11 HPGD2103 T7
11 HPGD2103 T7
11 HPGD2103 T7
Counselling
7
LEARNING OUTCOMES
By the end of this topic, you should be able to:
1. Define group counselling;
2. Explain when it is appropriate to conduct group counselling and its
advantages;
3. Identify the different types of group counselling;
4. Describe the four stages of group counselling; and
5. List the qualities of an effective group leader.
INTRODUCTION
In previous topics, we have discussed the counselling process on a one-to-one
client-counsellor relationship. In this topic, we will focus on group counselling.
Working in groups is a counselling specialty which is used to help individuals
resolve personal and interpersonal problems. Group counselling is based on the
premise that human beings have a natural tendency to share thoughts and feelings.
Groups are valuable because they allow members to experience a sense of
belonging when sharing common problems, observing behaviours and the
consequences of behaviours in others. By participating in a group counselling,
individuals develop social relationships and emotional bonds, and in the process
become more enlightened.
„I feel like the group is the only place in school where people understand me.‰
„During my time in the group, I came out of my shell. The group has helped
me open up to other people and not to worry about what other people think
about what I have to say.‰
„I was able to share things with my group that I was too afraid to share with
other people. Once I learned to do this, I started feeling better about myself.‰
However, there are also some misconceptions about groups. Childers and Couch
(1989) argued that some people are of the opinion that groups are artificial and
unreal when dealing with problems. They force people to lose their identity by
tearing down psychological defences when members are required to become
emotional and spill their guts or tell others about their innermost thoughts.
Some have also suggested that members in the group can become confrontational
and hostile. In addition, group counselling can lead to the brainwashing of
participants.
On the other hand, groups have a number of general advantages (Gladding, 2003)
as follows:
(b) Group members interact with one another and learn more about themselves
in social situations.
(c) Group members can try out new behaviours and ways of interacting when
the group provides a safe environment to experiment changes and receive
feedback.
(d) Group members pick up skills vicariously when they observe how others
talk, interact and solve problems.
(e) Group members may realise their need for individual counselling or the
accomplishment of a personal goal.
SELF-CHECK 7.1
ACTIVITY 7.1
2. Give four reasons why these problems and concerns are most
appropriate for group counselling.
Control of anger;
Study skills.
For students who are getting ready to graduate from secondary school:
(i) Provide them with information to deal with problems after school; and
(ii) A good example is the quality circle team in which a group of workers
meet to examine the processes they are using in their jobs and to devise
ways to improve them.
(e) T-Groups
The ÂTÊ stands for training. These groups are formed to emphasise
interpersonal relationships. Members of the group learn how oneÊs
behaviour in a group influences othersÊ behaviours and vice versa. In other
words, how an individual functions within a system.
(i) Self-help groups have grown in prominence since the 1970s. A self-help
group usually develops spontaneously and focuses on a single topic
which may be led by a person without professional training but with
experience in the issue. For example, residents in a neighbourhood may
meet to help each other to clean the neighbourhood (a kind of gotong-
royong) or to focus governmentÊs attention on issues (such as toxic
waste disposal or river pollution) that affect the quality of their lives.
SELF-CHECK 7.2
List the main differences between the various types of groups in group
counselling. What is a common element in all these groups?
In the forming stage the group is formed and efforts are made to help
members feel they are part of the group. For example, members initiate
conversations which may be superficial but aim to break the ice. The leader
structures the environment to make members feel safe by clarifying the
purpose of the group, establishes rules, models appropriate behaviours and
outlines a vision for the group. It is important that both the leader and group
members are clear regarding the purpose of the group to ensure a feeling of
trust.
The group members need to be involved and feel part of the group. They
need to voice out their expectations from the group. Group members who
are uninvolved and inactive will hinder the progress of the group. Serious
effort is made to help group members feel relaxed, welcomed and valued.
The room is set up in such a way that encourages interaction such as
arranging the chairs in a circle (see Figure 7.5). If at any point there is anxiety
and mistrust, enthusiasm and commitment by group members is likely to
deteriorate.
Both the leader and members may actively remind each other about the
conclusion of the group counselling process. There will be farewell events if
the experience was pleasant and satisfying. Members are required to state
verbally or in written form what they have learned from the group
experience. It is hoped that everyone will leave the group stronger and better
connected with other group members. Everyone are expected make a
successful transition from the life in the group back to everyday life.
