Sangdong 43-101 Tech Rep July16 Final-1
Sangdong 43-101 Tech Rep July16 Final-1
Sangdong 43-101 Tech Rep July16 Final-1
Prepared for
Almonty Industries
by
Qualified Person:
Adam Wheeler, B.Sc, M.Sc, C. Eng.
Mining Consultant
Cambrose Farm, Redruth
Cornwall, TR16 4HT
England.
E-mail: [email protected]
Technical Report on The Sangdong Project
TABLE OF CONTENTS
Page
1 SUMMARY ....................................................................................................................... 12
1.1 Introduction and Overview ....................................................................................... 12
1.2 Ownership ................................................................................................................ 12
1.3 Geology and Mineralisation ..................................................................................... 13
1.4 Database and Resource Estimation ........................................................................ 14
1.5 Mine Planning .......................................................................................................... 15
1.6 Mineral Processing .................................................................................................. 16
1.7 Infrastructure ............................................................................................................ 16
1.8 Mineral Resource and Reserve Estimates .............................................................. 17
1.9 Conclusions ............................................................................................................. 19
2 INTRODUCTION .............................................................................................................. 20
2.1 Introduction .............................................................................................................. 20
2.2 Terms of Reference ................................................................................................. 20
2.3 Sources of Information............................................................................................. 21
2.4 Units and Currency .................................................................................................. 21
3 RELIANCE ON OTHER PROJECTS ............................................................................... 21
4 PROPERTY DESCRIPTION AND LOCATION ................................................................ 22
5 ACCESSIBILITY, CLIMATE, LOCAL RESOURCES, INFRASTRUCTURE,
PHYSIOGRAPHY .................................................................................................................... 28
5.1 Topography, Elevation and Vegetation ................................................................... 28
5.2 Accessibility ............................................................................................................. 28
5.3 Climate ..................................................................................................................... 29
5.4 Local Resources ...................................................................................................... 30
5.5 Infrastructure ............................................................................................................ 30
6 PROJECT HISTORY ........................................................................................................ 32
6.1 Operations 1916-1949 ............................................................................................. 32
6.2 Korea Tungsten Mining Company Ltd. (KTMC) ...................................................... 32
6.3 Woulfe Mining Corporation (Oriental Minerals Inc) ................................................. 33
6.4 Historical Resource Estimates ................................................................................. 35
6.4.1 KTMC historical estimates ................................................................................... 35
6.4.2 Woulfe Mining Corporation .................................................................................. 36
7 GEOLOGICAL SETTING AND MINERALISATION ......................................................... 43
7.1 Regional Geology .................................................................................................... 43
7.2 Property Geology ..................................................................................................... 45
7.2.1 Taebaeksan Series .............................................................................................. 47
7.2.2 Yangdok Series ................................................................................................... 48
7.2.3 Great Limestone Series ....................................................................................... 49
July 2016
i
Technical Report on The Sangdong Project
July 2016
ii
Technical Report on The Sangdong Project
July 2016
iii
Technical Report on The Sangdong Project
July 2016
iv
Technical Report on The Sangdong Project
July 2016
v
Technical Report on The Sangdong Project
July 2016
vi
Technical Report on The Sangdong Project
LIST OF TABLES
Page
July 2016
vii
Technical Report on The Sangdong Project
July 2016
viii
Technical Report on The Sangdong Project
LIST OF FIGURES
Page
July 2016
ix
Technical Report on The Sangdong Project
Figure 14-12. Experimental and Model Variograms – WO3 Accumulation - MAIN ............. 112
Figure 14-13. Experimental and Model Variograms – WO3 – HW ....................................... 112
Figure 14-14. Density vs WO3 Scatterplot ............................................................................ 115
Figure 14-15. Histogram of Skarn Density Values ............................................................... 115
Figure 14-16. Plan of MAIN Zone – Resource Model WO3 .................................................. 118
Figure 14-17. Plan of MAIN Zone – True Thickness ............................................................ 119
Figure 14-18. Plan of MAIN Zone – Resource Classification ............................................... 121
Figure 14-19. Plan of HW Zone – WO3 Grades ................................................................... 123
Figure 14-20. Plan of HW Zone – Vertical Thickness .......................................................... 124
Figure 14-21. Plan of Section Reference System ................................................................ 125
Figure 14-22. Section 5, Showing Block Model Structure .................................................... 126
Figure 15-1. Stope Block Layout – F2 .................................................................................. 139
Figure 15-2. Stope Block Layout – HW ................................................................................ 139
Figure 16-1. Plan of All Levels, With Drillhole Data.............................................................. 143
Figure 16-2. Existing Level Development on Taebaek Level ............................................... 144
Figure 16-3. Existing Level Development on Sangdong Level ............................................ 144
Figure 16-4. Existing Level Development on the -1 Level .................................................... 145
Figure 16-5. Existing Level Development, Down To -1 Level .............................................. 145
Figure 16-6. Plan of Main Lode Hanging Wall Q .................................................................. 148
Figure 16-7. Stability Graph .................................................................................................. 150
Figure 16-8. Modified Rock Reinforcement Chart ................................................................ 151
Figure 16-9. Plan - Ore Reserve Zones By Mining Method ................................................. 154
Figure 16-10. Plan- F2 and F3 Reserve Areas .................................................................... 154
Figure 16-11. Plan and F2 and F3 Eastern Area ................................................................. 155
Figure 16-12. Section B-B Through F2-Halo-F3 Sequence ................................................. 155
Figure 16-13. Transition from CAF to MIP Stoping With Thickness Variation ..................... 156
Figure 16-14. Plan – Eastern Part of Main Zone Reserve Area ........................................... 157
Figure 16-15. Section C-C: Eastern Part of Main Zone Reserve Area ................................ 157
Figure 16-16. Plan – HW Zone Reserve Area off the -1 Level ............................................. 158
Figure 16-17. Section A-A: HW Zone Reserve Area ............................................................ 158
Figure 16-18. Plan of Western Part of HW Zone – With CAF Layout .................................. 159
Figure 16-19. Section Depicting Mechanised Inclined Panel Development......................... 160
Figure 16-20. Dilution Associated With Initial Drifting Phase of MIP Mining ........................ 161
Figure 16-21. Stoping Phases of MIP Mining ....................................................................... 162
Figure 16-22. CAF – Cross-Cut from Base Development .................................................... 164
Figure 16-23. CAF- Opening Up of Strike Drive ................................................................... 164
Figure 16-24. CAF – Development of Primary Panels ......................................................... 165
Figure 16-25. CAF – Hanging Wall Incline ........................................................................... 165
Figure 16-26. CAF – Next Lift By Access from Hanging Wall Incline ................................... 166
Figure 16-27. CAF – Overall Schematic ............................................................................... 166
July 2016
x
Technical Report on The Sangdong Project
APPENDICES
A Geostatistical Plots
B Resource Model Plans
C Resource Model Sections
D Glossary of Terms
July 2016
xi
Technical Report on The Sangdong Project
1 SUMMARY
This report was prepared to provide a Technical Report compliant with the provisions of National
Instrument 43-101 - Standards of Disclosure for Mineral Projects, (“NI 43-101”), and comprises a
review and summary of a Resource and Reserve Estimation for the Sangdong project, as of the end
of August 2015. The Sangdong deposit is considered as a potential underground operation, and is
located in the Gangwon Region of South Korea. The principal potential products are tungsten and
molybdenum.
This report was prepared by Adam Wheeler, at the request of Mr. N. Alves, Almonty Industries
(“Almonty”). Assistance and technical detail were supplied by the technical personnel of the
Sangdong Mining Corp. Adam Wheeler visited the Sangdong site on August 24th- 26th, 2015, along
with other Almonty technical personnel.
Previous underground mining at Sangdong took place at various times since the original discovery in
1916. The last main operation was from 1952 to closure in 1992.
This document describes an update to the previous 43-101 completed in December 2015, as a
consequence of the updated Phase 7 diamond drilling in 2016.
1.2 Ownership
Almonty Industries Inc (“Almonty”), is a corporation governed by the Canada Business Corporations
Act (the “CBCA”). Almonty trades on the TSX Venture Exchange (TSX-V) under the symbol “AII”.
Almonty acquired a 100% ownership interest in Woulfe Mining Corp. on September 10, 2015 by way
of a Plan of Arrangement. Woulfe Mining Corp., through its wholly owned subsidiary, Almonty Korea
Tungsten Corporation (AKT) [formerly Sangdong Mining Corporation], owns a 100% interest in the
Sangdong mine.
July 2016
12
Technical Report on The Sangdong Project
The Korean Peninsula is situated on the eastern margin of the North China– Korea Platform, a craton
composed of three blocks of Archean age, the Nangrim- Pyeongnam Block and the Gyeonggi and
Yeongnam Massifs that are separated by the northeast-trending Imjingang and Okcheon mobile belts
of Phanerozoic age. The Property is located within the Okcheon Belt.
The Sangdong Project is situated on the southern limb of the east-west orientated Triassic age
Hambaek Syncline. Cambro-Ordovician limestone, shale, and quartzite of the Chosun System
unconformably overlie the Pre-Cambrian Taebaeksan schist and gneiss.
The tungsten mineralisation of the Sangdong deposit is contained in several tabular, bedding-
conformable skarns in the Myobong Shale; these skarns have been interpreted as comprising
carbonate-bearing horizons that were altered and mineralised by fluids ascending from the underlying
Sangdong Granite. From uppermost to lowermost, these horizons are termed the Hangingwall, Main,
and Footwall horizons. Calc-silicate layers from 0.50 – 1.0m in thickness have developed on the
upper and lower contacts of the Main and Footwall horizons.
The Hangingwall horizon is located near the upper contact of the Myobong shale and varies in
thickness from approximately 5.0 to 30.0m because of the irregular boundary of the shale with the
overlying Pungchon Limestone. This zone has a strike length of about 600m and a down-dip extent
of about 800m. Above the most highly-altered portion of the Main horizon, the Hangingwall horizon is
not tabular, but extends steeply and irregularly into the overlying limestone. The base of the
Hangingwall horizon is approximately 14m above the upper contact of the Main horizon.
The Main horizon strikes about 100° and dips northerly between 15° and 30°. The strike length is in
excess of 1,300m and thickness varies from 5.0 – 6.0m. Alteration (skarnification) within the Main
horizon forms three concentric, roughly circular zones.
The Footwall horizons comprise multiple layers: Footwall Zone 1 (F1) normally occurs 1m below the
Main horizon and is approximately 2m thick; Footwall Zones 2 and 3 (F2, F3) are situated
approximately 35.0 to 40.0m below the Main horizon and are less than 1m thick. Further Footwall
Zones have been identified beyond F3 and are collectively referred to as F4.
The Oriental Minerals ownership period started in 2006. The total number of drillholes (surface and
underground) and total metres drilled at Sangdong before and after 2006 comprise 870/84,014m and
507/42,730m respectively.
July 2016
13
Technical Report on The Sangdong Project
The sample database, in the form of an Excel spreadsheet, is comprised of data from all available
surface and underground drillholes, over recent and historical drilling campaigns. This database has
separate tables for drillhole collars, survey data, assay data, RQD, lithology data, drillhole recovery,
geotechnical logging, density measurements, structural orientation and mineralised intersections.
The resultant spacing of samples with these different historical campaigns has ended up being fairly
sporadic, with sections spaced at distances from 30m to 100m. Most of the surface holes are vertical,
as are the very deep underground holes. Most of the underground holes are angled up or down so as
to give good intersections with the overall mineralised structures, which generally dip at
approximately 25o.
The database also included physical string and wireframe data, for previous interpretations, mined-out
limits, surface and underground topography. This data was also augmented by information from the
different resource estimation studies over the last four years: primarily from the Tetra-Tech and AMC
consultancy companies.
An updated mineral resource estimation was completed, during July 2016, by the Qualified Person.
This estimation employed a three-dimensional block modelling approach, using CAE Datamine
software. Two main resource blocks models were developed. The relatively thick hanging wall (HW)
zone was modelled using a conventional block model structure. All of the other skarn zones were
modelled using the initial generation of 3D digital terrain models (DTMs) for the zone centre-points,
onto which thicknesses and grade-accumulations were estimated, using ordinary kriging. This
enabled a 3D block model of all these zones to be developed – with columnar sub-blocks
representing the vertical in-situ thickness of the mineralised skarn bodies. Density values were also
estimated from sample measurements.
The models generated were derived from the interpretation of skarn zones, as generated by SMC
geologists, with additional intersection checks and refinements by the QP. The defined skarn
intersections have been based on a lithological skarn identification, as well as 0.1% WO3 cut-off
grade. Additional mined-out limits for the principal skarn structures were applied, as well as a 50m
remnant surface pillar below the surface topography.
In the resource estimation, a minimum thickness of 2.2m was applied, such that thinner blocks were
diluted to 2.2m.
Resource class categories were set, such that indicated resources, for the Main and F beds, only
used assay data from drillholes after 2006, along with drilling grid criteria.
July 2016
14
Technical Report on The Sangdong Project
The majority of the ore zones to be mined are relatively shallow dipping, with dips between 20° and
30°, so ore will not naturally flow by gravity on the footwall. In the A-Z Feasibility Study, the methods
proposed were inclined panel (IP) mining, to be applied in thick orebody areas, with panels that would
be mined in different sections; and up-dip panel mining (UP), which would be applied in narrow areas
with slushers and hand-held drilling equipment.
For this present study, it was decided not to rely on hand-held drilling equipment and slushers.
Instead, methods applied would be planned for the use of mechanized mobile diesel powered mining
equipment in all areas. Based on this requirement and the latest understanding of the orebody
geometry and mining areas, and evaluation of the resources, including in-situ thickness variations, it
was decided to apply two proposed mining methods, as summarised below:
• Mechanized Inclined Panel mining (MIP) – areas where the thickness less than 3 metres.
• Cut-and-Fill (CAF) – for areas where the thickness is greater than 3 metres.
A mine plan was developed, based on the application of these stoping methods. Stope blocks were
laid out as plan perimeters, bounded by horizontal parts on each level, where the footwall contact of
each zone cut through level's reference elevation. In general, most stope blocks were limited to a
maximum of 100m along strike. Stope blocks were only laid out in those parts of each zone
predominantly demarcated as containing indicated resources. Any inferred resource blocks within
stope outlines were treated as planned dilution with mineralised waste, with any grades greater than
0.2% WO3 set to 0.2%.
Mining will use almost exclusively mobile diesel-powered equipment. All newly stoped areas will be
backfilled with paste backfill.
In the evaluation of stope blocks, additional unplanned mining factors of 5% dilution and 5% losses
were also applied. Maps of maximum span distances have previously been prepared in a
geotechnical study by Turner Mining and Geotechnical Pty Ltd (TMG) in 2014. These maximum span
properties were superimposed onto the laid-out stopes in each skarn zone, so that higher cut-offs
were applied to those zones requiring higher support costs. The applicable cut-offs varied from
0.23% - 0.36% WO3.
Additional level development has been laid out so as to enable access to the identified reserve areas,
and to allow truck haulage from these new stoping areas. Main access to the underground mine will
use the old entry portals on the Sangdong and Taebak levels as well as a new portal on the -1 level,
that will enable ore haulage out from the mine directly into the valley, on approximately the same
elevation as the intended mill position.
July 2016
15
Technical Report on The Sangdong Project
Processing will utilize crushing, grinding (rod and ball mills) and flotation for scheelite concentration.
The processing plant will treat the run-of-mine (ROM) ore from underground at a nominal feed rate of
1,920 tpd. A new processing plant will be constructed, based on the valley, to the south of the
Sangdong adit entrance.
A marketable tungsten concentrate grade of 65% WO3 will be produced. Processing plant recoveries,
based on metallurgical testwork, are estimated to average 81%. The main process steps for treating
the Sangdong ore are primary, secondary and tertiary crushing and stockpiling; grinding; flotation
divided into two (2) sub-circuits (sulphide flotation and tungsten flotation); thickening; filtration and
packaging section; a waste water treatment facility; and services section
The processing plant will require a manpower complement of 36 personnel of which 8 are
management, technical staff and supervision.
The plant design will encompass crushing, grinding and flotation for scheelite concentration. In the
future, test work will also investigate the recovery of molybdenum into a sulphide flotation concentrate,
ahead of the scheelite flotation circuit.
1.7 Infrastructure
Existing infrastructure to be used includes the access road to site; site roads; powerline and stepdown
substation, potable water supply and communications and internet service. It also includes some old
KTMC buildings that will be reused and the KTMC slope support at the zone of the plant and water
treatment plant.
To return the mine to operation the existing Sangdong infrastructure will be reconfigured and
supplemented by new facilities as required. To accommodate the new waste storage facility the
existing buildings at the Sangdong portal level will be demolished to allow for placement of waste from
mine development. New site infrastructure will be built in the valley, on the footprint of old KTMC
installations. It will include a new mine/administration building, assay laboratory, warehouse,
maintenance shop, recreational facilities for employees, fuel storage, potable and process water
supply and water and sewage treatment facilities. The mine backfill plant will be placed at Sangdong
Terrace.
The surface services and general administration manpower complement will total 27 personnel.
July 2016
16
Technical Report on The Sangdong Project
The evaluation work was carried out and prepared in compliance with Canadian National Instrument
43-101, and the mineral resources in this estimate were calculated using the Canadian Institute of
Mining, Metallurgy and Petroleum (CIM), CIM Standards on Mineral Resources and Reserves,
Definitions and Guidelines prepared by the CIM Standing Committee on Reserve Definitions and
adopted by CIM Council May, 2014. The current in-situ resource estimation is shown in Table 1-1.
Notes
. Bed models diluted to a minimum thickness of 2.2m
. Resources shown are inclusive of reserves
. 50m surface pillar material removed
. Indicated HW material based on all samples,
with a maximum search of 35m x 50m (along-strike x down-dip)
. Indicated material in all other beds are based on only PO-P6 samples,
with a maximum search of 50m, and sample grid required
. Inferred material based on all samples, up to a maximum search of :
105m x 150m in HW
100m x 100m in all other beds
July 2016
17
Technical Report on The Sangdong Project
These resources have been used in the development of a mine plan. To start the mine operations,
the blocked-out stopes have enabled a reserve evaluation to be made, as summarised in the table
below.
Probable Reserves
Tonnes WO3
Kt %
HW 3,759 0.47
MAIN/F1 1,328 0.34
F2 1,495 0.48
F3 1,249 0.46
F4 65 0.33
TOTAL 7,896 0.45
Notes
. All reserves have a probable category
. WO3 Cut-offs applied:
0.36% Max Spans <=3m
0.28% Max Spans >3m <=6m
0.23% Max Spans +6m
. Level restrictions:
. Down to -1 level (633m) for the non-HW zones
. Mining Factors applied
. Minimum thickness = 2.2m
. Unplanned dilution = 5%
. Unplanned losses = 5%
July 2016
18
Technical Report on The Sangdong Project
1.9 Conclusions
a) The Phase 7 drilling completed in 2016, which was focussed on the HW zone, has helped to
verify the old KTMC data available in the HW zone. This has helped to support the use of both
KTMC and Phase 0 – Phase 7 drillhole data for the estimation of indicated HW resources.
b) The updated Feasibility Study calculations have identified Probable Reserves of 7.9 Mt, which
with an assumed mill capacity of 640 ktpa, will sustain a mining operation for approximately 12
years.
c) Based on the forecast operating parameters and capital and operating costs estimates for the
Sangdong project, the returns from the project are very positive and the project economics are
extremely robust to potential reasonably expected variances from the base case assumptions.
The mine will employ 170 people, including mine contractors.
d) The very large inferred resource base represents a very large source of potential future reserves,
as more exploration drilling can be completed.
e) There are more areas of the deposit down-dip and north-east which have not been currently
evaluated.
f) Most of the deposit has not yet been delineated off at depth.
July 2016
19
Technical Report on The Sangdong Project
2 INTRODUCTION
2.1 Introduction
This Technical report was prepared in compliance with the provisions of National Instrument 43-101 -
Standards of Disclosure for Mineral Projects, (“NI 43-101”), and comprises a Resource and Reserve
estimate for the Sangdong project, as of the end of July 2016. It represents an update to the previous
43-101 completed by Adam Wheeler in December 2015.
This report was prepared by Adam Wheeler, at the request of Mr. N. Alves, of Almonty Industries.
Assistance and technical detail were supplied by the technical personnel at Sangdong, which is a
wholly owned by Almonty Korea Tungsten Corp (AKT), and in which Almonty has a 100% ownership
interest. Adam Wheeler visited the Sangdong site from August 24th-26th, 2015.
The resource and reserve estimation work was commissioned by Almonty Industries, and completed
by Adam Wheeler, an independent mining consultant.
Adam Wheeler was retained by Almonty to provide an independent Technical Report on the Mineral
Resources and Reserves at Sangdong, and is considered current as of July 31st, 2016. This
Technical Report has been prepared to be compliant with the provisions of National Instrument 43-
101 - Standards of Disclosure for Mineral Projects (“NI 43-101”).
The Qualified Person responsible for the preparation of this report is Adam Wheeler (C. Eng, Eur.Ing),
an independent mining consultant. In addition to a site visit, Adam Wheeler carried out a study of all
relevant parts of the available literature and documented results concerning the project and held
discussions with technical personnel of Sangdong, who have been doing project development work at
Sangdong since 2012.
The purpose of the current report is to provide an independent Technical Report and update of the
resources for the Sangdong project, in conformance with the standards required by NI 43-101 and
Form 43-101F1. The estimate of mineral resources contained in this report conforms to the CIM
Mineral Resource and Mineral Reserve definitions (May 2014) referred to in NI 43-101.
July 2016
20
Technical Report on The Sangdong Project
In conducting this study, Adam Wheeler has relied on reports and information connected with the
Sangdong project. The information on which this report is based includes the references shown in
Section 27.
Adam Wheeler has made all reasonable enquiries to establish the completeness and authenticity of
the information provided, and a final draft of this report was provided to Almonty, along with a written
request to identify any material errors or omissions prior to finalisation.
All measurement units used in this report are metric, and currency is expressed in US Dollars unless
stated otherwise. Costs derived from Republic of Korea Won were converted at a rate of $US 1 =
Won 1180.
Adam Wheeler has reviewed and analysed data provided by Almonty and has drawn his own
conclusions therefrom. Adam Wheeler has not performed any independent exploration work, drilled
any holes or carried out any sampling and assaying.
While exercising all reasonable diligence in checking and confirmation, Adam Wheeler has relied
upon the data presented by Almonty, and previous reports on the property in formulating his opinions.
Title to the mineral lands for the Sangdong property has not been confirmed by Adam Wheeler and
Adam Wheeler offers no opinion as to the validity of the exploration or mineral title claimed.
July 2016
21
Technical Report on The Sangdong Project
The deposit is located at Sangdong in the south-eastern Korean Peninsula, about 170km east south
east of the capital city of Seoul, 20km southwest of Taebaek and 55km south east of Wonju, in
Yongweol County of Kangwon-Do Province (37°08’N Latitude and 128°50’E Longitude) as shown in
Figures 4.1 and 4.2. The main adit is at the head of a short, south-flowing tributary of the Oktong-
ch’on (river).
July 2016
22
Technical Report on The Sangdong Project
The Property comprises 12 Mining Rights with an aggregate area of 3,173ha, held in the name of Se
Woo. The licence areas are shown in Figure 4.3 and details of the licences in Table 4.1.
July 2016
23
Technical Report on The Sangdong Project
July 2016
24
Technical Report on The Sangdong Project
The existing exploration and mining permits cover all the active exploration and mining areas
discussed in this Technical Report. The exploration permits provide the right to carry out all
contemplated exploration activities with no additional permitting required. Exploration permits are
subject to exploration rights usage fees (a fixed annual charge), and applicable taxes. Mining permits
are subject to mining-right usage fees (a fixed annual charge), mineral resource compensation fees,
and applicable mineral resource taxes. The renewal of mining permits and extending mining depth
and boundaries occur in the ordinary course of business as long as mineral resources exist, are
defined, the required documentation is submitted, and the government resources royalties are paid.
Mining permits are subject to mining-right usage fees (a fixed annual charge), mineral resource
compensation fees, and applicable taxes. The renewal of mining permits and new applications for
extending boundaries occur in the ordinary course of business as long as mineral resources exist, are
defined, the required documentation is submitted, and the government resources taxes are paid. The
mining permits give the right to carry out full mining and mineral processing operations in conjunction
July 2016
25
Technical Report on The Sangdong Project
with safety and environmental certificates. Approval for installation of mining facilities (Sangdong
Portal, Woulfe Portal, Taeback Portal and Baekun Portal) have been issued by East Mine Registration
Office of the Ministry of Trade, Industry & Energy. Environmental certificates (Temporary Forest Land
Use) have been issued by the Department of Environmental Forest of Yeongwol County. There are
no known or recognized environmental issues that might preclude or inhibit a mining operation in this
area.
Surface rights for mining purposes are not included in the permits but AKT have leased some of land
use for mining and processing plant activities by effecting payment of a purchase fee based on the
appraised value of the land. The rest of the necessary lands for mining, waste disposal and
processing plant activities (processing plant, offices and accommodations etc.) were guaranteed by
Yeongwol County, through written official documentation. There are no significant factors and risks
that may affect access, title, or the right or ability to perform work on the Property known at this time.
A summary of the lease areas is shown in Figure 4-4.
Korea has an established Mining Industry Act which defines the mining rights guaranteed by the
government of Korea.
Korea has a 10% Value Added Tax (VAT) on sales of concentrates and on articles such as 1) supply
of goods or services by entrepreneurs, 2) importation of goods. However there is non-tariff and VAT-
free in case of concentrates exportation to overseas. Income tax rate is a maximum of 22%. There is
local resource and facility tax payable to the local government at a rate of 0.5% of the value of mined
minerals. There is no VAT surtax on sales.
Except for relatively small areas in the south in the main river valley and a few small areas of
vegetable farms, the Sangdong property is on government land. On government (i.e. non private)
land, an environmental security bond must be lodged. On private land, access must be negotiated
with the individual landowner(s). In the case of mining, there is no formal mediated process for land
disturbance, and the purchase or lease of the surface rights would have to be negotiated with the
landowner(s).
July 2016
26
Technical Report on The Sangdong Project
Environmental certificates have been issued by the Department of Environmental Forest of Yeongwol
County and there are no known or recognized environmental issues that might preclude or inhibit a
mining operation in this area. Some major land purchases may be required in the future for mine
infrastructure purposes (processing plant, waste disposal and offices). There are no significant
factors and risks that may affect access, title, or the right or ability to perform work on the Property
known at this time.
There are no Royalties imposed on minerals by government agencies in South Korea. The 2% net
smelter royalty (NSR) retained on the Project in South Korea from the vendor, Se Woo Mining Co.Ltd.
(Se Woo), as part of the Sangdong Acquisition Agreement with Oriental Minerals Inc. was purchased
for CDN$3.5M.
July 2016
27
Technical Report on The Sangdong Project
The Sangdong area is in the central portion of the most rugged part of the Taebaek-san in one of the
deep valleys running north-south on the southern slopes of Baegun Mountain (Baegun-san 1,428m
amsl). The highest outcrop of the Sangdong orebodies is about 800m amsl, the main adit is at about
650m amsl, and the old mine offices will be located on the floor of the valley at 550m amsl.
Many peaks in the Sangdong area, e.g. Sunkyeong-san (1,152mamsl), Maebong-san (1,282mamsl)
to the SE and Jang-san (1,408mamsl) consist of Jangsan Quartzite and form long narrow ridges
paralleling the axis of the Baegun-san Syncline. These peaks are separated by V shaped valleys in
general, forming a dendritic pattern. However, the dominant trend of the valleys in the Sangdong
mine area is north-south.
Despite the terrain, access is well developed countrywide and a paved road passes within several
hundred metres of the old mill site and forestry roads traverse the Property. The highest local peak in
the range is Taebaek-san, about 8km southeast of the Property.
