Elizabeth Deveny’s Post

View profile for Elizabeth Deveny, graphic

CEO at Consumers Health Forum of Australia (CHF) | Director, Advisor, Media Commentator | GAICD

Is Medicare having a mid-life crisis? Today's great symposium on the Future of Medicare felt a little like a group of caring friends staging an evidence-based intervention to help a dearly loved 40-year-old get back on track. The day started with the premise that forty years ago, Medicare was introduced to reduce healthcare costs and simplify the healthcare system. Along with Pradeep Philip, Prof Jane Hall and Richard Holden on the first panel, we asked: 'Is Medicare doing this now?' I'm keen to know - what do you think? There was a lot of talk about the universality of Medicare. What does universality mean to Australians? Is it about everyone paying their share to fund Medicare? Or is it about everyone getting fair access? Maybe it's about healthcare being free for all? This is a question we must answer together. What do you think Caroline Edwards, Stephen Duckett, Anthony Scott? There's more to Medicare than simply defining universality. Baked into Medicare are assumptions about risk versus benefit – it's a debate at the heart of healthcare. Should we use data about patient risk to determine access to care? Or should the likely benefit from treatment be more important? This question is more than academic. There were lots of conversations today about how we allocate taxpayers dollars to ensure the best outcomes for all Australians. Prioritising risk helps us address the most urgent needs first. But focusing on treatment benefits can lead to long-term health improvements. Striking the right balance is critical. I'd love your thoughts. Denzil G Fiebig James Downie Emily Lancsar Health equity was an recurring theme running through the sessions today. Tailored approaches to address inequities, like targeted bulk billing incentives or MyMedicare, can be problematic. These proliferating programs aim to help but in practice can make the system more difficult to navigate and so more inequitable for health consumers. Sam Shipley Dr Liz Develin The role of administrative data in evaluating and researching Medicare’s effectiveness cannot be overstated. Often it is all we've got. Yet administrative data is not usually collected for research or evaluation purposes. Colleagues today presented important insights using this not always fit-for-purpose data. It's crucial to bring academic views, such as those of health economists, evaluation experts, and others, into the conversation alongside public servants, citizens, industry, and clinicians. Phillip Gould Teresa Dickinson PSM Kees Van Gool Just like friends staging an intervention, there was honesty, support, hope, dare I say love, in the room today. Public conversations about Medicare where everything is open for conversation, even the more sensitive issues, are essential. By bringing all voices to the table, we can move forward together and ensure our healthcare system meets the needs of all Australians. Academy of the Social Sciences in Australia #Medicare #HealthFunding #HealthEconomics

  • Pradeep Phillip, Jane Hall, Richard Holden, Elizabeth Deveny, Anthony Scott in a post-panel selfie
Stephen Duckett

Health economist, board director

5mo

Medicare was (re)introduced as part of the Accord with the unions, it was to increase the social wage by reducing what would otherwise have been paid out of pocket for private health insurance or out of pocket fees. It was designed as a universal scheme, partly because that was more efficient than previous targeted schemes, and also, obviously, because that was equitable. This latter point re targeting may be true again now: a return to a universal scheme is not out of bounds in terms of cost as Yuting Zhang and Karinna Saxby have shown. I agree we need to do a lot more thinking about universality, although those questions wouldn’t be where I would start. Medicare when introduced was about financial barriers to access, with the assumption that what you were getting was high quality, clinically and culturally appropriate, timely care. I think the new universality agenda needs to do a lot more thinking about quality than was done when Medicare was introduced. For a start, is it possible for good quality care to be delivered in practices which are mostly monodisciplinary with contracted GPs? Assuming it is, how would we know, and how would a patient know which practice is better for them in terms of quality vs any other practice?

Mark Burdack, FGIA GAICD BLegS (Hon) BA

Chief Executive Officer | Associate Investigator @ University of Sydney | Governance Specialist

5mo

The point about targeting was really important & well made. Targeting is in my view a root cause of the failure of Medicare to ensure fair access. It takes away our focus from good health and health for all. This is not to suggest that there is not special needs from time to time, but by granting special status to one group or disease over another, there is an inevitable flow-on impact. Working in the remote town of Collarenebri (yes it was a long trip to Canberra for the symposium), we see every day how targeting results in a cascade failure of service access, and increased deaths, for rural and remote people. If universality is the goal, it needs to be integral to decision making - how does this decision lift all boats? When I hear an announcement of a new Urgent Care Centre in south-west Sydney or a hospital upgrade in Bathurst, all I think about is how many GPs rural people are going to lose this time as the government undermines its own rural medical workforce programs again. Until we make universality central to our decision making again, the system will continue to fail & prices will continue to rise.

Jason Trethowan

Chief Executive Officer at headspace

5mo

The 40 year old Medicare is failing young people who seek support for mental health, physical health and sexual health. Not so much for people who can afford but for those who can’t afford gap payments. For instance, through headspace there has been a decline in MBS activity by 52% in the last 6 years.

Alison Koschel

Executive Manager Population Access and Performance Hunter New England Central Coast Primary Health Network

5mo

When we look at the data it should be to start a conversation with the users of the system to confirm what we see and lead us to the “why”. It seems sometimes we forget consumers and clinicians on the ground who have invaluable insights. Evaluation with that in mind is crucial. As Mark points out sometimes what seems like the solution has such a negative impact on rural health which deepens the existing crisis.

Judy Powell

Policy | Advocacy | Strategic planning | Stakeholder engagement

5mo

An incredibly important conversation about aspirations for Medicare. Let's hope the future translates into better access for people to the treatment they need from the full multidisciplinary team including allied health professionals. Five sessions a year for a person with severe chronic conditions such as diabetes is not enough.

Suzanne Fuzzard

Summit Health Learning and Development Coordinator @suzannefuzzardconsulting (private consulting)

5mo

I agree change Is needed if Medicare is to be equitable to all, especially those with mental health concerns, social disadvantage and living in rural settings. I saw some exciting ways single session therapy could work alongside of GPs while on my Churchill Fellowship last year and really think this could support people in getting timely mental health support alongside of primary care, ensuring people only needing one session get this quickly, freeing up longer sessions for those also needing more. Let’s expand how we do primary care. My report is available on the Churchill Trust website.

Elizabeth de Somer

Chief Executive Officer at Medicines Australia | FMPP | GAICD | IMNIS Industry Mentor | Board and Advisory Boards

5mo

Medicare and the PBS go hand in hand. We need to ensure universal and equitable access to Medicare and to medicines can meet the needs of our communities. #strongerPBS

Thank you for being involved in the event and for capturing it so wonderfully above too!

Melissa Sweet

Public health journalist, Editor in Chief, Croakey Health Media

5mo
Peter Grimbeek

Contributor at MindHive

5mo

May Medicare continue onwards in increasingly refined and strengthened forms. It was a good idea, and continues to be that.

See more comments

To view or add a comment, sign in

Explore topics