Chapter 5 - Lean System
Chapter 5 - Lean System
Chapter 5 - Lean System
RICHARD TIAM
The Fundamental of
LEAN MANUFACTURING
"The Endless Journey of Continuous Improvement"
Publication
Published by:
Phone : 088-401800
Fax : 088-499960
Website : https://polikk.mypolycc.edu.my
e ISBN 978-967-2301-58-5
Preface
The purpose of this lean manufacturing ebook is to
provide a simple guide to help students understand the
fundamentals of the lean system. This ebook focuses on
lean applications in the manufacturing sector and serves as
a supplement to topic five for the course DJF41052
Manufacturing System, Politeknik Malaysia.
It reviewed Toyota Motor Corporation's history as a
system pioneer, as well as the origins of the lean principles.
It discusses the various types of waste generated in the
manufacturing industry and how the lean philosophy
addresses them. This ebook attempts to describe the
characteristics of the lean system in a simple but clear
manner. It also covers the lean system methodologies,
tools, and approaches of Just in Time, Value Stream
Mapping, Kanban, and Kaizen. Finally, the fundamentals of
supply chain and logistics management are covered.
I would like to thank all of my friends and colleagues who
contributed directly or indirectly to the creation of this
ebook. This ebook is dedicated to my family. Nathan,
Nathalie, and Noah, as well as Helena, my wife. Continuous
progress, like life, is a journey. Although there is no such
thing as a perfect existence, there is always room for
improvement. I adore each of you.
Richard Tiam
02 Waste in Manufacturing
03 Lean Characteristics
01
The History of Lean
The term lean production was first coined by John Krafcik in
his 1988 book Triumph of the Lean Production System. The
Machine That Changed the World, written by Daniel T. Jones,
Daniel Ross, and James P. Womack, was published in 1990,
contributed to its increased popularity. The book examines the
production strategy of the highly efficient Japanese automaker,
Toyota Motor Corporation (TMC). Lean production is the term
used to describe the management system developed and
adopted by Toyota Motor.
In other words, lean production refers to Toyota Production
System (TPS), a world class manufacturing management
system. TPS is now regarded as the most efficient
manufacturing organization in the world. In some publications,
the terms lean production and TPS were used interchangeably.
Many industries attempt to implement their own form of lean
production using the TPS as a standard, but many of them fail.
Failure was primarily due to a lack of grasp of the lean principle,
particularly its humanistic aspects. Even Toyota itself admitted
to having difficulties at the beginning with implementing its TPS
outside Japan. In order to properly understand lean production,
one may need to first review the background of its founder,
Toyota Motor Corporation.
02
Toyota Motor History
Kiichiro Toyoda
Sakiichi Toyoda Father of JIT
Toyota Motor Founder
03
TPS, however, took years of constant development across
the entire organization to be successful. Over time, the
foundation of the JIT concept was built through the
introduction and adoption of numerous continuous
improvement techniques, such as Kanban, Jidoka,
Standardized Work, Takt Time, 5S, SMED, Visual Control,
Error-proofing, and many others.
Although a lot of people mistakenly believe that lean is a
Japanese approach, the majority of its tools actually have
American roots. The Americans were the forerunners of ideas
like the assembly line, training within the industry,
comprehensive quality management, six sigma, time study,
and motion study. Notable American businessmen, scientists,
and researchers include Fredrick Taylor, Lilian Gilbreth, Henry
Ford, Abraham Maslow, Alfred Sloan, Edwards Deming, and a
host of others.
04
History of Production
Henry Ford invented and implemented the mass production
system in the automotive industry in 1908, long before the lean
concept became popular. Earlier, the only way to produce
goods was through handiwork or craft production.
The table below compares the characteristics of each type of
production system.
05
Waste in
Manufacturing
Waste is any activity for which the customer will not be
willing to pay, the opposite of value. Production activity can be
divided into three categories; value-added or actual work,
necessary non-value added or supporting work, and non-value
added or waste. According to lean concept, the non-value-
added activities must be eliminated, supporting works should
be minimized and the actual work is improvised.
