Should coproduction impact additionality claims for carbon removals? Coproduction is when a supplier of carbon removal credits produces additional revenue from another source. For example, a direct air capture facility that also produces hydrogen; or, as is the topic of today’s Reversing Climate Change episode, enhanced rock weathering that produces nickel. Most people agree that coproduction is good. However, it conflicts with financial additionality, which states that the carbon removal action would not take place were it not for the carbon credit. In this episode, Nori Cofounder Ross Kenyon interviews Eric Matzner, an alumnus of Carbon Removal Newsroom and Cofounder of Project Vesta who has a new venture called Metalplant. (This is Metalplant's podcast debut!) Their innovative project combines hyperaccumulator plants and enhanced rock weathering to extract nickel from soil and crushed rock while removing carbon from the air. Much of the conversation focuses on a possibly looming intellectual crisis in carbon removal: what does the industry do when it realizes that many of its methodologies are co-producing value besides carbon? Will it try to find a way to square that with conventional applications of financial additionality, or will they abandon or amend additionality to make sure co-producers aren't held down while the world desperately needs them to scale their operations? So much to talk about, and there will almost certainly be more on this topic in the future! Listen here: https://lnkd.in/gYmKuZyG
Reversing Climate Change’s Post
More Relevant Posts
-
I really enjoyed speaking with Eric Matzner on this episode. As carbon removal develops, I personally think there will be a tendency towards coproduction. Companies fully dependent upon carbon markets will be vulnerable to price fluctuation. Right now many carbon removal transactions are over-the-counter or mediated by a marketplace. Prices seem to be set by the seller and negotiated. In the future I believe we will see more liquidity and competition within grades of CDR, and suppliers will take prices rather than set them (not always, but for much of carbon removal I expect this to have an effect.) At that point, companies will want to have secondary (or even primary business lines!) uncorrelated or even anticorrelated from carbon pricing. That is how to build a robust and scalable CDR industry imho. These companies that can coproduce should be able monetize the net carbon removed. My hypothesis is that if these companies can fully monetize all of these value streams they will scale quickly and profitably and inspire loads of imitators, which is what we need to get to gigatonne scale. Applying financial additionality against these companies will slow carbon removal growth and not give us anything worth the slowed rate of PPM reduction. There is so much more to say about this, but Eric and I discuss this dynamic in detail in this episode of Nori’s Reversing Climate Change podcast. I highly recommend checking it out. I’d love to hear your thoughts on my own personal speculation!
Should coproduction impact additionality claims for carbon removals? Coproduction is when a supplier of carbon removal credits produces additional revenue from another source. For example, a direct air capture facility that also produces hydrogen; or, as is the topic of today’s Reversing Climate Change episode, enhanced rock weathering that produces nickel. Most people agree that coproduction is good. However, it conflicts with financial additionality, which states that the carbon removal action would not take place were it not for the carbon credit. In this episode, Nori Cofounder Ross Kenyon interviews Eric Matzner, an alumnus of Carbon Removal Newsroom and Cofounder of Project Vesta who has a new venture called Metalplant. (This is Metalplant's podcast debut!) Their innovative project combines hyperaccumulator plants and enhanced rock weathering to extract nickel from soil and crushed rock while removing carbon from the air. Much of the conversation focuses on a possibly looming intellectual crisis in carbon removal: what does the industry do when it realizes that many of its methodologies are co-producing value besides carbon? Will it try to find a way to square that with conventional applications of financial additionality, or will they abandon or amend additionality to make sure co-producers aren't held down while the world desperately needs them to scale their operations? So much to talk about, and there will almost certainly be more on this topic in the future! Listen here: https://lnkd.in/gYmKuZyG
321: Metalplant's Debut! Enhanced Rock Weathering, Coproducing Nickel, & Additionality—w/ Eric Matzner, Cofounder of Metalplant
nori.com
To view or add a comment, sign in
-
Looking forward to learning more about UNDO and their enhanced weathering carbon dioxide removal (CDR) methods. I heard the CEO, Jim Mann interviewed on the CarbonCurve podcast last week (https://lnkd.in/etRbkp56) and just saw this article on Kathari.News. Innovators and entrepreneurs have the capacity to help us to lower the cost of reducing our CO2 emissions as well as reducing the cost of removing past emissions. I hope our public policy focus targets both. Simply, we need an all-hands-on-deck attitude if we’re going to find the lowest cost and most effective ways to reduce the concentration of CO2 in our atmosphere.