Vegetation in the Taebaek district is dominated by dwarf pines. Thick dense undergrowth, consisting
of scrubby thorny vegetation develops in June after the first heavy rains, making access very difficult
off walking tracks. The scrub browns and dies out rapidly in October-November at the onset of winter.
5.2 Accessibility
The Sangdong Project is located approximately 175km east-southeast of Seoul, in Yongweol County
of Kangwon-Do Province on the eastern side of South Korea. Sangdong is easily reached by paved
roads from all directions and is a 3.5hr drive from Seoul. The project is well served by the Yeondong
Expressway 50 from Seoul, the Jungang Expressway 55 from Wonju, Highway 38 from Jechon to
Yongweol then Highway 31 to Sangdong. The road journey takes approximately 3.5hrs. A bus
journey from Dong Seoul Bus Terminal typically takes 4hrs to Taebaek. Taebaek (population of over
50,000) is located 25km to the east of Sangdong by paved road and is an established coal mining
town with most modern facilities, including reasonable accommodation facilities and some mining
equipment support
Access throughout the Sangdong Project area is generally very good, with sealed roads forming a
network throughout the district, together with numerous unsealed farm tracks up the river valleys.
Sangdong, a small rural village with a population of approximately 600, is situated 2km to the south of
the mine.
July 2016
28
Technical Report on The Sangdong Project
The national rail network system services the region. The train journey takes 4.5hrs to Taebaek from
Seoul Station. The closest railhead is situated at Yemi 5km north of Sangdong.
5.3 Climate
The Meteorological weather station nearest to the Project site is Yeongwol Weather Station. The
Project experiences seasonal climatic conditions and at Yeongwol can be described as cloudy with a
distinct hot wet season followed by a cold dry season during the winter.
The wet season from June to August, is hot and humid and 75% of the annual rainfall occurs during
this period. Daily temperatures average 27°C and rise to a maximum of approximately 30°C. Daily
thunderstorms are common in August and the occasional “typhoon” may occur in coastal areas.
During September to October, the climate becomes cooler, with daily temperatures reaching 20°C.
The winter “dry” season lasts from October to March, with snow falling from December to February.
Freezing temperatures occur during this time, occasionally reaching as low as -30°C. Mild
temperatures in the spring produce slush and muddy conditions on unsealed roads from March to
April.
The average relative humidity is 68.10%, the maximum relative humidity is approximately 80.81% in
July and the minimum relative humidity approximately 55.46% in April.
The annual average wind velocity is 1.46m/sec and the range of the monthly average wind velocity is
1.20-1.95m/sec according to the observation data for a recent 10-year interval (1997-2006) in the
Yeongwol area. The maximum average wind velocity is 2.34m/sec when the main wind direction is
south-westerly.
The average monthly daylight hours in the Yeongwol area are 175.5. The average daylight hours for
the month of March are 209.7 hours, representing the maximum daylight hours in the year.
On average there are 129 freezing days each year, 112 days of rainfall and 106 frost days. Of these
days, on average, each year there are 105 overcast days, 92 clear days, 29 foggy days, 26 snow
days and 19 thunderstorm days.
July 2016
29
Technical Report on The Sangdong Project
The former Sangdong Mine was a major employer in the area, but ceased operations in 1992. It is
therefore unlikely that a skilled mining workforce adequate for a new mining operation still exists in the
immediate area. Workers with the required skills and provided training would be available locally and
from elsewhere within Korea.
Potential sources of surface run-off water supply for future mining and milling operations exist in local
streams and rivers. There are also reasonable sources of groundwater contained in the limestones
overlying the tungsten skarn.
Sites adequate for the co-disposal of tailings and waste rock exist within the Property in the immediate
area west of the former mine. There are extensive deposits of limestone available on the Sangdong
Project area for use as neutralising/buffer media for acid generating materials as well as aggregate.
The Pungchon Limestone overlies the tungsten skarn of the Myobong Slate. It would provide useful
coarse rock aggregate for use in a “french drain” type arrangement at the base of the dry stack waste-
tailings storage facility. It could also be potentially mined for the production of lime in a cement
manufacturing plant.
There is no local logging industry within the property. The forest is administered by the Youngwol
Forest Service. There is only minor agricultural land within the Property and it is understood that local
residents are allowed by the government to grow crops, mostly cabbage, in forest clearings where
there is road access.
5.5 Infrastructure
A power line passes within several kilometres of the Property and two high tension power lines cross
over the Property Mining Rights boundary, servicing Sangdong village and the Kangwon High Golf
and Ski Resorts, situated to the north of the Sangdong Project. 20MVA of electrical supply capacity
will be provided for the Sangdong Project mining and milling operation, and the Uljin nuclear power
station facility is situated nearby on the coast and would be capable of providing a reliable, long-term
and low cost energy supply for the mine.
The rail network (Figure 5.1) is used for passenger service but also the transport of bulk cargoes,
including cement, limestone and aggregates, mineral concentrates, sulphuric acid tankers,
refrigerated goods and fuel cells.
Uljin is the closest port facility for the Sangdong Project, situated 50km east of Sangdong on the east
coast whilst Donghae, an additional port facility is situated 56 km northeast of Sangdong. Donghae is
a port mainly used for the export of cement clinker.
July 2016
30
Technical Report on The Sangdong Project
July 2016
31
Technical Report on The Sangdong Project
6 PROJECT HISTORY
Tungsten mineralisation was discovered on the Property in 1916 and mining took place at two
locations for several years, but then ceased. Operations at both locations recommenced in 1933 and
the main Sangdong deposit was discovered during the period 1939 to 1940. The Sangdong Mine
was operated during World War II by Sorim Resources Co. and during the period 1946 to 1949, under
the jurisdiction of the United States military government office.
In 1949 the Korean Tungsten Mining Company, a government agency, assumed control and operated
the mine until 1951. In 1952, the Korean Tungsten Mining Company changed its name to Korea
Tungsten Mining Co. Ltd. (KTMC) and resumed mining, producing tungsten and scheelite, bismuth,
and molybdenum concentrates.
The mine operated until 1992, with annual rates of production of up to 600,000t of ore. By the time of
closure, the mine had been developed on 20 levels, between the elevations of 242 and 755masl, with
a cumulative length of 20km of workings in addition to six inclines totalling 3.8 km, a ventilation incline
and a 450m vertical shaft (Lee, 2001). The mine had tracked haulage ways.
Historical mining employed underground room and pillar methods, and concentrated on four main
tungsten horizons: the Upper (H1), Main (M1), Lower II (F2), and Lower III (F3) listed in stratigraphic
order. Mining occurred mostly on the M1 horizon, with lesser operations on H1, and only very minor
workings on F2 and F3.
Production figures over the life of the mine are not available, having either been lost or having never
been fully documented. During the period 1952 to 1987, annual production of tungsten concentrate
varied between 994t (1955) and 3,268t (1961) and total production was 74,911t. There are
indications that in the period between 1987 and 1992 mine production was limited and concentrate
production was derived from toll treatment. Various quantities of ammonium paratungstate (APT),
tungsten metal and tungsten steel were also produced
Between 1961 and 1987, 2,930t of bismuth were recovered. Also 2,725t of paramolybdate or
molybdenum oxide were produced during the period 1967 to 1987. Gold and silver were also
recovered, with maximum annual production rates of 37kg of gold (1987) and 531kg of silver (1974),
apparently from the bismuth concentrate.
July 2016
32
Technical Report on The Sangdong Project
Based on tabulated data on longitudinal sections from the beginning of 1981 to the end of 1988, it is
evident that the great proportion of the ore-grade mineralisation was produced from the 3.5m to 5m
thick Main horizon: 3.918Mt. During the same period of time, about 2.041Mt were mined from the
Hangingwall (Upper) horizon in widely spaced stopes as deep as the -8 level. Data suggest that little,
if any, production came from the horizon prior to that period.
In 1981-1988, about 88,000t came from the Footwall (Lower) II horizon, mostly in the upper three
levels, and 167,000t from the Footwall (Lower) III horizon, also mostly in the three upper levels of the
mine.
Although no statistics are available for production from the various individual horizons, it is evident
from the 1989 longitudinal sections that there appear to be only pillars remaining at most levels in the
core of the mine area, to at least the -15 level. Most of the remaining resources at that time were in
peripheral, and probably lower grade, parts of the deposit, and in the “East Orebody".
Statistics for the period from 1987 to the mine’s closure in 1992 are unavailable; however there are
indications that mine production was limited and concentrate production was derived from toll
treatment. Various quantities of APT, tungsten metal, and tungsten steel were also produced
In 1959, a synthetic scheelite plant began operation, improving the grade and recovery of
concentrates. In 1961, a bismuth refining plant was opened, producing 99.9% bismuth metal. The
following year, a plant to produce tungsten metal was commissioned and in 1972, an ammonium
paratungstate ("APT") plant was built. From 1974 to 1987, up to 1,182t of APT was produced
annually, totalling 10,624t, but between 1978 and 1987, less than 170t of tungsten metal and steels
were produced. The drop in tungsten prices in the mid-1980’s caused the mine to reduce production
and eventually shut down in 1992. The Korea Tungsten Mining Co Ltd was finally dissolved in 1998.
Mr Jae Youl Sim (Se Woo Mining Co.Ltd) acquired 23 Mining Rights over the Sangdong deposit in
June 2001.
On October 19, 2006, Oriental Minerals Inc. entered into an agreement with Se Woo Mining Co. Ltd.
("Se Woo"), a private company based in Seoul, Republic of Korea, whereby Oriental could earn up to
100% interest in 23 Mining Rights with a total area of 5,924ha (59.24 km2).
Ownership of the 23 Mining Rights was transferred to Oriental Minerals Inc. 100%-owned Korean
subsidiary Oriental Hard Metals Korea Co., Ltd. upon closing of Sangdong Purchase Agreement and
acceptance by the TSX-V on 7 January 2007.
July 2016
33
Technical Report on The Sangdong Project
• Oriental, as operator of the project, earned a 51% interest in the Properties by:
• Paying Se Woo upon Closing, US$720,000 cash and $800,000 in any combination of cash or
Oriental shares (by February 28, 2007);
• Spending a minimum of US$800,000 on exploration and related activities in each of first and
second years; and
• Spending US$2,400,000 on exploration and related activities during each of the third, fourth
and fifth years after closing on the Sangdong properties or any other properties of Se Woo;
and spending at least US$16,000,000 if undertaking commercial production.
• Oriental could earn an additional 19% interest by the completion of a pre-feasibility study
within five years of closing, and a final 30% interest in the property by delivering an
independent feasibility study by the fifth anniversary after closing; that period could be
extended for up to 18 months without Orientals’ loss of any rights.
["Closing" is defined as being subject to regulatory and shareholder approval, as well as other
conditions].
On the 25 February 2010, Oriental Minerals Inc. changed its name to Woulfe Mining Corp. This was a
re-branding exercise and it appears that no other changes occurred in the company at this time.
Subsequently the project area was reduced to 12 Mining Rights with an aggregate area of 3,173ha.
In November 2011 Woulfe gained 100% interest in the property. The 2% net smelter royalty retained
on the Sangdong tungsten-molybdenum project in South Korea from the vendor, Se Woo Mining Co.
Ltd., was purchased for CDN $3.5M, of which CDN$500,000 was paid on execution of the agreement
and the balance of which was payable by December 19, 2011. In addition, the Company negotiated
July 2016
34
Technical Report on The Sangdong Project
an amendment to the acquisition agreement originally dated October 9, 2006 in respect of the
Sangdong project, such that the final outstanding 30% interest in the mining titles vested to the
Company immediately as part of the completion of the payments noted above.
.
6.4 Historical Resource Estimates
Two historic tungsten resource estimates (Table 6.1) were prepared for the Sangdong Mine, in 1985
and 1989. The 1985 estimate, prepared by the mine staff, contained a total of about 20Mt at a grade
of 0.5% WO3. The 1989 estimate, prepared by Korea Resources Corp., contained about 18.8Mt at an
average grade of 0.5% WO3.
The second estimate includes about 1.4Mt attributed to the Sangdong East deposit and therefore the
difference between the two estimates does not represent the tonnage mined in the interim. These
were polygonal estimates and used a relative density of 2.9. Tungsten mineralisation in Sangdong
East is lower-grade than in the main mine area. Drillhole data indicate that the Hangingwall (Upper)
horizon is 1.5-10.93m thick and contains 0.01-0.24% WO3; the partially mined Main horizon is 1.03-
8.83m in width and contains 0.01-0.65% WO3. Low-molybdenum, blue-fluorescent scheelite is
dominant.
West (W) Sangdong was estimated to contain 2.3Mt at an average grade of 0.5% WO3 but no details
of the estimation process or the number of holes employed in the estimate are known. It is unknown
on how many drillholes this was based, but because of the wide spacing of the drillholes (200m or
more), the resource could at best be considered Inferred under currently accepted resource
evaluation methodologies.
July 2016
35
Technical Report on The Sangdong Project
As reported by Lee, drill intercepts in the Main horizon varied from 0.24-0.8% WO3 across 0.8-2.8m.
Other intersections included 0.11-0.28% WO3 across 2.3-6.8m in the Upper vein; and 0.1-3.0% WO3
across 0.6-2.0m in the Lower vein. In drillhole 86-6 in the Hwajeolchi area, a roughly 15m interval in
the Hangingwall (Upper) horizon of interlayered limestone and calc-silicate rock (about 50% each)
was intersected, with one 3.5m interval containing 0.32% WO3.
A large molybdenite-quartz vein stockwork deposit located above a granitic intrusion was identified
and drilled between 1980 and 1987 (22 vertical holes; 12,390m core drilling). In 1985, KTMC
estimated a high grade “Prospective Ore Reserve” of 16.3Mt grading 0.40% MoS2 for this Deep Moly
deposit. A low grade global resource of 120Mt grading 0.13% MoS2 was also estimated. This
estimate is considered neither reliable nor relevant.
The estimates predate the institution of NI 43-101 and do not necessarily conform to the reporting
requirements of Sections 1.2 and 1.3 of that instrument. The estimates are of unknown reliability but
are included as an indication of the order of magnitude of tonnes and grades of mineralisation
present. All Mineral Resource or Mineral Reserve estimates that pre-date both NI 43-101 and WMC’s
involvement in the Sangdong Property should not be considered to be material.
The 2012 global resource (Table 6.2) estimated by Tetra Tech (TT) focused on the data acquired from
the 2006-2008 drilling programmes, completed by Woulfe, as well as the compilation of historical data
for the upper quarter of the known dip length of the mine i.e. the section from surface to just below the
water level.
The historical drilling data used in the Tetra Tech (Wardrop)/Woulfe April 2010 scoping study was not
used for the 2012 estimate, meaning that any down dip extension of the mineralised zones was not
represented as a Resource. The classification conformed to the CIM Definition Standards for Mineral
Resources and Mineral Reserves (2010). The Resource was split into two sections by elevation,
representing the down dip potential of the deposit below current waterline.
July 2016
36
Technical Report on The Sangdong Project
• A Metric Tonne Unit ("MTU") is equal to ten kilograms per metric tonne and is the standard
weight measure of tungsten. Tungsten prices are generally quoted as US dollars per MTU of
tungsten trioxide (WO3). Theoretically pure scheelite concentrate can contain 80.5% tungsten
metal, but in practice the grade of concentrate products acceptable for sale ranges from about
62% WO3 to about 72% WO3.
The previous estimate in the Wardrop 2010 scoping study was made on a very different basis to the
2012 estimate, the former relying on the holes drilled underground by KTMC and on a coarse
geological interpretation of the mineralised zones; the 2010 Resource was classified as Inferred.
The 2012 estimate relied entirely on the more recent drilling programmes with associated sample
quality control; however, it only covered approximately the upper quarter of the known dip length of
the mineralised zones, and therefore comparison of the two estimates would be unreliable.
In order to estimate the down-dip resource potential at the Sangdong mine (Table 6.2 above),
Tetratech (Wardrop) completed a separate estimation of the down-dip resource using all available
samples, including those samples which could not be included in the up dip ‘Indicated’ Resource.
July 2016
37
Technical Report on The Sangdong Project
Due to the unreliability of the historic data described above the Resource was classified as ‘Inferred’
but was included in order to reconcile the 2010 and 2012 estimates.
Resources were estimated using a block modelling approach, with three dimensional (3D) ordinary
kriging and Datamine’s™ dynamic anisotropy application2 being employed.
Table 6.3 shows the Mineral Resource estimate and metal content for the Property as of 15
September 2014. The cut-off grade of 0.4% WO3 was provided by WMC and was based on an
assumed mining method, production rate, metallurgical recovery and metal prices. AMC reviewed
these assumptions and considered that they met the requirement of reasonable prospects of eventual
economic extraction. It appears that AMC used some results from the pre-2006 drilling in the
Resource estimation.
Changes that occurred between the 2012 and the 2014 resource estimates included:
July 2016
38
Technical Report on The Sangdong Project
• Change in the estimation method from a single mineralisation grade threshold of 0.15% WO3
(TT), to splitting the mineralisation into three grade thresholds and estimating each
independently (AMC).
• Using the interpreted faults to constrain the Mineral Resource estimate.
• Significant additional underground mapping carried out and incorporation of these data in the
Mineral Resource estimate.
• Change in the definition of the Mineral Resource categories.
Table 6.4 compares the TT 2012 estimate with the AMC 2014 estimate. Both estimates are reported
at 0.15 % WO3 cut-off grade in this table for comparison purposes.
• Approximately half of the Indicated tonnes in the previous estimate were converted to
Measured Mineral Resources due to the increased drilling and improved understanding of the
geology gained through underground mapping.
• Measured plus Indicated tonnes increased by 12% overall, while the Inferred tonnes
increased by 5% overall between the two estimates.
• The change in density is not significant.
• Measured plus Indicated grades decreased by 46%, while Inferred grades decreased by
between 68% between the two estimates.
• The net result in the Measured plus Indicated categories was a decrease in the contained
tungsten metal of 29%.
• The net result in the Inferred category represents a decrease in the contained tungsten metal
of 59%.
AMC considered that the decrease in grades was mainly due to the previous method (TT) of creating
the mineralisation volumes from the underground development surveys, and then estimating grade
into those volumes from the coded intersections in the database. The coding in the database is not
based on a 3D interpretation but is interpreted on a drillhole-by-drillhole basis.
July 2016
39
Technical Report on The Sangdong Project
July 2016
40
Technical Report on The Sangdong Project
6.4.2.3 A-Z Mining Professionals Ltd./Tetratech (Wardrop) Feasibility Study June 2015
1. Mineral Resources
In 2014, AMC Consultants Pty. Ltd. was commissioned by Woulfe Mining Corp. to develop a resource
block model completely independent of the Tetra Tech geology block models. On an A-Z Mining
review of the completed AMC model, A-Z Mining and Woulfe decided not to retain the AMC resource
model due to the technical methodology employed.
The Feasibility Study relied on the Tetra Tech 2015 updated resource block model, which included
the 2013 Phase 4 drilling programme (7,200m of additional definition drilling to significantly increase
confidence in the resources).
The Indicated Mineral Resource in the Tetra Tech phase 4 updated model is shown in Table 6.5
reported at 0.15% WO3 cut-off grade above 600mrl. The resource is only reported above -3 level
(600mrl).
The phase 4 Mineral Resource Estimate update included changes from previous estimates,
specifically the 2012 Tetra Tech Feasibility Estimate.
• The hangingwall ground conditions were better understood up-dip, so a greater proportion of
the hangingwall was reclassified in Inferred, rather than just the bottom 3 levels above the
current waterline.
July 2016
41
Technical Report on The Sangdong Project
• The halo mineralisation surrounding the Footwall Zone had reduced in importance with better
definition of the Footwall 2 and Footwall 3 zones from the phase 4 drilling and this is reflected
in the resource categories.
• The Indicated Main and Footwall zones’ resources were largely unchanged from the previous
estimate as the Phase 4 infill programme had not changed the results significantly.
2. Mineral Reserves
The Mineral Reserves (derived from the Mineral Resource block model Measured and Indicated
Mineral Resources) were identified as being economically extractable, incorporating mining loses and
the addition of mining dilution, by A-Z Consultants. Measured and Indicated Resources were outlined
from the -2 to Taebaek levels (Refer to Figure 10.3 below – Section 10 Drilling) as almost all
resources below -2 Level were Inferred. The Measured and Indicated Resources were further
separated into the F2/F3 and Main Zones. The resources in a 50m surface pillar allowance were
subsequently removed.
Using an average processing plant recovery of 81%, a concentrate quality of 65% WO3 and revenue
per tonne of concentrate of $US15000, a cut-off grade of 0.275% WO3 was determined.
Mining recoveries of 100% in primary (rock walls, floor and back) stopes and 95% in secondary
stopes (backfill on both sides of stope) were assigned, based on industry norms and experience in
mining in these types of conditions.
Dilution for the stopes included waste inside the stope outlines in the stopes, and backfill sloughing
from primary stopes in the secondary stopes. Backfill dilution was included at 5% at a 0% WO3 grade.
Development ore was not separated from stoping ore in the reserves.
The Proven and Probable Reserves in the combined F2 and F3 Zones were estimated to be 3.9Mt
with a grade of 0.610% WO3. The Proven and Probable Reserves in the Main Zone were 2.0Mt at a
grade of 0.492% WO3.
The A-Z feasibility Study was updated during 2015, with a 43-101 report produced by Adam Wheeler
in December 2015. At a 0.15% WO3 cut-off grade, indicated resources of 5.18Mt were reported,
along with inferred resources of 52.8Mt. Mineral reserves were determined of 4.7Mt, at a grade of
0.42% WO3.
July 2016
42
Technical Report on The Sangdong Project
The Korean Peninsula is situated on the eastern margin of the North China– Korea Platform, a craton
composed of three blocks of Archean age, the Nangrim- Pyeongnam Block and the Gyeonggi and
Yeongnam Massifs that are separated by the northeast-trending Imjingang and Okcheon mobile belts
of Phanerozoic age. The Sangdong deposit is located within the Okcheon Belt (Figure 7.1).
The Okcheon Belt is a fold-and-thrust belt sandwiched between the Gyeonggi massif to the northwest
and the Yeongnam massif to the southeast. The Belt has been divided into the southern Okcheon
and northern Taebaeksan Basin or Zone.
The Okcheon Zone, in which the Property is located, is composed of low to medium-grade
metasedimentary and metavolcanic rocks of Cambrian to Ordovician age. The Taebaeksan Zone
contains weakly-metamorphosed shallow-marine Paleozoic sedimentary rocks and marginal-marine
to non-marine Early Mesozoic, sedimentary rocks that contain economically important coal measures.
These rocks rest unconformably upon Precambrian gneiss and metasedimentary rocks of the Yulli
Group of the Yeongnam massif.
In the Sangdong area, the Cambro-Ordovician strata belong to the Joseon System that is divided into
the lower Yangdeok and overlying Great Limestone Series. The Yangdeok Series is composed of
two formations, the basal Jangsan and overlying Myobong. The Great Limestone Series is
subdivided into six formations, from oldest to youngest, the Pungcheon, Sesong, Hwajeol, Dongjeom,
Dumudongl and Makdong Formations.
Plutonism occurred primarily during the Jurassic and Cretaceous Periods and most intrusions are
biotite granite in composition.
July 2016
43
Technical Report on The Sangdong Project
July 2016
44
Technical Report on The Sangdong Project
The Sangdong Project is situated on the southern limb of the east-west orientated Triassic age
Hambaek Syncline. Cambro-Ordovician limestone, shale, and quartzite of the Chosun System
unconformably overlie the Pre-Cambrian Taebaeksan schist and gneiss.
The Property area is underlain by metasedimentary rocks belonging to the Yangdok and Great
Limestone Series that are situated on the south limb of a syncline that plunges gently to the
southeast; strata strike at approximately 110° and dip to the north-northeast at 20° to 30° (Figure 7.2).
The local geology is summarised in Figure 7-3, with a brief description of each formation in ascending
stratigraphic order in Table 7.1.
Figure 7-2. Sangdong Project Area – Geological Map (TN - vertical grid lines)
(The area outlined in red represents the original 23 Mineral Rights areas)
July 2016
45
Technical Report on The Sangdong Project
Figure 7-3. Sangdong Project: Local Geology (Scale 1:30,000) (TN - vertical grid lines)
July 2016
46
Technical Report on The Sangdong Project
The Sangdong Project area is situated in the northeastern region of the Sobaeksan Massif, a
Precambrian basement complex. The Taebaeksan region of this massif has been subdivided into the
Taebaeksan Gneiss, Taebaeksan Schist, and Goseoni Series according to metamorphic episodes,
and the Naeduk and Nonggeori Precambrian granite complexes. At least three episodes of regional
metamorphism are recognised.
The Precambrian strata of the Taebeksan Series consist of interbedded biotite schist, sericite schist,
quartzite, crystalline limestone, hornfels and hornblende schist.
Migmatization, anatexis and potassic metasomatism due to partial melting of the Precambrian
basement formed the Naeduk and Nonggeori Granite Complexes.
July 2016
47
Technical Report on The Sangdong Project
The basal unit of the Yangdok Series of the Chosun System is the Jangsan Quartzite, which
unconformably overlies the Taebaeksan Schist and is about 200m thick. The Jangsan Quartzite
consists of mainly grey, white cream coloured, coarse grained quartzites, which form hard, well-
jointed resistant outcrops and prominent cliffs and bluffs. The quartzites are well bedded and cross
bedded, with some beds containing well rounded pebbles.
Quartz-molybdenite veins are developed in the Jangsan Quartzite and host the Deep Moly deposit,
situated below the tungsten skarn. Recrystalization and intense brecciation within the quartzite has
occurred in this area below the tungsten skarn ore body hosted in Myobong Slate. It is possible the
“Deep Moly deposit forms a “breccia pipe” like feature above a granite intrusion.
A marine transgression occurred following the deposition of the Jangsan Quartzite, represented by
the Myobong slate. The Myobong Slate consists of a 150m thick sequence comprising black, dark
greenish gray, brownish gray shales with some 7-8 thin limestone beds. These limestone beds have
been altered to skarn with accompanying tungsten skarn mineralisation in the Sangdong Project area.
Fossils assemblages identified include microfossils, trilobites, brachipods and a cephalopod. On the
basis of this palaeontological evidence, the Myobong Slate is dated as Early-Middle Cambrian.
The depositional environment of the Myobong Slate is uncertain, with several settings proposed,
including a littoral shelf environment or an unstable shelf - deep marine miogeosynclinal basin
environment.
This formation is about 150 to 200m thick in the Property area and is the host of all significant
tungsten mineralisation there.
July 2016
48
Technical Report on The Sangdong Project
The Great Limestone Series, of Cambrian to Ordovician age, is composed of six formations that have
a cumulative thickness in excess of 1,000m. These formations are largely composed of limestone
and dolomite with interbedded shale, quartzite, calcareous shale, and sandstone. They comprise the
following:
The Pungchon Limestone is the basal unit of the Great Limestone Series. It conformably overlies the
Myobong Shale and consists of white-gray massive limestones and dolomites, with occasional
intraformational limebreccia, shale and marl. Thickness of the Pungchon Limestone is estimated to
be 150-300m.
The limestone is generally poorly bedded and mostly pure in composition. It is considered to have
been deposited in a deep miogeosynclinal setting, although a shallow lagoonal environment is
proposed for the dolomitic limestone members.
The Sesong Shale conformably overlies the Pungchon Limestone and consists mainly of bluish gray
to dark gray shales, marls and arenaceous shales, with intercalations of thin bedded fine grained
sandstones and white-light pink limestones. Some graded bedding is observed. Thickness of the
shale varies from 10m to 30m in the vicinity of Sangdong Project.
The interbedded limestones are partly altered to skarn in the vicinity of the tungsten mineralisation.
