Socio Economic Impact of Women Entrepreneurship
Socio Economic Impact of Women Entrepreneurship
Socio Economic Impact of Women Entrepreneurship
Banglavision
39
1. Introduction
Existing sex ratio in demographic structure of Bangladesh indicates that women comprise
almost 50% of the total population (BBS, 2006). They are essential part of nations human
resources. Due to this demographic structure, the issue of the participation of women in the
mainstream economy is imperative. Without a meaningful and active participation of women,
half of the total population, in regular economic activities, a dynamic and sustainable
economy is impossible. A sustainable economy is a precondition for national growth and
prosperity including institutionalization of a democratic system. It is also impossible to
achieve the target of a poverty-free society without incorporation of women in the
mainstream economy. Womens economic empowerment is an inevitable part of
development discourse. Excluding women from the mainstream development program,
institutionalization of a sustainable development process is just unthinkable. It is inspiring to
mention here that a new womans entrepreneurs class is increasingly emerging each year
taking on the challenge to work in a male-dominated, competitive and complex economic
and business environment (BWCCI, 2008).
Bangladesh is a resource-limited and overpopulated country where society is highly
stratified, services and opportunities are determined by gender, class and location. However,
women make nearly half of the population which means huge potential to be utilized for
socio-economic development of the country. Development and enrichment of women
entrepreneurship are the means of promoting national competitiveness and sustainability. Its
represent the individual and community level initiative and contribution towards the greater
national economy, poverty alleviation models pursued by both the GOs and NGOs consider
the above mentioned phenomenon as one of the prior sector of intervention. Bangladesh is
one of the countries, which rectified the UN Convention on the Elimination of all Forms of
Discrimination against Women (CEDAW). The Constitution of Bangladesh also grants equal
rights to women and men in all spheres of public life [Article 28(1), and 28(3). The
Constitution also keeps an obligation for the state to ensure womens active and meaningful
participation in all spheres of public life (Article-10). Half of the population of Bangladesh is
female and it is very important to engage this segment in greater development of the nation.
For this reason, policies need to be made, with the existing one, to avail the utmost
opportunities. SME entrepreneurship is a vital sector to emphasize by the concerns to
develop the women in contributing the individual, national and thus international arena.
Government of Bangladesh has identified 32 thrust sectors and thus has been formulating
policies for development (Raihan and Haque, 2009). The major initiatives undertaken by the
Government so far include the establishment of a separate ministry on womens affairs, the
formulation of the National Policy for Advancement of Women in 2008, and the National
Action Plan (which was prepared in response to the Beijing Platform for Action). The
Government has also formed a National Women Small and Medium Enterprise (SME)
Forum under the SME Foundation of the Ministry of Industry to promote womens
participation in formal economic sectors. Bangladeshs Poverty Reduction Strategy Paper
(PRSP), which is now the main document for Bangladeshs national development, also
incorporated some noteworthy issues to ensure womens participation in social and economic
life. The industrial and SME policies of 2005 have emphasized women entrepreneurship
development, particularly in the SME sector (BWCCI, 2008).
40
Create friendly and favorable socio economic environment for women entrepreneurs
development;
41
4. Literature Review
Women entrepreneurship has been playing a pivotal role in terms of economic growth
employment generation and industrialization. Although the role of women entrepreneurship
is different at different stages of economic development, their role is particularly important
for developing countries. The following studies focus on various issues related to
entrepreneurship and the socio economic environment in Bangladesh.
