English 2 PDF
English 2 PDF
English 2 PDF
Ending AIDS
THAILAND AIDS RESPONSE PROGRESS REPORT
2015
คณะกรรมการแหง่ ชาติ วา่ ดว้ ยการป้องกั นและแกไ้ ขปัญหาเอดส ์ NATIONAL AIDS COMMITTEE
2015
T
HAILAND
AIDS R
ESPONSE
R
EPORT
Reporting Period: Fiscal Year of 2014
P
ROGRESS
Introduction
Thailand has joined the commitment to the 2011 UN General Assembly Special Session on HIV to
prevent and control the AIDS epidemic and pursue the strategy of 3 Zeroes: (1) Zero HIV new infection;
(2) Zero AIDS death; and (3) Zero AIDS stigma and discrimination. The Thailand National Strategic Plan
of HIV (2014-16) has set the 2016 targets to reduce new HIV infection by two-third, peri-natal
transmission rate less than 2%, AIDS related deaths reduced by half, and discrimination to key
populations and people living with HIV reduced by half. The National AIDS Committee (NAC) further
approved the policy of ending AIDS epidemic in Thailand by 2030 as the national priority on November
28, 2014, and directed all related agencies at the national and sub- national level to mobilize efforts to
achieving the objectives. In addition, Thailand has developed key measures and the operational plan for
2015-19 to support the ending AIDS policy. The measures have applied strategies of test and treat
regardless of CD4 level with the focus to most affected areas and populations
This report is the product of active and participatory collaboration of government and non- government
agencies, civil society organizations, academia, international agencies, and representatives of key
populations and the Thailand Network of Positive People (TNP+) during fiscal year of 2014.
Representatives from these agencies and individuals reviewed, analyzed and discussed the latest data on
indicator targets as a basis for the findings reported herein. This progress report has been acknowledged
by the NAC Sub-committee on Strategic Information.
I
Contents
Introduction I
Contents II
Table and Figure III
Acronyms IV
Summary 2015 Thailand Global AIDS Response Progress Report 6
1. Overview of the AIDS Epidemic 7
2. Thailand National AIDS Strategy and Responses during 2014 9
3. Country Progress
Target 1: Reduce sexual transmission of HIV 11
Target 2: Reduce transmission of HIV among people who inject drugs 21
Target 3: Eliminate mother-to-child transmission of HIV 25
Target 4: Reach universal access to quality antiretroviral therapy 28
Target 5: Reduce tuberculosis-related deaths for PLHIV 31
Target 6: Close the resource gaps 33
Target 7: Eliminate gender inequalities and gender-based abuse and violence and
increase capacity of women and girls to protect themselves from HIV
36
Target 8: Eliminate stigma and discrimination against PLHIV and the affected 40
Target 9: Eliminate travel restriction 42
Target10: Strengthen HIV integration 43
4. Summary Tables of GARP Indicators for all targets between 2009 and 2014 45
II
Table and Figure
Table 1 Key figures of HIV estimation in Thailand 7
Figure 1 Estimated new HIV infections in adult population based on the current
response
8
Figure 2 Estimated AIDS-related deaths based on the current response 8
Figure 3 Framework of the National AIDS Strategic Plan (2014-16) and Operational
Plan to End AIDS (2015-19) 10
Figure 4 Percentage (%) of people who inject drugs who reported using sterile
injecting equipment the last time they injected 10
Figure 5 Percentage (%) of people who inject drugs that have received an HIV test
in the past 12 months and know their results 22
Figure 6 Percentage of adults and children with HIV currently receiving
antiretroviral therapy
29
III
Acronyms
AEM: AIDS epidemic model AIDS: Acquired immunodeficiency syndrome ANC: Antenatal care ART:
Antiretroviral therapy ARV: Antiretroviral drugs ASO: AIDS-response Standard Organization BATS:
Bureau of AIDS, TB and STIs BOE: Bureau of Epidemiology BSS: Behavioral surveillance survey DDC:
Department of Disease Control DIC: Drop-in center DOC: Department of Corrections DOH: Department
of Health EWI: Early warning indicators FSW: Female sex workers Global Fund: Global Fund to Fight
AIDS, Tuberculosis and Malaria HIV: Human immunodeficiency virus HLM: High level meeting HSS:
HIV sentinel sero-surveillance HTC: HIV testing and counseling IBBS: Integrated biological and
behavioral surveillance IPSR: Institute of Population and Social Research KAP: Key affected population
KPI: Key performance indicator LAO: Local administrative organization M&E: Monitoring and
evaluation MHW: Migrant health worker MW: Migrant worker MICS: Multiple indicator cluster survey
MMT: Methadone maintenance therapy MOL: Ministry of Labour MOPH: Ministry of Public Health
MSDHS: Ministry of Social Development and Human Security MSM: Men who have sex with men
MSW: Male sex workers NAC: National AIDS Committee NAMC: National AIDS Management Center
NAP: National AIDS Program: Database program for antiretroviral treatment of NHSO NAPHA:
National access to antiretroviral drug for people living with HIV and AIDS NAS: National AIDS strategy
NASP: National AIDS strategic plan NCPI: National commitment and policy instrument NGO:
Non-governmental organization NHSO: National Health Security Office
IV
NSO: National Statistical Office PCM: Provincial coordinating mechanism PCR: Polymerase chain
reaction PHAMIT: The project entitled: Prevention of HIV and AIDS among Migrant Workers PHIMS:
Peri-natal HIV information monitoring system PICT: Provider initiated counseling and testing PLHIV:
People living with HIV and AIDS PMTCT: Prevention of mother-to-child HIV transmission PWID:
People who inject drugs RDS: Respondent driven sampling RIHIS: Routine integrated HIV information
system STI: Sexually transmitted infection TB: Tuberculosis TBCA: Thailand Business Coalition on
AIDS TG: Transgender people TNP+: Thai Network of People Living with HIV/AIDS TUC: Thailand
MOPH-US CDC Collaboration UNAIDS: Joint United Nations Programme on HIV/AIDS UNGASS:
United Nations General Assembly Special Session on HIV/AIDS UNHCR United Nations High
Commissions for Refugees UNICEF: United Nations Children’s Fund UN Woman United Nations Entity
for Gender Equality and the Empowerment of Women USAID: United States Agency for International
Development VCT: Voluntary counseling and testing WHO: World Health Organization
V
Summary: 2015 Thailand Global AIDS Response Progress Report
Target 1: Progress has been made but the scale and coverage are not enough to reach targets and have the desired impacts
particularly in MSM and TG. More effort and resources are needed to rapidly expand the re-designed services and approaches to
reach 90-90-90 targets in key population. Adjustment of HIV interventions to address specific needs and/or context is needed for
non-Thais, young key population, and non-venue based key populations.
Target 2: There has been progress on policy with better political support for harm reduction programs. While the drug use
situation is fast evolving and diverse, harm reduction services, including opioid substitution therapy, and needle/syringe programs
have to be rapidly implemented and addressed the needs of the local context.
Target 3: Thailand can be among the one of the first countries in the world to eliminate mother-to- child transmission of HIV.
The MTCT rate was 2.1% in 2014, thus achieving the target ahead of the national target date. Validation towards elimination of
MTCT is underway.
Target 4 Thailand was one of the first countries in the Asia and Pacific region adopting ambitious targets and providing
anti-retroviral treatment to people with HIV irrespective of CD4 count. There is a need to focus on early detection and treatment
for key populations as well as improving access to services for non-Thais.
Target 5 Thailand has made considerable progress in alignment of HIV and TB programmes. The focus needs to be on improving
ART in co-infected patients, monitoring and improving clinical practice to ensure early detection of HIV and/or TB, and
prevention of leakage in treatment cascade.
Target 6 Thailand has mobilized more domestic resources to support the Ending AIDS policy. Continuous effort is needed to
prepare for the transition to self–reliance and ensure sustainability of the HIV response with continued engagement of CSOs and
communities in delivering appropriate HIV prevention for key populations.
Target 7 Progress has been made on advocacy and mobilization of organizations, communities and networks on gender issues
related to transgender populations, MSM and women living with HIV. Thailand needs to ensure the provision of gender-sensitive
services especially for HTC, prevention, treatment and care through appropriate policies and quality- controlled implementation
with meaningfully engagement of CSO and local communities. Target 8 Legal and policy barriers have been reduced including
parental consent for HIV in young people, harm reduction, and migrants. Development and scaling up of stigma and
discrimination reduction interventions in the health care setting is underway. Thailand is planning to normalize HIV as a key
measure for enabling environment of sigma reduction
Target 9 Thailand has no travel restriction in place.
Target 10 The re-designed HIV/AIDS-related services can be an example for Global Health Integration through task-shifting and
task-sharing in new partnerships between the public sector, civil society, and the private sector.
6
2015 Thailand Global AIDS Response Progress Reporting
1. Overview of the AIDS Epidemic
HIV burden Using the AIDS epidemic model (AEM) for adults (aged 15+ year) and Spectrum for
children (aged less than 15 year), there were estimated 7,816 new HIV infections, 20,492 AIDS related
deaths, and 445,504persons living with HIV (PLHIV) at the end of 2014 in Thailand. Females account for
39% of total adult PLHIV and 47% of children living with HIV.
Table 1: Key figures of HIV estimation, Thailand
Estimated Number 2000 2005 2010 2012 2014
Total annual new infections
• New infections in all adults*
29,619 28,241
16,014 15,266
10,215
8,877 10,011
8,719
7,816 7,695 New infections in women adults *
• New infections in all children
New infections in girl children
15,716 1,378# 669#
7,237 748# 363#
3,294 204@ 99@
2,576 158@ 76@
1,944 121@ 59@
Total annual AIDS mortality
• AIDS mortality in all adults*
AIDS mortality in women adults *
• AIDS mortality in all children
AIDS mortality in girl children
20,670 20,422 6,079 248@ 133@
20,492 20,325 6,127 167@ 94@
Total people living with HIV
• All adults living with HIV *
Women adults living with HIV *
• All children living with HIV
Girl children living with HIV
55,531 55,079 12,036 452# 221#
31,211 30,805 7,153 406# 199#
20,477 20,270 6,116 207@ 114@
683,841 676,005 217,860 7,836# 3,843#
555,808 544,743 212,351 11,065# 5,428#
493,932 485,646 199,978 8,286@ 3,998@
471,811 464,086 198,013 7,725@ 3,697@
445,504 438,629 172,454 6,875@ 3,262@
Total population (million) 60.6 63.1 63.9 64.5 65.1
* Estimation using the ‘AEM’, # Estimation using ‘Spectrum’ in 2013, @ Estimation using ‘Spectrum’ in
2014
New HIV infections in adults have declined but are insufficient to reach the national and HLM target The
number of adults who are newly infected with HIV is continuing to decline but at a slower pace. The
reduction of new HIV infections during 2000-2010 was 65%. There were an estimated 7,700 HIV
infections in 2014, a decline of only 23% from 2010. This falls short of the national target by two-thirds
or the HLM target by half.
7
Figure 1 Estimated new HIV infections in adult population based on the current response
Closer to eliminating new HIV infections among children Progress in eliminating new HIV infections
among children has been dramatic in Thailand. In 2014, 121 children were estimated to be newly-infected
with HIV. This represents about 41% reduction compared to the level in 2010. The MTCT rate was
estimated 2.1% in 2014, thus in line for achieving the 2016 target ahead of the National Plan. Thailand
can be one of the first middle countries in the world to eliminate MTCT.
AIDS-related deaths remain unchanged in last 5 years The estimated number of AIDS-related deaths
sharply decreased by 63% between 2000 and 2010 (from 55,531 to 20,670); since then, the number of
AIDS deaths has remained stable. In 2014, the estimated number of AIDS-related deaths was 20,492.
These data indicate that, since the early of 2000s, when the ART programme was expanded and rapidly
scaled up, the Thai program has averted a significant number of AIDS related deaths since that time.
Although ART coverage still increased during 2010-2014, many PLHIV learn about their positive status
and receive ART very late in the course of disease. This reduces effectiveness of ART. In addition,
coverage of screening co-infection such as tuberculosis has not been increased significantly. Thus, a
significant proportion of PLHIV die within the first six months after diagnosis even though they have
access to services and treatment. Figure 2 Estimated AIDS-related deaths based on the current response
8
2. Thailand National AIDS Strategy and Responses
Thailand has committed itself to ending the AIDS epidemic by 2030. The Cabinet and National AIDS
Committee (NAC) approved the National AIDS Strategic Plan (NASP) for 2014-16. The updated NASP
has reinforced the original 2012-16 strategies and incorporated additional measures that will enable the
country to achieve the ending AIDS targets by 2030. The costed Operational Plan for Ending AIDS in
Thailand for 2015-2019 has been developed and approved by NAC in November 2014. Thailand has
implemented the new guideline of antiretroviral treatment by providing antiretroviral treatment to all HIV
positive people regardless of CD4 nationwide since October 1, 2014.