The Sesong Shale grades into the vermicular limestone of the Hwajeol Limestone. Interbedded gray
to dark gray shales are found near the bottom of the unit, with several quartzite beds (Hwajeol
Quartzite) observed in the middle of the formation. Thickness of the lower part of the formation varies
from 200-260m.
Local skarn alteration minerals are observed near the Sangdong Project.
July 2016
49
Technical Report on The Sangdong Project
Conformably overlying the Hwajeol Limestone, the Dongjeum Quartzite consists of light-dark gray and
dark green medium grained quartzites. Interbedded black shale is present at the base, with thin
bedded siliceous limestone in places. Thickness of the formation is 10-50m.
The dark grey quartzite contains some hematite crystals and some calcareous components in the
matrix. The formation is interpreted to be wind-blown aeolian sediment deposited in shallow water.
The Dumudong Limestone conformably overlies the Dongjeom Quartzite and consists of light brown
calcareous shale, dark gray shale, and light gray limestone. The formation is estimated to be 150-
200m thick.
Conodont microfossils have been recorded from the formation, together with trilobites, brachipods,
mollusks and echinoderms. Depositional environment was deeper than the Dongjeom Quartzite, but
mud cracks indicate it was uplifted and exposed in places.
The Dumodong Limestone displays weak skarn alteration minerals near the Sangdong Project.
The Makdong Limestone forms the uppermost unit of the Great Limestone Series. It conformably
overlies the Dumudong Limestone and consists mainly of dark-light gray limestone, with light brown
calcareous shale, intraformational breccia, limestone breccia (Yemi Lime Breccia) and black shale
interbedded with each other. The Makdong Limestone is estimated to be 300-400m thick.
In the immediate area of the Sangdong deposit, the Changsan, Myobong, Pungchon and several
overlying formations have been affected by thermal metamorphism
July 2016
50
Technical Report on The Sangdong Project
Drilling by Oriental Minerals (subsequently Woulfe Mining Corporation Ltd) intersected a flow banded
endoskarn quartz porphyry intrusive body. Although the endoskarn alteration is intense (comprising
garnet-epidote-fluorite assemblage), quartz eyes are intact suggesting a rhyolitic affinity. This
intrusion is most probably a porphyry molybdenum phase of the Sangdong Granite.
Pegmatite veins related to the Precambrian granitoids occur within the Taebaeksan Series, 4km to the
south-southeast from the Sangdong Mine. These veins contain a significant tin resource at Sunkyong
(2Mt @ 0.10% Sn) and are most probably related to the Sangdong Granite.
7.2.5 Structure
In the upper mine levels, pre-mineralisation bedding plane thrusts were developed within the Main
mineralised zone. In addition, pre-mineralisation shear zones striking approximately northeast-
southwest caused local upwarping or folding of the Myobong slate and Pungchon Limestone. These
shear zones caused large strike changes in the orientation of the mineralisation.
The dominant post-mineralisation structures strike approximately northeast-southwest and are near
vertical. Horizontal displacement on these structures is commonly observed from mapping to be >2 m
but rarely >10 m. Vertical displacement is not well documented.
7.3 Mineralisation
The tungsten mineralisation of the Sangdong deposit is contained in several tabular, bedding-
conformable skarns in the Myobong Shale; these skarns have been interpreted as comprising
carbonate-bearing horizons that were altered and mineralised by fluids ascending from the underlying
Sangdong Granite.
From uppermost to lowermost, these horizons are termed the Hangingwall, Main, and Footwall
horizons, as shown in Figure 7-4 and Figure 7-5 below. Calc-silicate layers from 0.50 – 1.0m in
thickness have developed on the upper and lower contacts of the Main and Footwall horizons.
The Hangingwall horizon is located near the upper contact of the Myobong shale and varies in
thickness from approximately 5.0 to 30.0m because of the irregular boundary of the shale with the
overlying Pungchon Limestone. This zone has a strike length of about 600m and a down-dip extent
of about 800m. Above the most highly-altered portion of the Main horizon, the Hangingwall horizon is
not tabular, but extends steeply and irregularly into the overlying limestone. The Hangingwall horizon
July 2016
51
Technical Report on The Sangdong Project
contains diopside, garnet, fluorite, zoisite, quartz, hornblende, wollastonite and up to 50% calcite and
although there is some zonal variation in mineral assemblages (diopside-, hornblende- and quartz-
rich zones) the zonation is not as well-developed as in the underlying Main horizon. The tungsten
values show some zonation and decrease in value up-dip. The base of the Hangingwall horizon is
approximately 14m above the upper contact of the Main horizon.
The Main horizon strikes about 100° and dips northerly between 15° and 30°. The strike length is in
excess of 1,300m and thickness varies from 5.0 – 6.0m. Alteration (skarnification) within the Main
horizon forms three concentric, roughly circular zones. A central quartz-rich zone consisting of
muscovite, biotite, quartz and minor chlorite is about 350m in diameter and plunges down the Main
horizon at N05°W and is coincident with the higher tungsten grade portion of the deposit. The central
zone is succeeded outward by a hornblende-rich zone containing diopside, hornblende or tremolite,
chlorite, fluorite and calcite. A diopside-rich zone occurs both horizontally beyond and
stratigraphically above the hornblende-rich zone and contains garnet, diopside, quartz, fluorite, zoisite
and plagioclase. The diopside zone is typically poorly-mineralised. Boundaries between these zones
are diffuse and transitional.
The Footwall horizons comprise multiple layers: Footwall Zone 1 (F1) occurs 1m below the Main
horizon and is approximately 2m thick; Footwall Zones 2 and 3 (F2, F3) are situated approximately
35.0 to 40.0m below the Main horizon and are less than 1m thick. Further Footwall Zones have been
identified beyond F3 and are collectively referred to as F4. Areal dimensions of these horizons and
the zonal distribution of calc-silicate minerals in them are similar to those of the Main horizon. F1 has
sometimes been mined with extraction of the Main Zone. Some parts of F2 and F3 have been mined
in the upper section of the mine.
Age determinations of metapelites beneath the footwall of the Main horizon gave potassium-argon
ages of 81.2 and 84.0Ma, consistent with the age (Late Cretaceous) of the underlying Sangdong
Granite and implying that this intrusive was responsible for the alteration and mineralisation (Lee
2001).
The Sangdong deposit contains scheelite, minor wolframite, molybdenite, bismuthenite and native
bismuth. Molybdenum also occurs in substitution with scheelite and about 30% of the molybdenum
produced at Sangdong was scheelite-related. Gold and silver occur in association with bismuthinite
and native bismuth and were recovered from the bismuth concentrate. Tellurides, arsenopyrite,
pyrite, chalcopyrite and sphalerite also occur.
Mineralisation is largely associated with quartz veins within those horizons, with the exception of the
central portion of the Hangingwall horizon. Quartz veins are most abundant within a central, quartz-
rich portion of the deposit, parallel to and discordant with the calc-silicate layering. Veining ranges
July 2016
52
Technical Report on The Sangdong Project
from one to ten centimetres in width and is best developed in the lower portions of the mineralised
horizons.
The abundance of scheelite within the mined portion of the Main horizon is concentrically zoned,
increasing with alteration intensity, depending on temperature. Scheelite abundance in the
Hangingwall horizon is more variable and less clearly concentrated in zones.
Molybdenum and bismuth are concentrically zoned in a similar pattern to tungsten in the Main
horizon.
Lee (2001) states that the mineralisation is hydrothermal in nature and that there were two stages of
mineral deposition; the first molybdenum-poor scheelite mineralisation was related to skarn alteration,
which was followed by quartz-scheelite-molybdenite-bismuthenite vein emplacement.
The area is cut by steeply north dipping reverse and normal faults which have resulted in offsets of
the mineralised horizons by as much as 50-100m.
July 2016
53
Technical Report on The Sangdong Project
July 2016
54
Technical Report on The Sangdong Project
July 2016
55
Technical Report on The Sangdong Project
Sangdong East (“East WO3 Orebody") is located about 1km to the east from the Main deposit. It is
essentially an extension of the main mine area, and stratigraphy and lithologies are similar. In
contrast, however, the Hangingwall (Upper) horizon, Main horizon, and Footwall (Lower) horizons are
thinner, and have a lower frequency of quartz veins. The constituent minerals are pyroxene and
garnet with accessory plagioclase, quartz, apatite, hornblende and wollastonite.
In the Sangdong West area (“West WO3 Orebody"), mineralisation and stratigraphy are similar to the
main Sangdong Mine, but skarn horizons are thinner, and there is a lower frequency of quartz veining
than in the Main horizon. The vein width and grade of tungsten mineralisation do, however, increase
northward to the Hwajeolchi area. Scheelite and molybdenite occur together in quartz veins, which,
according to Lee (2001), is rare in the Myobong Shale.
July 2016
56
Technical Report on The Sangdong Project
8 DEPOSIT TYPES
The Property contains a tungsten skarn deposit; skarns are contact metasomatic deposits, exploited
for tungsten, with accessory molybdenum, copper, tin and zinc.
They typically form in continental marginal settings, associated with syn-orogenic plutons that intrude
and metamorphose deeply buried sequences of carbonate-shale sedimentary sequences. Skarn
mineralisation is typically hosted by pure and impure limestones, calcareous to carbonaceous pelites.
Due to their contact metamorphic nature, mineralisation has a close spatial association with calc-
alkaline granitic intrusives (tonalite, granodiorite, quartz monzonite and granites). Deposits form
stratiform, tabular and lens-like deposits, which can be continuous for hundreds of metres along
intrusive contacts.
Exoskarns occur at, and outside the granite which produced them, and comprise alterations of wall
rocks. Endoskarns, including greisens, form within the granite mass itself, usually late in the intrusive
emplacement and consist of cross-cutting stockworks, cooling joints and around the margins and
uppermost sections of the granite itself.
July 2016
57
Technical Report on The Sangdong Project
Due to the paucity of information about the molybdenum-mineralised system beneath the Sangdong
underground workings, it is difficult to characterise a model for this mineralisation. However,
important molybdenum mineralisation falls into two classes: porphyry-type and granite-related
molybdenum-tungsten-tin systems. There is some overlap between the two.
The tungsten mineralisation of the Sangdong Deposit is contained within a series of tabular skarn
horizons within the Myobong Slate. Calcium carbonate horizons within the slate have undergone
metasomatic replacement to mineralised skarn by hydrothermal fluids. The source of these fluids is
thought to be the underlying Sangdong Granite. Potassium-Argon age determination of phyllites
within the Myobong Formation are consistent with the age of the granite below.
Swarms of quartz veins have ascended upward through the Jangsan Quartzite into the Myobong
Formation where they can be seen to follow the bedding planes and also cross cut the formation
(Moon, 1984). There is a correlation between the presence of quartz veins and the grade of
mineralisation.
Although hydrothermal alteration (skarn formation) is widespread in the Sangdong area from
Sangdong West to Sangdong East and beyond, there is no evidence of a pervasive porphyry-style
alteration system. Country rock above the Sangdong granite is hornfelsed, but not pervasively
altered.
July 2016
58
Technical Report on The Sangdong Project
replacement (skarn) bodies may be present in the wallrocks. Fluorine is an important constituent, and
bismuth minerals may also be present.
There is no recorded alteration system (i.e. greisen) at Sangdong, and therefore the deep
molybdenum mineralisation is likely to comprise a system of sheeted or stockwork veins.
9 EXPLORATION
It was stated by Klepper (1947) that exploration in 1939 and 1940 led to the discovery of the
Sangdong scheelite body although no further details are available.
Mineral Resource definition drilling is the only form of exploration that has been completed by WMC
and AKT on the Sangdong Property since becoming operators in 2006, and there is no record of
exploration other than drilling by previous operators.
An aeromagnetic map of the area was reproduced in a scoping report by Sennitt (2007) but the origin
is unknown.
July 2016
59
Technical Report on The Sangdong Project
10 DRILLING
A summary of the different KTMC drilling campaigns is shown in Table 10-1. Between 1980 and
1985, 15 holes (8,940 aggregate metres) were drilled to investigate the East Tungsten mineralised
zone, now referred to as Sangdong East, approximately 1km to the east of the main Sangdong Mine
and the deposit was further investigated with a drift approximately 1km long. About 100,000t were
mined here in 1990. No additional work has been completed in this area to date.
Between 1979 and 1989, 18 holes (16,502 aggregate metres) were drilled in the West Tungsten
mineralised zone, now referred to as Sangdong West, approximately 2 km northwest of the Sangdong
Mine area. This zone has not been further explored.
Between 1980 and 1987, 22 vertical holes (12,390 aggregate metres) were drilled underground from
the Sangdong Mine workings to investigate the extent of molybdenum mineralisation in the quartzite
unit that underlies the main skarn zone. No additional work has been completed in this area to date.
During an unknown period, about 780 holes with an aggregate length of 30,000m were drilled
underground to explore the mineralised zones. These historical holes were used in the 2010 scoping
study (Wardrop 2010).
This data set does not have associated quality assurance/quality control information for the assay
results, nor is the collar or downhole survey information adequately documented. Comparison of
grade values in pre-WMC drillholes with nearby WMC drillholes showed significant differences that
were considered (AMC) as unlikely to be a result of natural variability only. Therefore, the results
suggested that the pre-WMC location information and/or grade values were suspect.
AMC used the KTMC drillholes in their Mineral Resource estimate to estimate grade and tonnes
below -3 level (594mRL) only where WMC had not completed any drilling (Refer Figure 10.2). The
July 2016
60
Technical Report on The Sangdong Project
uncertainty in the location and/or grade below -3 level is reflected in the Mineral Resource
classification.
The exploration work undertaken by Woulfe at the Sangdong Property was the surface drilling
programme completed between November 2006 and July 2008. From June 2010 an underground
resource definition drilling programme was designed and the first phase completed.
Woulfe (as Oriental Minerals) conducted a drill programme on the Sangdong Property between
November 2006 and July 2008. Ninety HQ/NQ surface core holes were completed, with an
aggregate length of 22,800m. HQ and NQ cores are nominally 63.5mm and 47.6mm in diameter
respectively.
The holes were largely drilled within the area of the former underground Sangdong tungsten deposit.
Analyses for WO3, MoS2, bismuth and other minerals were completed and this dataset comprises
some 20,355 analyses.
The holes were all drilled in the south eastern portion of the deposit, where the mineralisation occurs
near surface or is outcropping, on a bearing of 135°, parallel or nearly so, to geological strike; about
30% were drilled on the opposite bearing of 315°.
The majority were drilled at a dip of 70°, although several were vertical or at a dip of about 80°.
The holes were designed to test all three principal horizons of mineralisation and, with several
accidental exceptions, all penetrated well into the Jangsan Quartzite that underlies the host Myobong
Formation. Difficulty was often experienced in penetrating the lower horizons due to the mined out
areas of the skarn mineralisation.
The drill hole collar locations were surveyed by global positioning survey (GPS – sub 0.2m accuracy)
and the down-hole positions of the holes were measured at 50m intervals. There were some
uncertainties with regard to the collar elevations and Woulfe subsequently undertook additional
surveying work to resolve the situation and consolidate the survey of the site in general.
Holes drilled on bearings of both 135° and 315° intersected strata and mineralisation obliquely, the
intersected thickness of mineralisation being about a 30% greater than the true thickness. .
July 2016
61
Technical Report on The Sangdong Project
Once access was gained to the underground workings WMC began a programme of infill and
resource definition drilling. The drilling was largely completed from the underground workings
supplemented by additional surface holes where underground access was not possible.
Underground drilling was either NQ core from a Sandvik Onram 1000 wireline rig, or BQ core from 3
Kempe pneumatic screwdrive open hole core rigs. Orientations vary based on access and the need
to intersect all three ore horizons. Conical drilling patterns are common as a result of fanning out in all
directions from the underground drilling platforms. Collar locations were surveyed using a Leica 1203
total station with sub-decimetre accuracy). Downhole surveys were conducted approximately at the
end of hole as the majority of holes are <30 m depth. A Camteq™ multiple shot camera was used,
with a stated accuracy of ± 0.5° on azimuth and ± 0.2° on dip. The downhole camera was routinely
calibrated to ensure maximum performance, using a purpose designed jig.
AKT have completed a Phase 7 underground drilling campaign in 2016. This was focussed in
improving the resource categorisation of the HW Zone, and consisted of 20 holes, drilling just over a
1,000m in total.
July 2016
62
Technical Report on The Sangdong Project
The total number of recorded boreholes drilled at Sangdong is summarised in Table 10.2 and Table
10.3 below and graphically represented in Figure 10-1.
There are minor discrepancies in the totals e.g. 2006 – 2008 90 holes/22800m (Tetra Tech Wardrop
2012) – 94 holes/23,270m (AMC 2015) and 407 holes/19287m (Tetra Tech Wardrop 2012) and 405
holes/19190m (AMC 2015).
Figure 10-1 shows a drillhole plan and Figure 10.2 shows a SW – NE reference section through the
deposit, clearly demonstrating the absence of down dip borehole intersections from the more recent
drilling programmes.
July 2016
63
Technical Report on The Sangdong Project
Red Traces – Modern WMC Drilling; Blue Traces – Historical KTC Drilling
July 2016
64
Technical Report on The Sangdong Project
Outlines of >0.1% WO3 and development levels are shown in Figure 10.3.
Figure 10-3. Mine South-North Reference Section
Note: Mineralisation interpretation >0.1 % WO3 is shown as red outlines; mine levels are
shown as black line; surface topography is shown as a green line.
Table 10.4 summarises the results of the drilling programmes completed between 2012 and 2014.
Figure 10.4 shows a representative section with mineralisation thickness and grades for each
intersection referenced in Table 10.5.
July 2016
65
Technical Report on The Sangdong Project
Drillholes displaying WO3 % grade (legend displayed); red lines are >0.1 % WO3 mineralisation
interpretation; grey wireframes represent underground development levels.
The drill core was collected from the drill site by WMC personnel on a daily basis and brought to a
core logging facility beside the WMC field office. Core was measured for recovery and rock quality
designation (RQD) and logged geologically, including the following characteristics:
July 2016
66
Technical Report on The Sangdong Project
• Lithology
• Weathering
• Alteration
• Structural features, and orientations were the core is orientated
• UV fluorescence
• Fracture frequency, planarity, roughness, infill, rock strength: for the calculation of
geotech parameters
The UV fluorescence was logged in a semi-quantitative way, on an intensity scale from one to five,
and by colour (i.e. yellow or blue) and the core marked up for sampling. Samples were collected
continuously at one metre increments from the collar or from the uppermost practical limit of bedrock
and did not cross geological boundaries.
Core was photographed wet and dry and scanned with an ultraviolet lamp to detect the presence of
scheelite. The abundance of scheelite was logged in a semi-quantitative way, on an intensity scale
from one to five.
The AMC representative (2014) observed the logging process which related to all the logging
undertaken by WMC and Oriental.
The mean core recovery for the WMC drilling was 91%, while the median value was 98% (Refer
Figure 10.5). The recovery was considered to be suitable to support a Mineral Resource Estimate.
July 2016
67
Technical Report on The Sangdong Project
Density measurements were routinely determined every 20m using the volume displacement method
in a purpose designed tubular jig. Sample lengths for density measurements were approximately
between 0.10 and 0.30m. This is considered to be an appropriate method considering the generally
solid nature of the core proximal to the ore zones within Sangdong.
In the current resource estimation work, density values (t/m3) have been estimated from the
measurements taken. Blocks without estimated density values after the second estimation pass were
assigned average zone density values.
July 2016
68
Technical Report on The Sangdong Project
An overall summary of quality control samples taken during the WMC drilling campaigns is shown in
Table 11-1.
Sample preparation from core to pulps for analysis is completed on-site. Core is sawn in half, half
placed in a plastic sample bag and half replaced in the core box for archival storage. Sample tags are
placed in the core box and in the sample bag and the sample number is written on the sample bag as
well. Standards are placed into the sample stream at this point in the sampling process, in
accordance with a sample list that has been drawn up by the geologist responsible for logging the
hole.
Core samples are dried, split, crushed and pulverized on-site by WMC personnel in a preparation lab
that was purchased as a modular unit from Marc Technologies in Perth, Australia. Equipment is
cleaned by brushing and the use of compressed air between each sample. WMC staff employed in
the sample preparation facility have been trained by SGS Australia Pty Ltd. (SGS Australia), Perth,
Australia.
An approximately 50g split portion of the pulverized sample is sent to SGS Australia in Perth,
Australia for analysis. Blanks are inserted one in every twenty samples to ensure there is no
contamination (see Section 11.4).
July 2016
69
Technical Report on The Sangdong Project
11.2 Analyses
From 2006 to 2008 samples were analysed at the ALS laboratory in Brisbane by inductively coupled
plasma mass spectrometry (ICP- MS) for 41 elements and for ore grade quantities of specific
elements by aqua regia or four-acid digestion followed by ICP analysis.
From 2010, molybdenum, tin and tungsten were analysed at the SGS laboratory in Perth by X-ray
fluorescence (XRF). The sample is fused in a platinum crucible using lithium metaborate/tetraborate
flux and the resultant glass bead is irradiated with X-rays and the elements of interest quantified. All
quantities are reported in parts per million (ppm). XRF detections limits are given in Table 11-2.
The sample preparation facility comprised a fenced area beside the WMC accommodation facility.
Sample tags are placed in the sample bag and the sample number is written on the sample bag as
well. A split portion of the pulp from each sample and coarse rejects is retained in a locked facility at
the project site. The pulps are placed in brown paper envelopes by the sample preparation manager,
then packed in cardboard boxes, sealed and sent by DHL courier to SGS Australia in Perth by a WMC
geologist.
The QA/QC protocol included the insertion of the following control samples in the assay batches:
• Pulp duplicates (one in 50, or 2%), consisting of second splits of the pulverized samples that
are submitted to the primary laboratory for analysis in the same batches as the original
samples, but with different numbers.
July 2016
70
Technical Report on The Sangdong Project
• Coarse blanks (one in 50, or 2%) and fine blanks (one in 50, or 2 %), consisting of coarse
(approximately 1” diameter) and pulverized material, respectively, whose blank character was
demonstrated by analysis conducted at SGS Laboratories. Initially ground glass was used as
blank for Phases #1 to #4 drilling, but was subsequently changed to coarse crystalline
feldspar for Phase #5 drilling.
• Check samples (two in 50, or 4%), collected from pulps that were previously assayed at the
primary laboratory, are resubmitted to a Bureau Veritas Laboratory in Perth Australia (BV) for
external control. The check sample batch includes an appropriate proportion of control
samples (pulp duplicates, CRMs and fine blanks).
• In addition, the QA/QC protocol includes independent granulometric checks on crushed and
pulverized samples (1 in 20 for each type, or 5% each) that are conducted by geological
personnel.
11.4.1 Precision
Precision is the measure of variability or repeatability of an assay result. Knowing the precision of a
set of assays allows for correction to any bias or accuracy problems that may occur. A lack of
precision may be the result of the sample collection process, laboratory preparation process, and/or
the analytical process.
Internal laboratory duplicates are two split pulps of the same pulverized sample. These laboratory
duplicates are considered to demonstrate good precision if the absolute relative paired difference
(RPD) is < 10%, 90% of the time. Internal laboratory duplicates quantify the precision of the chain of
laboratory sample preparation and analytical procedures.
During the Jan 2012- Sept 2014 reporting period, 819 samples were re-assayed. Tungsten internal
laboratory duplicate summary statistics are presented in Table 11-4. Molybdenum internal laboratory
duplicate summary statistics are presented in Table 11-5.
July 2016
71
Technical Report on The Sangdong Project
• The correlation coefficient for both tungsten and molybdenum show excellent agreement
between the original and duplicate assays.
• The tungsten RPD results also show excellent agreement between the original and duplicate
assays with 98% of samples below the 10% RPD threshold.
• The molybdenum RPD results show poorer agreement between the original and duplicate
assays with 86% of samples below the 10% RPD threshold. This is less than the 90%
threshold.
• The scatterplots show three outliers in the tungsten results and one outlier in the molybdenum
results.
Tetra-Tech considered that the outliers were not material to the Mineral Resource estimation and that
the duplicate results demonstrate the precision of the tungsten assay results and that they supported
the use of the SGS results in Mineral Resource estimation.
July 2016
72
Technical Report on The Sangdong Project
Independent re-assaying of selected pulps from the primary sample by a second laboratory provided
a measure of both precision and accuracy. WMC sent 133 samples previously assayed by SGS
Perth to BV Perth as an external laboratory check. These external laboratory duplicates are
considered to demonstrate good precision if the absolute relative paired difference (RPD) is < 20%,
90% of the time.
Tungsten duplicate summary statistics, for the Jan 2012- Sept 2014 reporting period, are presented in
Table 11-6.
• The correlation coefficient shows excellent agreement between the two laboratories.
• The RPD results also show excellent agreement between the two laboratories with 99% of
samples below the 20% RPD threshold.
• The scatterplot shows one outlier.
The outliers are not considered material for the Mineral Resource estimate.
The BV results demonstrate the precision and accuracy of the SGS assay results and that they
support the use of the SGS results use in Mineral Resource estimation.
11.4.2 Accuracy
Accuracy is the measure of how close the assay is to the actual sample grade. Poor accuracy can be
caused by various sampling or analytical problems, including problems with analytical equipment or
procedures such as machine calibrations. These problems can occur at any time. Accuracy of the
analytical process must be quantified on a batch by batch basis to enable samples to be re-assayed
July 2016
73
Technical Report on The Sangdong Project
over time periods by inserting assay Certified Reference Material (CRM) standards into each batch of
samples and monitoring the results.
A CRM is a standard sample that has been manufactured by a certified company, and is itself
certified. The manufacturing process creates a homogenized sample that has undergone an
extensive and rigorous certification process. This process generates an expected value and
acceptable limits for all elements in the sample.
Laboratories use CRMs to ensure that their analytical processes are accurate between calibrations of
the machines. Where drift is observed, it is normal procedure for a machine to be recalibrated. It is
possible for internal laboratory CRM assay results to be altered and it is now industry standard for
laboratory clients to submit their own CRM samples in order to be able to monitor the accuracy of the
laboratory.
Four certified reference materials (CRM) for tungsten and one for molybdenum are in use by WMC.
These, along with a blank and a re-split coarse duplicate are inserted routinely at every 20th sample
interval. The CRM's were produced by CDN Resource Laboratories, Canada. A summary of the
CRM’s is given in Table 11-6. Note that CRM values are reported here as W% or Mo ppm not WO3 or
MoS2%. If a CRM falls outside the 1SD range, re-analyses of 10 samples before and 10 samples
after the failed CRM sample are requested from SGS Labs.
Figures 11-1 to 11-5 show the CRM results for the reporting period (30 01 2012 – 15 09 2014).
July 2016
74
Technical Report on The Sangdong Project
July 2016
75
Technical Report on The Sangdong Project
July 2016
76
Technical Report on The Sangdong Project
Tetra Tech considered that the bias observed in the CRM plots is not material for the Mineral
Resource Estimate, but recommended continuous monitoring of CRM performance by batch. The
results demonstrated the accuracy of the assay results and support their use in Mineral Resource
estimation.
Tungsten standard results for Phase 6 are shown in Figure 11-6. The QP, after also checking the
Phase 7 results, considers these results to be demonstrating the same accuracy as previously, which
therefore supports their use in Mineral Resource Estimation.
July 2016
77
Technical Report on The Sangdong Project
W (ppm)
W (ppm)
10500
10000 26000
9500
9000 22000
8500
8000 18000
0 2 4 6 8 10 12 0 2 4 6 8 10 12
W (ppm)
W (ppm)
17000 4000
16000 3000
15000
2000
14000
1000
13000
12000 0
0 2 4 6 8 10 12 0 2 4 6 8 10 12
July 2016
78
Technical Report on The Sangdong Project
Blanks are required to be inserted into the sample sequence by both the laboratory and the laboratory
client. Laboratory blanks are usually flux or pure silica and are a test for cleanliness within the
laboratory, where poor cleaning of equipment may result in sample contamination.
