EMT Report 2017 Eng
EMT Report 2017 Eng
EMT Report 2017 Eng
PREPAREDNESS
2
Executive Summary...................................................................................................................................... 5
Report on the Objectives of the Meeting..................................................................................................... 9
Contents
1. Present developments in the implementation of the EMT initiative at the global,
regional and national levels................................................................................................................... 10
Implementation of the EMT Initiative in the Americas......................................................................... 10
The EMT Initiative: A global approach for saving lives during emergencies..........................................14
The experience of the countries of the Americas: Implementing
the EMT Initiative at the national level................................................................................................. 16
2. Consolidate best practices for the preparation and readiness of Emergency Medical Teams...................25
1. Overcoming readiness challenges. ................................................................................................. 25
2. Water supply.................................................................................................................................. 27
2. Sanitation...................................................................................................................................... 29
3. Waste management........................................................................................................................ 30
4. Fuel and electric power (consumption and EMT zones)................................................................31
5. Medicines and consumables........................................................................................................... 32
3. Develop regional capacities by promoting minimum standards and requirements
for EMT operations during emergency response: updating clinical care................................................ 33
1. Dialysis.......................................................................................................................................... 33
2. Surgery.......................................................................................................................................... 34
3. Basic radiology for EMTs............................................................................................................... 36
4. Blood transfusion........................................................................................................................... 37
4. Strengthen coordination, deployment, and operations during emergency response................................ 37
1. Considerations and regulations for EMT deployment.................................................................... 37
2. National mechanisms for EMT registration................................................................................... 39
3. Ensuring a comprehensive response: from the disaster zone to proper medical facilities..................40
5. Identify regional and national priorities to promote the agenda of
EMT Initiative implementation in 2018-2019...................................................................................... 42
1. Training......................................................................................................................................... 42
2. Human Resources.......................................................................................................................... 42
3. Logistics......................................................................................................................................... 42
4. Considerations for EMT deployment............................................................................................ 42
5. CICOM establishment and management....................................................................................... 43
Decisions of the Regional Group of the Americas..................................................................................... 45
1. Report of the Advisory Group of EMT-Providing NGOs...................................................................... 45
2. Reporte del Grupo Asesor de ONGs proveedoras de EMTs................................................................... 45
1. Structure........................................................................................................................................ 45
2. Objectives...................................................................................................................................... 46
3. Logistics......................................................................................................................................... 47
4. Leadership..................................................................................................................................... 47
5. Training......................................................................................................................................... 47
6. Personnel....................................................................................................................................... 47
7. Information management.............................................................................................................. 47
3. Updated List of EMT Focal Points Officially Designated by the
Health Authorities of the Americas (up to date as of June 26, 2018)..................................................... 48
3
II EMT REGIONAL MEETING OF THE AMERICAS - 2017 REPORT AND RECOMMENDATIONS
4
Executive Summary
The 2nd Regional Meeting of Emergency Medical Teams (EMT) in the Americas was held
from November 27–29, 2017, in Quito, Ecuador, chaired by the Ministry of Public Health
of Ecuador, represented by Dr. Verónica Espinosa in her capacity as Interim Chair of the
Regional EMT Group of the Americas. The meeting was co-hosted by the Ministry of Public
Health and the Pan American Health Organization.
A total of 109 participants attended the meeting, including 23 officially designated focal
points of 23 of Member States of PAHO/WHO (Ecuador, Mexico, El Salvador, Costa Rica,
Guatemala, Nicaragua, Panama, Cuba, the Dominican Republic, Haiti, Grenada, Jamaica,
Saint Vincent and the Grenadines, Antigua and Barbuda, Guyana, Argentina, Bolivia, Chile,
Peru, Brazil, Venezuela, Colombia, Uruguay, and the United States). Experts from the United
States, Costa Rica, Argentina, Chile, and Spain) [TN: These are not in alphabetical order (or
any other discernible order) in the original.] also attended, as did 17 representatives of NGOs
of the Americas which provide EMTs.
The inaugural address of the 2nd Regional Meeting was chaired by Dr. Gina Tambini,
PAHO/WHO Representative for Ecuador; Dr. Itamar Rodríguez, interim Deputy Minister
for Comprehensive Health Care of Ecuador; and Dr. Ciro Ugarte, Director of the PAHO/
WHO Health Emergencies Department (PHE). The inaugural session welcomed the par-
ticipants of the Meeting and highlighted regional achievements, with special emphasis on
the classification of the national EMTs of Ecuador and Costa Rica and the need to continue
building EMT capacity in the Americas.
The inaugural session also addressed the regional challenges for EMT response that have been
identified in the various instances of implementation of the initiative, with support and feed-
back from national focal points, NGOs, and other EMT providers, including the workshops
of EMT coordinators. This helped frame subsequent debates on opportunities for improve-
5
II EMT REGIONAL MEETING OF THE AMERICAS - 2017 REPORT AND RECOMMENDATIONS
ment, how to address the challenges faced by different EMT actors, and
best practices that should be standardized at the regional level.
Each of the three days of the meeting was focused on strategic discussion
of a key stage of implementation of the EMT Initiative in the Americas:
Ensuring EMT preparedness (November 27); Addressing the challenges
of deployment (November 28); and Coordination and post-deployment
(November 29). Side events included a poster gallery of EMT implemen-
tation presented by various actors involved in the initiative, a follow-up
meeting to the Union of South American Nations (UNASUR) “Decla-
ration on Minimum Standards for Emergency Medical Teams (EMT)1”
with the focal points of the UNASUR Member States, appointment of
the chair and vice-chairs of the EMT Regional Group, and prearranged
mentoring meetings.
6
At the end of the meeting, Ecuador was officially appointed as the chair of the EMT Region-
al Group of the Americas by a unanimous vote of the EMT focal points. Costa Rica and Pan-
ama were named First and Second Vice Chairs of the Regional Group, respectively.
PAHO/WHO thanks the Government of Ecuador for providing a venue for the II Region-
al Meeting of EMTs in the Americas and for its continuous support for the initiative; the
countries of the Americas for their strong collaboration during 2017 and their commitment
to advancing the objectives of the initiative at the national level for stronger regional cooper-
ation during emergencies and disasters; and Spanish Agency for International Development
Cooperation (AECID), the United States Department of Health and Human Services, and
the strategic partners of PAHO and the EMT initiative for their support in strengthening
the Member States’ capacities to respond to health emergencies and coordinate humanitar-
ian aid in the Americas. In this regard, PAHO/WHO and the EMT Regional Secretariat of
the Americas will continue to work on implementation of the initiative at the regional level,
pursuant to the provisions of PAHO Directing Council Resolutions 53 and 55.
7
II EMT REGIONAL MEETING OF THE AMERICAS - 2017 REPORT AND RECOMMENDATIONS
#EMTamericas
8
Report on the
Objectives
of the Meeting
With respect to establishing a regional agenda for the implementation of the EMT initiative
through a strategic debate among the Member States and EMT-providing organizations on align-
ment of coordination, preparation of teams’ challenges in response operations, and regional and
national initiatives, five (5) objectives were defined for the II Regional Meeting of EMTs in
the Americas:
5. Identify regional and national priorities to promote the agenda for implementation of
the EMT Initiative in 2018-2019.
• Keynote address: Sets the framework for the events and agenda.
9
II EMT REGIONAL MEETING OF THE AMERICAS - 2017 REPORT AND RECOMMENDATIONS
• Group work sessions: Collaborative work on tasks for review, reflection, and planning
of specific topics of regional implementation of the EMT Initiative.
• Open discussion: Open forum for mutual in-depth reflection, comprehension, and
clarification on key topics pertaining to the EMT Initiative in the Region.
The Region of the Americas, in which the Pan American Health Organization (PAHO)
operates, is made up of 49 Member States and Territories, which are exposed to a wide
variety of emergencies and disasters of increasing scale and frequency. It is estimated that,
between 2011 and 2016, around 20% of all natural disasters worldwide occurred in this
Region, affecting more than 67 million people. Emerging public health threats, such as the
Zika virus epidemic to which more than 500 million people were exposed in Latin America
and the Caribbean, represent new challenges for public health and require a broader scope of
preparedness and response.