The NSP (2014-2016) presents two over-arching strategic directions; (i) innovation and change; and (ii)
optimization and consolidation. It is based on the principles of promoting equality; implementation of
people-centered approaches; clear target setting; creating national ownership and leadership;
empowerment and increasing self-esteem; and working in partnership with government, private and
non-governmental sectors. The Plan focuses on vulnerable populations of MSM, TG, MSW, PWID, FSW
and their clients in 33 priority provinces.
The NSP (2014-2016) set ambitious targets: (i) new HIV infections reduced by two-thirds; (ii) vertical
transmission of HIV less than 2%; (iii) universal access to social protection and quality care and treatment
for PLHIV; (iv) AIDS related deaths reduced by 50%; (v) TB deaths among PLHIV reduced by 50%; (vi)
laws and policies which impede access to prevention, treatment and care and other government health
services revised; (vii) human rights and gender specific needs are addressed in all HIV responses; and
(viii) number of discrimination and /or human rights violation cases occurring to PLHIV and KAPs
reduced by 50%.
The Operational Plan (2015-2019) has been developed to elaborate critical activities to ensure the
achievement of the long term ending AIDS goals by 2030. Main inputs were drawn from the recent
knowledge of early antiretroviral treatment on prevention benefits(HPTN052), the evaluation studies, the
national consultation on strategic use of ARVs, and the national consultation of the ending AIDS in
Thailand through evidence based responses.
The Plan has identified 30 high burden provinces (including the greater Bangkok area) and utilizes the
preventive effects of ART in reducing HIV infections with the focus on effective package of service to
key populations. Thailand adopts a new approach, the Reach-Recruit-Test- Treat-Retain (RRTTR), as the
framework addressing gaps in linkage between prevention and life-long treatment system by connecting
five critical components. The plan also defines a tailored service package for each key population, and
lays out criteria for the intensity in which services should be delivered at the provincial level. The Plan
has been costed, with a total THB 9,214,862,566 for 5 years allocated to key action areas: providing
RTTR services (77%), strengthening health and community system (4%), enabling environment (6%),
and programme management (13%).
9
Figure 3 Framework of the National AIDS Strategic Plan (2014-16) and Operational Plan to End AIDS
(2015-19)
Thailand Getting to Zero
National Strategy on HIV/AIDS 2014 - 2016
Zero New HIV Infections Zero AIDS-related Deaths Zero Discrimination
Innovations and Changes 1. Expand rights based, gender sensitive and
comprehensive prevention services for key populations 2. Enhance protective social and legal
environments 3. Create sense of ownership to all
stakeholders 4. Implement a new generation of strategic
information and monitoring and evaluation
Optimization and Consolidation 1. Prevention of Mother to Child Transmission 2. Prevention among Young People
3. Condom Programming 4. Blood Safety and Universal Precaution 5. Treatment, Care and Support 6. Care and Support for
Affected Children and Families 7. Stigma and Discrimination 8. Public Communication
Social Justice and human rights based
People centered Beyond disease
focus
Community and
people Empowerment
Increased
Local leadership &
Partnership& focus
ownership
Networking
10
3. Country Progress towards 10 targets of UN HLM and Thailand’s NASP
Target 1 HLM: Reduce sexual transmission of HIV by half by 2015 Thai NASP: Reduce sexual
transmission of HIV by two-third by 2016
Key Affected Populations (FSW, MSW, MSM, TG)
Female sex workers (FSW)
National milestone for 2014
• 70% of FSW reached with prevention services in the last 12 month
• 70% of FSW received HTC and know their results in the last 12 month
• 95% of FSW reported condom use at last sex
Achievement by the end of 2014 The national estimated number of FSW was 123,530 in 2010, with
possibly one-fourth working as non-venue-based FSW (NVB-FSW). Based on program data, a
significant proportion is non- Thai FSW (about 21% based on program reports from the Global Fund sites
in 2014). HIV prevalence among venue-based FSW has declined steadily from 2.7% in 2010 to 2.2% in
2012 and 1.1% in 2014. The most recent survey among NVB-FSW in Chiang Mai, Phuket and Chonburi
in 2010 found HIV prevalence about 5, 1.4, and 1.2% respectively. The next round of IBBS among
NVB-FSW will take place in 2015.
Targeted peer-led outreach services are conducted in 41 provinces with mainly financial support by the
Global Fund and National Health Security Office (NHSO). Outreach activities are focused on hotspots
and conducted by 445 peer educators, staff and volunteers of NGOs. This is complemented with
behavioral change activities at drop-in centers, disseminated information materials and targeted condom
promotion. Based on the IBBS in 11 provinces, there was increased prevention coverage from 51% in
2010, to 54% in 2012 and 58% in 2014. However the increase is still insufficient to achieve the national
target of 70%. The number of FSW reached with prevention interventions (based on reports from GF
grantees) increased from 43,504 in 2010 to 49,756 at the end of Fiscal Year 2014. A total of 8,253
non-Thai FSW were reached with prevention interventions. Based on IBBS 2014, there has been
significant achievement in selected provinces where prevention uptake has met the national targets,
including Lopburi (83%), Srisaket (98%), Udon Thani (69%) and Phuket (75%).
Uptake of HTC services from IBBS data has improved somewhat but is still below the national target
coverage for 2014 of 70%. According to the IBBS 2010, 48% of venue-based FSW reported having had
HTC in the past 12 months and received HIV test results. This indicator improved to 57% in 2012 and
54% in 2014. There were 3 out of 11 sentinel sites reported significant increases of HTC coverage from
2010 to 2014, namely Srisaket (31% to 94%), Phuket (66% to 82%) and Songkla (56% to 88%). Data
from the national evaluation of services for HTC and treatment with the survey among FSW in 7
provinces in 2013 found that 85.6% of FSW had been ever tested for HIV and 68.3% had tested within 12
months. Even though mobile HTC clinics have been deployed in selected sites, the inconvenience and the
time required for knowing test results has been identified as major obstacles in addition to the fear of
knowing the
11
results (IPSR, 2013). There was a high proportion of FSWs (30%) who did not return for their HIV test
results (PPAT, 2015).
Condom use at last sex with a client is high and stable at over 95%, and this meets the national target.
The accomplishments are only known among VB-FSW. Limited data exist to demonstrate change of
access to key services overtime for NVB-FSW. Based on the previous survey in 2010 and 2007, the data
indicate that access to outreach activities, condoms and behavior change communication materials among
NVB-FSW was lower than for the VB-FSW. A similar pattern is found on accessing STI and HTC
services indicating that NVB-FSW had lower access to STI and HTC services.
Male sex workers (MSW)
National milestone for 2014
• 70% of MSW reached with prevention services in the last 12 month
• 70% of MSW received HTC and know their results in the last 12 month
• 99%of MSW reported condom use at last sex
Achievement by the end of 2014 It was estimated there were 18,239 MSW in Thailand in 2010. MSW are
largely concentrated in large and tourist provinces such as Bangkok, Chonburi, Chiang Mai and Phuket.
HIV prevalence among MSW has been declining but remains very high: 16.0% in 2010, 12.2% in 2012
and 11.7% in 2014.
Peer-led outreach interventions for MSW in 5 provinces were mainly funded by the US government, and
the Global Fund. In 2014, USAID established incentivized case-finding activities for MSW in Bangkok,
Chonburi and Chiang Mai, while the US CDC provided technical assistance for the MSW programme in
Phuket and Ratchaburi. The proportion of MSW who have been given condoms (by peer/outreach
workers) increased sharply from 73% in 2010 to 90% in 2012 and 94% in 2014. This trend is similar
across the 5 provinces. However, the programme did not achieve such improvements when using the
composite indicator of “have been given received condoms and know where to go for HTC.” The
prevention coverage among MSW decreased to 64% in 2014 compare to 74% in 2012)
Uptake of HTC in MSW has improved a little from 49% in 2010, to 52% in 2012 and 54% in 2014 but
still has not reached the national target for 2014 of 70%. The strategies of rapid test results and user
friendly services will become the standard at MSW drop-in centers in the priority sites with an
expectation to fill this gap in 2015.
Condom use at last sex with a client was high and increasing over time from 88% in 2010, to 98% in 2012
and 96% in 2014.
12
Men who have sex with men (MSM) and Transgender (TG) populations
National milestone for 2014
• 50% of MSM and TG populations reached with prevention services
• 60% of MSM and TG received HTC and know their results in the last 12 month
• 90% of MSM and TG reported condom use at last sex
Achievement by the end of 2014
Men who have sex with men (MSM) There were an estimated 550,000 MSM in Thailand (excluding
MSW) in 2010. The median estimates of HIV prevalence among MSM have been high and not
declining,8.0% in 2010 to 7.1% in 2012 and 9.2% in 2014 (BoE, 2015). The 2014 round of the IBBS was
carried out only in five sites, with a reduction from 12 sites in 2010 and 2012. Therefore the results
should be cautiously interpreted. For the purpose of comparing data during 2010 to 2014, only five sites
are included for this report. The studies of HIV in Bangkok among MSM do not show any sign of decline
or reversal in prevalence and incidence either. HIV prevalence among MSM in the HIV surveillance and
cross-sectional studies has consistently been around 20-30% for the past 10 years. This high HIV
prevalence is supported by similarly high HIV incidence of 5 to 6 per 100 person years (PY) among men
enrolled in observational and synthetic cohort studies conducted in Bangkok during the same period.
Targeted HIV interventions for MSM were implemented in 29 provinces with funding support by the
Global Fund, the US government, the NHSO and the Thai Health Promotion Fund. Peer-led interventions,
targeted IEC/media, condom promotion and distribution, HTC and referral to HIV and STI treatment have
been implemented as part of the core service package. In 2014, incentivized case-finding has been
implemented in selected sites to improve recruitment of MSM and TG into prevention services. Public
information campaigns via the Internet and social media have been developed and launched
systematically. However, the overall coverage of prevention interventions has not increased during the
report period. According to the IBBS in five sites (Bangkok, Chonburi, Chiang Mai, Ratchaburi and
Phuket) uptake of MSM for prevention services rose from 44% in 2010 to 53% in 2012 but dropped to
46% in 2014. These levels are insufficient to meet the national target. Through consultation with the
MSM community, the lack of improvement may be partly due to funding reduction and the trade-off of
applying different approaches to reach MSM: peer-outreach through venue-based and via social networks
or peer to peer networking. In addition, the IBBS was carried out using venue day time sampling frame,
so it is not known what the status is for the NVB MSM for these indicators.
The percentage of MSM who had HTC and received the results in the past 12 months increased from 15%
in 2010 to 26% in 2012 and to 31% in 2014. The survey among MSM in 7 provinces from the National
Evaluation of HTC and treatment in 2013 found 61.8% ever been tested for HIV and 41.6% been tested in
the last year. However, these levels are still low and far below the national target of 60%. Sub-national
analysis shows that better progress has been made in selected sites: HTC coverage among MSM in
Chonburi doubled from 2010 compared with 2014 (14% vs 27%), increased distinctly in Chiang Mai
(30% vs 46%), increased nearly four-fold in Ratchaburi (8% vs 31%) and doubled in Phuket (15% vs
32%). These increases may be the result of the introduction of rapid tests with same-day results, offered
at community-led HTC
13
clinics in six drop-in centers targeting MSM, TG and MSW. In addition, mobile HTC clinics were
deployed in hot spots in partnership with provincial health offices and general hospitals. There were still a
gap between coverage and the national target suggesting that the services are still limited in scale and are
not yet enough to generate national level impact.
Condom use at last sex with a male partner was high and stable at 80% - 82% between 2010 and 2014.
Urban and young men who have sex with men (YMSM) Data from observational and synthetic cohort
studies found that HIV prevalence among (older) MSM of ≥25 years of age in Bangkok now exceeds
40%, and the HIV incidence among (younger) MSM of ≤21 years of age ranges from 8.8 to 12.2 per 100
PY (Van Griensven, 2015).
Urban YMSM (aged 15-22 years old) have been considered at highest risk for HIV infection. The
in-depth analysis revealed that estimated HIV incidence increased from 4.1 to 7.6 per 100 PY during
2003-2014. Practice of anal sex declined from 99% in 2003 to 82% in 2014, and playing the receptive
anal sex role increased from 55% to 74%. Always-condom-use has remained stable at 50%. Increases
were seen in reports of drug use. History of HIV testing (ever) increased from 29% in 2003 to 47% in
2014, but testing during the past 12 months did not, and remains at 27% in 2014.