Crushed rock spread across Ontario fields in new push to capture carbon - Kathari News
https://kathari.news
To view or add a comment, sign in
-
𝐖𝐞𝐞𝐤𝐥𝐲 𝐂𝐃𝐑 𝐇𝐢𝐠𝐡𝐥𝐢𝐠𝐡𝐭𝐬 Here's your round-up of top #CarbonDioxideRemoval News from this week (17-23 June 2024): Microsoft signed largest-ever nature-based CDR deal with BTG Pactual, purchasing 8M tons of CDR credits through 2043. tinyurl.com/ypdetm7k Frontier has facilitated 1st European offtakes with Stockholm Exergi. The $48.6M offtake will support the 1st commercial-scale retrofit of a biomass-fueled heating facility. tinyurl.com/4p6a99c5 Downforce Technologies secured $4.2M in funding to measure C stored in soil. tinyurl.com/4unmwv59 Salesforce announced a $25M commitment to CDR tech via Frontier. tinyurl.com/mpevyxdb Bennetts Associates partnered with Restord for the purchase of 50 metric tonnes of CDR from Restord's pilot biochar project over 1 yr. tinyurl.com/4hjmy3mc CarbonCapture Inc. unveiled 1st US DAC system designed for mass production. This system will be capable of producing ~4,000 modules annually =~2 megatons of annual CDR. tinyurl.com/3c55cfk6 Equatic.tech in partnership with Deep Sky has commenced engineering work on its commercial-scale mCDR plant to be located in Canada. The facility would take 109,000t/yr of atm CO2. tinyurl.com/49znp23m Capture6 & Veolia Water Technologies announced a global collaboration to help reach industrial scale CDR. tinyurl.com/48jxh67w Isometric partnered with 10 major companies in the climate industry to enhance CDR. tinyurl.com/3vmv62ux Skytree joined forces with Purolite, An Ecolab Company to significantly improve DAC tech. tinyurl.com/56sv9f3u Soletair Power collaborated with Danica Pension in Denmark to deliver an HVAC integrated DAC unit for reducing the net emissions of a building in Århus, Denmark. tinyurl.com/4k35k6my Swiss WorldCargo - Air cargo division of SWISS in partnership with Climeworks is offering a new solution that will use DAC & sustainable aviation fuel to offset C emissions. tinyurl.com/3vpftpnh Microsoft purchased 40,000 agricultural soil-based C credits from Indigo. tinyurl.com/3h9jp2n5 Hemp Carbon Standard sold 514 CDR Units to Concordium. tinyurl.com/2thfn8t7 Carbon to Sea Initiative & COVE announced a Joint Learning Opportunity to support scientists conducting research & companies piloting new tech for emerging mCDR solutions. Proposals are due by July 13. tinyurl.com/2wuaahts Mission Innovation launched the SMART-CDR competition for students to propose innovative MRV solutions for CDR. Proposals are due by September 9. tinyurl.com/bdh94spd Carbon Standards International AG announced the launch of Global Biochar C-Sink standard, a new pioneering standard for negative emissions based on biochar, which follows the EBC C-Sink. tinyurl.com/ya5tufu7 DNV has validated a new methodology, developed by Drax Group & Stockholm Exergi for the certification of net CDRs delivered using BECCS. tinyurl.com/2p8y7253 For more details, sign up to our Weekly CDR Newsletter: ➡https://lnkd.in/gdN6YGyC YouTube➡https://lnkd.in/gR-ykN_P
Carbon Removal Updates | Andrew Lockley | Substack
carbonremovalupdates.substack.com
To view or add a comment, sign in
-
Exploring Carbon Capture mostly Non-Solutions In my latest appearance on Tom Raftery's Climate Confident podcast, we delved deep into why carbon capture is mostly a figleaf for the fossil fuel industry. Apple: https://lnkd.in/g_TEqY9H Spotify: https://lnkd.in/g-3je69E Show notes and transcript: https://lnkd.in/gdFtinMc Listeners will discover: - Direct air capture firms like Carbon Engineering, backed by Bill Gates, its only natural market for climate-harming enhanced oil recovery and bought by oil and gas major Oxy for that purpose. - The challenges of ocean-based carbon capture, including the impact of ocean acidification and the scalability issues faced by current proposals. - How the cement industry, responsible for 8% of global CO2 emissions, can shift towards alternatives like cross-laminated timber for sustainable construction. - The risks and concerns around carbon dioxide pipelines, highlighted by a recent incident in the tiny town of Satartia, Mississippi that left dozens unconscious and hundreds evacuated. Have a listen to the episode. #ClimateAction #CarbonCapture #Sustainability #EnergyTransition
To view or add a comment, sign in
-
