Article 1 Qualitative
Article 1 Qualitative
Article 1 Qualitative
FLORANTE P. IBARRA
Central Luzon State University
ABSTRACT KEYWORDS
This ethnographic-phenomenological study explores the holistic nature of araquio musical transmission
tradition. Araquio, a verse play on the search of the holy cross, is an indigenous music as social
folk theatre in the town of Peñaranda, province of Nueva Ecija, Philippines, that behaviour
has survived for over 100 years. The orihinal (script) utilized the local poetic styl- cultural anthropology
ized delivery of verses, conventionalized movements, choreographed sword fights, musical experience
songs and dances with distinct live musical accompaniment played by the commu- communal learning
nity band. Araquio’s musical tradition suggests a culturally specific metaphor that theatre ritual
has overshadowed its diminishing tradition. Constructed in the framework of music
as social behaviour, I investigated araquio’s musical tradition as the product of the
social behaviour of a specific group of practitioners and how music-making builds
a community. Eleven adult practitioners participated in this enquiry. An ethno-
graphic method was employed using participant-observation and an informal semi-
structured interview script. This oral tradition created a process of social structures
and situations stemmed initially from a self-imposed initiative that had become a
171
Florante P. Ibarra
www.intellectbooks.com 173
Florante P. Ibarra
www.intellectbooks.com 175
Florante P. Ibarra
www.intellectbooks.com 177
Florante P. Ibarra
of identity, iconicity, association and contrast that would offer manifold mean-
ing for music. In his metaphorical denotation on music as social behaviour,
Merriam (1964) likewise noted that each musical tradition connotes some-
thing significant about the nature of music in that specific group of society.
Since music is created and valued by the practitioners in that society, every
performance suggests a presentation of social structures and relations. Thus,
it is evident that araquio’s musical performance suggests social structures that
would dictate articulated and unarticulated meanings and boundaries.
Based on the premise that araquio is an avenue for musicological
discourse, I specifically examined how social behaviour creates social relations
and structures that would continually perpetuate araquio’s musical tradition.
In its capacity as a devotional ritual, I sought to reveal how these processes
became meaningful to the practitioners. Rice (2001) notes music’s significance
for human life, and its very nature is understood through metaphorical predi-
cation. Since music-making is a social phenomenon, it creates a social situa-
tion that is produced by a specific community of practitioners (Merriam 1964),
which has been expounded through interpretation of culture (Geertz 1973).
The interpretation of culture can be used to understand products of anthropo-
logical research consisting of thick descriptions. This forms an entity in which
social relation is regulated by customs and asserts that culture can be under-
stood by studying what people think about their experiences and ideas and
the meanings that are important to them. More so, it encompasses the inter-
pretation of human behaviour in a cultural context.
In relation to these underlying principles, my investigative study posited
that music as social behaviour constructed into categories can address the
symbolic and unique representation of araquio’s musical practice. This can
be organized into descriptive knowledge-based concepts on social relations,
social structures and meanings of practitioners’ experiences that are bound
outside the typical western perspective. The metaphorical connotation of
music as social behaviour was observed in relation to practitioners’ level of
exposure to araquio elements. Involving themselves in communal music-
making, social situations were created as a product of collective perfor-
mance that defined social structures. Since music-making was viewed as a
social phenomenon, this became a specifically significant area of enquiry.
The research enquiry illustrated the connection between social situations
and structures to community building through transmission phenomenon,
which framed the learning experience. This ethnographic documentation
aimed at discovering how these learning experiences were meaningful to
them. Thus, it underscored their shared experiences, what shaped their
beliefs, awareness and understanding of the araquio’s sociocultural and reli-
gious contexts.
METHOD
Using purposive sampling (Bernard 2006), I involved eleven adult practition-
ers in this study– four maestros, two female and two male personajes, and three
community musicians. Their ages varied according to their respective roles.