The 8 types of waste in manufacturing include defect,
overproduction, waiting, non-utilized skill, transportation,
inventory, movement, and extra processing. DOWNTIME is an
acronym for these wastes. In the manufacturing industry,
downtime refers to the time lost while production is forced to
halt due to equipment failures or other factors.
06
Defect
Defect products are unwanted outputs from the
manufacturing process. Unwanted outputs can be categorized
into defective and scrap. An output that does not meet specific
quality standards but can still be repaired is referred to as a
defective item. However, further procedures to fix the
damaged item cost the company more money for extra
manpower, material, facilities & material handling.
These additional costs have a direct impact on the
organization in the form of reduced capacity, increased
scheduling effort, increased inspection, and decreased client
confidence. Undetected problems that are shipped to
customers will result in warranty claims, in addition to
negatively affecting the company's reputation and brand.
The other defect, scraps refer to the manufacturing process
output that does not meet the predetermined product qualities.
Defects of this nature cannot be fixed and are placed directly in
the scrap bin. Scraps directly increase the cost of the operation
as the below;
Producing defective parts wastes resources including
labor, machinery, and materials.
Waste from handling, moving, and throwing away the
scrap item.
Waste from keeping the scrap items in stock.
“Stop
repairing
defects that
should
never have
occurred”
07
Overproduction
“ Producing more or sooner than the
customer requires - make to stock ”
08
Waiting
Time is priceless. Waiting for others, materials or equipment is
a waste of time as work cannot be done until they arrive.
Waiting may be due to the following;
09
Non-utilized skills
10
Transportation
11
Inventory
Types of Inventory
12
Motion
Time and energy are wasted by employees or machines
performing unnecessary motion or movement to complete
tasks. Poor workplace design is usually the main cause of this
situation. To perform their tasks, employees are frequently
required to move excessively, which can be hazardous to their
health and safety. Examples of these movements include
bending, twisting, stretching, reaching, and lifting.
The most frequent safety and
health hazard reportedly caused by
excessive movement at work is
fatigue. Worker fatigue decreases
productivity and raises the risk of
accidents.
The lean culture that values
respect for people, makes safety a
top priority. The employer is
responsible for providing employees
with the safest working environment
and the convenient method to do the
jobs.
To reduce worker movement, the
workstation may need to be
redesigned, as well as the operating
method. However, the new design
and method must not compromise the
final output quality. Workstation
design must consider human factors
or ergonomics for safety, comfort,
and productivity.
13 06
Extra-processing
performs more work than is
required on a task or project.
Extra-processing waste occurs whenever an employee
14 14
Characteristics of
Lean
The following characteristics are present in an organization
that has incorporated the lean principle into its production
system.
Pull Method
Quality at the Source
Uniform Load
Small Lot Size
Standardized Method
Close Supplier
Flexible Work Force
Line Flow
Automation
5S
Total Productive Maintenance
15
Pull Method
“ Make only what the customer has
ordered "
Companies that use lean operations employ the pull method,
in which product manufacturing is based on customer demand.
Pull systems will prevent many different types of waste
connected with the overproduction of goods by producing only
what customers require. The advantages of using the pull style
of manufacturing are accuracy in production, actual
consumption, small batches, low inventory, less waste, and
better communications.
16
Quality at the Source
" The workers, not inspectors, should responsible
for product quality "
“Always do
it right the
first time! ”
17
Uniform Load
The daily workload at each workstation must be fairly
uniform for a lean system to function effectively. An efficient
and steady production line is ensured by the uniform load.
Before a pull system can be used, a robust production process
must first be established.
Uneven loads at workstations
result in a substantial quantity of
waste (muda) due to the
Uneven Load
unevenness (mura) of the
production line and the overburden
(muri) on some workers. To obtain
uniform loads at each workstation,
production load levelling (heijunka)
or line balancing might be used. Two
approaches to load balancing are
based on product volume and
product mix.