In a recent study (Chowdhury, 2008) the author emphasized on the problems faced by the
women entrepreneurs and some of these are in terms of resource, marketing, raw materials,
utility services, infrastructure, official formalities and so forth. Another study (Rahman,
2008) stated that the technological advancement in terms of ICT is the solution of the female
entrepreneurs. Ahmed (2008) analyzed the governmental policies to elevate the overall
scenario of the women entrepreneurs in Bangladesh. Nawazesh (2007), in her research, has
revealed that female entrepreneurs belief that entrepreneurs are made, not born In a nut shell
it can be said that in starting and operating women-run enterprises, the women faced many
problems. The overall scenario can be drawn as follows. They are isolated, disadvantaged,
believe in fate and luck, beyond education opportunities, remain out of employment
opportunities, have no savings, out of supporting niches of the NGOs, extreme poor standing
keep them away from edges and so forth. Mazumder and Choudhury (2001) suggest that
there has been need for an Entrepreneurship Development Institute. Though the authors cited
the overall problems of managing SMEs, they do not provide any specific problems for
women entrepreneurs. They also provide limited suggestion for the removal of problems and
development of SMEs. Karim (2001) points out that illiteracy excludes women entrepreneurs
almost totally from entrepreneurship as they have fewer possibilities to access information
through which they could identify and assess different entrepreneurial opportunities. Also,
their relative ability to exploit an opportunity is severely hampered. Not being able to read,
write and count subjects an individual to two risks: first, a higher probability of being
financially exploited by others and second, a higher probability of having to operate in the
informal sector. Afsar (2008), who collected information from various disbursement reports
of the Bangladesh
Bank, observed that up to December 2007, six financial institutions have disbursed and
refinanced Tk. 3.9 million (about US$56,000) to women entrepreneurs. Comparing this
amount to the total SME funds of Tk. 6.2 billion (about US$90 million), funding for women
entrepreneurs appears highly insignificant (only .06 percent). Nawaz (2009) analyzes a
variety of critical factors of women entrepreneurship development in rural Bangladesh. She
depicts an analytical framework based on institutional theory, which focuses on three kinds
of factors: regulative, normative, and cognitive. Regulative factors refer to different rules and
regulations of the Government that facilitate women entrepreneurship development in rural
Bangladesh. Normative and cognitive factors include norms, rules, regulation, and values of
society. Based on the analysis of these factors, Nawaz provides various policy implications
on how to improve women entrepreneurship development in rural Bangladesh.
42
5. Conceptual Framework
Entrepreneurship can be defined as the process of using private initiatives to transform a
business concept into a new venture or to grow or diversify an existing venture or enterprise.
Women entrepreneurs, for the purpose of this study, can be defined as women running their
own SMEs within the formal or informal sector.
Figure : Conceptual Framework
Women Entrepreneurship
Education
Training
Age
Source of finance
Initial investment
Duration of business
Monthly returns
Use of profit
Social Impact
Upgrade social status
Improved decision making ability
Establish womens rights
Create self-dependency
Eradicate gender discrimination
Self inspiration
Pass leisure time
Economic Impact
Extra income for the family
Economic freedom
Self employment
Economic development
Creating employment opportunity
The framework of this study depicts influences of women entrepreneurship on the social and
economic arena. Women entrepreneurship depends on the variables such as source of capital,
initial investment, training, education Karim (2001) age, business duration and monthly
returns. Women entrepreneurship has a direct and positive impact on womens social status,
womens rights, self dependency, the eradication of gender discrimination, and self
inspiration. At the same time, it has a great impetus on the socio-economic sphere as it helps
women earning extra money for the family, enjoying economic freedom, creating
employment opportunities for themselves and others, and gearing up the process of economic
development. This study will try to establish the relationship between women
entrepreneurship and its impacts on the socio-economic sphere of life. In this research
women entrepreneurship and its socio-economic impact were respectively identified as
independent and dependent variables on the basis of a causal relationship (C. A AlHossienie,2011).
6. Woman Entrepreneurship Development in Bangladesh
It is important to note that nearly half of the total populations in Bangladesh are females. In
more specific, the female entrepreneurs deserve special attention to foster, promote, and
persuade economic growth. In developing countries, the role of various NGOs like BRAC,
Proshika, ASA, Swanirvar etc. for woman entrepreneurship are well-known. They provide
support services mainly to the rural women in income generating activities.
43
44
In all Development Plans, from the First to the last i.e. the Fifth-Five-Year-Plan,
development of women in all spheres of our national life has been given priority
considerations. The First Five Year Plan (1973-78), as for example, emphasized a welfareoriented approach and focused on rehabilitation of war-affected women and children. The
Two-Year-Plan (1978-80) was characterized by a shift from welfare to development efforts.
The Second Five Year Plan (1980-85) emphasized creating a congenial atmosphere for
womens increased participation in development through expanding opportunities for skill
development, credit and entrepreneurship development program. The Third-Five-Year-Plan
(1985-1990) had specific objectives to reduce disparity between development of men and
women. The
Fourth-Five-Year-Plan (1990-95) placed women within the context of macro framework with
multi-sectoral thrust and focused more on the development of poor and disadvantaged
women.
