Paper 191
Paper 191
Paper 191
& 2010 Macmillan Publishers Limited All rights reserved 0268-3369/10 $32.00
www.nature.com/bmt
ORIGINAL ARTICLE
Caspofungin at standard dose was evaluated as first-line Bone Marrow Transplantation (2010) 45, 1227–1233;
monotherapy of mycologically documented probable/ doi:10.1038/bmt.2009.334; published online 11 January 2010
proven invasive aspergillosis (IA) (unmodified European Keywords: allogeneic; aspergillosis; caspofungin;
Organisation for Research and Treatment of Cancer/ hematopoietic SCT
Mycosis Study Group criteria) in allogeneic hematopoie-
tic SCT patients. The primary efficacy end point was
complete or partial response at end of caspofungin
treatment. Response at week 12, survival and safety were Introduction
additional end points. Enrollment was stopped prema-
turely because of low accrual, with 42 enrolled and 24 Invasive aspergillosis (IA) may develop as a complication in
eligible, giving the study a power of 85%. Transplant was up to 30% of patients undergoing allogeneic hematopoietic
from unrelated donors in 16 patients; acute or chronic SCT (HSCT).1–3 Data from prospective and retrospective
GVHD was present in 15. In all, 12 patients were studies indicate that response rates for IA are low among
neutropenic (o500/ll) at baseline, 10 received steroids allogeneic HSCT recipients, and mortality is higher compared
and 16 calcineurin inhibitors or sirolimus. Median duration with autologous HSCT patients.4–6 Therapeutic decisions for
of caspofungin treatment was 24 days. At the end of these patients are difficult and it is not always possible to
caspofungin therapy, 10 (42%) patients had complete maintain an acceptable balance between toxicity and efficacy
or partial response (95% confidence interval: 22–63%); with commonly used antifungal regimens for IA.7–9 Caspo-
1 (4%) and 12 (50%) had stable and progressing disease, fungin is an exception in that, it has proven not only to be
respectively; one was not evaluable. At week 12, eight effective against IA, but has been well tolerated even among
patients (33%) had complete or partial response. Survival patients who were intolerant to or failed previous therapy.9–11
rates at week 6 and 12 were 79 and 50%, respectively. The objective of this study was to evaluate caspofungin as
No patient had a drug-related serious adverse event or dis- first-line therapy in the treatment of proven and probable
continued because of toxicity. Caspofungin first-line therapy IA in patients who had received allogeneic HSCT. Proven
was effective and well tolerated in allogeneic hematopoietic or probable IA was defined by European Organisation for
SCT patients with mycologically documented IA. Research and Treatment of Cancer–Mycosis Study Group
(EORTC–MSG) criteria, and based on microscopy, culture,
histopathology or Aspergillus galactomannan detection
assay.12 Unlike most studies in IA, patients with a halo
sign only (without proper microbiological documentation)
Correspondence: Dr R Herbrecht, Department of Oncology and were excluded. A second stratum of this study evaluating
Hematology, Hôpital de Hautepierre, Strasbourg 67098, France.
E-mail: [email protected]
caspofungin first-line monotherapy in patients with hema-
Received 10 July 2009; revised 29 September 2009; accepted 16 October tological malignancies and autologous HSCT was designed
2009; published online 11 January 2010 separately and the results have been reported separately.13
Caspofungin in invasive aspergillosis
R Herbrecht et al
1228
Patients and methods at the end of caspofungin therapy. Secondary end points
included the response rate at week 12 after the start of
Study design caspofungin treatment, survival rate at week 12 and safety.
This phase II, open-label, non-randomized, multicenter study The primary response and survival analyses were
was designed to evaluate the efficacy and safety of caspofungin performed in the modified intent-to-treat patient popula-
as first-line monotherapy in patients with IA and allogeneic tion, which included all patients with mycologically
HSCT. The protocol was approved by the EORTC protocol confirmed probable/proven IA who received at least one
review committee and the institutional review boards of all dose of caspofungin treatment. The per protocol group
participating centers, and the trial was conducted in accordance included eligible patients who received a minimum of 15
with Good Clinical Practices and the Declaration of Helsinki. days of caspofungin treatment but excluded those whose
Written informed consent was obtained from each patient and treatment was modified without adequate reason, accord-
enrollment was centrally coordinated at the EORTC Data ing to the Data Review Committee. Safety was assessed in
Center using a secure web-based system. A Data Review all patients who started treatment, including those who
Committee assessed eligibility and response for each case. were ineligible or not upgraded.