In 2014, the 53rd Directing Council of PAHO, made up of the Ministers of Health of
the Member States, established and approved the “Plan of Action for the Coordination
of Humanitarian Assistance” in the Americas, which sets out implementation of response
procedures and flexible national registration mechanisms for Emergency Medical Teams in
the Member States. The 55th Directing Council subsequently approved the “Plan of Action
for Disaster Risk Reduction 2016-2021”, which urges the Member States to strengthen
national-level efforts to develop and update the knowledge and procedures of emergency and
disaster response teams. Both resolutions constitute the framework on which the Emergency
Medical Teams (EMT) initiative and PAHO’s national-level capacity-building for risk reduc-
tion and disaster response are based.
The framework for regional implementation of the EMT Initiative in the Americas has been
completed in 2017. The Regional EMT Secretariat worked on creation of this implementa-
tion framework. In January 2017 it was shared with the Member States, which then made
recommendations and contributions which were included in the document and validated in
the final version. Currently, the Ministry of Health of Ecuador is the chair of the Regional
Group, and 23 countries of the Americas have designated focal points.
10
The Regional EMT Secretariat of the Americas is supported by two structures:
1. The EMT Regional Group, which includes the regional presidency, the advisory com-
mittee, the ad hoc working groups, and the NGO advisory group.
2. The focal points network of the Member States, with focal and operational points
who serve as references for implementation within the country.
Figure 1 illustrates the structure – created and approved by the focal points and Regional
Group – for the Regional EMT Secretariat of the Americas.
OPS/OMS
MEMBER STATES EMT REGIONAL GROUP
DEPARTAMENT OF
GOVERNMENT
HEALTH EMERGENCIES
Activities carried out periodically by the Regional Secretariat in 2017 included national workshops
to introduce the initiative, as well as 2-day sessions on flexible coordination tools and mechanisms,
which have met the goal of providing support and information so that Member States can develop
their own national workshops. To date, 17 national workshops have been held in 17 countries2.
The training of EMT coordinators also achieved its dual objective of training personnel in
EMT coordination at the regional level and ensuring that EMT coordinators are able to
2 Argentina, Bolivia, Chile, Colombia, Costa Rica, Cuba, the Dominican Republic, Ecuador, El Salvador, Guatemala, Honduras,
Mexico, Nicaragua, Panama, Paraguay, Peru, and Venezuela.
11
II EMT REGIONAL MEETING OF THE AMERICAS - 2017 REPORT AND RECOMMENDATIONS
support the implementation process in their respective countries. To date, three editions of
the Regional Course for EMT Coordinators have been held, in Panama (2015), Costa Rica
(2016), and Chile (2017), for a roster of 78 EMT coordinators from 23 countries. Addition-
ally, in 2017, a special edition of the coordinators’ workshop was carried out in Trinidad and
Tobago for the whole of the English-speaking Caribbean, which included the participation of
representatives from 23 Caribbean nations and territories.3
The Region of the Americas, which has led implementation of this initiative, hosted the I
Regional and Global Meeting in Panama in 2015. During the II Regional Meeting, held
in Quito from November 27 to 29, the regional agenda for implementation of the EMT
Initiative was defined through a strategic debate among the Member States and EMT-provid-
ing organizations on the alignment of coordination, preparation of teams challenges faced in
response operations, and regional and national initiatives.
Regarding mechanisms for coordination, five countries are currently implementing national
procedures to request and deploy EMTs, as well as working on implementation of CICOMs
with support from PAHO: Chile, Costa Rica, Colombia, Ecuador, and Peru. CICOM is
a tool affiliated with the Health EOC of each country and designed to facilitate handling
of information, as well as deployment and coordination of EMTs, to ensure continuity of
clinical care during emergencies and disasters. This tool was activated for the first time in
2016 during response to the earthquake in Ecuador, which resulted in efficient coordination
among 28 national EMTs and five international EMTs (from Colombia, Germany, Peru,
Spain, and the United States) deployed to the most affected areas.
Finally, among the advances achieved by the EMT Initiative in the Americas, one stands out:
the global classification of the national EMTs of Costa Rica and Ecuador, which successfully
met the international standards established by WHO. Costa Rica has achieved Classified status
for a fixed Type 1 EMT affiliated with the Costa Rican Social Security Fund. Ecuador, in turn,
classified three of its teams as Type 2 EMTs with a specialized surgical cell. During 2018, more
national teams that are currently adapting their EMTs to WHO’s international standards and
participating in mentoring are expected to reach Classified status. In this sense, it bears stressing
that, during the II Regional Meeting, the Member States of the Americas urged teams to not
only conform to global classification, but to promote a cycle of continuous improvement and
technical training so that these teams can work as national EMTs as well.
3 Anguilla, Antigua and Barbuda, Bahamas, Barbados, Belize, Bermuda, the British Virgin Islands, the Cayman Islands, Dominica,
Granada, Guyana, Jamaica, Montserrat, St. Kitts and Nevis, St. Lucia, St Vincent and the Grenadines, Suriname, Trinidad and
Tobago, Turks and Caicos, and the United States.
12
In 2018-2019, the Region will continue its progress toward a full rollout of the EMT Ini-
tiative, consolidating itself as the world’s leading region in implementation. The work plan
approved for the Region of the Americas consists of the following key points:
• Develop guidelines and standards for the establishment and operation of national
CICOMs during health emergencies;
13
II EMT REGIONAL MEETING OF THE AMERICAS - 2017 REPORT AND RECOMMENDATIONS
The EMT Initiative: A global approach for saving lives during emergencies
Currently, the EMT Initiative is being implemented globally with the priority of agreeing on
a common strategy that will allow us to fulfill our mission: To reduce loss of life and prevent
long-term disability as a result of sudden disasters, epidemics, and/or other emergencies, through
rapid deployment and efficient allocation of EMTs which adhere to internationally accepted min-
imum standards. This strategy focuses on the promotion and creation of platforms, mecha-
nisms, policies, and tools necessary to achieve the defined objectives.
For each of the 5 objectives of the EMT Initiative, the Global Secretariat is working on spe-
cific recommendations that will help meet the strategic priorities that have been identified:
a. Update the contents of the Blue Book, taking into account the potential need to
add new chapters, and identify specific technical or coordination elements that
should be highlighted.
3. Create a “Toolkit” for EMTs: A draft version is being developed, which will be revised
in concert with the “Blue Book” and published online.
14
Objective 2: Improvement/quality control and classification of Emergen-
cy Medical Teams:
EMT classification
Objective 3: Capacities and capacity-building:
Ecuador
1. Increase the capacity of national authorities to activate and
coordinate response by national and international EMTs through
national and regional workshops, as well as through EMT coordi-
nation courses.
3. Use support tools such as spreadsheets, MDS-type reports, Virtual CICOM, Virtual
OSSOC, etc.
15
II EMT REGIONAL MEETING OF THE AMERICAS - 2017 REPORT AND RECOMMENDATIONS
d. Political support;
1. Argentina
On March 8, 2015, Argentina established and started operation of a Technical Group com-
posed of the Ministries of Health, Defense, Security, Social Development, Foreign Affairs, and
Religion, with support from the PAHO Representative Office in Argentina. Through the work
of this Technical Group, a protocol was designed to offer, request, and activate EMTs. Cur-
rently, at the national level, these protocols are activated under the authority of the National
Comprehensive Risk Management System (SINAGIR) (National Law 27287).
During 2017, Argentina carried out a number of activities nationwide to promote implementa-
tion of the EMT Initiative and strengthen response capacities, which included workshops and
interagency meetings:
• National Workshop for the Coordination of EMTs in Emergency and Disaster Re-
sponse, Buenos Aires, March 2017.
• Presentation of the EMT program to Health Regions for the establishment of Type 1
Teams. Buenos Aires, May 2017.
• Workshop on health logistics and CICOM. Salta and Jujuy, September and October 2017.
• 1st National Course on Operational Support and Health logistics for EMT Deploy-
ment. Buenos Aires, October 2017.
16
• National CICOM Workshop, December 11-12, 2017.
• Participation in the regional logistics workshop held in Costa Rica in September 2017.
This same year, Argentina deployed its EMTs within a joint health response operation of the
National Comprehensive Risk Management System to Morillo, province of Salta, Northwest
Region. On this occasion, 1,442 patients were treated and 10 emergency transfers were per-
formed.