In the Fifth-Five-Year-Plan (1997-2002) as many as 24 goals and objectives are set for
development of women and children in the country. These goals and objectives if
implemented properly will definitely contribute with the participation of women in every
sphere of our national life.
Table 1: Percentage distribution of women entrepreneurs by the year of the
establishment of their enterprises;
Year of
Percentage Cumulative
Establishment
Percentage
1977
1.1
1.1
1982
2.1
3.2
1990
1.1
4.3
1992
3.2
7.5
1993
2.1
9.6
1994
1.1
10.7
1997
5.3
16.0
1999
1.1
17.1
2000
13.8
30.9
2001
2.1
33.0
2002
10.6
43.6
2003
10.6
54.2
2004
7.4
61.6
2005
8.5
70.1
2006
14.9
85.0
2007
15.0
100
Total
100
Source: Bangladesh Women Chamber of Commerce and Industry (BWCCI) 2008, P: 19
45
During 1990s, government and non-government bodies have paid increasing attention to
women entrepreneurs through formulation of various policies and programs and introduction
of new schemes and incentives. It adopted a multi-disciplinary approach for development of
women entrepreneurs. Women entrepreneurs were given top priority for implementation of
programs under agricultural and its allied activities of dairy farming, poultry, handicrafts and
small scale industries, etc. Women were given priorities in all the sectors including small
scale industries sector. In view of the need to bring the rural womenfolk in the development
stream of the economy, the government, the NGOs and others related agencies have provided
ample opportunities to promote entrepreneurial skill among women. As a result, the number
of women entrepreneurs has increased over the years. It is evident from the above data of the
year of establishment of enterprises in the sample were established between the years 20002007. That indicating women are gradually interested in self employed business and
entrepreneurial activities. It also indicating that womens visibility in economic sector is
increasing.
8. Analysis
8.1 Foretaste of Women Entrepreneur Scenario in Bangladesh
Bangladesh is an overpopulated country with limited resources and higher social
stratification. Economic, political and social recognition are determined on the basis of
gender, class and location (WED, 2001). Turban areas have greater opportunities for business
development while rural areas lag behind. Nearly half of the populations are women (sex
ratio 106). The enormous potentiality of the population has been unutilized as few women
participate in the mainstream of economic activities. For instance, only 16% of women are
self-employed out of 66% self-employed citizen (based on entrepreneurship status).
Encouragingly, there is a rising of a new class in rural Bangladesh, they are the women
entrepreneurs who have accepted the challenges of life and have emerged as leaders in the
socio-economic development, thus earning for themselves and for their families and
contributing towards the socio-political upliftment of women. Consequently,
entrepreneurship has become an important profession among women in both rural and urban
areas. Women in rural areas are being self-employed through the agricultural and
nonagricultural sector, as entrepreneurs (L. Parvin, J Jinrong and M. W. Rahman,2012).
These activities are cropping, livestock and poultry rearing, fish farming, nursery and tree
planting, tool making, handcrafting, food processing, tailoring, rice processing, etc.
Nevertheless, it is very difficult to quantify the contribution of micro, small and medium
enterprises (MSMEs), particularly estimation of the contribution of women due to lack of
available data. Alam and Miyagi (2004) reported that MSMEs contribute Tk. 741 billion
(US$10.15 billion), which is equivalent to 20 to 25% of gross domestic product (GDP).
About 40% of the populations (above 15 years old) are employed in this sector in both rural
and urban areas. The International Consulting Group (ICG) comprehensive survey in 2003;
46
Less than
Tk. 1 million
Small enterprise
Less than
Tk. 50,000 to
Tk,
15 5 million
million
Medium enterprise
Commerce and 25 to
service,
workers
manufacturing,
transportation
and construction
etc.
100 Tk. 15 to
100 million
Av.
bank
loans- Tk.
408,081, and
MFIs
Tk.
