DETERMINATION OF THE SODIUM CONTRIBUTION OF SOLVENT-

EXTRACTABLE ORGANIC COMPOUNDS IN BAYER PROCESS LIQUOR

Smith TK
Multitrator Pty Ltd, Brisbane, QLD, Australia
Abstract
A thermometric titrimetric procedure has been developed to determine the sodium contribution of solvent extractable
organic compounds in acidified Bayer process liquor. The precision of the method is estimated to be 0.2% RSD.

Introduction Caneiro et al. showed that sharp, highly reproducible endpoints

could be obtained from titrations which otherwise would have
The majority of organic compounds in Bayer process liquor
revealed little or no inflection at the endpoint. The catalytic
are present as their sodium salts. Knowledge of the sodium
indicator is paraformaldehyde, which undergoes an endothermic
contribution of organic compounds in Bayer process liquor
depolymerization with the first trace of excess hydroxyl ions after
is important in seeking causes for organic-related process
all acidic species have been neutralized.
disturbances, evaluating the effect of processes to remove
these compounds and closing sodium mass balances. Modern This work reports on the successful application of this technique
chromatographic procedures such as high performance liquid to the determination of extractable weakly acidic species in Bayer
chromatography (HPLC) and ion chromatography (IC) permit process liquor.
the quantitative determination of lower molecular mass organic
compounds, and it is easy to compute the sodium contribution of Experimental
these compounds to the total sodium content of the liquor. Equipment:
Higher molecular mass organic species have been implicated in • Metrohm 859 Titrotherm thermometric titration interface
a variety of Bayer process disturbances. However, speciation and module
quantification of these compounds present greater challenges, • Metrohm 800 Dosino with 10mL burette
and it is difficult to apportion the sodium contribution that these • Metrohm 802 overhead stirrer, with 804 titration stand
compounds make to the total sodium content of the liquor. This • Metrohm 6.9011.020 Thermoprobe thermometric titration
is so particularly in a process control environment where simpler, probe
more robust analytical instrumentation is preferred. • Metrohm 6.1415.220 glass titration vessel, 90mL.
It is well known that a considerable proportion of these higher Titration operating software:
molecular mass compounds may be extracted into certain non-
aqueous solvents after the liquor has been acidified. It was • Metrohm Titrotherm thermometric titration software, v. 1.0
considered that the gross acid value of the extractable organic
Reagents:
compounds could be determined by a non-aqueous titration with
standard base in a suitable alcohol. By knowledge of the amount • Titrant: 0.1mol/L potassium hydroxide in propan-2-ol,
of base consumed in the neutralization titration, the total sodium prepared from A.R. reagents
contribution of these extractable organic compounds could be • Paraformaldehyde, powder, 95% - Sigma-Aldrich cat. no.
determined. Potentiometric titrations in non-aqueous media 158127
present a number of challenges for the analyst. These include • Benzoic acid, min. 99.5%, Sigma-Aldrich cat. no. B-3250
the dehydration of the necessarily hydrated glass membrane of • Hydrochloric acid, 32% w/v, A.R. grade
the pH electrode, the poor electrical conductivity of such non- • Cyclohexanol, 99%, Sigma-Aldrich cat. no. 105899
aqueous solutions, the frequent and rapid fouling of both the glass • Propan-2-ol, A.R.
membrane and the reference electrode and the sensitivity of the • Saturated sodium chloride solution.
very high impedance pH signal to static electrical disturbances.
Samples:
Thermometric titrimetry offers obvious advantages over
potentiometric titrimetry in non-aqueous media, the relatively low Experiments were conducted on two samples of spent Bayer
impedance sensor requiring no electrical contact with the titration process liquor supplied by two Australian alumina refineries.
media. However, the reaction enthalpy of base with many weakly
Methodology:
acidic species in non-aqueous media is low, and endpoints are
often indistinct and imprecise. Several thermometric titration A 25mL of spent Bayer liquor is pipetted into a 400mL beaker,
techniques involving catalytic indicators have been developed and diluted with 125mL D.I. water. Allow 10 minutes for the
to enhance endpoints (Vaughan and Swithenbank 1965 in pipette to drain properly, due to the viscous nature of the liquor.
Vaughan, 1973, Smith 2003), but none of these has been proven Place on a stirrer, and while stirring, carefully neutralize and then
to have wide ranging industrial application. acidify with 32% w/v hydrochloric until the solution is clear. Cool
the solution, and transfer to a 250mL separating funnel.
A thermometric titrimetric procedure has been developed
recently for the determination of free fatty acids (FFA) in edible Extract this solution with 5 x 25mL aliquots of cyclohexanol,
oils from exotic plants (Carneiro et al., 2002), and this has been allowing adequate time after each extraction for a full separation
extended to cover the determination of FFA in a range of other of the two phases. Return the collected cyclohexanol extract to a
plant and animal fats and oils (Metrohm, 2006). The procedure clean separating funnel, and wash with 10 x 50mL amounts of
has also been found to be very satisfactory for the determination saturated NaCl solution (this aids phase separation, and reduces
of weakly acidic species in mineral oils as Total Acid Number, solubility of cyclohexanol). Quantitatively transfer the washed
or TAN (Metrohm, 2007). By using a catalytic endpoint indicator, cyclohexanol extract to a 200mL volumetric flask, and make to

