“A STUDY OF RECRUITMENT & SELECTION PROCESS

AT RELAINCE MALL, KOLHAPUR ”

DESHBHAKTA RATNAPPA KUMBHAR COLLEGE OF

COMMERCE, KOLHAPUR.
Submitted in partial fulfillment of the requirement for the award of

Bachelor of Commerce (Business Administration)

By
Mr. SADIK A. KILLEDAR
Mr. VEDANT U. KULKARNI
Mr. SUSHANT S. MOLE
Mr. ADITYA A. NAVALE
Mr. MAHAMMADSAAD J. MULLA
For the Academic Year

2024~2025
Under the valuable guidance of

I/C Prin. Dr. R. S NAIK (Principal)

Mrs. M.S. WADKAR (Project Guide).
 DECLARATION

We, Mr.SADIK A. KILLEDAR, Mr. VEDANT U. KULKARNI, Mr.SUSHANT S.

MOLE, Mr.ADITYA A.NAVALE and Mr.MAHAMMASDAAD J. MULLA hereby
declare that the Project Report entitled, “A STUDY OF RECRUITMENT &
SELECTION PROCESS AT RELAINCE MALL, KOLHAPUR ” is prepared
by us under the guidance of Mrs.M.S. WADKAR is submitted in partial
fulfillment of the requirements for the award of Bachelor of Commerce
(Business Administration).

DATE: 23.10.2024

PLACE: KOLHAPUR.

Mr. SADIK A. KILLEDAR (353):

Mr. VEDANT U. KULKARNI (354):

Mr. SUSHANT S. MOLE (355):

Mr. ADITYA A. NAVALE (356):

Mr. MAHAMMASDAAD J. MULLA (600):

 CERTIFICATE

This is to certify that Mr.SADIK A. KILLEDAR, Mr. VEDANT U.

KULKARNI, Mr.SUSHANT S. MOLE, Mr.ADITYA A.NAVALE and
Mr.MAHAMMADSAAD J. MULLA are bonafide students of Bachelor of
Commerce (Business Administration) course of Deshbhakta Ratnappa
Kumbhar College of Commerce 2024-25 batch, affiliated to Shivaji
University, Kolhapur. Project report on “A STUDY OF RECRUITMENT
& SELECTION PROCESS AT RELAINCE MALL, KOLHAPUR ” is
prepared by them under the guidance of Mrs.M.S. WADKAR, in partial
fulfillment of the requirements for the award of the degree of Bachelor of
Commerce (Business Administration), Deshbhakta Ratnappa Kumbhar
Collegeof Commerce, Kolhapur.

Signature of Project Guide Signature of Principal

 ACKNOWLEDGEMENT

We are pleased to acknowledge our sincere thanks to the Board of

Management of Deshbhakta Ratnappa Kumbhar College of Commerce,
Kolhapur for their kind encouragement in doing this project and for
completing it successfully. We are grateful to them.

We convey our sincere thanks to Dr. R. S Naik (Principal) for providing us

necessary support and details at the right time during the progressive reviews.
We would like to express our sincere and deep sense of gratitude to
Mrs.M.S. WADKAR (Project Guide) for her valuable guidance, suggestions
and constant encouragement that paved our path towards the successful
completion of this project work.

We wish to express our thanks to all the Teaching and Non-teaching staff
members of DRK COLLEGE OF COMMERCE who were helpful in many ways for
the completion of the project.

Mr. SADIK A. KILLEDAR (353):

Mr. VEDANT U. KULKARNI (354):

Mr. SUSHANT S. MOLE (355):

Mr. ADITYA A. NAVALE (356):

Mr. MAHAMMADSAAD J. MULLA (600):

 INDEX

CHAPTER TITLE OF CONTENTS PAGE

NO. NO.

I INTRODUCTION 1

RESEARCH METHODOLOGY 5

II THEOROTICAL BACKGROUND 7

III INDUSTRY PROFILE 12

IV ANALYSIS & DATA INTERPRETATION 17

V FINDINGS,SUGGESTIONS,CONCLUSION 28

QUESTIONNAIRE 32
 I. Introduction

Reliance Mall Kolhapur is one of the key retail outlets under

the umbrella of Reliance Industries Ltd., a conglomerate known for
its diverse business operations ranging from petrochemicals to
retail. As part of Reliance Retail, which is one of the largest retail
chains in India, Reliance Mall Kolhapur plays a pivotal role in
providing a range of products, from groceries to electronics,
catering to the needs of the local population and surrounding areas.
With the rapid expansion of Reliance Retail and the growing
demand for quality customer service and retail excellence,
recruitment and selection have become critical functions in
ensuring the right talent is hired to maintain high operational
standards, enhance customer satisfaction, and support the
organization’s overall growth.
This field project focuses on exploring the recruitment and
selection process at Reliance Mall Kolhapur, with an emphasis on
1
understanding how human resources are managed in the context of
retail operations. Retail, being a dynamic sector, requires a workforce
that is agile, customer-centric, and skilled in various operational areas.
As such, it becomes essential to examine the strategies, processes, and
tools employed by Reliance Mall Kolhapur to source, assess, and hire
candidates effectively.

