WritingLaw.

com

The Citizenship Amendment Act, 2019 is not an amendment in the Indian

Constitution, but an amendment in law. It amends the Citizenship Act of
1955. Therefore, it is not a constitutional amendment.
Article 11 of the constitution gives power to the parliament to amend the
laws relating to citizenship in the Citizenship Act, 1955. The Act of 1955
provides for getting citizenship by birth, by acquisition, by registration, by
descent and by the process of naturalisation.
Provisions of Citizenship Amendment Act, 2019

1. The amendment says that any Hindu, Sikh, Jain, Buddhist, Parsi, and
Christian who entered India before 31 December 2014 will be treated as
legal migrants.
2. The amendment protects six communities from religious persecution in
neighbouring countries, Pakistan, Afghanistan, and Bangladesh, with the
reason that all three are Islamic countries, and therefore there can not be
religious persecution with people of Islam religion.

WritingLaw.com
3. The amendment allows every foreigner of any religion to take
citizenship of India by the process of naturalisation or registration given in
the Citizenship Amendment Act, 1955.
Citizenship by Registration

1. Any person who is of Indian origin and has stayed in India for a period
of seven years before making an application for citizenship.
2. If the person applying for citizenship is minor and his parents are Indian
then he can get citizenship of India.
3. Any person who is a major in eyes of law and earlier was citizen of
India or his parents were citizens of India may apply for citizenship of
India. But subject to a condition that he lived in India for one year
following the date of application.
4. If a person applying for citizenship is married to a person who is having
citizenship of India and stayed in India for a period of seven years before
making the application.
5. If any person has been registered as an overseas citizen of India and that
person has stayed for one year before making the application for
citizenship.
Citizenship by Naturalisation

1. Before granting citizenship to any person, all the essential qualifications

of Schedule III of the Citizenship Act, 1955 must be satisfied. Then only
citizenship may be granted.
2. The application for getting citizenship of India has to be submitted to
the central government.
3. The person to whom citizenship is granted in India must carry a good
character, and he must be acquainted and well versed with any one
language mentioned in Schedule VIII and must have renounced citizenship
of the country where he was previously residing.
4. The person applying must have resided in India for a period of 11 years
in the preceding 14 years and one year immediately following the date of
application. This makes a total of 12 years.

WritingLaw.com
The amendment of 2019 has decreased the number of years from 11 to 5
years and one year immediately before application. This makes a total of 6
years.
5. The provisions of the Citizenship Amendment Act, 2019 do not apply to
two categories, and that is:
A. States that are covered under the sixth schedule of the Indian
Constitution and that are Assam, Meghalaya, Mizoram, and Tripura.
B. States protected under inner line permit. Currently, there are four states
in which inner line permit is operational. They are Arunachal Pradesh,
Mizoram, Nagaland, and Manipur.
Note: Inner line permit is a document issued to a person that allows an
Indian citizen not belonging to those states to travel there and stay for the
period specified in the permit.
Criticism of Citizenship Amendment Act, 2019

The people criticizing the Citizenship Amendment Act, 2019 give the
following reasons-
1. This amendment allows only six communities that is Hindu, Sikh,
Buddhist, Jain, Parsi, and Christian for citizenship in India.
2. By doing more documentation work, there shall be expenditure at the
end of the central government, and it shall affect the economic situation of
the country.
3. The amendment of 2019 affects the secular nature and structure of the
country by allowing only six communities. There is a fact that there may
be religious persecution of people of Muslim religion also in those three
countries.
4. The question also arose that why only three counties are listed for the
purpose of religious prosecution.
5. It was contended that if the secular structure of the nation is disturbed,
then it affects the basic structure of the constitution too.

WritingLaw.com
 Why Citizenship Amendment Act, 2019

1. This has enabled India to do a survey of illegal immigrants who are

residing in India without documentation.
2. On the other side, this Act has provided illegal immigrants a status of
legal migrants by doing their proper documentation on records.
3. It is an effort made towards proper resource management. With adequate
utilisation of resources, there is a long way of sustainability.
4. This provision applies only to foreigners, and it doesn't affect any of the
rights of Indian citizens.
5. This is not a violation of the constitution. As it amends the provisions of
the Citizenship Act, 1955. The Act provides to give homage to the people
belonging to six communities mentioned above who are religiously
persecuted in their countries.
6. It not violative of the right to equality. The Act still provides citizenship
to every foreigner of any religion to get citizenship by way of registration
or naturalisation. It does not prohibit any person from any religion.
And article 14 of the constitution holds the concept of reasonable
classification, and it was argued that the government has done reasonable
classification on the basis of religious persecution and not on the basis of
religion.
Is Citizenship Amendment Act, 2019 Discriminatory

The Citizenship Act, 1955, provides five ways to attain citizenship of the
country - India. The provisions with the best of their interpretation allow
every person irrespective of religion to get citizenship of India.
The amendment of 2019 only seeks to help the people who are religiously
persecuted in the three Islamic countries they are living in. It doesn't affect
the rights of Indian citizens at all.
The pros and cons are written with the best of information gained. You may
yourself decide what is good or bad in the interest of the nation.

WritingLaw.com

WritingLaw.com