Taylor Swift Supported by Friends Blake Lively and Ryan Reynolds at Her Eras Tour for Second Night in a Row

They know the show "All Too Well" — and they came back for more!

Blake Lively and Ryan Reynolds were spotted in the crowd at Taylor Swift's second Eras Tour show at New Orleans' Caesars Superdome on Saturday, Oct. 26, just one day after catching her first performance of the weekend at the same venue.

In footage shared on TikTok by a concert-goer, which later circulated on X (formerly Twitter), the couple could be seen in matching black attire during the concert, as Lively, 37, wore a wrist full of friendship bracelets and Reynolds, 48, stood closely behind her with his hands on her hips.

"This is adorable," the original TikTok caption read.

According to NOLA.com, which cited a photo shared on X, the pair returned for another night of pop music while joined by at least one of their daughters. The Deadpool actor reportedly also handed out The Tortured Poets Department guitar picks in exchange for friendship bracelets.

The latest outing for Lively and Reynolds took place just one day after their first New Orleans Eras Tour experience, when they were captured watching the show from what appeared to be a VIP area of the venue.

Footage from the show shared on multiple social media platforms showed Reynolds dancing to the music and Lively chatting with another attendee. The pair were also captured cuddling up at a few different points during the night.

Lively and Reynolds similarly opted for matching outfits during the first night, with Reynolds rocking a short-sleeved white shirt and dark pants, while Lively wore a fitted white vest and white shirt over the top.

Never miss a story — sign up for PEOPLE's free daily newsletter to stay up-to-date on the best of what PEOPLE has to offer​​, from celebrity news to compelling human interest stories.

Swift's friendship with the couple dates back to 2015. Since then, they've been spotted out on double date nights with Swift's boyfriend Travis Kelce, at Kansas City Chiefs games and — of course — at the Eras Tour.

The duo attended a show in Philadelphia back in May, with some of their four children. Lively and Reynolds are parents to daughters James, 9, Inez, 8, and Betty, 5, plus son Olin, 1.

Swift will be returning to the Superdome for one more night on Sunday, Oct. 27, before making her way to Indianapolis, Toronto and Vancouver for what is set to mark the end of her final leg of Eras Tour gigs.

Her latest performance in New Orleans didn't just include familiar faces in the crowd, as Swift also surprised her audience with special guest Sabrina Carpenter during her surprise songs portion of the show.

In a clip shared on X, Swift said she was putting Carpenter "on speakerphone," before telling her former supporting act that she sang part of her song "Espresso" and the crowd "sang every single word so loud."

"Why aren't you here with us?" Swift questioned her friend, before asking her to "come down to the stadium real quick."

The pair then sang a mashup of Carpenter's songs "Espresso" and "Please, Please, Please," with Swift's track, "Is It Over Now?"

The fellow pop star previously warmed up the crowd for Swift during opening Eras Tour slots in Mexico, Argentina, Brazil, Japan, Australia and Singapore.