For people who don't know, I'm Arushi, a trained trauma-informed psychotherapist with 7 years of experience. There's an important reason why I'm mentioning these words here. I moved to Dharamshala, Himachal Pradesh almost 3 years back. In these 3 years, I've seen enough to be able to understand the "psuedo-healer" culture that prevails here. In the lanes of Dharamkot, one will see posters of "meditative healing practitioner", "barefoot counsellors", NLP coaches, therapists taking their friends as clients, inner child healing practitioners offering sessions for money I can't even imagine asking for, as a trained trauma-informed psychotherapist. Today as I shared this with my fellow practitioners, I received an acknowledgement that my annoyances are valid, and my questions, indeed, are important to ask. Some personal experiences: 1. A therapist working with people who are their friends, because the place is quite small. Where's the ethical boundary? 2. A therapist asking for some medical advice from a friend of mine and offering her one session free. Is therapy a transactional barter relationship? 3. Someone mentioning they are a barefoot counsellor and can provide informal counselling. They also mentioned that they can't see clients, but what is informal counselling? 4. Going with a Gaddi (community) family to Tanda Medical Hospital to understand why a family member is eating anti-psychotics since 9 years. What's the assessment? What's the treatment plan? The questions were not only dismissed. I was asked to move out even though the Mental Health Care Act, 2017, allows all of us to ask these questions. 5. An organisation wanting to work on mental health don't even know the nuances of what's the role of psychologists, psychiatrists, and using terms "stress disorder" so mildly. 6. A well-known organisation calling facilitators to work with intergenerational trauma and inner child healing who haven't been trained in the field of Psychology and Mental Health. 7. So many people using the words - therapist, healing, counselling.. so loosely. I'm in no way saying we don't require more healers. We also require healing for healers. However, it makes me question the importance of my degree in Psychology and the 7 years of work. No, not because I'm not worthy, but because my starting base in Dharamshala would not be starting my private practice. It will be creating awareness at the root level. Looking forward to hear your perspectives. :)
I have lived in Himachal for a few years including Bir and I am well aware of this culture. I believe there is a certain advantage to a few workshops that these institutes and people offer such as sound baths and free flow dance, etc and people interested in such engagement are more inclined towards Spiritual healing and mysticism. Also, these institutes offer a sense of belonging and community to the people visiting them which I believe is a huge driving factor. I truly believe that in this day and age, people know the difference between a qualified psychologist and a self-proclaimed counsellor but they do not know of the impact a psychologist can make in their lives which coaches and other pseudo-healers can never do.
So proud of you for calling this out. It must’ve taken immense effort and reflection from your end, when most of them around you agree and contribute to the ways things are happening at the moment in mental health field, especially where you’re residing.
The lack of regulation in this field certainly has many harmful repercussions, some of which you've mentioned here, @arushi Ralli. It's unfortunate to see professionals indulging in such behavior and to see people without the necessary qualifications claiming to be professionals. Terminology is something really important and should not be used so loosely!
I was just talking about this with my therapist—the pandemic of “life coaches” and “spiritual healers” in the US that are just snake oil schemes that end up doing more harm than good. Someone’s mental health and brain is NOT your get rich quick scheme. Lots of good salespeople out there, not as many good therapists/life coaches/counselors. I love that we’re having more conversations about mental health and that the healing space is more accessible but some people are really abusing it.
I really feel sad looking at this post this is the reason why most of the therapist wants to become clinical psychologist because they have more command over these people who donot hold a license and India should provide license to counselling psychologists too so people can differentiate
Co- Founder That Desi Psychologist| M.phil Clinical Psychology Trainee (RCI) | TEDx Speaker | Psychologist | Entrepreneur | Content Creator|
7moI remember reading a lot of research papers on it and it's not just restricted to Himachal. Nagaland, Orissa, Jharkhand and various other parts of India has these cultural practices including spirit healing, shamanism etc. I was so intrigued that I read them all, many case studies too. Even the research showed that misleading information and treatment led to delaying and advancement of symptoms. But in certain cases lead to healing. There also it was because of a lot of factors including self fulfilling profecy. I belive, a lot more ground level research is required inorder to establish certain boundaries.