Liberty Mutual Complaint

UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT
for the
SOUTHERN DISTRICT OF GEORGIA

THE MAYOR AND ALDERMEN OF )
THE CITY OF SAVANNAH, GEORGIA )
)
Plaintiff, )
)
v. ) Civil Action No. 4:13-cv-00226
)
LIBERTY MUTUAL INSURANCE )
COMPANY )
)
Defendant. )

NOTICE OF A LAWSUIT
AND REQUEST TO WAIVE SERVICE OF A SUMMONS

To: Liberty Mutual Insurance Company, c/o Corporation Service Company, 40 Technology
Parkway South, Suite 300, Norcross, Georgia 30092.

Why are you getting this?

A lawsuit has been filed against you, or the entity you represent, in this court under the
number shown above. A copy of the complaint is attached.

This is not a summons, or an official notice from the court. It is a request that, to avoid
expenses, you waive formal service of a summons by signing and returning the enclosed waiver.
To avoid these expenses, you must return the signed waiver within 30 days from the date shown
below, which is the date this notice was sent. Two copies of the waiver form are enclosed, along
with a stamped, self-addressed envelope or other prepaid means for returning one copy. You
may keep the other copy.

What happens next?

If you return the signed waiver, I will file it with the court. The action will then proceed
as if you had been served on the date the waiver is filed, but no summons will be served on you
and you will have 60 days from the date this notice is sent (see the date below) to answer the
complaint (or 90 days if this notice is sent to you outside any judicial district of the United
States).

If you do not return the signed waiver within the time indicated, I will arrange to have the
summons and complaint served on you. And I will ask the court to require you, or the entity you
represent, to pay the expenses of making service.
2
Please read the enclosed statement about the duty to avoid unnecessary expenses.

I certify that this request is being sent to you on the date below.

Date: October 8, 2013
W. BROOKS STILLWELL
City Attorney
State Bar No.: 682500

J ENNIFER N. HERMAN
Assistant City Attorney
OFFICE OF THE CITY ATTORNEY
P.O. Box 1027
Savannah, GA 31402
(912) 525-3092 telephone
(912) 525-3267 facsimile
[email protected]
[email protected]

OLIVER MANER LLP

DOUGLAS E. HERMAN
__/s/ Douglas E. Herman
Georgia Bar No. 076219
Oliver Maner LLP T. LAWRENCE EVANS
218 West State Street Georgia Bar No. 419077
P.O. Box 10186 Attorneys for Plaintiff, The Mayor and Alderman of
Savannah, GA 31412 The City of Savannah, Georgia.
(912) 236-3311
[email protected]
[email protected]

for the

)
Plaintiff, )
)
)
COMPANY )
)
Defendant. )

WAIVER OF THE SERVICE OF SUMMONS

To: OLIVER MANER LLP, Attn: Douglas E. Herman, Esq., P.O. Box 10186, Savannah, GA
31412

I have received your request to waive service of a summons in this action along with a copy
of the complaint, two copies of this waiver form, and a prepaid means of returning one signed copy
of the form to you.

I, or the entity I represent, agree to save the expense of serving a summons and complaint in
this case.

I understand that I, or the entity I represent, will keep all defenses or objections to the
lawsuit, the court's jurisdiction, and the venue of the action, but that I waive any objections to the
absence of a summons or of service.

I also understand that I, or the entity I represent, must file and serve an answer or a motion
under Rule 12 within 60 days from October 8, 2013, the date when this request was sent (or 90 days
if it was sent outside the United States). If I fail to do so, a default judgment will be entered against
me or the entity I represent.

Date: ____________________
MILLS PASKERT DIVERS

________________________________________
KEITH LICHTMAN
1355 Peachtree Street NE
Suite 1550
Atlanta, GA 30309
[email protected]
(404) 870-8200
Attorney for Liberty Mutual Insurance Company
Duty to Avoid Unnecessary Expenses of Serving a Summons

Rule 4 of the Federal Rules of Civil Procedure requires certain defendants to cooperate in
saving unnecessary expenses of serving a summons and complaint. A defendant who is located in
the United States and who fails to return a signed waiver of service requested by a plaintiff located
in the United States will be required to pay the expenses of service, unless the defendant shows
good cause for the failure.

"Good cause" does not include a belief that the lawsuit is groundless, or that it has been
brought in an improper venue, or that the court has no jurisdiction over this matter or over the
defendant or the defendant's property.

If the waiver is signed and returned, you can still make these and all other defenses and
objections, but you cannot object to the absence of a summons or of service.

If you waive service, then you must, within the time specified on the waiver form, serve an
answer or a motion under Rule 12 on the plaintiff and file a copy with the court. By signing and
returning the waiver form, you are allowed more time to respond than if a summons had been
served.
for the

)
Plaintiff, )
)
)
COMPANY )
)
Defendant. )

WAIVER OF THE SERVICE OF SUMMONS

To: OLIVER MANER LLP, Attn: Douglas E. Herman, Esq., P.O. Box 10186, Savannah, GA
31412

I have received your request to waive service of a summons in this action along with a copy
of the complaint, two copies of this waiver form, and a prepaid means of returning one signed copy
of the form to you.

I, or the entity I represent, agree to save the expense of serving a summons and complaint in
this case.

I understand that I, or the entity I represent, will keep all defenses or objections to the
lawsuit, the court's jurisdiction, and the venue of the action, but that I waive any objections to the
absence of a summons or of service.

I also understand that I, or the entity I represent, must file and serve an answer or a motion
under Rule 12 within 60 days from October 8, 2013, the date when this request was sent (or 90 days
if it was sent outside the United States). If I fail to do so, a default judgment will be entered against
me or the entity I represent.

Date: ____________________
MILLS PASKERT DIVERS

________________________________________
KEITH LICHTMAN
1355 Peachtree Street NE
Suite 1550
Atlanta, GA 30309
[email protected]
(404) 870-8200
Attorney for Liberty Mutual Insurance Company
Duty to Avoid Unnecessary Expenses of Serving a Summons

Rule 4 of the Federal Rules of Civil Procedure requires certain defendants to cooperate in
saving unnecessary expenses of serving a summons and complaint. A defendant who is located in
the United States and who fails to return a signed waiver of service requested by a plaintiff located
in the United States will be required to pay the expenses of service, unless the defendant shows
good cause for the failure.

"Good cause" does not include a belief that the lawsuit is groundless, or that it has been
brought in an improper venue, or that the court has no jurisdiction over this matter or over the
defendant or the defendant's property.

If the waiver is signed and returned, you can still make these and all other defenses and
objections, but you cannot object to the absence of a summons or of service.

If you waive service, then you must, within the time specified on the waiver form, serve an
answer or a motion under Rule 12 on the plaintiff and file a copy with the court. By signing and
returning the waiver form, you are allowed more time to respond than if a summons had been
served.
IN THE UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT
SAVANNAH DIVISION
)
Plaintiff, )
)
v. ) Civil Action No. _______________
)
LIBERTY MUTUAL INSURANCE ) Jury Trial Demanded
COMPANY )
)
Defendant. )

COMPLAINT

COMES NOW Plaintiff, The Mayor and Aldermen of the City of Savannah, Georgia, and
asserts the following claims against Defendant, Liberty Mutual Insurance Company, and in
support thereof, shows this Court the following:
1. Plaintiff, The Mayor and Alderman of the City of Savannah, Georgia (hereinafter,
Plaintiff or the City), is a municipal corporation organized and existing under the laws of the
State of Georgia, with its principal office in Savannah, Georgia.
Parties
2. Defendant, Liberty Mutual Insurance Company (hereinafter, Defendant or
Liberty Mutual), is a corporation organized and existing under the laws of the State of
Massachusetts, with its principal office and legal citizenship at 175 Berkeley Street, Boston,
Massachusetts 02116. Liberty Mutual transacts business in the Southern District of Georgia and
is subject to service of process through its registered agent, Corporation Service Company, at 40
Technology Parkway South, Suite 300, Norcross, Georgia 30092.