Based on this analysis, more determined and rigorous HIV prevention efforts are needed to stop the HIV
epidemic among urban and YMSM.
Transgender people (TG) A rough estimate of 75,626 TG in Thailand was used for programme planning.
The rigorous estimation is planned and will be updated in the near future. A significant proportion of TG
is concentrated in the major cities. Median HIV prevalence among TG in 2014 in Bangkok, Chonburi,
Chiang Mai, Chonburi and Phuket was high at 12.7%
Based on available data from five sites in 2014, the reported condom use among TG was 84%, uptake of
prevention services was59% and HTC services was 34%
Trend data are available for only four sentinel surveillance sites: Bangkok, Chiang Mai and Phuket from
2005 to 2014 and Chonburi from 2012 to 2014. The data indicate that HIV prevention coverage has not
increased in Bangkok, Chiang Mai and Phuket between 2010 and 2014, or in Chonburi from 2012 to
2014. Chiang Mai is the only city where HTC coverage has increased over time, from 22% in 2005 to
43% in 2014. These results reflect the nature of prevention programming for TG in Thailand, in that
targeted prevention interventions and HTC designed to meet TG needs are few and limited.
Developments/factors facilitating the achievement of the target
Political commitment and national financing
• Reducing sexual transmission among MSM, TG, MSW, and FSW remains a top priority for Thailand,
and is addressed in the “Ending AIDS” Operational Plan.
14
• Thailand has reinforced implementation of same-day HIV results at public health facilities throughout
the country while an introducing national guidelines for using rapid HIV testing. These efforts are making
community-based HTC services possible and popular.
• The NHSO and the Thai Health Promotion Fund (THPF)allocated a significant amount of budget to
scale-up MSM prevention interventions (25 million baht from NHSO) in 11 sites, and support for media
and social media targeting MSM (30 million baht from THPF).
• The US government has approved additional budget to revitalize MSM/TG and MSW programs, starting
in 2014 and expected to continue.
Strong civil society
• With funding support from the Global Fund and USAID, civil society continues to be the backbone for
delivering community services, safeguarding treatment access, providing case management for retaining
MSM, TG and MSW in key services, providing substantive involvement in program design and planning
and improving the policy and legal context for these groups.
• Key implementing organizations for these interventions include Rainbow Sky, SWING, M- plus, the
Poz, Home Center, Care-Mat, Sisters and Thailand Red Cross.
Challenges/ factors hindering the achievement of the target
• Capacity of community service organizations (CSO) for delivering high-quality key services (reaching
and recruiting the target population to key services) is still inconsistent across sites. High staff turnover is
still a problem among most of CSO.
• Task-shifting to CSO and communities in carrying out HTC is a prerequisite for fast, massive scale-up
of HTC and early treatment. However, implementing task-shifting is a challenge, because Thai
government regulations do not usually allow HTC outside authorized health outlets, and most of the
CSO/communities have limited technical capacity to do HTC. The health-community interface is not yet
sufficiently strong.
• HIV prevention interventions should be extended to cover NVB FSW, MSW, MSM and TG, including
non-Thais.
• Tailored programs and key services are needed to address the needs of young MSM, TG and Sex
workers.
• There is a need to ensure sustainable domestic budget support for CSO and community involvement in
delivery of interventions for MSM, TG and SW.
Conclusion Reported condom use at last sex among FSW, MSW and MSM, TG remains at a high level.
While uptake of prevention and HTC services has increased slowly, service coverage has not reached
optimal levels and not be able to meet national targets. Progress has been made in reaching venue-based
FSW but still limited among NVB-FSW. HIV prevalence and incidence remain high or increasing among
MSM, TG including YMSM. Services need to be adapted to the local context and address specific needs
across the spectrum of MSM groups and sub-groups to increase service utilization.
The Way Forward: Priority Actions
1. Urgently mobilize efforts and resources to rapidly expand the tailored package of
services for MSM, TG, MSW, and FSW to meet the targets by 2016 in priority provinces.
15
2. Adjust and apply innovative approaches to reach and recruit diverse group and more
number of SW, MSM, and TG including incentivized case finding and expand options including
community based HTC and self-test of HIV to increase percentage of knowing HIV status. 3. Develop
and implement the innovative program monitoring system including real-time
monitoring among the key populations using national, single, unique identifiers; and integrating database
of the Routine Health Information System (RHIS) and NAP database.
Youths and General Population
National milestone for 2014
• 60% of youth aged 15-24 year reported condom use at last sex
• 55% of adult population (aged 15-49) who had more than one partner reported condom use at last sex
Achievement by the end of 2014 In 2014, prevalence of HIV among pregnant women age 15-24 years
and male military recruits is stable about 0.5%.
Risk of HIV for persons who are in the reproductive age groups has not changed significantly in recent
years. The 2014 round of the behavioral surveillance (BSS) found that Male factory workers had more
than one concurrent sex partner ranged from 16% to 22% and female factory workers ranged from 4% -
5%. Further, condom use in these relationships ranged from 48% to 54% for males and from 27% to 31%
for females. The proportion of factory workers who had been tested for HIV in the last 12 months
remained at 18% to 19%.
HIV prevention interventions for youth have been funded by the Global Fund against AIDS, TB and
Malaria (GF) through the ACHIEVED Project. An external evaluation of the Project sampled youth age
12 to 24 years in school, factories, and the community in Bangkok, Udon Thani, Petchburi, Nakornsawan,
Nakhon Pratom Pattalung and Phuket Provinces. The evaluation found that, overall, youth had a good
knowledge of condoms, but did not have improved HIV knowledge levels. Youth in school had
knowledge/understanding and positive attitudes toward PLHIV less than the factory and community
youth. About 32% of school youth used a condom for all episodes of sex in the past year with a
non-regular partners. The comparable rates of condom use for youth in the community and factory
workers were 41.7% and 25%, respectively.
Developments/ factors facilitating the achievement of the target
Policy Improvements
• The clinical guidelines for HTC in young people have been successfully changed so that persons aged
under age 18 are no longer required parental consent for HIV testing. The NAP also produced operational
guidelines on disclosure of test results and referral for, or receipt of, ART. These measures are intended to
help youth with HIV risk to enter the diagnosis and treatment system sooner, and help providers create a
youth-friendly service;
• The National AIDS Programme produced a National Condom Strategy for the period of 2015- 19 as a
framework and guide for implementation to promote use of the male and female condoms, and lubricant.
This strategy addresses issues of demand, supply and creation of an
16
enabling environment. There are five sub-strategies as follows: (1) Promotion of the acceptance and
reduction of negative stigma of condoms and lubricant; (2) Promotion of access to and use of condoms
and lubricant; (3) Development of a system of management and control of condom quality; (4) Creation
of an enabling environment for condom use; and (5) Implementation of monitoring and evaluation of the
condom promotion activities.
AIDS and sex education
• School-based AIDS and sex education for youth has continued to implement and expand in the 43
priority provinces receiving GF support. An additional 34 provinces are implemented with support from
the Thai Health Promotion Foundation (THPF). In 2014, a total of 1,380 schools delivered the
GF-supported sex education curriculum through 6 to 16 sessions (or 28% of the 5,001 schools in the 43
provinces). A total of 372,599 school youth were exposed to the curriculum.
• Sex education was designated as one component of health promotion in the school setting. Participating
schools were evaluated to assess the degree to which they were prepared to deliver the curriculum as
intended. The evaluation found that the sex education curriculum was well-accepted by the participating
schools and is consistent with the quality assurance system of schools, and linked with the policy and
principles of health promotion, care and assistance for students. There has been a clear hand-over of
responsibility for maintaining and expanding the sex education curriculum;
• In 2014, an evaluation was conducted among students to measure their knowledge, attitudes, and
accuracy of self-risk perception, and life skills. The evaluation was conducted in schools which delivered
16 sessions of the GF-supported sex education curriculum in the previous academic year. The evaluation
documented significant improvements in these schools in comparison with a control group which had not
yet implemented the curriculum. In addition, an external evaluation of ACHIEVED found that the
comprehensive sexuality education curriculum was well-accepted by participating schools, and capacity
of teachers was strengthened in delivering the curriculum. Attitudes toward sex are becoming more
positive, and this is helping spur a trend among implementers to work more constructively with youth.
Expansion these success at larger scale with domestic funds is needed.
Prevention of HIV and STI in youth
• The Bureau of AIDS, TB and STI (BATS) of the Department of Disease Control (DDC) of the Ministry
of Public Health (MOPH) collaborated with schools at all levels in Bangkok and the provinces to
implement the youth-focused project called the Anti-AIDS Academy (AAA). The purpose of AAA is to
build awareness, understanding and motivation for youth to practice prevention of HIV/STI. The project
uses a variety of strategies including expanding the network of youth-friendly services to increase youth
access and utilization of sexual health services;
• The NAP has promoted public information dissemination to improve the image of the condom so that it
is seen as a health product for safe living and healthy sex lives for all members of the reproductive age
group. In the report period, the NAP requested cooperation of all the provincial health offices and
regional disease control centers throughout the country to conduct campaigns on prevention of HIV/STI
in conjunction with Valentine’s Day using the slogan ‘Sex Roawp Koawp Toawp OK’ (Say Yes to caring
sex)
17
Integrated activities for youth The DDC, Department of Mental Health, and the Department of Health
collaborated in the development and implementation of an integrated health promotion program for youth
to address problems of alcohol and cigarette consumption, unsafe sex, reproductive health problems, and
mental health disorders. The programme used a variety of strategies such as creation of an enabling
environment in the workplace, stricter enforcement of laws, training in life skills and sex education, and
screening to identify and assist school-based youth in need. Hospitals set up youth-friendly clinics,
including contraception for sexually-active single teens. The program supported communities to create
spaces for youth, host outreach services, and implement a ‘parents school’ to help improve
communication between the generations about sex and other challenges which today’s youth face.
Challenges/factors hindering achievement of the target/
• Proven comprehensive sexual and life skill curriculum existed. Institutionalized these models in the
educational system is still challenge. There is a lack of integration of implementation at national scale,
and there is a lack of a formal host to champion the response.
• Motivation for HIV prevention and availability of youth-friendly services need to be refined and
expanded given the diversity of lifestyles and behavior of today’s youth. There need to be more effective
methods to identify at-risk youth in need of services.
• It remains a challenge to formally integrate AIDS into the routine health and reproductive health plans
for youth at all levels of the system.
Conclusion Progress of activities for young people has continued buthas limited positive change in the
trends of awareness, risk behavior and incidence. The population has not been sufficiently motivated to
know HIV status and stay in healthy behaviors.
The Way Forward: Priority Actions
1. Improve policy, coordination and strategies/measures of HIV prevention for young
people with integration of sexual and reproductive health, drugs, and other development issues. 2.
Conduct public campaigns with wide reach to increase awareness and motivation for
prevention behavior s particularly the right to free HTC twice a year. 3. Support and coordinate with
relating agencies, organizations to take joint
responsibility of programmes and progress for the target populations of youths and other general
population using a set of joint key performance indicators. 4. Support government agencies to serve as
models of good practice, to be emulated by
business and the private sector in creating an environment for prevention and response to HIV/AIDS in
the workplace.
Migrant Workers (MW)
The actual number of non-Thai livings in the country is unknown. The latest attempt to estimate was 3.7
million in 2013 (2014 Migration report). The estimated number of workers from Cambodia, Lao and
Myanmar was 2.7 million with work permits 1.1 million and irregular status 1.6 million. Registered
migrants have access to the Thai health-care insurance system through either the social security scheme
(SSS) for those employed in the formal sector or the migrant health insurance scheme for the rest. In
August 2013, the MOPH announced a policy to provide
18
health insurance (with ART coverage included) for cross-border migrant workers who are not covered by
social security, including both registered and unregistered migrants. As of September 30, 2014, the
number of migrants who registered with the migrant health insurance increased 1,423,831.
Developments Significant improvement has been made on migrant health policies. In August 2013, the
Cabinet revised its policy on health check-ups, and included ARV treatment in the health insurance
package. A subsidy of 500 THB was approved at first enrollment for documented and undocumented
migrants from Myanmar, Lao PDR and Cambodia.
In June 2014, the Government has established one-stop service center for migrant’s registration and the
MOPH has reduced the health insurance fees. The “Samutsakorn Model” where migrants can be
registered and enrolled on health insurance via a one-stop service has been expanded and implemented to
other provinces.
