Module 5 - Quality Gurus
Module 5 - Quality Gurus
Module 5 - Quality Gurus
QUALITY GURUS
TOTAL QUALITY MANAGEMENT (CIVCM 0425)
Submitted by
Rivero, Angelica (2018-00502)
Villanueva, Jan Aaron P. (2019-02084)
The theory of constraints states that bottleneck limits process performance. TOC identifies
constraints and restructures the rest of the organization around it by providing a ‘five-focusing
steps’ methodology. These 5 steps, also called the Process of On-going Improvement (POOGI),
are as follows:
The process must be reapplied, perhaps many times. It is very important not to let inertia
become a constraint.
1
WALTER SHEWART (1891-1967)
Shewhart’s principle was that bringing a process into a state of statistical control would allow
the distinction between assignable and chance cause variations. By keeping the process in
control, it would be possible to predict future output and to economically manage processes.
This was the birth of the modern scientific study of process control.
2
W. EDWARDS DEMING (1900-1993)
General Application in
Original Stage Description
Management
Detection of problem and its causes
Design Plan
which arose in product design
Collection of correct data about the
Production Do problem and sorting it statistically.
Implementation of the procedure.
3
Evaluation of the results after the
implementation of procedure. If the
Sales Check
target is not achieved, going back to
‘plan’ and ‘do’ is a must.
The transition to another cycle with
Research Action planning an improvement to the
previous one.
was first presented in 1950 in Japan after World War II. It illustrated Shewart’s concept that
productivity and quality improved as variation reduced. According to Deming, there are 7
deadly sins which affect quality such as: (1) lack of constancy of purpose, (2) emphasis of
short-term profits, (3) over-reliance on performance appraisals, (4) mobility of management,
(5) overemphasis on visible figures, (6) excessive medical costs for employee healthcare, (7)
excessive costs for warranty and legal costs.
4
were already doing their best with the systems that the management provided. However, doing
one’s best without direction led to poor results. “A bad system will beat a good person every
time.”
It is a set of management practices to help companies increase their quality and productivity,
making it a core concept in implementing total quality management.
5
Permit Pride of Remove the barriers that rob hourly workers and people
12 Workmanship in the management of their rights to pride of
workmanship.
A workforce rooted in knowledge will always enable an
13 Encourage Education
organization to be competitive.
A clearly defined commitment by the top management
to constantly improve quality and productivity and
Top Management’s
14 reinforcement of obligations to implement all these
Commitment
principles is always beneficial to the workforce and the
organization.
6
JOSEPH M. JURAN (1904-2008)
Questioning which aspect of the quality trilogy is most critical is similar to asking which leg
of a stool is the most important. The stool (and the quality system) cannot function effectively.
without all three. Juran defined quality as “fitness for use” and developed the concept of cost
of quality.
Quality Trilogy
The Juran Trilogy, published in 1986, identified and was accepted worldwide as the basis for
quality management. Juran developed the idea of the quality trilogy to bring continuous
improvement in the process. The elements of the trilogy are quality planning, quality
improvement and quality control. Every element of the trilogy is equally important as quality
will not be guaranteed if an aspect of the trilogy is missing.
7
Develop process features. Measure actual performance Provide remedies, prove that
the remedies are effective
Establish process controls, Interpret the difference. Deal with the resistance to
and transfer the resulting Take action on the change and control to hold
plans to the operating forces difference. the gains
1. Build awareness regarding the need and offer an opportunity for improvement
2. Set goals for improvements
3. Organize paths to reach the goals (establish a quality council, identify problems, select
projects, appoint teams, designate facilitators, etc.)
4. Provide training
5. Carry out projects to solve problems
6. Report progress
7. Give recognition
8. Communicate results
9. Keep score
10. Maintain momentum by making annual improvements part of the regular systems and
processes of the company
Cost of Quality
Juran developed the concept of cost of quality. The cost of quality (or the cost of not getting
it right the first time) should be recorded and analyzed and classified into failure costs,
appraisal costs and prevention costs. Juran divided quality costs into good and bad:
8
1. Good Quality Costs – costs of prevention
a. Prevention Costs - are those costs or activities that are specifically designed to
prevent poor quality in products.
b. Appraisal Cost - are associated with any activity specifically designed to measure,
inspect, evaluate, or audit products to assure conformance to quality requirements.
2. Bad Quality Costs – costs which could be avoided if the products and processes were
perfect.
a. Internal Failure Costs - are any cost incurred due to the failure of a product to
meet a customer requirement where the non-conformance was detected prior to
shipment to the customer.
b. External Failure Costs - Costs are any cost incurred due to the failure of a product
to meet a customer requirement where the non-conformance was detected after
shipment to the customer.
Pareto Principle
9
ARMAN FEIGENBAUM
Feigenbaum’s philosophy is summarized in his “Three Steps to Quality,” which has been
described below.
1. Quality leadership
• This is evident when the management emphasizes on sound planning rather than
reacting to failures. The management must maintain a constant focus and lead the
quality effort.
