TRADA CLT Guide - Chapter 1
TRADA CLT Guide - Chapter 1
TRADA CLT Guide - Chapter 1
TRADA Technology
publication is licensed to
SHEFFIELDUN
on
28/03/2018
This is an uncontrolled copy. Ensure use of the most current version of this document
by searching the Construction Information Service at http://uk.ihs.com
Licensed copy: SHEFFIELDUN, SHEFFIELD UNIVERSITY, 28/03/2018, Uncontrolled Copy, © TRADA Technology
Chapter 1
ISBN 978-1-909594-63-0
Design and performance
Cross-laminated timber
Licensed copy: SHEFFIELDUN, SHEFFIELD UNIVERSITY, 28/03/2018, Uncontrolled Copy, © TRADA Technology
ISBN 978-1-909594-63-0
Published in 2017 by Exova BM TRADA
Exova BM TRADA
Chiltern House
Stocking Lane
Hughenden Valley
High Wycombe
Buckinghamshire HP14 4ND
tel: +44 (0)1494 569600
fax: +44 (0)1494 565487
email: [email protected]
website: www.exova.com
Licensed copy: SHEFFIELDUN, SHEFFIELD UNIVERSITY, 28/03/2018, Uncontrolled Copy, © TRADA Technology
Contents Introduction 7
Chapter 1 CLT and its uses 8
1.1 What is cross-laminated timber? 8
1.2 How is cross-laminated timber made? 10
1.3 How sustainable is cross-laminated timber? 13
1.4 What are cross-laminated timber’s key structural properties? 17
1.5 What are cross-laminated timber’s other key properties? 19
1.6 What does cross-laminated timber look like? 21
1.7 What can cross-laminated timber be used for? 23
1.8 How does cross-laminated timber compare to the alternatives? 26
Chapter 2 Design principles 31
2.1 Key facts 31
2.1.1 Speed of construction 31
2.1.2 A renewable resource 31
2.1.3 Less weight 31
2.1.4 Versatility 33
2.1.5 Structural uses 33
2.1.6 Thermal performance 33
2.1.7 Sound transmission 34
2.1.8 Vapour control 34
2.1.9 Airtightness 34
2.1.10 Appearance 34
2.1.11 Fire resistance 34
2.1.12 Moisture, durability and movement 34
2.1.13 Integrating building services 35
2.2 Example buildings and forms 35
2.2.1 Cellular loadbearing CLT 36
2.2.2 Glulam frames and CLT panels 39
2.2.3 Low-rise CLT structures 42
2.2.4 Crosswall 44
2.2.5 Hybrid 46
Chapter 3 Performance 48
3.1 Structural design 48
3.1.1 Structural forms and stability 48
3.1.1.1 Structural forms 48
3.1.1.2 Stability 48
3.1.1.3 Disproportionate collapse 51
3.1.2 Structural elements 51
3.1.2.1 Commonly used methods of analysis 51
3.1.2.2 Crushing 53
3.1.3 Wall panels 54
3.1.3.1 Pre-scheme design of walls 56
3.1.4 Floor panels 56
3.1.4.1 Pre-scheme design of floors 59
3.1.4.2 Vibration 60
3.1.5 Roof panels 60
3.1.5.1 Pre-scheme design of roofs 62
3.1.6 Hybrid and composite construction 62
3.1.7 Connections 66
3.1.7.1 Connection types 66
3.1.7.2 Screws 66
3.1.7.3 Nails 68
3.1.7.4 Analysis of fasteners 69
3.2 Fire 69
4 | Contents
Licensed copy: SHEFFIELDUN, SHEFFIELD UNIVERSITY, 28/03/2018, Uncontrolled Copy, © TRADA Technology
Contents | 5
Licensed copy: SHEFFIELDUN, SHEFFIELD UNIVERSITY, 28/03/2018, Uncontrolled Copy, © TRADA Technology
William Perkin
CofE High School
(see also Case study 13)
Photograph
Dominic Cole
Licensed copy: SHEFFIELDUN, SHEFFIELD UNIVERSITY, 28/03/2018, Uncontrolled Copy, © TRADA Technology
Introduction
Introduction | 7
Licensed copy: SHEFFIELDUN, SHEFFIELD UNIVERSITY, 28/03/2018, Uncontrolled Copy, © TRADA Technology
CHAPTER 1
CLT and its uses
Humankind has been building with wood since the beginning of civiliza-
tion, leading in some cases to the development of extremely sophisticated
cultures of timber construction. In Britain we have a very particular affinity
with the material. In his 1955 Reith lectures titled ‘The Englishness of
English Art’, Nikolaus Pevsner suggested this was perhaps born out of the
importance of boat building to an island nation, ‘…English
poetry has shown awareness of the sea around the island,
and that hearts of oak are not only the ships, but also the
mighty and ingenious roofs of the churches of England.’
Figure 1.3
Exploded view of CLT
assembly
Next the panel faces are planed or sanded. The full-length panels are then
cut down to the specified lengths, window openings are cut and the edges
machined to the profile required.