The coarse crystalline feldspar blank material used by WMC during the period to test for
contamination during the sample preparation was certified to contain no metal. Tetra Tech
considered assays of blank material to be acceptable if they were less than three times the practical
detection limit of the laboratory.
Figure 11-7 and Figure 11-8 show the blank results for the Jan 2012- Sept 2014 reporting period.
The tungsten results show three blank values out of 822 are above the acceptable limits while the
molybdenum results show two blank values out of 822 that are above the acceptable limits. Tetra
Tech considers that the blank value results are acceptable and demonstrate adequate care is taken
by WMC staff during sample preparation and the lab employs correct cleanliness procedures. There
were also no unacceptable blank values for the Phase 6 blank results.
The QP considers that the sample preparation, security, analytical procedures and supporting QA/QC
results that were used to inform the Sangdong Property block model estimate were collected in line
with industry good practice as defined in the Canadian Institute of Mining and Metallurgy and
Petroleum (CIM) Exploration Best Practice Guidelines and the CIM Mineral Resource, Mineral
Reserve Best Practice Guidelines.
July 2016
79
Technical Report on The Sangdong Project
July 2016
80
Technical Report on The Sangdong Project
July 2016
81
Technical Report on The Sangdong Project
12 DATA VERIFICATION
The data verification procedures applied by various qualified persons at the Sangdong Project
since 2006 are summarised below.
The Sangdong Mine underground workings were either inaccessible or, if open, of unknown
condition. This restricted WGM’s independent sampling to low-grade outcrops and waste
dump material. Given the long documented record of tungsten production at the mine, the
sampling done during WGM’s site visit on November 20, 2006, was clearly not intended to be
definitive, rather simply to independently confirm that economically significant grades of
tungsten, in particular, were present.
All samples were put into bags and closed with uniquely numbered, locking plastic ties; they
remained under lock and key or in WGM’s possession during their representative’s time in
Korea. They were taken as personal baggage to Mississauga, Ontario, and shipped by
courier to SGS Mineral Services ("SGS") in Lakefield, Ontario. Samples were assayed for
tungsten (reported as %WO3) and molybdenum.
SGS normally inserted one blank per batch of 100 (maximum) samples, one duplicate per 20
samples, and one reference standard every 20 samples.
After drying, if necessary, the samples were crushed to 75% passing 9 mesh (2mm), and riffle
split to produce a reject portion and a smaller portion which was pulverized to 85% passing
200 mesh (74μm). A 0.2g charge of each pulverized sample was roasted for 20 minutes and
mixed with 5g of potassium pyrosulphate. The mixture was then fused, ground and pressed
into a disk. Samples were analysed by the wavelength dispersion X-ray fluorescence (WD-
XRF) method having detection limits of 0.05% for each of W and Mo. The XRF method was
chosen because normal ICP methods have an upper detection limit of 1% W, and it was
suspected that at least two of the Sangdong samples contained appreciably more than this
amount of tungsten.
Analytical results for the independent WGM samples, together with location and sample
descriptions, are presented in Table 12.1.
July 2016
82
Technical Report on The Sangdong Project
The outcrop sampled near the upper adit portal consists of diopside-garnet skarn with
subhorizontal quartz veins. There was a minor amount of local scheelite.
The most surprising result of 0.07% WO3 was from an 8m wide, steeply dipping (about -65°)
structural zone, with multiple quartz veins, in Myobong Shale on the forestry road.
Mineralised quartz veins cutting across skarn-type mineralisation are documented in the
Sangdong Mine, but apparently at not such a steep inclination. Other similar structural (fault
or shear) zones were observed by WGM on the forestry road south of the set-up for drillhole
SD-1. Oriental (WMC) had planned to sample this area in some detail.
The Sangdong Project database, residing in MS ACCESS database files, includes all drill
collar location, assay, quality assurance and geological data, as well as core recovery, visual
estimates of key minerals and bulk density data.
The collar, assay, geological (rock type codes only) and core recovery data were extracted
and input into the GEMCOM® modelling software system.
July 2016
83
Technical Report on The Sangdong Project
As a test of data integrity, checking of 10% of the data was made against original assay
certificates. Collar coordinates were checked against the original survey forms. Results from
the data checks showed zero error rate. It was concluded that the assay and survey
database used for the mineral resource update was sufficiently free of error to be adequate
for resource estimation.
• Multiple site visits to the Sangdong Property, the last in October 2011, inspection of
the exposed host skarn, veining and associated lithologies. The skarn and quartz
veining are illustrated in Figure 12.1 and Figure 12.2. Mineralisation in hand
specimen is shown in Figure 12.3.
July 2016
84
Technical Report on The Sangdong Project
• Core logging (lithology, mineralisation) of selected Sangdong diamond drill holes from
the latest drilling programme, at the Sangdong facilities.
• Observation and review of core storage, core logging, core sampling, core cutting and
sample preparation procedures, standard reference sample and reject sample
storage facilities at the Sangdong facilities.
• Detailed discussion with Woulfe staff was undertaken during the visit to the Sangdong
facilities.
July 2016
85
Technical Report on The Sangdong Project
• Selection of between 5% and 10% of the Sangdong drill holes for verification of
handwritten geological logs, original field sample sheets and original ALS assay
certificates against corresponding records in the Sangdong database supplied.
Copies and scans of original data were supplied by Woulfe in order to carry out the
verification exercise off-site.
Very minor discrepancies and errors were encountered during these processes and referred
to Woulfe for clarification or correction.
Overall it was concluded by Tetra Tech/Wardrop that appropriate care and attention in data
entry, validation and QA/QC procedures had been applied by Woulfe and that analytical
issues were identified and appropriate remedial action taken. A possible exception related to
downhole surveys of relatively short drillholes, but otherwise industry standard practices had
been followed and the quality of the Sangdong database meets NI 43-101 standards and
Canadian Institute of Mining, Metallurgy and Petroleum (CIM) best practice guidelines.
Tetra Tech/Wardrop concluded that the combination of the latest sampling and understanding
derived from the wealth of historical mining data provided adequate information for the
purpose of their resource estimation and Technical Report.
Tetra Tech/Wardrop did not complete any independent exploration work, drill any holes or
perform any programme of sampling and assaying on the property. During the field visit
(October 2011) Wardrop did not collect any samples from the Sangdong project but was
satisfied from visual inspection of the presence of mineralisation at Sangdong.
From the 17th of August 2013 to the 1st of September 2013 inclusive, Tetra Tech full-time
employee and Qualified Person Mr. Joe Hirst made a personal inspection of the Sangdong
Property and undertook the following data verification steps;
July 2016
86
Technical Report on The Sangdong Project
• Survey procedures
• Geological interpretation
• Exploration strategy
• A review of underground back and wall mapping (drifts and rises).
• An inspection of the core sheds and some recent drill core intersections from the
Property.
• 100 random cross-checks of the mineralised assay results in the database with
original assay results from the reporting period.
• Site geologists are appropriately trained and are conscious of the specific sampling
requirements of disseminated mineralisation with high grade lenses.
• Cross-checking the database with the original assay results did not uncover any
errors.
Between the 5th and 15th of August 2014, AMC full-time employee and QP Dr A P Fowler
visited the Sangdong Property; the data verification steps and conclusions were identical to
those summarised in the Tetra Tech section above.
Adam Wheeler visited the Sangdong site in August 2015, and discussed with site geologists
all aspects of sample collection, preparation and storage, as well as visiting the core storage
and sample preparation areas. The updated sample database has also been reviewed in
2015 and 2016, and during the resource estimation process, many aspects of the drillhole
data were checked by communication with the Sangdong geologists.
In the QP’s opinion, the geological data used to inform the Sangdong Property block model
estimates were collected in line with industry good practice as defined in the Canadian
Institute of Mining and Metallurgy and Petroleum (CIM) Exploration Best Practice Guidelines
and the CIM Mineral Resource, Mineral Reserve Best Practice Guidelines, and were suitable
for use in the estimation of Mineral Resources.
July 2016
87
Technical Report on The Sangdong Project
From the test work on the Sangdong scheelite ore, the following conclusions were drawn:
The test work on the Sangdong low-grade scheelite concentrate indicated the feasibility of' a
soda-ash roast-leach extraction of sodium tungstate to precipitate an artificial scheelite
product. The product made from the first part of this calcium chloride precipitation met market
specifications in both tungstic oxide content and maximum molybdenum content allowable.
The subsequent precipitation products were high in molybdenum, even though the minimum
grade for tungstic oxide was met.
Separation of the molybdenum from the tungsten in the pregnant solution was not attempted,
as it was beyond the scope of the investigation. However, a process was used by the U.S.
Vanadium Co. to make this molybdenum tungsten-separation.
A calculated combination of the results of these two beneficiation procedures was made. This
calculation was made to demonstrate the results possibly obtainable if a sample of the
Sangdong scheelite ore were treated by tabling, flotation, magnetic separation, and roasting
July 2016
88
Technical Report on The Sangdong Project
• A combined natural and artificial scheelite of 63.4% tungstic oxide and 0.65%
molybdenum, accounting for 73.6% of the tungstic oxlde;
• A bismuth by-product of 11.1% bismuth and 0.57 and 2.8oz/t of gold and silver,
respectively, with recovery of 46.3%.
Further detailed beneficiation study probably would improve the overall metallurgical results.
This applies particularly to the scavenger flotation circuit where 18.9% of the tungsten was
lost in a tailing containing 0.23% tungstic oxide. It is also probable that cleaning of the table
concentrate by sulphide flotation would yield a final tungsten product acceptably free of
molybdenum, bismuth and sulphides and at the same time increase the bismuth recovery in
the bismuth by-product.
Part of the molybdenum should be recoverable from the sulphide flotation concentrates. The
portion entering the pregnant solution may be precipitated with sodium sulphide solution and
filtered off before tungsten precipitates. Neither of these steps was attempted, since they
were part of existing metallurgical technology; the latter technique has been applied to Korean
concentrates, and it was therefore simply assumed that these methods would apply to this
ore. These conjectures point to the possibility of better metallurgical results; however, the
beneficiation work done has demonstrated that the Sangdong scheelite ore, as approximated
by the sample submitted for beneficiation, is amenable to concentration into marketable grade
products by a combination of tabling, flotation, magnetic separation, and chemical treatment.
The following is a summary, extracted from the Mineral Resource Estimate (TT/WMC 2012),
of the mineral processing and metallurgical testing completed during the 2010 Scoping Study.
Mineralogical studies and preliminary metallurgical test work have been conducted on four
composite core samples taken from the Sangdong deposit by SGS Mineral Services Europe
(SGS). The samples represented the four historical mineralised horizons, namely A,B,C and
D+E combined (although not stated the horizons are assumed to correspond to the
Hangingwall, Main and Footwall (F1, F2 and F3) horizons.
• The primary economic minerals in the ore are scheelite and molybdenite.
• The sample average head grades were 0.22% WO3 and 0.03% MoS2.
July 2016
89
Technical Report on The Sangdong Project
• Fluorite, rhenium, gold, silver, copper and bismuth are present but at sub-economic
levels.
• The bond work index was determined as 18.7kW/h/t and the ore is classified as
medium hard
• Scheelite becomes increasingly liberated below 500μm with ultimate liberation at
approximately 50μm.
• Scheelite is not associated with molybdenite or bismuthinite. Provided the ore
minerals are sufficiently liberated from the host rock silicates then separation should
be relatively straightforward.
• The relative density of the ore falls between 2.87 and 3.03 and averages 2.90.
• Preconcentration by gravity has been shown to give recoveries of 63% for tungsten
and 55% for molybdenum.
Although theoretical grade and recovery curves were established as part of the
quantitative mineralogical programme, process grade and recovery data remained to
be established.
Since publication of the Tetra Tech Feasibility Study in 2012 a pilot plant scale test was
completed on a bulk sample from the Sangdong deposit in late 2012. The pilot plant testwork
was carried out by the Guangzhou Research Institute of Non-ferrous Metals in China
producing a report entitled “Research Report on Pilot-plant Test of Mineral Processing for
Sangdong Mining Ore from Korea” dated September 2012. The results of this pilot plant
testwork are summarised below:
• Though the grade of the sample processed was lower than that used in bench scale
testing, comprehensive recovery can still be achieved. All products can be separated
into saleable products by processing or hydrometallurgy.
• The strong magnetic minerals in the ore should be removed to prevent adverse
effects on scheelite concentrate grade.
• The advised grinding fineness was recommended to be 78-80% -75μm for the Main
Zone and 90% -75μm for the FW Zone.
• The pilot plant testwork on the Main Zone used a 78.5% -75μm grind and a
molybdenum flotation-sulphide flotation-scheelite rougher flotation. The scheelite
concentrate using rougher flotation and heated floatation is produced with a mass
yield of 9.13% assaying 65.26% WO3 with an overall recovery of 81.13%. FW Zone
testwork used a 95% -75μm grind and a molybdenum flotation-sulphide flotation-
scheelite rougher flotation. The scheelite concentrate using rougher flotation and
July 2016
90
Technical Report on The Sangdong Project
heated flotation is produced with a mass yield of 8.95% assaying 66.07% WO3 with
an overall recovery of 78.81%.
• Main and FW Zones mineralogy are similar with the same flowsheet recommended
for the two ore types.
The overall conclusion from the pilot plant testwork was that the flowsheet proposed
by Tetra Tech in the 2012 Feasibility Study and technological conditions provided by
the pilot plant test could be used as the design basis for the processing plant.
In the pilot plant testwork by the Guangzhou Research Institute of Non-ferrous Metals in
China GYWA a proprietary Chinese collector was used in the plant; because of security of
supply concerns an alternative to this collector was sourced and tested. The conclusions
from testing the R3-3F unit from South Africa were:
• Scouting tests showed each collector capable of producing high grade (circa 20%
WO3) WO3 rougher concentrates, albeit at non-optimised recoveries.
• Overall better rougher flotation results were achieved with the R3-3F collector than
with GYWA, probably due to the reagent dosages selected.
• Heated cleaner flotation tests had yet to be conducted; however, rougher WO3 grades
are approximately double those achieved in China.
• Mo and Bi recoveries to the Mo and sulphide concentrates (which are independent of
the WO3 collector used) were low at 17.3 to 19.6% Mo and 29.2 to 32.0%Bi recovery.
Mo and sulphide flotation requires optimisation. Losses of WO3 to these concentrates
were correspondingly low at 0.5 to 0.8% of the WO3, although these losses will
increase slightly when these circuits are optimised.
• Future Work will proceed to optimise the Mo and sulphide circuits ahead of
maximising WO3 recovery into the WO3 rougher concentrate.
• Heated cleaner flotation will follow to achieve sales grade WO3 concentrates and
confirm this can be achieved with the Chinese collector and the South African
collector.
The validity of the Tetra Tech flowsheet and the projected tungsten recovery were
confirmed by the pilot plant and collector alternative testwork, in addition to the
original metallurgical testwork presented in the Tetra Tech report.
The testwork also de-risked the processing plant flowsheet and reagents used.
July 2016
91
Technical Report on The Sangdong Project
An updated mineral resource estimation was completed, during June-July 2016, by the
Qualified Person. This estimation employed a three-dimensional block modelling approach,
using CAE Datamine software. Two main resource blocks models were developed. The
relatively thick hanging-wall (HW) zone was modelled using a conventional block model
structure. All of the other bed-like skarn zones were modelled using the initial generation of
3D digital terrain models (DTMs) for the zone centre-points, onto which thicknesses and
grade-accumulations were estimated. This general methodology is described in the flowsheet
in Figure 14-1.
Sample Data
Estimation Parameters
Grade = Accumulation/Thickness
The interpretation of skarn zones has been generated by SMC geologists, with additional
intersection checks and refinements by the QP. The defined skarn intersections have been
based on a lithological skarn identification, as well as 0.1% WO3 cut-off grade. Additional
mined-out limits for the principal skarn structures were applied, as well as a 50m remnant
surface pillar below the surface topography.
July 2016
92
Technical Report on The Sangdong Project
The sample database, in the form of an Excel spreadsheet, is comprised of data from a
number of surface and underground drillholes, over a number of recent and historical drilling
campaigns. A summary of the available sample data is shown in Table 14-1. Plans of all
these sample data are shown in Figure 14-2, colour-coded by sampling campaign, and in
Figure 14-3, colour-coded by drillhole type – surface or underground. Overlain on these plots
are outlines of the mineralised zones.
As can be seen from the plan plots, the resultant spacing of samples with these different
historical campaigns has ended up being fairly sporadic, with sections spaced at distances
from 30m to 100m. Most of the surface holes are vertical, as are the very deep underground
holes. Most of the underground holes are angled up or down so as give good intersections
with the overall mineralised structures, dipping at approximately 25o. The lithology codes
assigned during logging are summarised in Table 14-1.
Drillhole recoveries were not consistently good. In the recorded recovery data, with over 75%
of the holes having a recovery of over 90%.
July 2016
93
Technical Report on The Sangdong Project
July 2016
94
Technical Report on The Sangdong Project
July 2016
95
Technical Report on The Sangdong Project
14.3 Interpretation
The tungsten and molybdenum mineralisation is principally contained within tabular calc-
silicate horizons, that are the product of skarn alteration of calcareous layers within the
Myobong Shale. These horizons dip at approximately 25o, and have a dip direction of
approximately 025o. The underlying Jangsan Quartzite also contain molybdenum
mineralisation related to quartz veining and stockwork development (described in to 2010
Wardrop scoping study). The current estimate work is only focused on the tungsten
mineralised skarn horizons. The updated interpretation has been built up using the following
procedure:
1. The initial zone intersections recorded by SMC geologists have been taken, and used to
demarcate the different primary mineralised intersections in each hole.
2. On importing the data into Datamine, checks have made for any illogical sequencing of
intersections, according to the basic top to bottom zone sequence shown below. Any
errors found were corrected. Communication with Sangdong geologists was also very
important in this process.
Zone Sequence
HW
MAIN
F1
F2
HALO
F3
F4
F5
3. For the HW zone, those relatively older holes (marked with H- prefix) holes were those
generally drilled into or near the HW zone. For those holes which did not have any
specific identifications flagged, HW intersections were automatically generated based on
a cut-off of 0.2%WO3. For the all of the HW data, the top-most and bottom-most
intersections were then flagged in each hole. Between these extreme points, 5m
composites were created in each flagged hole. Points of the hanging-wall and foot wall
contacts for the HW zone were created, and DTMs of these surfaces were generated.
4. For all the other zones, the mineralised intersections were converted into three-
dimensional composites. The centre-points of these composites were used to generate
July 2016
96
Technical Report on The Sangdong Project
central DTMs for each zone. In this DTM generation process, limiting edge perimeters
were also created for each zone.
5. The DTMs generated by the steps above were then used to test for any errors or
intersections. Sections throughout the deposit were also examined. This process
enabled many errors to be corrected, along with communication and checking by SMC
geologists, after which steps 2-4 were repeated again.
In this error checking process, particular types of intersections were also flagged for the HW
zone, marking valid intersections, but which are not representing footwall and or hanging wall
contacts. An example of the final intersections is shown in Figure 14-4, corresponding with
data for the same holes summarised in Table 14-4. Assay data for the surface hole SD_63 is
also shown in Table 14-5.
There are a number of post-mineralisation faults. These are generally steep and oriented
from north to 040o. The overall deposit is approximately bounded by major faults to the west
and east of the deposit. Within the deposit there areas of smaller faults, typically spaced at
50m apart. The vertical throw of these faults is typically 1-4m. These faulted structures have
not been specifically built into the current resource model. However, the DTMs generated
directly from the drillhole intersections do have sharp angular deviations, reflecting the overall
displacements produced by intersected faults.
An overall summary of the interpreted mineralised zones is shown in Table 14-3. As can be
seen from this table, the individual beds below the HW structure generally have an average
thickness of 1-4m. Most of these beds also outcrop. The overall thickness of the entire
mineralised tungsten suite of skarn bodies is approximately 130 m.
Dip Average
Strike Minimum Base Maximum Max.
Range Dip
Zone Length Dip Length Elevation Elevation depth Max Average
m m m RL m RL m m m (o ) (o )
HW 1,300 1,430 330 900 740 73.0 17.4 0-45 25
MAIN 1,600 1,410 300 870 580 14.9 4.7 16-40 24
F1 1,300 740 555 850 370 5.2 1.3 14-36 24
F2 1,540 1,070 435 870 510 8.4 3.5 17-32 25
HALO 820 450 570 760 185 3.3 1.1 15-45 25
F3 1,300 960 430 815 550 9.2 2.6 7-39 23
F4 1,220 980 386 800 580 5.7 2.7 10 24
F5 1,020 580 535 780 420 4.5 2.5 15-36 24
Overall
Mineralisation 1,770 1,500 300 900 740 150 130 10-45 25
July 2016
97
Technical Report on The Sangdong Project
July 2016
98
Technical Report on The Sangdong Project
July 2016
99
Technical Report on The Sangdong Project
1. For the HW zone, samples were initially selected as those marked as HW intersections in
the SMC database. For the relatively older holes (marked with an H- prefix), as well as all
Phase 6 holes, which did not have any specific identifications flagged, HW intersections
were also automatically generated based on a cut-off of 0.2%WO3. For all of the HW
data, the top-most and bottom-most intersections were then flagged in each hole. Those
unflagged samples between these contacts were flagged as waste samples
(AZONE=WAST). In addition to this, a customised set of HW contact point exceptions
was created, where flagged HW samples were not to be used for upper or lower contacts.
2. For all the other skarn MAIN and F- beds, samples were selected based on those
sampled flagged as such by SMC geologists, as well as additional corrections applied by
the QP. The original selection criteria by SMC geologists were based on a combination of
logged lithologies, as well as a cut-off of 0.1% WO3 for continuity.
Based on this selection process, a separate selected sample file was created, as summarised
in Table 14-6. In this table, the information has also been broken down between the older
KTMC/KORES era of sampling, as compared with the more recent sampling associated with
Oriental Minerals and WMC.
A histogram of sample lengths is shown in Figure 14-5. It can be seen from this that the two
most common sample lengths are 0.5 m and 1 m.
July 2016
100
Technical Report on The Sangdong Project
Notes:
KORE Korea Resource Corp
KTMC Korea Tunsten Mining Corp
WMC Woulfe Mining Corporation
AKT Almonty Korea Tungsten Corporation
For the generation of composites from the selected sample sets, the presence of grade
outliers was also tested, to determine if top-cut levels should be applied. This outlier analysis
included:
The results of all three tests were considered in the selection of appropriate threshold limits
for applying top-cuts. The coefficient of variation (CV) is calculated as follows:
July 2016
101
Technical Report on The Sangdong Project
In CV analysis, CV values are calculated above progressively higher lower-most grade values
of each main zone and grade field. A graph is then plotted of the CV values against its
ranking in the CV list. Marked breaks in this variation index indicate particular thresholds at
which marked changes in the grade population occur. A similar procedure was repeated for
all the principal zones. These threshold levels were then applied during the compositing
process, so as to top-cut any outlier values above these top-cut levels. Because of the
variable sample lengths, the top-cut levels were applied before the composites were created.
Log probability plots for WO3 grades in the selected samples are shown in Figure 14-6.
Example CV plots of WO3 grades for the HW and MAIN zones are shown in Figure 14-7, with
the selected top-cut levels, and example decile analysis results for the HW and MAIN zones
are shown in Table 14-8. Using these methods of analysis, the top-cut levels in Table 14-7
were selected. Log-probability plots, CV plots and decile analyses for all zones are shown in
Appendix A.
July 2016
102
Technical Report on The Sangdong Project
Figure 14-6. Log Probability Plot for WO3 Grades in Selected Samples
July 2016
103
Technical Report on The Sangdong Project
Table 14-8. Decile Analyses of WO3 Sample Grades in HW and MAIN Zones
July 2016
104
Technical Report on The Sangdong Project
The selected and top-cut samples were then composited. For the samples in the HW zone
intersections, the following composite controls were applied :
1. Based on samples being flagged as either WASTE or HW within each overall intersection,
zonal control was applied, such that separate waste and mineralised composites were
created, split on the original sample division.
2. Composite length 5m. This compositing length was applied as slightly variable, such that
an equal composite length of approximately 5m was applied across each intersection.
This length was chosen to represent vertical selectivity with respect to subsequent
underground mining.
For the samples in the MAIN and footwall zones, the following composite controls were
applied :
1. Complete intersection composites were created, across each skarn body defined by its
AZONE identifier.
4. Based on the central DTM of each skarn zone, local dip and dip directions were assigned
to all of the composites. Stemming from these dip variables, the intersected composite
lengths were used to calculate true thickness and vertical thickness values for each
intersection composite.
5. For all of the MAIN and F- skarn composites, grade accumulations were calculated, for
subsequent analysis and estimation purposes. These accumulations were calculated as
follows, using the calculated vertical thickness of each intersection.
July 2016
105
Technical Report on The Sangdong Project
14.5 HW Analysis
With the new results available from the Phase 7 drilling campaign, there is now much more
recent (P0-P7) data available for the HW zone, than there has been previously. This has
enabled a much more thorough analysis of these more recent P0-P7 HW samples, as a
means of potentially verifying the older historical KTMC data for the HW zone.
Summary statistics of selected samples and 5m composites, for the HW zone, are shown in
Table 14-9. Separate statistics have also been calculated for the older KTMC data, as
compared with the more recent PO-P7 data. It can be seen that these statistical parameters
compare very closely for the different sample sources.
Composites
FIELD AZONE NUMBER MINIMUM MAXIMUM MEAN VARIANCE STANDDEV CV
WO3 K 1,027 0.15 3.82 0.54 0.14 0.37 0.7
WO3 P 358 0.15 2.55 0.51 0.15 0.39 0.8
WO3 All 1,385 0.15 3.82 0.53 0.14 0.37 0.7
MOS2 K 824 0.00 1.00 0.07 0.01 0.10 1.4
MOS2 P 355 0.00 0.49 0.10 0.01 0.09 0.9
MOS2 All 1,179 0.00 1.00 0.08 0.01 0.10 1.2
DENSITY p 60 2.50 3.73 3.24 0.07 0.27 0.1
Notes
. All statistics length-weighted
. K = KTMC/KORE campaigns
. P = P0-P7 campaigns
. CV = Coefficient of variation
Comparative log-probability plots for the different sample groups are shown in Figure 14-8.
These show very similar grade populations between the KTMC and P0-P7 sample groups.
Pairs of intersections were selected where the P0-P7 intersection is very close to an existing
KTMC drillhole i.e. effectively a twin sample. Sections of these paired intersections were
examined, and generally showed good correspondence, as shown in the example in Figure
14-9, for both samples and composites.
July 2016
106
Technical Report on The Sangdong Project
July 2016
107
Technical Report on The Sangdong Project
The phase 7 drilling includes results from 20 drillholes, covering 1,004m. The QAQC
measures taken as previously have been applied, and the results are acceptable. There is
now a high proportion of P0-P7 data available for the HW zone (>25% of all the HW
samples), along with a very good correspondence obtained with statistical parameters, grade
distributions and twin-holes, when comparing the P0-P7 data with the older KTMC data.
July 2016
108
Technical Report on The Sangdong Project
The quantity and coverage of the new Phase 7 drilling results have now enabled a much
improved analysis between the more recent (PO-P7) drilling results and the older KTMC
data. This statistical analysis, along with a comparison of specific twin-hole pairs, has
supported the validity of the older KTMC data. Given this evidence, it is the opinion of the
QP that the KTMC data for the HW zone has now been effectively verified. The KTMC data
may therefore be used for the estimation of the HW zone, without any restrictions.
All of the available data has therefore been used for the estimation of both indicated and
inferred HW resources. This has therefore enabled a substantial increase in the proportion of
indicated resources, for the HW zone.
