Ifas Inorganic Tec
Ifas Inorganic Tec
Ifas Inorganic Tec
Chapter 8
Interaction of Metal with Carbonyl &
Nitrosyl Ligand
8.1. Metal Carbonyl Clusters
The compound in which several metal atoms are bound together directly through M-M bonds are called as cluster.
Metal carbonyl clusters are classified into two categories:
1. Low nuclearity carbonyl clusters
2. High nuclearity carbonyl clusters
Step I:
Calculate total valence electrons (TVE) on central metal in the compound (say it is x) which is equal to the number of valence
electrons of the metal plus the number of electrons from each ligand and the charge.
Substract A from n x 18 (where n is the number metal atoms in the compound), say it is M-M bonds
𝟏𝟖 × 𝐧 −𝒙
M – M bonds =
𝟐
n = number of metal atoms
x = total no of valence e- (metal + legand e-s)
Example:
a. Mn2 (Co)10 – valence electron count
2 Mn 14 electron
10 CO 20 electron
Total = 34 electron
18 × n −𝑥
M – M bonds =
2
18 × 2 −(14+20)
=
2
36−34 2
M –M bonds = = =1
2 2
e. Co4(CO)12, Ir4(CO)12
18 × 4 −(36 + 24)
M–M =
2
72 − 60
= =6
2
Solid Co4(CO)12 :- Bridged CO = 3 Solid Rh4(CO)12 :- Bridged CO = 3
f. Ir4(CO)12 :
In Ir4(CO)12 number of bridged CO ligand = zero
g. Os4(Co)14 :-
Number of M – M bonds are = 6
h. Os4(Co)15 :
In Os4(Co)15 M – M bonds = 5
i. Os4(Co)16 :-
In Os4(Co)16 M – M bonds = 4
Except Os4(Co)14, in remaining all Os – CO clusters bridging CO ligand are zero
Os4(CO)16 is analogous to cyclobutane conformation.
To Determine the Expected Charge on the Complex Ions Using 18-Electron Rule
a. [Co(CO)3]x
9+3 X 2 + x = 18
15 + x = 18
x = 18 – l5 = 3
Therefore, charge on the complex ion is = -3
b. [(OC)3 Ni-Co(CO)3]x
3 X 2 + 10 + 2 + 9 + 3 X 2 + x = 36
33 + x = 36
x = 36-33 = 3
Therefore, charge on the complex ion = -3
b. [M(µ6-C6H6) (CO)2]2 (M is the second row transition metal and two M= M bond)
2x + 4 + 2 x 6 + 4 * 2 = 36
2x = 36- 24 ; i.e. 2x = 12 or x = 6
Therefore, metal is Mo(4d55s1).
The structures of the HNCC can be, determined by skeletal or framework electron counts with the help of Wade's rule.
a. Calculate total electron count (TEC).
b. Add to TEC the valence electrons for interstitial atom, for example, 1 for H, 4 for C, 5 for N, 5 for P and so on.
c. Calculate the skeletal electron pairs(S)
Table 8.1: The valence electron counts corresponding to the various structural classifications for main group and transition
metal clusters are summarized.