Follow-up is used in the group counselling to keep in touch with members after
the group has terminated in order to determine how well the members are
progressing on personal as well as group goals (Gladding, 2003). Follow-up helps
group members and the leader assess what they have gained from the group
experience. It also allows the leader to refer a group member for further help,
if appropriate (Gladding, 2003). Follow-up sessions maximise the effects of group
experience and encourage members to keep pursuing their original goals.
ACTIVITY 7.2
SELF-CHECK 7.3
Because of the unstructured nature of the group, the major problem faced by
the participants was how they were going to use their time together
effectively. There was puzzlement, anxiety and irritation at first because of
the lack of structure. Only gradually did it become evident that the major aim
of nearly every member was to find ways of relating to other members in the
group. Then as we gradually began to explore our feelings and attitudes
towards one another, it became increasingly evident that what was first
presented were façades or masks. Slowly and cautiously our real feelings and
real personality began to emerge. The contrast between the outer shell and the
inner person became more and more apparent as the hours went by.
In the group I had come to know myself and each of the members more
intimately than is possible in the usual social or working relationships. I
became deeply acquainted with other members and their inner selves, the self
that otherwise tended to be hidden behind a façade. Hence, I could relate
better to others, both in the group and later in everyday life situations.
(c) What Types of Concerns are Group Counselling Most Helpful For?
Group counselling is especially helpful for the following types of student
concerns because it is one of the most direct ways of providing the type of
contacts that a student needed to work through his concerns:
(ii) „People don't react to me the way I would like them to.‰
(iv) Learning to express oneÊs own wishes and act on oneÊs own behalf;
However, we have found that the people who benefit most from group
accept a sense of responsibility for making the group work by sharing their
concerns and speaking up when they have reactions to issues or to other
individuals in the group.
(i) If I Do Share Personal Information with The Group, How Can I Trust That it
Will Be Kept Confidential?
The issue of confidentiality is an important one and it is addressed in the first
group session. Group members are asked to make a commitment to protect
each otherÊs confidentiality by agreeing not to divulge information that
would identify other members to outside groups or individuals. While we at
the UCS cannot provide you with an absolute guarantee of confidentiality,
our experience shows that group members respect each otherÊs privacy just
as they respect their own. Some issues do not remain confidential whether
you are being seen in group or individual counselling. The decision to break
confidentiality is based on the issue of protection. If a member appears to be
planning harm to self (suicide), harm to others (homicide) or if he reports
that he has abused children or dependent adult individuals, the counsellor is
legally bound to break confidentiality in order to provide the individuals
with the assistance they need.
(i) If you are going to miss a session, please let the group leaders know;
(ii) We ask that you give the group a chance. If you decide the group is not
appropriate for you, please discuss your concerns with the group;
(iii) It is your responsibility to talk about your reasons for being in the
group and to let the group know what you expect from them; and
SELF-CHECK 7.4
(f) Find out how many universities and colleges in Malaysia actually
provide group counselling services for their students.
Skills Description
Group counselling is based on the premise that people have a natural tendency
to share thoughts and feelings.
Ć Joseph Pratt, a Boston physician, was the first to use group counselling in 1905.
Ć Counsellors have to make the decision when, where and with whom to apply
group counselling. In some situations, group counselling is not an appropriate
way of helping individuals.
Ć Some people are of the opinion that groups are artificial and unreal when
dealing with problems.
Guidance/Psychoeducational Groups;
Task/Work Groups;
T-Groups; and
Self-Help/Support Groups.
In the forming stage, efforts are made to help members feel they are part of
the group;
In the norming stage, the leader and group members try to find their place
in the group and develop a sense of cohesiveness or „we-ness‰;
In the performing stage, the group is ready to „work‰ and members are
more trusting of self and others. They are more focussed in achieving the
goals of the group; and
In the termination stage, group members have completed their tasks and
having accomplished goals, they take time to celebrate and ultimately
disband the group.
Forming Performing
Group counselling Personality reconstruction group
Guidance/psychoeducational groups Self-help/Support group
Interpersonal problem-solving group Termination
Misconceptions T-Group
Norming
Childers, J. H., & Couch, R. D. (1989). Myths about group counseling: Identifying
and challenging misconceptions. Journal for Specialists in Group Work,
Vol. 14(2), p. 105ă111.