Morphological Adaptation of P. Canaliculata Shell To The Different Ecosystems in Lanao Del Norte, Mindanao, Philippines
Morphological Adaptation of P. Canaliculata Shell To The Different Ecosystems in Lanao Del Norte, Mindanao, Philippines
Morphological Adaptation of P. Canaliculata Shell To The Different Ecosystems in Lanao Del Norte, Mindanao, Philippines
Abstract
Different physiological, morphological, and behavioral adaptations of Pomacea canaliculata aided them in their
survival to different adverse environmental conditions. Furthermore, the said adaptations can be very vital in the
control and management strategies that can be employed in the areas where their population posed a threat to
food security. The study employed an explorative-investigative study design for the gathering of data. Eight
hundred seventy-three Golden Apple Snails from different freshwater ecosystems, namely stream, irrigational
canal, and rice field were collected, cleaned, and examined. To elucidate the different adaptations of the GAS to
the various ecosystems, their shell characteristics were observed, recorded, and examined. Consequently, this
study found out that those shells from snails sampled in streams had bigger length, width, width of the aperture,
a higher number of bands, and whorls when compared to those shells from irrigational canals and rice fields.
Moreover, there was a negative correlation between pH and dissolved oxygen to the height, width, and width of
the aperture. There was also a significant correlation between the temperature and width, weight, and the
number of bands. It was concluded that to control and manage the population of the GAS the area should have
less palatable food sources and less anthropogenic activities so that environmental parameters like high pH,
lower temperature, and higher dissolved oxygen can be achieved.
* Corresponding Author: V. Logronio Ferlyn [email protected]
The snails were boiled and cleaned and the meat was d) Width of aperture
removed by pin. Sex identification was made through The width of the aperture was also measured using a
shell shape (Mahilum & Demayo, 2014) and actual vernier caliper (Fig. 2.a).
body parts examination. The presence of the penial
complex would signify male and the absence thereof e) Shell chirality
would be of female. Shell chirality was the orientation of the aperture
opening. To determine the chirality, the shells were
held with the spire pointing upwards and the aperture
was facing the observer. Dextral shells are determined
if the opening was facing right and sinistral if the
opening was facing left.
f) Shell shape
Shell shape according to Gould (1966) as mentioned
by the paper of Kemp, et al. (1984) was governed by a
genetically allometric relationship. In this study, the
snail shape was determined by the proportion of the
height and the width. Oblong was determined if the
Fig. 1. Map of the Philippines. A) Rice field at Brgy. height is much bigger than the width, globose – if the
Tenazas, Lala, Lanao del Norte; B) Dam and Stream at height and the width of the shell are proportional and
Brgy. El Salvador, Lala, Lanao del Norte; and C) Irrigation depressed if the width is much bigger than the height.
Sample Preservation
Representative samples of the species of freshwater
gastropods were preserved in 70% ethyl alcohol and
were kept for future referencing purposes. Shells were
then air-dried and were subjected to different
measurements.
b) Shell width
The width of the shell was done by measuring the
right angles to the central axis. Vernier caliper was
used in the measurement (Fig. 2.a).
Stream/dam
male 3.98 3.32 2.92 1.79 11.82 4.77
female 4.25 3.76 3.71 1.87 15.5 5
Irrigational canal
male 2.77 2.29 1.39 1.23 12.5 4.4
female 2.87 2.42 1.47 1.28 9.34 4.31
Shell length, width, and weight differences in shell’s length, width, and weight in the
The snails found in the stream and dam were observed different environments with a p-value less than 0.05.
to be significantly higher in terms of the shell length, Furthermore, it can be observed using Post-hoc analysis
width, and weight when compared to the snails sampled that streams and dams are significantly different from
from the irrigational area and ricefield regardless of the rice fields and irrigation canals in terms of shell’s length,
location. Analysis of variance showed significant width, and weight (Fig. 3).