−
- HCo6(Co)15 → H – atom Encapsulated
- Rh6P(Co)3−
22 → P atom Encapsulated
−
- Fe4N(Co)12 → N atom Encapsulated
- Rh6As(Co)3−
22 → As atom Encapsulated
So, ClosoOctahedran
b. Os5C(Co)15 :
TEC = 40 + 4 + 30
= 74
74 − 12 × 5
S =
2
74− 60
= =7
2
i.e n + 2 = 7
5 + 2 = 7 Nido
Number of vertices =S–1
=7–1=6
So, Nido
c. Os5(Co)16 :
TEC = 40 + 32 = 72
72 − 12 × 5
S =
2
72 − 62
S = =6
2
i.e. n + 1 = 6 →Closo
Number of vertices = S – 1
= 6 – 1 = 5 (TBP)
So, Closo TBP
d. Fe4C(𝐂𝐨)𝟐−
𝟏𝟐 :
TEC = 32 + 4 + 24 + 2= 62
62 − 12 × 4
S =
2
62 − 48
S = =7
2
i.e n + 3 = 7 (Arachno)
Number of vertices =S–1
= 7 – 1 = 6 (oh)
So, ArachnoOctahedran
e. H3Ru4(𝐂𝐨)−
𝟏𝟐 :
TEC = 3 + 32 + 24 + 1 = 60
60 − 12 × 4
S =
2
60 − 48
S = =6
2
i.e. n + 2 = 6 →Nido
Number of vertices = S – 1
= 6 – 1 = 5 (TBP)
So, Nido TBP
f. Ru5N(𝐂𝐨)−
𝟏𝟒 :-
TEC = 40 + 5 + 28 + 1 = 74
74 − 12 × 5
S =
2
74 − 60
S = =7
2
i.e. n + 2 = 7 →Nido
Number of vertices= S – 1
= 7 – 1= 6 (oh)
So, Nido oh
g. Fe4N(𝐂𝐨)−
𝟏𝟐 :-
TEC = 32 + 5 + 24 + 1 = 62
62 − 12 × 4
S =
2
62 − 48
S = =7
2
i.e. n+ 3 = 7 →Arachno
Number of vertices = S – 1
= 7 – 1 = 6 (oh)
So, Arachno oh
h. Os7(Co)21:
TEC = 56 + 42 = 98
98 − 84
S =
2
=7
i. Os8(𝐂𝐨)𝟐−
𝟐𝟐 :
TEC = 64 + 44 + 2 = 110
110 − 96
S = =7
2
j. Os10C(𝐂𝐨)𝟐−
𝟐𝟒 :
TEC = 80 + 4 + 48 + 2 = 134
134 − 120
S = =7
2
• In above 3Os clusters number of metal atoms are increasing but no change in skeletal e- pair.
• In Os7(Co)21 one of the triangular faces of polyhedran capped by Os metal
• In Os8(Co)2−
22 , two triangular faces of polyhedran capped by 2 Os metals.
• In Os10C(Co)2−
24 , four triangular faces of polyhedran capped by 4 Os metals.
• Capping atoms only increasing TEC but does not change skeletal e- pair
The ionic clusters of main group elements are called Zintl ions. Since these ions have no ligand, these are also known as nacked
clusters Zintl ions are also classified into closo, nido, arachno and hypho clusters
It is also based on the Wades rules if total electron count is equal to:
= 4n + 2 Closo
= 4n + 4 Nido
= 4n + 6 Arachno
= 4n + 8 Hypho
= 4n + 10 Klado
Where; n= number of metal atoms in the Zintl ion.
Examples:
1. P4:
Valence electron count for P4 is as follows:
P is group 5 element so it has 5 valence electrons = 5 × 4
Total valence electron count = 20 electron
i.e. 4 = 4 × 4 = 16 + 4 = 20
So, structure is 4n + 4 → Nido cluster
2. 𝐒𝐧𝟒−
𝟗 :
Sn is group 4 element so it has 4 valence electrons = 4 × 9
Charge = 4
Total valence electron count = 40 electron
i.e. 4n = 4 × 9 = 36 + 4 = 40
So structure is 4n + 4 = Nido cluster.