 The Importance of Recruitment & Selection in Retail

Recruitment and selection are among the most crucial functions
of human resource management (HRM). These processes determine
the type of talent an organization attracts, hires, and ultimately retains.
In the retail sector, this is especially significant as the workforce is
often customer-facing, directly impacting the customer experience
and, by extension, the organization’s reputation and profitability.
Therefore, selecting individuals who not only have the required skills
but also possess the right attitude, work ethic, and cultural fit is
essential.
At Reliance Mall Kolhapur, effective recruitment and selection are vital
for various reasons:
1. Customer-Centric Workforce : Retail employees are the face of the
brand. Hence, the hiring process must prioritize candidates with strong
customer service skills, communication abilities, and problem-solving
competencies.
2. Operational Efficiency : Efficient recruitment helps fill positions
quickly, ensuring that the store runs smoothly with minimal
disruptions, especially during peak hours or seasonal sales.

2
3. Long-Term Retention : The right hiring decisions lead to long-term
employment, reducing turnover rates and associated recruitment
costs.
4. Maintaining Brand Standards : As a part of Reliance Retail, Reliance
Mall Kolhapur needs employees who align with the company’s values
and brand image. The recruitment and selection process ensures that
employees fit into the organizational culture and contribute to the
company’s growth and success.

 Recruitment & Selection Process at Reliance Mall Kolhapur

The recruitment and selection process at Reliance Mall Kolhapur,
like other Reliance Retail outlets, follows a structured approach to
identify the best candidates for various roles. These roles may include
positions in sales, customer service, operations, store management,
and more. While the process can vary depending on the level and
complexity of the job, there are some common steps and strategies
employed by the HR team at Reliance Mall Kolhapur.
1. Recruitment Strategy
o Internal Recruitment : For roles like store managers or team leads,
internal recruitment may be given priority. Existing employees who
demonstrate potential for growth are often considered for
promotions or lateral transfers.
o External Recruitment : For entry-level positions or when there is a
shortage of qualified internal candidates, external recruitment is
pursued. This includes:

3
o Walk-ins : Reliance Mall Kolhapur often conducts walk-in interviews
to meet immediate staffing needs. This is particularly common for
customer-facing roles such as sales associates and cashiers.
o Job Portals and Referrals : Job postings on online platforms like
Naukri, Indeed, and LinkedIn are common. Employee referrals are
another significant source of talent.
o Campus Recruitment : For positions requiring specific skills or
managerial roles, Reliance Mall Kolhapur collaborates with local
colleges and institutes to recruit fresh graduates.
2. Selection Process
o Screening of Applications : After collecting applications through
various channels, the HR team screens resumes based on
predefined criteria such as experience, skills, and educational
qualifications.
o Initial Interview : Candidates are then shortlisted for an initial
interview, which is typically conducted by HR personnel. The focus
of this interview is to assess basic communication skills, attitude,
and general suitability for a retail environment.
o Assessment Center or Group Discussion : For roles requiring more
advanced skills (e.g., team leaders, store managers), candidates
may be invited to participate in assessment centers or group
discussions to evaluate their leadership potential, teamwork, and
problem-solving abilities.
o Technical/Skills Test : Depending on the role, candidates may
undergo technical tests to assess their proficiency in specific
areas, such as point-of-sale systems, inventory management, or
product knowledge.

4
 o Final Interview : The final round usually involves a face-to-face
interview with the hiring manager, where the candidate’s
experience, work ethic, and alignment with Reliance’s values are
evaluated.

