Skip to main contentSkip to navigation

Another view

In a weekly series, we ask the people whose jobs or areas of expertise are depicted in a work of art to give us their personal verdict
  • Interview by Laura Barnett

    A bomb disposal expert on the comedy Bluestone 42

    Interview by Laura Barnett

    Bluestone 42 succeeds in capturing the gallows humour that surrounds this most dangerous of jobs, says bomb disposal corporal Daniel Whittingham

  • Jared Leto and Matthew McConaughey in Dallas Buyers Club

    A drug expert on Dallas Buyers Club

    Dallas Buyers Club succeeds at showing how hard it is to establish the effectiveness of a new drug, says consultant physician and clinical toxicologist David Wood

  • Interview by Laura Barnett

    An SAS officer on Lone Survivor

    Interview by Laura Barnett

    'Your loyalty to your fellow soldiers is absolute,' says ex-SAS officer John Richards, on the remarkably realistic Mark Wahlberg drama about sharp-shooting Navy Seals battling al-Qaeda

  • Interview by Laura Barnett

    A boxer's view on Grudge Match

    Interview by Laura Barnett
    Boxer Frank 'Wise Guy' Buglioni tallies the points and renders his verdict on the De Niro-Stallone comedy about two fighting rivals
  • Interview by Laura Barnett

    A fencing champion on BBC swashbuckler The Musketeers

    Interview by Laura Barnett

    Fleet of foot and sharp with his weapon, D'Artagnan takes the gold medal for his TV sabre-rattling, writes fencing champion Karim Bashir

  • Interview by Laura Barnett

    A torture rehabilitation expert's view on The Railway Man

    Interview by Laura Barnett
    The torture scenes are terrifying – and completely realistic. Dick Cheney should see The Railway Man, says torture rehabilitation expert Dr William Hopkins
  • Interview by Laura Barnett

    A shipwrecked yachtsman on All Is Lost

    Interview by Laura Barnett

    No sailor worth his salt would set sail without the usual safety equipment the way Robert Redford does, says rescued sailor Tony Bullimore

  • Interview by Laura Barnett

    A mountaineer on the wintry princesses of Frozen

    Interview by Laura Barnett

    Women climbers are not high in number, but Disney's heroine Anna has the right credentials to join them – as long as she ditches the high heels, says Mollie Hughes

  • Interview by Laura Barnett

    A PG Wodehouse expert on Jeeves and Wooster in Perfect Nonsense

    Interview by Laura Barnett
    PG Wodehouse Society treasurer Jeremy Neville praises a clever, cross-dressing stage translation that stays true to the books – and is enormously enjoyable
  • Interview by Laura Barnett

    An astronaut's view on Gravity

    Interview by Laura Barnett

    Space garb isn't as sexy as Sandra Bullock's in Gravity, and real-life spacewalk dangers can be even worse, says astronaut Major Tim Peake

  • Twelve Angry Men

    A former juror's view on Twelve Angry Men

    Interview by Laura Barnett
    There's as much tense negotiation among the jurors in many real-life court cases as there is in this stage adaptation of the Sidney Lumet film, says former juror Emma Danvers
  • Interview by Laura Barnett

    A Scottish iron-age expert's view on Asterix and the Picts

    Interview by Laura Barnett
    Asterix and the Picts wasn't meant to be a historical record, says Scottish iron-age expert Fraser Hunter, but it captures the clannish mentality of the times
  • Interview by Ben Beaumont-Thomas

    A person with OCD's view on Bedlam

    Interview by Ben Beaumont-Thomas
    Bedlam captured the hemmed-in lives of many people with OCD, says Trudy Angus, but the documentary also showed it's possible to break out
  • Captain Phillips

    A counter-piracy expert's view on Captain Phillips

    Filmed on the open seas and psychologically savvy, Captain Phillips should be required viewing for anyone involved in combating Somali piracy, says counter-piracy expert Gerry Northwood

  • Interview by Laura Barnett

    A 16-year-old's view on Some Girls

    Interview by Laura Barnett
    South-London school drama Some Girls doesn't fall into the Skins trap and manages to portray teenage life realistically, says 16-year-old Grace Berger
  • Interview by Laura Barnett

    A psychosexual therapist's view on Masters of Sex

    Interview by Laura Barnett
    The TV drama about pioneer sex researchers Masters and Johnson understands the prudishness of the period perfectly, says therapist Krystal Woodbridge
  • Interview by Laura Barnett

    An Austen expert's view of Austenland

    Interview by Laura Barnett
    Louise West was curator of Jane Austen's House Museum. What does she think of the US theme-park romcom?
  • Interview by Laura Barnett

    A town planner's view of The Wrong Mans

    Interview by Laura Barnett
    James Corden and Mathew Baynton's new comedy of council staff engulfed by a sinister plot gets some things spot-on – but planners are more fun in real life, says Derek Carnegie
  • Interview by Laura Barnett

    One Direction superfan's view of their documentary This is Us

    Interview by Laura Barnett

    The band's film could have had more music, but impresses Ryan Clarke by showing how hard the boys work

  • Interview by Laura Barnett

    A teacher's view on Big School

    Interview by Laura Barnett
    The staffroom stereotypes may be spot on, but even David Walliams can't save a show that laughs at teachers more than with them, says Sarah Jones
About 319 results for Another view
1234...