Six Milestones From Pints of HIstory 1.00
Six Milestones From Pints of HIstory 1.00
Six Milestones From Pints of HIstory 1.00
Except as specifically set forth below on this page, all rights are reserved, and no part of this booklet may be
reproduced or used in any form or by any means, electronic or mechanical, including photocopying or recording, or
by any information storage and retrieval system, without written permission from the author.
Title Fonts: Cover page and Chap. 4: Roman Antique, by Dieter Steffmann. Chap. 1: Ancient Hellenic, by John
Barounis. Chap. 2: Tanach, by Typographer Mediengestaltung. Chap. 3: mgs4brush, by David Hayter. Chap. 5:
Benegraphic by Tepid Monkey. Chap. 6: Black Sam's Gold, by Redruth's Basement Software, licensed under
Creative Commons (by-nd) Attribution No Derivatives (presumably this license)
If you received this Booklet directly through the Pints of History website (including its author), you may
keep a copy on any computer you own or control and also print a copy, all for your personal use and
enjoyment. Please share this Booklet only by sending a link to https://PintsofHistory.com/, so recipients
can download their own copies. Please don’t distribute copies yourself. (“You” refers to natural persons,
not organizations. And “Booklet” refers to this publication, including text, illustrations, and maps.)
This Booklet is not licensed for commercial use. If you’d like to make any use of this Booklet not authorized
above, including commercial use, please contact us through www.PintsofHistory.com/contact. We’d be
happy to hear from you.
Contents
Introduction
1. The Realm Of Zeus: From Ireland to Northern India
2. The Many Origins of the Israelites
3. Zhang Qian and the Start of World History
4. Nature vs. the Roman Empire
5. How William the Conqueror Broke Up the Domain of the North and Redirected World History
6. The End of Nomad Barbarian Power and the Start of Modern History
Introduction
To study history means submitting to chaos but nevertheless retaining faith in order and meaning.
~ Herman Hesse
Not all histories are created equal. Every event shapes the future, but most only incrementally. A few,
however, lay foundations for great structures or redirect major roads. This booklet explores six histories of
the latter type, set mostly on the world’s largest connected landmass, Afro-Eurasia.
These six histories have something in common. They are seldom told. Some of the six address events
rarely described in popular literature or in the classroom, while others cover familiar events but offer
unfamiliar interpretations. In other words, though these preludes and pivots shape modern civilization, we
rarely think about them.
*
Linguists “reconstructed” Dyeus Pater. They guessed the
Proto-Indo-European name, extrapolating from words in
daughter languages we know today. Linguists use various
symbols when they write these reconstructions – e.g.,
“*Dyḗus Ph₂tḗr.” This booklet leaves the symbols out.
Northern India’s Dyaus Pitr, Rome’s Jupiter, and Ireland’s The Dagda
SIX MILESTONES 1
also evolved in Italy among the Latins. Hinduism). Thousands of miles to the west, goddess reconstructed as Sehul. She
There, Dyeus Pater became the Roman god among the Proto-Celts, Dyeus Pater became probably evolved into goddesses like the
Jovis Pater – or just Jupiter or Jove. The something like Dewos or Dago-dewos, who Celtic Sulis and the Germanic Sól or Sunna,
Romans adopted many tales of Zeus into evolved into the Irish father god The Dagda. as well as male sun gods like the Greeks’
their beliefs about Jupiter, so we often Dyeus Pater probably reigned over other Helios, the Romans’ Sol, and the Vedic god
assume they copied the Greek thunder god. Indo-European speakers too, like the Surya. The Proto-Indo-Europeans probably
But it’s probably more accurate to say they ancient Slavs (Ukrainians, Poles, etc.) and also worshipped a dawn goddess
realized the Greeks worshipped the same Latvians. And among Germanic-speakers, reconstructed as Hausos, source of the
ruling god. So myths of Zeus were myths of he may have become Ziu and eventually Greeks’ Eos and the Vedic Usas. Other
Jupiter. Tiw, the source of Tuesday (Tiw’s day). ancient gods share Proto-Indo-European
roots too. These divine beings shaped
In northern India, Dyeus Pater became Sky Father is not the only Proto-Indo- cultures and beliefs across western Eurasia,
Dyaus Pitr, sky god and father god of the European god shared among these distant from Ireland to India.
ancient Vedic faith (a key source for peoples. Other candidates include the sun
SIX MILESTONES 2
2. THE MANY ORIGINS OF THE
ISRAELITES
The Bible’s Book of Exodus says Moses
freed 600,000 men from slavery in Egypt.