Proceedings of the 8th International Alumina Quality Workshop • 2008 69

AQW2008_Proceedings_FINAL-1-120.69 69 4/08/2008 2:55:14 AM

 volume with cyclohexanol. Dry the solution overnight in a sealed
container with 50g anhydrous Na2SO4 freshly dried at 120ºC
using a magnetic stirrer to ensure efficient drying.

Depending on the organic content of the original liquor, transfer

25 to 40mL of the dried cyclohexanol extract to a 200mL
volumetric flask, and make to volume with dry A.R. propan-2-
ol. Allow 10 minutes for the pipette to drain properly due to the
viscous nature of the fluid.

Pipette a 30mL aliquot into a titration vessel, allowing to drain

for a timed 3 minutes due to the viscous nature of the fluid.
Add approximately 0.5g of paraformaldehyde, and titrate to a
thermometric endpoint with 0.1 mol/L potassium hydroxide in
propan-2-ol.

Basic titration parameters (applicable to Metrohm 859 Titrotherm Alumina refinery 2

only) Figure 1. Titration of weakly acidic species extracted from alumina refinery
process liquors
Titrant delivery rate (mL/min) 2
Red = direct temperature plot
No. of exothermic endpoints 1 Black = second derivative of direct temperature
Data smoothing factor 75 Tags denote endpoint as determined from second derivative curve.
Stirring speed (802 stirrer) 9
Delay before start (secs) 3 A comparison of typical titration plots illustrated in Figure 1
suggest that the spectrum of organic compounds extracted from
Results and Discussion the spent liquor from alumina refinery 1 might differ from that
1. Replicate analysis of alumina refinery spent liquor, “organic extracted from the liquor from refinery 2. This is suggested by
soda contribution” as g/L Na2CO3 the greater rounding of the endpoint, indicating greater non-
equilibrium behaviour between the weakly acidic species and
From alumina refinery 1 9.92 ± 0.01 (n=6)
the titrant base at the endpoint. Such non-equilibrium behaviour
From alumina refinery 2 18.37 ± 0.04 (n=6)
does not affect the ability of the thermometric titration technique
The analysis has been shown to be highly precise, and thus is very to accurately and precisely locate and endpoint (Bark and Bark,
suitable for following process trends, as well as investigations 1969). For comparison, a thermometric titration plot of benzoic
into organic removal processes. However, this work needs to be acid titrated under the same conditions is illustrated in Figure 2.
followed by an investigation into the range of organic species
which can be extracted under these conditions.

2. Thermometric titration plots

Figure 2. Titration of benzoic acid in propan-2-ol with 0.1 mol/L KOH in

propan-2-ol

3. Choice of extractant
Alumina refinery 1 Cyclohexanol was chosen as the most suitable solvent as an
extractant for the organic species present in the acidified Bayer
process liquor after qualitative tests based on the colour of the
extract suggested that it was superior to toluene.

Conclusions
A highly reproducible procedure has been developed for the
determination of the sodium contribution of acid-extractable
organic species in Bayer process liquor.

References
Vaughan G. A., Thermometric and Enthalpimetric Titrimetry, Van Nostrand Reinhold Company, London, 1973.
Smith T. K., ‘The analysis of free fatty acids in edible oils by catalyzed endpoint thermometric Titrimetry (CETT)’, Journal of the American Oil Chemists
Society, Vol 80, no.1, pp. 21-24, 2003.
Carneiro M. J. D., Feres Júnior M. A., and Godinho O. E. S., ‘Determination of the acidity of oils using paraformaldehyde as a thermometric end-point
indicator’, Journal of the Brazilian Chemical Society, Vol. 13, no. 5, pp. 692-694, 2002.
Application Note H-029, ‘Free fatty acids in edible fats and oils’, Metrohm Limited, 2006.
Application Note H-001,‘Determination of TAN in crude and lubricating oils’, Metrohm Limited, 2007.
Bark L. S. and Bark S. M.,‘Thermometric Titrimetry’, Pergamon Press Oxford, 1969.

70 Proceedings of the 8th International Alumina Quality Workshop • 2008

AQW2008_Proceedings_FINAL-1-120.70 70 4/08/2008 2:55:15 AM