I've seen this article about Regenerative corn/maize being posted a lot in my #foodsystems circles, and was interested to take a deeper dive into it. Some reactions: -It was cool to see that some of the farmers in the study are from my home state of #Nebraska, not far from the farming community where I grew up. -It's truly wonderful to see farmers in the Midwestern US being able to increase profitability while investing in #soilhealth, reducing pesticide usage, and improving #biodiversity. This is something I'm celebrating, and I wish we could see more farmers adopting in that context. However, this section gave me pause: "Regenerative farms produced 29% less corn grain than conventional operations" "They also received higher value for their crop by receiving an organic premium, by selling their grain directly to consumers as seed or feed" What's difficult about translating this for smallholders in sub-Saharan Africa is that the context can be quite different: a) For many vulnerable farmers One Acre Fund works with, a 29% decrease in grain yields can be devastating to their families. b) All of the nine countries in sub-Saharan Africa One Acre Fund works in are currently net importers of cereals and grains. c) There is currently no regenerative organic price premium to offset the 29% drop in yields for staple crops like maize or beans in the smallholder context in sub-Saharan Africa (higher value crops like cacao and coffee are a slightly different story). Bottom line: We need to make #Regenerative practices like cover crops make financial sense for smallholders (which is one of the reasons why One Acre Fund joined the CASH Coalition: to figure out how to make regenerative practices economically viable for #smallholders across the world). https://lnkd.in/duRdHhur
I love LinkedIn posts like this. Very informative, and then good discussion in the comments to add further nuance. Thanks 🙏
Interesting!
... 🤔
Thanks for sharing Claire!
Programme Manager Agricultural Livelihoods at IKEA Foundation
6moInteresting thoughts Claire. I think we have to carefully look at the point of departure. Farmers in the US may have been over-supplying nutrients to their system resulting in yield levels that soils cannot naturally sustain. Smallholders in Africa may well have been under-supplying nutrients resulting in low yields and degrading soils from a different perspective. In trials we have supported in countries in Africa we mostly do not see a yield decline when farmers apply regenerative practices but rather a yield increase. This does need a lot more research to come to solid conclusions.