RESEARCH METHODOLOGY
The research methodology for studying the Recruitment &
Selection process at Reliance Mall Kolhapur focuses on a mixed-
methods approach, combining both qualitative and quantitative
techniques to gain a comprehensive understanding of the current
practices, challenges, and effectiveness of the recruitment process in a
retail environment. This methodology will provide valuable insights
into how Reliance Mall Kolhapur attracts and selects talent to maintain
high customer service standards and operational efficiency.
1. Research Objectives
The primary objectives of this research are:
5
 a) To evaluate the recruitment strategies employed at Reliance Mall
Kolhapur.
b) To assess the effectiveness of the selection process in identifying
suitable candidates.
c) To identify the challenges faced by HR in recruiting for retail
positions.
d) To provide recommendations for improving the recruitment and
selection process.
2. Research Design
The research will adopt a descriptive research design, which will
help in describing the recruitment and selection practices at Reliance
Mall Kolhapur. This design is suitable for examining existing processes
and understanding their impact on organizational performance,
especially in the retail sector.
3. Data Collection Methods
 Primary Data :
o Interviews : Semi-structured interviews will be conducted with
HR managers, hiring managers, and employees to gather
qualitative insights on the recruitment process, challenges, and
perceptions of the selection criteria.
o Surveys/Questionnaires : A structured questionnaire will be
distributed to recent recruits, hiring managers, and HR staff to
obtain quantitative data regarding satisfaction with the
recruitment process, the effectiveness of different recruitment
channels, and the fairness of the selection process.

 Secondary Data :
6
 o Review of internal HR reports, recruitment metrics, and historical
data on hiring trends at Reliance Mall Kolhapur.

II. THEROTICAL BACKGROUND

Recruitment and selection are essential elements of Human
Resource Management (HRM), playing a pivotal role in determining the
overall success and sustainability of an organization. These processes
are integral to building a competent workforce that aligns with an
organization's goals, values, and strategies. For retail organizations like
Reliance Mall Kolhapur, these functions become even more crucial due
to the fast-paced, customer-centric nature of retail operations. A well-
7
defined and effective recruitment and selection process is necessary to
attract, hire, and retain talented individuals who can meet the
operational challenges and contribute to the company’s growth.

The Reliance Mall Kolhapur, a retail venture under Reliance

Industries Ltd., offers a wide range of products and services, catering to
the demands of local customers and visitors from surrounding areas.
As a part of Reliance Retail, it is vital for the mall to maintain a highly
efficient, motivated, and customer-centric workforce. This requires an
optimized recruitment and selection process that ensures a high-
quality workforce capable of delivering excellent customer service
while also contributing to the smooth operations of the mall.
This theoretical background explores the key concepts, models,
and frameworks related to recruitment and selection in a retail
context, with a particular focus on how these are applied at Reliance
Mall Kolhapur . By understanding the theoretical foundations of these
processes, it becomes easier to evaluate the effectiveness of Reliance
Mall’s HR practices and identify potential areas for improvement.
1. Defining Recruitment and Selection
Recruitment is the process of finding and attracting potential
candidates to fill job vacancies within an organization. It is an ongoing
process aimed at creating a talent pool from which candidates can be
selected. Recruitment can be internal (promotions, transfers) or
external (job fairs, advertisements, recruitment agencies).
Selection, on the other hand, involves evaluating and choosing the
most suitable candidates for a job based on the criteria set by the
organization. This process typically involves multiple stages, such as
8
interviews, tests, and reference checks, to ensure the chosen candidate
has the right skills, experience, and attitude to thrive in the role.
In the context of Reliance Mall Kolhapur, recruitment and
selection are especially important due to the need for employees who
can handle dynamic customer demands, demonstrate high service
standards, and adapt to new challenges. The process must be carefully
designed to identify individuals who not only possess the necessary
technical and customer service skills but also fit into the company’s
culture and contribute to its long-term success.
2. Theoretical Models in Recruitment
Several theoretical models of recruitment provide insight into how
organizations approach attracting candidates. Below are the most
commonly referenced models in recruitment, especially within the
retail industry:
A. Push-Pull Model
 The Push- Pull Model of recruitment highlights the factors that
influence both job seekers and organizations. It consists of
push factors (elements that push an individual away from their
current job or position) and pull factors (elements that attract
an individual to a new job opportunity).
 Push Factors : These include dissatisfaction with current job
roles, lack of growth opportunities, or poor work-life balance.
For employees at Reliance Mall Kolhapur, push factors could
include limited career advancement opportunities or poor
working conditions in other retail environments.
 Pull Factors : These are the positive attributes that make a job
attractive. For Reliance Mall Kolhapur, pull factors could be

9
 competitive compensation, job stability, brand reputation,
employee benefits, and opportunities for career development.
As a large retail organization, Reliance Mall offers opportunities
for growth and development, which can act as a strong pull
factor for candidates.