As part of its resource map, the country is working on regionalization of the initiative, under
the leadership of the Ministry of Health, together with the medical components of the Min-
istries of Defense and Security. The mission is to adapt international tools at the national level
through Health Emergency Committees (Comités de Emergencias Sanitarias, CES), which are
units that coordinate, regulate, implement, and plan activities and resources in emergency and
disaster situations in the provinces that constitute each regional level. Within this system, Type
1 EMTs operate at the regional level and Type 2 EMTs at the national level; both are articulated
through the Inter-ministerial EMT Group, with technical support from PAHO.
In 2018, Argentina plans to hold the 2nd National Logistics Workshop and the 1st National
Workshop on surgical management in austere conditions and start CICOM implementation at
the national level.
2. Brazil
With a population of over 200 million, Brazil has a universal, publicly funded Unified
Health System, which is free at the point of care and characterized by its decentralized man-
agement, focus on providing comprehensive care (prioritizing preventive activities without
detriment to curative ones), and promotion of community involvement.
Within this system, the objective of the Vigidesastres program is to develop a set of activities
to be adopted on an ongoing basis by the public health authorities to reduce exposure to
disaster risk in the general population and among health professionals; reduce the morbid-
ity burden resulting from disasters; and mitigate damage to health infrastructure. Within
the framework of the Vigidesastres program, the country has developed a risk management
model with three cornerstones: risk reduction (prevention, mitigation, and preparedness),
emergency and disaster management (alert and response), and recovery (rehabilitation and
reconstruction). Organization and guidance of the health sector for disaster prevention, pre-
paredness, and response is carried out through State Committees for Disaster Health (Comi-
tês Estaduais de Saúde em Desastres, CESD) and Strategic Information and Response Centers
for Health Surveillance (Centros de Informações Estratégicas em Vigilância em Saúde, CIEVS).
17
II EMT REGIONAL MEETING OF THE AMERICAS - 2017 REPORT AND RECOMMENDATIONS
Achievements have included the creation of contingency plans for care in public health
emergencies, as well as the standardization of medicine kits and strategic supplies for disaster
relief (20 kits are permanently assembled and available). Brazil’s response teams are made up
of health professionals, volunteers, and medical facility managers, with a minimum staff of 1
physician, 1 nurse, and 2 nursing technicians, as well as mobile hospitals with advanced life
support and intensive care capabilities for treatment and stabilization.
In November 2017, Brazil designated 2 national focal points for the EMT Initiative (oper-
ational and national). Currently, the country is working on a diagnosis of Unified Health
System and FN-SUS (Força Nacional do SUS) regulations that can support the Brazilian
government’s decision to join the EMT Initiative. Also, an assessment is underway of tools,
regulations, and policies that can be adapted for the registration and operation of national
EMTs within the Unified Health System framework. The first training activities for EMTs in
Brazil are scheduled to take place in 2018, with the support of PAHO.
3. Chile
Through 2017, Chile worked on creating regulations or procedures for requesting and deploy-
ing EMTs. As a result, the country now has procedures in place to activate national EMTs. It
has begun to develop procedures with an emphasis on requesting and receiving international
EMTs, involving customs officials, medical professionals, the Office for Cooperation and Inter-
national Affairs (OCAI), and the Institute of Public Health (ISP), among others.
Also in 2017, Chile carried out its first exercise in CICOM capacity-building; the role of
CICOM at the national level was defined as a tool to advise and support the Health EOC at
the national and local levels. In country, the CICOM operates in 3 stages:
• Stage I: Data analysis, including capacities and supply, as well as activation of EMTs.
• Stage II: Receiving and setting up international EMTs and their operations.
Between September 22 and 26, 2015, the SIMEX-INSARAG Simulation Exercise was held
in Santiago, Chile, organized by the National Emergency Office of Chile (ONEMI) and the
Chilean Fire Department, in coordination with the Office for the Coordination of Hu-
manitarian Affairs (OCHA), through the International Search and Rescue Advisory Group
(INSARAG). The national teams that participated included members of the Health EOC, as
well as authorities and representatives from the national level. International EMTs that par-
ticipated in this exercise included teams from Argentina, Cuba, Spain, Costa Rica, and Peru.
Regarding Chile’s resource map, the following achievements are worthy of note:
• Dissemination of the strategy at the national level and joint work with the Armed Forces;
• 900 staff members trained through e-learning (300 in 2016 and 600 in 2017);
18
• 20 health facilities trained in EMT courses through training workshops in 2016 and 2017;
• Supporting documents have been developed to insert the EMT Initiative within the
available resources of the health sector;
• National EMTs were deployed several times in Chile in 2016 and 2017.
During 2018, Chile will work on reaching of an agreement with the Ministry of Defense for
EMT preparedness and response, make draft documents official in the form of resolutions,
implement E-learning to train human resources, carry out training of trainers for EMT
workshops, and develop a logistics workshop for EMTs.
4. Colombia
In Colombia, the EMT Initiative is being implemented within preparedness and integrated
response program that includes emergency preparedness and strengthening of response capacity.
Colombia has four technical documents to support emergency preparedness on the subjects of:
health standards for Colombia’s humanitarian assistance; technical guidelines for health man-
agement and preparedness for events involving mass movement of people; hospital guidelines
for disaster risk prevention (Ministry of Health and Social Protection); and proposed guidelines
for the creation and operation of health teams for disaster response. Colombia also hosted the
SIMEX-INSARAG regional exercise of simulated earthquake response, carried out in Bogotá
on September 26-30, 2016. Regarding response capacity, implementation of the Safe Hospitals
program is a noteworthy achievement.
In June 2017, the municipality of Mocoa, department of Putumayo, suffered severe landslides
and floods which left 398 injured and 332 dead, with significant economic losses and infra-
structure damage. As part of the response, resources, transportation, and supplies were mobi-
lized, with permanent coordination at the national and local levels through the Health EOC
and CICOM. To support the growing demand for health services in the affected communities,
the national EMTs of the Armed Forces, National Police, Colombian Red Cross, Colombian
Civil Air Patrol, María Luisa de Moreno Foundation, and EPS, among others, were deployed.
The national EMTs played an important role in providing comprehensive care in shelters and
responding to outbreaks and epidemics.
One lesson learned by the Colombian government within the framework of implement-
ing this initiative is the value of national EMTs not only during emergencies, but also as
a preventive measure during major events. Two examples that highlight this utility are the
visit of Pope Francis to Colombia and the Peace Process. The first was an event attended by
approximately 4 million people, during which 5,000 support staff and 247 ambulances were
deployed at 200 stations. In total, 1,964 patient encounters and 96 transfers were record-
ed. During the Peace Process, the high concentrations of demobilized personnel in diffi-
cult-to-reach areas revealed a need to deploy personnel to ensure comprehensive health care
in the demobilization zones.
19
II EMT REGIONAL MEETING OF THE AMERICAS - 2017 REPORT AND RECOMMENDATIONS
Colombia is now working on addressing the main challenges of EMT program implemen-
tation. These challenges include: harmonizing the EMT program with the Safe Hospitals
program, harmonizing bimodal teams (contingency teams, PHC-EMT1), ensuring nation-
wide coverage, obtaining national registration and authorization of EMTs, strengthening
capacities, and securing funding to ensure sustainability.
5. Costa Rica
The Ministry of Foreign Affairs and Worship, in coordination with the National Emergen-
cies Commission, is the managing authority for both output (deployment of Costa Rican
cooperation) and input (any international cooperation the country might need to receive). To
coordinate these efforts, the 2011 Manual de procedimientos de Cancillería para la Coor-
dinación de la Asistencia Humanitaria y Técnica en Casos de Desastre [Manual of Foreign
Ministry Procedures for the Coordination of Humanitarian and Technical Assistance in Case of
Disasters] serves as the framework for agile, effective coordination of international humani-
tarian assistance. Implementation of the EMT initiative is adapted to this procedure at the
national level whenever requesting or deploying an EMT.
Likewise, the 2017 Guía Técnica Nacional para la Implementación de la Célula de Información
y Coordinación Médica (CICOM) de los EMTs de Costa Rica [National Technical Guideline
for Implementation of the Costa Rican EMT Medical Information and Coordination Cell
(CICOM)] is undergoing revisions to ensure that responsibility for coordinating the request,
deployment, and reception of national and international EMTs rests with CICOM.