Fig. 4. Difference of width of the aperture as Fig. 5. Difference of the number of bands as observed
observed in the samples from the rice field, streams in the samples from the rice field, streams and dams,
and dams, and irrigation canal. and irrigation canal.
that all three sampling sites shared the same Conclusion and recommendations
temperature level. In an article by Sokolova, et al. As the environment played a vital part in the survival
(2000) they cited that the color of the shells can be of the snails, the physiological, morphological, and
related to environmental gradients like climate, behavioral adaptations of Pomacea canaliculata to
insolation, wave exposure, and salinity. In this case, various environmental conditions ensure their
all of the sites where the snails were sampled had a survival in an environment. The plasticity nature of
common climatic pattern, thus, this is a common the species also helped them adapt easily to the
factor that influenced its shell color. environment where they thrive. As is observed in this
study, there were variations in the shells based on the
When the different shell characteristics of Pomacea observed characteristics. However, there was
canaliculata were subjected to correlation analysis similarity in the shells that were relevant in Site A and
with the observed environmental parameters in the C and this can be pointed to the closely related land
area, it was found out that these conditions also use in the areas. Moreover, the proximity between
played a significant factor in terms of its adaptation. Site A and B did not influence the similarity of the
It was observed that the higher pH could limit the shells, hence, it was concluded that since they had
length, width, and width of the aperture. This can be different use and functions, the adaptations of the
related to the studies of Samsi and Karim (2019), snails was different.
Glass and Darby (2009), Marshall, et al. (2008) and
Orr, et al. (2005) where the pH influenced the The noted difference can be because of the different
conditions of the shells of the GAS and other anthropogenic activities, pollutants, and other
calcifying organisms. Accordingly, the shells of those environmental factors in the sites. The pH,
snails in treatment with high pH produced small shell temperature, and dissolved oxygen also played
length and manifested signs of shell erosion. important roles in the adaptation of the snails. The
pH and dissolved oxygen of the area had a negative
Consequently, the higher level of dissolved oxygen correlation to the length, width, and width of the
aperture of the snails. On the other hand, the
was also negatively correlated to the length, width,
temperature had a positive correlation to the width,
and width of the aperture of the shell. The result was
weight, and number of bands.
contrary to the result of Gupta, et al. (2017) that there
was a linear growth rate in both the tank with
Given this premise, to manage and control the
elevated and lowered DO use in their study.
population of the golden apple snails and minimize
Moreover, this study also observed the positive
the damages they caused to agriculture, it is
correlation of temperature to the width, weight, and
recommended that the areas should cater
number of bands of P. canaliculata.
environment with less palatable food sources and
should have adverse environmental conditions like
This finding is related to the findings of Estebenet, et
higher pH, lower temperature, and higher dissolved
al., 2002 that P. canaliculata were influenced in all
oxygen. Further studies should also be conducted to
aspects by temperature. Snails’ growth rate was
test and check for the similarity of this study to
highest in elevated temperature (Kalinda, et al., 2017;
different areas.
Tamburi, et al., 2018; Memon, et al., 2011) and could
explain the increase in width, weight, and the number Acknowledgments
of bands. Furthermore, the result of this study is The researchers would like to thank the Department
contrary to the findings of Galan, et al. (2015) that of Science and Technology Accelerated Science and
temperature together with pH and DO did not Technology Human Resource Development Program
manifest correlation to the characteristics of the shell (DOST ASTHRDP) for the scholarship grant that
being tested in their study. enabled the researchers to produce the paper.
Cazzaniga N. 1987. Pomacea canaliculate (Lamrk, Gould S. 1966. J Paleontol 42, 81-98
19801) en Catamarca (Argentina) y un comentario sobre
Ampullariacatamarcensis Sowerby, 1874 (Gastopoda, Gupta A, Pereira C, Soukup J. 2017. Effects of
AMpullaridae). Iheringia, Serie Zoologia 66, 43-68. thermal stress on growth and mortality of juvenile
Crepidula fornicate in New England. Marine
Chukwuka CO, Ejere VC, Asogwa CN, Physiology and Climate Change 2017, 1-9.