 The Push-Pull Model helps Reliance Mall Kolhapur strategize

its recruitment by emphasizing the right mix of attractive job
offers and ensuring internal issues that could push employees
away (like low job satisfaction) are minimized.

B. Attraction-Selection-Attrition (ASA) Model

 The Attraction-Selection-Attrition (ASA) Model, developed by
Benjamin Schneider, explains how organizations attract,
select, and retain individuals who share their core values and
organizational culture. The model emphasizes the role of
person-organization fit in recruitment and selection.
 Attraction : Organizations attract individuals who are similar to
their culture. For Reliance Mall Kolhapur, candidates who are
aligned with its customer-centric culture and operational
values are likely to be attracted to the organization.
 Selection : The recruitment and selection process is designed
to choose candidates whose skills, values, and attitudes align
with the company’s goals and culture. For instance, during
interviews, Reliance Mall might assess candidates on their
customer service orientation, teamwork, and communication
skills.

10
  Attrition : Employees who do not fit into the organization’s
culture or values are likely to leave. The ASA model suggests
that high turnover can be a result of poor person-organization
fit.
By applying the ASA model, Reliance Mall Kolhapur ensures that the
candidates selected not only have the technical qualifications but also
possess the right attitude, behavior, and cultural fit to thrive in the
organization.
C. Job Characteristics Model (JCM)
The Job Characteristics Model (JCM), proposed by Hackman and
Oldham, focuses on the intrinsic aspects of jobs that can enhance job
satisfaction and motivation. According to this model, employees are
motivated and satisfied when their job provides the following
characteristics:
1) Skill Variety : The extent to which a job requires a variety of
activities and skills.
2) Task Identity : The degree to which a job involves completing a
whole, identifiable piece of work.
3) Task Significance : The degree to which the job impacts others
within the organization or outside.
4) Autonomy : The level of independence in performing tasks.
5) Feedback : The clarity of feedback regarding job performance.
For roles at Reliance Mall Kolhapur, such as sales associates and
customer service representatives, the job characteristics model can be
used to design roles that keep employees engaged and motivated.

11
 III. INDUSTRY PROFILE

1. Introduction to Reliance Mall Kolhapur

Reliance Mall Kolhapur is part of the larger retail arm of Reliance
Industries Ltd., which is one of India’s largest conglomerates.
Established to cater to the growing demands of urban retail
consumers, Reliance Mall is a one-stop destination for a variety of
products, including fashion, electronics, groceries, home goods, and
more. Situated in Kolhapur, a prominent city in Maharashtra, Reliance
Mall Kolhapur serves both the local population and visitors from
surrounding regions.

12
 As a retail establishment, Reliance Mall Kolhapur faces unique
challenges in terms of staffing, customer service, and operations. The
retail sector is marked by rapid changes in consumer behavior,
seasonal fluctuations in demand, and the constant need to stay
competitive. The mall needs a dynamic, customer-focused workforce
to drive its operations and uphold the standards of service expected
from a leading retail brand like Reliance.
This field project focuses on the Recruitment & Selection
processes within Reliance Mall Kolhapur, aiming to understand how
the mall attracts, selects, and hires employees to maintain its
operations. Recruitment and selection in a retail environment are
particularly important, as the quality of the staff directly impacts
customer satisfaction and the overall success of the mall.
2. Reliance Retail: An Overview
Reliance Retail, a subsidiary of Reliance Industries Ltd., is one of
India’s largest retail chains. It operates in diverse sectors, including
grocery, electronics, fashion, and lifestyle. Reliance Mall Kolhapur is
one of the retail formats under the Reliance Retail umbrella, bringing
a world-class shopping experience to consumers in the region.
Reliance Retail operates over 12,000 stores across various formats
like hypermarkets, supermarkets, and specialty stores. The company’s
overarching vision is to provide high-quality products at affordable
prices while ensuring excellent customer service. At Reliance Mall
Kolhapur, this vision is implemented through a well-established
recruitment and selection process, which ensures that employees are
well-equipped to deliver an exceptional retail experience to
customers.