Seeking to strengthen national capacity, in 2017, the Costa Rican Social Security Fund (Caja
Costarricense de Seguro Social, CCSS) provided training opportunities and support to the
health services network of its WHO-classified Type 1 EMT. Examples included deployment
to Ciudad Neilly, Zona Sur (June 2017), and deployment for the provision of medical care
in the Caribbean zone (October 2017). Likewise, CCSS/CAED officials have participated as
facilitators in regional and sub-regional training exercises, and were part of the verification
team for the Type 2 EMT certification process in Ecuador. It should be noted that Costa
Rica hosted the II Regional EMT Coordinators Course, held in August 2016, and the Re-
gional EMT Operational Support Course held in June 2017.
Costa Rica also has practical experience in deployment of its national EMT during emergen-
cies, such as the deployment to Upala in November 2016 in response to Hurricane Otto. In
October 2017, mobile Type 1 EMTs were deployed in response to Tropical Storm Nate.
The national priorities for 2018 are the consolidation of a specialized surgical care unit and
formalization of the technical guideline for CICOM implementation.
20
6. Cuba
Cuba has the Henry Reeve International Contingent of Physicians Specialized in Disaster
Situations and Serious Epidemics, which was established on September 19, 2005. These
all-volunteer brigades are set up in all 16 provinces of the country, and most members have
previous experience in other international missions. The brigades are deployed 24 and 48
hours after the health event.
With the consent of the affected country and according to the origin and magnitude of the
disaster, Cuba activates its national procedure for mobilization of emergency medical bri-
gades, considering the following criteria: the type of brigade to be deployed is selected, based
on the characteristics of the disaster; the necessary medicines and supplies are organized to
ensure provision of care for a minimum of 30 days; and, finally, the brigades are deployed
with the means to ensure their self-sufficiency and survival for 30 days, including water, food,
hygiene supplies, undergarments, and others.
• Implementation of two national workshops for the heads of medical brigades expect-
ed to respond at the national level to a massive earthquake;
Due to several events of great public health impact that occurred both in the Caribbean and
worldwide, Cuba participated in disaster response in 2017, deploying 4 medical brigades:
to Peru in response to floods and heavy rains (23 team members), to Dominica in response
to the effects of Hurricane Maria (42 team members), to Mexico in support of earthquake
response (40 team members), and to Sierra Leone in response to landslides (10 team mem-
bers). The last brigade is still active, at the request of the health authorities of Sierra Leone.
These brigades treated 49,439 patients, 8,736 of which in the field; performed 172 surgical
operations (including 129 major surgeries); 11,370 nursing procedures; and 23,275 edu-
cational activities aimed at promotion and prevention to mitigate the risk of outbreaks of
infectious diseases.
During 2018, Cuba plans to evaluate the composition of its health brigades so they will meet
the standards of the EMT Initiative and can achieve global Classification status. Likewise, it
has requested the establishment and socialization of team composition and structure, medical
equipment, instruments, and supplies as needed to standardize its national EMTs.
21
II EMT REGIONAL MEETING OF THE AMERICAS - 2017 REPORT AND RECOMMENDATIONS
7. Ecuador
In 2016, the members of the Ecuador EMT received their first training, with PAHO support,
only a few days before an earthquake struck on April 16. This training made it easier to apply
EMT response standards after the earthquake while, at the same time, incorporating coordi-
nation tools to medical teams. In the months following the event, the Ministry continued to
adopt WHO standards for personnel, logistics issues, processes, and guidelines at the national
level, which ultimately secured international recognition as Emergency Medical Teams.
On March 31, 2017, at the 10th Meeting of Ministers of Health of the South American
Health Council (CSS) of UNASUR, the Minister of Public Health of Ecuador, Dr. María
Verónica Espinosa, presented the “Declaration on Minimum Standards of Emergency
Medical Teams (EMTs)”, which encouraged the Member States of UNASUR to create and
update national policies or mechanisms to support this type of international assistance and
allow implementation of the EMT Initiative. The commitment also included development
of a national mechanism for the classification and registration of national and international
EMTs; the establishment of customs, migratory, jurisdictional, logistical, and administrative
procedures for the entry, transit, stay, and departure of EMTs and their medicines, devices
and supplies, among others.
From July 2016 to September 2017, Ecuador made progress toward obtaining WHO global
Classification status. This process included the definition of preparatory measures, strength-
ening of human resources, and strengthening, development, and further building of response
capacities. The classification process was supported by the development of supporting docu-
mentation, such as the 2017 “Response by Type 2 EMTs of the Ministry of Public Health of
Ecuador” manual, and supplemented by the design of simplified protocols which take into
account the roles of the Ministry of Foreign Relations and Human Mobility, the Ecuador
Customs Service (SENAE), the Ministry of the Interior, the Ministry of National Defense,
and the Risk Management Secretariat.
Between September 13 and 15, 2017, an international PAHO/WHO mission with experts
from Costa Rica, the United States, and Peru verified compliance with minimum EMT stan-
dards. The experts reviewed process documentation, standards and guidelines for patient care,
administrative and logistical processes, and EMT activation, deployment, and deactivation
protocols. In Guayaquil, they evaluated Mobile Hospitals 1 and 2 and a surgical unit.
As a result, on September 26, 2017, the emergency medical team of the Ministry of Pub-
lic Health of Ecuador became the second in the region of the Americas to receive WHO
verification as part of the EMT Initiative. The Ecuador team is the first in the region of the
Americas to receive this recognition for two Type 2 EMTs and a specialized surgical cell,
which implies, among other things, that it is able to deploy a field hospital, in addition to
providing care.
22
9. Mexico
In the event of emergencies and disasters, Mexico has a government channel to request or
offer humanitarian support from any agency of other countries through the Secretariat of
Foreign Affairs/AMEXCID. Within this Secretariat, the decision to request medical support
rests with the National Committee for Health Security. Recently, the need for a thorough re-
view by all members of the Health Sector of regulations or procedures to request/send EMTs
within the country has been discussed.
Currently, the resource map for Prehospital Emergency Medical Services and EMTs is being
constructed by request to the Technical Subcommittee on Monitoring and Evaluation of the
National Committee for Health Security. The resource map is being made at two levels: at
the state level, with health facilities, and at the federal level, with the institutions that make
up the health sector.
For 2018, Mexico has set itself the goal of integrating the resource map into public health
policies in the field of medical attention. A massive disaster response drill with EMTs is also
being considered, as part of a series of activities in observance of the September 19 earth-
quakes of 1985 and 2017.
10. Panama
In 2017, Panama completed the Activation Manual for the Health EOC, which sets out the
steps to be followed in case when requesting or deploying an EMT at the national level. Top-
ics addressed include standardized first response procedures (ambulances and helicopters),
setting up the primary post, support teams for higher-complexity facilities, and deployment
of advanced resources.
Overall, the EMT Initiative in Panama has the political backing necessary for efficient implemen-
tation. Implementation is an inter-agency process, led by the health sector through the Ministry
of Health, as well as CSS Panama and 911 Medical Emergencies. The initiative is also being
implemented with the support of the National Naval Aviation Service, the National Police, the In-
stitutional Protection Service, the National Border Service, Civil Protection, the Fire Department,
and the Panamanian Red Cross.
In 2017, the first interdisciplinary medical meeting was held, where the national coordinating
team was ratified and coordinators were selected for the medical, surgical, logistics, CICOM,
mental health, and nursing sections within the framework of the EMT Initiative.
23
II EMT REGIONAL MEETING OF THE AMERICAS - 2017 REPORT AND RECOMMENDATIONS
11. Perú
The Ministry of Health has approved a technical document for a health contingency plan in
the event of a large-scale earthquake in Metropolitan Lima and the Lima and Callao regions.
A technical document for the implementation of national EMTs was also developed, which
included a 6-month evaluation of health brigades. One of the most interesting findings of
this evaluation is the interaction and integration of brigades and agencies, which constitutes
the country’s main challenge for implementation of the EMT Initiative.
A budget for the EMT Initiative, approved by ministerial resolution, has been included in
Peru’s 2017-2021 risk reduction plan for earthquakes. Currently, the country has 2,669
first responders operating in brigades at the national level, but the biggest challenge is that
only 30% are doctors. The operational capacity of EMTs in Peru is supported by coordi-
nation between SAMU and DIGERD, whose objectives are rescue and first response/basic
life support.
