Celebrity Celebrity Weddings Celebrity Wedding Dresses All The Details of Maks and Peta's Fairytale Wedding: The Dresses! The Dances! The ... Serenade? Peta Murgatroyd came down the aisle on the arm of her father in a romantic ball gown By Stephanie Petit Stephanie Petit Stephanie Petit is a Royals Editor, Writer and Reporter at PEOPLE. People Editorial Guidelines Published on July 9, 2017 09:58AM EDT Peta Murgatroyd and Maksim Chmerkovskiy started their marriage off right! The Dancing With the Stars lovebirds tied the knot Saturday, July 8, at Oheka Castle in Long Island, New York. Chmerkovskiy's brother and fellow DWTS pro Val Chmerkovskiy served as best man. Other DWTS wedding guests included groomsman Tony Dovolani, bridesmaid Rumer Willis, Sharna Burgess, Jenna Johnson, Nyle DiMarco and Candace Cameron Bure — who all made sure to share snaps of the fairy tale ceremony and rocking reception on social media. Nyle DiMarco/Instagram Murgatroyd came down the aisle on the arm of her father in a romantic ball gown with an off-the-shoulder fitted bodice and multi-tiered, full-gathered skirt. "I didn't want a stark white dress," Murgatroyd, 30, told PEOPLE of her outfit choice in the days leading up to the wedding. "I just love the old-fashioned feel of the ivory. Especially against the castle, I didn't want stark white. I think it's more sleek, in a way." Chmerkovskiy looked dashing in a white jacket and tie with black pants. Nyle DiMarco's Instagram Following the ceremony, the couple shared a kiss under a rainbow. DiMarco shared the romantic moment on his Instagram story, captioning the video, "Brb crying." Nyle DiMarco's Instagram Nyle DiMarco's Instagram RELATED VIDEO: DWTS Couples Who Are Dancing Down the Aisle! The couple's first dance was surprisingly simple for a pair of dance pros — just a simple slow dance. However, Chmerkovskiy went all out to serenade his new bride. He sang as his talented pals performed a choreographed dance behind him. At the reception, Murgatroyd and Chmerkovskiy partied with their guests, with Murgatroyd linking up with her former DWTS partner DiMarco for a fun dance and Cameron Bure taking over the dance floor with Val. Nyle DiMarco's Instagram Guests also posed in a photo booth, where Murgatroyd showed off her second gown of the evening: a sheer dress covered in feather details. FROM PEN: How Tara Lipinski Surprised BFF 'Bridesman' Johnny Weir on Her Wedding Day: 'She's The Most Caring Person I Know' Before the big day, the couple and their guests celebrated with a lavish pre-wedding party on Friday. The newlyweds got engaged in December 2015, a little more than a year before their son Shai was born.