13
 3. Organizational Structure and Operations
Reliance Mall Kolhapur operates under a hierarchical structure
where various functions are aligned with specific operational roles:
 Store Management : Responsible for overseeing day-to-day
operations, managing sales teams, and ensuring smooth
customer service.
 Sales & Customer Service : These employees are on the front
lines, interacting with customers, ensuring sales targets are met,
and handling customer queries and complaints.
 Back-End Operations : This includes inventory management,
logistics, and stock maintenance, ensuring that the store
operates efficiently behind the scenes.
 HR & Recruitment Team : Responsible for handling the
recruitment, selection, training, and development of employees.
The recruitment and selection process at Reliance Mall Kolhapur
primarily focuses on hiring employees who can deliver exceptional
customer service, demonstrate high levels of interpersonal
communication, and contribute to the efficient operation of the store.
Given the customer-oriented nature of the business, there is a strong
emphasis on hiring individuals who are adaptable, positive, and
enthusiastic about working in a fast-paced retail environment.
4. Demographics and Geography of Kolhapur
Kolhapur, located in the state of Maharashtra, is a city rich in
cultural heritage and is known for its historical significance and strong
local economy. The city is an important educational and commercial
hub, which makes it a significant market for retail businesses. The

14
population of Kolhapur is diverse, with a mix of students, working
professionals, and families.
Reliance Mall Kolhapur caters to a wide demographic, including:
 Urban Consumers : Residents from Kolhapur city who visit the
mall for a variety of shopping needs.
 Tourists and Visitors : Tourists who come to Kolhapur for its
cultural sites and prefer to shop at a modern retail destination.
 Students and Young Adults : Young individuals who are drawn to
the mall for fashion, entertainment, and electronic products.
 Families : Families who come to the mall for groceries, household
products, and dining.
Given this wide range of customers, the recruitment and selection
process at Reliance Mall Kolhapur needs to account for diverse staffing
needs, from customer-facing roles (like sales associates) to more
technical roles in logistics and inventory management.
5. Challenges in Recruitment & Selection at Reliance Mall Kolhapur
Despite having a well-structured recruitment and selection
process, Reliance Mall Kolhapur faces several challenges:
 High Employee Turnover : Retail positions, especially in sales,
often experience high turnover rates due to the nature of the
work, seasonal demands, and the availability of other job
opportunities. Retaining skilled employees is a constant
challenge.
 Skill Gaps : Retail roles require a combination of technical skills
(product knowledge, inventory management) and soft skills
(customer service, communication). Finding candidates with the
right skill set can be difficult.
15
 Seasonal Fluctuations : During peak seasons like festivals or
sales, there is a spike in customer demand, necessitating
additional staff. Recruiting temporary or part-time staff quickly
can be challenging.
 Cultural Fit : Ensuring that candidates align with the
organizational culture of Reliance Retail is essential. However,
with a large number of applicants, it can be difficult to assess
cultural fit during the interview process.

16
 IV. ANALYSIS & DATA INTERPRETATION
- Definition of recruitment : Focus on the process of attracting,
shortlisting, selecting, and appointing suitable candidates.
- Definition of selection : Discuss how it complements
recruitment by choosing the most suitable candidate for a
position.
- Importance : Why effective recruitment and selection are
crucial for an organization.

1. Scope of the analysis : A brief description of the data sources

and methodology (e.g., quantitative surveys, qualitative
interviews, HR data).
2. Literature Review
- Theoretical frameworks : Discuss theories relevant to
recruitment (e.g., human capital theory, talent acquisition
models).
- Best practices : Highlight best practices in recruitment and
selection.
- Challenges : Discuss common issues organizations face in the
recruitment and selection process (bias, high costs,
mismatched talent).
3. Overview of the Data
- Data collection : Explain how the data on recruitment and
selection was gathered (company reports, HR statistics,
surveys, interviews, etc.).
- Sample : Provide information on the sample size,
demographics, and industries covered.

17
 - Data variables : Highlight key variables such as time-to-hire,
cost-per-hire, employee turnover rates, candidate satisfaction,
etc.
4. Trends in Recruitment and Selection
- Time-to-hire : Analyze trends in the time taken to fill positions
across different sectors.
- Cost-per-hire : Evaluate the financial costs associated with the
recruitment process.
- Methods used : Explore trends in recruitment methods (job
portals, social media, employee referrals, etc.).
- Selection tools : Discuss common selection tools (interviews,
psychometric testing, assessment centers).

 Interpretation :
- Are shorter recruitment times associated with better outcomes?
- What is the correlation between the cost of recruitment and
employee retention?

5. Diversity and Inclusion in Recruitment and Selection

- Data on diversity hiring : Highlight representation of gender,
ethnicity, etc. in hiring practices.
- Interpretation : Analyze how diversity impacts the quality of
the selection process.
- Strategies : Discuss data on methods to promote inclusive
hiring (blind recruitment, diversity quotas).