Regarding response logistics, Peru has seven mobile hospitals currently active in high-risk
areas, and three in reserve. These mobile hospitals are ceded by the Ministry of Health to
affected regions and run by the Ministry or the regional government. Mobile hospitals are
currently active in the Piura, Huarmey-Ancash, Lambayeque, and Andoas regions, which are
difficult to reach and beset by social conflicts. Regulations for the operation of mobile hospi-
tals have recently considered a change in mandate to expand their coverage to itinerant care
in Peru, including a detailed checklist of requirements for implementation; regionalization
has been identified as the main challenge.
Peru has worked on strengthening human resources through capacity building. To date, 6
surgical EMTs have been trained, the equipment available in the country has been reviewed,
and Health EOC staff have been trained on CICOM issues.
In 2018, Peru will continue to work on implementation of the 2017-2021 disaster risk
reduction plan by establishing and strengthening Type 2 and 3 EMTs to supplement its
existing health brigades. Likewise, it will seek to improve the selection of specialized medical
human resources and risk management insurance for health personnel. Finally, directives are
being developed to guide management of field hospitals at the central level and begin their
regionalization.
24
2. Consolidate best practices for the preparation and
readiness of Emergency Medical Teams
During the meeting, key points about self-sufficiency were discussed in an interactive format.
The moderator posed questions to the participants, who started the debate, followed by ques-
tions and remarks from the audience.
During the meeting, challenges that directly affect the readiness of EMTs were discussed and
identified in a series of components: personnel, supply management, deployment, and train-
ing standards. Participants had the opportunity to discuss these issues and identify key areas
where further guidance is needed. As a result, a set of the resources and best practices that
have been useful for overcoming these challenges by regional EMTs was compiled.
Maintaining an up-to-date roster of trained personnel available for deployment is one of the
main challenges facing EMTs in the Americas. Recruitment of volunteers and professionals is
not always done through up-to-date rosters, and information required for deployment is often
incomplete. Online platforms for registration of volunteer and professional staff are limited.
At the time of deployment, health personnel face new obstacles, including insufficient
funding, overtime payments, union relations, as well as limited health, malpractice, and civil
liability insurance coverage. One possible solution was the management of insurance through
countries’ Ministries of Health, or coverage by humanitarian crisis status.
Expiration dates, transport logistics, and receiving-country regulations were identified as the key
challenges for supply management. In the most recent emergencies, EMTs in the Americas have
encountered difficulties in the management of controlled substances, as well as limited private
transportation, reducing the capacity to provide health care to affected communities.
Deployment presents its own risks and challenges, which, if not addressed in a timely manner,
can jeopardize the intention to respond. During the regional meeting, particular attention
was paid to understanding the customs systems and immigration requirements of receiving
countries, as well as the regulations and public policies of the receiving governments. However,
beyond understanding and compliance of these regulations by EMTs, it is important to ensure
25
II EMT REGIONAL MEETING OF THE AMERICAS - 2017 REPORT AND RECOMMENDATIONS
that countries have the political will and legislation in place to clearly
determine regulations for the deployment of humanitarian assistance – and,
specifically, EMTs – in times of crisis.
Member States and other EMT-providing organizations are working to strengthen the cur-
rent capabilities of their national EMTs so that they are aligned with global EMT standards.
Although logistical capacity may be somewhat flexible for those who respond at the national
level as compared to those who deploy internationally, clinical care standards must remain
the same for everyone.
• Technical documents necessary for EMT accreditation in the languages of the Region;
• How to reconcile minimum standards with the particular needs of each country
or region;
• How to follow the example of other countries that are implementing the initiative;
• Lists of essential medicines and medical equipment, specifying type and quantity;
• Logistics.
26
Tools used by the EMTs of the Americas to address these challenges
• Establish a unified clinical practice guideline platform that makes it possible to follow
a single model;
2. Water supply
All EMTs must carry drinking water treatment and access systems, which must be flexible enough
to adapt to the different circumstances that may arise during missions. This can range from receiv-
ing drinking water in tanks for storage and use (where both quality analysis and safe storage would
have to be ensured), to purifying surface water or water from nearby sources (which would require
pumping, pre-treatment, and purification, followed by storage and distribution to the various
EMT facilities as needed), ensuring at all times the water is not contaminated and that it can be
used for drinking and hospital use. This entails several treatment steps. Multiple systems and op-
tions are available for this process, depending on the capacity and budget of the EMT; these range
27
II EMT REGIONAL MEETING OF THE AMERICAS - 2017 REPORT AND RECOMMENDATIONS
from flocculation to reverse osmosis, ultraviolet irradiation, and ultrafiltration to ensure that the
treated water meets minimum quality standards. Calculation of water demand will also determine
how purification should be approached with one system or another.
Calculation of water demand should follow WHO standards,4 augmented by Sphere project
guidelines5 and whichever interpretation of quality each team wishes to provide. Table 1 presents
an example of water demand calculated by the Spanish Technical Aid Response Team (START)
team on the basis of analysis of water consumption by its Type 2 EMT, taking into account that
production capacity is sufficient and the sanitation system will consist of pour-flush toilets (which
require approximately 5 L water per use):
4 Logistical Support to FMTs. In: Classification and Minimum Standards for Foreign Medical Teams in Sudden Onset Disasters (“The
Blue Book”). p. 84. Geneva: WHO; 2013. http://www.who.int/water_sanitation_health/emergencies/WHO_TN_09_How_
much_water_is_needed.pdf?ua=1
Water, Engineering, and Development Centre (WEDC). WHO technical notes on drinking-water, sanitation and hygiene in
emergencies, 2011 [cited 2012 2 November].
5 The Sphere Handbook: Humanitarian Charter and Minimum Standards in Humanitarian Response. Available from: http://www.
sphereproject.org/handbook/
28
3. Sanitation
The core tenet here is that teams must also be flexible when it comes to sanitation solutions.
A mobile Type 1 EMT must ensure sanitation for its team at the base camp and when going
into communities. Sanitation solutions for patients at outpatient clinics can be considered,
but in many cases, when an EMT travels to a community, it will use the sanitation system
that is regularly available to the community. In this context, mobile sanitation solutions for
teams include portable chemical toilets or individual bags containing a chemical solution that
convert both liquid and solid waste into common waste. These are effective, but quite expen-
sive. Simple latrines can be used at base camp, as long as their quality is assured and measures
are taken to reduce environmental impact.
In the case of a fixed Type 1 EMT, consideration must also be given to patients who will
present to the hospital during its open hours; sanitation solutions should provide for their
needs as well. Several solutions are available, from portable chemical toilets (for instance,
if the emergency has occurred in the Team’s own country, destruction has not been very
significant, cleaning/waste collection are still a possibility, and deployment time is limited) to
latrines as a semi-permanent solution.
Type 2 EMTs must take many more elements into account but hewing to the same idea of
flexibility and adaptability to the different conditions that may be encountered during field
hospital deployment. The first element to consider is that they will have many more patients
than an Type 1 EMT, and everyone will have sanitation needs. At least 100 outpatients
should be expected (along with people accompanying them), 20 inpatients (not all of them
will be able to use the facilities) and people accompanying them, and, finally, personnel. Sec-
ond, a gender perspective must be considered (this can and should be supported) and bath-
rooms may need to be adapted accordingly, if the EMT so decides (this is not mandatory,
but is recommended). In addition, the reduced mobility of some patients (both outpatients
and inpatients) must be considered. Finally, the method to be used should be appropriate to
the context. The same criteria can be followed as for an Type 1 EMT in terms of the systems
to be used, from chemical toilets to latrines.
29
II EMT REGIONAL MEETING OF THE AMERICAS - 2017 REPORT AND RECOMMENDATIONS
4. Waste management
This is an especially important issue in an EMT, because of the amount and variety of waste
generated. Medical waste must be separated and disposed of in accordance with international
guidelines on waste management/disposal. Within the structure of the field hospital, there
should be a specific area for management of the different wastes generated by activity of the
EMT. It is recommended that waste be sorted as follows:
On waste management issues, it is important to rely on the support of the national authori-
ties as far as possible, so that waste collection and disposal can proceed as is usually done for
waste from the national health system. But, once again, following the principle of self-suf-
ficiency, EMTs must be prepared to carry out comprehensive management of all wastes
produced by the field hospital. The following stages must be taken into account:
• Secure system for waste collection and transport to the EMT’s storage site;
Several different systems, with different cost profiles, are available for the process of waste
destruction; from the incineration system proposed by Ecuador (100% self-made by the
logistics team and based on a crude oil drum) to the more expensive and sophisticated
incineration system presented by Spain to the waste compaction system recently acquired
by Costa Rica.