3. Organizational commitment
10
Key Elements of Feigenbaum’s Philosophy of Quality Control
1. Total quality control refers to a system of integrating quality development, maintenance and
improvement efforts in an organization that will enable engineering, marketing, production,
and service to function at optimal economic levels while achieving customer satisfaction.
2. The “control” aspect of quality control should involve setting quality standards, appraising
performances relative to these standards, taking corrective action when the standards are not
met and planning for improvement in the standards.
3. Factors that affect quality can be divided into two major categories—technological and
human. The human factor is the more critical factor.
4. Operating quality costs can be divided into four categories: Prevention costs, appraisal costs,
internal failure costs and external failure costs.
11
PHILIP B. CROSBY (1926-2001)
He established the Absolutes of Quality Management, which states that the only performance
standard (that makes sense) is zero defects, and the basic elements of improvement.
Zero Defects:
The Zero Defects theory states that there is no existence of waste in a project. Waste refers to
anything that is unproductive i.e., processes, tools, employees, etc. Anything that is not adding
any value to a project should be eliminated, thereby leading to the elimination of waste.
Eliminating waste leads to process improvement and consequently lowers costs. The zero
defects theory is the concept of doing it right the first time to avoid cost and time spent later in
the process of project management.
According to Crosby, zero defects was not just a manufacturing principle but an all-pervading
philosophy that ought to influence every decision that we make. Managerial notions of defects
being unacceptable and everyone doing ‘things right the first time’ are reinforced.
The essence of Crosby’s teachings is contained in what he calls the “four absolutes of quality.”
Crosby defined Four Absolutes of Quality Management, which are:
1. The First Absolute: The definition of quality is conformance to requirements, not goodness.
12
management must insist that they must be met every time. You want employees to do
it (the requirements) right the first time, you must have to tell them what it (the
requirements) is.
• Prevention is better than correction, detection, or appraisal. In the whole process, you
need to analyze what can go wrong and then take preventive action. By that, it can
minimize the error, damage, and problem.
• Here Crosby is stating that nothing less than perfect quality must be the aim. Setting
targets below 100% is the start of downward.
• This measure looks for the cost of failure—when something is done incorrectly and
does not meet the requirements. Most failure costs (PONC) are caused when
management does not set achievable requirements and does not insist that all employees
take requirements seriously. Some PONC examples might be as follows:
• a. When a component must be reworked to the design requirements because the
manufacturer has made an error.
• b. When a builder or remodeler must redo work that does not meet the buyer’s
requirements.
• c. When a hotel room is unclean, and the customer cancels his or her stay as a result.
Crosby’s 14 Steps:
13
To provide a method of raising personal concern among
the personnel in the company towards the conformance
5 Quality awareness
of the product and service, and the reputation of the
company on the issue of quality.
To provide a systematic method of resolving the
6 Corrective action
problems identified through actions taken previously.
To examine the various activities that must be conducted
7 Zero defects planning in preparation for formally launching the zero defects
program.
To define the type of training that supervisors need to
8 Supervisor training actively carry out their roles in the quality improvement
program.
To create an event that will let all employees realize,
9 Zero defects day through personal experience, that there has been a
change.
To turn pledges and commitments into action by
encouraging individuals
10 Goal setting
to establish improvement goals for themselves and their
groups.
To give individual employees a method of
communicating to the
11 Error cause removal management, the situations that make it difficult for
employees to meet the pledge to
improve.
12 Recognition To appreciate those who participate
To bring together professionals in the domain of quality
for planned
13 Quality councils
communication on a regular basis with the workforce and
management alike.
To emphasize that the quality improvement program
14 Do it over again
never ends.
14
KAORU ISHIKAWA (1915-1989)
Ishikawa was the first quality guru to emphasize the importance of the “internal customer,” the
next person in the production process. The essential idea is to enable employees of all
departments to come together to solve problems. Staff members must consider themselves as
service providers. Otherwise, the staff members are in constant struggle with line management,
and nothing gets done.
He is best known for: the Ishikawa diagram; Seven basic quality tools; Quality circles and
Company-wide quality control.
1. Ishikawa Diagram
He is well known for coming up with the concept for the fishbone-shaped diagram, known as
the Ishikawa or cause and effect diagram, used to improve teams’ performance in determining
potential root causes of their quality problems.
15
1.1 Types of Ishikawa Diagrams:
16
d. Simple fishbone
• The 3M diagram, also known as the 'man, machine, material' fishbone, organizes
information into three categories: manpower, machinery, and materials. It is most used
in the manufacturing industry. For instance, it could be used in a food processing plant
to determine why product quality has declined.
Ishikawa said that seven basic tools were “indispensable for quality control.” These are Pareto
analysis, fishbone diagrams, stratification, tally charts, histograms, scatter diagrams and
control charts. Ishikawa argued that with these tools, managers and staff could tackle and solve
the quality problems facing them.
17
Stratification A technique that separates data gathered from a variety of
7 sources so that patterns can be seen (some lists replace
stratification with flowchart or run chart).
3. Quality Circles
Quality Circle is a small group of employees working in the same area or doing the same job.
This group regularly meets for one hour every week to identify and collectively resolve the
problems in the work area. They use Seven Basic Quality tools to understand the causes and
propose solutions.