3. 𝐒𝐧𝟐−
𝟗 :
Sn is group 4 element so it has 4 valence electrons = 4 × 9
Charge = 2
Total valence electron count = 38 electron
i.e. 4n = 4 × 9 = 36 + 2 = 38
So, structure is 4n + 2 = Closo
Ge4−
9 → Nido
Ge2−
9 → Closo
4. 𝐁𝐢+𝟑
𝟓 :
Bi is group 5 element so it has 5 valence electrons = 5 × 5
Charge = - 3
Total valence electron count = 22 electron
i.e. 4n = 4 × 5 = 20 + 2 = 22
So, structure is 4n + 2 = Closo
5. 𝐁𝐢𝟐−
𝟒 :
Bi is group 5 element so it has 5 valence electrons = 5 × 4
Charge = 2
Total valence electron count = 20 +2=22
i.e. 4n = 4 × 4=16 = 16 + 6= 20
So, structure is 4n + 4 = Arachno
Monocapped Bicapped
Square-antiprismatic Square-antiprismatic
[Ge9]4- [Ge10]2-
[Sn9]4-
[Pb9]4-
Fig. 8.1: Schematic representations of structure types for selected Zintl ions
Rules:
1. Molecules with similar chemical properties
2. Molecule with similar FMO’s
3. Molecules with similar symmetry properties
4. Molecules with similar energies
5. Molecules with similar number of e-s
EX:
Mn(Co)5 17e- (Lack of 1 ligand forOd and 1 e for stability)
CH3 7e- (Lack of 1 ligand for Td and 1 e foe octet)
Cl 7e-
Table 8.2: Some Isolobal Fragments of Transition Metals and Main Group Elements
CH4 CH3 CH2 CH C
Cr(CO)6 Mn (CO)5 Fe (CO)4 Mn(CO)4 Fe(CO)3
[Mn(CO)6]+ [Fe(CO)5]+ [Cr (CO)5]- Cr (CO)5 Ni (CO)3 Co(CO)3 Ni(CO)2
Fe(CO)5 Co (CO)4 CpCo(CO) CpCr(CO)2 Cr(CO)4
Ni (CO)4 CpFe(CO)2 [Co (CO)4]- CpNi CpCo
CpMn(CO)3 V(CO)6 CH+3 CH+2 CH+
CH-3 CH-2 CH-S P
A transition metal clusterand a borane are isolobal if both have same number of vertices. Some examples are given below:
1. Os6(CO)18 :
TEC = 6 x 8 + 18 x 2 = 48 + 36 = 84
PEC = 84 – 6 x 12 = 84 – 72 = 12
PEC/2 = 12/2 = 6 (= n)
hyper closo
B6H6:
Number of skeletal electron pairs = (6 * 2) / 2 = 6 (= n)
(hyper closo)
Os6(CO)18↔ B6H6
𝑜
2. [Os6(CO)18]2- :
TEC = 6x 8 + 18 x 2 + 2 = 48 + 36 + 2 = 86
PEC = 86- 6 x 12 = 86 - 72 = 14
PEC/2 = 14/2 = 7 = 6 + 1 (n + 1)
closo (regular octahedron)
[B6H6 ]2- (regular octahedron)
Number of skeletal electron pairs = (6 x 2+ 2)/2 = 14/2
= 7 (n + 1)
closo
[Os6(CO)18]2-↔ [B6H6]2-
𝒐
3. [Os5(C0)15]2- :
TEC = 5 x 8 + 15 x 2 + 2 = 40 + 30 + 2 = 72
PEC = 72 - 5 x 12 = 12
PEC/2 = 12/2 = 6 (n + 1)
closo
[B5H5 ]2-
Number of skeletal electron pairs = (5 x 2 + 2)/2
= 6 (n + 1)
(closo)
[Os5(CO)15]2-↔ [B5H5]2-
𝒐
4. Fe4C(CO)13:
TEC = 4 x 8 + 4 + 13 x 2 = 32 + 4 + 26 = 62
PEC = 62 – 4 x 12 = 62 – 48 = 14
𝑃𝐸𝐶 14
= = 7 (n+4) Archno
2 2
[B4H4 ]6-:
4 𝑥 2+6 14
Number of skeletal electron pairs = =
2 2
= 7 (n + 4) arachno
Fe4C(CO)13↔ [B4H4]6-
𝒐
5. Fe5C(CO)15:
TEC = 5 x 8 + 4 + 15 x 2 = 40 + 4 + 30 = 74
