Tori Spelling Says She Feels Like a 'Stupid Girl' Reminding Brian Austin Green of the First Time They Had Sex 

Tori Spelling and Brian Austin Green are reminiscing on their past.

On the Nov. 5 episode of the misSPELLING podcast, the Beverly Hills, 90210 alums reflected on their relationship while they were on the show, debating whether they were ever even dating. Both were hesitant to label it as that, with Green, 51, saying it was “much more.”

“That label of, like, oh, boyfriend girlfriend, are you dating? That almost felt disrespectful to me because it's like, no, we went through way more than just what normal people go through when they're dating,” he explained. “Like, oh, we dated, and then we broke up — we never did anything, we never broke up. We never said, ‘it's just you and me, let's try.’"

"There were never any boundaries or rules or anything set to it because it showed itself in so many different ways," he added.

Spelling, 51, then recalled a time when Fox rented out Disneyland for the 90210 cast and she and Green spent the entire day fighting. 

“We used to have those huge blowout fights for a lot,” Green chimed in. “And I think a lot of that was attraction and a lot of that was really coming of age in it all.”

As Spelling told more of the story, teasing that the argument ended in the two having sex for the first time, Green insisted that he didn’t remember those details.

“I was like, ‘Why are you always getting mad? Why are you why are we always fighting?’” Spelling said. “And you said, ‘Have you ever thought that maybe I fight with you because I love you?’”

“No I did not,” Green said, calling the moment "magical."

“Yeah, and you were probably saying ‘I love you’ like we're sister, brother, like, friends,” she continued. “And I was like, ‘He said I love you.’ And then we started kissing.”

“Wait, what? I love this story,” Green joked. “I feel I'm hearing a story of you and someone else right now.”

"I feel like such a stupid girl right now!" Spelling exclaimed.

She went on to tell the story, saying that because they were in public, Green proposed that they go back to the hotel. The next morning, Spelling recalled going to the hotel lobby to call co-star Jennie Garth to tell her the news.

“She was the first person I was like, ‘You're not gonna believe what happened, Brian and I slept together,’” Spelling laughed. “She was like, ‘What?’”

Green then noted, “I remember other times, but I do not remember that time at all. I don't know how that's possible.”

Never miss a story — sign up for PEOPLE's free daily newsletter to stay up-to-date on the best of what PEOPLE has to offer, from celebrity news to compelling human interest stories.

Though Green and Spelling had a romantic connection in the past, both eventually moved on to different relationships. Spelling ended up marrying Dean McDermott in May 2006, but they have since split and filed for divorce. Meanwhile, Green was married to Megan Fox from 2010-2021 and is now engaged to Sharna Burgess.