Purposive sampling was utilized to generate representative types of each role
in the araquio tradition, to adequately capture the diverse backgrounds and
characteristics of the practitioners, and determine the similarities and differ-
ences that would reveal social behaviours evident in araquio’s musical tradition
in the context of a social phenomenon. I had purposely chosen adult native
culture bearers because their experiences had been whetted and nurtured
through the passing of time. Thus, they were able to share their meaningful
experiences on how musical behaviour had greatly affected their decision in
choosing roles for the araquio. They had acquired different musical skills repre-
senting the distinct characteristics of music, songs and movement conven-
tions. The distinctive representation of each of the participants shed light on
establishing a vivid comparison between the processes of social relations and
structures and how these processes were meaningful to the practitioners.
After the two-day production, I conducted semi-structured and open-
ended interviews with the participants that ranged from 30 to 40 minutes
each. Three different sets of questions, each for a specific group of partici-
pants, were used. The first section, comprising questions for all interviewees,
focused on their personal background in the araquio and the source of moti-
vation for their involvement. The second part was categorized according to
participants’ roles and centred on experiences and the meanings that defined
their experiences.
In gathering my data, I utilized an interactive method in the form of partic-
ipant-observation. This method served as my investigative tool to gather data
on participants’ experiences. I immersed myself in the investigative proce-
dure using a balanced emic and etic, or outsider–insider perspective (Bernard
2006; Geertz 1973). During the process of investigation, I stayed in the small
village of Santo Tomas for three months, and participated in the simultaneous
rehearsals and two-day araquio productions as a participant-observer and in
the exclusive rehearsals as a plain observer.
Consequently, I utilized three approaches to data analysis in this study:
classification of data, inductive coding, and hermeneutic/interpretive analysis.
I used classification of data as an initial approach to coding. Wiersma and
Jurs (2005) and Lofland (in Lofland and Lofland 1996) suggested a number
of ways in which data can be classified, which I have reconstructed to fit this
study. Further, I used categories such as meaning-makers and meaning descrip-
tion to define the meanings these four groups of participants identified in this
study. The unarticulated meaning was based on my own reflection as a prod-
uct of typification. It was then followed by inductive coding. ‘Inductive codes
were used specifically for categorizing the information in the data’ (Wiersma
and Jurs 2005: 259). Thus, it provided me with a clear path to identify factors
related to my research. Finally, I utilized hermeneutic/interpretive analysis.
Bernard (2006) defined it as the continual interpretation and reinterpretation of
texts. This analytical approach highlighted the underlying meaning contained
in the texts given by the participants who experienced the phenomenon
under study. In this view, the hermeneutic interpretive analytical tool offered
a logical approach to the search for meanings and their interconnections
in the araquio tradition. The idea that culture is an assemblage of texts was
the basis for interpretive anthropology (Geertz 1973). As Geertz (1973) noted,
cultural interpretation in anthropology denotes the meaningful experiences
of practitioners’ involvement in the sociocultural life of a community. Geertz
(1973) asserted that culture can be fully understood by studying what prac-
titioners think of their experiences and ideas as well as the meanings that
are significant to them. Because learning araquio music was considered a
social behaviour, eight salient themes that emerged in the research were: (1)
early induction into religious community, (2) socialization by imitation and
interaction, (3) expectations on content and learning behaviour, (4) mould-
ing of a master–apprentice relationship, (5) gender roles on music-making,
www.intellectbooks.com 179
Florante P. Ibarra
[m]y mother was a devotee to the holy cross. She told me that when I
was in her womb, she danced onstage and prayed to our patron saint
that, when I reached certain age, she wished me to join the araquio
tradition which really happened.
[m]y mother went up onstage and handed me over to a personaje for the
ritual dance. My mother said one female personaje carried and danced
me to the music.
[b]oth my parents joined the production for several years when I was a
child, I remember I watched every rehearsal [and] tried to imitate the
dance movements at home and hum the songs then hum the music
while brandishing [imaginary] my sword.