30
5. Fuel and electric power (consumption and EMT zones)
Combining the answers to the two preceding questions, electricity consumption and fuel
consumption go hand in hand. Different systems are available for each type of EMT, from
the lowest consumption (Type 1 EMT that requires only lighting and some limited equip-
ment and has no air-conditioning systems) up to the level of Costa Rica, which has cli-
mate-control capacity for all EMT facilities, from treatment tents to staff living quarters. It
is essential to know how much electricity will be needed, in order to design each zone and
select the necessary components (connectors, panels, cables and wiring by type, safety, and
distance to generators). Furthermore, not only baseline consumption but the possibility of
surges or peaks in consumption must also be considered. At certain specific times of day,
such as when EMT clinical facilities are operating at full capacity and some essential services
(such as a water treatment plant, air conditioning, and high-power machinery) are also run-
ning, power consumption can peak. Regarding high-power machinery, the surges in power
consumption that can be produced by X-ray machines or autoclaves must be taken into par-
ticular account. All of these factors must be considered when deciding on an electricity gen-
eration system and the fuel consumption thereof. Likewise, a fallback or backup system must
be available in case the main system fails, including several generators, of different capacities
if possible, to ensure that mission-critical sections of the EMT, i.e., those that must never run
out of power (emergency ward, operating room, sterilization facility, etc.), are always online.
Concerning fuel, the first step is to ensure a supply system in the field, as it is difficult and
expensive to be self-sufficient in this regard. In nearly all deployments, both internation-
al and domestic, fuel supply is provided on site. Therefore, economic and administrative
mechanisms must be in place for EMTs to obtain the necessary systems (including security
measures) for proper fuel storage.
31
II EMT REGIONAL MEETING OF THE AMERICAS - 2017 REPORT AND RECOMMENDATIONS
Formulas based on the Blue Book standards are helpful, but should be
supplemented by other, common sense-based calculations. The following
example is based on SURGICAL CARE provided by a Type 2 EMT:
1. Dialysis.
A standard definition is required for care of acute dialysis needs during disasters. To arrive at
such a definition, the complexity of events in prior disasters must first be recognized, as well
as the opportunities to provide effective clinical care to dialysis-dependent patients affected by
disasters. In general, the goal is to prevent dialysis and reduce complications. Depending on
the type of disaster, dialysis will be needed for crush injuries, acute kidney injury of various
etiologies (including infection and dehydration), and acute-on-chronic renal failure. The base
population that requires this type of treatment includes those with end-stage renal disease, those
on peritoneal dialysis, and those with chronic kidney disease.
The renal management team should ideally be made up of a nephrologist, a hemodialysis nurse,
a peritoneal dialysis nurse, pediatricians, internists, a vascular surgeon, a nursing technician, a
WASH engineer, a logistics technician, a security officer, and a team leader. Essential elements
32
for dialysis include water, sanitation, electric power, the dialysis machine itself, and special
supplies as needed.
In the context of the most recent experience, the deployment of a specialized dialysis cell in
response to Hurricane Maria in Dominica, developing a specific skillset for renal care was iden-
tified as being key to effective and efficient care.
The amount of water that might be needed to facilitate hemodialysis during such an emergency
was estimated as follows:
Prior to deployment of the specialized dialysis cell to Dominica, the EMT conducted a
needs assessment based on the information obtained through communications with PAHO
and Virtual OSOCC, supplementing information gaps with the experience gained during
the response to Hurricane Matthew. The team was equipped for 2 weeks of self-sufficiency,
including security, shelter, communications, food, a water purification system, and personal
health supplies.
Work was divided into two teams, with the second arriving to relieve the first after 2 weeks of
operations. Both teams participated actively in coordination meetings, which facilitated work
during the most critical weeks of the emergency. In addition to these meetings, the teams
benefited from communication with other medical specialties and NGOs that responded
to the emergency, achieving integrated management of the most common complications.
Regarding medical care, the team focused on standardization of dialysis care through PPE,
clinical management, and available guidelines. Standardization made it possible to treat an
average of 20 patients per day, train health personnel and patients on critical issues to meet
the needs of the target population and implement dialysis rounds.
The challenges identified were due to causes directly or not directly related to the nature of
the disaster. Challenges directly related to the disaster included the unavailability of labora-
tory facilities, medical complications, illnesses related to lack of water/food or infections, a
33
II EMT REGIONAL MEETING OF THE AMERICAS - 2017 REPORT AND RECOMMENDATIONS
greater number of patients versus a limited number of resources, and loss of documentation.
Challenges not directly associated with the disaster included a lack of local nephrologists and
vascular surgeons, lack of vascular access in certain patients, and lack of specialized training
for support staff.
2. Surgery
The process of surgical care during emergencies begins during the first response provided by
the USAR team to the patient, or patient arrival to the EMT facility, and continues through
the stabilization and transfer phases on to definitive treatment and ends with the rehabilita-
tion phase. For EMTs, 90% of the overall burden of surgical care is related to management of
injuries to extremities. In this sense, surgical teams must be prepared to take care of patients
from triage through to definitive care, following protocols to work with what means are
available and prevent secondary damage, considering the different curative possibilities of
each EMT type.
EMTs with operating rooms must have sufficient space, protocols, supplies, and equipment
to ensure satisfactory OR management, including support services: physical space and
equipment, circulation, clothing, cleaning, sterilization, waste management, airflow, electri-
cal power, etc. In this sense, it is essential that EMTs follow evidence-based protocols, since
their work is carried out under austere conditions and in the absence of a local hospital-based
support infrastructure. Moreover, given that EMTs can only mobilize a limited number of
human and physical resources, the use of evidence-based protocols helps minimize the possi-
bility of postoperative complications while ensuring greater benefits to the team and patients,
reducing secondary damage and preventing malpractice.
During the regional workshop on surgical care in austere conditions, held in Lima, Peru, the
following evidence-based practices were identified and discussed:
• Patient: The patient and surgical site should be prepared, taking three factors into
account: the patient’s skin, the providers’ skin, and the surgical field, considering
general perioperative care.
• Airflow in the operating room: It is essential to control the direction and character-
istics of the air circulating in the operating room. “Sterilizing” the air in the operating
room (with ultraviolet light or “ultraclean” air systems) has no influence on surgical
infection rates. Air entry into the operating room of a Type 3 EMT must be preceded
by an adequate filtration process, which should retain 30% in the first filter and 90%
in the second filter (99.97% for a HEPA system). Air must flow from the ceiling in a
vertical direction toward the floor and flow out at floor level, since the vast majority of
particulate matter is located at lower levels. The operating room should be under posi-
tive pressure, and ventilation systems should ensure at least 15 air changes per hour.
34
specific circulation corridors reduces bacterial colony counts. However, this has no
impact on infection rates. This may be due to the fact that the environment is not
the main source of microorganisms involved in surgical infections. These findings are
compounded by the fact that increased contamination of the floors of the operating
theater does not contribute much to contamination of the circulating air or health
personnel, which are the main sources of external microorganisms. As the circulation
of personnel does not contribute significantly to the transfer of microorganisms from
the floor to the air and/or to the personnel themselves, the use of shoe covers does
not seem to be justified except to protect providers’ personal footwear, rather than to
avoid environmental contamination. Increased movement of personnel near the surgi-
cal field, however, does increase the number of microorganisms in said area. It is thus
essential to limit circulation within the operating room. Consequently, it is important
that all of the necessary supplies be available in the room before starting surgery.
• Cleaning of contaminated rooms and patients: Several studies have shown that
strict cleaning of operating room floors and walls reduces the number of microorgan-
isms, but only temporarily; 2 hours after cleaning, bacterial counts are the same as
before. These publications conclude that routine disinfection of OR a floor is not an
epidemiologically justifiable practice, nor is its cost/benefit ratio significant.
• Equipment and supplies: OR equipment can be used in other areas of the hospital,
and vice versa, without increased risk of infection. There is no evidence that masks
and shoe covers have any impact on surgical infection rates. It is recommended that
powder-free gloves be worn and changed systematically every 2 hours of surgery or
when torn or pierced, whichever comes first. To ensure rational use of medicines, an-
tibiotic prophylaxis should be administered within 120 minutes prior to the incision
and should not be extended for more than 24 hours postoperatively. All dirty clothes
and linens should be bagged and labeled inside the operating room before transfer.