Then they and their families fled east to the
nearby Sinai Peninsula. But the former
slaves’ destiny lay beyond Sinai. Their
ancestors had once lived in Canaan: modern
Israel/Palestine. (See the map on page 5.) So
after forty years in Sinai, Moses’s people
moved east again (northeast, actually). They
invaded and conquered Canaan and
eventually set up their own kingdom.
Exodus recounts the origin of Moses’s
people, known as Israelites. It also provides
an indirect origin story for billions alive
today, since the Israelites’ descendants and
religious successors include today’s Jews,
Christians, and Muslims. But the Exodus
story has some problems.
SIX MILESTONES 3
Canaan. History does record Israelites in make the trip. But they’re still too few to artifacts in the Golan Heights, at Tell el-
Canaan by 1200. But their origins don’t disrupt local society much, and they still Qadi: chief city of the ancient Israelite Tribe
seem to match the Bible. Historical and leave no trace in the historical record. of Dan. And some of the ancient city’s
archeological evidence suggests the Sometime later, this immigrant group joins pottery was fired in or near Greece,
Israelite nation arose within Canaan, from an alliance of local tribes. Our according to chemical analysis. That
among the many tribes and peoples who Sinai/Egyptian group still treasures oral suggests the Tribe of Dan immigrated from
lived there, not from invaders. tales of its ancestors’ escape from slavery. Greece to Canaan, or at least some of its
As time goes by and the details grow fuzzy, founders did, possibly in the 1300s BCE.
That, however, doesn’t mean Exodus has that story joins the other tribes’ myths and Even Dan’s name could come from across
the history all wrong. legends to form a history for the whole the sea. Homer’s Iliad often calls the Greeks
alliance – which by then has fused into the Danaans. (The Bible’s Samson comes from
The Bible records twelve Israelite tribes in Israelite nation. Dan, and he resembles the Greek’s Herakles
Canaan, and other histories agree. So it’s – a.k.a. Hercules. If the Dan/Danaan theory
possible the nation began as an alliance of It’s even possible our original runaway has it right, the legendary musclemen could
separate peoples. It seems most of these slaves have some ancestral connection to have a common origin.)
tribes came from Canaan. They’d lived Canaan, just as the Bible suggests, or at least
there for centuries. But multiple tribes could to the lands nearby. A century or two before If the Bible does gloss over the Israelites’
mean multiple origins. If so, one of the Exodus, native Egyptians overthrew the multiple origins, it’s not unusual. Many
tribes could have come from Sinai. It’s even Hyksos: conquerors from those eastern nations arise from multiple earlier groups
possible that tribe included former slaves lands. (History remembers them as Egypt’s but don’t realize it – and treasure legends of
from Egypt or at least their descendants. 15th Dynasty.) As the native Egyptians a single origin.
regained power, they could have enslaved
Imagine a small slave escape from ancient supporters of the Hyksos who remained in
Egypt: maybe two dozen people – few Egypt – like immigrants from Canaan.*
enough to leave no record. The slaves take
refuge among nomad herders in the Sinai We have no support for that story except
Peninsula. They become Sinai herders the Bible. But archeology does support the
themselves and intermarry with other idea of widely different origins for the
herders. After several generations, members Israelite tribes – by suggesting one of them
of this new tribe migrate into Canaan. came from Greece. During the past decade,
They’ve multiplied, so perhaps hundreds researchers have unearthed Greek-style
*
The Hyksos rulers spoke a language from the Semitic family. Most of Canaan’s people spoke Semitic languages too, as did the people of nearby lands, including the nomadic herders of the Sinai
Peninsula. The Israelite language, Hebrew, comes from that family too.
SIX MILESTONES 4
3. Zhang Qian and the
civilizations so far apart and so divided by wilderness. The emperor told Zhan Qian to
wilderness that they lived in separate worlds find the nomadic Yuezhi people – renowned
– until a Chinese explorer blazed a trail and horseback warriors – and propose an
SIX MILESTONES 5
years a prisoner, he escaped with his wife
and son, as well as a Xiongnu-born guide
from the original expedition. He led this
much reduced expedition west, across
desert and plains. They finally reached the
Yuezhi in 127, just north of Bactria, on the
Central Asian plains of today’s Tajikistan
and Uzbekistan.