I was inspired by bouncy rhythm of the paso doble that accompanied the
movements. My father was very good at sword-fight movement and I
wished to learn his skills. It was a delightful experience watching my
family members performed onstage having those skills.
www.intellectbooks.com 181
Florante P. Ibarra
[w]hen I play bit off key, I watch and listen to my friendand ask him
the right finger positions on trumpet keys. I let him play the notes with
sharp or without the effect of accidental, then I repeatedly practice the
melodic phrase afterwards.
Similarly, the cyclical approach to learning the songs was also evident among
female personajes. Consistently, the singer maintained a high-throaty singing
style to complement the verve and execution of the hand- and foot-work of
the masters. According to Blanca:
I told my Uncle Lucio [former maestro], I didn’t have his blessing yet
to assist him in rehearsals with the community musicians, it was not
proper to just assist in rehearsal without his approval. After a year, my
uncle granted me his permission. He asked me to undergo apprentice-
ship which I complied. I served for 11 years assisting them in rehearsals
from 1996 to 2007. Then just a couple of years later, he died.
In learning the songs, movements, and improvised sound effects, Tino shared
his experience:
[t]he four of us have assigned tasks. Ciano handles the songs and verse
recitation. Romeo and I teach the movements, we use improvised
bamboo instrument in teaching them the dance steps. And it took us
more than ten years to serve as apprentice maestro.
This long period of traditional preparation supported the idea that an inexperi-
enced individual can eventually become an experienced ‘culture bearer’ (Kerlin
2004; Klinger 1996). Their initial involvement necessitated immersion and
apprenticeship on araquio elements. With constant repetitive rehearsals and
training over the years, their skills were whetted and nurtured in a way that
conformed to their cultural criteria of becoming an apprentice. These criteria
had been met until they were officially appointed as maestros. This observation
gave credence to the truism that constant practice and repetition make one
perfect. Aptly put: practice indeed brings perfection to life and reality.
An interesting historical phenomenon that had been chronicled was that
in order for an apprentice to become a full-fledged maestro, he had to wait for
someone to die so he could take the place of an official maestro of the araquio
www.intellectbooks.com 183
Florante P. Ibarra
tradition. This established cultural norm became dependent on the health and
physical capability of the existing maestros. Once they reached the retirement
age or felt sickly, or incapacitated, a successor’s appointment became inevitable.
[w]e maintain the practice of araquio that only males can take the posi-
tion of maestro. We’ve inherited this from our ancestors.
I’ve been actively involved in araquio for almost fifty years. I never see
female playing an instrument for araquio, since then when I first joined
until now, male dominates the instrumental music.
learning gradually shaped into a communal school of learning that was more
of an informal setting that required a unified communal setting.
Given their mutual and salient charted goals of perpetuating the araquio
tradition, a new generation of ‘araquio-ers’ have emerged who share recipro-
cal knowledge, skills, sentiments and beliefs in their own traditional practices.
They had become consciously and dynamically involved in learning together
within the context of reciprocity. Communal participation was believed to be
the dominant factor in learning. Ciano emphasized:
[a]ll practitioners [in the community] play their respective roles in the
araquio. We make sure that it is staged yearly. There are so many people
[believers] coming from abroad attending this to witness the venera-
tion of the cross through araquio. We have their full support until now
because they’ve been part of it.
Apart from a sense of belongingness, there were other social factors that
contributed to the practitioners’ definition of community. Desire to participate
was believed to be the dominant factor for learning to be communal. Each
member had a significant role to portray and each part could not be separated
from the others. The essence of membership in the community production
offered a feeling of belongingness within the group. Satisfaction was meas-
ured in terms of the emotional impact felt by an individual, such as feelings of
enjoyment, fulfilment, and the appreciation of unity that araquio offers. These
emotional attributes were attained from performing their respective roles as
maestro, musikero or personaje. Contentment was achieved when practition-
ers’ goals and expectations were met by means of their desire to contribute
something to the community. Through this process, a communal approach to
learning araquio was built and established.