Case 4:13-tc-05000 Document 81 Filed 10/08/13 Page 1 of 12 Case 4:13-cv-00226-WTM-GRS Document 1 Filed 10/08/13 Page 1 of 12
2

3. This Court possesses original diversity jurisdiction over this civil action pursuant
to 28 U.S.C. 1332 because Plaintiff and Defendant are citizens of different states and the
amount in controversy exceeds the sum of $75,000.00.
Jurisdiction and Venue
4. This Court possesses personal jurisdiction over Defendant because Defendant
transacts business in this judicial district and because it breached a contract entered into in this
judicial district for purposes of guaranteeing performance of the construction of improvements
on real property located in this judicial district.
5. Venue is proper in this Court pursuant to 28 U.S.C. 1391(b) because the events
and omissions giving rise to this civil action occurred in this judicial district and because the real
property that is the subject of this civil action is situated in this judicial district.
6. Plaintiff incorporates by reference the averments set forth in paragraphs 1-5 above
as though they were set forth at length hereunder.
Factual Background
7. On or about August 22, 2007, the City entered into a Development Agreement
with ALR Oglethorpe, LLC, a Georgia limited liability company (hereinafter, ALR), which
provided that ALR, as owner and developer, agreed to develop certain infrastructure (the
Infrastructure) on property owned by it, located along the banks of the Savannah River in
Savannah, Georgia and commonly known as Savannah River Landing (the Property), and to
convey to the City certain portions of the Property to be used as public spaces and rights of way.
8. In exchange, the City agreed to convey to ALR certain unopened street rights-of-
way then existing within the Property and to install and maintain certain landscaping,
hardscaping and lighting on the portions of the Property to be conveyed by ALR to the City. A
3

true and correct copy of the Development Agreement and Amendments thereto are attached
hereto and collectively marked as Exhibit A.
9. The Development Agreement defined the term Owner to mean ALR
Oglethorpe, LLC, a Georgia limited liability company, or its successors or assigns. See
(Exhibit A, Development Agreement at Article 2, Definitions) (emphasis supplied).
10. The Development Agreement defined the term Developer to mean Owner
[ALR] and all successors in title or lessees of the Owner who undertake Development of the
Property or who are transferred Development Rights. See (Id.) (emphasis supplied).
11. The Development Agreement, and the Citys applicable Zoning Regulations,
which were incorporated by reference into the Development Agreement, required ALR, as
Owner and Developer, to obtain the following performance bonds ensuring ALRs performance
under the Development Agreement:
5.2.1 Bonds for the installation of all roads, drainage, and related water and
sewer improvements, necessary to serve all lots shown on any Plat, shall
be provided to the City at the time the Plat is submitted to the City for
approval.
5.2.2 Bonds for the installation of all sidewalks, landscape and street lights
shall be submitted on a Parcel by Parcel basis at the time a Land
Disturbance Activity permit is requested for the parcel.
5.2.3 Bonds for the installation of landscape / hardscape work at each
individual public park as set forth in the Civic Master Plan shall be
provided at the time the Plat, which shows such public park, is submitted
to the City for approval.
See (Id. at 5.2).
12. Ambling Construction Company, LLC (Ambling) is a limited liability company
organized under the laws of the State of Georgia. Ambling and ALR share the same principal
office address, registered agent address and registered agent. A true and correct copy of the
4

corporate registration information maintained by the Georgia Secretary of State with respect to
Ambling and ALR is attached hereto as Exhibit B.
13. Upon information and belief, Ambling and ALR share a complete or substantially
similar identity of ownership.
14. Upon information and belief, Ambling is a successor, assign or alter ego of ALR,
and/or ALR transferred Development Rights under the Development Agreement to Ambling.
15. On January 11, 2008, Ambling obtained three (3) separate Construction Bonds
that were were issued by Liberty Mutual, and pursuant thereto, Ambling and Liberty Mutual
were bound, as Principal and Surety, respectively, to the City, as Obligee, for the completion of
the Infrastructure outlined in the Development Agreement. True and correct copies of each of the
Construction Bonds are attached hereto as follows:
a) Bond No. 016035629 in the sum of $1,903,101.90 Exhibit C;
b) Bond No. 016035628 in the sum of $653,358.35 Exhibit D;
c) Bond No. 016035630 in the sum of $653,358.35 Exhibit E.
16. The three (3) Construction Bonds specifically provide that they are intended to
secure performance of the projects identified as Infrastructure at Savannah River Landing (OP-
132-06) Phase 1A; Infrastructure at Savannah River Landing (OP-132-06) Phase 1B; and
Infrastructure at Savannah River Landing (OP-132-06) Phase 1C. See (Exhibits C, D and
E, Construction Bonds).
17. The three (3) Construction Bonds contain designations of OP-132-06, which is
the Capital Improvements Project (CIP) Number for the Savannah River Landing project, as
assigned by the City, and reflected in the referenced the Development Agreement.
5

18. The Phases covered by each of the Construction Bonds are reflected in the
Savannah River Landing site maps, with overlays, attached hereto as Exhibits F, G and H,
respectively. See (Id.).
19. Upon information and belief, in connection with the issuance of the Construction
Bonds, Liberty Mutual was supplied with a copy of the Development Agreement and
Amendments thereto (collectively marked as Exhibit A), was advised that the Construction
Bonds were being sought by Ambling in order to satisfy ALRs obligations pursuant to the
Development Agreement, and was afforded an opportunity to conduct appropriate due diligence
with respect to ALR and Ambling.
20. Ambling commenced construction of the Infrastructure on or about December 7,
2006. Ambling ceased construction of the Infrastructure in or about September of 2008.
21. Upon information and belief, ALR did not complete any relevant construction of
the Infrastructure, nor did it obtain any applicable bonds securing such performance.
22. After Ambling ceased work on the project, the City determined that Ambling had
materially breached the Development Agreement and the Amendments thereto by failing to
properly construct the Infrastructure in the manner required by the Development Agreement.
The deficient and incomplete work was catalogued as accurately as possible at this juncture, at
the Citys direction. A true and correct inventory of those items identified by the Citys agents is
attached hereto and marked as Exhibit I.
23. On August 25, 2011, the City supplied ALR and Ambling with written notice of
their collective failures. A true and correct copy of the default notice letter is attached hereto as
Exhibit I. Neither ALR nor Ambling attempted to cure the specified failures within ten (10)
6

days of said notice, thereby placing ALR and Ambling in default under the Development
Agreement. See (Exhibit A, Development Agreement at 9.1).
24. The City declared ALR and Ambling to be in default under the Development
Agreement and, in correspondence dated October 17, 2011, notified Defendant: (a) that
ALR/Ambling was in default and (b) that the City was exercising its rights and demanding
payment pursuant to the three referenced Construction Bonds. A true and correct copy of the
October 17, 2011 correspondence to Defendant is attached hereto as Exhibit K.
25. On June 5, 2012, Defendant sent correspondence to the City, advising that it was
refusing to pay the submitted claims. A true and correct copy of the June 5, 2012
correspondence to Plaintiff, with enclosures, is attached hereto as Exhibit L.
26. In its correspondence of June 5, 2012, Defendant incorporated by reference the
purported defenses raised by Ambling, as Principal under the Construction Bonds. See (Exhibit
L).
27. Defendant and Ambling contended that Ambling Construction had no agreement
whatsoever with the Claimant [i.e., Plaintiff] or the Owner [i.e., ALR] to construct any
improvements for the Project, and as such, Defendant contends that the bonds have nothing to
guarantee and, therefore, have no force or effect. See (Id.).
28. Defendant has not asserted, at any time prior to the filing of this Complaint, that
the construction deficiencies and failures do not exist, and that the breaches of ALR/Ambling are
not material.
29. More than sixty (60) days have elapsed following the Citys notice to Defendant
of its claims and its demand for payment of the same.
7

