Kym Johnson and Robert Herjavec Gush About Newlywed Life, Joke They're Already 'an Old Married Couple"

After enjoying their Bora Bora honeymoon and July wedding, Robert Herjavec and Kym Johnson are back to work.

“We had the best time and now we’re back to reality – and it’s still great,” Johnson told PEOPLE at the Stars Usher In the 68th Emmy Awards Season at Television Academy’s Performers Peer Group Celebration event in Beverly Hills on Monday.

As for how newlywed life is, the 39-year-old ballroom dancing champ admits she and her new husband feel like “an old married couple now.”

“It’s funny,” the Dancing with the Stars pro added. “I feel like we’ve been married for ages.”

And the couple – who fell in love during DWTS rehearsals in 2015 – admits that they’re still learning new things about each other.

“I’ve learned Kym is an amazing cook,” says Herjavec, 53, who adds his favorite dish from Johnson so far is an “incredible wrap” she made for lunch.

“I’m taking my wife duties and cooking more,” says Johnson, adding that she’s “trying.”

Along with wraps, Johnson has a few other dishes she wants to make for her Shark Tank husband including crepes – and one recipe the couple found while soaking up the sun on their honeymoon: “I got a recipe from a local French Polynesian man as well so I’ll be trying that one out,” shared Johnson.