The results that emerged on communal learning as observed in the araquio
tradition were also consistent with the key factors that defined a sense of
community articulated in the community of practice (Bonk et al. 2004; Elliot
1995; McMillan and Chavis 1986). Specifically, learning to be communal
necessitates membership, influence, fulfilment of individual needs, and shared
events and emotional connections. These key areas emerged consistently with
araquio practitioners’ communal learning experiences.
Further, the araquio-ers, through the unspoken import of their tradition,
purported to nurture some underlying principles in order to foster, preserve
and perpetuate their culture. They had certain unspoken unifying factors in
at least four areas: unity of purpose, ancestral adhesion, unification of tribal
strength, and shared experiences.
In their unity of purpose, the foremost common denominator of the
araquio-ers was their deep-rooted observance of their religious beliefs and
attending (or continuing) rituals. Their early exposure to their traditional prac-
tices, coupled with their stimulated interest in their music, performance and
play, songs, and dances to the corresponding celebrated occasion, all served
to propel them to maintain a natural inclination for ‘meeting of the minds,
souls, and spirit’. Those were primarily the elements, hence the achievement
of ‘unity of purpose’. One of the primary attributes of their ‘social factors’ was
their sense of belonging. Self-identity, their identified and recognized perso-
nas, and contributions to their community, as well as their sense of achieve-
ment and pride were evidently contributory to their preservation of a distinct
ancestral heritage.
www.intellectbooks.com 185
Florante P. Ibarra
Aside from the above-mentioned unifying factors and purposes, and serv-
ing well as common denominators of remarkable compelling forces, the araquio
people were evidently tribal. Their ancestral dominion could be traced directly
to those factors that brought them in the first place to be interdependent. Their
tribal style and practices were not quite the same as compared to those of other
neighbouring tribes (or of their neighbouring communities and regions). They
respected each other as people, as well as each other’s roles for fulfilling their
missions within the araquio tradition. Consequently, their mutual respect for
one another led them to their path of interdependency and their special close-
ness with one another as a unique community unto itself. That served as their
binding force against partition and the outward flow towards other groups.
Their sense of adhesion as a unique group was as non-detachable as glue. A
sense of being an independent political entity as a tribe gradually surfaced.
The unification of tribal strength was also their communal goal. The
araquio, for more than a century, did not depart to join other tribes, nor did
they merge with other tribal regions. Apparently, their ancestral adhesion,
with their purposeful unifying factors of their own religious beliefs, gave them
the earmark of being an independent political entity. Politically speaking, this
recognized entity may still be in the infancy stage of growth. I had a strong
perception that this small group has a strong propensity to influence the
nation as well. Behind the unifying factors of purposes and binding forces, the
chain of continuity could not be broken because of their ‘shared experiences’.
Their shared experiences are important elements of their cultural practice.
The secret of success of the araquio can be attributed to the process of promot-
ing social situations and relations from as early as pregnancy and progressing
into adulthood. Even an unborn fetus, while inside the womb of the mother,
can hear and appreciate the musical sounds and rhythms during practice,
actual participation, and finally during the public performance. Psychologists
often advise mothers to read and talk to their unborn child and infants regard-
less of whether the baby can openly respond to the music or to the stories.
The araquio practice seems to have adopted this unwritten norm.
Rituals on music-making
All practitioners believed that araquio is a form of offering to their patron
saint. Under the leadership of the maestros in the community, all practitioners
combined their efforts to annually observe and stage the play. This underscored
the ceremonial dance wherein audience members of all ages performed their
intentions onstage through a ritual dance termed as pantot. Celebrated with
the involvement of all sectors of the community, infants and toddlers were
handed over to the personajes for a common purpose as a culminating activity.
Elders, mothers, children of school age, and seniors having severe illnesses
(i.e. a person with Parkinson’s disease) joined the dancing, symbolizing their
veneration and thanksgiving for the blessings they had received through the
years. This included but was not limited to plentiful agricultural harvests,
good health, and divine guidance and intervention. While mothers wished for
their children’s good health and bountiful life in the future, elders with severe
sickness hoped for their immediate recovery from their illnesses. Blanca and
Bernie emphasized the reason for their annual participation thus:
www.intellectbooks.com 187
Florante P. Ibarra
Blanca: My parents are actively involved in the araquio for more than
20 years. According to them, it is their way of expressing their panata
[vows] to our patron saint. So I do the same.