30. At the filing of this Complaint, Defendant has not paid any amount to Plaintiff
pursuant to its obligations under the three (3) referenced Construction Bonds.
31. Plaintiff incorporates by reference hereunder the averments contained in
paragraphs 1-30, above.
Count I - Breach of Construction Bond Obligations Phase 1A
32. Ambling undertook to perform the obligations of ALR pursuant to the
Development Agreement.
33. Defendant, as Surety pursuant to Construction Bond 016035629, guaranteed the
performance of Ambling pursuant to the terms of the Development Agreement (which
Development Agreement was incorporated by reference into the Construction Bonds) for Phase
1A work. See (Exhibits C and F).
34. Ambling defaulted pursuant to the terms of the Development Agreement, thereby
triggering Defendants obligations to issue payments to Plaintiff, as Obligee, pursuant to the
Construction Bond 016035629.
35. Plaintiff has demanded payment from Defendant pursuant to said Construction
Bond, and said demand for payment has been denied by Defendant.
36. Defendants refusal to pay pursuant to its obligations under said Construction
Bond constitutes a material breach of Defendants contractual obligations.
37. Defendants breach has caused Plaintiff substantial monetary harm, and Plaintiff
is therefore entitled to recover the full amount of its losses occasioned thereby.
Count II - Breach of Construction Bond Obligations Phase 1B
8

1B work. See (Exhibits D and G).
Count III - Breach of Construction Bond Obligations Phase 1C
9

1A work. See (Exhibits E and H).
Count IV - Bad Faith
53. Upon information and belief, Ambling and ALR share a complete or substantial
identity of ownership.
54. Upon information and belief, Ambling is an alter ego entity to ALR.
55. Upon information and belief, ALR assigned its development rights pursuant to the
Development Agreement to Ambling.
56. Upon information and belief, Ambling is a successor in interest to ALR.
57. The Construction Bonds issued by Defendant specify that the Bonds guarantee the
performance of Ambling pursuant to the project designated as Savannah River Landing and
reference the City of Savannahs Capital Improvement Project (CIP) designation of OP-132-
10

06 for the Savannah River Landing Project. See (Exhibits C, D and E, Construction
Bonds).
58. Upon information and belief, in connection with the issuance of the Construction
Bonds, Liberty Mutual was supplied with a copy of the Development Agreement, was advised
that the Construction Bonds were being sought by Ambling in order to satisfy ALRs obligations
pursuant to the Development Agreement, and was afforded an opportunity to conduct
appropriate due diligence with respect to ALR and Ambling.
59. More than sixty (60) days have elapsed, without payment, since Plaintiff notified
Defendant of Plaintiffs claims pursuant to the Construction Bonds and made demand for
payment of same.
60. Defendants purported reason for denying Plaintiffs claims i.e. that Ambling
Construction had no agreement whatsoever with the Claimant [Plaintiff] or the Owner [ALR] to
construct any improvements for the Project and, consequently, that the bonds have nothing to
guarantee and, therefore, have no force or effect is an utter sham because no reasonable
person could believe that: (a) Ambling was performing work at Savannah River Landings for any
reason other than to fulfill ALRs duties pursuant to the Development Agreement; and/or, (b)
either Defendant, as Surety, or Plaintiff, as Obligee, voluntarily entered into three (3) separate
Construction Bonds with the understanding that none of the Construction Bonds would have any
legal force or effect.
61. Defendant has no reasonable basis for denying Plaintiffs claims, and said denial
constitutes bad faith.
62. Pursuant to O.C.G.A. 10-7-30, Defendant is liable to Plaintiff for the full
amount of the loss occasioned by Defendants bad faith denial of Plaintiffs claims, plus twenty
11

five percent (25%) of the amount of said loss, plus all reasonable attorneys fees incurred by
Plaintiff in the prosecution of this civil action.
WHEREFORE, Plaintiff, The Mayor and Aldermen of the City of Savannah, Georgia,
prays for relief as follows:
(a) That summons and process be issued and served upon Defendant;
(b) For a trial by jury composed of twelve persons;
(c) An award of full compensation for its losses occasioned by Defendants actions as
determined at trial;
(d) An award of an additional twenty five percent (25%) of its losses and all reasonable
attorneys fees incurred by it as authorized by O.C.G.A. 10-7-30; and
(e) Any other relief that this Court deems to be just and proper.

This 8th day of October, 2013.

Respectfully submitted,

W. BROOKS STILLWELL
City Attorney

JENNIFER N. HERMAN
Assistant City Attorney
OFFICE OF THE CITY ATTORNEY
P.O. Box 1027
Savannah, GA 31402
(912) 525-3092 telephone
(912) 525-3267 facsimile
[email protected]
[email protected]

12

OLIVER MANER LLP

__/s/ Douglas E. Herman
DOUGLAS E. HERMAN
__________
Georgia Bar No. 076219
Oliver Maner LLP T. LAWRENCE EVANS
218 West State Street Georgia Bar No. 419077
P.O. Box 10186 Attorneys for Plaintiff, The Mayor and Alderman of
Savannah, GA 31412 The City of Savannah, Georgia.
(912) 236-3311
[email protected]
[email protected]
EXHIBIT A

Case 4:13-tc-05000 Document 81-2 Filed 10/08/13 Page 1 of 61 Case 4:13-cv-00226-WTM-GRS Document 1-1 Filed 10/08/13 Page 1 of 61
EXHIBIT B

Home Edit Account | Log Out
AMBLING CONSTRUCTION COMPANY, LLC Control Number: 0426197
Main Reports Officers Filing History
Entity Id 274377
Model Type
Locale
Qualifier
Business Name
Registration Date
Entity Status
Entity Status Date
Foreign Name
Date of Organization
State
Country
Line1
Line2
City VALDOSTA State Georgia Zip 31601
Is non-commercial Registered Agent?
Name
Line1
Line2
Email
Entity Info
Key Indicators
Principal Office Address
Agent
Address
Limited Liability Company
Domestic
None
AMBLING CONSTRUCTION COMPANY, LLC
5/04/2004
Active/Compliance
3/04/2013
Georgia
PRINCIPAL
348 ENTERPRISE DRIVE
Yes
MICHAEL H. GODWIN
https://cgov.sos.state.ga.us/BizEntity.aspx/ViewEntityData?entityI...
1 of 2 10/2/2013 3:08 PM
Home Edit Account | Log Out
ALR OGLETHORPE, LLC Control Number: 0538449
Main Reports Officers Filing History
Entity Id 362343
Model Type
Locale
Qualifier
Business Name
Registration Date
Entity Status
Entity Status Date
Foreign Name
Date of Organization
State
Country
Line1
Line2
Is non-commercial Registered Agent?
Name
Line1
Line2
Email
Entity Info
Key Indicators
Principal Office Address
Agent
Address
Limited Liability Company
Domestic
None
ALR OGLETHORPE, LLC
6/02/2005
Active/Compliance
4/19/2013
Georgia
PRINCIPAL
Yes
MICHAEL H. GODWIN
[email protected]
https://cgov.sos.state.ga.us/BizEntity.aspx/ViewEntityData?entityI...
1 of 2 10/2/2013 3:10 PM
EXHIBIT C