PEC = 74 – 5 x 12 = 14
𝑃𝐸𝐶 14
= = 7(n + 2) nido
2 2
[Fe5(CO)15]4-:
TEC = 5 x 8 + 15 x 2 + 4 = 40 + 30 + 4 = 74
PEC = 74 – 5 x 12 = 14
𝑃𝐸𝐶 14
= = 7(n + 2) nido
2 2
[B5H5]4-:
5 𝑥 2+4 14
Number of skeletal electron pairs = =
2 2
= 7 (n + 2) nido
Fe5C(CO)15↔ [Fe5(CO)15]4-↔ [B5H5]4-
𝒐 𝒐
6. [HCo6(CO)15]-:
TEC = 1 + 6 x 9 + 15 x 2 + 1 = 1 + 54 + 30 + 1 = 86
PEC = 86 – 6 x 12 = 14
𝑃𝐸𝐶 14
= = 7 (n+1) closo
2 2
[Co6(CO)15]2-:
TEC = 6 x 9 + 15 x 2 + 2 = 54 + 30 + 2 = 86
PEC = 86 – 6 x 12 = 14
𝑃𝐸𝐶 14
= = 7 (n+1) closo
2 2
[Fe6(CO)18]2-:
TEC = 6 x 8 + 18 x 2 + 2 = 48 + 36 + 2 = 86
PEC = 86 – 6 x 12 = 14
𝑃𝐸𝐶 14
= =7 (n+1) closo
2 2
[B6H6 ]2-:
6 𝑥 2+2 14
Number of skeletal electron pairs = =
2 2
= 7 (n+1) closo
7. [CpNi]6 :
TEC = 6 x 5 + 6 x 10 = 30 + 60 = 90
PEC = 90 – 6 x 12 = 90 – 72 = 18
𝑃𝐸𝐶 18
= = 9(n + 3) Arachno
2 2
[B6H6]6-:
6 𝑥 2+6 18
Number of electron pairs = =
2 2
= 9(n + 3) arachno
[CpNi]6↔ [B6H6]6-
𝒐
Classify the heteroboranes compounds into Closo, Nido, Arachno, and Hypo
1. NCB10H11
N=BH2
C=BH
(BH2) (BH) B10H11
B12H14Closo
Bn Hn + 2 →Closo
Bn Hn + 4 →Nido
Bn Hn + 6 →Arachno
Bn Hn + 8 →Hypo
Bn Hn + 10 →Klado
2. PCB9H12 :-
(BH2) (BH) B9H12
B11H15 Nido
3. GeC2B9H11 :-
(BH) (BH)2 B9H11
B12H14Closo
4. SB9H11 :-
(BH3) B9H11
B10H14Nido
5. SB9H13 :-
(BH3) B9H13
B10H16Arachno
6. CB10H14 :-
(BH) B10H14
B11H15Nido
7. SiC2B2H10 :-
(BH) (BH)2 B4 H10
B7H13Arachno
8. B4H6(CoCp)2 :-
B4H6(BH)2
B6H8Closo
9. C2B7H11CoCp :-
(BH)2 B7H11 (BH)
B10H14 Nido
10. C2B9H11Ru(Co)3 :-
(BH)2 B9H11 (BH)
B12H14Closo
11. C2B4M6[Ni (pph3)2] :-
(BH)2 B9H6 (BH)
B7H9 Closo
12. B5H10(FeCp) :
B5H10B
B6H10Nido
group
B2H6 = [2 0 0 2]
B4H10 = [4 0 1 2]
B5H9 = [4 1 2 0]
B5H11 = [3 2 0 3]
B6H10 = [4 2 2 0]
B10H14 = [4 6 2 0]
Table 8.4 Electrons available for framework bonding for various organometallic fragmentsFramework electrons
Fragment Cr, Mo, W Mn, Tc, Re Fe, Ru, Os Co, Rh, Ir Ni, Pd, pt
M (η5 -C5H5) -1 0 1 2 3
M (CO)2 -2 -1 0 1 2
M (CO)3 0 1 2 3 4
M (CO)4 2 3 4 5 6
• Possibilities include (in addition to [Fe (η5 -C5H5)]-Fe(CO)3, Co(η5-C5H5), Ni(CO)2, Al-R, or Sn (the transition metal
fragments are 14-electron species.
• Our electrons short of 18, and the non-transition metal units are four electrons short of an octet). Similarly, one could
imagine a CH unit of a carborane being replaced by a species which can provide three orbitals and three electrons.
• Fitting this description are Co(CO)3, Ni(η5-C5H5), and P.
• The table consist of organometallic fragments and the number of electrons each can provide to a framework structure.