A CLT panel has a primary and secondary span direction as shown in Figure
1.4. It ranges in thicknesses from approximately 60mm to 300mm, in lamella
of typically three, five or seven sheets. Due to the cross-laminations there
is a primary span direction (the grain direction of the outer laminar) and a
secondary direction perpendicular to the primary span. The primary span
is stiffer and stronger than the secondary direction due to more material in
the stronger, parallel-to-grain direction, and an increased distance from the
neutral axis. This two-way spanning nature means it can create a flexible
structure with floor voids or service penetrations through walls.
Figure 1.4
Primary and
secondary span
directions
Figure 1.5
Typical size of Typically 16m
CLT panel
up to 2.95m
Figure 1.6
Punched openings and
openings with lintels
There are instances where penetrations will be required, such as for services
distribution. Due to the secondary spanning nature of CLT it is possible to
cut holes in the panels, but this must be pre-planned and done in the factory.
The introduction of an opening in a CLT wall panel alters the stress distribu-
tion in a panel and methods of analysis should take this into account. High-
level service penetrations can be achieved with either a punched opening
Figure 1.7
Penetrations for
openings near top of
wall
Figure 1.8
KLH Factory, Austria and utilisation of the floor panel span, or a lintel arrangement where longer
spans are required (see Figure 1.7).
Panels, some of which
include cut-outs for
windows and doors, await
For typical wall, floor and roof sizes, TRADA’s Structural timber elements
transportation within the offers pre-scheme design guidance.
controlled environment
of an industrially scaled The main producers of both cross-laminated timber and glulam are currently
factory environment
located in Central Europe and Scandinavia. Transport by articulated lorry
Photograph brings the completed pre-fabricated panels from these locations to the UK
Andrew Waugh for fast site assembly.
may be dismantled and re-used, in which case the carbon remains stored. Kay Hartmann,
Alternatively, the panels can be used as fuel for biomass, and while the Technical Director,
carbon re-enters the environment when the wood combusts, this is within KLH UK
an efficient process that generates energy in turn, reducing the use of fossil
fuels.
Figure 1.9
Timber awaiting milling
in central Europe
Photograph
Liam Dewar
continue to recommend
it to our clients as a low
environmental impact
product. We find it a
Timber with
particularly effective sequestration –2130
material because it
provides solutions to Tonnes CO2
several issues without
having to add layers of
additional materials.
”
Carol Costello, Architect,
Cullinan Studio carbon-producing alternatives provides a compelling strategy for reducing
the construction industry’s significant environmental impact.
Figure 1.11
Manor Longbridge Architect
Primary School Greenhill Jenner Architects
Project engineer
Following delivery to site, MLM Engineers (London)
the frame can be quickly
and simply erected. The Client
material was chosen for this Dagenham and Barking
new school in East London Council
in large part due to the tight Timber structure
build programme that cross- B&K Structures/Binderholz
laminated timber construction
was well suited to meeting Photograph
B&K Structures
Figure 1.12
Lancaster Institute for the Architect
Contemporary Arts Sheppard Robson
Project engineer
New classrooms and offices Sinclair Knight Merz
provide spaces for Art, Design,
Music and Theatre Studies Client
for the Lancaster Institute for Lancaster University
the Contemporary Arts. Three Timber structure
larger arts spaces provide a Eurban/Schilliger Holz
gallery, theatre and concert
hall. The carbon stored within Timber superstructure
the frame assisted the building engineer
in becoming the first higher Eurban
education project in the UK Photograph
to achieve the new BREEAM Hufton & Crow
rating of ‘Outstanding’
Cross-laminated timber panels are typically used to form wall, floor and roof Figure 1.13
elements within buildings, but can also be used to construct service cores 52 Whitmore Road,
and stairs. The method of cross-laminating during production means the London
panels do not have a single direction of structural span, performing instead
in a multi-directional manner, and therefore providing a great degree of flex- This mixed-use canal-side
development in London
ibility in how they can be used. The outermost direction of timber therefore included a 5m high space
does not necessarily correlate with the direction of structural span, although at 2nd floor accommodating
performance is enhanced if it does. a photographer’s studio.
The cross-laminated timber
spans 9m and includes 23m
As a solid, planar material the panels differ from framed structural systems of open, column-free space,
of columns and beams, where non-structural materials are used to infill achieved by the walls acting
between linear acting elements. Instead the panels combine structural as deep beams and the
and enclosing properties, providing a loadbearing capacity spread over its party walls in the apartments
above acting as trusses
entire width. The large bearing area also allows a great degree of freedom
in the positioning of openings for doors, windows and services penetrations. Architect
The lightness of the construction, in comparison with steel, concrete and Waugh Thistleton Architects
masonry structures, reduces foundation requirements. Project engineer
Akera Engineers
Connections between panels are made with brackets or with long, self- Client
drilling woodscrews. Cross-laminated timber elements also provide an Private
excellent substrate for follow-on trades to fix into. Speed and flexibility are Timber structure
particularly apparent in the ease with which additional construction layers KLH UK
can be added, without the time or co-ordination associated with fixing wall Photograph
plugs into masonry or identifying timber stud locations for fixings. Alastair Ogle
Figure 1.14
The Open Academy, Architect
Norwich Sheppard Robson Architects
Project engineer
Following its completion in WSP (substructure)
2010, the Open Academy
was the UK’s largest solid Timber superstructure
timber panel building. The engineer
building combines cross- Ramboll UK Ltd
laminated timber with glulam Client
downstand beams to provide Norfolk County Council
large spans and more
efficiently transfer loads Timber structure
KLH UK
Photograph
Kier Eastern
Figure 1.15
Architecture Archive
Architect
Hugh Strange Architects
Project engineer
Price & Myers
Client
Private
Timber structure
Eurban/Stora Enso
Timber superstructure
engineer
Eurban
Photograph
David Grandorge
Figure 1.16
Stadthaus, 24 Murray
Grove, London
Following completion in
2009, this residential tower,
constructed with eight
floors of cross-laminated
timber structure, became
the tallest habitable timber
building in the world.