EXHIBIT D

EXHIBIT E

EXHIBIT F

EXHIBIT G

EXHIBIT H

EXHIBIT I

Budgetary Numbers and Engineer's Opinions of Cost
Savannah River Landing
Phase 1 Plat Completion and Road Constrution!Connetions
Sept "#1$
Opinion of Cost
Description Total
Sanitary Sewer Punch List Items
568,665.00 $
Pavement Punch List Items
129,781.00 $
Storm raina!e Punch List Items
59",518.00 $
#om$%etion o& Street System 1,"'6,701.00 $
Phase 1 Sur&ace #ourse
"'7,299.00 $
Par(s
'12,000.00 $
Phase 1 Si!na!e, Stri$in!
10",000.00 $
TOTAL PROJECT 3,582,964!! "
)PI*I)* )+ P,)-.-L/ #)*S0,1#0I)* #)S0
Since the /n!ineer has no contro% over the cost o& %a2or, materia%s, e3ui$ment,
the #ontractor4s metho5s o& 5eterminin! $rices, or over com$etitive 2i55in! or
mar(et con5itions, the )$inions o& Pro2a2%e #onstruction #osts $rovi5e5 &or
herein are ma5e on the 2asis o& the /n!ineer4s e6$erience an5 3ua%i&ications.
0hese o$inions re$resent the /n!ineer4s 2est 8u5!ment as a 5esi!n $ro&essiona%
&ami%iar with the construction in5ustry. 9owever, the /n!ineer cannot an5 5oes
not !uarantee that $ro$osa%s, 2i5s, or the construction cost wi%% not vary &rom
)$inions o& Pro2a2%e #onstruction #osts $re$are5 2y him:her.
O:\16619\Documents\OPC\Take-Offs\2013 INFRATR!CT!R" #IT\umma$%&9-2'-2013()*s
SAVANNAH RIVER LANDING
OPINION OF PROBABLE CONSTRUCTION COST FOR INFRASTRUCTURE REPAIRS
SANITARY SEWER
REFER TO EXHIBIT FOR LOCATION OF REPAIRS
LOCATION STRUCTURE SCOPE OF WORK EST. UNIT EST. EST. EST COST
NAMES QTY. UNIT UNIT
COST COST
INCR. 4%
2011 2013
AREA 2 SSMH C2-C1 195 LF 8" PVC SEWER - 6" SAG
REMOVE 8" PVC !-8" 1#$ LF 2$.00 % 2!.00 % $&0'0.00 %
REPLACE 8" PVC !-8" 1#$ LF '$.00 % '8.00 % 1$&210.00 %
REPAIR SSMH CRACK 1 EA 1&$00.00 % 1&$!0.00 % 1&$!0.00 %
REMOVE 8" WATER $0% ()*+,- ./0) (,.,+" !0 LF 12.00 % 12.48 % '48.80 %
REPLACE 8" WATER $0% ()*+,- ./0) (,.,+" !0 LF !0.00 % !2.40 % 3&'44.00 %
REMOVE !" WATER $0% ()*+,- ./0) (,.,+" !0 LF 10.00 % 10.40 % !24.00 %
REPLACE !" WATER $0% ()*+,- ./0) (,.,+" !0 LF 4$.00 % 4!.80 % 2&808.00 %
REMOVE 1 RECONNECT SEWER LATERALS # EA $00.00 % $20.00 % 4&!80.00 %
REMOVE 8" VALVE IN MANHOLE 1 EA 1&$00.00 % 1&$!0.00 % 1&$!0.00 %
REPLACE 8" VALVE IN MANHOLE 1 EA 2&000.00 % 2&080.00 % 2&080.00 %
REMOVE !" VALVE IN MANHOLE 1 EA 1&000.00 % 1&040.00 % 1&040.00 %
REPLACE !" VALVE IN MANHOLE 1 EA 1&$00.00 % 1&$!0.00 % 1&$!0.00 %
REMOVE ASPHALT PAVEMENT 320 SY 10.00 % 10.40 % 3&328.00 %
REPLACE ASPHALT PAVEMENT 320 SY $0.00 % $2.00 % 1!&!40.00 %
PROTECT E2ISTIN3 UTILITIES 1 LS 2&$00.00 % 2&!00.00 % 2&!00.00 %
AREA 2 SUBTOTAL 59,29!" #
AREA 3 SSMH C2-C1 CRAC$ED DUCTILE IRON SEWER PIPE
REMOVE 8" 4UCTILE IRON SEWER !-8" 20 LF 30.00 % 31.20 % !24.00 %
REPLACE 8" 4UCTILE IRON SEWER !-8" 20 LF 100.00 % 104.00 % 2&080.00 %
REMOVE ASPHALT PAVEMENT 4$ SY 10.00 % 10.40 % 4!8.00 %
REPLACE ASPHALT PAVEMENT 4$ SY $0.00 % $2.00 % 2&340.00 %
PROTECT E2ISTIN3 UTILITIES 1 LS 1&000.00 % 1&040.00 % 1&040.00 %
AREA % SUBTOTAL 6,552! #
AREA 4 SSMH A! - C3 15 LF 8" PVC SEWER - 2" SAG
REMOVE 8" PVC SEWER 8-10" 10$ LF 30.00 % 31.20 % 3&2'!.00 %
REPLACE 8" PVC SEWER 8-10" 10$ LF 8$.00 % 88.40 % #&282.00 %
REMOVE ASPHALT PAVEMENT 23$ SY 10.00 % 10.40 % 2&444.00 %
REMOVE 1 RECONNECT SEWER LATERALS ! EA $00.00 % $20.00 % 3&120.00 %
PROTECT E2ISTIN3 UTILITIES 1 LS 2&000.00 % 2&080.00 % 2&080.00 %
AREA " SUBTOTAL %2,"22! #
AREA 8 CIH1 - CIH2 15" RCP STOR& '5( SHARED WITH STOR&)
REMOVE 1$" RCP STORM 1$ LF 3$.00 % 3!.40 % $4!.00 %
REPLACE 1$" RCP STORM 1$ LF 8$.00 % 88.40 % 1&32!.00 %
REMOVE CUR5 1 3UTTER 3$ LF '.$0 % '.80 % 2'3.00 %
REPLACE CUR5 1 3UTTER 3$ LF 18.00 % 18.'2 % !$$.20 %
REMOVE ASPHALT PAVEMENT 40 SY 10.00 % 10.40 % 41!.00 %
REPLACE ASPHALT PAVEMENT 40 SY $0.00 % $2.00 % 2&080.00 %
AREA 8 SUBTOTAL * 5( 2,6"8!1 #
THIS OPINION OF PRO5A5LE CONSTRUCTION COST IS 5ASE4 ON AREAS CURRENTLY I4ENTIFIE4 TO 4ATE 5Y THOMAS 1 HUTTON& AN4 CURRENTLY UN4ER
REVIEW 5Y THE CITY OF SAVANNAH& AS 5EIN3 4EFICIENT AN4 IN NEE4 OF CORRECTION. IT IS NOT INTEN4E4 TO 5E E2HAUSTIVE OF ALL
REPAIRS6MO4IFICATIONS THAT MAY 5E REQUIRE46RECOMMEN4E4 TO THE E2ISTIN3 INFRASTRUCTURE.
ESTIMATE4 COST OF REPAIRS
O781!!1#849:;<,=0(8OPC8T*>,-O??(82013 INFRASTRUCTURE LIST8SRL REPAIR ESTIMATE@'-#-2013.AB(
SANITARY SEWER
AREA # SSMH E1-E2 11 LF 8" PVC SEWER PIPE - 8" SAG
REMOVE 8" PVC SEWER 10-12" 110 LF 3$.00 % 3!.40 % 4&004.00 %
REPLACE 8" PVC SEWER 10-12" 110 LF 120.00 % 124.80 % 13&'28.00 %
REMOVE ASPHALT PAVEMENT 18$ SY 10.00 % 10.40 % 1&#24.00 %
REPLACE ASPHALT PAVEMENT 18$ SY $0.00 % $2.00 % #&!20.00 %
REMOVE 4UCT 5ANK 3$ LF '$.00 % '8.00 % 2&'30.00 %
REPLACE 4UCT 5ANK 3$ LF $00.00 % $20.00 % 18&200.00 %