• You can construct your own table by remembering that each transition metal has twelve electrons associated with it
that are reserved for non-framework bonding.
• Electrons in excess of twelve can be contributed to the framework (thus the 14-electron species above contribute two
electrons each, and the 15-electron species contribute three electrons, etc.).
• If there are fewer than twelve electrons in the fragment, the framework. must make up the difference [e.g., Mn (CO)2,
and an 11-electron species, is assigned a framework contribution of -1].
• One of our goals here is to be able to predict the structure of a cage or cluster from its molecular formula.
• We do this by first finding the number of framework electrons.
• The structure will then be predicted to be closo, nido, or arachno if the number of framework electrons is 2n + 2, 2n +
4, or 2n + 6 respectively,
As an example let us consider B3H7[Fe(CO)3]2, for which n equals five
B3H7[Fe(CO)3]2
The three BH units and the two Fe(CO)3 units contribute two electrons each and the four extra hydrogen atoms contribute one
electron each to give a total of 14 framework electrons:
2Fe(CO)3: 2 x 2 = 4e-
3BH: 3 x 2 = 6e-
4H: 4 x 1 = 4e-
Total = 14e-
Since n = 5, we see that there are 2n + 4 framework electrons and we predict a nido structure which is found experimentally.
The square pyramidal structure can be thought of as resulting from substitution of two BH units with two Fe(CO)3 units in B5H9.
Let us apply these procedures to the nonborane molecule, Rh6(CO)16, for which n equals six. Each of the six Rh(CO) 2 units
contribute one electron to the framework; while the four extra CO molecules provide eight electrons:
6Rh(CO)2: 6 x 1 = 6e-
4CO: 4 x 2 = 8e-
Total = 14 e-
Thus we have 14 framework electrons with the complex fitting the 2n + 2 categories and predicted to have a closo structure.
There are two terminal CO groups per Rhodium and four bridging carbonyl groups which are placed on alternate triangular faces.
Another method for obtaining the number of framework electrons starts by counting the valence electrons of all of the metal
atoms and then adds of the electrons donated by the ligands:
6Rh: 6 x 9 = 54e-
16CO: 16 x 2 = 32e-
Total = 86e-
Twelve of these electrons per Rhodium (a total of 72) will be used for nonframework bonding leaving 14 for framework bonding.
Thus there are seven bonding pairs in the framework corresponding to 2n + 2 electrons and, as above a closo structure is
predicted.It is worth noting that the 18-electron rule fails for Rh6(CO)16, while Wade's rules are entirely successful.There are
exceptions to Wade's rules, even among modest-sized clusters. In some cases large transition metals cause geometrical
distortion.
Within this table we see three strcutures (tetrahedron, butterfly, and square plane) for tetranuclear metal clusters. The
tetrahedron is a 60-electron cluster, while the butterfly and square plane clusters have 62 and 64 electrons, respectively. When
we go from a tetrahedron to a butterfly, one of the edges of the tetrahedron is lengthened corresponding to bond breaking.
Table 8.5: Relationship between geometry, molecular orbitals, and cluster valence electrons
Geometry No. Of metal atoms Bonding molecular orbitals Cluster electrons Examples
Monomer 1 9 18 Ni(CO)4
Dimer 2 17 34 Fe2(CO)9
Trimer 3 24 48 Os3(CO)12
Tetrahedron 4 30 60 Rh4(CO)12
Butterfly 4 31 62 2−
Re4(CO)16
Square plane 4 32 64 Pt4(O2CMe)8
Trigonal bipyramid 5 36 72 Os5(CO)16
Square pyramid 5 37 74 Fe5(CO)15C
Bicapped tetrahedron 6 42 84 Os6(CO)18
Octahedron 6 43 86 Ru6(CO)17C
Capped square pyramid 6 43 86 Os6(CO)18H2
Trigonal prism 6 45 90 Rh6(CO)15C3-
Capped octahedron 7 49 98 3−
Rh7(CO)16
6 B4H6(CoCp)2 C2B3H5Fe(CO)3
Pentagonal Bipyramid
Dodecahedron
8 C2B4H4[(CH3)2Sn]CoCp
9 C2B6H8Pt(PMe3)2 C2B5H7(CoCp)2
10 [B9H9NiCp]- CB7H8(CoCp)NiCp)
Octahedron
11 [CB9H10CoCp]- C2B8H10IrH(PPh3)2
Icosahedron
12 C2B7H9(CoCp)3 C2B9H11Ru(Co)3
To do this, two additional electrons must be added to the tetrahedron to keep all electrons paired.
