Wayamba Journal of Animal Science - ISSN :2012-578X; P1-P5, 2009

First Submitted September 09, 2009; Number 1251889590

Formulation of dog food using locally available ingredients

Dilrukshi H.N.N., Jayaweera B.P.A. & Gamika A.Prathapasinghe
Department of Livestock and Avian Sciences, Faculty of Livestock, Fisheries and Nuitrition, Wayamba University of Sri Lanka

Puppy stage is a critical period of dog's life cycle as it requires more “Complete” or “Balanced” diet. The amount of food a puppy requires changes
nutrition. During this time period, puppy requires more than 28% of during growth and depends on the puppy's nutritional deficiencies and/or
protein and energy density of less than 3.5 kcal ME/g DM. Dog food is imbalances during this period are more devastating than at any other time
material intended for consumption by the domestic dog. Dogs are able to (National academy of sciences, 1974). During this phase, dog develops a
healthily digest a variety of foods. The remarkable adaptability of the dog functioning immune system, dramatically adds bone and muscle mass, and
has led to the successful use of commercial diets that differ widely in their developing proper socialization behaviors all the while. There is no more
ingredient composition. The pet food industry has well established critical time to ensure proper nutrition. Growth diets have been formulated to
markets in developed countries like United States but it plays minor role in meet the increased requirements of puppies. The more reputable brands are
developing countries like in Sri Lanka. Therefore, this study was carried available at the market for growing puppy to ensure that they support healthy
out with the objectives of formulating a palatable dog-food using locally growth. But in developing countries like Sri Lanka, due to low income levels,
available ingredients in Sri Lanka at lower price level, which confirm the dog foods are not very popular among the pet owners. Because, most of
main nutritional requirements and to determine its influence on growth available imported brands are high in price. Therefore, this study was carried
rate of local breeds. Maize, Rice flour, Rice polish, Animal fat, Soya bean out to formulate the puppy feed using locally available ingredients at lower
meal, Fish meal, Hypro meal, Chicken, Eggs, Baking soda and Vitamin price level with which confirm the main nutritional requirements.
premixes were the ingredients used in dog food formulation. A total of 08
puppies, between 06-08 weeks of age were selected for the study. Body METHDOLOGY
weight was measured using weighing scale and serum electrolyte
concentrations were measured to determine nutritional status. Sensory Study Design and Study Period
evaluation was performed for dog feces and skin/coat condition. The body This study was conducted as an experimental study, during the period of
weight and feed intake had a significant (P<0.05) and positively March to June, 2009 to formulate the dog feed using locally available
associated relationship (r = 0.84, P =0.000). The mean growth rate of ingredients.
puppies which were fed using formulated feed was 0.088 kg/day ± 0.038
whereas 0.025 kg/day ± 0.006 was the mean growth rate of puppies which
were fed using homemade diets in first trial. The current study found that Study Sample
the mean growth rate was 0.0586 kg/day ± 0.022 in formulated feed group
whereas 0.0628 kg/day ± 0.019 was the weight gain in imported feed Apparently 08 healthy puppies that were in the age range of 6 to 8 weeks were
group in second feed trial. Sensory evaluation results revealed better mean selected purposefully. Puppies were divided in to two groups which were
scores for sensory attributes in dog feces and skin/coat condition in having same total weight based on individual body weight.
formulated feed group. In conclusion, formulated puppy feed had positive
association with growth rate, electrolyte concentration and sensory
Materials
attributes of skin/coat condition and dog feces.
All ingredients which required preparing dog feed (maize, rice flour, rice
Key words: Puppy stage, Formulation, Dog feed, Locally available
polish, animal fat, soya bean meal, chicken, fish meal, hypro meal, eggs,
ingredients, Pellets
vitamin premixes and baking soda) were purchased from commercial stores.
Maize and soya bean meal were ground in to powder form. Animal fat was
turned into liquid form using heat treatment. Chicken flesh was grounded and
Dog food is material intended for consumption by the domestic dog minced.
(Canis lupus familiaris) which is one of the most widely kept working and
companion animals in human history. Of the total production of pet food, Preparation of dog feed
dog food accounted 61% in 2007 (www.petfoodindustry.com, 2008). In
The ingredients were weighed using a kitchen scale.
the world pet food industry, the leading exporters of pet foods were France
($993 million), United States ($786 million) and Netherland ($511
million) while the leading importers were Japan ($718 million), Germany
($617 million) and the UK ($563 million). In 2007, global sales of cat and
dog food totaled US$ 45.12 billion, a growth of 4.9% from the previous
year (www.petfoodindustry.com, 2008). The Association of American
Feed Control Officials (AAFCO) is a commercial enterprise which
attempts to regulate the quality and safety of pet food. AAFCO regulations
for pet food include requirements regarding product names, flavor
designations, guaranteed analysis, nutritional adequacy statements,
proper ingredient names, and other aspects of labeling. The remarkable
adaptability of the dog has led to the successful use of commercial diets
that differ widely in their ingredient composition. Commercial dog foods
are of the three basic types. Dry type dog foods contains l o w i n
moisture content (usually about 10-12%), Semi moist dog foods are
moderate in moisture content (usually 25-30%) whereas Canned Dog
foods high in moisture content (usually 74-78%)(Mcellhiney R.R.,1994).
Dog's unique nutritional requirement varies with age, breed, gender, Figure 1: Dog feed preparation procedure
activity, temperament, environment and metabolism. From a nutritional
Data collection
stand point, growth is the most critical time in a dog's life. By two months
of age, pups can be fed using puppy food. They are in an important phase Determination of weight
of life-growth; skeletal development is at its peak for the first six months
of life (National academy of sciences, 1974). Puppies in their active Weight was determined using the weighing scale. Subjects were hanged using
growth phase should be fed a high-quality diet that meets their specific thread and measurements were recorded to the nearest 100 g.
nutritional needs (National research counsil, 2006). Growing dogs exhibit
omnivorous feeding behavior and therefore, their diet should be Determination of feed intake
comprised of proteins, carbohydrates, fats, vitamins and minerals in
correct proportions. A puppy food that meets these requirements is called a Daily feed requirement was determined using standards according to body