Uniform Load
18
Small Lot Size
" Small lot moves more quickly and smoothly "
A lot is the number of items that are processed together.
Smaller lot sizes are used in lean manufacturing processes. The
amount of work-in-process inventory is reduced since small lots
move through the system more quickly and smoothly.
19
Standardized Components
& Work Methods
Standardized work procedures outline the easiest, safest,
and most efficient method to complete the task based on
available technology. Additionally, standardized parts will need
the same manufacturing procedure and working approach,
which will speed up the changeover. Standardizing components
and work methods increase job repetition with lower setup time
will support the process stability for the following advantages.
Higher productivity.
Consistent quality.
Lower cost.
Increase safety.
Enable future
improvement.
20
Close Supplier
The core philosophy of the lean system is to continuously
seek new ways to increase productivity and decrease inventory
levels. Having a good relationship with their suppliers is vital for
lean systems that function with little raw material inventory. It
requires supplies to be delivered frequently, has a shorter lead
time, and arrives on schedule with high quality.
" Delivered
frequently, on
schedule & high
quality "
Therefore, in order to promote
solid partnerships, suppliers
perform best when they are
situated near together
geographically. When customers
and their suppliers, however,
cannot be found close to one
another, a buffer or safety stock
is required because of the
distance.
To achieve a win-win situation, close supplier relationships
should be formed and maintained. Later chapter will include a
detailed discussion of the supply chain strategy.
21
Flexible Workforce
The worker's role is elevated in lean systems. Workers in the
flexible workforce concept can be trained to handle a wide
range of tasks. By moving workers across workstations,
bottlenecks can be relieved without the need for inventory
buffers. Employees can also fill in for absent or ill coworkers.
22
Line Flow
Work moves through a production system according to flow.
A continuous or line-flowing process is ideal for a production
system. Manufacturing processes must run continuously to
ensure that work goes smoothly and reliably. Continuous
production flow without bottlenecks, pauses, diversions,
backflows, or waiting is a characteristic of lean systems.
23
Automation
Automation is the use of technology and innovation to
manufacture and deliver a product with little or no human
involvement. Automation is critical to lean systems and reduces
operating costs. The overall manufacturing costs are reduced as
a result of shorter lead times and lower inventory.
24
“ There is a place for everything,
5S everything is in place ”
Five S (5S) is a methodology for
organizing, cleaning,
developing, and sustaining a productive work environment. It
represents five related terms, each beginning with an S, that
describe workplace practices conducive to visual controls and
lean production.
lower costs.
improve on-time delivery.
Improve productivity.
higher product quality.
better use of floor space.
safer working environment. “ 5S - making
builds the discipline needed to the invisible,
make the lean systems effective.
visible ”
25
Total Productive
Maintenance (TPM)
“ The performance standard is zero breakdowns - total
involvement, preventive & predictive ”
Lean systems place a strong emphasis on a continuous
production flow, which depends on reliable machinery and
equipment. Hence, a comprehensive and effective maintenance
program is needed. Implementing Total Productive
Maintenance (TPM) in a lean system involves performing
maintenance tasks in accordance with a systematically
scheduled preventative program. Planned maintenance will
ensure that there is minimal or no downtime during production.
26
Lean Tools &
Approaches
28
Kaizen Tools
In lean manufacturing, any improvement activities are
impractical unless production system elements such as
manpower, machines, materials, and methods are first
stabilized. Without the stability of these elements, the lean
characteristic of the pull system is not possible. Many
continuous improvement tools, approaches, and methods were
used and adopted in order to achieve production system
stability.
Kaizen models and concepts have been developed over the
years to aid in improvement. Well-known concepts are such as
PDCA, DMAIC, and Total Quality Management (TQM).