38,250
5 million and
above
47
2003-04
2004-05
2005-06
2006-07
2007-08
Small and
Cottage
Industry
11496.5
12408.5
13551.5
14865.1
16090.9
Medium
to Large
Industry
27572.3
29860.5
33268.2
36507.1
39142.4
Total
39068.8
42269.0
46819.7
51372.2
55233.3
60000
50000
40000
30000
20000
10000
0
Small and
Cottage Industry
Medium to Large
Industry
20 20 20 20 20
03- 04- 05- 06- 0704 05 06 07 08
Total
Series1
1000
500
0
2003- 2004- 2005- 2006- 200704
05
06
07
08
48
Total contribution
to GDP (in million
Tk.)
Percent of
total
contribution
Agriculture
4993.71
18
Fishing
94.28
Manufacturing
1397.36
50
Construction
75.38
4227.38
15
Hotels, restaurants
2370.61
327.72
514.19
338.15
Other services
308.54
Total
14309.17
100
49
Poverty Reduction Strategy Paper, 2004, a follow up policy initiative in line with MGDs but
comprehensive than that of previous ones. It states about the different entrepreneur-friendly
setting ups for women. Some statements are given below as examples-Improving Business
Support Services, Setting up Information bank on private investment, Ensuring women rights
and advancement, Mainstreaming gender issues in agriculture, rural development and labor
market, Ensuring female education starting from the primary level, Enhancing good quality
employment and Emphasizing on female health, hygiene etc.
10. Support Services for Women Entrepreneurship Development
Different types of organizations provide either direct or indirect supports to women
entrepreneurs besides the government. Among various supporting organizations, the financial
institutions are considered most important. A list of supporting organizations is given
subsequently but only government policy supports and financial institutions supports are
illustrated broadly. (a) Bangladesh Small and Cottage Industries Corporation (BSCIC) (b)
Bangladesh Bank (c) State and private commercial banks (d) Financial institutions (e)
Bangladesh Rural Development Board (BRDB) (f) Bangladesh Management Development
Institute (BMDI) (g) Directorate of Women Affairs (DWA) (h) Development of Youth
Development (DYD) (i) Bangladesh Manpower Training Bureau (BMTB) (j) Microindustries Development and Assistance Services (MIDAS) (k) Job Opportunities and
Business Support (JOBS) and (l) NGO-MFIs MSME program
11. Motivating Factors to be Women Entrepreneurs
Factors that encourage women to be an entrepreneur; Inspiration factors are; i) To create selfdependency ii) Extra income for the family iii) Self inspiration Self employment iv)
Inspiration by friends v) For economic freedom vi) To upgrade social status vii) Pass leisure
time vii) Economic development viii)Inspiration from some organizations ix) No alternative
to have a job x) Inspired by training xi)To establish womens rights xii) Eradicate gender
discrimination xiii) Creating opportunity for others
12. Key Challenges for the Women Entrepreneurs:
Existence challenges discussed in a recent report (Chowdhury, 2008) are as follows.
12.1 From the aspect of demand side:
(a) Fear of being rejected, unwillingness to have collaterals from partners, doubts about
defending the project (b) Lack of knowledge on different available options of financing
scheme (c)Lack of appropriate skills to evaluate the business especially those in the informal
sectors (d) Complex procedure in the institutional level (e) Sometimes gender biasness of the
male officers (f) Complicated arrangement in legalizing and formalization of business (g)
Inadequate technical knowledge and managerial experience which make it difficult foe them
to sustain in the competitive market (i) High cost of credit (j) Weak and poorly enforced
credit rights in the country and (k)Lack of effective policies and infrastructure to expedite
their economic activities.
50
Female
(%)
Male
(%)
Mixed
(%)
Agriculture
18
25
29
Fishing
01
04
06
47
14
23
Manufacturing
handicrafts)
(Boutiques,
Total
Female (%) 18 1
47 0 23 7 1 1 0 1
Construction
00
01
03
23
42
25
Male (%) 25 4 14 1
42 5 1 3 1 3
07
05
11
Mixed (%) 29 6 23
3 25 11 0 4 0 --
Transport,
storage
communication
and
01
01
00
and
01
03
04
00
01
00
01
03
--
Total
100
100
100
Source: Deniels, Lisa, October (2003) Figure 03: The number (in %) of men and women
Entrepreneurs
12.3 Factors hindering marketing of the product
The women entrepreneurs interviewed were asked to describe their perception about the
factors that were hindering proper marketing of their products. The major opinions were as
(a) Lack of proper training (b) Lack of raw materials (c) Lack of capital (d) Social barriers
(e0Unsecured communication system (f) Lack of efficient workers (g) Sexual harassment (h)
Family restriction (i) Religious beliefs and traditional customs (j) Lack of linkage with
national and international market (l)Failure to recover cost and (m) Lack of market
information
51
52
53
Separate banks may be established for women entrepreneurs and for the other banks;
an obligation may be imposed to maintain a minimum quota for the underprivileged
women entrepreneurs.