Challenges Migrants still have limited access to HIV diagnosis treatment and care due to legal, financial
and language constraints. Fears of job loss and interactions with the Ministry of Labour, police and
immigration authorities are not supportive to positive health seeking behavior among undocumented
migrants.
The implementation of the MHI scheme is ongoing, but the system is not fully rolled out due to
management and financial challenges. There are also gaps in coverage. Hospitals are still reluctant to sell
MHI for fear of incurring net losses or administrative procedures. Therefore, access for migrants to
prevention and care services for HIV and TB, while improving, is still limited.
In order to encourage migrants to subscribe to health insurance, they must feel that it is to their benefit.
The development of “Migrant Friendly” services, which primarily incorporates Migrant Health Workers
and community-based services, has been in process some time, but needs for institutionalization.
Conclusion The management of the Migrant Health Insurance scheme needs to be further developed to
increase willingness of the hospitals to cover additional migrant workers and their dependents. Risk
mitigation in this respect should be advocating for policy change to ensure that hospitals have finance
mechanisms in place that will support the provision of health services for migrants, especially for HIV
prevention and treatment services.
The Way Forward: Priority Actions
1. Improve coordination mechanism and management of migrant health insurance scheme,
social security scheme at central level in order to effectively translated policy into implementation. 2.
Reorganize fund management of MHI to assure that hospital will be able to recover their
costs. 3. Institutionalize Migrant Assistant Health Workers and Migrant Health Volunteers in the
government’s health services for migrants.
19
Refugees
Key accomplishments in 2014 As of 31 December 2014, Thailand was hosting more than 118,000
refugees including approximately 110,000 refugees from Myanmar residing in 9 temporary shelters along
the Thai- Myanmar border, and approximately 8,560 refugees and asylum seekers of various origins
living in urban areas across Thailand. The HIV prevalence among refugees is low, both in camps and in
urban settings. Refugees are provided access to HIV prevention, care and treatment through activities
supported by UNHCR and its partners, under the umbrella of the Royal Thai Government. Refugees and
asylum seekers have access to male condoms. Information, education and communication (IEC) materials
were disseminated to reinforce the messages of HIV/AIDS prevention and stigma reduction as well as to
promote gender equality and non-violence, ensuring that women and children were also targeted to
receive the messages.
HTC services was available free of charge and focused on but not limited to key affected populations,
new arrivals and pregnant women. Comprehensive HIV/AIDS care and treatments have also been offered
to the refugees, partly under the specific national ART scheme for migrants and Non-Thai population
(NAPHA extension programme), partly under the financial contribution of international donors. As a
result, almost 100 people living in temporary shelters and 11 people living in Bangkok have received
ART as per Thailand’s National Guidelines on HIV/AIDS Diagnosis and Treatment.
Anticipating a possible future voluntary repatriation of refugees living in the temporary shelters, in 2014
UNHCR has developed contacts and facilitated exchange of information between the Myanmar national
AIDS program and the NGO’s working in Thailand. A referral protocol has been established.
The Way Forward: Priority Actions:
Continue to prioritize and include HIV in the agenda of health and all preparation for the repatriation
process.
20
Target 2 HLM: Reducing HIV transmission among PWID by 50% by 2015 Thai NASP: Reduce
HIV transmission among PWID by two-third by 2016
HIV prevalence among people who injection drug (PWID) has been on the decline but remains high
(21.9%, 25.2% and 19.0% in 2010, 2012 and 2014 respectively). Substance use patterns have been
changing and diverse by local context, with non-injecting substance use replacing the injections in some
settings.
National milestone for 2014
• 65 % of PWID reached with prevention services
• 60% of PWID received HTC and know their results in the last 12 month
• 65 % of PWID reported condom use at last sex
• 81% of PWID reporting the use of sterile injecting equipment the last time they injected
Achievement by the end of 2014
Thailand has an estimated 40,300 people who inject drugs in 2010. According to IBBS data collected
from three provinces (Bangkok, Chiang Mai and Songhkla), the proportion of PWID who reported the use
of a condom at last sexual intercourse were still less than 50%. There has been an increase in the
percentage of people who reported using sterile injecting equipment the last time they injected (from 42%
in 2009 to 85% in 2014 in Figure 3). Other achievements include the number of people testing for HIV
and knowing their status has increased from 40% in 2009 to 61.2% in 2014 (Figure 4). The median HIV
prevalence declined from 25.2% in 2012 to 19.02% in 2014. However, IBBS data for PWID is limited to
3 sites only and should be interpreted with caution.
Figure 4 Percentage (%) of people who inject drugs who reported using sterile injecting equipment the
last time they injected, IBBS data
Percentage (%) of people who inject drugs who reported using sterile injecting equipment
the last time they injected
100%
Target 82% 80%
78%
80%
85%
Target 60%
42%
2016 2009 40%
2010 20%
2012 0%
Target 2016
2009 2010 2012 2014
21
Figure 5 Percentage (%) of people who inject drugs that have received an HIV test in the past 12 months
and know their results
Percentage (%) of people who inject drugs that have received an HIV test in the past 12
months and know their results
100%
80%
Target 60% 60%
40% 41%
61%
Target 2016 44%
2009 40%
2010 20%
2012 0%
Target
2009 2010 2012 2014 2016
In 2014 there were 42 sites which distributed needles and syringes at no cost, this includes some
pharmacies. The average number of needles and syringes distributed to the estimated toal PWID in 2014
was 14, improved from the previous year but far from reaching the country target of 88.
The number of opioid substitution therapy (OST) sites in 2014 was 140, decreased from 147 in 2013, and
the number of people on OST through those sites was 3,646 individuals, decreased from 4068 individuals
on OST in 2013).
It is noted that OST is appropriate in the treatment of the dependence on Opiate (Heroin and Opium)
whereas no specific treatment has been developed for treatment of the dependence of ATS and MA with
injection.
Developments/ factors facilitating the achievement of the target
Political commitment Thailand has been demonstrating sustained political commitment to curb the HIV
epidemic. The country has been one of the first to take on board the goal of ending the AIDS epidemic by
2030. In February 2014 the Thai Office Narcotics Control Board (ONCB) launched a new harm reduction
strategy. The strategy was the first multi-sectoral coordinated harm reduction project involving key
government agencies and civil society. In November 2014, the NAC endorsed the policy and strategies on
harm reduction for drug use to support the Ending AIDS measures. It is first time that harm reduction is
formally approved in the HIV programme after a long struggle with the negative law interpretation from
the State Council. NAC further authorized the Department of Disease Control to use government budget
to procure needle and syringe to support harm reduction programme.
National financing Much of the funding for harm reduction services on outreach and NSP comes from the
Global Fund grant through the PSI Champion IDU project which was based in 19 provinces over the year.
But, that grant came to an end in 2014. The prioritization process was undertaken to reach
22
larger number of PWID despite fewer number of provinces. In 2015, the GF provided support for
community outreach in 12 provinces, whilst the domestic budget is supporting the MMT service. The
effort has been made to request funding to support from government and National Health Security Office
for the 7 demonstration sites.
Strong civil society Civil Society groups have played a key role in accessing the target group of drug
users, especially with harm reduction interventions, including community outreach and peer educators.
The outreach workers provide prevention information and services, and motivation for other PWID to go
for HIV VCT and harm reduction services. Civil Society has been also a key player in the needle/syringe
exchange programme and community-based MMT.
Challenges/factors hindering the achievement of the target
• The closing down of the Champion IDU project in 7 of the 19 provinces has resulted in fewer outreach
and NSP sites nationally to offer the required Harm Reduction services, although the targeted numbers
from the previous grants have been maintained.
• The laws and policies on drug often conflict with each other, and this causes confusion and different
practice of intervention programmes. The guidelines for harm reduction view drug dependence as a health
problem which requires therapy and care. However, the 1979 Narcotics Control Act views drug use as a
crime, subject to arrest and imprisonment.
• While Thailand now has a policy to support harm reduction, the implementation of this policy is
incomplete, and the responsible authorities and staff at the provincial level do not have a good
understanding of the policy and implementation guidelines. The provincial task forces on drugs have not
been established yet, and this could be a result of the political upheaval in recent years. Many people still
have inadequate knowledge, understanding and negative prejudice against harm reduction.
• The current status of harm reduction is not consistent with the needs and context of the local community
where PWID live. There are gaps in outreach by the Civil Society groups, and gaps in static services in
the public sector. There is a need for more integrated effort among the government and Civil Society
groups to link outreach with government clinics, ensure better coverage of clean needle/syringe
distribution, and spur greater uptake of MMT services in the community and clinic settings.
Conclusion There has been considerable progress in harm reduction policy and programs, resulting in
improved access to related services. However, challenges remain particularly in achieving full
implementation of the policy and strategies to achieve optimal coverage. Implementing staff, especially in
the public sector, from the top levels down to the front-line services, need to have better knowledge and
understanding of harm reduction. Thus, there needs to be a shift in strategy toward more genuine
implementation, including changes to the relevant laws so that drug addiction is viewed as a public health
problem and not a criminal offence. Thailand should eliminate the practice of arresting and imprisoning
drug users. There should be more access to quality services for drug users and protection of their basic
human rights.
The Way Forward: Priority Actions
1. Support, monitor and evaluate the implementation of harm reduction services in the 19
pilot provinces as demonstration of translating policy into effective actions.
23
2. Increase the role of government in expanding harm reduction services and reduce
negative attitudes of government personnel toward drug users, 3. Develop and improve service model
e.g. government’s role in clean needle/syringe
distribution, the community-based program MMT service, education on HIV and hepatitis C, prevention
of drug overdosing, operational guideline for harm reduction services, and static and outreach services
through collaboration among the government, private, civil society and the population of drug users. 4.
Advocate for change the laws which conflict with policies in order to create a more
enabling environment for prevention. There should be consideration of eliminating the policies which
criminalize drug use, and there should be provision of MMT in the prison setting.
24
Target 3 HLM: Elimination of mother-to-child transmission (PMTCT) of HIV and
significant reduction of AIDS Mortality Thai NASP: Vertical transmission of HIV
less than 2%
National milestone for 2014 95.5% of Thai and non-Thai HIV positive pregnant women received ARV
drugs to reduce the risk of MTCT 80% of infants born to HIV-infected women received virological tests
for HIV within 2 months of birth. 2.5% of infants born to HIV infected mothers are infected
Achievements by the end of 2014
The rate of MTCT declined from 2.3% in 2013 to 2.1% in 2014 which suggests good progress toward the
goal of under 2.0% MTCT by 2016. Data from 2014 indicate that the proportion of pregnant women not
receiving any kind of ART declined from 4.9% in 2013 to 4.2% in 2014.
The proportion of newborns to HIV+ mothers who received PCR screening for HIV in the first two
months of life increased from 73% in 2013 to 76% in 2014. However, to reach the 2016 target of 90%,
there need to be new and intensified strategies for neonatal HIV screening for infants of HIV infected
mothers.
Coverage of couple testing for HIV in the ANC increased from 38% in 2013 to 41% in 2014, though this
level is still far below the 2016 target of 60% coverage.
Developments/ factors facilitating the achievement of the target
Increased coverage of PMTCT
• The MOPH announced the policy to provide free ANC to all couples who register for care within the
first 12 weeks of the pregnancy in order to reduce the problem of late initiation of ANC and no ANC
• Since August 2014, the MOPH has implemented an outreach program to diagnose HIV infection of
newborns and promote earlier initiation of ART among infected infants. This effort includes training of
relevant staff in PMTCT and immediate blood testing of the infants (of HIV+ mothers) at birth
• In October 2014, new HIV treatment guidelines were introduced, including guidelines and regimens for
PMTCT from the original protocol of AZT+3TC+LPV/r to be changed toTDF+3TC+EFV. ART is to
begin at the time of diagnosis, regardless of the age of gestation or CD4 level. All cases are counseled to
continue ART post-partum in accordance with the new treatment guidelines for adult cases of HIV
infection. This should help increase coverage of ART for new and repeat cases of pregnancy among
HIV+ women, and further reduce MTCT in the coming years.
• Implementation of a program to improve control, monitoring and evaluation of the PMTCT service.
This includes a various following steps: 1. Meeting of the national committee and regional health centers
to develop the system
and handbook for use of M&E data on PMTCT; 2. Meeting of the Task Force to promote monitoring
of implementation progress,
planning the monitoring system, database maintenance, and applied use of the data
25
in the ICT system to feed into the GIS and website graphs to inform decisions and use of data from the
PHMIS and NAP. 3. Workshop for national committee members, resource persons and regional health
centers to improve use of M&E data. 4. Inspect and feed data back to managers and relevant others 5.