SIX MILESTONES 7
4. NATURE VS. THE people. Yet the state and its people hardly
faltered during his reign. The Roman
restore the empire in the early 500s. But
Justinian failed, and his own realm soon
ROMAN EMPIRE Empire seemed unbreakable. declined into a rump state historians call the
Byzantine Empire. The “fall of the Roman
Still, the empire had its problems, and they Empire” was done by 550.
began to pile up during the late 100s CE. A
Historians have offered dozens of
long recession struck around 160, followed The paragraphs above summarize a well-
explanations for the fall of the Roman
by political instability. After the troubled known history. Recent scholars, however,
Empire. They include the decadence of
reign of Emperor Commodus,* who was have pieced together another story playing
latter-day Romans, barbarian migrations, a
strangled in 192, civil wars repeatedly out in the background. And that tale – that
bad system for choosing emperors, and the
shook the Roman world – and toppled natural history – offers its own explanation
loss of Roman valor due to Christianity. A
emperors. During the 200s, naked military for fall of the Roman Empire.†
newer line of thinking, however, pins the
might became the only real credential for a
blame mostly on nature: on climate change
ruler. So generals replaced senators as the The empire rose during an unusually
and disease.
top candidates for the imperial purple. And warm, wet period in the Mediterranean,
while the Romans killed each other in their ideal for farming. This Roman Climatic
The Roman Empire rose during the 200s
many struggles for power, barbarian Optimum (RCO) began around 250 BCE. In
and 100s BCE. By 30 BCE, it had
invasions surged – and the economy mid-100s CE, however, the
conquered all the lands around the
staggered. Mediterranean’s climate turned drier and
Mediterranean. From there, it had a long
colder. Farm outputs fell, leading to more
run, led by giants like Augustus Caesar,
A new soldier-emperor, Diocletian, led a regular famines and general food insecurity.
Trajan, and Marcus Aurelius. But the
massive reorganization and militarization of
empire also thrived under terrible leaders,
Roman society in the 280s and 290s CE. Reduced nutrition likely increased the
like the many corrupt consuls and governors
That saved the empire, for quite a while. But empire’s vulnerability to disease. The
of last century BCE. And it thrived under
the Roman world never recovered its old Antonine Plague – probably smallpox or
awful emperors, like Caligula, who ruled
peace, stability, or wealth. The civil wars, measles – struck in 165 CE. In the city of
during the next century, from 37 to 41 CE.
invasions, and other troubles mounted again Rome alone, two thousand people died per
The “mad emperor” allegedly declared
in the 300s and early 400s. The empire’s day at the epidemic’s height, according to
himself a living god, made the army collect
western half fell during the late 400s, taken ancient sources. The plague raged until 180.
seashells, planned to appoint his horse a
over by barbarian kings. An emperor still Then, in 249, the Plague of Cyprian struck
consul … and had a penchant for executing
ruled in the east, and he tried to reunite and – probably smallpox, measles, or some
*
In fiction, Commodus often shows up as the bad guy or the fool. Juaquin Phoenix played Commodus in Gladiator (2000), and so did Christopher Plummer in The Fall of the Roman Empire (1964).
†
Much of the credit goes to Kyle Harper and his popular work, The Fate of Rome: Climate, Disease and the End of an Empire (Princeton University Press 2017). Harper has not escaped criticism, but
few deny nature’s significant role.
SIX MILESTONES 8
version of hemorrhagic fever, like Ebola.
It’s hard to overstate the suffering.
According to Cyprian, Bishop of Carthage,
“as the strength of the body is dissolved, the
bowels dissipate in a flow; … a fire that
begins in the inmost depths burns up into
wounds in the throat; … the intestines are
shaken with continuous vomiting; [and] the
eyes are set on fire from the force of the
blood.” This epidemic continued until 262
and probably killed even faster than the
earlier plague. The two epidemics cut the
empire’s population and military
manpower, though no one knows how
much.
SIX MILESTONES 9
550.) This Plague of Justinian was Yersinia
pestis, the Black Death (which would strike
again in the Middle Ages). Some historians
estimate a quarter of the eastern empire
died. Instead of restoring Roman power, the
emperor Justinian and his people struggled
just to dispose of the corpses.
SIX MILESTONES 10
In January of 1066 CE, England’s King
Edward the Confessor died with no
children, and three men promptly claimed
his throne. Harold Godwinson was the
kingdom’s principle noble, and the Witan
(high council) chose him as king. Then the
other two claimants attacked. Harald
Hardrada, King of Norway, landed a large
army on England’s northeast coast in
September. But Harold Godwinson
defeated and killed the Norwegian king at
the Battle of Stamford Bridge. Then Harold
rushed south to face the third claimant:
William the Bastard, Duke of the French
province of Normandy. William invaded
southern England in late September, and the
two armies met on October 14 for the Battle
of Hastings. This time, the invaders won,
and King Harold was cut down. William the
Conqueror became King of England (after
the English nobles brushed aside a fourth
possible claimant, who was young and
lacked support). And world history pivoted.