NEW EPISODE 🌍 Exciting updates from the heart of Europe! Catching Carbon goes live from Austria, bringing you exclusive insights from the 2024 gasworld European CO2 Summit. Join Jeff and Luke as they dive into a focused discussion on the evolving CO2 market, spanning across Europe and North America. 💬 From stakeholder analysis to governmental trends, emerging technologies, and potential industry disruptors, we leave no stone unturned. How can we ignite innovation, safeguard supply chains, and achieve our climate objectives as a global community? 🌱 Don't miss this pivotal episode setting the stage for a sustainable future! #CatchingCarbon #gasworld #ClimateAction #Innovation #Sustainability #CO2 #carbondioxide #CO2utilization #45Q #biogas #permitting #pricing #investment #business #podcast
To view or add a comment, sign in
-
Our Jeffrey Rissman joins S&P Global's #podcast host Camellia Moors to discuss industrial greenhouse gas #emissions and dive into some of the #decarbonization strategies that he outlines in his book, Zero Carbon Industry. 🏭🔊 https://lnkd.in/e7USiitt
Energy Evolution: Decarbonizing heavy industry with technology and policy on Apple Podcasts
podcasts.apple.com
To view or add a comment, sign in
-
🌎🆕 Climate Correction Podcast episode!🌎🔊 🎙Starting our fourth season!🎙 Jason Dodier, Co-Founder of the GRAIN Ecosystem, is a visionary American business professional committed to revolutionizing carbon dioxide removal global project development through digitization, transparency, and increased access to capital. Based in New York City, he played a key role in advancing Energy as a Service microgrid in the U.S., notably contributing to the groundbreaking JFK's New Terminal One Microgrid. A circular economy is an economic system aimed at minimizing waste and making the most of resources. In a circular economy, resources are kept in use for as long as possible, extracting the maximum value from them, and then recovering and regenerating products and materials at the end of each service life. This contrasts with the traditional linear economy model, which follows a "take-make-dispose" pattern. The circular economy is based on several principles, including designing out waste and pollution, keeping products and materials in use, and regenerating natural systems. It encourages practices such as recycling, reuse, remanufacturing, and the use of renewable energy sources. Biochar is a type of charcoal produced from biomass (organic matter) through pyrolysis, which involves heating the biomass without oxygen. Biochar is known for its potential benefits in agriculture, carbon sequestration, and soil improvement. 🔊Listen now here : https://bit.ly/3uSB5XT 🔊 https://lnkd.in/eihYcMNd #EnglishPodcast #Podcasting #Podcaster #NewSeason #Season4 #ClimateCorrection #Florida #CircularEconomy
To view or add a comment, sign in
-
🚀 🚀 🚀 S1-E01_"Turning metals Green”: from conventional steel-making to low carbon emission process with SMS group. The first episode of the #Green_Transition_podcast is out! 🎆 In this episode we talk with Thiago Campos – co-head of the Green steel at the SMS group. I remember for writing graduation project everyone at my university’s group wanted to get an internship at the metallurgical enterprise, with steel production plants to be on top – because we were environmental engineers and metallurgical industry have been giving many opportunities for environmental engineering improvements. Simply speaking, the processes contribute heavily to the carbon emissions. Hea-vi-ly. You cannot imagine how impressed I was to be introduced to the SMS Group and the Green steel concept that allows for emission reductions of way over 50%, and even net zero is becoming a reality. In this episode we discuss: 🔹 How the conventional metallurgical process looks like 🔸 What are the differences between iron and steel (there is just one tiny difference, did you know that?) and that the conventional production process takes place in a furnace higher than a cottage 🔹 What is the meaning behind the color labels for hydrogen and related technologies: Grey vs. Blue vs. Green hydrogen 🔸 What is Green steel and how this technology is different from the conventional route 🔹 Importance of the steel industry here in Luxembourg 🇱🇺 🔸 And the biggest challenges for the industry and possible ways to address them We really hope you will enjoy the talk! Find out more at the first episode, the Podcast team *** "Green Transition" is a podcast where we aim to give a big picture for the Green Energy transition with a specific focus on H2 technologies through reviewing the full value chain and interconnecting all the related fields. Subscribe and leave us your comments and questions(!) to be covered at the next episodes: ✅ Apple Podcast https://lnkd.in/e3C2ackd ✅ Spotify https://lnkd.in/eMKcdDAn Stay tuned! ✨ #GreenSteel #Metallurgy #Hydrogen #EnergyTransition #CarbonEmissions #ProcessUpgrade #Innovations #Luxembourg Bradley Ladewig Thiago Campos Anastasiia Gafiullina Riccardo S. Tom Brinckmann Pia Ladstätter