• Waste: Waste incineration has long been a widespread practice, but if it is incomplete
or if unsuitable materials are incinerated, pollutants and residual ash are released into
the atmosphere. If chlorinated products are incinerated, they can release dioxins and
furans, substances that are carcinogenic to humans and have been associated with
various health effects. The incineration of heavy metals or products with high metal
content (particularly lead, mercury, and cadmium) can disseminate toxic metals into
the environment. Only modern incinerators that operate at temperatures between
850 and 1100°C and have a special flue-gas cleaning system can meet international
emissions standards for dioxins and furans. There are now alternative solutions to in-
cineration, such as autoclaving or microwave sterilization, steam treatment combined
with agitation of treated materials, or chemical treatment
35
II EMT REGIONAL MEETING OF THE AMERICAS - 2017 REPORT AND RECOMMENDATIONS
The best location for the X-ray area is near the emergency, resusci-
tation, and inpatient wards. The chosen location and arrangement
should facilitate good climate control to ensure that radiological
equipment is in good working order.
radiology area
4. Blood transfusion
Blood transfusion during emergency response operations is indicated in the event of Grade
III and IV hemorrhagic shock, in hemostatic resuscitation, in damage control surgery, in
exchange transfusion, and in patients requiring red blood cell transfusion when red blood
cell concentrates are not available. In this context, blood transfusion is contraindicated in
patients with chronic anemia and in patients requiring massive transfusion of stored blood.
Blood obtained by EMTs during the deployment must meet the following quality standards:
no separation from its components when extracted; addition of a preservative and anticoagu-
lant solution (CPDA); and no further processing. Whole blood must be collected, screened,
and processed to the following standards:
• Content: Hct 35-44%, Hb 12.5 g/dL, stable clotting factors and plasma proteins.
36
4. Strengthen coordination, deployment,
and operations during emergency response
After the devastating 2010 earthquake in Haiti, the health cluster estimated that 420 orga-
nizations were participating in response in the country as of December 2010. Despite this
massive influx of international organizations deployed to provide assistance, they had little
involvement with national organizations, local authorities, and civil society, leading in some
cases to duplication of efforts and parallel structures.
Until recently, there was a lack of agreement on minimum standards and supervisory mecha-
nisms. Both situations led to a major problem during emergency operations: How to handle
a significant but unknown number of international actors traveling and deploying locally,
often ignoring the government’s decision not to request assistance, as well as improvised,
poorly prepared and/or poorly equipped medical teams, and even outright incompetent
medical teams.
At the national level, if the host country takes no formal position as to requesting and
accepting EMTs, this may be interpreted as tacit approval for their deployment. That is why
governments must specify under which conditions EMTs will be accepted, if at all, and what
will happen if the entry of certain teams is unwanted or deemed unacceptable. Only the
authorities of the affected country have the legal capacity and mandate to accept or reject
EMTs. No international organization, regardless of its technical or operational quality, can
effectively replace local authorities.
At the international level, there are a number of treaties, resolutions, codes, and models
seeking to regulate the provision of international disaster relief. However, this internation-
al regulatory framework also has its shortcomings. First, some of the relevant treaties have
few signatory parties and, therefore, a limited geographical scope. Many other treaties only
address one type of disaster or one type of international actor (usually only states). More
importantly, there is a lack of awareness of existing instruments, and they are not used to the
extent that would be expected.
In 2007, the 30th International Conference of the Red Cross and Red Crescent adopted, by
consensus, a new series of “Guidelines for the domestic facilitation and regulation of inter-
national disaster relief and initial recovery assistance” (also known as the IDRL Guidelines).
The IDRL Guidelines are not binding. They are global in scope, relevant for state and non-
state actors, for all response sectors, and for all types of disasters (except armed conflicts).
They serve as recommendations to governments on how to prepare national legal frameworks
for international disaster assistance, to avoid the most common problems and facilitate the
rapid delivery of relief and assistance for the initial recovery of those affected by natural disas-
ters. The IDRL Guidelines also recommend that the granting of any package of legal facilities
37
II EMT REGIONAL MEETING OF THE AMERICAS - 2017 REPORT AND RECOMMENDATIONS
must be conditional upon compliance with the eligibility requirements established by the
affected recipient state, as well as adherence to minimum humanitarian standards.
In this sense, the eligibility of EMTs is to be determined using the international classifica-
tion system, based on minimum standards, with a view to improving the quality of medical
response. However, national registration mechanisms need to be established within countries
to make it easier for governments to monitor the continuing obligation of EMTs to comply
with these standards.
Pre-deployment considerations
Ideally, the decision to offer or request EMTs should be based on evidence that provide an un-
derstanding of the scenario as quickly as possible, e.g., identify needs for clinical care, ascertain
the capacity of the existing health services, and detect gaps in care that must be bridged. How-
ever, the great heterogeneity of criteria makes optimal decision-making difficult. In any case,
EMTs must meet the following criteria before deploying to an affected country:
1. Respect national decisions to accept EMTs. Always wait for formal request by the
affected State.
2. Before offering to deploy, consider the factors that influence acceptance of EMTs,
such as prior experience during similar events, institutional sources of trust, and
capacity for mass casualties.
3. Adhere to the minimum guiding principles and standards for EMTs defined by
PAHO/WHO.
38
Considerations during deployment and medical care
In all countries, the medical profession is subject to general licensing as well as specific accred-
itation of medical specialties. Unfortunately, some humanitarian teams are in a legal gray area
in terms of their medical practice and responsibility. Few countries have taken legal steps to
provide temporary licenses or adopt a positive legal interpretation of the laws: New Zealand
(2011) and Japan (2011), for example, granted access to carefully selected partners for whom
the risk of negligence was considered acceptably small. In Nepal (2015), the normal process
for international health personnel to obtain a temporary license from the Medical Council of
Nepal was suspended, and the Ministry of Health and Population required health technicians
to simply present a copy of their passport together with a copy of their professional medical li-
cense. Through this process, team members were granted a temporary license to work as health
professionals for 30 days (renewable upon request), if and only if they practiced medicine
within their EMT and in line with their training.
Other important considerations during the deployment and medical practice in an affected
country include going through customs and immigration procedures, in which involvement
of the local authorities is required for expedited clearance. It is also important to establish an
entry register with prior accreditation, consideration of logistical aspects that ensure complete
self-sufficiency, and the carry of professional accreditation licenses.
The Medical Information and Coordination Cell (CICOM) supports the Health EOC on
decision-making to ensure the provision of clinical care and an efficient response by EMTs,
facilitates management of information on EMTs, simplifies case management and patient
transfers, and monitors compliance with EMT principles and standards. The CICOM also
had the additional role of a flexible national mechanism for registration of national EMTs.
CICOM roles and functions within the Health EOC are organized around the phases of
health sector preparedness and response to emergencies and disasters. During the prepared-
ness phase, CICOM registers, verifies, and carries out a nationwide mapping of EMTs.
When responding to emergencies and disasters, CICOM takes on the role of a contact
center, which facilitates coordination through technical support, operations support, and
information management. Figure 2 illustrates these roles and their organizational structures:
39
II EMT REGIONAL MEETING OF THE AMERICAS - 2017 REPORT AND RECOMMENDATIONS
PREPAREDNESS R E S P O N S E
COORDINATION
CONTACT CENTER
When implementing a CICOM at a Health EOC, it is important to set the mandate that will
establish it as a flexible mechanism for EMT coordination and registration. This mandate is
executed through supporting regulations, structures with set roles and functions, a roster of
professionals, standardized procedures, infrastructure, and resources. Once implemented, the
CICOM life cycle begins with the preparedness phase, followed by activation, operations, and
transition, and ends with the demobilization phase. The CICOM life cycle begins anew once
EMT demobilization has been completed.
The value added by CICOM during the preparedness stage lies in the fact that the registration
process allows identification of the specific capabilities of national EMTs and of the resources
available to ensure clinical care. This translates into a more timely and efficient response while
improving coordination mechanisms, strengthening information management for deci-
sion-making, and facilitating support of international EMTs.