P1 Copyright © 2009 Society of Animal Science, Department of Livestock & Avian Science, Wayamba University of Sri Lanka. http://www.wayambajournal.com
 P2

weight.

kg puppy needs 1000 kcal/ME per day (Nutrient requirement of dogs

and cats, National academic press)

Daily feed intake was recorded using remaining amount.

During month of April two groups of puppies were fed using homemade
diets and formulated feeds. After one week of flush up, homemade diet
group was replaced by imported feed.

Determination of electrolyte concentrations in blood serum

3-5 ml of blood was taken from every puppy and those were centrifuged
1000 r.p.m for 05 minutes. Serum was separated and sent to PetsVcare
animal hospital for electrolyte analysis.
Sensory evaluation
Figure 3: Increase of body weight (kg) with the time (weeks) in group
Three types of sensory evaluation tests were carried out with thirty five number 01
untrained panelists.

First 5 points Hedonic scale tests were performed to evaluate the skin/
coat condition and texture, color and odor of dog feces of two treatment
groups.

Palatability test was performed by using two- pan free choice test.

Proximate analysis

Proximate analysis was done for the crude protein and energy was
calculated using bomb calorimeter.

Statistical analysis

Statistical analysis was done using Minitab15 software.

Non parametric Friedman test was used to analyze the sensory Figure 4: Increase of body weight (kg) with the time (weeks) in group
evaluation data using MINITAB software. (Test is significant at number 02
P<0.05)
Table 2: Mean growth rate (kg/day) values of two groups of puppies (n=8)
RESULTS
Growth rate (kg/day)
A total of 8 puppies were recruited to the study of formulation of dog
Treatment Mean ± SD P value
feed using locally available ingredients. Growth rate, feed intake, blood
parameters, cost condition and sensory evaluation data were used in
analysis in this report.

Characteristics of the sample Homemade diets 0.025 0.006 0.0491

The total sample obtained, consisted of 07 females and 01

male aged 06-08 weeks. Formulated feed 0.088 0.038
Growth performances
Puppies in group number 01 were fed using formulated feed
t- test for the difference between growth rates of puppies were fed using
and group number 02 was fed using homemade diets.
homemade diets and formulated feed.
Table 1: Growth performances of puppies during first feed
trial (03 weeks) Body weight gain of the group 01 was greater than that of group 02. One
week of flush up period was carried out for puppies fed with homemade diet
group (group number 02) to be adapted to imported feed. Group number 01
was continuing with formulated feed as usual.
Group Code Initial Final Weight
number number of weight weight gain (kg) / Table 3: Growth performances of puppies during adaptation period (01
puppy (kg) (kg) week week)

01a 3.0 5.9 0.967 Group number Code number Initial weight Final weight Weight gain
of puppy (kg) (kg) (kg) / week
01b 5.2 7.0 0.600
01a 5.9 6.3 0.4
01 01c 5.0 5.9 0.300
01b 7.0 7.1 0.1

01d 3.3 5.1 0.600 01 01c 5.9 6.0 0.1

02a 2.8 3.3 0.167 01d 5.1 5.5 0.4

02a 3.3 4.9 1.6

02b 7.0 7.7 0.233
02b 7.7 8.9 1.2
02 02c 3.8 4.3 0.167
02 02c 4.3 5.9 1.6
02d 2.9 3.3 0.133 02d 3.3 4.0 0.7

