Delivering Cognitive Behaviour Therapy for

Insomnia via Virtual Platform

Erin Desmarais, MSW, RSW; Clinical Social Worker, Queen's Family Health Team
Cynthia Leung RPh, Pharmacist, Department of Family Medicine, Queen's University

July 21, 2021

Presenter Disclosures

Faculty: Erin Desmarais, MSW, RSW; Clinical Social Worker, Queen's Family Health
Team

Relationships with commercial interests: None

Potential for conflict(s) of interest: None
Presenter Disclosures

Faculty: Cynthia Leung, RPh, Pharmacist, Department of Family Medicine, Queen's University

Relationships with commercial interests: None

Potential for conflict(s) of interest: None
Learning Objectives

At the end of this session the participant will be able to:

• Understand CBT-I (Cognitive Behavioural Therapy for
Insomnia) as the first line treatment for chronic
insomnia and its key components
• Describe key processes and a general outline in setting
up a virtual group CBTi program
• Identify tools and resources to develop and
individualize your own CBT-I program
Suggested Training for CBT-I

• Judith Davidson & Queen’s University CPD On-demand

program:
https://healthsci.queensu.ca/opdes/programs/insomniaondemand

• Colleen Carney, Ryerson University:

www.drcolleencarney.com

• Sleep training program at Oxford:

https://www.ox.ac.uk/admissions/graduate/courses/msc-sleep-
medicine

• Sleep Course by Dr Ralph Lydic of University of Michigan:

• https://www.coursera.org/learn/sleep
 This presentation has been adapted with permission from
Dr Judith Davidson, Katherine Fretz, PhD Candidate and
Queen’s Continuous Professional Development Office based on
material from the Insomnia Online Intervention Series
(April – May 2021)
 Delivering Cognitive Behaviour Therapy for Insomnia via Virtual Platform
Cynthia Leung, Erin Desmarais, Jennifer MacDaid, Diane Cross

Objectives Program Set Up & Administration Results & Discussion

Covid-19 pandemic can cause insomnia for many Insomnia Severity Index Scoring
individuals as well as exacerbate insomnia in those
who already have it. We hope to share our experience 0-7 No clinically significant insomnia
in transforming our face-to-face CBTi-based sleep
8-14 Subthreshold insomnia
program to a virtual CBTi program.
15-21 Clinical Insomnia (moderate severe)
Patient Recruitment & Assessment
22-28 Clinical Insomnia (severe)
Patient Eligibility:
• A physician referral The program was delivered via Zoom.
• A valid email address & internet connection • Share screen feature was used to present program
• A device with webcam, microphone & speaker material, useful websites and smartphone apps.
• A printer (optional for printing program material) • Breakout room features were used to allow smaller
Recruitment & Assessment: group discussion with individual facilitators.
• Patient recruitment was initiated via telephone. • Chat feature was used to facilitate Q&A and encourage
Interested candidates were invited to complete an interactions with participants.
online survey (via email) which include the following • Poll feature was not used, could be explored to
components: encourage interactions or assessment of knowledge
• Program Material & Consent base. Pearls to share:
• Davidson Sleep Questionnaire • We completed ~ 12 patient assessments and enrolled 6 patients. Reasons for
• Insomnia Severity Index non-enrollment include lack of interest, timing, contraindications.
Patient Satisfaction & Improvement in Sleep • Of the 6 enrolled patients, 1 patient dropped out.
• Epsworth Sleepiness Scale
• HADS & PhQ9 20% Moderate improvement On Line. Warm & • Patients who are prescribed sleep medications may be more reluctant to
• A follow up phone call was conducted to discuss 60% Much improved friendly. Super well participate in the sleep program
result and confirm enrollment. Also explored (if 20% No trouble at all organized. • Our first virtual sleep program suggests this platform is effective in delivering
relevant) if the patient was receptive to medication cognitive behaviour therapy for insomnia with high patient satisfaction.
deprescribing and discussed program goals. Patients Although, I had never used Zoom for learning However, we are limited to recruiting less complex cases.
were also asked to complete weekly sleep diaries. purposes, I found the mode of communication more • Further validation is needed with more experience with larger group.
than adequate and very handy

I am completely satisfied with the whole program Suggestions for future:

….My sleep habits have improved tremendously! • Develop a secured portal for sharing material
• Set up a program specific email for streamlined communications
 Insomnia
• a complaint of difficulty initiating or maintaining sleep
• causes clinically significant distress or impairment in
functioning
• often associated with fatigue
American Psychiatric Association
American Academy of Sleep Medicine Chronically for ≥ 3 months
 What is CBT-I?