PDCA Cycle
29
DMAIC
DMAIC is a Six Sigma model for continuous improvement and
problem solving approach popularized by Motorola, Honeywell,
and General Electric. DMAIC is the acronym for the five steps of
the process improvement model, which are Define, Measure,
Analyze, Improve, and Control. It is a program designed to
reduce defects in order to reduce costs, save time, and improve
customer satisfaction.
DMAIC Process
30
Value Stream Mapping
A lean technique called value stream mapping (VSM) uses
graphics to show how information and materials move through
a production process. It provides a clear visual representation
of how a process works with precise time for each step-by-step
activity. Value stream mapping's goal is to identify between
activities that contribute value and those that do not so that
prospects for improvement can be explored.
VSM is a crucial qualitative lean tool for “ A diagnostic
waste reduction initiatives. It makes a TOOLS used to
visual map of the supply chain that covers assist in
the arrival of raw materials to the shipment identifying &
of finished goods to the customer, making eliminating
it very useful. It presents and provides a lot
waste ”
more data than a standard process map.
31
VSM Process Steps
The steps in the process of value
stream mapping are as shown. The
initial stage is to concentrate on one
product family that can be mapped.
The production situation's current
state map is then drawn after that.
In order to create a map and
record actual process timings, the
analysis begins at the customer's end
and moves upstream. This allows for
first-hand observation. The shop
floor can provide data for drawing
the material and information flows, The steps in the process
such as information on each process' of value stream mapping
cycle time, setup or changeover time, are as shown. The initial
availability, production batch sizes, stage is to concentrate on
personnel requirements, number of one product family that can
product variations, pack size, be mapped. The production
working time, and scrap rate. situation's current state
map is then drawn after
that.
32
Just-in-Time (JIT)
“ A management APPROACH in
production - producing and delivering
item as customers need it ”
33
JIT Characteristics Element
As previously stated, the terms JIT and lean system are frequently used
interchangeably in the literature. As a result, the JIT characteristics mirror
those of the lean system, as discussed in topic 3. These characteristics
are as follows:
JIT Elements
34
JIT Tools - Kanban
35
Withdrawal & Production
Kanban
The two forms of kanban used in manufacturing are
withdrawal and production kanban. At the user's location, the
withdrawal card's container is emptied. The item and quantity
the user of the item shall withdraw from the container are
specified on the withdrawal card. The producer should be
notified when a container is empty so that another item may be
supplied. The work order is the production kanban. The work
order specifies the amount, material, and delivery location for
the item that has to be manufactured. The general rules of using
kanban are as follow;
The 6 Rules of Kanban
36
JIT Tools - Jidoka
“ Autonomation or Smart Automation -
Stop production, so that production
never has to stop ”
The Japanese name for something that automatically stops a
procedure when something goes wrong is jidoka aka
autonomation. Jidoka gives employees the authority to stop
production so that problems can be discovered and corrected.
The founder of Toyota, Sakichi Toyoda, invented a loom that
automatically stopped when a thread broke in 1926. This is the
first time the Jidoka concept has been used.
Jidoka is a visual management system that helps employees
check the quality of their work at each station. This technique
also frees up employees from constantly attending machines,
enabling them to carry out other tasks.
Andon board
38
Supply Chain
The phrase supply chain refers to a series of operations that
begin with the procurement of raw materials for production,
continue into product manufacturing and distribution, and end
with customer satisfaction. Suppliers, manufacturers,
distributors, wholesalers, and retailers who provide products to
final consumers are members of a supply chain network.
Supply Chain
There are upstream and downstream activities in the supply
chain. The process of providing the resources required for
production is referred to as upstream activity. On the other
hand, downstream operations refer to the procedure of
distributing the finished product to the end customers.
Thus, supply chain management is the coordination of
linkages between upstream and downstream operations with
the aim of efficiently matching supply and demand.
Logistics Management
Logistic is a component of the larger supply chain. Logistics
management is the planning, execution, and control of the
effective flow and storage of raw materials, goods, services,
and information to meet customers' demands. Logistics
management systems cover transportation, warehousing and
inventory management.