Bernie: I have spent my whole life with the araquio and I consider my
participation as pamamanata [my devotional expression to the Holy
Cross].
CONCLUSION
The Araquio musical practice as social behaviour created a process of social
structures and situations that stemmed initially from a self-imposed initiative
that had become template to a group or community-building setting. Such
a process gradually shaped into a communal learning experience by gene-
alogical transmission in an informal setting. This was a continuous process
of passing down the araquio skills. Communal learning was the end product
of genealogical transmission,which evidently occurred in the araquio tradi-
tion. The transmission of music, songs and movements happened within old
and young generations of practitioners. These were passed down aurally and
orally from their great ancestors within that particular community. This was
an enduring attribute of the practitioners’ communal process. The process of
communal learning also assisted each individual in developing self-identity
and communal solidarity. Through this unique intergenerational process,
their culture was revitalized, and their religious beliefs were put into practice
in celebrating their offering rites.
The modes of utilizing the music, songs, dances and stylized movements
were all considered fundamental elements in bringing vivaciousness to the
native folk tradition. Musikeros or maestros did not see themselves as sepa-
rate entities in fulfilling their obligation but rather as mutually important.
Their communality was evident when personajes combined the elements of
music provided by the musikeros and the song and dance patterns directed
by the masters into a collective rendition. Because of the collaborative effort,
the practitioners served the purpose of commitment to unite the community
in upholding its practices, traditions and religious beliefs. Even the commu-
nal non-performers (i.e. family members, relatives, peers, audience and tribal
members) showed devotion and passion in playing their passive roles, by
watching all elements of the music, song, dance and movements, interweav-
ing them together, utilizing their spiritual beliefs and religious expression
to their araquio supernatural. These essentials supported the holistic nature
ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS
I am most grateful to my academic adviser, Dr Lori A. Custodero, for her
inspiring mentorship, unwavering support, patience and generosity in shar-
ing her music research expertise. I thank my professors Dr Harold F. Abeles,
Dr Randall Allsup, Dr Jeanne Goffi-Fynn and Dr Lenore Pogonowski at
Columbia University Graduate School of Education for offering me such
wonderful learning experiences. The knowledge I acquired from all of you gave
me considerable insight to aid my investigation into araquio music as social
behaviour. I extend special thanks to Dr Esmeralda Cunanan, executive direc-
tor of Fulbright Philippines (Philippine American Educational Foundation –
Fulbright Philippines), for helping me transform my intention to study abroad
into reality. I thank Cinthya Alvarez, Jacqueline Sindoni and the entire staff
of the Institute of International Education (IIE) in New York City. I thank the
Santo Tomas community, especially the organizers of the araquio production:
hermanos, hermanas, maestros, musikeros and personajes. I am grateful to my
home institution, Central Luzon State University, for granting approval for
my study abroad. I extend special thanks to former deans Professor Mauricia
Borromeo and Dr Ramon Santos of the University of the Philippines, Diliman,
for introducing me to the araquio. I take this opportunity to say how grateful I
am to the Gottesman Libraries of Teachers College, Columbia University, for
their extensive and vast resources. I also extend my gratitude to The University
of the Philippines Main Library, University of Santo Tomas Main Library,
Ateneo de Manila Main Library, La Salle University Main Library, Cultural
Center of the Philippines Library, Philippine National Library, Central Luzon
State University Main Library and the Municipality of Peñaranda Library.
www.intellectbooks.com 189
Florante P. Ibarra
REFERENCES
Bañas, R. C. (1969), Pilipino Music and Theater, Quezon City: Manlapaz
Publishing Company.
Beltran, Benigno P. (1987), The Cristology of the Inarticulate: An Inquiry
into the Filipino Understanding of Jesus Christ, Manila: Divine Word
Publication.
Bernard, Russell H. (2006), Research Method in Anthropology, New York:
Altamira Press.