• A set of techniques that have been shown through research to

improve sleep for the long term.

• Involves uncovering the biological processes that control sleep

and wakefulness.

• Recommended first-line treatment for chronic insomnia

• For adults, including elderly and patients with comorbidities

Four Components Of CBT-I

Sleep Restriction Stimulus Control

Therapy Therapy

CBT-I

Cognitive Relaxation
Restructuring Techniques

Judith R. Davidson, Ph.D., C.Psych.

Stimulus Control Therapy

• Learned associations

• People with insomnia spend a

lot of time in bed while
awake.

• Involves breaking the

connection between being in
bed and wakefulness and
strengthening the
relationship between the bed
and sleep
Sleep Restriction

• Considered one of the most

effective components of CBT-I

• Works to build your sleep drive.

• Involves spending less time in

bed

• Use sleep diaries to calculate the

amount of time spent in bed vs.
the amount of time sleeping.
Restrict time in bed to amount of
time sleeping
Cognitive Restructuring

1) Identify the thoughts that are keeping you up

• “I will never be able to fall asleep”

2) Challenge unhelpful sleep thoughts

• Is it really true? Is there another way of looking at it?
Am I falling into a thought trap?

3) Find a more balanced sleep thought

• “I will sleep again. I will focus on one
night at a time. I will use the tools I am
learning to help restore my sleep”
Relaxation Techniques

• Goal is to achieve the relaxation response, which is the opposite

of the “fight or flight” response

• Deep Breathing- Set aside time 2 times daily for 1-2 minutes to
practice

• Use of guided meditation

• Mental Vacation
• Body scan
• Progressive muscle relaxation
Stepped Care for
Insomnia Behavioural Sleep Experts
Providers with expertise in behavioural sleep
medicine, insomnia clinics

Trained CBT-I Providers

Family Health Team group programs, community providers

Primary Care and Community Pharmacy

Education, brief appointments to introduce and support CBT-I core strategies and
sedative-hypnotic deprescribing and avoidance

Self-care
Self-guided books, apps, and online resources and services
Benefits of Group Programs

• Access to social support

• Increased motivation
• Increased capacity & access
Our Program Overview

• 6-week program run, 1.5 hours in duration

• 3 programs per year, with one offered in the evening

• Maximum 10 patients with 2 facilitators.

• Offer Sleep Therapy Drop-In Sessions to support

maintenance plans
 How to set up a CBT-I Group Program

Face-to-Face Sleep Program Virtual Sleep Program

Planning Stage Set up assessment dates Set up assessment dates (optional)
Set up program dates Set up program dates
Develop Program Poster for promotion Develop program poster for promotion
Advertise Advertise
Book Board Room Book Zoom Account?
Set up sleep program email
Patient Recruitment Review Waiting list to recruit patients Review waiting list to recruit patients
Admin support to mail out information Email information package & assessment link
package

Patient Assessment Book appointment for 45 minutes Review assessment forms completed online
Patient to be allotted 20 minutes to Schedule phone appointment to discuss
complete assessment forms assessment results
If deemed appropriate, will enroll patient If deemed appropriate, will enroll patient into
into program program.
 How to set up a CBT-I Group Program

Face-to-face Sleep Program Virtual Sleep Program

Program Set Up  Physical set up  Set up Zoom appointment
 Book Room and arrange for tables and  Email participants
chairs  Zoom support on-demand, phone number
 Projector/Laptop of participants if need trouble shooting
 Print program materials, pens, markers,  Program materials in PowerPoint / PDF documents
extra forms, calculators

Program Administration Overall: Overall:

 Email program material (week by week or
 Print program material (week by week or
all together?)
all together)
 Know how to share screen
 Print name tags
 Use whiteboard
 Set up projectors if necessary
 Mute participants
 Use of chat room / break out room as needed
Program
ProgramPoster
Poster
- Virtual
 Referral Pathway to the CBT-I Group Program
Request more Patient is taking
Patient wanting Patient had a recent Poor sleep is affecting
Zopiclone or other Zopiclone for years
something for fall and fracture, taking mood, quality of life
sedatives- & continues to have
sleep lorazepam and ability to function.
hypnotics insomnia

Prescriber / MD encounter with patient with “poor sleep” Encourage Sleep

Hygiene
Referral to the CBT-I Group
Program
Review Referral Form & Add to
Waiting List

Recruit patient and provide

additional info about CBT-I

Individual Sleep Assessment

Participate in 6-week CBT-I

Program
How to refer?

E-Form: QFHT Sleep Therapy Referral

 Confirms this patient
has chronic insomnia

Assess patient’s readiness

for change

Ensure the patient does

not have any
contraindications

Please specify plan for

Gradual Dose Reduction

E-Form in our EMR to refer patients to the Sleep Program

Information Package - Virtual
Information Package – Attachments
An Example of the Sleep Diary
Assessment

The purpose of the assessment is to rule out any other sleep

disorders, to answer questions and to reduce attrition rate.
• Davidson Sleep Questionnaire
• Epworth Sleepiness Scale
• Insomnia Severity Index
• HADS
• PHQ-9
• Stop-Bang Questionnaire
Online Assessment
Program Outline Assessment To meet with Erin and Cynthia

Program Outline
*The description is a general Session 1 Introduction to Sleep
guide. Each program may vary
according to the patients’ Session 2 Reconnecting your Bed with Sleep
needs.

Session 3 Consolidating your Sleep

Session 4 Relaxing Your Mind and Body
Session 5 Putting it All Together
Session 6 Maintaining Your Progress
General Structure of
Sessions
1) Deep breather
2) Large group check-in
3) Small group with an
assigned facilitator
4) Introduction of new strategy
5) Review homework
6) Medication discussion with
pharmacist, if relevant

** exception are sessions 1 & 6

Week #1:Introduction to Sleep
Facilitator Tips
• Provide psychoeducation and rationale for
program
• Group introduction and setting the stage
• Ensure group participants understand how
to complete their sleep diary.
• Discuss the safety concerns with sedatives-
hypnotics
• Introducing the deep breathing exercise
• Review of sleep tips
Example of Outline for Week #1:Introduction to Sleep
 Week #2:Reconnecting Your Bed With Sleep
Facilitator Tips

• Begin sleep restriction & review

rationale
• In breakout rooms, calculate sleep
efficiency using sleep diary & set new
bedtime & rise time*
Provide the following warning:
• Introduce stimulus control therapy and
“Six Solid Steps to Sleep” If you find that you are very sleepy during
this program (especially likely in the first
• Follow up with participants a few days few days), be sure to avoid driving and
other potentially dangerous activities
that require vigilance during this time
Six Steps to
Solid Sleep
Example of Outline for Week #2: Reconnecting Your Bed With Sleep
 Week #3: Consolidating Your Sleep
Facilitator Tips

• Emotional Support & Reassurance

• Most challenging week.
Participants are tired, may not
have responded to sleep
restriction.
• Focus on cognitive strategies
• Offer to follow up with patient if
needed
Example of Outline for Week #3: Consolidating Your Sleep

Relaxing Breathing
Adapted from Cognitive Behaviour Therapy Skills training workbook
(https://www.hpft.nhs.uk/media/1655/wellbeing-team-cbt-workshop-booklet-2016.pdf)
Week #4: Relaxing your Mind and Body
Facilitator Tips
• Encourage patients to
continue to follow sleep
schedule and brainstorm
any challenges they are
encountering.
• Sleep improvement should
be noted by this time.
• “Clear Your Head Time”
introduced as a means of
managing worries.
Clear your head time