King Harald Hardrada of Norway would not have been England’s first Scandinavian king if he’d won in
1066. The Danish royal family held the throne from 1016 to 1042.
SIX MILESTONES 11
The Norman-French conquest pulled Post-Roman civilization tried to reabsorb words, and not just for new or exotic
England into post-Roman civilization: into England during the late 500s and 600s. The concepts. They’re everyday terms, like arm,
the community of kingdoms that had risen Pope sent missionaries to the Anglo- husband, knot, law, mistake, same, sister,
from the ashes of the Roman Empire. We Saxons, and by 700 CE, most of England want, and wrong. The Vikings also gave
tend to assume England always belonged to had converted the Christianity. But in 865, England the noble title earl (originally jarl).
that civilization. But before 1066, more barbarian pagans invaded, once again That’s why England has no counts and
Scandinavia held England’s attention more from northern Europe. These were the originally had no dukes or barons. Those are
than France and the other post-Roman Danes and other Scandinavians, today post-Roman titles.
lands. For centuries before Hastings, the called Vikings. They raided post-Roman
English belonged to what I’ll call the lands too, but in England they conquered Denmark and the other Scandinavian
Domain of the North: the far-flung and settled half the country. lands eventually converted to Christianity,
community of Scandinavian-ruled lands. In particularly during the 1000s. English
fact, if Harold Godwinson or Harald of Native Anglo-Saxon kings reconquered missionaries get much of the credit. Trade
Norway had won in 1066, we might most of England during the early 900s. But between Scandinavia and England grew,
consider England part of Scandinavia today. they did not remove the Vikings. Rather, the and so did political connections, including
The English, of course, went on to shape two peoples merged. The Anglo-Saxons royal and noble marriages.
and shake much of the globe. So if not for and Vikings were cousins, from
the Norman conquest, we’d live in a very overlapping regions in northern Europe. So In other words, England’s attention turned
different world. their traditions grew out of the same toward Scandinavia – not exclusively but
Germanic roots, and the merger came decisively.
Six hundred fifty years before the Battle of naturally, particularly once England’s
Hastings, in the early 400s CE, the Roman Vikings converted to Christianity. The Vikings also conquered or settled
Empire lost control Britain. Barbarians Scotland, Ireland, Iceland, Greenland,
from northern Europe invaded soon after. The cultural blend left an especially Poland, Ukraine, and more. So during the
By the early 600s, they’d taken over most of visible mark on the English language. 900s and 1000s, the Scandinavians presided
Roman Britain: the part we call England. Anglo-Saxon and old Danish were sister over a community of connected realms: the
Trade and political contact with the other languages, almost mutually Domain of the North. Its greatest kingdoms
post-Roman kingdoms plummeted. Even comprehensible, so English gradually were Denmark, Sweden, Norway, and –
religious contacts faded. Christianity simplified for easier communication. Our largest and richest of all – England.
dominated post-Roman civilization, but nouns, for instance, generally have no
England’s invaders – Angles, Saxons, and gender and few case endings. That’s If not for William the Conqueror, the war
Jutes – were pagans. because Danish-speakers had trouble in 1066 would look like just another power
following all that complex grammar. struggle among Anglo-Scandinavian rulers:
English also has many Scandinavian-born Harold Godwinson and Harald Hardrada.
SIX MILESTONES 12
Medieval Northern Europe - including the Domain of the North
William’s reign set England on a new path. The English went on to conquer a quarter
His Norman-French barons soon displaced The Scandinavian kingdoms gradually of the globe, between 1600 and 1900. And
England’s traditional nobles.* These followed England into post-Roman their influence stretches even further. What
Normans imposed feudalism: the key civilization – into the network of trade and if William the Conqueror had lost in 1066?
economic and military system of post- diplomacy connecting most of Europe. What if England had kept its close ties with
Roman civilization. And the Normans’ Many factors contributed, but if the Domain Scandinavia? Would it have grown so
language, French, became England’s of the North had kept England, its greatest strong without feudalism, French culture,
language of government and remained so kingdom, England, it might have remained and other trappings of post-Roman
for centuries. Trade and diplomacy turned strong: a real rival for post-Roman civilization? And if it had, would the British
south and east. England had entered the civilization. Empire have spread Scandinavian culture
orbit of France – and joined post-Roman across the globe?
civilization.