Plasterboard linings
complement the timber’s
inherent properties to
provide the required fire
and acoustic performance
Architect
Waugh Thistleton Architects
Project engineer
Techniker
Client
Telford Homes PLC /
Metropolitan Housing Trust As a large-format, panelised material, machined to high tolerances,
Timber structure cross-laminated timber has the potential to provide a building with excellent
KLH UK airtightness, thus improving the thermal performance of the structure and
Photograph reducing energy usage. Joints between panels are either detailed to incorpo-
Anthony Thistleton rate flexible seals or taped on the outside face to achieve airtightness.
The Standard Grade or non-visible Grade panels have a rough surface finish
that may display some discolouration, and the outer layers can have knot
holes and open joints. This grade is generally lined and used in concealed
locations within the finished building.
Domestic Grade offers a good quality surface finish suitable for exposed
situations. Open joints, cracks and knot holes might all be present in this
grade, but they are generally small and occasional, and do not affect the
overall appearance.
Industrial Grade panels offer an intermediate finish that can be used inter-
nally as an exposed surface, although larger open joints up to 4mm are to
be expected. The panels will nevertheless have a planed and sanded finish.
The panels are generally used to form an inner layer of a composite construc-
tion insulated and clad externally. As well as combining structure and Figure 1.17
enclosure, designers can also dispense with an internal lining if appropriate, Garden Museum,
significantly reducing the number and types of components involved within London
a typical cavity wall construction.
Cross-laminated timber
provides a free-standing
structure installed within
the historic fabric of the
Museum of Garden History
housed within St. Mary’s,
Lambeth. The exposed
wood of the intervention
is used to complement
the surface texture of the
existing stone building
Architect
Dow Jones Architects
Project engineer
Momentum
Client
Garden Museum
Timber structure
Eurban/Schilliger Holz
Photograph
David Grandorge
Through its exceptional combination of technical properties, CLT provides Figure 1.19
a remarkable degree of flexibility in use. This flexibility also extends to the Kingsdale School
appearance of buildings, allowing for a high level of creativity and versatility.
Buildings with a solid timber superstructure can be faced in any material, Completed in 2005, the new
sports hall and music school
although cross-laminated timber provides a sub-base that is particularly
for Kingsdale School was the
well suited to lightweight claddings. first cross-laminated timber
school building in the UK
The relatively lightweight nature of CLT lends itself to building on sites with
Architect
difficult ground conditions, bridging over existing infrastructure or even
dRMM
reusing existing foundations.
Project engineer
Michael Hadi
The method of factory production means that while repetitive structures
Client
can often have an intrinsic economy, an assortment of window and door
London Borough of
openings can also be developed within the design process and fully inte- Southwark
grated within the manufacturing of the panels, while still remaining cost-ef-
Timber structure
fective. This adaptability lends itself to freedom of design within the briefs KLH UK
of low-rise, non-residential projects as well as one-off houses.
Photograph
Alex de Rijke
Buildings for the education, health, civic and cultural sectors can all benefit
from the possibility of exposing the timber internally. This may be for
aesthetic or acoustic reasons, or because of the particular feel of a timber
internal environment.
Figure 1.20
Bridport House
Architect
Karakusevic Carson
Architects
Project engineer
Peter Brett Associates
Client
Hackney Borough Council
Timber structure
Eurban/Stora Enso
Timber superstructure
engineer
Eurban
Photograph
Ioana Marinescu
There are other, more practical site benefits that accompany the pre-fabricated
nature of cross-laminated timber construction:
• The reduction in wet trades and the ability to fix the panels with
handheld, lightweight tools means that CLT building sites are safer
and quieter than those with concrete superstructures.
Figure 1.21
Theatre facilities and Architect
box office, Regent’s Haworth Tompkins
Park Structural engineer
Price & Myers
The building site, located
within Regent’s Park in Client
central London, contained a Regent’s Open Air Theatre
number of significant trees, Timber structure
including several that were Eurban/Stora Enso
subject to Tree Preservation
Orders. The use of cross- Timber superstructure
laminated timber significantly engineer
reduced the weight of the Eurban
building, allowing smaller Photograph
foundations so as not to Philip Vile
impact on the tree roots