REMOVE CUR5 1 3UTTER 100 LF '.$0 % '.80 % '80.00 %
REPLACE CUR5 1 3UTTER 100 LF 18.00 % 18.'2 % 1&8'2.00 %
AREA 9 SUBTOTAL 52,858! #
AREA 10 SSMH A!-A' 2%" LF 8" PVC SEWER - 6"-+" SAG
SSMH A'-A8 A5AN4ON 8" PVC SEWER IN PLACE 3#0 LF 10.00 % 10.40 % 4&0$!.00 %
SSMH A!-RW1 INSTALL 12" PVC SEWER 14-1!" 448 LF 1!0.00 % 1!!.40 % '4&$4'.20 %
SSMH RW1-RW2 REMOVE 1 4ISPOSE MANHOLE A' 10-12" 1 EA 1&$00.00 % 1&$!0.00 % 1&$!0.00 %
SSMH RW2-E1 REMOVE ASPHALT PAVEMENT 830 SY 10.00 % 10.40 % 8&!32.00 %
REPLACE ASPHALT PAVEMENT 830 SY $0.00 % $2.00 % 43&1!0.00 %
REMOVE 4UCT 5ANK 40 LF '$.00 % '8.00 % 3&120.00 %
INSTALL 4UCT 5ANK 40 LF $00.00 % $20.00 % 20&800.00 %
INSTALL NEW MANHOLES 10-12" 2 EA 4&000.00 % 4&1!0.00 % 8&320.00 %
REMOVE 48" RCP STORM 30 LF 11$.00 % 11#.!0 % 3&$88.00 %
REPLACE 48" RCP STORM 30 LF 220.00 % 228.80 % !&8!4.00 %
REMOVE CUR5 1 3UTTER 400 LF '.$0 % '.80 % 3&120.00 %
REPLACE CUR5 1 3UTTER 400 LF 18.00 % 18.'2 % '&488.00 %
REMOVE 8" WATER MAIN 4$ LF 12.00 % 12.48 % $!1.!0 %
REPLACE 8" WATER MAIN 4$ LF !0.00 % !2.40 % 2&808.00 %
REMOVE CUR5 INLET HI 1 EA 1&000.00 % 1&040.00 % 1&040.00 %
REPLACE CUR5 INLET HI 1 EA 4&$00.00 % 4&!80.00 % 4&!80.00 %
REMOVE 24" RCP STORM 1$ LF !0.00 % !2.40 % #3!.00 %
REPLACE 24" RCP STORM 1$ LF 120.00 % 124.80 % 1&8'2.00 %
REMOVE 8" PVC SEWER 10-12" 1$$ LF 3$.00 % 3!.40 % $&!42.00 %
REPLACE 12" PVC SEWER10-12" 1$$ LF 1!0.00 % 1!!.40 % 2$&'#2.00 %
AREA 1 SUBTOTAL 228,586!8 #
AREA 13 SSMH A#-A8 115 LF 15" PVC SEWER PIPE - %-"", 6-8" SAG
SSMH A#-E1 REMOVE 1$" PVC SEWER PIPE 12-14" 11$ LF '0.00 % '2.80 % 8&3'2.00 %
REPLACE 1$" PVC SEWER PIPE 12-14" 11$ LF 18$.00 % 1#2.40 % 22&12!.00 %
REMOVE 1 4ISPOSE MANHOLE A' 10-12" 1 EA %1&$00 1&$!0.00 % 1&$!0.00 %
INSTALL NEW MANHOLES 10-12" 1 EA 4&$00.00 % 4&!80.00 % 4&!80.00 %
REMOVE ASPHALT PAVEMENT 28$ SY 10.00 % 10.40 % 2&#!4.00 %
REMOVE 8" WATER MAIN 3$ LF 12.00 % 12.48 % 43!.80 %
REPLACE 8" WATER MAIN 3$ LF $0.00 % $2.00 % 1&820.00 %
REMOVE 1$" RCP STORM 20 LF 3$.00 % 3!.40 % '28.00 %
REPLACE 1$" RCP STORM 20 LF '$.00 % '8.00 % 1&$!0.00 %
REMOVE !" WATER MAIN 20 LF 10.00 % 10.40 % 208.00 %
REPLACE !" WATER MAIN 20 LF 40.00 % 41.!0 % 832.00 %
REMOVE CUR5 1 3UTTER #0 LF '.$0 % '.80 % '02.00 %
REPLACE CUR5 1 3UTTER #0 LF 18.00 % 18.'2 % 1&!84.80 %
REMOVE 1 REPLACE FIRE HY4RANT 1 EA 1&000.00 % 1&040.00 % 1&040.00 %
REMOVE 8" WATER VALVE AN4 MANHOLE 1 EA 1&$00.00 % 1&$!0.00 % 1&$!0.00 %
REPLACE 8" WATER VALVE AN4 MANHOLE 1 EA 2&000.00 % 2&080.00 % 2&080.00 %
AREA 1% SUBTOTAL 6+,1+%!6 #
AREA 1$ SSMH A8 - F4 %9 LF 15" PVC SEWER PIPE - 1" SAG
REMOVE 1$" PVC SEWER 10-12" 3# LF !0.00 % !2.40 % 2&433.!0 %
REPLACE 1$" PVC SEWER 10-12" 3# LF 180.00 % 18'.20 % '&300.80 %
REMOVE ASPHALT PAVEMENT 100 SY 10.00 % 10.40 % 1&040.00 %
REPLACE ASPHALT PAVEMENT 100 SY $0.00 % $2.00 % $&200.00 %
REMOVE 4UCT 5ANK 20 LF '$.00 % '8.00 % 1&$!0.00 %
REPLACE 4UCT 5ANK 20 LF $00.00 % $20.00 % 10&400.00 %
REMOVE 8" WATER MAIN 20 LF 12.00 % 12.48 % 24#.!0 %
REPLACE 8" WATER MAIN 20 LF 40.00 % 41.!0 % 832.00 %
REMOVE CUR5 1 3UTTER 30 LF '.$0 % '.80 % 234.00 %
REPLACE CUR5 1 3UTTER 30 LF 18.00 % 18.'2 % $!1.!0 %
PROTECT E2ISTIN3 UTILITIES 1 LS 1&$00.00 % 1&$!0.00 % 1&$!0.00 %
AREA 15 SUBTOTAL %1,%+1!6 #
SANITARY SEWER
AREA 18 SSMH F3-F2 1%1 LF 12" PVC SEWER - 1" SAG
REMOVE 12" PVC SEWER 12-14" 131 LF $$.00 % $'.20 % '&4#3.20 %
REPLACE 12" PVC SEWER 12-14" 131 LF 1$$.00 % 1!1.20 % 21&11'.20 %
REMOVE ASPHALT PAVEMENT 430 SY 10.00 % 10.40 % 4&4'2.00 %
REPLACE ASPHALT PAVEMENT 430 SY $0.00 % $2.00 % 22&3!0.00 %
REMOVE CUR5 1 3UTTER 14$ LF '.$0 % '.80 % 1&131.00 %
REPLACE CUR5 1 3UTTER 14$ LF 18.00 % 18.'2 % 2&'14.40 %
REMOVE 1$" RCP STORM 24 LF 3$.00 % 3!.40 % 8'3.!0 %
REPLACE 1$" RCP STORM 24 LF 8$.00 % 88.40 % 2&121.!0 %
PROTECT STORM STRUCTURE 1 PIPE 1 LS 1&000.00 % 1&040.00 % 1&040.00 %
REMOVE 4UCT 5ANK 20 LF '$.00 % '8.00 % 1&$!0.00 %
REPLACE 4UCT 5ANK 20 LF $00.00 % $20.00 % 10&400.00 %
AREA 18 SUBTOTAL +5,28%! #
MH F1& F2& F3 SANITARY SEWER &ANHOLE LINING 3 EA 4&000.00 % 4&1!0.00 % 12&480.00 %
&ANHOLE LINING SUBTOTAL 12,"8! #
SANITARY SEWER TOTAL 568,665!5 #
PAVEMENT
LOCATION SCOPE OF WORK EST. UNIT EST. EST. EST. COST
QTY. UNIT UNIT
COST COST
INCR. 4%
2011 2013
PAVING 1 PUNCH LIST ITEMS
REMOVE PAVEMENT 750 SY 10.00 $ 10.40 $ 7,00.00 $
REMOVE CUR! " #UTTER 550 LF 7.50 $ 7.0 $ 4,2$0.00 $
MILLIN# 3% WI&E STRIP OF !IN&ER '.25 SY 100.00 $ 104.00 $ '50.00 $
NEW CUR! " #UTTER 550 LF 1.00 $ 1.72 $ 10,2$'.00 $
NEW PAVEMENT 750 SY 50.00 $ 52.00 $ 3$,000.00 $
A&(UST FRAMES OF CUR! INLETS ) STRUCTURES $ EA 500.00 $ 520.00 $ 4,'0.00 $
CLEAN STREETS 52,5'0 SY 0.25 $ 0.2' $ 13,''5.'0 $
REPAIR CUR! INLET !MP* 100 EA 25.00 $ 2'.00 $ 2,'00.00 $