A comprehensive credit policy should be initiated under the direct supervision of the
central bank in order to create access of women entrepreneurs to finance. The policy
must keep a provision of collateral free loan, credit without interest or low rate of
interest, loan for long time duration etc.
Proper coordination, necessary fund and trained staff should be provided by the GOs
and NGOs to improve service delivery mechanisms.
54
The central bank should fix up a target for each bank to provide loan for women
owned enterprises and form a monitoring team to monitor the implementation of its
circular.
National Action Plan for the development of women entrepreneurship should make
provision for undertaking necessary steps to feed women entrepreneurs with
resources.
Ensuring timely implementation of the Policies of National Action Plan.
Ensuring Implementation are regular monitoring of the Beijing UN Convention
Women Development
Women entrepreneurship is not only a source of income generation but also a way of
achieving economic independence. Realizing the importance of women entrepreneurship,
Bangladesh government has taken several initiatives to encourage women getting involved in
various micros, small and medium enterprises. Women have now become aware of their
socio-economic rights and have ventured to avail the opportunities initiated for them. It is
impossible to achieve the target of a poverty-free society without incorporation of women in
the mainstream economy. Considering the issue, a special emphasis has been given by the
Government, donor agencies, NGOs, business community and all other relevant stakeholders
through different interventions to ensure increased womens participation in formal economic
sectors, especially in business and industry.
55
References:
Ahmed, M. U. (2008), The Women SME Entrepreneurs and Business Leaders of
Bangladesh Speak for Themselves paper presented on the 2nd National SME Women
Enterpreneurs Conference, pp. 71-72
Ahmed, M. (1993). Growth of Industrial Entrepreneurship in Bangladesh: A Study Of bank
financed Engineering Industries. (Unpublished Doctoral Dissertation). Institute of
Bangladesh Studies, Rajshahi University, Rajshahi.
Afrin, Sharmina; Nazrul Islam; and Shahid Uddin Ahmed (2008) A Multivariate Model of
Micro Credit and Rural Women Entrepreneurship Development in Bangladesh,
International Journal of Business and Management, Vol.3, No. 8 (August), pp. 169-185.
A. Sultana (2012), Promoting Womens Entrepreneurship through SME: Growth and
Development in the context of Bangladesh, IOSR Journal of Business and Management
(IOSRJBM) ISSN: 2278-487X Volume 4, Issue 1 (Sep,-Oct. 2012), PP 18-29,
www.iosrjournals.org
ADB project Report Sep 2009; Promoting Women's Entrepreneurship in Bangladesh.
Aktaruddin, M. (1999) A Case Study of Some Successful and Unsuccessful Entrepreneurs
in Bangladesh, Journal of Business Administration, Vol.25, pp. 89-126.
Alam MS, Ullah MA (2006). SMEs in Bangladesh and Their Financing: An Analysis and
Some Recommendations, The Cost and Management. 34(3): 57-72.
Abdul Awal (2006) SMEs in Bangladesh, CACCI Journal, Vol. 1, pp. 1-19
According to the Statistical Pocket Book, published by the Bangladesh Bureau of Statistics in
2006, the sex ratio is105 per 100 female. Local Business Dynamic: Ground Realities and
Policies Challenges, PPRC, Dhaka, 2006, pg. 23.
Bangladesh Women Chamber of Commerce and Industry (BWCCI), Bangladesh Women
Chamber of Commerce and Industry (BWCCI), February 2008
BBS (2009). Bangladesh Bureau of Statistics, Statistical Division, Ministry of planning,
Government of the Peoples Republic of Bangladesh.
BER (2011). Bangladesh Economic Review, Economic Division, Ministry of Finance,
Government of the Peoples Republic of Bangladesh, Dhaka (In Bengali).