Copyright © 2009 Society of Animal Science, Department of Livestock & Avian Science, Wayamba University of Sri Lanka. http://www.wayambajournal.com
P3
1
Table 4: Mean growth rate (kg/week) values of two groups of puppies
(n=8) during adaptation period 12

Growth rate (kg/week) 10

Body Weight (Kg)

Treatment Mean ± SD P value
8
2a
6 2b
2c
4 2d

Imported Feed 1.27 0.427 0.0211 0

1 3 5 7 9 11 13 15 17 19 21 23 25 27 29 31 33 35

Time Duration (Days)

Formulated feed 0.25 0.173

1 Figure 6: Increase of body weight (kg) with the time (days)

t- test for the difference between growth rates of puppies were fed Table 6 Mean growth rate (kg) values of two groups of puppies (n=8)
using imported feed and formulated feed. Treatment Growth rate (kg/day)

During the adaptation period puppies in group number 01 were Mean ± SD P value
achieved weight gain in a significantly higher rate than that of group
number 02.
Table 5: Growth performances of puppies during second feed trial (05 Imported feed 0.0628 0.0189 0.7811
weeks)
Formulated feed 0.0586 0.022

Group number Code number Initial weight Final weight Weight gain
of puppy (kg) (kg) (kg) / week 1
t- test for the difference between growth rates of puppies were fed using
01a 6.3 7.4 0.22 imported diets and formulated feed.

01b 7.1 9.2 0.42 Results indicated, there was no significant difference of growth rate of
puppies were feusing imported diets and formulated feed.
01 01c 6.0 8.0 0.40
Relationship between feed intake and body weight
01d 5.5 8.5 0.60
As figure 4.2.5 shows, there was a positive relationship between feed intake
02a 4.9 6.2 0.26
and body weight of puppies in group number 01 which was significant.
02b 8.9 11.2 0.46

02 02c 5.9 8.8 0.58

02d 4.0 6.3 0.46

Figure 4 shows the pattern of growth of puppies was fed by formulated

feed during 35 days.

10
9
8
Figure 7: Regression analysis between feed intake and body weight(Group
Body Weight (Kg)

7
no. 01)
6
5 Pearson correlation = 0.864 (P-Value = 0.000)
1a
4
1b
3
1c
As same in group number 01, there was a positive relationship between feed
2
1d
intake and body weight of puppies in group number 02 which was significant.
1
0
1 3 5 7 9 11 13 15 17 19 21 23 25 27 29 31 33 35

Time Duration (Days)

Figure 5: Increase of body weight (kg) with the time (days)

Puppies in group number 01 have similar pattern of growth. In the case

of puppy numbered as 1a had gradually declining pattern of growth,
nearly for 07 to 15 days. The reason for that was its suffering from
bacterial disease.

Figure 5 shows the pattern of growth of puppies was fed by imported Figure 8: Regression analysis between feed intake and body weight(Group
feed during 35 days. no. 02)

Copyright © 2009 Society of Animal Science, Department of Livestock & Avian Science, Wayamba University of Sri Lanka. http://www.wayambajournal.com
 P4

Copyright © 2009 Society of Animal Science, Department of Livestock & Avian Science, Wayamba University of Sri Lanka. http://www.wayambajournal.com
P5

Table 10: Prices of dog food brands available at today's market and general well-being and the nutritional adequacy or superiority of its diet. The
current study used evaluation table to measure the skin and coat condition
price of formulated feed established by WALTHAM centre for pet nutrition in UK (Appendix 01).
According to the study results formulated group scored mean values in
between 0 and 2 for gloss, softness and optimum coat feel which indicates
Dog food brand Price (Rs/Kg) those attributes better than imported group. This could be due to superiority
of formulated feed over the imported feed in terms of micronutrients such as
essential fatty acids. Two- pan, free choice test was used as palatability test
Nutripet 1040 (Plate 4.3.3.1). “First choice” indicates the diet first consumed and “first
approach” indicates the diet first examined and smelled. In the study
population, 67.85% of subjects had first choice for formulated feed. Imported
Pedegree 640 feed showed 69.64% as first approach (Figure 4.4.3.1). This revealed there
should be enhancement of palatability in formulated feeds.
Eukanuba 500 Cost analysis is an important event in new product development. To produce
01 kilogram of formulated feed, it costed around 160 rupees. Most of the
commonly available dog food brands cost more than 500 rupees/kilogram at
Formulated Feed 160 present market (Table 4.5.2).