Nnamonu EI, Okeke OC, Odii EI, Ugwu GC,
Okanya LC, Levi CA. 2014. Eco-physiological Kalinda C, Chimbari M, Mukaratirwa S. 2017.
adaptation of the land snail Achatina achatina Effect of temperature on the Bulinus globosus –
(Gastropoda: Pulmonata) in tropical agro-ecosystem. Schistosoma haematobium system. Infectious
The Journal of Basic and Applied Zoology 67, 48-57 Diseases of Poverty 2017(6), 57.
Comfort A. 1950. The Pigmentation of Molluscan Kemp P, Bertness M. 1984. Snail shape and growth
Shells. 285-300. rates: Evidence for plastic shell allometry in Littorina
littorea. Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci, USA. 81, 811-813
Ermentrout B, Campbell J, Oster G. 1986. A
Model for Shell Patterns Based on Neural Activity. Madjos G, Anies O. 2016. Morphometrics
The Velger 28(4), 369-388. approaches to studying phenotypic plasticity in
Pomacea canaliculate (Golden apple snail).
Estebenet A, Martin P. 2002. Pomacea canaliculata International Journal of Advanced and Applied
(Gastropoda: Ampullariidae): Life-history and Traits Sciences 3(4), 50-56.
and their Plasticity. Biocell 26(1), 83-89.
Madjos G, Demetillo M, Baguio M, Torres M. 2015.
Phenotypic variation in populations of Pomacea
Estebenet A, Martin P. 2003. Shell Interpopulation
canaliculata (Golden Apple Snail): a case of agroecotypes?.
Variation and its Origin in Pomacea canaliculata
Advances in Environmental Sciences – International
(Gastropoda: Ampullariidae) from Southern Pampas,
Journal of the Bioflux Society 7(3), 432-441.
Argentina. J. Moll. Stud 60, 301-310.
Mahilum J, Demayo C. 2014. Sexual Dimorphism
Estebenet A, Martin P, Burela S. 2006. on Shell Shape of Pomacea canaliculata Lamark
Conchological variation in Pomacea canaliculate and Thriving in Lakes using the Geometric Morphometric
other South American Ampullariidae (Caenogastropoda, Approach. International Journal of Bioscience,
Architaenioglossa). Biocell 30(2), 329-335. Biochemistry, and Bioinformatics 4(4), 284-289
Fink P, Von Elert E. 2006. Physiological responses Marshall D, Santos J, Leung K, Chak W. 2008.
to stoichiometric constraints nutrient limitation and Correlations between gastropod shell dissolution and
compensatory feeding in a freshwater snail. Oikos water chemical properties in a tropical estuary.
115, 484-494. Marine Environmental Research 66(4), 422.
Galan G, Porquis H, Bulasa M. 2015. Shell band Memon U, Balich W, Tunio G, Burdi G, Korai
pattern of Golden Apple Snail (Pomacea canaliculate, Al, Pirzada A. 2011. Food, feeding, and growth of
Lamark) in Selected Aquatic Habitats. International Golden Apple Snail Pomacea canaliculate, Lamark
Journal of Environmental Science and Development (Gastropoda: Ampullariidae). Sindh University
6(8), 625-628. Research Journal (Science Series) 43(1), 25-28.
Minton R, Lewis E, Netherland B, Hayes D. Silverwood K. 2011. Apple Snail Risk Analysis for
2008. Large Differences over Small Distances: Arizona. Accessed at http://www.azgfd.gov/h_f/
Plasticity in the Shells of Elimia potosiensis documents/AIS-AppleSnailRisk.pdf
(Gastropoda: Pleuroceridae). International Journal of
Biology 3(1), 23-32c.
Sokolova I, Berger V. 2000. Physiological
Morrison W, Hay Mark. 2016. Feeding and variation related to shell color polymorphism in
growth of native and exotic apple snails White Sea Littorina saxatillis. Journal of
(Ampullariidae): Invasive eat more and grow more. Experimental Marine Biology and Ecology
Accessed at http://www.lib.noaa.gov/about/news 245(2000), 1-23
/Morrison_06302010.pdf