Patient evaluations included medical history, physical
Patient population examination, Karnofsky score, laboratory assessments (hema-
EORTC-MSG definitions were used to determine whether tology and chemistry profiles) at study entry, weekly while on
patients had proven, probable, or possible IA.12 Only treatment, and up to 30 days after end of study treatment.
patients with proven or probable IA strictly according to Repeated Aspergillus galactomannan tests and computed
EORTC–MSG criteria that require positive microscopy, tomography scans or magnetic resonance imaging of chest
culture, histopathology or galactomannan Ag in serum or or any other site of infection were carried out in patients if
in bronchoalveolar lavage (BAL) fluid were eligible for this clinically indicated. Sputum cultures, BAL, biopsy of pulmon-
study. Patients with possible IA, namely those with halo ary and extrapulmonary lesions, and CSF examination were
sign only but without mycological documentation, could be carried out if clinically appropriate. A galactomannan index
enrolled but had to be upgraded to proven or probable IA X0.7 was considered to be positive.14,15 Definite infection
within 7 days of registration based on tests performed required a positive histopathology or culture from a sterile site
before or within 48 h after registration. Patients not (for example, lung biopsy). Two consecutive positive galacto-
upgraded were discontinued from the study but assessed mannan tests in blood or one positive test in BAL or a positive
for safety and treated for IA at the discretion of the sputum or BAL microscopy or culture were needed for a
investigator. All patients were at least 18 years of age and diagnosis of probable infection.
had not received previous therapy with an echinocandin, Study evaluations were carried out using standard
more than 72 h of previous empirical antifungal therapy, or response assessment criteria.16 Complete response required
any investigational agent within 14 days before registration. resolution of all attributable clinical signs and symptoms,
Antifungal prophylaxis was discontinued at study entry. disappearance of all radiological lesions, and no new
Patients were excluded on the basis of known allergy or clinical symptoms or signs or radiological abnormalities
adverse reaction to echinocandins, severe renal failure, compatible with IA (in the case of a residual scar, a
significant liver function test abnormalities (increases in decrease of at least 90% in the sum of the area of the
alanine aminotransferase or aspartate aminotransferase attributable measurable lesions was required). Partial
45 upper limit of normal; serum bilirubin/alkaline response required major improvement of fever and
phosphatase 45 upper limit of normal; Child Pugh attributable clinical signs and symptoms, with no new
score X9), hepatic insufficiency, known bacterial infection clinical symptoms or signs or radiological abnormalities
not adequately treated, documented human immuno- and at least a 50% decrease in the sum of the areas of the
deficiency virus infection, pregnant/lactating women, con- attributable measurable lesions. Stable disease was defined
ditions hampering compliance or a Karnofsky score p20. as the absence of complete or partial response or
progression. Disease progression was defined as worsening
of baseline clinical signs and symptoms attributable to IA,
Treatment or appearance of new clinical signs or symptoms or new
Patients received a 70 mg loading dose of caspofungin on radiological lesions compatible with IA regardless of
day 1, followed by 50 mg/day for at least 15 days and up to localization, or an increase in the sum of areas of the
12 weeks (maximum treatment duration). Dose modifica- attributable measurable clinical and radiological lesions, or
tions were made for patients with body weight 480 kg death likely because of aspergillosis and death because of
(70 mg/day) or moderate hepatic insufficiency (after 70 mg any cause at any time if response could not be assessed
loading dose, 35 mg/day). Addition or modification to before death.
protocol therapy in the absence of an evaluation of efficacy
was considered a treatment failure. Patients with stable
disease were requested to continue study treatment for at Statistical considerations
least 28 days to obtain a final efficacy evaluation. On the basis of a one-stage Fleming design with significance
level of 0.10 and 95% power to detect an effective therapy if
Efficacy and safety end points and evaluations the true response rate was at least 33% (null hypothesis:
The primary end point was the proportion of patients true response rate p13%), this therapy would be recom-
with complete response or partial response to caspofungin mended for further investigation in a phase III trial if at
80
Percent survival
60
40
20
0
0 2 4 6 8 10 12
Time (weeks)
Figure 1 Survival in 24 allogeneic hematopoietic SCT recipients with mycologically documented invasive aspergillosis (IA) and treated in first line with
caspofungin.
240 1000
900
200 800
Creatinine (μmol/L)
700
160 γ-GT (IU/L)
600
120 500
400
80 300
200
40
100
0 0
Baseline EOT Baseline EOT
200 200
160 160
AST (IU/L)
ALT (IU/L)
120 120
80 80
40 40
0 0
Baseline EOT Baseline EOT
1000
900
800
a: Creatinine; P =0. 16
700
ALP (IU/L)
600
b: γ-glutamyltransferase; P =0.19
500
c: Aspartate aminotransferase; P =0.08
400
300
d: Alanine aminotransferase; P =0.93
200
100
e: Alkaline phosphatases; P =0.75
0
Baseline EOT
Figure 2 Renal and liver function tests at baseline and end of caspofungin therapy (EOT). Box plots show median values (line in box), 25th and 75th
percentiles, and outlying values (vertical lines). Safety population comprises 42 patients.
those used for the voriconazole trial; a partial response Recent data suggest that survival should be assessed at
required a decrease of at least 50% of the sum of the area of week 6 rather than week 12 as most deaths occurring
the baseline radiological lesions in conjunction with after week 6 are related to the underlying condition.20,21
significant symptomatic improvement. Interestingly, survival analysis showed 79% survival at