*
Ironically, William and the Normans descended from Vikings. The French king had given Normandy to their ancestors in 911.
SIX MILESTONES 13
plains of the Middle East. Thanks to that horsemen out. And Zhang Qian journeyed
6. The End of mobility, they had no cities or towns. To into Central Asia to ask one nomad nation,
Nomad Barbarian urban societies, they were barbarians. the Yuezhi, for help against another, the
Xiongnu. Some of the latter may have
Power and the Start of The herders had smaller populations than joined an alliance that eventually became
agricultural civilizations. But their mobility the Huns: nomadic warriors who devastated
Modern History gave them military advantages. They could the teetering Roman Empire in the mid-400s
raid caravans and outlying villages and even CE. Similar nomad nations controlled and
penetrate deep into settled kingdoms. Then taxed long stretches of the Silk Road. And
Historians have suggested several they’d retreat to the safety of distant in the 1200s, nomads built history’s largest
launching points for the modern age. They pastures once local forces got organized. land-based empire. The Mongol Empire
include Columbus’s 1492 voyage to the Nomads grew particularly deadly once they stretched from China to Eastern Europe.
Americas, the 1453 fall of Constantinople, domesticated the horse (and in some places
and the 1440s invention of the movable type the camel). On grasslands like the vast Then, the nomad herders’ power faded.
printing press. But another event may have Eurasian Steppe, their lifestyle proved ideal The last great nomad conqueror was Timur
done as much or more to create the for raising horses – and for assembling (a.k.a. Tamerlane), who built a Turkic-
conditions for modern life. For most of cavalry forces, armed with deadly bows. Mongol empire in Central Asia and the
history, agricultural civilization faced a Under the strongest chieftains, nomad Middle East shortly before 1400. After
major rival and, in much of the world, a cavalry could conquer settled kingdoms Timur’s time, Eurasia’s nomads gradually
constant menace. The threat came from near the plains – and sometimes not so near. fell under the power of agricultural
another lifestyle: nomadic herding, a.k.a. So for most of history, much of agricultural kingdoms. Those kingdoms include the
pastoral nomadism. In the 1500s, that threat civilization lived in fear of nomad attack. Ottoman Empire, Safavid Persia, India’s
faded away. Mughal Empire, the Russian Empire, and
We’ve seen nomad herders’ impact in Qing China. In fact, the latter two divided
The herding lifestyle arose in the Neolithic almost every chapter above. Indo- the Eurasian Steppe between them in 1689.
(New Stone Age), probably soon after European-speaking nomads played a key On the world’s greatest grasslands, the
farming. The nomads lived off of goats, role in spreading the worship of Dyeus nomads had become subjects of settled
sheep, cattle, horses, or other domestic Pater. Other nomads settled or conquered kings. Herders around the world soon faced
grazers, eating the animals’ meat and milk. much of the Fertile Crescent and gave rise the same fate. Africa’s Masai and Turkana
They often foraged too. They generally to Semitic-speaking societies. Those peoples, for instance, fell under British
didn’t farm, or at least they relied very little include the Israelites’ likely ancestors in control during the decades before and after
on farming. They were mobile, migrating Canaan, as well as the herders of Sinai (like 1900. North America’s Comanche and
from one grassland to another in broad, flat Moses’ wife, Zipporah). In the East, China Sioux fell to the United States around the
regions like the Eurasian Steppe or the built its Great Wall to keep nomad same time.
SIX MILESTONES 14
What had happened to nomad power?
Bubonic plague may have reduced nomad
populations on the Eurasian Steppe after
Timur’s time. And those same nomads lost
economic power as trade declined on the
Silk Road, thanks to competition from
European oceangoing trade. But those
forces struck only the Eurasian Steppe. And
even there they probably did not deliver the
decisive blow. That blow came from a
Chinese invention, refined by Western
Europeans: the gun.
SIX MILESTONES 15
Mongol Empire. But Babur established an
agricultural domain, the Mughal Empire –
thanks in large part to intelligent use of
muskets and cannons at Panipat and other
battles. Rival empires soon followed
Babur’s example, particularly those
mentioned above. History remembers the
Ottomans, Safavids, and Mughals as
gunpowder empires. The Russians and Qing
Chinese deserve that title too. Artillery gave
those empires and other settled kingdoms a
reliable defense against nomad cavalry.
SIX MILESTONES 16