18
Some of the key elements of his philosophy are:
1. Quality begins with education and ends with education
2. The first step in quality is to know the customers’ requirements
3. The ideal state of quality control occurs when inspection is no longer necessary
4. Remove the root cause, not the symptoms
5. Quality control is the responsibility of all workers and all divisions
6. Do not confuse means with the objectives
7. Put quality first and set your sights on long-term profits
8. Market is the entrance and exit of quality
9. Top management must not show anger when facts are presented by subordinates
10. Ninety-five percent of problems in a company can be solved with simple tools for
analysis and problem-solving
11. Data without dispersion information (variability) are false data
19
DR. GENICHI TAGUCHI
Robust Design
It is used to find the appropriate control factor levels in a design or a process to make the system
less sensitive to variations in uncontrollable noise factors.
Design of Experiments
It is an engineering approach that focuses on developing robust design that enables products to
perform under varying conditions. It is used to quickly gather information on the effects of
control factors on product performance. It can also be used to determine the interaction between
control and noise factors. The 5 steps in Taguchi’s approach include:
This is a necessary first step in any application. The brainstorming should include
individuals with first-hand knowledge of the project.
• Determine what one is after (cost, supplies, etc.) and how to evaluate it. When
there is more than one criterion of evaluation, one needs to decide how each
criterion is to be weighted and combined for overall evaluation.
• Identify all influencing factors and those to be included in the study.
20
• Determine the factor levels.
• Determine the noise factor and the condition of repetitions.
2. Designing experiments
Using the factors and levels determined in the brainstorming session, the experiments
can be designed and the method carrying them out can now be established.
It is used to determine the losses suffered by the user when the product performance deviates
from its real performance. It is represented by the equation:
L = C(X − T)2
C = a cost constant,
21
X = actual average value of quality characteristic and
The smaller the value of this social loss, the more desirable the product is. This theory also
suggests that quality losses vary as the square of the deviation from target.
The loss described in this theory can be categorized into three types namely:
• Loss incurred by the company, such as, in terms of increased scrap, rework and
warranty costs, damage to the company’s reputation and loss of market share.
• Loss incurred by the consumers, such as, in terms of short product life, increased
maintenance and repair costs.
• Loss incurred by society in general, such as, in terms of pollution, safety, etc.
22
DR. SHINGO SHIGEO (1909-1990)
It is a system for dramatically reducing the time it takes to complete equipment changeovers.
SMED was developed to reduce the fixed costs associated with the setup and changeover of
dies. The basic elements driving the SMED concept is to reduce the setup time of dies, which
directly results in smaller batch sizes for parts. According to Shigeo, the simple steps in
achieving a quick setup and changeover of the dies are:
23
Theory of Zero Quality Control (ZQC)
• 100 per cent inspections done at the source instead of sampling inspections.
• Immediate feedback from successive quality checks and self-checks.
• Poka-yoke designed manufacturing devices.
24
MASAAKI IMAI
As a consultant, he assisted more than 200 foreign and joint-venture companies in Japan in
fields including recruiting, executive development, personnel management and organizational
studies. Between 1976 and 1986 Masaaki Imai was President of the Japanese Federation of
Recruiting and Employment Agency Associations.
Masaaki Imai is the Founder of Kaizen Institute which was established in Switzerland in 1985
to help companies implement the practice of kaizen and the various systems and tools known
today as Lean Management. Today Kaizen Institute Consulting Group (KICG) is the leading
global operational excellence consultancy with offices across the globe.
That same year, he published his book on Japanese management; Kaizen: The Key to Japan’s
Competitive Success. This best-selling book has since been translated into 14 languages. Other
books by Imai include 16 Ways to Avoid Saying No, Never Take Yes for an Answer and
Gemba Kaizen published in 1997. The Kaizen Institute operates in over 22 countries and
continues to act as an enabler to companies to accomplish their manufacturing, process, and
service goals.
Kaizen
Over 30 years ago, Masaaki Imai sat down to pen the groundbreaking book ‘Kaizen: The Key
to Japan’s Competitive Success’ (McGraw Hill). Through this book, the term KAIZEN was
introduced in the western world. Today KAIZEN is recognized worldwide as an essential pillar
of an organization’s long-term competitive strategy. Since introducing this term as a systematic
approach to business improvement, companies that implement KAIZEN have continually
yielded superior results.
25
The English translation is, broadly speaking, continuous improvement. ‘Kai’ means ‘change’
and ‘zen’ means ‘for the better’. It is a philosophy that helps to ensure maximum quality, the
elimination of waste, and improvements in efficiency, both in terms of equipment and work
procedures.
The concept of kaizen encompasses a wide range of ideas. It involves making the work
environment more efficient and effective by creating a team atmosphere, improving everyday
procedures, ensuring employee engagement, and making a job more fulfilling, less tiring, and
safer.
These five principles lead to three major outcomes: elimination of waste (also referred to
as economic efficiency), good housekeeping, and standardization. Ideally, kaizen becomes so
ingrained in a company's culture that it eventually becomes natural to employees.
26