Zooey Deschanel Dresses as Angie K. From RHOSLC for Halloween: 'If You Know Who I Am We Can Be Friends'

Zooey Deschanel is playing an unexpected character for Halloween!

This year, the New Girl alum is dressed up as someone only Bravo superfans would recognize. In an Instagram post, Deschanel was pictured in costume as The Real Housewives of Salt Lake City’s Angie Katsanevas, wearing the reality star's outfit from when she went butter churning in season 4.

“If you know who I am we can be friends…” Deschanel, 44, captioned the series of photos, which featured a friend dressed as Lisa Barlow from the same episode.

“OMG!!! Little Bo Greek is SHAKING in her Bonnet right now💕🪿💕🐑💕,” Katsanevas replied, going on to poke fun at the accusation from that season that she was in the Greek mafia. “Zooey I’m honored!!! You’re an icon🩷The Greek Mafia loves you🇬🇷🐑💣”

Complete with a pink bonnet, Deschanel nailed the look with a fur coat, long pink skirt and sunglasses. She also posed with a jar of milk, which the women shook until it turned to butter in the memorable Pioneer-Day-themed scene. 

People in the comments were just as big of fans of the costume as Katsanevas was, with one joking, “Greek mafia approved” and another writing, “HAHAHAHHA THIS IS EVERYTHING.”

January Jones even reacted, commenting: “👌🏻👌🏻”

The 500 Days of Summer star also shared a photo with fiancé Jonathan Scott, who was dressed as Hugh Jackman’s Wolverine in Deadpool & Wolverine. 

In 2023, Deschanel was Little Red Riding Hood and Scott was an elf. The pair went all out, with Scott even wearing a wig. 

“Didn’t you know? Red Riding Hood’s got moves,” she captioned an Instagram carousel, which included a video of her dancing on a light-up floor. 

In his own post, her Property Brothers beau quipped, “I know what you’re thinking…a little tall for an elf right? 😅 #Link #LegendofZelda.”

He also acknowledged in another post that the two weren’t exactly in couple’s costumes. “I know what you’re thinking… Which Red Riding Hood and Zelda crossover is this?” Scott wrote. 

Never miss a story — sign up for PEOPLE's free daily newsletter to stay up-to-date on the best of what PEOPLE has to offer, from juicy celebrity news to compelling human interest stories.

A third Instagram upload was a joint post from his twin brother Drew Scott, which saw the two siblings with their significant others, as well as Drew, 45, and wife Linda Phan’s 1-year-old son Parker. 

“Just trying out some new looks…they may stick 😆 Happy Halloween 👻,” the group photo’s caption read.