14.6 Geostatistics
A statistical summary of the selected samples is shown in Table 14-10. These statistics are
divided by zone assignment. It can be seen that all of the coefficient of variation (CV) values
for WO3 are generally just over 1.
July 2016
109
Technical Report on The Sangdong Project
Table 14-11 that the coefficient of variation values for WO3 have been reduced to well below
1.0, by the effect of compositing and top-cut application. Individually the zones’ grade
populations show very clear log-normal populations.
Notes
. TRUETHK = True thickness
. Statistics for WO3 and MoS2 weighted by true thickness
Experimental variograms were generated for the generated composite data sets. Consistent
with the estimation of variable thicknesses of the skarn beds, variograms were generated for
grade accumulations, as well as thickness values. Example experimental and model
variograms are shown in Figure 14-12 and Figure 14-13. In general, for the non-HW zones
there was no particular directional anisotropy observed. Most of these skarn bed variograms
have ranges of influence from 50-100m. For the HW zone, the WO3 variograms range of
influence is longer down-dip (50m) as compared to along-strike (35m). All of the modelled
variogram parameters are summarised in Table 14-12.
July 2016
110
Technical Report on The Sangdong Project
July 2016
111
Technical Report on The Sangdong Project
July 2016
112
Technical Report on The Sangdong Project
Notes:
HW anisotropy directions:
1 Along-strike
2 Down-dip
3 Cross-strike
Two separate resource models were generated: one with a parent block structure of 10m x
10m x 10m blocks (for the HW zone), and the other with a columnar block structure for all the
other skarn zones. In the columnar block structure used, parent blocks were sized 10m x
10m, and in the vertical dimension single sub-blocks were generated, with a height equivalent
to the vertical height of the skarn structure being modelled. In both models, sub-blocks were
also generated down to 5m x 5m in the XY directions. Both model structures were orthogonal
– no rotation was applied. A summary of the model prototypes is shown in Table 14-13.
HW MAIN+F Beds
Minimum Maximum Range Size Number Size Number
X 483,900 486,000 2,100 10 210 10 210
Y 4,110,900 4,113,000 2,100 10 210 10 210
Z 0 1,000 1,000 5 200 1000 1
July 2016
113
Technical Report on The Sangdong Project
Physical controls used, during the generation of the volumetric block models, included:
For the MAIN and F- beds, an artificial vertical thickness of 2m was set onto model blocks.
The vertical thickness of these blocks was subsequently estimated on these blocks and then
used for the actual bed thickness.
14.8 Densities
Density measurements have been made during the recent WMC and AKT campaigns, as
summarised in Table 14-14. A histograms of the skarn density measurements is shown in
Figure 14-15. Histograms for each skarn zone are shown in Appendix A. There does not
appear to be particular relationship between density and WO3 grade values, as shown in
Table 14-14. The approach taken in this study was to estimate density values from the
sample measurements, using inverse-distance weighting, up to a maximum within-bed
distance of 100m. Beyond this distance, where no density samples were available, the
average values shown in Table 14-14 were applied.
July 2016
114
Technical Report on The Sangdong Project
July 2016
115
Technical Report on The Sangdong Project
For the HW zone, composites were first flagged with indicator (0/1) values, according to
whether they were proper mineralised HW composites (IND=1), or if they were representing
internal waste within the overall limits of the HW structure (IND=0). These indicator values
were then estimated into the HW volumetric block model, thus flagging blocks as either
mineralised or waste. WO3 and MoS2 grades were then estimated, using the corresponding
mineralised/waste composites for each block. Progressive search distances were applied, so
that if the initial search criterial were not met, another search was then applied with bigger
search distances and/or more relaxed parameters. The process was repeated until all
mineralised blocks received estimated grades. The initial search applied for the HW zone
was 35m x 35m x 5m, oriented parallel with the HW zone. Dynamic anisotropy was applied
so that the search orientation varied according to the actual HW zone structure.
For the MAIN and F skarn beds, vertical thicknesses and grade-accumulations were
estimated into the volumetric block model, both using ordinary kriging (OK). The estimated
vertical thicknesses were then used to set the actual vertical thicknesses of the model blocks.
Grades were then back-calculated from the estimated accumulations, such that:
Progressive searches were also applied for estimation in the MAIN/F beds, starting off with a
horizontal distance of 50 m . This is equivalent to a vertical search distance of 24m, which is
generally less than the 30m level interval. An octant search was also applied, so that initial
searches were only successful if composites were encountered in at least 3 octants.
For all zones, primary grades were estimated using ordinary kriging (OK). For validation
purposes, alternative grades were also estimated using inverse-distance weighting (ID) and
nearest neighbour (NN) methods. The grade estimation parameters are summarised in Table
14-15.
Example plans of the WO3 and thickness variation in the MAIN zone are shown in Figure
14-16 and Figure 14-17, respectively. Plans depicting grade and thickness variations in all
zones are shown in Appendix B.
July 2016
116
Technical Report on The Sangdong Project
Notes:
. Dynamic anisotropy used to orient searches such that:
X = along-strike
Y = down-dip
Z = cross-strike
. Maximum no. of composites used:
MAIN/F 24
HW 15
. WO3 Grades interpolated using Ordinary Kriging (OK)
. MoS2 Grades interpolated using ID for HW, OK for all other beds
. Alternative grades also determined for validation:
- Inverse-Distance (^2) weighting (ID)
- Nearest neighbour (NN)
. Octant control:
. Min. number of composites per octant = 1
. Max. number of composites per octant = 3
. Minimum octants = 3
. Density values also estimated by ID
July 2016
117
Technical Report on The Sangdong Project
July 2016
118
Technical Report on The Sangdong Project
July 2016
119
Technical Report on The Sangdong Project
It is considered that none of the resources at the current time should be classified as
measured resources, owing to the lack of detailed fault modelling. The resource classification
applied are summarised in Table 14-16. As compared to the previous resource estimation in
December 2015, the HW zone criteria have been updated with respect the verification of
KTMC data, as described in Section 14.5.
Measured (No material currently classified as measured) (No material currently classified as measured)
The distances applied for indicated resources stem from the variographic analysis, and
generally correspond to the range or less. The 50m applied for the MAIN and F beds is
equivalent to a vertical interval of approximately 24m. A plan depicting the resource
classification for the MAIN zone is shown in Figure 14-18. Resource classification plans for
all of the zones are shown in Appendix B.
July 2016
120
Technical Report on The Sangdong Project
July 2016
121
Technical Report on The Sangdong Project
Plan projection and sections were created from the resource block model, and compared with
the sample composites used in grade estimation. Example plans of grade and thickness for
the MAIN zones are shown in Figure 14-16 and Figure 14-17, respectively. Corresponding
plans for the HW zone are shown in Figure 14-19 and Figure 14-20. Sections were also
produced over the whole deposit, based on the mine section reference system shown in
Figure 14-21. All of the sections are shown in Appendix B. In general, these plans and
sections show a fairly good correspondence between estimated and composited sample
grades.
July 2016
122
Technical Report on The Sangdong Project
July 2016
123
Technical Report on The Sangdong Project
July 2016
124
Technical Report on The Sangdong Project
July 2016
125
Technical Report on The Sangdong Project
July 2016
126
Technical Report on The Sangdong Project
Comparison of global grade averages for each separate bed, as derived from samples,
composites and the resource block model. For validation purposes, alternative block model
grades derived from nearest neighbour (NN) and inverse-distance (ID) estimates were also
used in this comparison. The comparison was also done with alternative model estimates:
one with all samples, and one with both samples data and model pertaining just to the
Oriental Minerals and WMC campaigns. These results are shown in Table 14-17, and display
acceptable comparisons.
Notes
. All grades in %
. OK = model grades from ordinary kriging
. NN = model grades from nearest neighbour estimation
. ID = model grades from inverse-distance weighting
July 2016
127
Technical Report on The Sangdong Project
The current resource estimate was compared with principal estimates completed during the
past four years, as summarised in Table 14-18. It can be seen from this comparison that
different approaches have been applied to resource classification, the current one being the
more conservative. However, the total resource figure compares closely the total resources
estimated earlier in 2015 by Tetra-Tech.
Notes
. All evaluations limited in depth to above -3 level (594mRL), so as to be
comparable with previous reports
. Totals shown for comparative purposes only
* The AMC indicated resource figure above comprises 56% measured resources
July 2016
128
Technical Report on The Sangdong Project
A summary of the updated Mineral Resources is shown in Table 14-19, relating to a cut-off
grade of 0.15% WO3 cut-off grade, for areas above 594mrl. The resources summarised for
different cut-offs are shown in Table 14-20. These resources have an effective date of
End-July 2016, and are inclusive of reserves. Grade-tonnage tables, and associated curves
are shown in Table 14-21. A resource breakdown by level is shown in Table 14-22. Level-
Zone breakdowns are shown in Tables 14-23 to 14-25, for cut-offs of 0.15, 0.20 and 0.30
%WO3, respectively.
Notes
. Cut-off = 0.15% WO3
. Bed models diluted to a minimum thickness of 2.2m
. Resources shown are inclusive of reserves
. 50m surface pillar material removed
. Indicated HW material based on all samples
with a maximum search of 35m x 50m (along-strike x down-dip)
. Indicated material in all other beds are based on only PO-P6 samples,
with a maximum search of 50m, and sample grid required
. Inferred material based on all samples, up to a maximum search of :
105m x 150m in HW
100m x 100m in all other beds
July 2016
129
Technical Report on The Sangdong Project
Notes
. Bed models diluted to a minimum thickness of 2.2m
. Resources shown are inclusive of reserves
. 50m surface pillar material removed
. Indicated HW material based on all samples,
with a maximum search of 35m x 50m (along-strike x down-dip)
. Indicated material in all other beds are based on only PO-P6 samples,
with a maximum search of 50m, and sample grid required
. Inferred material based on all samples, up to a maximum search of :
105m x 150m in HW
100m x 100m in all other beds
July 2016
130
Technical Report on The Sangdong Project
WO3 CLASS
Cut- Level Indicated Inferred
Off % Tonnes Kt WO3 % MoS2 Tonnes Kt WO3 % MoS2
Sungyeong_805 - 1,759 0.29 0.04
Jangsan_755 38 0.40 0.01 4,065 0.36 0.04
Baegun_727 98 0.44 0.09 2,771 0.41 0.04
Taebak_685 704 0.46 0.05 5,212 0.41 0.06
Sangdong_659 1,683 0.51 0.04 4,099 0.46 0.06
-1_633 2,193 0.54 0.06 3,931 0.46 0.07
-2_617 1,542 0.53 0.08 2,184 0.43 0.06
-3_594 642 0.47 0.05 4,040 0.45 0.06
-4_566 372 0.53 0.06 4,746 0.46 0.06
0.20 -5_536 472 0.50 0.08 4,742 0.50 0.05
-6_509 119 0.51 0.06 2,371 0.51 0.03
-7_482 - 930 0.41 0.03
-8_457 - 1,030 0.44 0.04
-9_433 - 1,321 0.48 0.05
-10_407 - 2,192 0.49 0.05
-11_380 - 1,571 0.50 0.03
-12_352 - 600 0.47 0.02
-13_326 - 66 0.35 0.02
TOTAL 7,864 0.51 0.06 47,630 0.44 0.05
WO3 CLASS
Cut- Level Indicated Inferred
Off % Tonnes Kt WO3 % MoS2 Tonnes Kt WO3 % MoS2
Sungyeong_805 - 510 0.45 0.05
Jangsan_755 28 0.45 0.01 2,446 0.43 0.05
Baegun_727 85 0.47 0.10 2,023 0.46 0.04
Taebak_685 651 0.47 0.06 4,001 0.46 0.06
Sangdong_659 1,533 0.54 0.04 3,350 0.51 0.07
-1_633 2,042 0.56 0.06 3,357 0.50 0.07
-2_617 1,470 0.54 0.08 1,903 0.46 0.06
-3_594 563 0.50 0.06 3,384 0.48 0.06
-4_566 356 0.54 0.06 4,033 0.49 0.06
0.30 -5_536 472 0.50 0.08 4,157 0.54 0.05
-6_509 118 0.51 0.06 1,859 0.58 0.04
-7_482 - 417 0.63 0.06
-8_457 - 500 0.64 0.08
-9_433 - 1,023 0.54 0.06
-10_407 - 1,774 0.55 0.06
-11_380 - 1,237 0.58 0.04
-12_352 - 471 0.53 0.02
-13_326 - 23 0.55 0.02
TOTAL 7,316 0.53 0.06 36,466 0.50 0.06
July 2016
131
Technical Report on The Sangdong Project
CLASS Inferred
AZONE
LEVEL HW MAIN F1 F2 HALO F3 F4 F5 TOTAL
Kt WO3 % Kt WO3 % Kt WO3 % Kt WO3 % Kt WO3 % Kt WO3 % Kt WO3 % Kt WO3 % Kt WO3 %
Sungyeong_805 1,284 0.28 375 0.20 9 0.18 198 0.40 - 101 0.41 - - 1,966 0.28
Jangsan_755 2,339 0.37 469 0.28 77 0.19 502 0.34 0 0.15 543 0.33 499 0.32 54 0.27 4,483 0.34
Baegun_727 1,657 0.40 30 0.38 7 0.22 300 0.49 31 0.21 426 0.34 469 0.30 289 0.29 3,210 0.38
Taebak_685 3,114 0.41 165 0.45 73 0.27 434 0.53 50 0.18 618 0.37 796 0.32 452 0.35 5,701 0.39
Sangdong_659 2,682 0.48 93 0.44 38 0.29 250 0.54 15 0.24 210 0.49 579 0.33 385 0.38 4,251 0.45
-1_633 2,422 0.49 185 0.51 32 0.33 187 0.52 4 0.22 258 0.52 602 0.30 416 0.33 4,107 0.45
-2_617 920 0.48 242 0.47 43 0.30 123 0.44 0 0.18 210 0.50 445 0.31 294 0.32 2,277 0.42
-3_594 1,680 0.53 548 0.43 104 0.29 394 0.34 2 0.20 523 0.47 463 0.32 442 0.35 4,156 0.44
-4_566 2,356 0.50 524 0.54 75 0.25 627 0.37 2 0.17 599 0.44 556 0.32 166 0.28 4,906 0.45
-5_536 2,475 0.55 677 0.65 8 0.18 717 0.36 - 541 0.36 454 0.37 54 0.26 4,926 0.49
-6_509 1,288 0.55 368 0.65 - 187 0.31 - 281 0.23 457 0.36 - 2,582 0.48
-7_482 511 0.43 106 0.72 - 17 0.36 - 76 0.19 313 0.28 - 1,023 0.39
-8_457 993 0.44 - - - - - 164 0.25 - 1,156 0.41
-9_433 1,391 0.46 - - - - - 2 0.26 - 1,393 0.46
-10_407 2,202 0.49 98 0.34 - - - - - - 2,299 0.48
-11_380 1,360 0.52 224 0.36 - - - - - - 1,584 0.50
-12_352 488 0.45 112 0.53 - - - - - - 600 0.47
-13_326 48 0.26 18 0.59 - - - - - - 66 0.35
TOTAL 29,208 0.46 4,235 0.47 467 0.27 3,935 0.41 104 0.20 4,386 0.39 5,800 0.32 2,552 0.33 50,686 0.43
July 2016
132
Technical Report on The Sangdong Project
CLASS Inferred
AZONE
LEVEL HW MAIN F1 F2 HALO F3 F4 F5 TOTAL
Kt WO3 % Kt WO3 % Kt WO3 % Kt WO3 % Kt WO3 % Kt WO3 % Kt WO3 % Kt WO3 % Kt WO3 %
Sungyeong_805 1,196 0.28 320 0.21 - 146 0.49 - 97 0.42 - - 1,759 0.29
Jangsan_755 2,216 0.38 469 0.28 29 0.21 402 0.38 - 516 0.34 378 0.37 54 0.27 4,065 0.36
Baegun_727 1,406 0.44 19 0.49 4 0.27 296 0.50 15 0.24 396 0.36 347 0.34 289 0.29 2,771 0.41
Taebak_685 2,737 0.44 140 0.50 50 0.31 434 0.53 10 0.21 605 0.38 785 0.33 452 0.35 5,212 0.41
Sangdong_659 2,562 0.50 92 0.44 30 0.32 248 0.54 12 0.25 208 0.49 579 0.33 369 0.38 4,099 0.46
-1_633 2,331 0.50 184 0.51 25 0.38 187 0.52 4 0.22 258 0.52 600 0.30 342 0.36 3,931 0.46
-2_617 920 0.48 241 0.48 33 0.34 120 0.45 0 0.25 210 0.50 440 0.32 221 0.37 2,184 0.43
-3_594 1,679 0.53 548 0.43 88 0.31 361 0.36 1 0.22 516 0.48 447 0.32 399 0.37 4,040 0.45
-4_566 2,339 0.50 524 0.54 47 0.30 606 0.37 - 577 0.45 502 0.34 152 0.30 4,746 0.46
-5_536 2,430 0.55 677 0.65 1 0.25 678 0.37 - 496 0.37 408 0.39 54 0.26 4,742 0.50
-6_509 1,235 0.56 368 0.65 - 129 0.36 - 182 0.26 457 0.36 - 2,371 0.51
-7_482 458 0.45 106 0.72 - 12 0.42 - 40 0.21 313 0.28 - 930 0.41
-8_457 867 0.48 - - - - - 164 0.25 - 1,030 0.44
-9_433 1,319 0.48 - - - - - 2 0.26 - 1,321 0.48
-10_407 2,094 0.50 98 0.34 - - - - - - 2,192 0.49
-11_380 1,347 0.53 223 0.36 - - - - - - 1,571 0.50
-12_352 488 0.45 112 0.53 - - - - - - 600 0.47
-13_326 48 0.26 18 0.59 - - - - - - 66 0.35
TOTAL 27,672 0.48 4,137 0.48 306 0.31 3,620 0.43 41 0.23 4,100 0.41 5,422 0.33 2,332 0.35 47,630 0.44
July 2016
133
Technical Report on The Sangdong Project
CLASS Inferred
AZONE
LEVEL HW MAIN F1 F2 HALO F3 F4 F5 TOTAL
Kt WO3 % Kt WO3 % Kt WO3 % Kt WO3 % Kt WO3 % Kt WO3 % Kt WO3 % Kt WO3 % Kt WO3 %
Sungyeong_805 323 0.40 3 0.30 - 132 0.51 - 51 0.58 - - 510 0.45
Jangsan_755 1,460 0.44 195 0.38 - 335 0.41 - 219 0.45 234 0.42 4 0.34 2,446 0.43
Baegun_727 1,097 0.49 19 0.49 0 0.48 271 0.52 2 0.32 297 0.38 220 0.38 117 0.35 2,023 0.46
Taebak_685 2,167 0.49 138 0.50 15 0.49 405 0.55 - 525 0.39 500 0.36 251 0.42 4,001 0.46
Sangdong_659 2,131 0.55 81 0.47 11 0.48 242 0.55 2 0.32 190 0.51 394 0.37 298 0.42 3,350 0.51
-1_633 2,160 0.52 174 0.52 18 0.43 177 0.53 - 256 0.53 331 0.34 242 0.41 3,357 0.50
-2_617 899 0.48 217 0.50 22 0.39 100 0.49 - 210 0.50 279 0.34 177 0.40 1,903 0.46
-3_594 1,661 0.53 428 0.47 56 0.34 207 0.43 - 480 0.49 263 0.36 289 0.41 3,384 0.48
-4_566 2,275 0.51 435 0.59 25 0.34 418 0.43 - 527 0.47 310 0.38 44 0.42 4,033 0.49
-5_536 2,358 0.56 676 0.65 - 502 0.41 - 319 0.45 302 0.43 - 4,157 0.54
-6_509 1,107 0.60 363 0.66 - 81 0.42 - 31 0.41 276 0.45 - 1,859 0.58
-7_482 240 0.65 100 0.75 - 12 0.42 - - 64 0.43 - 417 0.63
-8_457 500 0.64 - - - - - - - 500 0.64
-9_433 1,023 0.54 - - - - - - - 1,023 0.54
-10_407 1,676 0.56 98 0.34 - - - - - - 1,774 0.55
-11_380 1,014 0.62 223 0.36 - - - - - - 1,237 0.58
-12_352 359 0.53 112 0.53 - - - - - - 471 0.53
-13_326 6 0.42 18 0.59 - - - - - - 23 0.55
TOTAL 22,457 0.53 3,279 0.54 147 0.39 2,882 0.47 3 0.32 3,104 0.46 3,173 0.38 1,422 0.41 36,466 0.50
July 2016
134
Technical Report on The Sangdong Project
The Mineral Reserves were derived from the Mineral Resource block model described in
Section 14.0. The Mineral Reserves are those Indicated Mineral Resources (there are no
Measured Resources in the current estimate) that have been identified as being economically
extractable and which incorporate mining losses and the addition of mining dilution. The
Mineral Reserves form the basis for the mine plan presented in Section 16.0.
The steps taken in block model (and other data) preparation for stope planning included:
3. Because of the close proximity of the different narrow skarn zones, alternative test block
models were created with combinations of an upper bed, the intermediate waste and the
underlying bed. These combined models were created, so as to test the feasibility of
mining thicker bed systems with lower mining cost. All possible different bed
combinations were tested. After this analysis, the only combined set which was selected
for subsequent for mine planning was the MAIN-F1 combination.
4. Level strings were created where the base of each modelled skarn zone intersected the
relevant level elevation. These strings were used for string construction during stope
layout. .
5. For each skarn zone, the resource model blocks were split into separate block models for
each zone, and projected so that all grades or other model properties could be viewed
and used in a plan projection view.
July 2016
135
Technical Report on The Sangdong Project
A mine plan was developed, using cut-and-fill (CAF) and mechanised inclined panel (MIP)
mining. The planning and development of these methods have evolved from the Up-Dip
Panel (UDP) mining, for narrower or poorer ground areas, and Inclined Panel (IP) mining
methods proposed in the A-Z Feasibility Study. Details of the currently applied CAF and MIP
methods are described in Section 16.
In the A-Z feasibility study, an overall average mining cost of $US33.76/t was applied,
according to the overall proportions of mining methods applied of 20% UDP and 80% IP. In
the current study, the same processing and G&A unit costs were applied as in the A-Z
feasibility study. The mining costs have been revised in the current study, to reflect the
updated mining methods and by getting updated mining costs estimates from Korean mining
contractors. With respect to cut-off grades, information was also used from the geotechnical
study by Turner Mining and Geotechnical Pty Ltd (TMG) in 2014, so as to also consider
recommended maximum span ranges.
A summary of the cut-off calculations and parameters is shown in Table 15-1. This shows the
parameters used in the A-Z Study, which results in a breakeven cut-off grade of 0.23% WO3.
A-Z subsequently applied a cut-off of 0.275% WO3 in their reserve calculations.
Using the updated mining costs, breakeven cut-off grades of 0.20% WO3 for CAF and 0.24%
WO3 for MIP were calculated. Based on the overall reserve proportions of 60% CAF and 40%
MIP, an overall combined breakeven cut-off of 0.22% was determined. The applied cut-off in
the current study was 0.23% WO3 for the majority of stope blocks, where recommended
maximum spans were limited by geotechnical recommendations, with elevated cut-offs of
0.28% WO3 for 3-6m, and 0.36% for less than 3m. These elevated cut-offs are only
applicable to 26% of the reserve base, and ensure that such blocks would still be profitable,
even if substantial additional support costs are required.
As with the A-Z feasibility study, mining factors of 5% losses and 5% additional unplanned
dilution have been assumed.
July 2016
136
Technical Report on The Sangdong Project
Current Study
Mine
A_Z June 2015: Average:
CAF MIP
20% UDP, 80%IP 60% CAF,
Description Unit 40% MIP
Prices
APT Price $/mtu WO 3 370 370 370
Metal Price - received $/mtu WO 3 288 288 288
Conc grade %WO3 65% 65% 65% 65%
Price per t of concentrate 18200 18,720 18,720 18,720
after transport + smelting $/t WO 3 28,000 28,800 28,800 28,800
Costs
Recovery % 81.0% 81.0% 81.0% 81.0%
Processing Cost $/t ore 10.95 10.95 10.95 10.95
G&A $/t ore 4.85 4.90 4.90 4.90
Total Applied Ore Cost $/t ore 49.56 44.25 54.1 48.18
(Processing+G&A+OreMining)
Mining Factors
Production rate tpd 1,920 1,820 1,820 1,820
Mining Recovery 95% 95% 95% 95%
Dilution 5% 5% 5% 5%
Cut-Offs
Breakeven Economic Cut-Of f % WO 3 0.23% 0.20% 0.24% 0.22%
Notes
Key
Bold Value supplied
Normal Derived
A-Z Study
UDP Up-Dip Panel Mining
IP Inclined Panel Mining
Mining factors of 5% losses and 5% additional unplanned dilution have been assumed.
July 2016
137
Technical Report on The Sangdong Project
Stope blocks were laid out as plan perimeters, bounded by horizontal parts on each level,
where the footwall contact of each zone cut through level's reference elevation. In general,
most stope blocks were limited to a maximum of 100m along strike. Stope blocks were only
laid out in those parts of each zone predominantly demarcated as containing indicated
resources. For reference during this planning process, the model blocks were coded with
WO3 grade, so as to highlight those blocks above the cut-offs described in Section 15.2. Any
inferred resource blocks within stope outlines were treated as planned dilution with
mineralised waste, with any grades greater than 0.2% WO3 set to 0.2%.
All stope blocks were automatically assigned block IDs, based on the level interval to which
they belong. An example of the stope block layouts of the F2 skarn zone is shown in Figure
15-1. This also shows the maximum span limits for F2, stemming from geotechnical limit
maps. The stope block layouts for the updated HW zone are shown in Figure 15-2.
Stope blocks were overlaid onto the resource block model, and evaluated. At the same time,
the tonnages relating to the different span limits within each stope block were also
determined, from which an aggregate cut-off grade for the stope block was determined. The
stope blocks’ average grades were determined, included any waste as planned dilution. The
grades were then further decreased with the unplanned dilution factor of 5%. Block contents
were only confirmed as reserves if the resultant average stope grades were above the
derived block cut-off.
A summary of the resultant reserves is shown in the Table 15-2. A grade-tonnage table of the
stope block reserves is shown in Table 15-3.
July 2016
138
Technical Report on The Sangdong Project
July 2016
139
Technical Report on The Sangdong Project
Notes
. All reserves have a probable category
. WO3 Cut-offs applied:
0.36% Max Spans <=3m
0.28% Max Spans >3m <=6m
0.23% Max Spans +6m
. Level restrictions:
. Down to -1 level (633m) for the non-HW zones
. Mining Factors applied
. Minimum thickness = 2.2m
. Unplanned dilution = 5%
. Unplanned losses = 5%
July 2016
140
Technical Report on The Sangdong Project
16 MINING METHODS
Extensive mining has taken place within the Sangdong Mine property and at the time of its
closure, the mine had been developed on more than 20 levels, between the elevations of 242
and 755 masl, with a total length of 20 km of development. The mine is flooded to -1 level
(633mRL) where a tunnel and trench, situated at the level floor elevation, drains water out to
a valley in the mountainside. The level reference system is summarised in Table 16-1.
The mine is located on a mountainside, with two old and one new entry portal situated on the
Sangdong level. Old entry portals are also located on the Taebaek, Baegun, Jangsang and
Sunyeong levels. A ramp from the Sangdong accesses the -1 level at the eastern end of the
level. There are several inclined shafts and vertical shafts that were used to access lower
levels. A plan of all levels, overlain with sample data, is shown in Figure 16-1.
Existing verified level development on levels Taebaek, Sangdong and -1 are shown in Figure
16-2, Figure 16-3 and Figure 16-4, respectively. A composite drawing of all levels down to
the -1 level is shown in Figure 16-5.