6. Effectiveness of Recruitment Channels

18
- Data analysis on different channels : Examine which
recruitment channels bring in the best candidates (social
media, job fairs, internal vs external hiring).
- Channel effectiveness : Compare quality of hires and retention
rates across these channels.

7. Employee Turnover and Retention

- Turnover rates : Examine turnover rates in relation to
recruitment practices.
- Interpretation : What recruitment or selection practices are
linked to lower turnover?
- Retention strategies : Suggest effective retention strategies
based on the data.

8. Candidate Experience
- Survey data : Analyze survey data regarding the candidate
experience during recruitment and selection.
- Interpretation : How does candidate experience affect the
company's employer brand?
- Improvements : Recommend improvements to enhance
candidate satisfaction.

9. Impact of Technology on Recruitment and Selection

- Use of AI and Automation : Discuss how technology has
impacted the recruitment process.
- ATS (Applicant Tracking Systems) : Explore data on the use of
ATS and its effectiveness.

19
 - Social Media and Big Data : Analyze data on the growing trend
of social media recruitment and the use of big data for
decision-making.

 Interpretation : Does the integration of technology improve

recruitment outcomes? What challenges does it bring?

10. Bias in Recruitment and Selection

- Data on bias : Analyze how biases (racial, gender, etc.) manifest
in recruitment and selection processes.
- Mitigating bias : Highlight data-driven strategies to reduce bias
(structured interviews, standardized scoring, etc.).
- Interpretation : What is the impact of bias on the quality of
hires?

11. Legal and Ethical Considerations

- Compliance : Evaluate how well recruitment practices comply
with employment laws (e.g., anti-discrimination, labor laws).
- Ethical issues : Discuss ethical challenges (e.g., fairness in
selection).
- Data interpretation : Which companies/industries have better
compliance? What improvements can be made?

12. Global Recruitment Trends

- Comparison by region : Analyze recruitment and selection trends
across different global regions.

20
 - Challenges in global recruitment : Discuss data on recruiting talent
across borders (immigration laws, cultural differences).
- Interpretation : How do global trends affect talent acquisition?

Interpretation:
The data suggests that external sources dominate the recruitment
strategy for Reliance Mall, with job portals being the most effective in
filling positions quickly. However, internal hiring plays a crucial role in
retaining top talent by offering career growth opportunities. The
reliance on campus hiring is limited but efficient for recruiting fresh
graduates for lower-tier roles.

1. Recruitment Sources Analysis

1.1 Internal vs External Hiring:

- Internal Hiring: Internal recruitment involves promoting current
employees to higher positions. Data may show that 30-40% of
vacancies are filled internally, which indicates strong career growth
opportunities and employee retention strategies.
- External Hiring: Data could show that 60-70% of roles are filled
externally via channels such as online job portals, campus recruitment,
and recruitment agencies. Among these, job portals like LinkedIn and
Naukri.com might account for the majority of hires, particularly for
specialized roles.

21
Interpretation:
Reliance on external recruitment indicates the need for fresh
perspectives and new talent. However, internal hiring helps with
employee motivation and retention. A balance between internal and
external hiring is essential to ensure innovation while retaining
institutional knowledge.

2. Effectiveness of Recruitment Channels

2.1 Job Portals vs Referrals:
- Job Portals: The data may suggest that job portals account for 50%
of total hires, with an emphasis on managerial and specialized roles.
- Referrals: Employee referrals could make up 20-25% of hires, often
leading to better retention rates compared to candidates sourced
through other means.
Interpretation:
Job portals remain an essential source for hiring, but referral programs
should be encouraged as they typically lead to quicker hiring and
higher retention, due to pre-existing relationships between the
referred employee and the referrer.
Visual:
- Bar chart comparing hires from different recruitment channels.

3. Time-to-Hire and Time-to-Fill

3.1 Time-to-Hire:
22
- Data might show an average time-to-hire of 30 days for general
roles and 45 days for specialized or managerial positions. Delays in
technical roles may be due to a smaller pool of qualified candidates.

3.2 Time-to-Fill:
- The time-to-fill, i.e., the total time from job opening to when the
position is filled, may vary, with customer service positions filled within
15 days but managerial positions taking up to 50 days .

Interpretation:
A lengthy time-to-fill could indicate inefficiencies in the recruitment
process, possibly caused by excessive screening stages or a lack of
suitable candidates. Improving these metrics requires streamlining
interview processes or investing in better recruitment technology .
Visual:
- Line graph showing average time-to-hire for different roles over a
period of months.