The goal of logistic management is to achieve effective
operations through the coordination of activities associated
with material procurement, distribution, and storage. Logistics
management that is efficient and effective offers manufacturers
a competitive edge by lowering costs and enhancing customer
service.
39
The Elements of
Supply Chain Management
(SCM)
The four supply chain elements that work together to create
an economical and competitive business strategy are
purchasing, operations, distribution, and integration.
Purchasing
Purchasing is the process of acquiring goods or services
that are required for production. Purchasing activities should be
carefully planned in order to supply the best resources possible
for manufacturing processes. The procurement of resources
such as materials, tools, and equipment is a component of the
inventory management system.
Make-or -by
The manufacturing company's make-or-buy decision refers
to deciding whether to manufacture a part, or service in-house
or outsource it to an external supplier. Regardless of the option,
the supply chain's performance should be evaluated constantly.
Supplier performance, cost variation, production capacities, and
other related costs should be reviewed on a regular basis. The
figure on the next page, shows some factors to consider when
deciding whether to make an item in-house or outsource it.
Sourcing Strategies
The organization must decide its supply chain strategy
before sourcing goods and services from outside suppliers.
There are 5 strategies that a company can take into
consideration shown in the next figure.
40
Make-or-buy Decision
5 Sourcing Strategies
41
Sourcing Strategy - Supplier Assessment
Making decision on a supplier is challenging because each
has unique strengths and weaknesses. A company's
procurement policy may facilitate the selection and
management of suppliers. Nevertheless, the following are some
factors to consider when assessing the suppliers.
Technical Ability
Have the production capacity & flexible to technological
changes.
Production Capability
Able to produce in accordance to quantity & quality.
Reliability
Proven track record, stable and financially solid.
Supplier Location
Prefer a close location for lower delivery time & cost.
Price
Reasonable price that match the product quality.
Purchasing Terms
Credit terms and conditions.
42
Operation
Operation refers to the production process that converts
inputs into outputs in accordance to customer expectations. To
remain competitive, manufacturing organizations must
implement the lean production approach or JIT principle.
43
The ideal inventory management system balances supply,
inventory, and customer demand. Such a system is determined
by the ability to classify inventory items and keep accurate
inventory records. The 4 inventory management strategies that
an operations manager can employ are as follows:
44
Distribution
Companies are aware that transporting goods to and from
facilities can account for up to a quarter of the total cost of
production. Because of the high cost of distribution, businesses
must constantly evaluate their options. Trucking, railroads,
airfreight, waterways, and pipelines are the five main modes of
transportation.
Mode of Transportation
45
Warehousing
A warehouse is another important element of the distribution
management. The primary function of a warehouse is to hold
products until they are ready to be delivered to customers.
Operating a warehouse is frequently very expensive, and poor
management of the warehouse operations will even drive up
costs. The purpose of a warehouse is listed in the table below.
Warehouse Function
46
Integration
The integration of the supply chain from suppliers to
production, warehousing, distribution, and end to the customer
is wide-ranging. Inefficiencies, also known as waste in the lean
principle, could occur anywhere. This is due to the fact that
each member of the supply chain operates as a separate and
often very independent organization.
47
Integrated Supply Chain - Issues
49
The Benefits of Effective
Supply Chain Management
The supply chain receives a
great deal of attention because
it is an essential component of company strategy and the most
expensive activity in most businesses. The goal of effective
supply chain management is to create a network of suppliers
who are focused on providing the most value to the end user.
“ Competition is no longer
between enterprises, it is
the supply chains ”
Competition now exists between supply chains, which are
frequently global. Thus, creative planning and thorough
research are necessary for a successful strategic plan for
supply chain management. Effective supply chain management
has the following benefits;
50
References
51
References
Womack, J.P., Jones, D.T., & Roos, D. (1990). The Machine That
Changed The World. Macmillan.
52