Present results of implementation of PMTCT for managers and relevant other
stakeholders.
Promoted HTC for pregnant women and their partners
• Develop and produce a handbook with guidelines for promoting and expanding couple ANC HTC.
• Support activities at service outlets, educational media, flip charts on ANC HIV testing, a couple
counseling handbook, and videos on couple ANC HTC.
• Follow-up results of couple counseling services using the PHMIS to assess coverage, expose gaps, and
identify target areas for supervision;
• Conduct monitoring at the level of the zone and service outlet by the program staff with service
providers to increase knowledge, understanding and confidence in service provision.
Challenges/ factors hindering achievement of the target
• Coverage of the couple counseling program in 2014 was only in 60% of service outlets, and this
prevented more complete identification of discordant couples as evidenced by the finding that only 42%
of ANC couples received HTC. This low level of coverage threatens to increase partner HIV
transmission, reduces confidence in the service system, and exposes the need for more training of staff in
couple counseling;
• There remain a significant number of pregnant women who have not registered for ANC and, thus, the
full picture of ANC infection is not known. This impedes care for pregnant and delivering women, and
limits achievement of the PMTCT target goals;
• Access to PMTCT for non-Thai pregnant women in Thailand is not universal, in part because they have
to pay for service;
• Fully 40% of the pregnant women diagnosed with HIV do not return to the delivering facility for
on-going care post-partum;
• The progress reports on PMTCT do not include data from private hospitals and large hospitals outside
the MOPH system, and these facilities could have a different level of performance than the MOPH
outlets.
Conclusion Thailand succeeded in reducing HIV transmission from mother to child. The MTCT rates fell
to 2.1 % in 2014, coincided with the national target that is below 2% by 2016. The country could be
among the first countries in the world to achieve the target of getting zero PMTCT related infection.
The Way Forward: Priority Actions
1. Review data on PMTCT, and reflect these data back to those locations which are below the national
target for coverage so that they will implement improvements to services, improve laboratory procedures,
and extend coverage of the right to receive care for the target groups, toward the goal of eliminating
MTCT.
26
2. Increase coverage of PMTCT for migrant women in Thailand through increased coverage of the
insurance for migrants so that HIV+ pregnant migrant women and their newborns receive equal and
quality care. 3. Conduct evaluation on the impact of policy changes, the coverage and retention into the
ART system of HIV+ pregnant women, and identify obstacles to couples counseling.
27
Target 4 HLM: Reach15 Million PLHIV with lifesaving antiretroviral treatment Thai NASP: All
PLHIV residents in Thailand receive social protection and access to
quality treatment and care, AIDS-related deaths reduced by half
National milestone for 2014
• 75% of eligible adults and children with HIV (CD 4 < 350) receiving antiretroviral therapy (NASP)
• 60% of adults and children with HIV received anti- retroviral therapy (OP target)
• 86% of adults and children with HIV still alive and to be on treatment 12 months after initiating
antiretroviral therapy
• 81% of people on ART for 12 months having viral load suppression
Achievements by the end of 2014
Thailand has been one of the first countries to adopt the Test and Treat Strategy with revised HIV
treatment guideline that recommend the provision of anti-retroviral treatment to all HIV positive people
irrespective of CD4 count. This policy has been fully implemented nation-wide on October 1, 2014.
Previously, the guidance was to initiate treatment at CD4 350 or less per mm3, at which level Thailand
had ART coverage of 80.3% in 2013.
A total of 426,274 adults and children were enrolled in HIV care by 2014, of which 271,652 were
receiving ART. Of these, 267,150 were adults and 4,502 were children aged below 15. Of these, 35,282
patients were newly enrolled in 2014. The coverage of ART was 61% of all HIV positive adults and
children.
ART was delivered via 949 health facilities (that can initiate or provide follow up for PLHIV on ART).
Retention in treatment at the end of 12 months was 83.0%. The rate among men and women was slightly
different (82.4% among men vs. 83.8% among women), and higher among children than adults (87.3%
vs. 82.9%, respectively). The 2014 retention rate, compared with the 2013 results, was very similar
(83.0% in 2014 vs. 82.7% in 2013). The loss to follow-up was 8.5%, mortality was 8.3% and 0.13%
people chose to stop ART. The trend of death rate, lost-to- follow and those who stopped therapy was
also stable. Longer term retention at 24 and 60 months was 77.9% and 74.6% respectively. However,
mortality at 24 months was 11.5% and increased to 17.4% at 60 months.
Coverage of ART
Access to ART has continued to improve in Thailand at a rapid rate, with coverage increasing from 64.6%
in 2011, and increasing more than 15% only two years later in 2013 to 80.3%. It should be noted that this
increase is based on a different treatment initiation criterion than what is used now. Apart from
improvements in treatment access and high retention rates, Thailand has made exception progress in
improving the quality of ART. This is seen through the improvements in access to viral loads testing and
levels of viral load suppression – in 2014, 96.1% of ART patients who tested for viral load during the
reporting period had suppressed viral loads. It is also notable that in Thailand, ART stock outs are very
rare – in 2014, only 3.1% facilities reported ART stock-out.
28
Many HIV positive people are unaware of HIV status and seek HIV services late. It is critical that rapid
diagnosis and massive scale up of HIV Counseling and Testing, strong linkages are in place to support
early treatment initiation and retention. This will in turn require well-functioning referral linkages, task
sharing, and consistent promotion of early diagnosis and treatment adherence.
Figure 6 Percentage of adults and children with HIV currently receiving antiretroviral therapy
Developments/ factors facilitating the achievement of the target
Political commitment Thailand has been demonstrating sustained political commitment to curb the HIV
epidemic. The country has been one of the first to take on board the goal of ending the AIDS epidemic by
2030. In doing this, Thailand has very quickly utilized new scientific knowledge, and been able to
translate that into context specific policy and implementation practice. This has been reflected in the
HIV/AIDS Operational Plan (2015-2019), which is focused on combination prevention approaches and
early treatment (including bio-medical interventions). This has been endorsed by the National AIDS
Council.
National financing The National HIV response is largely funded by domestic resources. In particular,
where treatment is concerned, a 100% of resources are domestic. All three health insurance schemes for
Thai nationals offer a comprehensive benefits package addressing the entire continuum of diagnosis,
treatment, and follow up (including free first and second line ARV, salvage regimens, viral load and
resistance monitoring).
Conclusion Thailand is on track to meet the HLM and National Targets for access to life saving ART.
The country performed well both in terms of the coverage of ARV and the quality of ART services.
29
The Way Forward: Priority Actions 1. Increase the proportion of people who know their sero-status by
investing in demand
generation programme, HTC services, and reduction of stigma and discrimination. 2. Improve access to
simplified and decentralized diagnostic technologies as well early
diagnosis and completed referrals into care and treatment. 3. Improved mechanisms to support
adherence and life-long treatment as part of the Test and
Treat approach. 4. Ensure universal access to ART and quality treatment for unregistered migrants.
30
Target 5 HLM: Reduce tuberculosis deaths in PLHIV by half by 2015 Thai NASP: TB deaths
mortality among PLHIV reduced by half by 2016
National milestone for 2014
• 32 % of estimated HIV positive incident TB cases that received treatment for TB and HIV All HIV
positive patients are screened for TB in HIV care settings at each visit
• 95% of TB patients will be tested for HIV and have their test result recorded in the TB Register
• 8% of people with HIV and TB co-infection die after beginning of treatment
Achievements by the end of 2014 At the end of 2014, the Bureau of Tuberculosis reported 50,670 TB
patients had been tested for HIV at the time of TB diagnosis or had a known HIV status. Among these,
6,831 were HIV positive. Of these, 4,691 were on ART and 4,359 were receiving co-trimoxazole
preventive therapy.
Reporting for HIV -TB indicators is not complete in Thailand, and there is significant under- reporting of
HIV testing and treatment among TB patients from specific sites. Data to report on GARP HIV –TB
indicators 5.2, 5.3 and 5.4 are not routinely collected at a nationally representative level. However some
other data sources allow some conclusions to be drawn. For example, the HIV performance measurement
for hospital quality improvement, namely HIVQUAL-T, in which patient charts who visited clinics
during the review period were abstracted using a sampling methodology to achieve 90% confidence
interval (+/- 8% random error) are available. This database specifically provides information on the
percentage of PLHIV receiving care/treatment services at HIV clinics that had TB screening at least one
time during the reporting year. In 2014, coverage of at least one-screening for TB was 98.8% according to
HIV –QUAL data. Data on TB screening for each visit are not routinely collected and reported at the
moment.
Coverage of ART for TB patients with HIV There are an estimated 12,000 HIV positive incident TB case
in Thailand. The proportion of estimated HIV positive incident TB cases that received treatment for TB
and HIV has gone up steadily in Thailand from 26.07% in 2010 to 39.1% in 2014 (4,691/12,000).
However, as a proportion of those diagnosed TB patients with HIV, this is 68.6% (4,691/6,831). This
number has also steadily improved compared to 2013, when it was lower at 59.6%. However, this
increase in the proportion is a result of a decline in the number of TB patients who were recorded to be
HIV positive. This is a reporting issue rather than a decline in actual testing rates.
Developments/ factors facilitating the achievement of the target
National financing The National HIV-TB response is largely funded by domestic resources. In particular,
where treatment is concerned, a 100% of resources are domestic. All three health insurance schemes for
Thai nationals offer a comprehensive benefits package addressing the entire continuum of diagnosis,
treatment, and follow up (including free first and second line ARVs, first line and
31
second line TB treatment, molecular diagnostics, viral load and resistance monitoring). HIV testing is also
free for all Thai citizens and registered migrants.
Challenges/ factors hindering the achievement of the target For HIV-TB, inadequate diagnosis of TB
among HIV patients remains a gap, specifically due to the large proportion of smear negative cases,
extra-pulmonary and asymptomatic TB noted in this group, (which is poorly diagnosed in routine verbal
screening algorithms). The main intervention to address this gap in detection of TB infections is to
improve the quality of diagnosis by using Gene-Xpert, even though asymptomatic patients will need
ongoing evaluation and investigations. Overall HIV testing rates among TB patients are high, but still not
universal and extra effort to ensure 100% testing coverage among TB patients is required. Finally, clinical
practice among TB care providers which may lead to delayed initiation of ART in TB patients needs
revision. While this has been addressed in the National HIV and TB treatment guidance, more
consultation and capacity building to give clinicians adequate confidence to treat with ART early is still
needed.
Conclusion Thailand has made considerable progress in alignment of HIV and TB programmes over time.
Overall, the proportion of estimated HIV positive incident TB cases in Thailand who are receiving ART
is still low and requires ongoing focus and commitment in order to achieve the targets set for 2016. It is
notable that this is not a financial resource or technical guidance issue, as adequate financing and
technical tools are already available. The focus needs to be on monitoring and improving clinical practice
to ensure early detection of HIV and or TB and prevention of leakage in the treatment cascade.
The Way Forward: Priority Actions 1. Improve case finding of TB among those living with HIV
including adequate diagnosis of smear negative and extra-pulmonary TB patients to ensure early
diagnosis, and antiretroviral treatment using new molecular diagnostic technology and initiation of ART.
2. Ensuring universal testing for HIV among TB patients and completed referral for ART for all
those with a HIV positive test result. 3. Improve and harmonize information system of TB and HIV
co-activities in order to monitor
progress and identify gaps for improvement.
32
Target 6 HLM: Close the global AIDS resource gap by 2015 and reach annual global
investment of US $22-24 billion in low-and middle-income countries Thai NASP: Increase budget
proportion for prevention in priority provinces by 2016
Based on the recent NASA in 2013, total HIV expenditure was 8,827 million THB, reflecting an increase
of 14% from 2010 (7,733 million THB). Thailand was financing 89% of the total HIV expenditure
through domestic funds (7,889 million THB), which is an increase from 85% or 6,588 million THB in
2010.
The spending on prevention increased from 1,015 in 2010 to 1,506 million THB in 2013, or 48%
increased. Domestic financial resources were still a major funding source of prevention activities
accounted for 78% in 2013. However, the proportion of spending for prevention among MSM, female and
male SW, and PWID was only 13% of the total prevention expenditure in 2010 (134 million THB), 18%
in 2011 (247 million THB), 11% in 2012 (166 million THB) and 11% in 2013 (167 million THB).
The Global fund is the main funding source for prevention among key populations: 73% in 2010, 86% in
2011, 86% in 2012 and 78% in 2013. Even though the proportion of domestic funds for prevention among
key populations increased from 6% in 2010 to 14% in 2013, there remains a large gap to achieve
self-reliance of domestic financing for the HIV response among key populations.