As you become more familiar with transition metal clusters (no nonmetals in the framework) you will come to associate closo
structures with numbers of electrons.A trimer will have 48 electrons, a tetrahedron will have 60 electrons, a trigonal bipyramid
will have 72 electrons, and an octahedron will have 86. Some care is required, however, as can be illustrated with Os 3H2(CO)10.
An electron count gives us 46 electrons rather than 48. If, however, we allow for one Os - Os double bond, the electron count is
as expected. In accord with this expectation, one osmium-osmium bond is found to be shorter than the other two and the
complex shows the reactivity expected for an unsaturated complex.Some of the beautiful relationships that exist between closo,
nido, and arachno osmium complexes are shown in Figure.
Fig 8.3: Structures of Osmium complexes which have seven pairs of skeletal electrons.
Each capped triangular face adds twelve electrons to the total electron count, but the number of skeletal pairs remains seven.
Likewise removing Os(CO)3 deletes twelve electrons without changing the number of skeletal pairs. The diagonal lines show
alternate geometries with the same total number of electrons.
QUESTIONS:
1. The compound which obeys 18-electron rule is:
(a) Mn(CO) (b) Fe(CO)4
(c) V(CO)6 (d) Cr(CO)6
Solution: [Cr(CO)6]
TVE=6 + 6 x 2 = 6 + 12 = 18
Answer: (d)
(iii) [Mn(CO)n]-
7 + 2n + 1= 18, 2n= 10 = 5
(v) [Rh(CO)3]n
6+9+n=18 or n=18-15 or n=3
8. Based on isolobalanalogies , choose the groups that might replace the group in boldface in
(a) Co3 (CO)9CH→ OCH3 , N(CH3)2 , or SiCH3 ?
Solution:
• Isolobal groups have the same number, shape and valence orbitals and the same number of electrons in those
orbitals.The CH group has three sp3 hybrid orbitals that each contain a single electron.
• The SiCH3 group has three similar orbitals similarly occupied, so it is isolobal with CH and would probably replace
it in Co3(CO)9CH to form Co3(CO)9SiCH3 . In contrast, the OCH3 and N(CH3)2 groups are not isolobal with CH .
Instead, they have, respectively, three sp3 orbitals that each contain a pair of electrons and two sp3 orbital that
each contain a pair of electrons.
Solution:
• The Mn(CO)5 group has a single 𝜎 - type orbital that contains a single electron . An iodine atom is isolobal with it,
since it also has a singly occupied 𝜎 orbital. Therefore, you can expect the compound MnI(CO) 5 to be reasonably
stable . In contrast, the CH2 and CCH3 are not isolobal with Mn(CO)5.The CH2 group has either a doubly occupied 𝜎
orbital and an empty 𝑝 orbital or singly occupied 𝜎 orbital and a singly occupied 𝑝 orbital.
• The CCH3 group has three singly occupied 𝜎 orbitals (note that it is isolobal with SiCH3.
9. Ligand substitution reactions on metal clusters are often found to occur by associative mechanism , and it is postulated that
these occur by initial breaking of an M-M bond , thereby providing an open coordination site for the incoming ligand. If the
proposed mechanism is applicable, which would you expect to undergo the fastest exchange with added 13CO , Co4(CO)12
or Ir4(CO)12? Suggest an explanation.
Solution:
• If the rate –determining step in the substitution is cleavage of one of the metal – metal bonds in the cluster.
• The cobalt complex will exhibit faster exchange .
• This is because metal – metal bond strengths increase down a group in the d-block.
• Therefore, Co-Co bonds are weaker than Ir – Ir bonds , all other things like geometry and ligand types kept the
same .