Blacking, John (1995), Music, Culture, and Experience: Selected Papers of John
Blacking, Chicago: University of Chicago Press.
Bonk, C. J., Wisher, R. and Nigrelli, M. (2004), ‘Learning communities,
community of practice: Principles, technologies and examples’, in Karen
Littleton (ed.), Learning to Collaborate, New York, NY: Nova Science,
pp. 199–219.
Briones, Nikki S. (2010), ‘From war dance to theater of war: Moro-moro
performances in the Philippines’, Ph.D. thesis, Southeast Asian Studies:
National University of Singapore.
Campbell, Patricia S. (1989), ‘Music learning and song acquisition among
native Americans’, International Journal of Music Education, 14, pp. 24–31.
—— (2003), ‘Ethnography and music education: Crossroads for knowing
music, education, and culture’, Research Studies in Music Education, 21:16,
pp. 16–30.
Campbell, Patricia S., Connell, C. and Beegle, A. (2007), ‘Adolescents’ expres-
sed meanings of music in and out of school’, Journal of Research in Music
Education, 55, pp. 220–36.
Cope, Peter and Smith, Hugh (1997), ‘Cultural context in musical instrument
learning’, British Journal of Music Education, 14:13, pp. 283–289.
Custodero, Lori A. (2011), ‘Meaning and experience in musical learner’, in
H. Abeles and L. Custodero (eds), Critical Issues in Music Education:
Contemporary Theory and Practice, Oxford: Oxford University Press,
pp. 61–86.
Custodero, Lori A. and Johnson-Green, Elissa A. (2003), ‘Passing the cultu-
ral torch: Musical experiences and musical parenting of infants’, Journal of
Research in Music Education, 51:2, pp. 102–114.
Elliot, D. (1995), Music Matters, New York: Oxford University Press.
Feay-Shaw, Shirley J. (2002), ‘The transmission of Ghanaian music by culture-
bearers: From master musician to master teacher’, Ph.D. thesis, Seattle:
University of Washington.
Geertz, Clifford (1973), The Interpretation of Culture, New York: Basic Books.
Ibarra, Florante P. (2002), ‘The Araquio of Sto. Tomas Penaranda, Province
of Nueva Ecija: A study on the music in devotional theatre’, MA thesis,
Diliman Quezon City: University of the Philippines.
Ileto, Reynaldo C. (1979), Pasyon and Revolution: Popular Movements in the
Philippines, Quezon City: Ateneo de Manila University Press.
Kerlin, Jerry (2004), ‘The transmission of song among the New York Irish:
Teaching, learning, and Irish sensitivity’, Ph.D. thesis, New York: New
York University.
Klinger, Rita (1996), ‘Matters of compromise: An ethnographic study of
culture-bearers in elementary music education’, Ph.D. thesis, Seattle:
University of Washington.
Llana, Jazmin B. (2009), ‘The Bicol Dotoc: Performance, postcoloniality, spiri-
tuality’, Ph.D. thesis, UK: Aberystwyth University.
Lofland, John and Lofland, Lyn H. (1996), Analyzing Social Setting, 3rd ed.,
Belmont, CA: Wadsworth.
Lumbera, Bienvenido L. (1986), Tagalog Poetry 1570–1898: Tradition and
Influence in its Development, Quezon City: Ateneo de Manila Press.
Marsh, Kathryn (2009), ‘Music education ethnographic research and thick
description: A response’, Research Studies in Music Education, 31:1,
pp. 96–101.
McMillan, D. W. and Chavis, D. (1986), ‘Sense of community: A depiction and
theory’, Journal of Community Psychology, 14, pp. 6–23.
Merriam, Alan P. (1964), The Anthropology of Music, Chicago: Northwest
University Press.
Nettl, Bruno (1996), ‘Ideas about music and musical thought:
Ethnomusicological perspectives’, The Journal of Aesthetic Education, 30,
pp. 173–87.