RE+SEE& SITE 30 AC 1,500.00 $ 1,5'0.00 $ 4',00.00 $
PAVING 1 ESTIMATED COST OF REPAIR 129,781.60 $
PAVEMENT TOTAL
ESTIMATE& COST OF REPAIRS
129,781.60 $
T,IS OPINION OF PRO!A!LE CONSTRUCTION COST IS !ASE& ON AREAS CURRENTLY I&ENTIFIE& TO &ATE !Y T,OMAS " ,UTTON,
AN& CURRENTLY UN&ER REVIEW !Y T,E CITY OF SAVANNA,, AS !EIN# &EFICIENT AN& IN NEE& OF CORRECTION. IT IS NOT
INTEN&E& TO !E E-,AUSTIVE OF ALL REPAIRS)MO&IFICATIONS T,AT MAY !E REQUIRE&)RECOMMEN&E& TO T,E E-ISTIN#
INFRASTRUCTURE.
O./1''1$/&0123456*/OPC/T784+O99*/2013 INFRASTRUCTURE LIST/SRL REPAIR ESTIMATE:7+$+2013.;<*
OPINION OF PROBABLE COST FOR INFRASTRUCTURE REPAIRS
STORM DRAINAGE
Revised 7-18-211
LOCATION STRUCTURE SCOPE OF WORK EST. UNIT EST. EST. EST. COST
NAMES QTY. UNIT UNIT
COST COST
INCR. 4%
2011 2013
AREA 1 CIY1 - CIY2 1!" RCP STORM
REMOVE 15" RCP STORM 166 LF 35.00 36.40 6!042.40
REPLACE 15" RCP STORM 166 LF "5.00 "".40 14!6#4.40
REMOVE ASP$ALT PAVEMENT %5 SY 10.00 10.40 %"".00
REPLACE ASP$ALT PAVEMENT %5 SY 50.00 52.00 4!%40.00
REMOVE CUR& ' (UTTER 1#0 LF #.50 #."0 1!326.00
REPLACE CUR& ' (UTTER 1#0 LF 1".00 1".#2 3!1"2.40
SM$ Y2-Y3 2#" RCP STORM
SM$ Y3-Y4 REMOVE 24" RCP STORM 261 LF 60.00 62.40 16!2"6.40
REPLACE 24" RCP STORM 261 LF 120.00 124."0 32!5#2."0
REMOVE ASP$ALT PAVEMENT 2%0 SY 10.00 10.40 3!016.00
REPLACE ASP$ALT PAVEMENT 2%0 SY 50.00 52.00 15!0"0.00
REMOVE CUR& ' (UTTER 261 LF #.50 #."0 2!035."0
REPLACE CUR& ' (UTTER 261 LF 1".00 1".#2 4!""5.%2
PROTECT E)ISTIN( 12" WATER MAIN 1 LS 3!000.00 3!120.00 3!120.00
REMOVE "" WATER 20 LF 12.00 12.4" 24%.60
REPLACE "" WATER 20 LF 50.00 52.00 1!040.00
PROTECT CUR& INLET Y3 1 LS 1!000.00 1!040.00 1!040.00
SM$ Y4A-Y4 2#" RCP STORM
REMOVE 24" RCP 45 LF 60.00 62.40 2!"0".00
REPLACE 24" RCP 45 LF 120.00 124."0 5!616.00
REMOVE SM$ *Y4 1 EA 1!500.00 1!560.00 1!560.00
REPLACE SM$ *Y4 1 EA 3!500.00 3!640.00 3!640.00
REMOVE +UCT &ANK 50 LF #5.00 #".00 3!%00.00
INSTALL +UCT &ANK 50 LF 500.00 520.00 26!000.00
REMOVE ASP$ALT PAVEMENT 415 SY 10.00 10.40 4!316.00
REPLACE ASP$ALT PAVEMENT 415 SY 50.00 52.00 21!5"0.00
SAW CUT ASP$ALT PAVEMENT 60 LF 3.00 3.12 1"#.20
REMOVE CUR& ' (UTTER 255 LF #.50 #."0 1!%"%.00
REPLACE CUR& ' (UTTER 255 LF 1".00 1".#2 4!##3.60
REMOVE 12" WATER MAIN 160 LF 1".00 1".#2 2!%%5.20
REPLACE 12" WATER MAIN 160 LF #0.00 #2."0 11!64".00
REMOVE "" WATER MAIN 10 LF 12.00 12.4" 124."0
REPLACE "" WATER MAIN 10 LF 50.00 52.00 520.00
REMOVE 12" VALVE IN MAN$OLE 1 EA 2!000.00 2!0"0.00 2!0"0.00
REPLACE 12" VALVE IN MAN$OLE 1 EA 2!500.00 2!600.00 2!600.00
REMOVE "" VALVE IN MAN$OLE 1 EA 1!500.00 1!560.00 1!560.00
REPLACE "" VALVE IN MAN$OLE 1 EA 2!000.00 2!0"0.00 2!0"0.00
AREA 1 SUBTOTAL 21$#!7%!2 &
AREA 2 STM Y5-Y4A 2#" RCP STORM
ESTIMATE+ COST OF REPAIRS
T$IS OPINION OF PRO&A&LE CONSTRUCTION COST IS &ASE+ ON AREAS CURRENTLY I+ENTIFIE+ TO +ATE &Y T$OMAS ' $UTTON! AN+ CURRENTLY
UN+ER REVIEW &Y T$E CITY OF SAVANNA$! AS &EIN( +EFICIENT AN+ IN NEE+ OF CORRECTION. IT IS NOT INTEN+E+ TO &E E)$AUSTIVE OF ALL
REPAIRS,MO+IFICATIONS T$AT MAY &E REQUIRE+,RECOMMEN+E+ TO T$E E)ISTIN( INFRASTRUCTURE.
O-.1661%.+/0123456.OPC.T783-O996.2013 INFRASTRUCTURE LIST.SRL REPAIR ESTIMATE:#-%-2013.;<6
STORM DRAINAGE
Revised 7-18-211
REMOVE 24" RCP 1"0 LF 60.00 62.40 11!232.00
REPLACE 24" RCP 1"0 LF 120.00 124."0 22!464.00
REMOVE SM$ *Y4A 1 EA 1!500.00 1!560.00 1!560.00
REPLACE SM$ *Y4A 1 EA 3!500.00 3!640.00 3!640.00
REMOVE "" WATER =50% 6>7?3@ AB5> 63A3?C 60 LF 12.00 12.4" #4"."0
REPLACE "" WATER =50% 6>7?3@ AB5> 63A3?C 60 LF 60.00 62.40 3!#44.00
REMOVE 6" WATER =50% 6>7?3@ AB5> 63A3?C 60 LF 10.00 10.40 624.00
REPLACE 6" WATER =50% 6>7?3@ AB5> 63A3?C 60 LF 45.00 46."0 2!"0".00
REMOVE CUR& ' (UTTER 1"5 LF #.50 #."0 1!443.00
REPLACE CUR& ' (UTTER 1"5 LF 1".00 1".#2 3!463.20
REMOVE ASP$ALT PAVEMENT 300 SY 10.00 10.40 3!120.00
REPLACE ASP$ALT PAVEMENT 300 SY 50.00 52.00 15!600.00
SAWCUT ASP$ALT PAVEMENT 30 LF 3.00 3.12 %3.60
AREA 2 SUBTOTAL ''$!78%2 &
STORM DRAINAGE
Revised 7-18-211
AREA 5 SM$ P1-P2 (OINT OF 1!" RCP STORM
REMOVE 15" RCP STORM " LF 35.00 36.40 2%1.20
REPLACE 15" RCP STORM " LF "5.00 "".40 #0#.20
REMOVE ASP$ALT PAVEMENT # SY 10.00 10.40 #2."0
REPLACE ASP$ALT PAVEMENT # SY 50.00 52.00 364.00
REMOVE CUR& ' (UTTER 10 LF #.50 #."0 #".00
REPLACE CUR& ' (UTTER 10 LF 1".00 1".#2 1"#.20
AREA ! SUBTOTAL 1$7%# &
AREA 6 CIY10-FESY11 #8" RCP STORM
REMOVE 4"" RCP STORM 43 LF 115.00 11%.60 5!142."0
REPLACE 4"" RCP STORM 43 LF 210.00 21".40 %!3%1.20
REMOVE ASP$ALT PAVEMENT 3 SY 10.00 10.40 31.20
REPLACE ASP$ALT PAVEMENT 3 SY 50.00 52.00 156.00
REMOVE CUR& ' (UTTER 5 LF #.50 #."0 3%.00
REPLACE CUR& ' (UTTER 5 LF 1".00 1".#2 %3.60