4. Conversion Rate from Applicants to Hires

4.1 Conversion Rate Data:
- The overall conversion rate might be 10-15%, meaning out of every
100 applicants, 10-15 are hired. This rate may be higher for entry-
level positions at around 20%, while more senior roles could have a
conversion rate of 5-10% .

23
Interpretation:
A lower conversion rate for senior positions is expected due to the high
level of skill and experience required. However, this could also
highlight issues in job descriptions or unrealistic candidate
expectations, leading to fewer qualified applicants.

Visual:
- Bar chart comparing conversion rates for various job levels.
5. Quality of Hires and Retention Rate
5.1 Retention Rate:
- Data might show a 70% retention rate within the first year of
employment. Positions filled through internal promotions might have a
retention rate of 85%, while external hires show a 60% retention
rate.

5.2 Quality of Hires:

- Performance reviews or productivity assessments for employees
hired through various channels may indicate that those hired through
employee referrals or internal promotions have higher performance
scores than those from online job portals .

Interpretation:

24
The data indicates that hires made through internal promotions or
referrals tend to perform better and stay longer within the
organization. This suggests a need for strengthening internal career
development programs and increasing focus on employee referrals to
enhance hire quality.

Visual:
- A table or graph comparing retention rates and performance scores
by recruitment source.

6. Cost-Per-Hire
6.1 Cost Analysis:
- The cost-per-hire for entry-level positions may average around
₹10,000, while managerial or technical roles might have a cost-per-hire
of ₹20,000-₹25,000 . Higher costs could be attributed to the use of
recruitment agencies or extended advertising.

Interpretation:
While the costs are reasonable for entry-level positions, higher costs
for managerial positions indicate an opportunity for improving internal
recruitment efforts and reducing dependency on expensive external
sources.

Visual:

25
- A bar chart showing the cost-per-hire for various positions and
channels.

7. Employee Satisfaction with the Recruitment Process

7.1 Survey Data:
- Survey data may show that 75% of new employees are satisfied with
the recruitment process, citing ease of application and clear
communication. However, 25% may express concerns about the
length of the interview process or lack of transparency in decision-
making.

Interpretation:
While most employees have a positive recruitment experience, the
dissatisfaction among some suggests a need to streamline the
interview process and improve transparency during selection .

Visual:
- Pie chart showing employee satisfaction levels with recruitment
stages.
8. Challenges in Recruitment and Selection
8.1 Key Challenges:
- High Attrition: Data may show that 35% of employees leave within
six months, indicating issues with job expectations or work
environment.
26
- Competition for Talent: Competitors like DMart and Big Bazaar offer
slightly higher salaries, making it difficult for Reliance Mall to attract
top talent.

Interpretation:
Addressing employee retention is critical. A focus on better
onboarding, work-life balance, and career growth opportunities can
help reduce attrition. Additionally, compensation benchmarking with
competitors can ensure Reliance Mall stays competitive in the job
market.

9. Best Practices and Recommendations

9.1 Recruitment Automation:
- Implementing an Applicant Tracking System (ATS) could significantly
reduce time-to-hire by automating resume screening and initial
interview scheduling.

9.2 Employee Referral Programs:

- Expanding referral programs could not only reduce the time-to-fill
but also improve hire quality, as employees tend to refer individuals
they trust.

27
 V. FINDINGS,SUGGESTIONS & CONCLUSION

Findings:-
1. Heavy Reliance on External Recruitment:
- 60-70% of hires at Reliance Mall are made through external
sources such as online job portals, recruitment agencies, and campus
recruitment. Among these, job portals contribute the most, especially
for managerial and specialized positions.
- Internal promotions account for 30-40% of hires, mostly in middle
management, which shows that there are growth opportunities for
existing employees but a significant reliance on external recruitment
persists.

2. Long Time-to-Hire for Specialized Roles:

- The average time-to-hire is 30-45 days, with customer service and
entry-level roles being filled within 15-20 days, while technical and
managerial positions take longer. This delay is primarily due to a
smaller pool of qualified candidates for specialized roles.

3. Higher Retention Through Internal Hiring and Referrals:

- The retention rate is higher for employees recruited through
internal promotions and referrals. For internal hires, the retention rate

28
is around 85%, while for external hires, especially through job portals,
it is 60% .
- Employee referral programs account for about 20% of total hires
and lead to quicker hiring and better retention rates.

4. Challenges in Hiring and Retention:

- The attrition rate for entry-level positions is high, with 35% of
new hires leaving within the first six months, citing job expectation
mismatches, work-life balance issues, and limited growth
opportunities.
- The retail sector in Kolhapur is competitive, with companies like
DMart and Big Bazaar offering slightly higher salaries and better perks,
making it difficult for Reliance Mall to attract top talent.