A significant portion of the opening accessing the Mina zone, where it was mined, have caved
in but can be rehabilitated if required.
The old ventilation incline located at the west end of mine is in good condition and may be
used as the main exhaust air shaft and a secondary egress. Its collar is at 856 mRL.
The existing administration and geology buildings are located on surface on a plateau near
the Sangdong portals.
July 2016
141
Technical Report on The Sangdong Project
July 2016
142
Technical Report on The Sangdong Project
July 2016
143
Technical Report on The Sangdong Project
July 2016
144
Technical Report on The Sangdong Project
July 2016
145
Technical Report on The Sangdong Project
A geotechnical study was completed by Turner Mining and Geotechnical Pty Ltd in 2014,
which comprised:
The current proposed mining area extends from -2 Level to Sangdong and Taebaek Levels
on the HW, Main, F1, F2, F3 and F4 Zones. The geotechnical study was focussed on the
HW, Main, F2 and F3 zones.
Intact rock tests were undertaken by Geomechanics Co. Ltd., in Kangwon-Do. The results of
these tests are summarised in Table 16-2.
There were no records found of stress measurements having been undertaken at Sangdong.
The stress regime used for stability analyses has therefore been estimated from the weight of
overburden and from visual assessment of conditions relative to other mines. Virgin stress
magnitudes vary considerably under hilly terrain and a reasonably conservative depth of
350m has been assumed. The hangingwall stress assumed for the stability analysis has a
July 2016
146
Technical Report on The Sangdong Project
stress concentration factor of 1.5. The assumptions leading to the representative virgin stress
of 10 MPa and hangingwall stoping stress of 15 MPa are shown in Table 16-3.
The Q-system (Barton, Lien and Lunde, 1974) was used to determine the rockmass strength.
Q is the preferred method for assessing rock mass strength due to its accepted use in the
Stability Graph Method for determining stable stope span limits and for empirical relationships
between Q and excavation support requirements. The rockmass strength was calculated for
the hangingwall domains of each of the zones, for the zones themselves and for the footwall
of the F3 Zone (where permanent access would be located).
Table 16-4 shows the parameters and results for Q′ and Q for the main domains. The results
for Q are all in the ‘poor’ and ‘fair’ categories (Table 16-5, Barton, 1974).
July 2016
147
Technical Report on The Sangdong Project
RQD and Q values have been contoured using the Surfer software, for each studied zone
across the mine, as shown in the example in Figure 16-6.
July 2016
148
Technical Report on The Sangdong Project
All non-caving mining methods require the determination of maximum spans to ensure
extraction is maximised whilst at the same time minimising the risk of collapse and loss of
reserves. Two empirical methods have been used to determine the maximum spans:
Data has been related to the Stability Graph, as shown in Figure 16-7. Data and estimates of
the critical hydraulic spans calculated are shown in the last column in Table 16-6. The A, B
and C stability factors are based on current mine designs, estimated strengths and stresses,
core logging data and calculated joint dips.
This method does not consider instabilities caused by individual wedges and the rises will still
need to be supported with rockbolts.
Maximum unsupported span variations were also determined for each zone, and contoured
maps prepared. These were overlain on plans for the reserve blocking-out process in the
current study (Section 15.3).
July 2016
149
Technical Report on The Sangdong Project
Support requirements have been estimated from core logging data using empirical analysis
based on RQD, Q and from observations of exposed rock mass. The modified rock
reinforcement chart (Turner, Green and Teasdale, 2006), as shown in Figure 16-8, was used
for the rockmass quality Q = 6 (SRF=1, ‘medium stress, favourable stress conditions’
assuming no mining induced stresses).
July 2016
150
Technical Report on The Sangdong Project
Small-sized development would require Category 3 support, i.e. ‘systematic bolting ’ and
jumbo development would require Category 4 support i.e. ‘systematic bolting and mesh’.
In current underground excavations, falls of ground in development and stopes are generally
located at the intersection of faults and fault-associated jointing. These sections of poor
ground are generally supported with timber sets which have deteriorated and require re-
supporting.
Very poor ground towards the hangingwall of the shale unit required concrete arches for
permanent stability but this appears to improve towards the far west. Old rockbolts and
timber support should be assumed to have lost all load-bearing capacity. Old concrete that
has not cracked will generally be stable, as will most steel and concrete sets.
Areas sprayed with old shotcrete appear to have maintained their integrity, with small rocks
supported. The old shotcrete was only 5-10mm thick and is not capable of supporting 0.5m
thick blocks.
July 2016
151
Technical Report on The Sangdong Project
Current development primarily requires check-scaling to remove smaller loose rocks and to
determine which areas need supporting. Area requiring rehabilitation would involve the
removal of all timber sets and steel sets (where the timber lagging is non-functioning). The
most effective support of poor ground sections will be achieved with rockbolting and shotcrete
or rockbolting and mesh, using either Swellex-type bolts or resin grouted solid steel bars.
New areas of jumbo development should be supported with mesh or shotcrete plus 2.4m split
sets (46mm, galvanised) over the backs and shoulders. Wall support will be required where
steep jointing is likely to create slabs, especially in areas close to stoping and in ore drives
adjacent to pillars. Mesh should be galvanised weldmesh, 5.6mm wire thickness, 100mm x
100mm apertures, with sheet size chosen to suit drive size and optimise bolting. Bolt spacing
will be designed to pin the mesh sheets with 0.2m overlaps.
Where shotcrete is used it should be sprayed after loading, watering down and scaling.
Hydraulic scaling is recommended with high-pressure pump attached to the shotcrete sprayer
Bolting should be undertaken once the shotcrete has cured sufficiently to prevent fall-off
during bolting (1MPa strength at 1 hour required).
Wide spans in stopes will be more susceptible to wedge block failure than in development
and the use of split sets is not recommended. Resin grouted bolts or Swellex-type
expandable bolts are far more effective in supporting large blocks. Rises should be
supported with 2.0m solid steel Threadbar rockbolts installed with resin on a 1.5m pattern or
Swellex-type bolts. Shorter bolts would require closer spacings.
Wide excavations and 3-way and 4-way intersections should be supported with cable bolts.
The length and spacing would be dependent on dimensions and structures, but could involve
fully grouted (cement) 8.5m twin-strand bulbed, 15.2mm cable bolts on a 2.5m pattern.
Cables should be tensioned to 50kN and installed with 8-10mm thick plates. The quality of
cable bolt installations was extremely good and this should be continued.
16.2.3 Earthquakes
The seismic hazard data for the Sangdong area has been assessed from the Global Seismic
Hazard Assessment Program data (GSHAP, 1999). The data indicated a 10% probability of
exceeding between 0.2 and 0.8 m/s2 peak ground acceleration over 50 years (based on a 475
year return period). This falls in the low-hazard category and increased acceleration has not
been considered in any design analysis.
July 2016
152
Technical Report on The Sangdong Project
Selection of the mining method requires a flexible design, which is suitable to the geometry of
the ore body and typical types of variations. The majority of the ore zones to be mined are
relatively shallow dipping, with dips between 20° and 30°, so ore will not naturally flow by
gravity on the footwall.
In the A-Z Feasibility Study, the methods proposed were inclined panel (IP) mining, to be
applied in thick orebody areas, with panels that would be mined in different sections; and up-
dip panel mining (UP), which would be applied in narrow areas with slushers and hand-held
drilling equipment.
For this present study, it was decided not to rely on hand-held drilling equipment and
slushers. Instead, methods applied would be planned for the use of mechanized mobile
diesel powered mining equipment in all areas. Based on this requirement and the latest
understanding of the orebody geometry and mining areas, and evaluation of the resources,
including in-situ thickness variations, it was decided to apply two proposed mining methods,
as summarised below:
• Mechanized Inclined Panel mining (MIP) – areas where the thickness less than 3 metres.
• Cut-and-Fill (CAF) – for areas where the thickness is greater than 3 metres.
Selection of these mining methods was based on plan projections of grades and thicknesses,
along with examination of many cross-sections across the whole orebody, as shown in
Appendix C. With the requirement for mechanised access in all stopes, the in-situ geological
models have all initially been diluted to a minimum thickness of 2.2m. Based on assessment
of the relative proportions of these different thickness thresholds for the two mining methods,
the approximate split between MIP and CAF mining will be approximately 40%:60%. This
ratio will likely change with future Phase 7 drilling and as additional reserves get added from
the HW zone.
A plan view of the current reserves, with the different areas split by mining method, is shown
in Figure 16-9. The central and western part of the F2 and F3 reserves are generally below
3m true thickness, and so will be mined by MIP. The rest of actual reserves will be exploited
by CAF. Within the eastern part of the F2 and F3, certain parts of the Halo zone in-between
will also be mineable, allowing a greater overall thickness, which will enable CAF stoping, as
depicted in Figure 16-10. A plan and cross-section showing the F2-Halo-F3 relationship are
shown in Figure 16-11 and Figure 16-12.
July 2016
153
Technical Report on The Sangdong Project
July 2016
154
Technical Report on The Sangdong Project
July 2016
155
Technical Report on The Sangdong Project
Some areas of the F2 and F3 reserves will be represent a transition from thicker (CAF) to
thinner (MIP) parts in Figure 16-13.
Figure 16-13. Transition from CAF to MIP Stoping With Thickness Variation
The eastern part of the Main zone is 8m+ thick, and so amenable to CAF. A plan and cross-
section of this zone are shown in Figure 16-14 and Figure 16-15. The cross-section also
shows the F1 zone just below the MAIN zone, which will be mined as part of the stope unit.
July 2016
156
Technical Report on The Sangdong Project
Figure 16-15. Section C-C: Eastern Part of Main Zone Reserve Area
July 2016
157
Technical Report on The Sangdong Project
The entire HW zone reserve area on the -1 and Sangdong levels has an appreciable
thickness and so can be exploited in Cut-and-fill. A plan and cross-section of this reserve
area are shown in Figure 16-16 and Figure 16-17.
July 2016
158
Technical Report on The Sangdong Project
A plan of the of the western part of the HW reserve area is shown in Figure 16-18.
This method has evolved from Inclined Panel (IP) method described in the A-Z Feasibility
Study. This previous method had primary and secondary panels, with slashing from small
drives first developed up the centre of each panel.
The envisaged MIP method involves drifting on apparent dip, so as not to exceed a gradient
of 15%, and so allow trackless equipment. The stope development is planned to be
symmetrical, with panels being extended both up and down from access galleries, as shown
in Figure 16-19. This method is also flexible in that it can be easily adapted to room and pillar
(as used previously at Sangdong) if local conditions do not favour complete extraction with
primary and secondary panels.
July 2016
159
Technical Report on The Sangdong Project
This method is very flexible, in allowing working upwards or downwards, and conversion to
cut-and-fill. The development of HW zone can be done in between stope access to F2 and
F3, which will save development lengths between the base development and stope access.
The F2 can be mined from the Sangdong level to the -1 Level, and at the same time upwards
into the F3 between the Sangdong and Taebaek levels. After stoping and backfilling
operations have finished in these two zones, the mining direction can be reversed, exploiting
F2 upwards and F3 downwards from Sangdong level.
July 2016
160
Technical Report on The Sangdong Project
5. The primary panel(s) can then be backfilled with paste backfill and cement. As the drifts
are inclined this filling should end up tight to the back.
6. After curing the primary panels’ backfill, secondary panels can be mined out in the same
way as the primaries. The backfilling of secondary stopes can be done with a reduced
amount of cement.
To reduce the dilution associated with the development of the primary drives, separate blasts
can be made on faces with narrow ore thicknesses, so that some waste can mined
separately. This will reduce likely dilution in this phase to approximately 15%, as depicted in
Figure 16-20. This primary and secondary blasting has been accounted for in estimating the
stoping costs.
Figure 16-20. Dilution Associated With Initial Drifting Phase of MIP Mining
In the slashing operation, dilution can be dramatically reduced, with parallel drilling to the ore
structure, as well as a much reduced height, as shown in Figure 16-21. All drilling for these
slashes can be inside the mineralized structure, with up to two blasts of 1.5 m width on the
up-side. Dilution of 15% (maximum) on drifting and almost no dilution with slashing, should
give a combined maximum dilution of 7.5 %, and an average dilution of approximately 5%.
July 2016
161
Technical Report on The Sangdong Project
Another important characteristic of scheelite is the visual recognition of that mineral under
short wave UV light. With this feature, internal waste dilution can be reduced by blasting and
transporting waste to separate neighbouring stope for backfill.
The ore blasted at the stopes of Mechanized Inclined Panel will be loaded by LHDs to 40t
dump trucks, or alternatively smaller 15t Korean trucks, in the main development adjacent to
the strike drives.
A mining recovery of 95% has been assumed, based on the stoping method envisaged, and
the ability of visual recognition of scheelite using UV light.
July 2016
162
Technical Report on The Sangdong Project
This method will be applied to ore zone areas with a thickness of 3m and higher, up to 20m
depending on the local ore thickness. It can be considered a simplification of the previous
Inclined Panel Stoping, and in some areas it could also be adapted with uppers for extraction
of panels up to 12m in height. One particular advantage of this method is the potential high
selectivity, with separate removal of internal waste encountered.
From the base gallery, a cross cut can be opened up, mining though to the footwall of the ore
structure, as shown in Figure 16-22. A strike drive can then be developed in ore at the
footwall contact, for the length of the stope panel, as shown in Figure 16-23.
From the strike drive, the primary panels are opened in the ore, perpendicular to the strike
drive and developed across to the footwall contact, as shown in Figure 16-24. These panels
wiil be inclined upwards, to a maximum gradient of 15% to assist with tightfilling during
subsequent backfilling operations, and also to create longer stopes. Both primary and
secondary panels are nominally planned to be 6m x 6m in cross-section.
An additional footwall drive will facilitate ventilation and backfilling. Some others will need
individual barricades. After primary panels have then been backfilled, and time left for curing,
secondary stope panels can be opened up. For the excavated secondaries, many panels
may be backfilled with just two fill barricades. Some others will need individual barricades,
depending on local conditions.
After the backfilling of the entire first 6 m lift, access to the next 6m lift will be from the
hanging-wall incline, as shown in Figure 16-26. Access to stope panels behind the incline will
need to be done by the footwall strike drift, as shown in Figure 16-26. The backfilling will
continue through the footwall strike drive, with multiple barricades in the primary stope panels
and with two barricades per sector for secondary stope panels.
A diagram showing the mining of several stope lifts is shown in Figure 16-27. All mining
operations will from inside areas of relatively thick ore, so dilution will be minimised. There
will be some dilution in secondary panels from primary panels’ backfill. The identification of
internal waste will be assisted by the use of UV lamps, as shown in Figure 16-29. Overall, a
5% dilution has been assumed for this method, after the application of a 2.2m minimum
mining thickness.
July 2016
163
Technical Report on The Sangdong Project
July 2016
164
Technical Report on The Sangdong Project
July 2016
165
Technical Report on The Sangdong Project
Figure 16-26. CAF – Next Lift By Access from Hanging Wall Incline
July 2016
166
Technical Report on The Sangdong Project
In the MIP mining, drilling will be done with single arm electric/hydraulic jumbos. Drill steels
will be 3m, allowing an effective advance/blast of 2.1m in drifting, and 1.5m advance/blast in
the slashing. Slashing lengths will be adapted to the local ore exposures ore blending
requirements. The drive patterns will typically be a 600mm x 600 mm pattern, with an extra 9
burn-cut holes, 4 of which are reamed. The slash holes will be drilled on a 900 mm by 900
mm pattern. Perimeter holes may be drilled on a similar pattern, depending ground
conditions.
In the CAF zones, drilling will be with two arm electric-hydraulic jumbos, that will have 3.6m
rods, drilling 44 mm drillholes of 3.1 m length and an effective 2.6 m advance per blast. The
burn cuts will have a similar pattern to MIP, and the remaining drillholes will have a pattern of
July 2016
167
Technical Report on The Sangdong Project
All zones to mine will be well drained, production drillholes will be blasted with ANFO. If there
are wet zones, drillholes will be blasted with cartridge emulsions. All explosives will be
initiated using non-electric caps, initiated by two electric caps connected to a central blasting
system.
Mucking and drilling operations will run 2 shifts, with the 3rd shift for blasting and ventilation.
As the operation would be using two mining methods with multiple faces scattered along a big
area, explosive gases will be quite extensive throughout the mine, so a full shift is warranted
for ventilation and safety inspection before the 1st shift of the following day.
Haulage drifts, main access drifts and CAF stope cross-cuts will be supported with swellex
and welded wire mesh screen. The majority of MIP panels will not require support, but in
some poorer zones, swellex bolts will be installed. All support drilling will be drilled with
jumbo and installed from scissor lift trucks in the trackless development headings or from the
floor and muckpiles.
Generally cable bolts will not be required, as both mining methods will be limited to maximum
6m spans. In the zones of worst quality ground identified in the geotechnical study, additional
cable-bolting will be required. Cables will generally be bulged twin strand 7-10 metres long
and grouted in place. Drilling of holes will utilize a pneumatic long hole drill on a rubber tired
rig. Cables will be inserted manually from a scissor lift work platform and grouted using a
small grouting pump. Cable support will be designed for the ground conditions and to
maximize the span of the stopes that can safely be mined.
Mucking will be done only by LHDs. In the MIP stopes, 2.3m3 LHDs will be used, and in CAF,
bigger 5.25 m3 may also be used. The ore will then be loaded onto dump trucks, for direct
transportation to the processing plant.
July 2016
168
Technical Report on The Sangdong Project
16.5 Development
New development headings will be drilled off using 44 mm diameter drill holes, with 4 cut
holes reamed. Slashes will be drilled off to the required width and height using 44 mm
diameter drill holes as well. Headings will be blasted using a combination of ANFO, stick
emulsion for the lifters, perimeter blasting products for the wall and back holes and nonel
caps, initiated by electric caps. A typical drift cross-section is shown in Figure 16-30.
Ground support will consist of 1.8 metres long resin grouted rebar, installed on a 1.2 m by 1.2
m pattern, along with welded wire mesh screen on the backs and walls to within 1.5 m of the
floor. The ground support will be installed using jumbos and installed from scissor lifts. All
services will be installed from scissor lifts.
Services installed in these drifts and ramps will include a 152 mm service waterline, a 152
mm discharge water line, 500 MCM power cable, 1000 volt cable, 48-fibre fibre optic data and
communication cable and a central blasting line.
July 2016
169
Technical Report on The Sangdong Project
For stope development, the ore haulage drifts will initially be developed with the back of the
drifts located at the hanging-wall ore/waste contact, at the end of the access cross-cuts. The
drifts will be developed nominally 5m wide x 5 m high, with a shanty back to the up-dip side of
the drive. This will accommodate the mining equipment, allow loading of trucks in the cross-
cut entrances and coincide with the 6m mining slices planned across much of the ore body.
Ore cross-cuts and raises will be developed off these drifts as stope accesses. A 10 m pillar
will be left between the ore haulage drift and the stoping panels. The stoping panels will be
developed from the ore cross-cuts.
The mine development will require two 2 boom electric/hydraulic jumbos, two 5.25 cubic
metre bucket LHDs, 2 platforms for explosive chargers, 2 back hoes for scaling, small
cleaning works and accessory works, 6 Dump Trucks of 15ton and three light utility vehicles.
Mine production (done by contractors) will require 1 jumbo of 2 arms, 3 jumbos of 1 arm, 2
platforms for explosive charge and accessory services, 1 back hoe of 0.6 m3 and 1 Back hoe
of 0.15 m3, 1 LHD of 2.3 m3 and 1 LHD of 5.25 m3. Production works will also require 2 light
utility vehicles. The equipment list for the underground mine is shown in Table 16-7.
July 2016
170
Technical Report on The Sangdong Project
• Underground infrastructure.
The mine services group will also assist the safety department when needed. Services will
have 1 lift truck, for the backfill pipes installation and maintenance, and one light truck for the
transportation of materials, equipment and backfill pipes.
Maintenance of the mine equipments will be the responsibility of the contractor. For these
activities, the contractor will have 1 light vehicle, available at all times during the two
production shifts.
Mine staff, engineering and geology will require two light utility vehicles.
Ore and waste haulage to surface will require six 15 tonne trucks. Those trucks are not
normal mine trucks, but reinforced road trucks as used in Korea for tunneling and
underground limestone quarries, as shown in Figure 16-31.
July 2016
171
Technical Report on The Sangdong Project
Mine production of 640 ktpa is schedule, stemming from approximately 40% of ore from MIP
mining and 60% from CAF mining. Development is scheduled to support both mining
methods’ requirements, on a yearly basis. Mining will take place initially on the -1 Level, both
on the Main and F2 structures. Stoping will then proceed onto other mineralized structures
and towards higher levels. Zones above the Jangsan and below -1 Levels will be left until
later in the mine life.
Development crews in waste headings will generally have multiple headings available. For
development scheduling, each crew and equipment is scheduled to advance 2.6 rounds
(each of 2.6 metres length) per day, on 4 m by 4m or 5m by 5m headings. This will give a
total for the two crews of 270m/month, or 3200 m of advance per year. In addition to this the
crew will also develop the necessary safety bays, slashing, cutouts etc.
MIP stopes in the drifting phase will produce 60t/blast, so 13 blasts/day would be required if
all ore comes from drifting. This would be achievable with 3 jumbos working the 2 production
shifts, making a minimum of 2.1 faces/shift. The MIP method has multiple faces were both
jumbos and LHDs can go from one face to another with a minimum loss of time, giving a good
usage of the equipment; as blasting times are in the 3rd shift. Jumbos and LHDs can also go
continuously from 1 face to another, making advance on 3 faces/shift quite realistic. The
situation described all drifting is conservative, as half of the production from MIP stopes will
come from slashing.
It is assumed for the current study that at any time, two MIP stopes will be in full production,
one in the preparation phase and one in the backfilling phase; for a total of 4 active stopes. In
reality only 3 active stopes will be required, as strike drives can be developed simultaneously
with the stoping phase in the same stopes.
Each face in CAF mining will produce an advance/blast of 2.6m, for 270t of ore. This means
that four faces will be required for daily production. One two-boom jumbo can be used for the
drilling required in 2 shifts, as the faces will be close together and always available for
mucking and drilling.
July 2016
172
Technical Report on The Sangdong Project
Prior to multiple faces being available, stope preparation will require execution of an incline up
to the upper level for ventilation and backfilling. For a typical CAF stope of 250m length, it
could take up to 10 days for backfilling, plus 28 days for curing, meaning that each stope
could involve almost 2 months without production over the whole stope cycle. It has therefore
been estimated that the mine will require a minimum of 3 CAF stopes active at any time: one
in preparation, one in production and the other in backfilling phase. This is readily achievable
in the zone accessible via -1 Level gallery into the HW zone, where the HW mineralization is
recognized along a minimum length of 600m (as shown in Figure 16-18).
The mine development schedule also includes rehabilitation and enlarging of existing lateral
development, as well as new waste and ore development. The development schedule will
provide access in place, at least one year before ore zone stope development and mining is
required. Table 16-8 shows the schedule for development metres and estimated costs.
This planned development is shown in Figure 16-32. Sectors 1 to 5 are on -1 level and
sectors 6 to 8 are on Sangdong Level. Sectors 2 and 9 are ramps connecting both levels.
With this development layout, a well-defined ventilation circuit is also created, along with
flexibility for the use of equipment among the different zones of the mine, as well as access to
escape routes.
The pre-production development program is based on starting with 2 work faces: one
developing the ramp between Sangdong and -1 Levels (sector 2), and another continuing a
new gallery (sector 6) through Sangdong Level. After finishing the development of the ramp,
July 2016
173
Technical Report on The Sangdong Project
the new portal can be started on -1 level from the surface and its connection to -1 Level
(sectors 1-1 and 1-2). The location of this new adit is shown in Figure 16-33.
In parallel, sectors 3 (access to the HW zone) and 3-1 (access to Main Zone reserve) can be
started. After zone 3, the development can continue through the development of the actual
HW gallery off -1 Level (sector 4), and in parallel through the Sangdong Level gallery destined
to give access to F2 and F3 (sector 7). The Sangdong Level development can continue
through new gallery (sector 8), to link to the ventilation shaft of west sector of the mine.
Preparation can then start for the stopes that will be accessed from Sangdong Level. The
continuation of the HW gallery on -1 Level will be developed, parallel to the HW mineralized
structure (sector 5), for 174 m until reaching a point for the new ramp to be built at the west
end of the mine (sector 9). This will link the -1 Level with the Sangdong Level, and will
provide ventilation for the entire exploitable areas accessible from -1 Level.
The mine production schedule is based on mining 450 ktpa of ore for Year 1, and thereafter
640 ktpa (1,830 tpd for 350 days per year), as presented in Table 16-9.
July 2016
174
Technical Report on The Sangdong Project
July 2016
175
Technical Report on The Sangdong Project
July 2016
176
Technical Report on The Sangdong Project
16.8 Backfilling
All stopes will be backfilled with paste backfill, cemented and uncemented, which will also
minimize surface tailings management. The paste backfill will consist of classified mill
tailings. Paste backfill will be delivered at approximately 70% solids by weight, at a rate of
100 tph.
Paterson & Cooke (P&C) carried out backfill testing for the Sangdong project in 2011 for Tetra
Tech. Their report is contained in Appendices of the Tetra Tech Sangdong Feasibility Study.
The backfill testing program pertained to paste fill and tested tailings size distribution,
rheology, and strength with various binder content. The tailings were found to be medium
grained with D80, D50, and D10 sizes of 100, 33, and 10 microns, respectively. They were
also found to have rheology characteristics adequate for paste backfill. Strength gains over 7
and 28 days curing time were found to be adequate. Once the processing plant detailed
design is complete, a bulk sample of representative tailings product produced by the
processing plant will be prepared and tested as paste backfill. The testing will determine the
potential fines component to be removed, to allow for adequate backfill drainage and to
develop binder recipes for strength. This backfill testing can be performed during the detailed
design phase.
Paste backfilling for Mechanised Inclined Panel and Cut-and-Fill stopes will use
approximately 65% of the tailings produced. The paste filling operation envisaged will be
almost continuous. To achieve this, several stopes will need to be simultaneously in the
process of backfilling, to allow for backfill fences water pressure control and other operational
constraints.
The remaining portion of backfill not placed in active mining voids will be backfilled on voids
below -1 level or sent to the co-disposal facility, to give consistency and long term stability to
the waste rock. It may be possible to transport some of this material to cement factories,
receiving some discount on the transportation cost. The old Main Zone mining areas, are
also available to store excess tailings. By the time of its closure, the mine had been
developed and mined on more than 20 levels, between the elevations of 242 and 755 mRL.
Most of the mining was carried out in the Main Zone. The primary mining method used was
inclined room-and-pillar. Plans of the old workings indicate that many of the pillars were left
intact to support the stope roofs and that extensive voids remain within the Main Zone. The
other significant area of voids is in the F2 subzone of the Footwall Zone. This void is
estimated to extend from 484500E to 485000E (i.e. approximately 500 m along strike). The
backfilling of the Main and FW Zones stopes would ensure that these areas will not cave, as
mining in the HW Zones progress.
July 2016
177
Technical Report on The Sangdong Project
Paste backfill would be delivered to the top of the stopes by the paste backfill pipelines. The
backfill would be pumped from the backfill plant, on the Sangdong level terrace, in a 102 mm
Schedule 80 steel pipeline. The main distribution line would be installed in the Taebaek old
galleries, that have been recommissioned for that purpose and through Sangdong main drift
over the length of the orebody to be mined. This main line would feed backfill lines to the
mining levels below, initially the Sangdong and -1 levels.
The backfill distribution system is shown in Figure 16-34. The backfill plant will be close to
the old KTMC ore bin, where there is enough space to build the plant and accessory
infrastructure. There will be a short pipeline from the backfill plant to the waste storage facility
for co-disposal of the tailings and for storage in case of emergency. There is also some
storage capacity in the tailings thickener. The site of the backfill plant will also allow the
circulation and loading of the trucks that will transport the tailings to co-disposal or cement
factories.