BIDS (2010). Recent Performance of the Bangladesh Economy- An Assessment of the State
of the Economy and Short-Term Outlook 2009-10,
BMS (2008). Bangladesh Microfinance Statistics, Credit and Development Forum (CDF) &
Institute of Microfinance (InM), Dhaka, Bangladesh.
BMS (2009). Bangladesh Microfinance Statistics, Credit and Development Forum (CDF) &
Institute of Microfinance (InM), Dhaka,Bangladesh
Begum, A., & Islam, Z. H. (2006). Role of NGOs in poverty alleviation in Bangladesh: An
Overview. Asian Studies, 25, 71-75.
Brush and Hisrich (1999) women represent a rapidly growing group in the small business
sector, and one reason for why womens entrepreneurship is rapidly growing is that it has
started from a relatively small base.
56
57
Momen, Md. Nurul and Mst. Marzina Begum (2006) Impact of Micro Credit Program for
Women Development in Bangladesh: A Case Study of BRAC, Asian Journal of Information
Technology, Vol. 5, No. 11, pp 1269-1283 Morshed, S. F. (2008), Current Policy
Regulations: Challenges and Opportunities for Women SMEs in Bangladesh, Paper
presented on 2nd National SME Women Entrepreneurs Conference, Dhaka, p. 18,Ibid. p. 19
MIFA (2009). Bangladesh Microfinance and financial sector diagnostic study, Final report,
2008. MIFA- promoting microfinance in Asia, IFC, Washington Dc, USA
Nawaz, Faraha (2009) Critical Factors of Women Entrepreneurship Development in Rural
Bangladesh, Bangladesh Development Research Working Paper Series (BDRWPS),
Nawazesh, N. (2007), Entrepreneurship: A New Platform for the Disabled?, Dhaka
University Journal of Business Studies, Vol. XXVIII, No. 2, p. 13
Pervin, S., & Akther, R. (2002). Problem and Prospects of entrepreneurship development in
Bangladesh. University Press Ltd.
Rahaman, M., Hossain, I., & Miah, A. S. (2000). Problems of Women Entrepreneurship
Development: A Study of Grameen Bank Finance on Some Selected Areas. Islamic
University Studies, 3, 120-133.
Rahman, H. (2001). Entrepreneurship Development. University Grants Commission of
Bangladesh. Rajshahi Krishi Unnayan Bank, Annual Report 2004-05.Raihan, S and Haque,
A. K. Iftekharul (2009), A Critical Observation on Some Major Governmental Policies,
Bangladesh Economic Outlook, Vol. 2, No. 2, p. 7 Rahman, M. M. (2008), ICT for Women
Entrepreneurs in Bangladesh, paper presented on the 2nd National SME Women
Enterpreneurs Conference, pp. 45-521
Bangladesh Women Chamber of Commerce and Industry (BWCCI), (2008)
Saleh, Abu (1995) A Profile of the Women Entrepreneurship in Bangladesh, Journal of
Business Studies (of Dhaka University), Vol. 16, No.1 (June), pp, 159-170.
Sultana, N. (2006). The role of NGOs in Increasing awareness among vulnerable women in
Bangladesh: A study on two selected NGOs in Rajshahi. (Unpublished M. Phil Paper).
Department of Public Administration, University of Rajshahi.
Tambunan T (2009). Women entrepreneurship in Asian developing countries: Their
development and main constraints, J. Dev. Agric. Econ., 1(2): 27-40.
The Constitution of the Peoples Republic of Bangladesh, published by The British Council,
Dhaka
Ullah, A. (2003). Empowerment of women in Bangladesh: Do NGO Intervention Matter?
Empowerment, 10, 21-32.
UNPD (2010). Power, Voice and Rights: A turning point for gender equality in Asia and the
Pacific, United Nations Development Programs.
WED (2001). Economic Policy Paper on Women Entrepreneurs in Bangladesh, Dhaka
Bangladesh.African Journal of Business Management Vol. 6(11), pp. 3862-3871, 21 March,
2012 World Bank (1999), World Bank Report
Zareen, & Kabir. (2003). BRACs Intervention in poverty alleviation: A Partial Profile.
Empowerment, 10, 93-118.