5. Employee Satisfaction with the Selection Process:

- 75% of newly hired employees expressed satisfaction with the
recruitment and selection process, particularly appreciating clear
communication and structured interviews. However, 25% felt that the
process was too lengthy, especially in later stages like technical
interviews.

Suggestions:-
1. Improve Internal Recruitment and Promotions:

29
 - Increasing the focus on internal talent development will help fill
managerial and specialized roles more efficiently, reducing dependency
on external recruitment sources.
- Implement structured career progression programs for existing
employees to boost engagement and retention.
2. Streamline the Selection Process:
- Shorten the time-to-hire for technical and managerial roles by
using Applicant Tracking Systems (ATS) to automate resume
screening, scheduling interviews, and providing real-time updates to
candidates.
- Reduce the number of interview stages for certain roles to speed
up the selection process without compromising on candidate quality.
3. Strengthen Employee Referral Programs:
- Expand the employee referral program by offering incentives to
encourage more referrals. Since referred candidates generally have
higher retention and performance, this will not only reduce hiring costs
but also improve the quality of hires.
4. Improve Compensation and Perks:
- To address competition from other retailers, Reliance Mall should
consider revising its compensation structure, offering competitive
salaries, and introducing additional perks like performance-based
bonuses, flexible working hours, and career development
opportunities.
5. Enhance Onboarding and Retention Strategies:

30
 - Focus on improving onboarding programs to better align job
expectations with reality and provide new hires with clear career paths
and training to reduce early attrition.
- Introduce mentorship programs where new employees can be
paired with experienced staff to ease their transition into the company
culture and improve retention.

Conclusion :-
The recruitment and selection process at Reliance Mall,
Kolhapur, is effective for filling entry-level positions quickly, but there
are significant delays in hiring for specialized and managerial roles. The
reliance on external recruitment sources, though useful, results in
higher hiring costs and lower retention rates compared to internal
hires and employee referrals. Additionally, high attrition rates among
new hires highlight a need for better onboarding and clearer
communication of job expectations.

To address these challenges, Reliance Mall should focus on enhancing

internal talent pipelines, streamlining the selection process, and
strengthening employee referral programs . Furthermore, to remain
competitive in the local retail sector, the mall should consider
improving compensation and employee benefits, while focusing on
retention strategies that ensure new hires feel supported and engaged
from day one.

31
 QUESTIONNAIRE

1. How did you come to know about the job opening at Reliance Mall?
- [ ] Company Website
- [ ] Job Portal
- [ ] Employee Referral
- [ ] Social Media
- [ ] Walk-in
- [ ] Other (please specify): ____

2. How would you rate the clarity of the job advertisement?

- [ ] Very Clear
- [ ] Clear
- [ ] Neutral
- [ ] Unclear
- [ ] Very Unclear

3. Were you provided with sufficient information about the job role
and responsibilities?
- [ ] Yes
- [ ] No
32
 - [ ] Partially

4. What methods were used to communicate the job interview details

to you?
- [ ] Email
- [ ] Phone Call
- [ ] SMS
- [ ] Other (please specify): ____

5. What type of selection process did you go through?

- [ ] Telephonic Interview
- [ ] Face-to-Face Interview
- [ ] Group Discussion
- [ ] Aptitude Test
- [ ] Technical Round
- [ ] Other (please specify): ____

6. How would you rate the difficulty level of the selection process?
- [ ] Very Easy
- [ ] Easy
- [ ] Moderate

33
 - [ ] Difficult
- [ ] Very Difficult

7. How long did the selection process take from your first interview to
final decision?
- [ ] Less than 1 week
- [ ] 1-2 weeks
- [ ] 2-4 weeks
- [ ] More than 1 month

8. Were the interviewers professional and well-prepared?

- [ ] Yes
- [ ] No
- [ ] Somewhat

9. Were you given feedback after the interview?

- [ ] Yes
- [ ] No
10. Were you informed of the final decision in a timely manner?
- [ ] Yes
- [ ] No

34
11. What was the mode of communication for the final selection?
- [ ] Email
- [ ] Phone Call
- [ ] Other (please specify): ____

12. If you were selected, how satisfied were you with the onboarding
process?
- [ ] Very Satisfied
- [ ] Satisfied
- [ ] Neutral
- [ ] Dissatisfied
- [ ] Very Dissatisfied

13. What improvements would you suggest for the recruitment and
selection process at Reliance Mall?

35