National priorities for 2014: Closing the AIDS resource gaps for prevention services among key
populations, in particular for community-based/led service delivery in priority provinces, is a national
priority. Thailand has made efforts through different mechanism of central budgeting system including
AIDS Care Fund, and Thai Health Promotion Fund to support prevention services. In the meantime,
Thailand is focusing on preparing for the transition to fully self-reliance to ensure sustainable domestic
financing of the HIV response. Thailand is establishing, advocating and accelerating leadership at the
sub-national level, including Local Administrative Organizations (LAO), for a sense of local ownership
and contributing budget to fund the HIV response in local areas.
Key achievements by 2014:
Political commitment
• The costed five-year Operational Plan for ending the AIDS epidemic was finalized and endorsed by the
National AIDS Committee. Informed by quality up-to-date evidence, the Ending AIDS Strategy and
Operational Plan prioritized combination prevention (including treatment as prevention), early treatment,
and reduction of stigma and discrimination; placed a strong emphasis on reaching with quality services
the key populations of MSM, PWID, SW and migrant workers; and accentuated the shift to
community-based/led service delivery.
• The Joint Key Performance Indicators for HIV response (Joint KPI) has been approved by the NAC to
be used by relating Ministries for 2015-16 on measuring progress of HIV response across government
organizations and line ministries.
• The National Health Security Office with the endorsement from NAC agreed to establish prevention
service category in the AIDS Care Fund for 2015. The 2015 budget request was
33
initiated at 500 million THB to support the prevention services for key populations. Unfortunately, the
budget allocation in 2015 of NHSO was not increased due to economic constraints. The 2015 HIV
prevention budget has been postponed. However, the prevention budget has been requested again for
fiscal year 2016. The initial approval is endorsed at 186 million THB for delivering prevention services
and 14 millions for service strengthening.
National financing The Global Fund New Funding Model (NFM) concept note was developed and viewed
as a means of strategic short-term support that would cushion the transition to a full, domestically-funded
HIV and TB response. This front-load investment will allow Thailand to sustain and expand the gains in
the HIV response while concentrating on mobilizing diversified domestic financing. The total amounts to
US$ 39.75 million over a two-year period from 1st January 2015 to 31st of December 2016. The budget
for HIV (about US$ 24 million) is focused on service delivery for key populations in prioritized
provinces, as epidemiological and cost-benefit investment analysis indicate that the highest return on
investment will be obtained by that focus. To fill country gaps, over a third (38%) of the budget is
allocated for prevention and HTC for KPs; with the largest share going to prevention and HTC activities
for MSM and TG populations (reflecting the highest burden of infections in this group). The second
largest allocation goes to PWID interventions, and the remainder of the investments addresses
heterosexual transmission.
With the updated NSP reinforced additional measures, the National Health Security Office (NHSO)
continued its support to prevention and STI services for key populations (22 million THB in Fiscal Year
2014). Prevention activities include peer-led interventions, community mobilization, demand-generation
for HTC through social and health networks, linkage of services provided at the district, sub-district and
community levels, and quality of counseling services in the community and health outlets.
Steps were taken in preparing for the transition to self –reliance and ensuring sustainable domestic
financing of the HIV response. A review of funding mechanisms and alternative funding sources and
management as well as a prioritization of services is underway. An alliance with CSO was established to
support an analysis of existing and potential domestic funding mechanisms and sources, including
examining government-NGO financial models that could be adapted to Thailand’s context.
Increase involvement and local ownership
The national sub-committee on promoting provincial and local stakeholder ownership fully preformed its
functions throughout 2014. A number of approaches have been developed to promote involvement and a
sense of ownership in the expansion of the HIV response at local levels including;
• Established a memorandum of understanding (MOU) between the Department of Provincial
Administration, Ministry of Interior and Ministry of Public Health to integrate the HIV response into the
“district health system”.
• Supported the “ASEAN Cities Getting to Zero” initiative, and four provinces in Thailand namely
Bangkok, Phayao, Ubonratcha Thani and Lopburi were selected for pilot activities. These cities received
support from BATS and UNAIDS to effectively translate the Ending AIDS strategy into actions with
inclusive effort from relevant key partners and stakeholders within each city. The goal is to enhance the
response to HIV and
34
mobilize all resources by the local team to support the Ending AIDS operations in an effective and
harmonized manner.
• Promoted the use of the “AIDS ZERO PORTAL” as an innovative interactive tool for policy makers
and program managers to provide quality and up-to-date strategic information to guide the HIV response
at sub-national levels.
• Translated the national Ending AIDS operational plan into actions, including a “Flagship Project” to
accelerate the HIV response in 13 priority provinces.
• The Health Promotion Fund provided financial support for implementation of Ending AIDS in three
provinces with inclusive engagement of key stakeholders and LOA. Systematic documentation of this
process will be undertaken for future replication.
Nakhon Ratchasima Province was successful in mobilizing financial support for the HIV response from
local organizations, in particular for HIV prevention for youth. In early 2015, 165 out of 232 (75%) of
LAO provided financial support for HIV-related activities in the amount of 30 million THB. This
represents an average LAO contribution of 182,000 THB and a significant increase over the contribution
during2006-2008 which ranged from 39,000-81,000 THB per LAO per year (UNDP, 2010). There was
effective implementation of the joint KPI at the provincial level, with a clear HIV strategic framework
and establishment of standard operation procedures to support HIV activities for local organizations.
Challenges/ factors hindering the achievement of the target
• There is a need to ensure sustainable allocation of domestic financing for continued engagement of CSO
and communities in delivery of an appropriate response by targeting the key populations of MSM, SW,
PWID and migrants.
• The capacity of local organizations to mobilize financial support is still modest. A more systematic
approach is needed for this, including skills-building in sharing lessons learned between provinces.
Conclusion Thailand achieved top–level commitment in policy endorsement towards Ending AIDS by
2030. Progress was made with additional financial support for prevention, targeting MSM and FSW, from
domestic funds in 2014, but the amount is still limited. Steps were taken in establishing prevention
category in AIDS Care Fund of NHSO and preparing for the transition to self-reliance. Both existing
mechanism and new model are needed to ensure sustainability of financing the HIV response to continue
engagement of CSO and communities in delivery of appropriate HIV interventions targeting key
populations. Scale up good practices of mobilization of local ownership as well as leveraging financial
support for the HIV response at the sub-national level are also important mechanism to support the ending
AIDS strategy.
The Way Forward: Priority Actions
1. Develop new funding mechanisms for sustainable and flexible domestic financing
support of the HIV response particularly the CSO activities. 2. Capacitating and empowering CSO
and communities for effective engagement in policy
work related to sustained financing of the HIV response. 3. Engaging leadership and accelerating
capacity-building at the provincial level, including local organizations to strengthen ownership of the HIV
response, including creating more opportunities for CSO and communities.
35
Target 7 HLM: Eliminate gender inequalities and gender-based abuse and violence and increase
the capacity of women and girls to protect themselves from HIV Thai NASP: Human rights and
gender specific needs are addressed in all HIV Responses
Data on Violence against Women (VAW) and Intimate Partner Violence (IPV)
• The National Statistical Office (NSO) survey of 27,000 sampled households on the status of women and
children in Thailand and found that 13.1% of women aged between 15-49 think that physical violence by
a husband is justifiable in cases in which the wife leaves the house without informing the husband, not
being attentive in taking care of children, refusing to have sex with the husband and burning the food.
• Data from the One Stop Crisis Center (OSCC) in 829 hospitals of the MOPH for 2013 show that 12,637
women and 19,229 children received services from the OSCC. The majority of clients receiving the
services were victims of either physical or sexual violence from their intimate partners or boyfriends. The
VAW was highest among the population age of 24-45 years. Fifty-three percent of perpetrators were
spouses. These findings are consistent with the national survey conducted in 2013 by the MSDHS. That
study identified 2,976 cases of domestic violence, who were mostly women, children and elderly. Of
these, 85.2% suffered from emotional violence, 69.9% from physical violence and 21.6% from sexual
violence. The majority of perpetrators were spouses, siblings or intimate partners.
Achievements by the end of 2014
Empowerment of Women Living with HIV (WLHIV) Network
• Participation in Reproductive Health (RH) Services. The WLHIV network was empowered to
participate in RH services for pregnant women at ANC clinics in 13 hospitals across nine provinces. The
RH services include provision of knowledge on prevention and care for HIV/AIDS, rights-based
information, assistance for cases of gender-based violence, as well as life planning for couples. The
gender perspective was applied to solve the problems regarding STI, AIDS, RH and human rights.
• Strengthening the network and capacities of women living with HIV (WLHIV). In December 2014, 36
WLHIV attended a workshop, organized by UN Women, Mahidol University, the Raks Thai Foundation,
the Network of WLHIV and government agencies. This workshop provided an opportunity for
participants to brainstorm on progress, gaps, challenges, lessons learnt and strategic directions for the
network of WLHIV. Three key issues were identified and addressed. Firstly, the WLHIV network needs
to be reconstructed to reflect its organizational capacity. That is, the network needs to be re-formulated
into either an association or a foundation, at the sub-national or national level. Secondly, the
representatives of the WLHIV network identified challenges in building a new generation of WLHIV
leaders. Thus, there is a need for capacity building to groom the new generation of WLHIV leaders.
Thirdly, the network identified priority areas for implementation in RH and rights. Also, it is essential to
advocate for other rights, such as economic, social and cultural rights. These are reflected in some of the
activities of the “Strengthening Evidence and Empowerment Living with HIV/AIDS in Thailand Towards
Gender-Sensitive and Rights-base HIV/AIDS Prevention and Response” Project, which was launched in
2015 by Mahidol University and the Raks Thai Foundation, supported by UNWOMEN and UNAIDS.
36
Legal framework for gender equality The draft Gender Equality Law was submitted to the National
Assembly in December 2014, and subsequently approved by the National Assembly in January 2015.
Article 3 includes the statement that sexual expression that is different from one’s sex at birth’ as a basis
for gender discrimination is prohibited1. There was also policy advocacy on the laws related to who
constitutes a “marital partner.”
Evidence and knowledge generation Mahidol University, supported by UNWOMEN and UNAIDS,
conducted a study to document and analyze the contribution of gender in the cause and consequence of
HIV and the extent to which gender issues are considered and integrated into HIV policy and programmes
at the national and sub-national level, as well as provide policy recommendations in 2015.
Developments/factors facilitating the achievement of the targets Policy commitment Gender equality is
one of the core concepts of the National AIDS Strategy (NAS) 2014-2016 related to social justice and
“promoting equality in the society through respect and protection of full enjoyment one’s rights and
gender equality”. Gender is incorporated in Strategy 1 of the NAS 2014-2016 by virtue of “expand
rights-based and gender-sensitive comprehensive prevention services for population/risk behavior at
highest risk of HIV transmission.” In addition the Gender Equality Law was presented to the National
Assembly in late 2014 and was approved by the National Assembly in January 2015.
Policy space for participation of women living with HIV In 2014, the Network of WLHIV participated in
policy advocacy for the draft Gender Equality Legislation (GEL) in consultation brokered and supported
by UNWOMEN, including input by Civil Society, for submission to the National Assembly Working
Group for consideration. The Network of WLHIV also participated in consultations to review the progress
of the Beijing Platform for Action adopted at the Fourth World Conference on Women in Beijing, China
in 1995 as well as coordination of inputs on women and health, as brokered and supported by
UNWOMEN, and organized by the Foundation for Women and Social Watch, Thailand. In addition, the
Network of WLHIV also participated in consultation and advocacy forums to identify key issues and to
tender proposals from the women’s groups to the Constitution Drafting Committee, as brokered and
supported by UNWOMEN and the Women’s Reform Network.
Challenges/factors hindering the achievement of the targets The overall challenge hindering the
achievement of the target lies in the lack of follow-through of policy commitment/gender equality in the
policy space for implementation.
Stigma & Discrimination and Rights Violations against WLHIV
• Universal access to ARV and health services, comprehensive services for PLHIV, and options in caring
for one’s health are commendable policies. However, WLHIV still face discriminatory attitudes in service
provision. In many cases, service providers adopt a ‘superior’ position in provision of counseling, and
make decisions for WLHIV, including
1 Article 3: Unjust gender discrimination refers to an action or an omission of action of distinction, exclusion or
restriction of benefits, either direct or indirect that is unjust on grounds of self-identified sex or of sexual expression
that is different from sex at birth.
