Walter Boys' Nikki Rodriguez and Noah LaLonde Walk People's Choice Carpet amid Show's 'Roller Coaster' Success

From life with the Walter boys to life on the red carpet!

My Life with the Walter Boys costars Nikki Rodriguez and Noah LaLonde attended the 2024 People's Choice Awards together on Sunday in Los Angeles. Rodriquez, 21, opted for a strapless black dress, while LaLonde, 25, went with a pop of color in a lavender suit.

Laverne Cox asked the pair ahead of the show at E! Live from the Red Carpet how they celebrated the success of their Netflix series.

“It was just shock and disbelief,” Rodriguez said. “I still can’t believe it. So, I probably still haven’t celebrated. That time will come.”

LaLonde called the experience “mind-blowing.”

“I mean, it’s just this crazy roller coaster and we’re just holding on,” he said.

Netflix’s My Life with the Walter Boys, based on Ali Novak’s 2014 book of the same name, follows Rodriguez’s character, protagonist Jackie, as she navigates life on a farm in rural Colorado surrounded by 10 kids — nine of whom are boys. Jackie becomes particularly friendly with two of the Walter boys, Cole (LaLonde) and Alex (Ashby Gentry). A love triangle ensues and causes rifts among brothers, which impacts Jackie’s ability to start a new life on the ranch.

When asked by Cox, 51, which boy she thinks is a better fit for Jackie, Rodriguez said, “I truly think both are so good for different reasons. I know that’s the worst answer!”

LaLonde took a stand, though. “Shoutout Ashby Gentry! I love you brother,” he said. “It’s always him.”

Regardless of their opinions on who Jackie should ends up with, Rodriguez and LaLonde agreed on their appreciation for the Walter Boys fans.

“I just want to say thank you so much for watching,” Rodriguez said to the viewers on the carpet. “It really, really means the world.”

LaLonde echoed, “It means the world to us — and let’s stay on the ride for season 2.”

Netflix renewed My Life with the Walter Boys in December, less than two weeks after the first season premiered and reached No. 1 on the streamer’s Global English Top 10 TV list.

Rodriguez and LaLonde's People’s Choice Awards appearance comes the month after they stepped out together at the 2024 Golden Globes in coordinated black and white outfits. The actress wore two looks throughout the night, kicking things off with an off-the-shoulder, body-hugging black Oscar de la Renta pencil dress. She finished the look with a pair of sparkly Louboutin heels, two silver rings and a pair of stud earrings.

Later in the night, at the Billboard Golden Globes after party at the Beverly Hilton Hotel, Rodriguez rocked a short black-and-white Carolina Herrera dress that featured thin and a skirt with tiers of white tulle flowers.

LaLonde stuck with one outfit for the evening, a classic black suit with a double-breasted jacket, a crisp white button-down shirt and a black bowtie.

Never miss a story — sign up for PEOPLE's free daily newsletter to stay up-to-date on the best of what PEOPLE has to offer, from juicy celebrity news to compelling human interest stories.

The 2024 People's Choice Awards are airing Sunday at 8 p.m. ET on NBC, E! and Peacock.