During the Haiti earthquake, multiple problems were encountered during clinical care of the
victims, starting when they were found in the rubble and continuing throughout the process
of extrication, on-site stabilization, and transportation, and persisting even into definitive
care. A large number of rescue teams—most of them uncertified and without clearly defined
clinical care procedures—had only minimal resources for prehospital care and transportation,
and limited infrastructure for patient intake and definitive care. This was compounded by a
preexisting lack of coordination in prehospital care, emergency care, and definitive treatment,
resulting in discontinuity of care for patients.
40
In this type of disaster, USAR teams involved in search and rescue operations play a key
role in promotion and implementation of the International Search and Rescue Operations
Advisory Group (INSARAG) guidelines. These guidelines divide USAR operations into five
components, including a medical component, and define the scope of medical interventions:
care for the USAR team members themselves and for located victims until their transfer to
local health facilities. However, in light of recent emergencies that have required intervention
by these teams, a gap has been identified regarding how to ensure a comprehensive response
that allows proper transport of rescued victims to the EMT or to the local health facility that
is best prepared to meet their medical needs.
In this line, it bears stressing that each country has an existing prehospital care system with
which rescue services and EMTs will have to interact to ensure continuity of care. There is no
one-size-fits-all formula, as each country’s health system is built upon a unique legal frame-
work and has different resources available for transportation, medical care, and coordination.
Despite its importance, the role of this system has not been sufficiently visible.
Implementation of the EMT Initiative helps close gaps in clinical care during disaster and
emergency response, but simultaneously introduces a new actor into this already complicated
scenario. The challenge lies in local, national, and regional initiatives to facilitate organization
of the different actors involved in humanitarian health response, with the aim of ensuring a
coordinated transition between each of these links in the chain of care.
To overcome the current challenge, two hurdles must be addressed from the coordination
and individual points of view. In terms of coordination, the clinical management of USAR
medicine, prehospital medicine, and care provided by the EMT and at the definitive hospital
must be integrated into a clinical guideline constructed consensually among the three actors
involved in the chain of care. Individually, each of these three actors carries out their activities
in a completely different field, with different levels of risk, and must thus rely on different
equipment, training, and optimal conditions to meet their individual objectives. Comple-
mentarity should be sought, rather than one group adapting to take over another’s functions.
Each country is responsible for implementing and disseminating a protocol for communi-
cation and coordination among official structures and the structures made available through
international cooperation mechanisms.
41
II EMT REGIONAL MEETING OF THE AMERICAS - 2017 REPORT AND RECOMMENDATIONS
1. Training
• Establish collaborative working groups, with the participation of focal points from
the Region, to strengthen Initiative standards and evaluate the benefits obtained.
• Develop a tool to facilitate data analysis and sharing of best practices and les-
sons learned.
2. Human Resources
3. Logistics
• Strengthen training in logistics and define logistics coordination standards that cover
medicines, equipment, and other key resources necessary during emergency response.
• Develop flexible registry mechanisms with criteria for acceptance prior to a disaster.
42
• Establish a quick-reference repository of individual country requirements, so that
EMTs can be up to date on the requirements they need to meet in anticipation of
potential deployments. This recommendation requires inter-institutional consensus
with other relevant ministries.
• Establish CICOMs within existing national structures by defining roles and responsi-
bilities, SOPs, use of the Virtual CICOM tool, and training.
43
II EMT REGIONAL MEETING OF THE AMERICAS - 2017 REPORT AND RECOMMENDATIONS
Presentation of posters
during regional meeting
44
Decisions of the
Regional Group
of the Americas
Costa Rica was named First Vice-Chair, and Panama, Second Vice-Chair of the Regional Group.
To date, Ecuador, Costa Rica, and Panama have had their appointments ratified by PAHO.
a. Structure
The sole criterion for membership in the NGO Advisory Group is to be an organization in
the process of obtaining EMT classification. The Group is also open to National Red Cross
Societies in the region.
A chair will be appointed for the Advisory Group. This person will coordinate with other sec-
tions of the Regional Group to define the roles, reports, and periodicity of meetings expected of
the Advisory Group.
45
II EMT REGIONAL MEETING OF THE AMERICAS - 2017 REPORT AND RECOMMENDATIONS
b. Objectives
The work of the NGO Advisory Group is based on 6 objectives defined at the 2nd Regional
Meeting:
2. Define the main objective of the NGO Advisory Group. This objective should be-
come a method for communicating, sharing best practices, and facilitating implemen-
tation of documents.
3. Identify the connection and level of participation of the NGO Advisory Group
with other NGOs in Latin America and the Caribbean. This objective is proposed
because the group is currently constituted of organizations from the United States
and Canada alone.
5. Establish connections with the health cluster, other NGOs, and Member States.
Plenary Regional
Meeting
46
c. Logistics
Cydney Justman of Direct Relief was named Logistics Focal Point for the NGO Advisory
Group.
d. Leadership
Hillary Cranmer of the Massachusetts General Hospital was appointed Coordinator of the
NGO Advisory Group.
Cydney Justman of Direct Relief was named Deputy Coordinator and, as noted above, Lo-
gistics Focal Point for the NGO Advisory Group.
e. Training
The group will work on identifying courses available free of charge in the Region, and will
determine the best practices that make training processes more effective and efficient.
f. Personnel
There was discussion of the possibility of sharing trained personnel among NGOs during emer-
gencies that, due to their nature and context, require medical specialties of limited availability.
However, when analyzing this possibility, it is important to consider the responsibilities and
risks to organizations and their personnel when providing personnel for deployment.
The Group reached the conclusion that more information is required, and that this option
should be evaluated in light of experiences from past emergencies.
7. Information management
A database of guidelines will be established (e.g., lists of the basic supplies and minimum
requirements needed for different contexts).
47
II EMT REGIONAL MEETING OF THE AMERICAS - 2017 REPORT AND RECOMMENDATIONS
>>> Continue
48
Country National Focal Point Operational Focal Point PAHO Focal Point
Guatemala Francisco Ardon Francisco Theissen Orellana Virginia Herzig
Risk Unit Hospital Coordination [email protected]
Ministry of Health Ministry of Health
[email protected] [email protected]
Guyana Zulfikar Bux Dhaneshwar Deonarine
National EMS Medical Director [email protected]
Ministry of Public Health
[email protected]
Honduras Eduardo Ortiz
[email protected]
Haiti Jimmy Marie Chenier Beaubrun Chantal Calvel
Director, Medical and Health Emergency [email protected]
Management Unit Ministry of Public
Health and Population
[email protected]
Jamaica Jacqueline Bisasor-Mckenzie
Director, Emergency Disaster Manage-
ment and Special Services
Ministry of Health
[email protected]
Mexico Jesús Felipe González Roldan Alejandro López Samano Tamara Mancero
General Director, CENAPRECE Director, Epidemiological Emergencies and [email protected]
Health Secretariat Disasters Health Secretariat
[email protected] [email protected]
Nicaragua Eduardo vado Mayorga Oscar Vásquez Vado Guillermo Gonzalvez
Coordinator, Technical Liaison Unit Director for Hospitals [email protected]
Ministry of Health Ministry of Health José Luis Perez
[email protected] [email protected] [email protected]
Panama Rolando Luque Nuñez Marilyn Thompson
Coordinator, Emergency Center [email protected]
Ministry of Health
[email protected]
Paraguay Ricardo Torres
[email protected]
Peru Mónica Meza Celso Bambaren
Deputy Minister for Public Health [email protected]
Ministry of Public Health
[email protected]
Dominican José Luis Cruz Raposo Edwin Olivares Lizbeth Parra
Republic Director, Risk Management and Disaster Deputy Director, Emergency Operations [email protected]
Response Ministry of Health Center Ministry of Health
[email protected] [email protected]
St. Vincent Simon Keizer Beache Donna Joyette Bascombe
and the Medical Director Health Emergencies Coordinator
Grenadines Ministry of Health, Wellness, and the Ministry of Health, Wellness, and the Envi-
Environment ronment
[email protected] [email protected]
Uruguay Raquel Rosa Nuria Santana Ricardo Rodriguez
Director-General of Health Technical Advisor, Ministry of Public Health [email protected]
Ministry of Health Ministry of Health
[email protected] [email protected]
Venezuela Maribel Mejia Peña Nelsky Julio López Gutiérrez Hector Ojeda
Director-General for Evaluation of the Coordinator of Emergency and Disaster [email protected]
Comprehensive Health Network Epidemiology
Ministry of People’s Power for Health Ministry of People’s Power for Health
[email protected] [email protected]
49
PREPAREDNESS