37
decisions to terminate or continue pregnancy. Regarding prevention, many WLHIV are ‘forced’ to bring
their spouse/intimate partners to receive services. Disclosure of HIV status, as recounted by the majority
of WLHIV, leads to intimate partner violence, both verbal and physical, for ‘infecting’ the
husband/spouse, regardless of the reality. WLHIV whose husband passed away face pressure to leave the
household. Children of WLHIV and girls living with HIV are often stigmatized and discriminated against
by the community.
• WLHIV also face discrimination and stigmatization in the workplace, receiving lower pay than
others/minimum wage and being forced to work in involuntary positions.
Limited Capacities and Policy Platform for Advocacy by the Network of WLHIV While progress has
been made, the Network of WLHIV remains rather weak in their collective capacity for policy advocacy,
influencing gender-sensitive services and addressing discrimination, stigmatization and VAW & IPV.
The Network of WLHIV, which was formed in 1999, remains an informal and loosely formed network,
with a number of committed WLHIV, with technical support mainly from the Raks Thai Foundation.
Identified gaps include inadequate and uneven understanding and exposure to rights, particularly
reproductive health and other rights related to gender equality, women’s human rights, discriminatory
issues, and limited managerial and organizational capacities. The Network is still a small, informal, and
loosely formed operation. The effectiveness of the network ebbs and flows depending on project-based
funding, challenges in recruiting new generations of members of the WLHIV network, as well as the need
to strengthen opportunities and space for formal advocacy at the policy level, with a corresponding
capacity to do so.
Intimate Partner Violence (IPV) Many women living with HIV experience IPV, mostly physical violence,
when disclosing the HIV status to their partners.
No indicators on gender and gender-based violence (GBV)
• Gender issues were incorporated in the review undertaken during the preparation and development of
the National AIDS Strategy 2014-2015. Despite success of having CEDAW and gender mentioned in the
strategy, there is no mechanism to follow up with regards to specific strategies and actions.
• There are no gender-specific indicators. Gender indicators are now under development. However, all
indicators related to gender issues are quantitative and only focused on key affected populations and their
spouses, including discordant couples, and PLHIV. Therefore, it is difficult to capture the situation and
trend of comprehensive gender inequalities in the context of HIV. In addition, there are no indicators to
capture rights violations and discrimination against WLHIV, as well as capturing the risks and
vulnerabilities of women to GBV.
• There are no indicators that capture GBV amongst women and men, violence against women, violence
against people with gender diversity, or violence amongst same-sex couples.
Lack of coordination for the implementation to achieve the targets There is no institutional cross-cutting
mechanism on gender and HIV among the relevant government organizations. While the National
Strategy on HIV/AIDS 2014-2016 encourages using the Convention on the Elimination of All Forms of
Violence against Women (CEDAW) as a direction in HIV and AIDS-related service provision, there is no
clear implementation nor monitoring mechanism for the integration of gender into the rolling out of the
strategy. Similarly, the National Plan on the Advancement of Women 2012-2014 refers to HIV/AIDS in
its
38
Strategy 3 on the Promotion of Well-being, Quality and Security of Life, but primarily from the health
and prevention perspectives. In addition, reference to HIV work in the plan and its implementation
framework is minimal. On top of this, there is no platform nor formal mechanism to coordinate the work
of gender and HIV in Thailand. Given the lack of formal coordination mechanisms on gender and HIV,
there is no platform for policy discussion and recommendations towards a vision of “Getting to Zero
Stigma and Discrimination” for Thailand, a goal for 2016, in which ‘human rights and gender-specific
needs are addressed in all HIV responses’.
Lack of sex-disaggregated data There is no systematic collection of sex-disaggregated data with regard to
IPV beyond married women, violence against women, women’s vulnerabilities to HIV infection or
vulnerabilities of women affected by HIV.
Conclusion VAW and IPV remain a common issue in Thailand, but systemic empirical data on GBV,
either at the national or sub-national levels, is still limited. The NAS still lacks mechanisms to translate
strategy in to the implementation. It is not clear how gender perspective be integrated into the roll-out
strategies.
The Way Forward: Priority Actions
1. Establish a formal platform for coordination of the work on gender and HIV.
Strengthen national coordination among government agencies for the full protection of rights of WLHIV
and their access to gender-sensitive, rights-based and effective services, as well as implementation of the
multi-sectoral coordination mechanism at the provincial level. 2. Strengthen capacity of the national and
sub-national networks of women and girls
living with HIV, including individual and organizational capacity building, and government funding.
Engage the network of women and girls living with HIV in national platforms to amplify their voice and
reduce gender inequality. Engage the network of women and girls living with HIV in the mainstream
work of PLHIV. 3. Improve attitudes of service providers so that they are non-discriminative and
respectful toward WLHIV, and ensure the provision of gender-sensitive services, with participation from
WLHIV. Ensure a comprehensive approach for women’s empowerment in service provision, instead of
taking the social welfare approach. 4. Strengthen accountability frameworks and mechanisms, including
clear targets,
indicators, sex-disaggregated data collection and analysis which will enable reporting under Target 7.
Support active use of strategic information relevant for gender-sensitive services and GBV protection.
39
Target 8 HLM: Eliminate stigma and discrimination against people living with and affected
by HIV through promotion of laws and policies that ensure the full realization of all human rights
and fundamental freedoms by 2015 Thai NASP: Reduce stigma and discrimination by 50% in 2016
Expand the protective social and legal environment essential for HIV prevention and care
National priorities Thailand has identified stigma and discrimination (S&D) as key drivers of epidemic
and barriers in making progress to end the AIDS epidemic. Non-discrimination and promoting human
rights and gender equality remain a priority of Thailand’s HIV response. The national plan focused on
revising laws and policies on drug use, age of consent for HIV testing among young people (<18 years),
health policy related to non-Thais accessing health services, expanding implementation of the national
code of conduct to reduce S&D at workplaces, implementation of “normalizing HIV” and developing and
rolling-out tools to routinely measure HIV-related S&D, and human rights violations.
Achievements by the end of 2014
Political commitment
• Progress was made in revision of certain laws and policies as well as enhanced implementation:
1. The ONCB launched the order and operational plan for implementation of harm reduction in 19
provinces for 2014-15 and the National AIDS Committee (NAC) endorsed the policy and strategies on
Harm reduction for drug user in November 2014. A Task Force was established and serves as a platform
for effective coordination, enhancing collective efforts among all relevant organizations. Nineteen priority
provinces have been identified to implement a comprehensive harm reduction programme, and the
evaluation at the end of the first year of its implementation is to be finalized; 2. An official declaration
was made by the Medical Council of Thailand eliminating the requirement of parental consent for HIV
testing by clients age below 18 years; the NAC acknowledged the statement and has disseminated it
widely;
• Because S&D still exist in many worksites, the Bureau of AIDS and STI, (BATS) worked in close
collaboration with 12 Regional Department of Disease Prevention Control units to reinforce the
implementation of “the national code of conduct” at public workplaces throughout the country. During
the report period, human rights, gender equality and reduction of S&D towards people living with HIV
(PLHIV) were cornerstones of these efforts. 93 workplaces participated an initiative to create workplaces.
These best-practice worksites were acknowledged and received awards at the 2014 National AIDS
Seminar and serve as models for replication. The AIDS Standard Organization (ASO) certification is used
as a tool for promoting good AIDS policy at companies and private workplaces with no HIV testing for
job applicants, and support for HIV+ employees.
• Led by the National AIDS Management Center with strong involvement of civil society, PLHIV and
key population networks, academia and international organizations (RTI/USAID and the UN Joint team
on AIDS) made significant progress on developing tools to routinely measure S&D in various settings,
including the following:
40
1. Successful introduction of six S&D questions including a new indicator that was first introduced in the
2014 Global AIDS Progress Report Guidance on measuring attitudes towards PLHIV among the general
population in a population-based survey for the first time ever; 2. The tool for routinely monitoring S&D
in healthcare settings and among PLHIV, along with the respective manuals, was completed. A total of 51
professionals from 10 regions and 22 provinces were trained in using the tool. Currently, the tool is being
rolled out throughout the country. In particular, eight provinces have committed to participate as the
national sentinel sites to systematically monitor the situation and response toward S&D in healthcare
settings. PLHIV and key populations in the community are fully engaged in the tool development and
roll-out, and its findings are informing stigma-reduction action at the national and sub-national levels; 3.
Completed development of optimal sets of question to be integrated in the integrated biological and
behavioral surveys among key populations (MSM, SW, PWID) and migrant workers.
National financing Results from a pilot study in two provinces showed HIV-related to S&D in health care
settings and among PLHIV are common and very resilient even in a country with a mature epidemic like
Thailand. Health facility staff still displayed a high level of enacted and observed stigma. PLHIV reported
experiencing S&D as well as avoiding health services because they anticipated stigma at the health care
settings. This evidence is critical information and is used to inform design of the national operational
plan. In 2014 the Ministry of Public Health took action in designing a S&D reduction curriculum and
sustained in-service training of health care staff, including enhanced implementation of universal
precautions, and developed communication strategies for raising awareness related to S&D and rights of
PLHIV and key populations. Through the Global Fund/NFM, activities will be implemented in 2015 on
expansion of protective mechanisms in response to human rights violations and S&D in four provinces.
Creating an enabling environment is proposed as one of core approaches under the National Ending AIDS
operational plan for 2015-2019. Securing funding support to implement comprehensive activities as
planned is underway.
Civil society involvement Stigma reduction was at the core of the National AIDS Campaign/ World AIDS
Day activities in 2014. Civil society and communities carried out stigma-reduction campaigns, including
media coverage. The campaign culminated at the National AIDS Seminar. In the build-up to the Seminar,
civil society implemented a series of public awareness and social mobilization campaign activities,
involving media representatives and companies which targeted various audiences. These campaigns
produced and disseminated material in support of provincial campaigns. As a result, CSO-media
partnership grew and public awareness on S&D increased. Throughout 2014, key affected population
networks continued to campaign and disseminate communication materials to promote use of clean
needles and syringes and reduce drug-use- related stigma. NGOs 12D, TDN led the CSO/ community
effort.
Challenges/ factors hindering achievement of the target Revision of some conflicting laws, policies and
harm reduction operational guidelines regarding recreational and illegal drugs is needed. For example, the
harm reduction policy considers drug users as patients while the Criminal Drug Law for 1979 defined
drug users as criminals who
41
must be jailed. Distribution of sterile needles is not yet widely accepted, and this prohibits clean needle
distribution in certain provinces;
Fragmented evidence is available related to various types of drug dependence treatment centers, and this
information would facilitate effective transition towards community-based drug dependence treatment
and supporting services.
Conclusion Progress was made in removing certain legal and policy barriers that impede access to key
services among PLHIV and key populations. Continued efforts are still required to maintain momentum
towards eliminating remaining including ensuring effective implementation at the sub-national level.
Tools for routinely measuring S&D in the general population, health care setting (health facility staff and
PLHIV) and among key populations exist. Rolling out these tools demonstrated has achieved significant
progress. Evidence-informed design and implementation of S&D reduction interventions at the health
care setting and public campaign are occurring.
The way forward: Priority actions
1. Remove conflicting laws and policies related to drug users and sex workers. 2. Develop a ‘reduction of
S&D’ curriculum for health facility staff, and conduct training in selected provinces. In addition, scale up
implementation of national the code of conduct at public and private workplaces. 3. Establish mechanisms
that effectively response to human rights violations, and S&D in
selected provinces including empowering PLHIV and key populations on AIDS rights protection, and
reduce internal stigma. 4. Create the enabling environment with public communication and campaigns to
“normalize HIV”.
Target 9 HLM Eliminate Travel Restriction Thai NSP Thailand has no travel restriction
42
Target 10 HLM: Eliminate parallel systems for HIV-related services to strengthen
integration of the AIDS responses in global health and development efforts Thai NSP: No specific
target
Overview The Global-Fund-supported CHILDLIFE program aims to strengthen the community system
by building capacity and providing support to 1,160 Child Action Groups (CAGs) in 257 districts in 29
provinces. CAGs works as the first-contact point to recruit vulnerable children and assess their needs in
order to provide appropriate services, including referring them to social and protection services. CAGs
also follow up the referred cases in both sectors to ensure the needs are fulfilled. Activities and services
provided by CAGs are child’s camp to provide psychosocial support in groups, quarterly peer-group
support, and training for parents and caretakers, in addition to services given to individual cases based on
special needs. Throughout the three years of the program, a total of 107,200 children affected by AIDS
(CABA) and other vulnerable children (OVC) were reached by the CAGs.
Achievements by the end of 2014
From October 2012 – September 2014, 81,141 children (aged 0 – 18 years) were enrolled into the
CHILDLIFE program and 83% were considered as OVC in accordance with the MSDHS’s definition.