AREA ' SUBTOTAL 1#$8!)%8 &
AREA # CIV2-FESV3 1!" RCP STORM
REMOVE 15" RCP 44 LF 35.00 36.40 1!601.60
REPLACE 15" RCP 44 LF "5.00 "".40 3!""%.60
REPLACE ASP$ALT PAVEMENT 3 SY 50.00 52.00 156.00
REMOVE CUR& ' (UTTER 5 LF #.50 #."0 3%.00
REPLACE CUR& ' (UTTER 5 LF 1".00 1".#2 %3.60
AREA 7 SUBTOTAL !$811% &
AREA " CI$1 - CI$2 1!" RCP STORM *!+ SHARED ,ITH SE,ER-
=S$ARE+C REMOVE 15" RCP STORM 15 LF 35.00 36.40 546.00
REPLACE 15" RCP STORM 15 LF "5.00 "".40 1!326.00
REMOVE CUR& ' (UTTER 35 LF #.50 #."0 2#3.00
REPLACE CUR& ' (UTTER 35 LF 1".00 1".#2 655.20
CI $2-CI $3 1!" RCP STORM AND 18" RCP STORM
=UNS$ARE+C REMOVE 15" RCP STORM 40 LF 35.00 36.40 1!456.00
REPLACE 15" RCP STORM 40 LF "5.00 "".40 3!536.00
REMOVE 1"" RCP STORM 50 LF 40.00 41.60 2!0"0.00
REPLACE 1"" RCP STORM 50 LF 100.00 104.00 5!200.00
REMOVE +UCT &ANK 33 LF #5.00 #".00 2!5#4.00
REPLACE +UCT &ANK 33 LF 500.00 520.00 1#!160.00
REMOVE "" WATER MAIN 20 LF 12.00 12.4" 24%.60
REPLACE "" WATER MAIN 20 LF 60.00 62.40 1!24".00
REMOVE CUR& ' (UTTER 35 LF #.50 #."0 2#3.00
REPLACE CUR&' (UTTER 35 LF 1".00 1".#2 655.20
AREA 8 SUBTOTAL ).$!7!%. &
AREA 11 CI (4 - FES(5 2#" RCP STORM
REMOVE 24" RCP 46 LF 60.00 62.40 2!"#0.40
STORM DRAINAGE
Revised 7-18-211
REPLACE 24" RCP 46 LF 120.00 124."0 5!#40."0
AREA 11 SUBTOTAL 8$'11%2 &
AREA 12 CI D2-FESD3 2#" RCP STORM
REMOVE 24" RCP 36 LF 60.00 62.40 2!246.40
REPLACE 24" RCP 36 LF 120.00 124."0 4!4%2."0
AREA 12 SUBTOTAL '$7).%2 &
STORM DRAINAGE
Revised 7-18-211
AREA 14 SM$ A#-SM$ A" '" RCP STORM
SM$ A"-CIA% REMOVE 60" RCP STORM 335 LF 145.00 150."0 50!51".00
CIA% - $WA% REPLACE 60" RCP STORM 335 LF 350.00 364.00 121!%40.00
REMOVE "" WATER MAIN 315 LF 12.00 12.4" 3!%31.20
REPLACE "" WATER MAIN 315 LF 50.00 52.00 16!3"0.00
REMOVE "" VALVE IN MAN$OLE 3 EA 1!500.00 1!560.00 4!6"0.00
REPLACE "" VALVE IN MAN$OLE 3 EA 2!000.00 2!0"0.00 6!240.00
REMOVE "" WATER LATERAL 56 LF 12.00 12.4" 6%".""
REPLACE "" WATER LATERAL 56 LF 50.00 52.00 2!%12.00
REMOVE 6" WATER LATERAL 56 LF 10.00 10.40 5"2.40
REPLACE 6" WATER LATERAL 56 LF 40.00 41.60 2!32%.60
RECONNECT WATER LATERALS 4 EA 500.00 520.00 2!0"0.00
REMOVE 6" VALVE IN MAN$OLE 2 EA 1!000.00 1!040.00 2!0"0.00
REPLACE 6" VALVE IN MAN$OLE 2 EA 1!500.00 1!560.00 3!120.00
REMOVE 15" RCP 35 LF 35.00 36.40 1!2#4.00
REPLACE 15" RCP 35 LF "5.00 "".40 3!0%4.00
REMOVE CUR& INLET 2 EA 1!000.00 1!040.00 2!0"0.00
REPLACE CUR& INLET 2 EA 3!000.00 3!120.00 6!240.00
REMOVE +UCT &ANK 130 LF #5.00 #".00 10!140.00
REPLACE +UCT &ANK 130 LF 500.00 520.00 6#!600.00
REMOVE ASP$ALT PAVEMENT 10%0 SY 10.00 10.40 11!336.00
REPLACE ASP$ALT PAVEMENT 10%0 SY 50.00 52.00 56!6"0.00
REMOVE CUR& ' (UTTER 5%5 LF #.50 #."0 4!641.00
REPLACE CUR& ' (UTTER 5%5 LF 1".00 1".#2 11!13".40
REMOVE $EA+WALL 1 EA 2!500.00 2!600.00 2!600.00
REPLACE $EA+WALL 1 EA #!000.00 #!2"0.00 #!2"0.00
AREA 1# SUBTOTAL #1$!.!%#8 &
AREA 16 CI A#C-A#C1 1!" RCP STORM
REMOVE 15" RCP STORM 26 LF 35.00 36.40 %46.40
REPLACE 15" RCP STORM 26 LF "5.00 "".40 2!2%".40
REMOVE +UCT &ANK 20 LF #5.00 #".00 1!560.00
REPLACE +UCT &ANK 20 LF 500.00 520.00 10!400.00
REMOVE CUR& ' (UTTER 40 LF #.50 #."0 312.00
REPLACE CUR& ' (UTTER 40 LF 1".00 1".#2 #4"."0
REMOVE "" WATER MAIN 20 LF 12.00 12.4" 24%.60
REPLACE "" WATER MAIN 20 LF 50.00 52.00 1!040.00
AREA 1' SUBTOTAL 17$!!!%2 &
AREA 1# SM$ &4-&5 #8" RCP STORM PIPE
REMOVE 4"" RCP STORM 310 LF 115.00 11%.60 3#!0#6.00
REPLACE 4"" RCP STORM 310 LF 210.00 21".40 6#!#04.00
REMOVE ASP$ALT PAVEMENT 365 SY 10.00 10.40 3!#%6.00
REPLACE ASP$ALT PAVEMENT 365 SY 50.00 52.00 1"!%"0.00
REMOVE CUR& ' (UTTER 200 LF #.50 #."0 1!560.00
REPLACE CUR& ' (UTTER 200 LF 1".00 1".#2 3!#44.00
REMOVE "" WATER MAIN 1" LF 12.00 12.4" 224.64
REPLACE "" WATER MAIN 1" LF 50.00 52.00 %36.00
REMOVE 12" WATER MAIN 24 LF 1".00 1".#2 44%.2"
REPLACE 12" WATER MAIN 24 LF #0.00 #2."0 1!#4#.20
REMOVE +UCT &ANK "5 LF #5.00 #".00 6!630.00
REPLACE +UCT &ANK "5 LF 500.00 520.00 44!200.00
AREA 17 SUBTOTAL 187$#7%12 &
STORM DRAINAGE
Revised 7-18-211
PATC$ SEE E)$I&IT PATCH PIPE$ (OINTS$ AND STRUCTURES
PATC$ CRACKE+ PIPE 13 EA 1!500.00 1!560.00 20!2"0.00
PATC$ DOINTS 20 EA 1!000.00 1!040.00 20!"00.00
PATC$ STRUCTURES 3 EA 1!000.00 1!040.00 3!120.00
PATCHING SUBTOTAL ##$2% &
STORM DRAINAGE TOTAL !.#$!18%)# &
BENNING STREET, RIVER STREET, ROAD CONNECTIONS CONSTRUCTION
GRADING
Item Description Quantity Unit Unit Price Total
1 Grading Job LS 100,00000 ! 100,00000 !
"
#ontractor Supplied $orro%
&#ompacted in Place'
1(,000 #) 1*00 ! "0+,00000 !
*
,emo-e and Dispose o. Unsuitable
/aterial and ,eplace 0it1 /aterial
Supplied by #ontractor
100 #) 1(00 ! 1,(0000 !
2 Proo. ,olling ( 3, 10000 ! (0000 !
310,200.00 $