Peterson, William (2007), ‘Holy week in the heart of the Philippines:
Spirituality, theatre, and community in Marinduque’s Moriones Festival’,
Asian Theatre Journal, 24:2, pp. 309–37.
Phuthego, M. (2005), ‘Teaching and learning African music and Jaques-
Dalcroze’s eurhythmics’, International Journal of Music Education, 23:3,
pp. 239–50.
Rice, Timothy (1994), May it Fill Your Soul: Expressing Bulgarian Music,
Chicago: Chicago University Press.
—— (1996), ‘Traditional and modern methods of learning and teaching music
in Bulgaria’, Research Studies in Music Education, 7:1, pp. 1–13.
—— (2001), ‘Reflections on music and meaning: Metaphor, signification
and control in Bulgarian case’, British Journal on Ethnomusicology, 10:1,
pp. 19–28.
Robertson, John (2011), ‘Semiotic, habitus, and music in the transmission of
Tibetan culture in Toronto’, MA thesis, Toronto: Liberty University.
Shelemay, Kay K. (1996), ‘The ethnomusicologist and the transmission of
tradition’, Journal of Musicology, 14:1, pp. 35–51.
Sheridan, Mark, MacDonald, Iona and Byrne, Charles G. (2011), ‘Gaelic
singing and oral tradition’, International Journal of Music Education, 29:2,
pp. 172–90.
Small, Christopher (1998), Musicking: The Meaning of Performing and Listening,
Hanover, NH and London: Wesleyan University Press.
Tiongson, Nicanor G. (1986), ‘The Arakyo of San Jose, Peñaranda, Nueva
Ecija’, in E. Maranan (ed.), Komedya: Philippine History and Anthology, vol. 2,
Quezon City: University of the Philippine Press, pp. 191–217.
Trimillos, Ricardo D. (1989), ‘Halau, hochschule, maystro, and ryu: Cultural
approaches to community music learning and teaching’, International
Journal of Music Education, 14, pp. 32–43.
Veblen, Kari K. (1991), ‘Perception of change and stability in the transmis-
sion of Irish traditional music: An examination of the music teacher’s role’,
Ph.D. thesis, Wisconsin, USA: University of Wisconsin-Madison.
—— (1994), ‘The teacher’s role in transmission of Irish traditional music’,
International Journal of Music Education, 24:1, pp. 21–30.
Waldron, Janice L. (2006), ‘Learning, teaching and transmission in the lives of
two Irish musicians: An ethnographic case study’, International Journal of
Community Music, 4, pp. 1–21.
Wiersma, W. and Jurs, S. (2005), Research Method in Education: An Introduction,
Boston, MA: Chestnuts Hills Enterprises.
www.intellectbooks.com 191
Florante P. Ibarra
SUGGESTED CITATION
Ibarra, F. P. (2017), ‘Voices from devotional ritual: Practitioners’ unity of
purpose to building community in araquio musical tradition’, International
Journal of Community Music, 10:2, pp. 171–92, doi: 10.1386/ijcm.10.2.171_1
CONTRIBUTOR DETAILS
Dr Florante P. Ibarra was a recipient of the 2009 Classic Fulbright Scholarship
Award to the Unites States for his doctorate degree in music and music educa-
tion at Columbia University, Graduate School of Education in the City of New
York, USA (2009–12). He finished his master of music at the University of
the Philippines College of Music major in music education and his bache-
lor’s degree at the University of Santo Tomas, Conservatory of Music major
in music education and voice with distinct honour of Cum Laude. A multi-
awarded music educator and music researcher, his interest centred on teach-
ing and learning musical traditions, cultural anthropology, choral pedagogy
and general classroom music teaching and learning. He is currently affiliated
with Central Luzon State University College of Education in Philippines.
Contact: Department of Elementary Education, College of Education, Central
Luzon State University, Science City of Munoz, 3120 Nueva Ecija, Philippines.
E-mail: [email protected]
Florante P. Ibarra has asserted his right under the Copyright, Designs and
Patents Act, 1988, to be identified as the author of this work in the format that
was submitted to Intellect Ltd.