Nearly 70,000 CABA and OVC in the 29 provinces received services under the CHILDLIFE program,
provided by CAGs.
The MSDHS has provided support for people affected by HIV/AIDS including CABA. In 2014, a total of
15,674 children received support from the MSDHS. The support included provision of four orphanage
shelters, located in Bangkok, Chiang Mai, Udonthani and Songkhla, where CABA have received special
support in basic needs including education, child development and foster family placement. A total of 211
CABA were placed in foster families in 2014.
A Child Status Index (CSI) survey was conducted to measure child well-being status and external support
among 902 families with CABA and OVC in five provinces. The survey found that only 29.7% of
children were living in circumstances that could be rated as satisfactory, and 79.1% of families with
CABA and OVC received economic support in the three months prior to the survey.
Challenges / factors hindering the achievement of the targets The cessation of support by the Global Fund
for the CHILDLIFE Project presents the biggest challenge. The linkages among community systems and
government support service systems have only just been initiated. However, there is an on-going effort to
maintain these mechanism using local resources.
Conclusions Strengthening system and collaboration across the sectors (e.g., community, health, and
social protection) as well as reduction of stigma and discrimination towards CABA and OVC is essential.
The end of GF support has created major challenge to promote a community-based holistic care program
for CABA and OVC in the HIV-affected provinces.
43
The Way Forward: Priority Actions
1. Continue functions of Child Action Group through collaboration of the MOPH and MSDHS,
and integrate these functions into the MSDHS structure. 2. Enhance the Provincial Child Protection
Committees (PCPC), which are a legally-binding
mechanism of the MSDHS, to be more proactive in addressing problems of children and youth at
different levels, and translate the Child Protection Act into strategies and action plans at the provincial
level with meaningful participation of the CAGs. 3. Restructure the Child Department under the MSDHS
to be more effective in
implementation of the Child Protection Act; the support should also cover non-Thai children.
44
Summary GARP Indicators for all targets between 2009 and 2014 TARGET 1:
Reduce sexual transmission of HIV HLM Target: Reduce sexual transmission of
HIV by 50% by 2015 Thai NASP: Reduce new HIV infections by 2/3 by 2016
Indicators Indicator Description GARP UA
National target by 2016
2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014
General population
1.1 Percentage of young women and men aged 15-24 who
correctly identify ways of preventing the sexual transmission of HIV and who reject major
misconceptions about HIV transmission
● ● Data not available
1.2 Percentage of young women and men aged 15-24 who
have had sexual intercourse before the age of 15
● ● Data not available
1.3 Percentage of adult (woman and men) aged 15 - 49
who have had sexual intercourse with more than one partner in the past 12 months
● ● Data not available
1.4 Percentage of adult (woman and men) aged 15-49 who have had more than one sexual
partner in the past 12 months who reported the use of a condom during their last sexual
intercourse
● ● Data not available
1.5 Percentage of women and men aged 15-49 who
received an HIV test in the last 12 months and who know their results
● ● Data not available
1.6 Percentage of young people (woman) aged 15-24 who
are living with HIV ● ● 0.33% 0.58% 0.44% 0.44% 0.40% 0.43% 0.52%
45
National Indicators Indicator Description GARP UA
target by
2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014 2016 Sex workers B1 Estimated number of sex workers (man
and woman) ● 141,769 141,769 141,769
Female sex workers
1.7 Percentage of sex workers reached with HIV
prevention programmes
● ● 80.00% 50.45% 53.89% 57.74%
1.8 Percentage of sex workers reporting the use of a
condom with their most recent client
● ● 95.00% 95.56% 93.60% 96.09%
1.9 Percentage of sex workers who have received an HIV
test in the past 12 months and know their results
● ● 90.00% 47.76% 55.60% 54.19%
1.10 Percentage of sex workers who are living with HIV ● ● 1.00% 2.69% 2.16%
1.13% Male sex workers
1.7 Percentage of sex workers reached with HIV
prevention programmes
● ● 80.00% 61.00% 73.77% 64.04%
1.8 Percentage of sex workers reporting the use of a
condom with their most recent client
● ● 99.00% 88.00% 98.18% 95.52%
1.9 Percentage of sex workers who have received an HIV
test in the past 12 months and know their results
● ● 90.00% 49.00% 52.38% 54.37%
1.10 Percentage of sex workers who are living with HIV ● ● 10.20% 16.00%
12.20% 11.66% Man who have sex with man
B2 Estimated number of men who have sex with men
●
550,000 550,000 550,000 1.11 Percentage of men who have sex with men reached
with HIV prevention programmes
● ● 80.00% 43.79% 52.65% 45.92%
1.12 Percentage men reporting the use of a condom the last time they had anal sex with a male
partner
● ● 95.00% 80.22% 85.49% 82.08%
1.13 Percentage of men who have sex with men that have received an HIV test in the past 12
months and know their results
● ● 90.00% 14.93% 25.58% 30.85%
1.14 Percentage of men who have sex with men who are
living with HIV
● ● 6.00% 8.02% 7.13% 9.15%
46
National Indicators Indicator Description GARP UA
target by
2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014 2016 Counseling and testing
1.15 Percentage of health facilities that provide HIV testing
and counseling services ● 100% 100% 100% Number of Health facilities 1324 1365 1480 1.16
Number of women and men aged 15 and older who
received HIV testing and counseling in the past 12 months and know their results (including
pregnant women)
● 1,054,334 1,146,093 1,344,165 1,357,350
Number of HIV+ 22,339 21,907 22,122 22,650 Number
of women and men aged 15 and older who received HIV testing and counseling in the past 12
months and know their results (excluding pregnant women)
● 307,114 356,816 527,373 609,079
Number of HIV+ 17,464 16,984 17,031 18,061 1.16.1
Percentage of health facilities dispensing HIV rapid test kits that experienced a stock-out in the
last 12 months.
● Data not available
Sexually transmitted infections
1.17 Sexually Transmitted Infections (STIs)
1.17.1 Percentage of women accessing antenatal
care (ANC) services who were tested for
● 91.55% 95.78% 96.84%
syphilis at first ANC visit 1.17.2 Percentage of antenatal care attendees who
were positive for syphilis
● 0.06% 0.05% 0.07%
1.17.3 Percentage of antenatal care attendees
positive for syphilis who received treatment
● 93.10% 97.87% 97.79%
1.17.4 Percentage of sex workers with active
syphilis
●
Median 0.26% 0.00% 0.00% NA Mean 0.62% 0.54% 0.69% NA
47
National Indicators Indicator Description GARP UA
target by
2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014 2016 1.17.5 Percentage men who have sex with men
with active syphilis
● Data not available 24.36% NA
1.17.6 Number of adults reported with syphilis
(primary/secondary and latent/unknown) in the past 12 months
● 2,273 2,990
1.17.7 Number of reported congenital syphilis cases
(live births and stillbirths) in the past 12 months
Data not available
1.17.8 Number of men reported with gonorrhea in
the past 12 months
●
Data not available
● 6,409 5,210
1.17.9 Number of men reported with urethral discharge in the past 12 months
● NA NA
1.17.10 Number of adults reported with genital ulcer
disease in the past 12 months
● NA NA
1.19 Diagnosis of HIV and AIDS cases (New 2014)
1.19.1 Number of HIV cases diagnosed by age and
● 40,069 38,602 37,922 54,840 37,287 sex from 2010-2014 (New 2014) 1.19.2 Number
of AIDS cases diagnosed by age and
sex from 2010-2014 (New 2014)
● 28,759 39,753 25,598 27,424 29,627
48
TARGET 2: Reduce transmission of HIV among people who inject drugs HLM
Target: Reduce transmission of HIV among people who inject drugs by 50% by
2015 Thai NASP: Reduce new HIV infections by 2/3 by 2016
Indicator description GARP UA
National target by 2016
2009* 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014
B3 Estimated number of People who inject drugs (PWID)
● 40,300 40,300 40,300 40,300
2.1 Number of Syringes distributed per person who injects drugs
per year by Needle and Syringe Programmes
● ● 88.0 9.79 11.52 12.02 13.79
2.2 Percentage of people who inject drugs who report the use of
a condom at last sexual intercourse
● ● 95.0% 39.18% 46.02% 49.06% 47.16%
2.3 Percentage of people who inject drugs who reported using
sterile injecting equipment the last time they injected ● ● 82.0% 42.02% 77.68% 80.45%
84.88%
2.4 Percentage of people who inject drugs that have received an HIV test in the past 12 months
and know their results
● ● 90.0% 39.99% 40.71% 43.65% 61.15%
2.5 Percentage of people who inject drugs who are living with HIV ● ● 21.0% 17.20% 21.87%
25.20% 19.02% 2.6 Estimated number of opiate users (injectors and non-injectors) Number of
people on opioid Substitution therapy (OST)
2.6a Estimated number of opiate users (injectors and non- injectors)
● Data not available
2.6b Number of people on opioid substitution therapy (OST) ● 4,500 2,201 2,612 3,735
4,068 3,646 2.7 Number of needle and syringe programme (NSP) sites Number of substitution
therapy (OST) sites (WHO)
2.7a Number of needle and syringe programme (NSP) sites ● 39 49 42 36 38 42
2.7b Number of substitution therapy (OST) sites ● 49
Data not available
147 147 147 140
49
TARGET 3: Eliminate mother-to-child transmission of HIV HLM Target:
Eliminate new HIV infections among children by 2015and substantially reduce
AIDS-related
maternal deaths Thai NASP: Vertical transmission of HIV less than 2%
Indicator Description GARP UA
National target by 2016
2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014
3.1 Percentage of HIV-positive pregnant women who received
antiretroviral medicine to reduce the risk of mother-to-child transmission
● ● 98.80% 93.60% 95.00% 94.20% 93.98% 93.75% 95.15% 95.78%
3.1a Percentage of women living with HIV who are
provided with antiretroviral medicines for themselves or their infants during the breastfeeding
period
Indicator not relevant
3.2 Percentage of infants born to HIV-positive women receiving
a virological test for HIV within 2 months of birth
● ● 90.00% 75.80% 73.13% 77.23% 72.87% 76.14%
3.3 Estimated percentage of child infections from HIV-infected
women delivering in the past 12 months
● ● 2.00% 3.75% 3.04% 2.74% 2.30% 2.13%
3.4 Percentage of pregnant women who were tested for HIV and
received their results - during pregnancy, during labour and delivery, and during the post-partum
period (<72 hours), including those with previously known HIV status
● 99.70% 99.30% 99.50% 99.87% 99.14% 99.74% 99.83%
3.5 Percentage of pregnant women attending antenatal care
whose male partner was tested for HIV in the last 12 months ● 60.00% 32.30% 38.41% 41.08%
3.6 Percentage of HIV-infected pregnant women assessed for
ART eligibility through either clinical staging or CD4 testing
● 44.00% 85.56% 88.16% 88.30%
50
National Indicator Description GARP UA
target by
2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014 2016
3.7 Percentage of infants born to HIV-infected women receiving
antiretroviral prophylaxis to reduce the risk of early /mother to child transmission in the first 6
weeks
● 96.50% 99.30% 99.40% 99.00% 99.17% 99.47% 99.48%
3.8 Percentage of infants born to HIV-infected women (HIV-
exposed infants) who are provided with antiretrovirals (either mother or infant) to reduce the risk
of HIV transmission during the breastfeeding period.
● Indicator not relevant
3.9 Percentage of infants born to HIV-infected women started on
cotrimoxazole (CTX) prophylaxis within two months of birth ● 35.90% 42.00% 51.99%
57.34% 52.55%
3.10 Distribution of Outcomes of HIV-Exposed Infants (WHO)
●
3.10.1 Number of infants born to HIV positive mothers
(“HIV-exposed infants”) born in 2013 (or latest data available)
● 4589
3.10.2 Number of infants, born in 2013 (or latest data
available) to HIV positive mothers, classified as indeterminate (i.e.: all lost to follow up, death
before definitive diagnosis, indeterminate lab results)
● 1103
3.10.3 Number of infants born in 2013 (or latest data
available) to HIV positive mothers that are diagnosed as positive for HIV
● 70
3.10.4 Number of infants born to HIV positive mothers in 2013 (or latest data available) that are
diagnosed as negative for HIV
● 3416
3.11 Number of pregnant women attending ANC at least once
during the reporting period
●
772,772 747,967 783,305 804,484 737,150
51
National Indicator Description GARP UA
target by
2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014 2016
3.12 ANC and EID Facilities (WHO)
3.12.1 Number of antenatal care facilities providing HIV
testing and counseling services
●