To view or add a comment, sign in
-
We’re pleased to share the Green Transition Podcast, an initiative led by Professor Bradley Ladewig and Anastasiia Gafiullina from the Université du Luxembourg, which explores hydrogen’s role in the green energy transition. In the first episode, Bradley and Anastasiia, from the coordination team of LuxHyVal, talk with Thiago Campos , Co-Head of Green Steel at the SMS group and a partner of the LuxHyVal project. The discussion highlights hydrogen's impact on sustainable industries and its importance in driving the green transition. 👉 Link to the original post : https://lnkd.in/enYKNb3k
🚀 🚀 🚀 S1-E01_"Turning metals Green”: from conventional steel-making to low carbon emission process with SMS group. The first episode of the #Green_Transition_podcast is out! 🎆 In this episode we talk with Thiago Campos – co-head of the Green steel at the SMS group. I remember for writing graduation project everyone at my university’s group wanted to get an internship at the metallurgical enterprise, with steel production plants to be on top – because we were environmental engineers and metallurgical industry have been giving many opportunities for environmental engineering improvements. Simply speaking, the processes contribute heavily to the carbon emissions. Hea-vi-ly. You cannot imagine how impressed I was to be introduced to the SMS Group and the Green steel concept that allows for emission reductions of way over 50%, and even net zero is becoming a reality. In this episode we discuss: 🔹 How the conventional metallurgical process looks like 🔸 What are the differences between iron and steel (there is just one tiny difference, did you know that?) and that the conventional production process takes place in a furnace higher than a cottage 🔹 What is the meaning behind the color labels for hydrogen and related technologies: Grey vs. Blue vs. Green hydrogen 🔸 What is Green steel and how this technology is different from the conventional route 🔹 Importance of the steel industry here in Luxembourg 🇱🇺 🔸 And the biggest challenges for the industry and possible ways to address them We really hope you will enjoy the talk! Find out more at the first episode, the Podcast team *** "Green Transition" is a podcast where we aim to give a big picture for the Green Energy transition with a specific focus on H2 technologies through reviewing the full value chain and interconnecting all the related fields. Subscribe and leave us your comments and questions(!) to be covered at the next episodes: ✅ Apple Podcast https://lnkd.in/e3C2ackd ✅ Spotify https://lnkd.in/eMKcdDAn Stay tuned! ✨ #GreenSteel #Metallurgy #Hydrogen #EnergyTransition #CarbonEmissions #ProcessUpgrade #Innovations #Luxembourg Bradley Ladewig Thiago Campos Anastasiia Gafiullina Riccardo S. Tom Brinckmann Pia Ladstätter
To view or add a comment, sign in
-
I’m 🔥 overjoyed 🔥 to see a 🇫🇷 French startup 🇫🇷 taking the lead with breakthrough technology to turn air into low-carbon energy sources for transportation that can soon be priced at parity with hydrocarbon-based fuels. The energy-tech startup Aerleum, headquartered in Strasbourg, has raised €5.5 billion in a seed funding round led by 360 Capital and HTGF | High-Tech Gründerfonds. Other investors participating include Bpifrance, Norrsken VC and Marble. I am SO GLAD the Earth isn’t going to get trapped into a default solution of capturing carbon, burying it in the ground and desperately hoping it stays there. The carbon has value once it is extracted from the atmosphere and, frankly, I’m relieved that Aerleum is committed to turning carbon into e-fuels. Its first objective is to turn 1 billion metric tons of CO2 into methanol. Why is that important? Shifting from traditional hydrocarbon-based fuels to green methanol can reduce CO2 emissions 60% to 95%.[Source: World Economic Forum]. Other benefits include slashing nitrogen oxide emissions 60% to 80% and practically doing away with emissions of particulate matter and sulfur oxide. Bottom line: Aerleum is good news for our friend the Earth. 🌍 #efuel #cleanfuel #methanol #greenmethanol 🌍 REG CROWDER - Freelance writer, journalist & editor - www.RegCrowder.com 🌍 https://lnkd.in/eE8n9htB
Company aims to turn one of the world's worst pollutants into usable ship fuel: 'Super competitive, even with fossil fuels'
https://www.thecooldown.com
To view or add a comment, sign in
513 followers