4 5rosion and Sedimentation #ontrol Job LS (0,00000 ! (0,00000 !
60,000.00 $
WATER DISTRIBUTION SYSTEM
( +6 P7# 0ater /ain 1,((1 L8 *"00 ! 4*,14"00 !
9 (6 P7# 0ater /ain :0 L8 "400 ! ","4000 !
+ "6 Domestic Lateral 424 L8 1*40 ! 9,*4940 !
: 8ittings 1,"12 L$S :00 ! 10,:"(00 !
10 +6 7al-e ; /an1ole * 5< *,29000 ! 10,21000 !
11 (6 7al-e ; $o= 2 5< :0000 ! *,(0000 !
1" "6 7al-e ; $o= 19 5< 94000 ! 1",94000 !
1* 8ire 3ydrant ( 5< *,40000 ! "1,00000 !
12
#onnect >e% +6 Line to 5=isting +6 Line
0it1 0et Tap, Tapping Slee-e and
Tapping 7al-e
" 5< 12,20000 ! "+,+0000 !
14 +6 ,estrained Joint 2* 5< 11:00 ! 4,11900 !
1( (6 ,estrained Joint : 5< +*00 ! 92900 !
156,109.50 $
STORM DRAINAGE*
19 "26 ,#P *"1 L8 4+00 ! 1+,(1+00 !
1+ 1+6 ,#P 211 L8 2400 ! 1+,2:400 !
1: 146 ,#P (+4 L8 *:00 ! "(,91400 !
"0 146 85S 1 5< 1,00000 ! 1,00000 !
"1
(6 Subgrade Drain &Incl Stone and
8abric'
1,000 L8 "000 ! "0,00000 !
"" #urb Inlet + 5< *,2(000 ! "9,(+000 !
"* )ard Inlet 4 5< ",40000 ! 1",40000 !
"2 #on-ert 5=isting #urb Inlet to /an1ole 1 5< 1,40000 ! 1,40000 !
"4 #onnect to 5=isting /an1ole 1 5< 1,40000 ! 1,40000 !
SAVANNAH RIVER LANDING !"#$% 1 !&#' I()*#$'*+,'+*% C-./&%'0-(
O/0(0-( -) !*-1#1&% C-$'
SE!TEMBER 2013
S+1T-'#&, GRADING
EROSION AND SEDIMENTATION CONTROL
S+1T-'#&, WATER DISTRIBUTION SYSTEM
S+1T-'#&, EROSION CONTROL
00*1*?2
"( #onnect to 5=isting Structure " 5< 1,00000 ! ",00000 !
"9 ,ip?rap 10 S) 9000 ! 90000 !
"+
1"6 Stone [email protected] &under pipe as
bedding'AA
1(0 #) 9"00 ! 11,4"000 !
":
1"6 Sand [email protected] &under pipe as
bedding'AA
*"0 #) +00 ! ",4(000 !
*0 Geote=tile &5Bual to /ira.i 3P 490' 200 S) 4(0 ! ","2000 !
*1 $orro% 1(0 #) +00 ! 1,"+000 !
*"
,emo-e and Dispose o. Unsuitable
/aterial and ,eplace 0it1 /aterial
Supplied by #ontractor
100 #) 1(00 ! 1,(0000 !
129,903.00 $
ELECTRICAL DUCT BAN4
** 8urnis1 and Install T%o 0ay /an1ole 2 5< "1,*+400 ! +4,42000 !
*2 8urnis1 and Install Splicing #1amber " 5< +,(*000 ! 19,"(000 !
*4
8urnis1 and Install Duct $an@ &10 ,o%
= (6 Diameter'
242 L8 14"00 ! (:,00+00 !
*(
8urnis1 and Install Duct $an@ &( ,o% =
(6 Diameter'
"1 L8 11"00 ! ",*4"00 !
*9
8urnis1 and Install Duct $an@ &2 ,o% =
26 Diameter'
2(1 L8 9900 ! *4,2:900 !
209,655.00 $
*+ 1+6 Standard #urb ; Gutter (,20( L8 1"40 ! +0,09400 !
*: Granite #urb *40 L8 9400 ! "(,"4000 !
20
+6 Graded Granite <ggregate $ase
&Incl Prime and Tac@ #oats'
10,+90 S) 1400 ! 1(*,04000 !
21 *6 <sp1altic #oncrete $inder 6$6 /i= 10,+90 S) +41 ! :",40*90 !
2"
1?1C"6 :4 mm <sp1altic #oncrete
Superpa-e
10,+90 S) :00 ! :9,+*000 !
2* <sp1alt #ement ** TD> 20900 ! 1*,2*100 !
22 Pa-ement /ar@ings Job LS 9,00000 ! 9,00000 !
24 Dnsite Tra..ic Sign Job LS 10,00000 ! 10,00000 !
2( Grassing 10,000 S) 042 ! 4,2*000 !
295,569.50 $
1,*+1,222"0 !
1,236,501.95 $
!HASE 1 IN6RASTRUCTURE E7ISTING WOR4 !UNCH LIST
1
1?1C"6 :4 mm<sp1altic #oncrete
Superpa-e
4",4(0 S) +00 ! 2"0,2+000 !
2"0,2+000 !
SU$?TDT<LE $5>>I>G ST,55T, ,I75,ST,55T, <>D ,D<D #D>>5#TID>
#D>ST,U#TID>E
SU$?TDT<LE P3<S5 1 I>8,<ST,U#TU,5 ? 5FISTI>G 0D,G PU>#3 LISTE
S+1T-'#&, STORM DRAINAGE
S+1T-'#&, ELECTRICAL DUCT BAN4
!AVING
S+1T-'#&, !AVING
SUBTOTAL8 BENNING STREET, RIVERSTREET, AND ROAD CONNECTION
CONSTRUCTION WITH IN6LATION 90()&#'0-(
#//*-:0.#'%; #' 2<=8
00*1*?4
235,299.20 $
1,352,001.15 $ TOTAL8 !HASE 1 IN6RASTRUCTURE COM!LETION
A Unit prices .or storm drainage pipes s1all include all material and labor necessary .or installation per speci.ications
AA Quantity .or Stone and Sand [email protected] at structures &does not include Buantity under pipe'
>DT5SE
1 Since t1e engineer 1as no control o-er t1e cost o. labor, materials, eBuipment, t1e #ontractorHs met1ods o. determining
prices, or o-er competiti-e bidding or mar@et conditions, t1e Dpinion o. Probable #onstruction #ost pro-ided 1erein
1as been made on t1e basis o. t1e engineerHs e=perience and Buali.ications T1ese opinionHs represent t1e engineerHs
SUBTOTAL8 !HASE 1 IN6RASTRUCTURE E7ISTING WOR4 !UNCH LIST
WITH IN6LATION8
90()&#'0-( #//*-:0.#'%; #' 2<=8
best Iudgment as a design pro.essional .amiliar %it1 construction met1ods and costs
00*1*?(
EXHIBIT J

EXHIBIT K

EXHIBIT L


Liberty Mutual Complaint

Uploaded by

Copyright:

Available Formats

Liberty Mutual Complaint

Uploaded by

Document Information

Original Description:

Copyright

Available Formats

Share this document

Share or Embed Document

Sharing Options

Did you find this document useful?

Is this content inappropriate?

Copyright:

Available Formats

Liberty Mutual Complaint

Uploaded by

Copyright:

Available Formats

UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT

You might also like