Instructions

1. Schedule 30 minutes in the early evening as “Clear-Your Head

Time”.
2. Take some paper and a pen or pencil with you to a quiet place
(away from your bed and bedroom).
3. Sit and relax, take a deep breath, and let your thoughts and worries
come to mind. Keep breathing.
4. Write each issue down on paper (no matter how big or small).
5. Do this for about 10-15 minutes, or until you can’t come up with any
more issues.
6. Consider each item and write down a solution, even if it is a
temporary solution. For example, if your issue is that you have too
much to do tomorrow, write down a realistic plan.
7. Put the paper away. You have done your work of thinking about
these issues for the night.
Example of Outline for Week #4: Relaxing your Mind and Body
 Week #5: Putting it all Together
Facilitator Tips

• Continue to explore relaxation strategies

• Although sleep has improved, patients
may have anxious thoughts about sleep
deteriorating again.
• Sleep Jeopardy quiz to de-bunk sleep
myths
• Remind patient to complete final
assessment (Insomnia Severity Index,
HADS, PHQ-9) before the next session
Example of Outline for Week #5: Putting it all Together
Week #6: Maintaining Your Progress
Facilitator Tips

• Celebrate that everyone is

sleeping better.
• Maintenance Planning &
Individual Support Session
• Program evaluation
• Invite patients to attend
future drop-in sessions
Example of Outline for Week #6: Maintaining Your Progress
Sample of Post Group Sleep Note

Post Group Sleep Note

• Important to update the
physician once the program
is complete
• Outcomes:
• Sleep improvement
(before and after
Insomnia Severity Index)
• Gradual Dose Reduction
• Drop Out
Patient Feedback and Satisfaction

Also include the following questions:

• How would you rate the quality of the treatment
you received?
• If a friend had a problem like yours would you
recommend this treatment program to her or
him?
• Did you feel that the group leaders gave you
enough personal attention?
• Did you feel that the leaders were warm and
accepting of your problem?
• Did the leaders seem competent to treat your
problem?
• Do you feel that you still have trouble getting a
good sleep?
• What do you like best and least about the
program?
• Other Comments
CBT-I & Gradual Dose Reduction of Sedative-Hypnotics

Sleep Assessment EAGER: Patients begin gradual dose reduction before or

shortly after sleep assessment. Sometimes, patients are
able to stop taking the sedatives-hypnotics before
starting CBT-I.

RESERVED: Patients begin gradual dose reduction at

CBT-I 6-week Program week 2 of the CBT-I program (when sleep restriction
begins). As the sleep improves, they are able to
continue with gradual dose reduction over the course of
the program.

Post Program Follow up in RESISTANT: Patients begin gradual dose reduction of

sedatives-hypnotics at week 2 of the CBT-I sleep
2-4-8 weeks program. By the end of the program, they continue to be
on a lower dose of sedatives-hypnotics.
• Able to continue with gradual dose reduction post
program follow up at 4-8 weeks OR
• Continue to be at low dose sedatives-hypnotics.

Be Flexible and Individualize the Gradual Dose

Reduction Plan to Your Patient’s Needs.
Lessons Learned……

• CBT-I is effective for insomnia.

• Both in-person and virtual formats are effective.
Patients may have specific preferences.
• Group programs are great to engage patients and
motivate them to be accountable for behavioural
changes
• Group programs require routine administrative
support and sufficient resources must be built into
program development
Outcome Measures

Average Insomnia Severity Index

Before & After CBT-I Virtual Group Program
20

18

16

14

12

10

0
Summer 2020 Fall 2020 Winter 2021 Spring 2021
Before ISI (after)
How to improve accessibility of Virtual Programs?

• Make transcripts available

• Allow captions for video
• Adapt material for Screen Reader
• Still make program material available in other formats
(e.g. word document available)
• Interactions should be accessible friendly
• Offer on-demand programs, evening programs, in-
person programs
Other Resources
Resources for Patients
Can you (or your practice setting) provide CBT-I?
Stepped Care for
Insomnia Behavioural Sleep Experts
Providers with expertise in behavioural sleep
medicine, insomnia clinics

Trained CBT-I Providers

Family Health Team group programs, community providers

Primary Care and Community Pharmacy

Education, brief appointments to introduce and support CBT-I core strategies and
sedative-hypnotic deprescribing and avoidance

Self-care
Self-guided books, apps, and online resources and services
QUESTIONS?