total QBR: #12

DYAR: #10

Advertisement

10. Tony Romo, Dallas Cowboys

Cowboys quarterback Tony Romo
AP

Average ranking: 9.66

QB rating: #10

Total QBR: #13

DYAR: #6

Advertisement

9. Alex Smith, San Francisco 49ers

Alex Smith
Wikipedia Commons

Average ranking: 8.33

QB rating: #3

Total QBR: #7

DYAR: #15

Advertisement

8. Colin Kaepernick*, San Francisco 49ers

colin kaepernick san francisco 49ers
Thearon W. Henderson/Getty Images

Average ranking: 7.66

QB rating: #7

Total QBR: #3

DYAR: #13

*Small sample size

Advertisement

7. Russell Wilson, Seattle Seahawks

russell wilson seattle seahawks quarterback in the preseason
Justin Edmonds/Getty Images

Average ranking: 6.66

QB rating: #4

Total QBR: #8

DYAR: #8

Advertisement

6. Drew Brees, New Orleans Saints

drew brees new orleans saints quarterback
Streeter Lecka/Getty Images

Average ranking: 6.66

QB rating: #8

Total QBR: #9

DYAR: #3

Advertisement

5. Robert Griffin III, Washington Redskins

robert griffin iii washington redskins qb against new orleans saints 2012
Ronald Martinez/Getty Images

Average ranking: 6.66

QB rating: #3

Total QBR: #6

DYAR: #11

Advertisement

4. Matt Ryan, Atlanta Falcons

matt ryan atlanta falcons covered in fire
Scott Cunningham/Getty Images

Average ranking: 4.66

QB rating: #5

Total QBR: #4

DYAR: #5

Advertisement

3. Aaron Rodgers, Green Bay Packers

green bay packers aaron rodgers
Jeff Gross/Getty Images

Average ranking: 3.33

QB rating: #1

Total QBR: #5

DYAR: #4

Advertisement

2. Tom Brady, New England Patriots

tom brady new england patriots quarterback
Nick Laham/Getty Images

Average ranking: 3.00

QB rating: #6

Total QBR: #2

DYAR: #1

Advertisement

1. Peyton Manning, Denver Broncos

peyton manning of the denver broncos nfl
Jim Rogash/Getty Images

Average ranking: 1.66

QB rating: #2

Total QBR: #1

DYAR: #2

Advertisement

The rest of the playoff QBs

Andrew Luck
Getty Images/Gregory Shamus

17. Joe Flacco

18. Andy Dalton

20. Andrew Luck

21. Christian Ponder

Advertisement

Read next

NFL Sports
Advertisement
Close icon Two crossed lines that form an 'X'. It indicates a way to close an interaction, or dismiss a notification.