The backfill pipeline will enter underground by Taebaek Level, where existing galleries will be
used for distribution to the stoping areas, as shown in Figure 16-35. The connection with
Sangdong Level will be done through a gallery (2 in Figure 16-36) to access areas below a
caved zone on Taebaek Level. From there, the pipes will go through one of the MIP galleries
down to base galleries on the Sangdong Level, where it will serve stopes accessed from
there.
July 2016
178
Technical Report on The Sangdong Project
July 2016
179
Technical Report on The Sangdong Project
The backfill pipeline that will serve the HW zone will go through the base galleries of
Sangdong Level, until connecting with the HW strike drive, from where the backfilling of the
HW Cut-and-Fill stopes will be possible .
Future exploitation zones in the upper zones of the Taeabek and Jangsang levels will be
backfilled through the ramp which will be developed on the east side of the deposit. The
backfilling of lower zones of the deposit will also be done through the east side ramp.
Fill fences, constructed at the stope entrances of CAF stope areas, would consist of a timber
frame anchored to the rock at the floor, walls, and back with 25mm dowels, wiremesh, and a
synthetic filtering material. Perforated drainage pipes would be installed to collect water from
the paste fill and transport it to the other side of the fence lowering the pressure on the fence.
Backfill would be delivered to the high point in the stope, via a HDPE pipe hanging at the back
of the stope. Water pressure will be monitored and filling would be interrupted if pressure
reached a safety limit.
To use excess tailings for backfilling of the old Main zone stopes, these old stopes would
require dewatering to their lowest extent. This could mean that the whole mine would require
dewatering, to the lowest level before backfilling of oldest past-mined stopes could be
completely feasible. Access to the lower levels for this purpose would require dewatering the
mine below level -1, rehabilitation of an inclined shaft, and the installation of a hoisting facility
for the transportation of workers, materials, and equipment between levels. This option has
not been included in the current study. Backfilling of the old past-mined stopes would also
require fill fences to be constructed in key areas, to protect existing drifts and inclined shafts
for future use. These voids could also be partly filled with development waste and internal
waste encountered in stopes.
July 2016
180
Technical Report on The Sangdong Project
16.9 Ventilation
The ventilation system at Sangdong is designed to adequately dilute the exhaust gases
produced by diesel equipment. The required air volume was calculated as 0.05 cubic metres
per second (100 cubic feet per minute) per brake horsepower of diesel equipment. The
horsepower rating of the underground equipment was determined, and utilization factors were
applied to estimate the total amount of air required (see Table 16-11). At full production a
total air volume of 185 m3/s (390,000 cfm), including losses and miscellaneous usage areas,
is required.
Two independent systems are planned; one for the Sangdong level, and one for the -1 level.
Figure 16-37 shows a mine ventilation schematic, with main intakes and exhaust air routings.
The main high pressure fans will be the exhaust fans installed on each level at the existing
inclined ventilation shaft, located at the west end of the mine. Fresh air will be pulled through
the portal on each level. Air will travel in the main drifts and through the access cross-cuts to
the ore haulage drifts. The air will be distributed to stopes from the haulage drifts. Exhaust
air from the stopes will re-enter the haulage drifts and travelways, in the opposite direction to
the fresh air flow, to access cross-cuts and out to the main drifts. Air will flow in the main
drifts and exhaust to the existing west inclined (shaft) exhaust ventilation raise and up the
raise to surface.
July 2016
181
Technical Report on The Sangdong Project
All exhaust fans installations will be located underground (to avoid surface disturbance and
noise in a forestry area) at the West Exhaust Ventilation Raise. On the Sangdong and -1
Levels, 2-60-30-1500RPM, type 2000, 250/300 HP fans with a capacity of approximately 80
m3/s (170,000 cfm) with maximum operating head pressure capacity of approximately 2.5 to
2.9 kPa will be installed, where most of the equipment will initially be operating. As levels
below -1 Level are brought into production, 250/300 HP fans of the same capacity as those
on the Sangdong and -1 Levels will be installed on the levels (or moved from a level where
the main exhaust fan is no longer required). Fans will be variable speed to facilitate adjusting
air volume delivery to working areas, as required.
Fresh air delivery to the stopes will be controlled using auxiliary ventilation fans and ducting.
Ventilation regulators, doors, and bulkheads will also be used to control the airflow in the
mine.
The ramp development will use 150 hp fans. Other lateral development will use a
combination of 100 HP and 150 HP fans depending on the heading length. Development
headings are sized to accommodate large ducting (107 mm), to reduce head losses.
Auxiliary ventilation delivery to stopes will typically use 75 or 100 hp fans, with 914 mm (36 in)
flexible ducting.
July 2016
182
Technical Report on The Sangdong Project
17 RECOVERY METHODS
The process flowsheet and plant designs rely on the same flowsheet as used in the Tetra
Tech 2012 Feasibility Study, and confirmed by pilot plant tests performed on Sangdong ore
by the Guangzhou Research Institute of Non-ferrous Metals. The equipment considered in
the 2012 Tetra Tech study has now been resized by METSO for the smaller plant capacity
now being currently considered.
The present report contains a flowsheet developed for the recovery of a scheelite through a
flotation process, producing a final concentrate grading approximately 65% WO3. Based on
test results, the estimated tungsten overall recovery will be 81% with an average mass yield
of 0.86%. The processing plant will have a capacity of 1,920 metric tons per day. The details
of the process design criteria are summarised in Table 17-1 below.
Design
Designation Unit
value
Scheduled operating days per year 365 Days
Equipment utilisation
- Crushing 68.5 %
- Others 92.2 %
Plant capacity 1,920 tpd
Plant feed analysis
WO3 0.69 %
Moisture (assumed) 10 %
Plant recovery
Tungsten overall recovery 81 %
Final concentrate grade 65 % WO 3
Annual production
Tungsten final concentrate 5,519 tpy
The main process steps for treating the Sangdong ore are primary, secondary and tertiary
crushing and stockpiling; grinding; flotation divided into two (2) sub-circuits (sulphide flotation
and tungsten flotation); thickening; filtration and packaging section; a waste water treatment
facility; and services section. Figure 17-1 shows the process flow diagram.
July 2016
183
Technical Report on The Sangdong Project
July 2016
184
Technical Report on The Sangdong Project
The run of mine (ROM) ore from the mine will be received in a feed hopper equipped with an
inclined 600 mm square opening grizzly. A rock breaker will be used to bring the grizzly
oversize down to 600 mm. The ore will be extracted from the feed hopper by an apron feeder
which discharges onto a belt conveyor. The belt conveyor will feed a primary jaw crusher
through a static grizzly feeder, which prevents the feeding of the fine fraction to the jaw. The
jaw crusher discharge and the fine fraction will be conveyed by a 914 mm transfer belt
conveyor. A magnet is located at the head of the transfer belt conveyor to remove steel
fragments which might be present in the ore.
The transfer belt conveyor will feed a single deck screen with an aperture of 19 mm. The
screen oversize is directed to a surge bin hopper which feeds a secondary standard cone
crusher in closed circuit with the single deck screen. The screen undersize (at P100=19 mm)
will be carried via a 914 mm belt conveyor to a coarse ore stockpile (approximately 2,000 t).
The crushing facilities will be equipped with a dust collection system consisting of a bag
house with a fan to minimize the dust exhausted into the atmosphere.
17.2.2 Grinding
The ore will be drawn from the coarse ore stockpile by one or two variable speed apron
feeders. The feeders discharge onto a 914 mm belt conveyor carrying the ore to a Rod mill of
3.3 m diameter x 4.9 m long, driven by a variable speed 725 kW WR motor. The feed to the
Rod mill will be monitored by a weight scale and controlled by automatic adjustment of the
Apron feeders. The grinding water addition will also be controlled to suit the ore feed rate, to
maintain the selected pulp density.
The Rod mill discharge will be classified through a cyclone cluster consisting of 10 cyclones
of 250 mm diameter (9 in operation and 1 standby). The cyclones underflow will be reground
in a ball mill of 4.2 m diameter x 4.6 m long, driven by a synchronous 1,400 kW WR motor.
The ball mill discharge is also directed to the cyclones cluster feed pump box. The circulating
load is 250%, thus taking into account the high ore hardness.
The cyclone overflow, at a P80 of 75 microns, will be directed by gravity to the sulphide
flotation circuit conditioning tank. There is an inline sampler installed in the cyclone overflow
line. This sampler delivers a continuous flotation feed sample stream for analysis.
July 2016
185
Technical Report on The Sangdong Project
17.3 Flotation
The pulp from the 7-minutes conditioning tank will be pumped to the sulphides rougher
flotation bank (2+3 x 15 m3 cells for molybdenum roughing and 2+2 x 15 m3 for other sulphide
roughing). The rougher concentrates will be pumped by vertical spindle pumps to the
respective cleaner banks, each of 2 x 5 m3 cells. The cleaner concentrate is directed to the
final tails pump box. The cleaner tails are combined with the rougher tails and pumped to a
20 m diameter inter-stage thickener. An inline sampler located in the sulphides floatation final
tails, delivers a continuous rougher tail sample stream for analysis.
Testwork to simplify this circuit is underway, with the object of having a single bulk sulphide
float and single stage cleaning. Elimination of the rougher tails thickener is also considered
possible, through modification of the water treatment plant (see Section 18.6.3).
The use of a thickener before the tungsten primary flotation circuit is intended to reduce the
amount of water containing previous flotation reagents which can have a negative effect on
the tungsten flotation process, and also allow a more efficient conditioning at high solids
density. The thickener underflow at 55% solids is pumped to the 11-minute two (2)
conditioning tanks. In the first conditioning tank, the pH will be adjusted with lime and
reagents will be added, while in the second conditioning tank (dilution tank), process water is
added to adjust the solid density at 35%, suitable for the flotation process. The diluted pulp is
pumped to the rougher flotation bank (2+2) x 15 m3 cells.
The rougher tails are directed to the scavenger banks 1 and 2, each (2+2) x 15 m3 cells. The
rougher concentrate is pumped by a vertical spindle pump to the 1st cleaner bank 3 x 10 m3
cells. The scavenger concentrate is combined with the 1st cleaner’ tails and returned to the
conditioning tank ahead of the tungsten flotation circuit. The 1st cleaner concentrate is further
cleaned in the 2nd cleaner bank (3 x 5 m3 cells). The 2nd cleaners’ tails are returned to the
1st cleaner bank. The scavenger tails are directed to the final tails pump box. An inline
sampler is installed on this scavenger’ tails line, to deliver a continuous sample stream for
analysis.
July 2016
186
Technical Report on The Sangdong Project
The tungsten concentrate obtained after the primary flotation stages has an average assay
around 7-8% WO3, and requires to be further upgraded to reach the marketable grade of 65%
WO3. A modified Petrov process consisting of a high density heated conditioning at 90°C for
90 min is used to achieve this concentration. The tungsten primary concentrate at 30% solids
is thickened in an 8 m diameter thickener. The thickener under flow at 60% solids is pumped
to a series of 8 x 1 m3 heated carousel type agitated tank. After the conditioning step, the
pulp is diluted at 18% solids and pumped to a rougher and 3 stage scavenger circuit with
each stage consisting of 2 x 5 m3 cells.
The scavenger concentrates are returned (countercurrent) to the heated conditioning tank.
The rougher concentrate is pumped by a vertical spindle pump to three stages of cleaning
cells, respectively 2 x 3 m3 cells, 2 x 0.8 m3 and 2 x 0.8 m3. All of the cleaner tails are
returned, countercurrent to the heated conditioning tank.
The scavenger tails which stand as middlings are stocked to be retreated. The tungsten final
concentrate is filtered and dried on a 1.2 m diameter x 1.2 m long drum filter. The filter cake
is dried in a Holoflite rotary drier and tungsten concentrate with moisture of 3% is conveyed to
a 50t capacity silo. A big bag filling equipment with a scale for tungsten concentrate
packaging is installed under the silo.
July 2016
187
Technical Report on The Sangdong Project
The process water for the mill will be a combination of mine water (28 m3/h), abstracted river
water (30 m3/h maximum) and treated recycled water. The overall water balance is shown in
Figure 18-3.
Mine water is very hard, with calcium ion concentrations of well over 100 ppm and
magnesium of 50 ppm. These two ions react with most organic acids, forming calcium and
magnesium salts, thus inhibiting their ability to froth. Test results suggest a much higher
dosage of frother is required to precipitate the hardness ions.
In the scheelite (tungsten) flotation circuit, calcium and magnesium will be replaced by
sodium, which increases the salinity of the water. If this water is recycled, the salinity will
increase continuously (if not treated) and result in increased equipment corrosion and a
decrease in froth stability (as the salinity decreases the ability of the process to produce
foam). Therefore, the sulphide-molybdenum flotation circuit will use recycled water from the
process water treatment facility, while the scheelite flotation circuit will use a combination of
fresh process water and scheelite flotation circuit recycled water, while maintaining the
optimal water salinity for the scheelite flotation circuit operation.
A mix of approximately 1/4 fresh water and 3/4 recycled water has been used in the
processing plant design.
The process of flotation of the scheelite requires the addition of several chemicals. Many of
which are of organic acid mixture and oils such as pine oil. These chemicals adhere to the
minerals to be floated and with the introduction of air produce a froth which contains the
mineral values. The froth breaks down when the pulp is not agitated and these chemicals
remain mostly in the water. At the end of the flotation cycle the total amount of chemicals
introduced, into the conditioning tanks, will be in solution in the waste water exiting the plant.
For environmental reasons the organic chemicals must be removed. The classical method to
remove these is by aeration. Several aeration processes exist for a wide scale of industrial
wastes. In the current study, prolonged aeration has been selected, using surface
mechanical aeration (10 units of 20HP); these aerators should be installed in lagoons 3
metres deep (maximum) and with a total area of 12,640 m2. This is the area equivalent to 5
days of retention. These types of treatment usually give 85-90% reduction of BOD5 in the
waste stream, which would allow for direct discharge of water, in most cases. It must be
noted that the above process does not remove the salinity in the waste water. It is expected
July 2016
188
Technical Report on The Sangdong Project
that the sodium ion content in the discharge water will be approximately 100ppm higher than
the sodium content in the raw water. This is due to the large quantities of sodium silicate and
sodium carbonate used in the plant.
The aeration pond will be installed on Sangdong property, downstream of the area planned
for the tailings storage area.
The major equipment to be used in the processing plant is shown in Table 17-2. Minor
equipment such as pumps and conveyors have been excluded from this list. The installed
power totals 4006 kW, as compared to 5109 kW in the June 2015 Feasibility Study, mainly as
the result of the use of larger volume flotation cells. Power costs have been left unchanged,
however.
Two (2) 15 m diameter x 10 m high fresh water tanks, including their pumps, will be installed
within the service area. Two compressors are provided one for the plant air supply (150 HP)
and the second for the instrumentation air supply (50 HP). An allowance for reagents and
flocculants preparation and distribution is included in the main floor of the flotation building. A
blower (210 HP) for the flotation cells is provided. The installation of a steam boiler with a
water treatment system is planned to provide steam to the heat conditioning of the tungsten
flotation and final tungsten concentrate drying.
Processing plant manpower included in the operating costs totals 36 personnel, of which 28
people are hourly personnel and the remaining 8 personnel are staff.
July 2016
189
Technical Report on The Sangdong Project
Grinding
Rod Mill(Chute, Screen포 함 ) 1 3.3DIA x 4.9m
Ball Mill(Screen포 함 ) 1 4.2DIA x 4.6m
Crane 20t Over Crene 1 Crane 20t
3
CLASSIFYING CYCLONES CLUSTER 1 234M /HR
Molybdenum Flotation
Molybdenum Rougher Flotation RCS 15 5 15M3
Molybdenum Cleaner Flotation RCS 5 2 5M3
Sulphide Flotation
Sulphide Rougher Flotation RCS 15 4 15M3
Sulphide Cleaner Flotation RCS 5 2 5M3
Floccuant Feeding System #1 1
Scheelite Flotation
Scheelite Rougher Flotation RCS 15 4 15M3
Scheelite Scavenger 1 Flotation RCS 15 4 15M3
Scheelite Scavenger 2 Flotation RCS 15 4 15M3
Scheelite Cleaner 1 Flotation RCS 10 3 10M3
Scheelite Cleaner 2 Flotation RCS 5 3 5M3
Magnetic Separator 1 1200DIA. x 600mm x 1810L
Flocculant Feeding System #2 1
Tailings Thickening
Floccuant Feeding System #4 1
Disc. Vacuum Filtration 1 88M3/HR
Weightometer #6 1 47M3/HR
Vacuum Filtration
July 2016
190
Technical Report on The Sangdong Project
18 PROJECT INFRASTRUCTURE
To accommodate the new waste disposal facility, the existing buildings at the Sangdong
portal level will be demolished to allow for reconfiguration of the space. New site
infrastructure will include a new mine/administration building, assay laboratory, warehouse,
maintenance shop, laboratory and recreational facilities for employees, fuel storage, process
water supply and water and sewage treatment facilities.
Surface facilities will generally be located outside of the -1 Portal in the footprint of old KTMC
installations, as shown in Figure 18-1. Exceptions will be the backfilling plant (on the
Sangdong Terrace) and surface explosives magazine, that will be located at Baegun portal
level, in order to meet the Korean distance requirements to the remaining areas.
July 2016
191
Technical Report on The Sangdong Project
July 2016
192
Technical Report on The Sangdong Project
Due to the consumption of explosives and to the eventuality of explosive interruption due to
traffic constrains, or interruptions due to meteorological reasons, the project shall have
surface explosive and detonators magazines with capacity to supply production during 4
working days. The explosives and detonators storage area for the mine would be located at
surface at Baegum Level and constructed in accordance with Korean regulations.
A new surface mine/administration office complex will be integrated into the new industrial
complex. This will comprise:
There will be 6 mine offices and a crew lineup area comprising 6 wickets for informing miners
of their daily lineup. The engineering and geology departments will require 6 offices and an
area divided into 6 to 8 workstations. The administration personnel will require 10 offices,
including a couple of spare offices for visitors/consultants to use. The offices will be located
mainly on the outside walls of the office complex and look into the open areas for engineering,
geology and other personnel located at workstations.
July 2016
193
Technical Report on The Sangdong Project
The surface maintenance shop will be constructed, in a new regular building, next to the old
APT plant. The building will be a steel framed or brick structure clad with roof and wall
sheeting.
The main shop area will be 20 metres long and 15 metres wide, with offices and storage
areas inside. This facility will perform major and preventative maintenance servicing on all,
surface mobile and small equipment (such as pumps, etc.). It will also be available, for
necessary maintenance of underground mobile trackless equipment. The shop will be divided
into sections for mobile equipment maintenance, and the electrical and instrumentation group.
The maintenance shop will be equipped with an overhead bridge crane. Shielded bays will
allow welding to be carried out without affecting activities in the main shop area. Offices for
the maintenance staff will be located off of the main shop area and include a conference
room, lunchroom, washrooms and small parts storage areas.
Attached to the maintenance shop will be a drill repair shop, along with bit sharpening
facilities. Additional facilities will include a small electrical shop, as well as a self-contained
area for mine rescue facilities.
The warehouse will have attached a fenced yard area for storage of large bulky items that do
not require weather protection or secure storage. The building will be a steel framed or brick
structure clad with roof and wall sheeting.
The interior of the warehouse building will be equipped with pallet shelving shelves and
racking. Separate small stores will be provided for oxygen and acetylene bottle storage,
paints, solvents and rubber lining, a cool store and a safe storage area for small tools and
valuables. An office area will be provided for purchasing and stores administration functions.
The warehouse for mine items only would be a combination of pallet (large or bulk items) and
shelved (smaller items) storage. Valuable items would be placed in a locked storage area.
The warehouse for the mine will be built at the expense of the contractor, who will be doing
development and mining works. Small items concerning backfilling and others from AKT will
be stored at the main warehouse at the refurbished APT KTMC plant.
July 2016
194
Technical Report on The Sangdong Project
A purpose-built laboratory (inside the processing plant building will provide analytical,
investigational and quality assurance services to the production operation.
All underground mine water would be sent to the water treatment facility and reused or
discharged.
A fully equipped mine rescue station will be installed on the property. The mine rescue
station will be equipped with all necessary equipment, including self-contained breathing
apparatus, flame lamps, gas testing equipment, rescue equipment, etc. and supplies and
chemicals required to operate the station. There will be enough emergency equipment to
have 3 five person mine rescue teams operating or on standby at any one time.
Sewage will be connected to the local Sangdong sewage treatment distribution system and
be treated in the Sangdong waste water treatment facility. Sewerage piping to the town
Sangdong Sewage Treatment Plant will be installed parallel to the access road. This will
require 2 kilometres of 203 mm HDPE Sewerage heat traced piping.
Fire water will be provided by electric and diesel driven fire water pumps from the town water
supply.
Staff and visitors to the mine will be housed in village apartments to rent. Employees and
contractors (totaling approximately 170 people) will be housed in the local communities. All
hourly employees will be provided with a meal in mid shift from the catering facilities. A
catering facility providing meals for all employees on the 3 shifts would include refrigerated
foods storage. non-perishable food storage, kitchen, food serving, eating, and dish washing
areas. Recreational facilities would include common lounging areas with comfortable chairs
and couches, large screen TV rooms indoor games such as darts, ping pong, etc. and
outdoor facilities for basketball soccer, etc.
July 2016
195
Technical Report on The Sangdong Project
The mine site has existing road access from the village of Sangdong. The main road that
runs up the valley to the site is a public road (National Road No. 31) recently repaved. The
Taebaek to Naedeok Road runs adjacent to the Sangdong mine site. This two lane bitumen
road can accommodate trucks carrying heavy equipment and road haulage transport trucks.
The present route for this road will go through the proposed plant area. An allowance of 1.5
kilometres for site roads connecting surface support facilities has been included in cost
estimation. The roads will be built from waste rock, gravel top covered and wide enough to
accommodate 2-way transport truck traffic.
The project will be powered by one (1) overhead line, which is scheduled to be installed by
KEPCO in October 2016, and which will supply 2 main substations installed in the immediate
vicinity of the plant. The substations will mainly be composed of step-down transformers of
10MVA (22.9/3.3 kV). One substation will supply power to the mine and non-processing plant
facilities while the second will be dedicated to providing power to the processing plant.
Planned High Voltage Equipment for the project is summarised in Table 18-1.
4000/380/220 _ 6
final design of nderground equipment)
니
2
ASTM-AAAC or Eq ivalent Overhead Line Conductor
니
100 mm m 1,800
2
ASTM-AAAC or Eq ivalent Overhead Line Conductor
니 40 mm m 7,200
Note: All Cables to be to ICEA S57-381/ NEC Code - Article 400 or equal or equivalent
July 2016
196
Technical Report on The Sangdong Project
The Medium Voltage (MV) network will be designed in such a way that each main substation
can power the entire load normally fed by the other main-substation in case of outage of the
other main-substation. Such as configuration will avoid the installation of an expensive, diesel
generator based, emergency power supply.
As much as possible, all the MV switchgear will be installed in the same MV-Substation within
the process plant. Dry step-down transformers will be used to feed the LV-Switchgears and
MCCs. Inside the mine, transportable skids mounted substations and switchgear will be
used. All the Medium voltage cables will be preferably trenched cables.
Figure 18-2 indicates the location of the underground transformers.
As much as possible, all the LV-Switchgears and MCCs will be installed in a dedicated LV-
Substation within the process plant. The low voltage network will be 440V/220V-60Hz. Given
the existing plant and the other components’ foot-print, the trenches will be developed for the
LV cables routing.
The following table shows the connected loads of the Main-Substations, based on a
production rate of 80 tonnes of ore/hour:
Load kW
Main- Mining 2,000
Substation-1 Backfill 1,000
Total 1 3 000
Process plant 2,212
Main- Crushing 480
Substation-2 Grinding 2,172
Camp 400
Total 2 5,264
July 2016
197
Technical Report on The Sangdong Project
The estimate for energy consumption for the project was calculated according to the design
criteria associated with the planned plant capacity, as summarised in Table 18-3. The costs
were derived from a local electricity cost of 76.56 Won/kW.
In the event of a power interruption in the KEPCO power supply the plant will shut down. For
operational and safety reasons, emergency power will be supplied to essential services,
which include the backfill plant agitators, thickener rakes, and underground mine main
ventilation fans.
The emergency power supply will be supplied by two, 2 MVA generator sets located near and
terminating in the KEPCO HV Substation South. An alternative to the standby power
generators, which will be evaluated in the future, will be to analyse a possible switched
interconnection between the two 10MVA incomers.
July 2016
198
Technical Report on The Sangdong Project
In all stoping areas, trucks will be loaded with ore directly from the stopes by LHDs. Primary
stope entrances have been configured to allow loading of trucks. The trucks will haul ore out
of the ore zones directly to surface.
On surface, the underground haul trucks will haul ore to a crusher dump located at the
processing plant. The dump will be equipped with a grizzly and rockbreaker, to size
underground ore to minus 0.6 metres before crushing. Low grade ore (mineralization which
must be mined as part of a stope, but is below the mining cut-off grade, but above the grade
where revenue equals processing and general and administration costs) will be trucked on
surface to a low grade stockpile for processing at the end of mine life, or when excess milling
capacity is available.
Waste rock will be placed in mined out stopes or trucked to a surface waste rock stockpile for
sale to construction companies.
July 2016
199
Technical Report on The Sangdong Project
It is proposed to supply power from the-1 Level substation into the underground mine using a
total of 2,000 m of HV cable(s), via the new -1 Level mine portal. The cable(s) will be buried
in outdoor areas up to the mine entrance, and then supported on hangers along the mine
drifts and ramps. Underground cables and substations fixed in mined "cubbies" will be
protected, as required by mining law.
The main sub-station will comprise two 2.5 MVa unit substations, which step the power down
from 15kV to 5000 volts. One 5000 V bus will feed the mine exhaust fans and crusher, while
the other feeds the underground mine power requirements. Local distribution will be carried
out using mine load centres of 1000 kVA capacity, which will step voltage down from 5000V
to 1000V/240V, as required for use with pumps, fans or other items.
Lighting panels and welding plugs will be serviced via low-capacity, local transformers and
panels, feeding work areas as required. The mine load centres will be completely
transportable, allowing them to be re-used in new working areas, rather than being replaced
as the work advances
Compressed air will be supplied by individual mobile compressors, placed where necessary
for shotcreting, ANFO charging or other necessary purposes.
Service water consumption for drilling and other purposes (not including backfill water) in the
mine is estimated to be 673,000 cubic metres per year. Water will be delivered in 102 mm
HDPE pipes in the haulage drifts and 50 mm HDPE pipes in access drifts to stopes.
Water flows out of the mine by gravity at the -1 level, via a tunnel/trench excavated from the
Main zone old stopes floor elevation. This drain is located near the bottom of the access
ramp out to the mountainside, and can be seen in Figure 16-33.
Initially, very little pumping will be required to keep the mining operations dewatered. During
development of the ore haulage drifts, some pumping may be required to dewater the
advancing faces. Water will be directed to sumps, and drainage holes will be drilled to the
level below. All water will be collected on the -1 level.
July 2016
200
Technical Report on The Sangdong Project
There is significant water flow in current excavations during the rainy season. Water inflow
will be directed to the flooded portion of the mine, while dewatering of the flooded workings is
taking place, and then diverted as much as possible when all workings have been dewatered.
It is planned to utilize the existing water within the mine for process water for the underground
mine and surface processing plant. The water will be treated where necessary. Mine water
will be pumped to the storage areas on the Sangdong level (for the underground stoping
water), and to a surface process water pond for the processing plant. All water will need to be
pumped out of the mine once working areas progress below the -1 level elevation.