Association of American Feed Control Officials (AAFCO) is the responsible

Protein and Energy measurements body to provide a mechanism for developing and implementing uniform and
equitable laws, regulations, standards and enforcement policies for
Table 4.6.1 represents the AAFCO standards, which implementing regulating the manufacture, distribution and sale of animal feeds. According
uniform and equitable regulation and standards for the manufacture to the AAFCO Dog Food Nutrient Profiles Published in 2008, puppy food
and measurements of energy and protein should contain energy density of less than 3.5 kcal ME/g DM (metabolizable
energy/gram dry matter) and minimum protein 28%. Formulated feed
Table 11: AAFCO standards, protein and energy measurements in contains 3.3 kcal ME/g DM and 30% of protein whereas imported feed
imported and formulated feed contains 4.3 kcal ME/g DM and 32 % of protein.
AAFCO standards Imported Feed Formulated Feed
CONCLUSION
Protein 28% 32% 30% In this study the positive and significant relationship observed between body
weight and feed intake. The mean growth rate of puppies that were fed using
formulated feed was 0.088 kg/day ± 0.038 whereas 0.025 kg/day ± 0.006 was
Energy <3.5 - 4.0 Kcal/g 4.3 Kcal/g 3.3 Kcal/g
the mean growth rate of puppies that were fed using homemade diets in first
trial. The current study found that, the mean growth rate was 0.0586 kg/day ±
0.022 in formulated feed group whereas 0.0628 kg/day ± 0.019 was the
weight gain in imported feed group in second feed trial. There is no any
DISCUSSION significance in terms of electrolyte concentration in blood serum in
formulated and imported feed trials. Sensory evaluation results revealed
The pet food industry has global business system which comprises with better mean scores for sensory attributes in dog feces and skin/coat condition
developed and developing countries. Dog and cat foods play a major in formulated feed group. Two-pan free choice test results shows, there
role among the other pet foods. The developed countries have rapidly should be an enhancement of palatability in formulated feed. Protein and
expanding markets for pet foods than developing countries. The main energy measurements of formulated feed
reason for this scenario is pet owners in developing countries do not
prefer for imported dog foods because of its high price. Pet owners RIFERENCES
often prefer dry food for reasons of convenience and price. Therefore,
this study was an experimental study designed to formulate a palatable, 1) Ad hoc committee on dog and cat nutrition, Committee on Animal
dry dog-food using locally available ingredients for lower price levels Nutrition, Board on agriculture and natural resources, Division of earth
which confirm the main nutritional requirements and to determine its and life studies and national research counsil. (2006). Nutrient
influence on growth rate and blood parameters of local breeds. requirements of dogs and cats. http://books.nap.edu (accessed 24 th April
2009)
The mean growth rate of puppies in group number 01 which were fed
using formulated feed, showed a significantly higher value (0.088 2) Association of American Feed Control officials, (2009) Electronic
kg/day ± 0.038) than puppies in group number 02 (0.025 kg/day ± references. Retrieved March 20, 2009 from http://www.aafco.org
0.006) which were fed using homemade diets. This could be due to
inadequate nutritional composition of home made diets. During the 3) MCellhiney R.R.(1994). Feed manufacturing technology. (4th
adaptation period there was significantly higher growth rate (1.27 ed).Ammerican feed industry association
kg/week ± 0.427) in group number 02 which were fed using imported
4) National academy of sciences. (1974). Nutrient Requirement of Dogs.
feed than group number 01 ( 0.25 kg/week ± 0.173). The present study
Wasington,D.C.
found that, there was no any significant difference in terms of growth
rate of puppies during second feed trial. The mean growth rate was 5) National research council of the national academies. (2006). Your dog's
0.0586 kg/day ± 0.022 in formulated feed group where 0.0628 kg/day ± nutritional needs. National academies press
0.019 was the weight gain in imported feed group. This may be the
consequence of similar nutritional, mainly energy and protein balance 6) Pet food industry, (2009) Electronic reference. Retrieved April 23, 2009
in formulated and imported feeds. The positive and significant from http://www.petfoodindustry.com
relationship observed between body weight and feed intake.
Potassium, Calcium, Sodium, Chloride and Phosphorus are the 7) Pond,W.G., Church, D.C. and Pond K.R.(1995). Basic Animal Nutrition
common electrolytes available in blood serum. Results revealed that, and Feeding. (4 th ed). John wiley and sons, New york:p.531-53
there is no any difference in terms of concentration of electrolytes in
both formulated and imported feed groups. 8) The internet animal hospital, (2009). Electronic reference. Retrieved July
28, 2009 from http://www.thepetcenter.com
Pet owner's preference for dog foods varies according to some factors.
Those factors are age of pet, activity level, breed, and health at the same
time some owners are considering some characteristics of the dog
feces. To analyze the dog feces, used some of common characteristics
of feces such as texture, color and odor in sensory evaluation. That
study revealed a significant difference in texture and color but in the
case of odor, there was no any difference (Table 4.4.1). There is a strong
perception that skin and coat condition is an indicator of an animal's

Copyright © 2009 Society of Animal Science, Department of Livestock & Avian Science, Wayamba University of Sri Lanka. http://www.wayambajournal.com