Pumping out of the flooded mine workings water will take place from -1 Level using the
Vertical Shaft to the Baegun Level. A submersible pump on a pontoon will be placed in the
shaft and water pumped out to the processing plant process water pond. As the pump
descends during pumping, the pipeline in the shaft will be extended downwards. A total of
approximately 400 metres of pipeline will be required to reach the bottom developed level, -8
Level.
The maintenance shop will be the responsibility of the mine contracting company. Enough
space for this purpose will be left in the surface infrastructure arrangement in front of the -1
Level Portal.
It will contain a wash bay and will be built at a 2% slope, with an integrated centre grated
trench, to facilitate water flow towards a sump at the back of the wash bay.
After the development phase, the most convenient underground loading points will be
adapted into meeting points.
The meeting rooms will be equipped with wooden benches and tables and those informal
mine offices will be equipped with 4 workstations connected to the mine information
management system.
Fuel stations will be located on surface near the -1 Level portal. The fuel station on the -1
level will consist of one 50,000 litres tank with an integrated catch basin.
July 2016
201
Technical Report on The Sangdong Project
Refuge stations will be located initially on the Sangdong, and -1 Levels of the mine. As the
mine progresses, they will be transferred to the main operating levels. The refuge stations will
be constructed in old excavations at suitable areas, or in loading points transformed for that
purpose. The refuge stations walls and backs will be supported with 1.8 metre resin rebar
installed on a 1.2 metre by 1.2 metre pattern.
The stations will have a door in a concrete wall at one end. A 1% sloped concrete floor
(towards the entrance) will be poured in the refuge station to allow gravity drainage of water to
a sump outside the refuge station. The refuge station will include a main area for the mine
workers, containing wooden benches and tables for the crew, hand washing station and other
equipment and supplies. The refuge station will be equipped with safety and rescue
equipment such as a fire extinguisher, eyewash station, first aid kit, emergency food and drink
rations and stretcher. Compressed air and water lines will be connected from the mines
supply system to the inside of the refuge station. The refuge station will also be fitted with an
electric heater unit and will be vented through intake and exhaust ventilation ducts to the
outside.
The magazines’ ground support will consist of 1.8 metre resin rebars (on a 1.2 metre by 1.2
metre pattern), with welded wire mesh screen. The floor will be graded with a 3% slope using
crushed gravel. The magazine entrance will include a concrete wall, with a roll-up door, to
allow access for mobile equipment, and a man door for people traffic. Both will remain
closed, except when explosives are being placed into or removed from the magazine.
One side of the magazine will be fitted with a low 1.5 metre wide wooden shelf, onto which
bulk explosives bags can be placed, holding approximately five 1,000 kg bags. Above this
shelf will be a wall mounted 1.5 tonne jib crane, to pick up the bags and move them around.
The opposite side of the magazine will have a series of shelves to store stick powder off the
ground. Boxes of explosives will be transferred to the shelves and removed by hand.
July 2016
202
Technical Report on The Sangdong Project
Detonator magazines will also be located on the Sangdong and -1 Levels. The magazine will
include a concrete wall with a prefabricated lockable steel access door, providing for the
inside length of the magazine to be 4 metres.
The magazine will be equipped with suitable wooden shelving to allow stacking of detonator
boxes on each side. Access controls and sign out documentation will be placed inside the
magazine. The magazine will also be equipped with ventilation slots to allow some air
circulation through the magazine. An explosion proof red light will be installed outside the
magazine to indicate its location.
Explosives and detonators will be transported directly to magazines. An explosion proof red
light will be installed outside the magazine to indicate its location. The detonator magazines
will also be equipped with sufficient auxiliary ventilation to remove any chemical fumes.
An 802.11 (WiFi) voice and data transmission network will connect the mine and the surface
operations. The system will comprise access points (transmits data to and from clients -
computers, tags, PLC’s etc.) installed in the mine drifts, which facilitate communication
between clients and transfers data to a database server and control system on surface.
Wired telephones will be located at key infrastructure locations, such as the refuge stations.
Key personnel (such as mobile mechanics, crew leaders and shift supervisors) and mobile
equipment operators (such as loader, truck and utility vehicle operators) will be supplied with
handheld mobile telephones, suitable for use underground, for contacting over the 802.11
network.
The paste backfill plant will be located on surface at the Sangdong elevation. All stopes will
be backfilled. Paste fill will be originally delivered to the mining areas through a 102 mm
pipeline in the main access drifts on Taebaek level and on Sangdong level. The Sangdong
level pipeline will be fed from a pipe installed in the service raise from Taebaek level. The
pipeline will consist of 102 mm diameter schedule 80 steel pipes suspended to the back of the
main haulage drifts.
July 2016
203
Technical Report on The Sangdong Project
The Project will require approximately 40,000 m3 per year of potable water which will be
supplied from the local town water supply. The site is already connected to the Sangdong
town water supply.
The process water supply will utilize water pumped out of the underground mine as part of the
mine dewatering programme below the -1 Level, until this source is depleted. The processing
plant requires approximately 2 million cubic metres per year of process water. Of this process
water volume approximately 75% will be recycled, requiring 500,000 cubic metres of fresh
process water per year for the processing plant. The flooded underground mine has an
estimated volume of 6.7 million cubic metres of water which if utilised, would provide
processing plant requirements for approximately 13 years. However, a proportion of this
volume will serve as a reservoir to allow for seasonal and annual fluctuations. Water inflows
to the mine are estimated at 245,000 cubic metres per year. The combination of water in the
flooded mine and inflow water meets project process water requirements for the life of mine
forecast in this study. Water captured during rainfall events in sedimentation ponds will also
be reused.
Clean service water for uses such as gland water for pumps, fire-fighting, cooling circuits, etc.
will be supplied from town water and recycled water. The main losses of water will occur from
water which is not recycled, dust suppression on site roads and evaporation.
The underground water run-off has been tested and found to be very hard. The mine water
was tested to approximately 70 to 80 metres depth and found to contain acceptable levels of
arsenic and potentially deleterious constituents. Water hardness has been assumed to
continue in mine water at depth, in the flooded mine. The water in deeper flooded areas
cannot be easily tested without pumping out the whole mine, but past operations did not have
major water treatment issues. This suggests that mine water at depth will not contain major
contaminants harmful to the operation or the environment. However, over time, and with
seasonal fluctuations in water level within the lower levels of the mine, this will most likely
result in a decrease in pH, as the result of in-situ sulphide mineral oxidation.
July 2016
204
Technical Report on The Sangdong Project
To ensure the mine water can be used in the processing plant, all water pumped from the
mine will be sent to an aeration pond for removal of the calcium and other water hardness
components using biological ingredients and aeration. Should the mine water contain other
undesirable components, these will be removed at the same treatment site pond or an
adjacent facility. The overall conceptual water balance is shown in Figure 18-3.
It is estimated that more than 75% of processing plant water is to be recycled from backfill
and tailings placement operations, for reuse in the processing plant. To facilitate this, the
water will need re-treating to remove salts and other deleterious chemicals. This will be
performed using a reverse osmosis plant.
Water storage at the site will be designed for either waters which are potentially chemically
contaminated (e.g. process water) or waters which have a low potential of containing
chemical contaminants (e.g. surface runoff).
Water collected on site will comprise runoff water from rainfall and snow, process water from
the processing plant and contaminated potable water. The site water collection systems are
designed to minimize the contact of runoff water with water used in mining, processing and
July 2016
205
Technical Report on The Sangdong Project
associated activities. All water, except for diverted runoff water will be treated in a water
treatment plant prior to re-use or release to the local environment.
Storm and snow melt runoff water will be diverted around the site where possible and directed
to sediment ponds where suspended solids will settle out, before water is released. The
sediment ponds and dams will be located downstream of all infrastructure. Each sediment
pond will comprise a small embankment with a water decant system to drain water after the
water sediment load has achieved acceptable standards. Each sediment pond will also have
an overflow spillway to safely pass large storms that exceed the capacity of the reservoir.
Adjacent to the processing plant will be the process water pond which will store return water
pumped from the tailings management area, the underground mine dewatering programme,
ROM rock storage pad pond(s) and other minor water sumps around the site. This pond will
be lined with a single 1.0mm HDPE liner. This pond will also supply firefighting water for the
processing plant.
Sales of 65% WO3 concentrate would be directly to IMC, of Israel under an existing off-take
agreement with IMC, based on Asian Metal China Pricing.
The price levels used in this study represent the current long term expectations of $370
$/MTU WO3.
July 2016
206
Technical Report on The Sangdong Project
In 2011 Woulfe initiated environmental baseline studies for the project including water
sources and quality, climate, flora and fauna, air quality, noise, heritage, land use and water
quality.
As well as providing information for the Feasibility Study the studies provided the
comprehensive environmental information required in preparing the Environmental Impact
Assessment (EIA) Report.
The proposed operations (i.e. preferred alternatives) were selected based on technical and
economic viability, as well as minimisation of potential environmental and social impacts.
Several permanent streams run thought the site. These streams drain to Okdong Creek,
which flows through the town of Sangdong. The water is generally of good quality, based on
the analytical results for “Living Environment” items (pH, biochemical oxygen demand,
suspended solids, dissolved oxygen). Water quality is classified as first grade at all sampling
points except at one site where results for pH and suspended solids exceed the standards.
However, analytical results for total coliforms (an indicator of potential human and animal
waste present in water) were high 10-22,000 total coliforms/100ml. In accordance with these
results, water quality is classified as fourth grade for the “Living Environment” standards. It is
assumed that slash-and-burn-fields around the stream contribute substantially to total
coliforms concentrations.
Strategies to prevent degradation of the surface waters of the Project site include:
• sediment settling dams to reduce the volume of sediment, derived from mined and
disturbed land, from entering the natural river systems of the area;
• storm water will be diverted around mining operations as much as practicable, and
where contact occurs with disturbed areas, water will be collected, monitored, and
treated as appropriate;
• all spills of chemicals or fuels will be cleaned up immediately and contaminated
areas remediated in accordance with the relevant guidelines and standards;
• any potentially acid forming material will be blended or encapsulated in the waste
rock storage facility to prevent possible contamination.
July 2016
207
Technical Report on The Sangdong Project
20.1.2 Groundwater
Groundwater is expressed as springs where there is contact between the limestone and
either skarn or shale. For example, there are three springs, near the old mine buildings
where there is a limestone outcrop with a strike of approximately 300° and a dip of 80° north.
Elsewhere to the west of the site, springs occur where there is contact between limestone and
shale. Flows from the springs are in the order of 2 to 20l/s.
Ground water varied in quality. Total coliforms were above the established quality criteria.
Nitrates were also found in concentrations above the Korean drinking water standards.
Exhaustive testing for arsenic in water during 2014 was performed and concentrations were
found to be well within those for Korean drinking water standards. Elevated nitrate
concentrations are likely to be a result of the application of nitrogenous fertilisers both for
forestry and agriculture, while the heavily mineralised region around Sangdong will lead to
elevated concentrations of arsenic in ground waters.
Potential groundwater quality impacts from Project activities may include contamination of
groundwater by process water spillage and chemical spills on site. Based upon a review of
the water quality of the existing tailings dams, leachate from tails is expected to be of good
quality. It should be noted that Sangdong does not own or have any liability for the old
tailings dams.
Two flora and fauna surveys were completed in the spring and summer of 2007. One
hundred and eighty three species of fauna were identified. No endangered or endemic
species were found.
A total of 73 families, 165 genus, 183 species, 30 varieties, and 3 forma were identified from
the site investigation in the project area and surrounding area. No endangered species and
endemic species designated by Ministry of Environment (MOE) or protection species were
found.
July 2016
208
Technical Report on The Sangdong Project
Eleven mammal species were identified including mice, rats, and wild cats. A total of 5
orders, 10 families, and 11 species of mammals were confirmed through direct field
investigation and the survey questionnaire. Footprints and excrement of elk were found in
several spots in the investigation area. The presence of elk in the project area was also
confirmed through the survey questionnaire.
The Serbian weasel and the racoon dog in addition to two species of deer were identified.
Feral goats, mice and cats were also present. Wild boar, the Serbian chipmunk and the red
squirrel were found across the site and surrounds.
Three birds of conservation significance were recorded across the site. They were the
Kestrel, Chinese Sparrow Hawk and the Common Buzzard. These species have become
vulnerable as a result of habitat disturbance from changes in land use. As the footprint of the
proposed development requires very little additional clearing or habitat disturbance it is not
expected that the development will have any impacts on these regional species.
A total of 5 families, 6 genus and 11 species of amphibians were found. Bombina orientalis
(toad) was the most frequently observed species. No amphibians of conservation
significance or precious natural treasure as designated by the Ministry of Environment were
observed on the Project Site during the survey periods.
A total of 4 families, 6 genus, and 10 species of reptiles were recorded. Eight species were
confirmed from site investigation and two species were confirmed by use of a questionnaire
survey. No reptiles of conservation significance and precious natural treasures as designated
by the Ministry of Environment were observed on the Project Site during the surveys.
A total of 301 fish of 11 different species were collected during the first round of sampling. In
the second round of sampling, 279 fish of 9 different species were collected. Nine species of
fish were caught at a one site and 11 species were caught at the second site, none are
July 2016
209
Technical Report on The Sangdong Project
protected. One hundred and forty two insect species were found, with one dead insect
classified as an endangered species.
Based on this review, the flora and fauna are common in Korea. There were two natural
monument and two endangered species found; however it is considered that mining impacts
would not be significant on these species because of the underground nature of the mine and
small surface disturbance.
A number of levels of conservation zones are designated in South Korea. A review of these
conservation zones showed that these areas are a substantial distance from the mining
tenure areas and will be not be impacted by the mining activities.
The land affected by the Project is not likely to become part of a protected area estate or
subject to any treaty. In making this statement, consideration has been given to national
parks, conservation parks, fish habitat areas, wilderness areas, aquatic reserves, national
estates, world heritage listings and sites covered by international treaties or agreements (e.g.
RAMSAR, KAMBA), and scientific reserves.
The Ecological Nature Maps for Korea were developed by the Ministry of Environment.
Grade one areas are set aside for conservation and restoration of the natural environment
whilst Grade two basically restricts development with small scale development approved for
exceptional cases.
These areas have been identified to the west of the mine site (Figure 20.1). The mine will
have no impact on these or any other conservation areas.
July 2016
210
Technical Report on The Sangdong Project
Figure 20.1; Ecological Nature Map of the Area West of Sangdong Mine
A number of levels of conservation zones are designated in South Korea. A review of these
conservation zones showed that these areas were a substantial distance from the mining
tenure areas and will not be impacted by the mining activities.
There are 30 designated ecosystem conservation areas in Korea. Among these are ten sites
designated by the Ministry of Environment (MOE) and four sites designated by the Ministry of
Marine Affairs and Fisheries. The remaining sixteen sites are designated by provincial and
county entities. Keumdaebong in Daeduck Mountain, is designated as a rare wildlife habitat,
July 2016
211
Technical Report on The Sangdong Project
and is located approximately 8 km from the project area. No impacts on these sites from the
project are expected.
There is no protection zone for ecology and scenery in the project area.
Natural parks are classified either as national, provincial, or county natural parks. As of 2007
there were 20 national, 23 provincial, and 33 county natural parks in Korea. Taebaek
Provincial Park is situated 8km from the Project site. No impacts on these sites are expected
from the Project.
The area surrounding the proposed mine is predominantly forestry and agricultural land. The
main sources of ambient dust in the region are likely to be due to grass seeds, pollens and
wind erosion of exposed soil surfaces particular during tree harvesting.
Modelling of dust from the site originating from the waste rock storage facility, processing, and
truck movements showed that dust increases were minimal in the community and will meet
Korean air quality standards.
• dust emissions associated with clearing vegetation, extracting and transporting small
quantities of waste rock and ore, blasting and stockpiles;
• dust emissions associated with the transport of ore via conveyor and stockpiling;
• dust emissions associated with the crushing and milling processes at the ore
processing plant;
• windblown dust from erosion of disturbed and cleared areas on the Project site.
July 2016
212
Technical Report on The Sangdong Project
20.3 Noise
Noise modelling of truck movements and the milling and processing activities showed a small
increase in noise at the nearest community receptors, while still meeting Korean noise
standards. The mountainous terrain surrounding the mine acts as a significant barrier to
noise propagation, assisting in noise reduction from the site.
The following mitigation strategies will be adopted by the Project to minimise noise from
operations:
The following mitigation strategies will be adopted to minimise impacts from blasting on the
Project:
• blasting will be underground;
• a blasting strategy will be maintained to meet vibration regulatory requirements.
20.4 Waste
• waste rock;
• tailings;
• process/storm water;
• solid and liquid wastes (e.g. waste oil, tyres, batteries and plastics).
A waste management plan will be developed prior to the commencement of mining. The
waste management strategy of the Project will follow a four tiered waste management
strategy according to practicalities and available markets, in preferential order:
• waste minimisation;
• waste reuse and/or recycling;
• waste treatments, and
• waste disposal.
July 2016
213
Technical Report on The Sangdong Project
Waste rock material will be stacked in a single waste rock stockpile at the site. Over a eight-
year period, 750,000 t of waste rock will be produced, the majority of which will be
accumulated in the early phase of mining. There may be the opportunity to backfill waste in
the historic underground workings and it is expected that some may be used locally as a
building material. The remaining waste rock will be stored on-site in a single waste rock
storage facility at Sangdong Portal.
Some waste material from internal dilution control with UV lamp can be stored inside the mine
in neighbouring active stopes and mixed with backfill. The pre-production amount of waste
will be approximately 500,000 t, that will be stored in a secondary valley, shown in according
to Figure 20-1. This zone has a reduced thickness of topsoil and will require the
transportation of topsoil from other zones in the final restoration of this area. The final waste
dump planned at Sangdong Terrace is shown diagrammatically in Figure 20-2.
Sixty-eight waste rock samples were collected to determine the potential for acid rock
drainage. The samples were sourced from core samples across the ore body and are
representative of all profiles of all geological units encountered in the deposit.
Acid-base and net acid generation testing indicated that 61 samples were classified as non-
acid forming and 7 of the samples were potentially acid forming.
The results of the waste rock assessment indicate the proportion of material which will be
potentially acid forming is relatively small at approximately 10% of the total waste volume.
Historically, there has been no acid rock drainage from the existing well vegetated waste rock
storage facility on site, or from the existing tailings dams. This trend is expected to continue.
However, during operations continuing assessment of all waste rock will be conducted to
confirm if any potentially acid forming material is present and if required, this material will be
encapsulated to reduce the likelihood of acid rock drainage.
July 2016
214
Technical Report on The Sangdong Project
July 2016
215
Technical Report on The Sangdong Project
Five historical sites were reviewed according to the Cultural Asset Map Book. Of these sites,
two were natural caves, one is a historical temple ruin, one is a significant fossil discovery,
and one is a Monument of Loyalty and Filial Piety. All are described below:
• Geukgol Cave – shut to public a few years earlier and not accessible;
• Beophwasa Temple Site – now used as a cabbage patch, remains have been
excavated here including some pottery;
• Bat Cave – close to the mining site, no products come from this cave and it was
inaccessible due to overgrowth and high water levels. It is said bats are found in the
cave;
• Palaeozoic Cephalopod – fossil found 35km from the mine site;
• Monument of Loyalty and Filial Piety – 5 km southwest of the mine site.
• potential acid rock material and storage in the waste rock storage facility and tailings
disposal underground with particular emphasis on leachate water quality monitoring
and management.
July 2016
216
Technical Report on The Sangdong Project
Water quality monitoring will be undertaken to meet relevant statutory guidelines for
ecological and drinking water quality. Water quality monitoring will include:
• surface water quality at established baseline sites upstream and downstream of the
mine site;
• ground water quality and depth at established baseline sites upstream and
downstream of the mine site; and
• surface water flows at selected springs adjacent to the mine site at established
baseline sites.
Monitoring of noise and dust will be undertaken at baseline sites within the community on a
regular basis.
The town of Sangdong is located 2km from the mine site. The population of the town is
approximately 500 people. Sangdong was once a regional centre for the district’s agricultural
and mining industries, when the mine was operable, with mining supporting 40,000
inhabitants (thereby acquiring the title Sangdong-eup).
Sangdong has a hospital, schools, supermarkets, shops, service stations, road and transport
links. It is planned to house the 95 AKT full time employees in the town and the surrounding
region, except for staff who will live in a camp on site.
The economic flow-on benefits to Sangdong and the towns and cities of the county include
increases in the following service industries:
July 2016
217
Technical Report on The Sangdong Project
The Project is expected to directly employ up to a maximum of 400 people during the
construction phase, reducing to approximately 200 people during operations.
The flow-on benefits in terms of employment vary between three to four people for each
permanent employee, so the direct employment benefits are in the order of another 800 -
1,000 people.
The mine concentrate product will be transported by road to the APT plant located some
distance from the mine.
The local county and Sangdong regions have predominantly elderly populations, which in
general are declining. The re-opening of the mine will provide a number of employment
opportunities for both unskilled and skilled trades, with resulting economic benefits locally,
regionally and nationally.
The purpose of the Act is to prevent air pollution which causes harm to people and the
environment and manage and preserve the atmospheric environment in a proper and
sustainable manner, thereby enabling all people to live in a healthy and comfortable
environment. The dust emissions from the mine operations comply with guidelines
established under this Act for a rural area and will not have any significant detrimental effects
on surrounding air quality.
20.10.2 Water Quality and Ecosystem Conservation Act, No. 8976, March 21, 2008
The purpose of the Act is to prevent people’s health and environment from being exposed to
harm and danger caused by water pollution and to properly manage and preserve water
quality and aquatic ecosystems of the public waters, including rivers, lakes and marshes, etc.
in order to enable people to enjoy benefits accruing from measures, and hand down such
benefits to future generations. The mine project is consistent with this purpose in that there
will be no waste water discharged to the natural environment, best practice storm water
management techniques will be used and water recycling will take where possible.
20.10.3 Noise and Vibration Control Act No. 8976, Mar. 21, 2008
July 2016
218
Technical Report on The Sangdong Project
The purpose of the Act is to enable all citizens to live in a calm and tranquil environment by
preventing any damage due to noises and vibrations generated in factories, construction work
fields, roads, railroads, etc. and by controlling and regulating such noises and vibrations
properly. Analysis of the noise impacts of the mine operation on the rural community has
shown it will comply with the guidelines developed under the Act.
The purpose of the Act is to contribute to environmental conservation and the enhancement
of the quality of life for the people by minimising the production of wastes and proper disposal
of wastes generated. It does so by establishing a preferred waste management hierarchy
and various principles as the basis for waste management. The waste control hierarchy
moves from the most preferred – waste avoidance, to re-use, recycling and energy receiver,
through to waste disposal, the least preferred. The mine generates a significant waste
tailings stream which is to be disposed of in underground voids. All other wastes are
generally of much smaller nature and will be recycled where possible.
20.10.5 Soil Environment Conservation Act No. 8469, May 17, 2007
The purpose of this Act is to enable all citizens of the nation to live in a healthy and
comfortable environment, by preventing potential hazards or injury to public health and
environment due to soil contamination and by conserving the soil ecosystem by properly
maintaining and preserving soil, including purifying contaminated soil, etc. The mine will
capture all contaminated material and restore as per the Act. Rehabilitation as part of the
mine closure plan will also focus on restoring any contaminated land.
The purpose of the Act is to seek sustainable utilisation of the natural environment and to
allow people to lead a leisurely and healthy life in a comfortable natural environment by
systematically conserving and managing the natural environment, such as protection of the
natural environment from artificial damage, conservation of the ecosystem, natural scenery,
etc. The mine plan has recognised these values and will be managed to meet the purpose of
the Act.
• Act on the Promotion of Saving and Recycling of Resources, Act No. 8957, March 21,
2008;
July 2016
219
Technical Report on The Sangdong Project
• Act on Special Measures for the Control of Environmental Offences Act No. 9313,
Dec. 31, 2008;
• Framework Act on Environmental Policy, Act No. 9037,March 28,2008;
• Management of Drinking Water Act No. 8952, March 21, 2008;
• Natural Environment Conservation Act No. 9037, March 28, 2008.
• Exclusive use of a mountain area (Temporary use of forest land) for an application of a
mining plan has been extended on Dec. 18 2013 for another 2 years (Jan. 1 2014 to Dec.
31-2015). Note: Yeongwol County Land lease has been extended for 3 years (Jan. 1
2016 to Dec. 31 2018). AKTC is preparing for the temporary use of forest land for an
application of a mining plan and the period will be extended for another 3 years. (Jan. 1
2016 to Dec. 31 2018).
• The term of SMC's mining plan is related to the Temporary use period of a mountain
area. SMC has been extended the Temporary use of a mountain area to Dec. 31 2015
and will keep extending the term of the Temporary use of a mountain area as required.
• Approval for construction of an installation for a mining facility, to build the Sangdong adit,
on July 09 2011, by the Eastern Mining Safety Office.
• Approval for construction of an installation for a mining facility, to build the Woulfe adit, on
Nov. 13 2012, by the Eastern Mining Safety Office.
• Approval for construction of and installation for a mining facility, to build Taebaek and
Baegun adits, on Sep. 29 2014, by the Eastern Mining Safety Office.
When these approvals have been granted, additional information will also be sought on
environmental controls during construction.
The relationship between Almonty Korea and the Sangdong community is excellent. AKT
have been an active member of the Sangdong community since 2009. The workforce at the
mine is approximately 15 people. Because of these strong local connections, public
consultation has been undertaken both informally and formally, particularly with the local
Sangdong Township and Yeongwol County. Again because many members of the workforce
are locally based, there is a high degree of awareness and anticipation of the project coming
to fruition.
The site manager has excellent contacts within the Sangdong community and site visits are
encouraged for local people. There is widespread support for the project to date with no
major environmental issues being raised by the public or government department. There has
been good local consultation with government staff related to day to day issues with the
exploration programme at the AKT tungsten project. When the integration of the project into
the Almonty group was completed, it was warmly welcomed by the display of over 30 different
banners (Figure 20-3) from the representative community associations in Sangdong
supporting the proposed mine development. The relationship with the surrounding land
holders is good.
Discussions between AKT and the Town are extremely positive, particularly in view of the
fact, that the operation will be community based and the mine can help support and improve
local services. This strategy by AKT allows the Town and Yeongwol County to develop
longer term planning strategies for the town with an emphasis on affordable housing,
increased employment opportunities and appropriate support services.
AKT intends to hold further public information days in Sangdong during the development of
the mine plan. This is to assist local people further with their understanding of the project.
There have been numerous activities held with the community of Sangdong and to foster
long-term relationships, a memorandum of understanding has been signed with the local high
school to provide employment opportunities for graduating students.
July 2016
221
Technical Report on The Sangdong Project
The following rehabilitation procedures will be implemented for each disturbance area.
20.13.1 Contouring
The preparation of disturbed areas prior to the establishment of vegetation will involve surface
contouring to minimise erosion and maximise beneficial land use.
20.13.2 Ripping
Following surface contouring, ripping of the surface is required. The design criteria for ripping
operations are detailed in Table 20-1. The spacing between rip lines which acts to reduce soil
erosion and increase plant establishment rates, is determined by the slope of the land.
Where soils are particularly compacted, a more suitable ripping depth of 300mm would be
employed.
July 2016
222
Technical Report on The Sangdong Project
All clearing will be conducted in accordance with AKT’s Permit to Clear procedure.
Construction activities will be limited to designated construction areas unless approved by
AKT’s General Manager. The total area to be cleared will be restricted to the minimal area
required. Prior to clearing, the boundary of the area authorised to be cleared will be identified
and clearly marked to ensure construction vehicles do not impact on adjacent undisturbed
areas. Prior to clearing, a clearing pattern will be determined that will allow fauna adequate
opportunity for dispersal into adjacent habitats.
Cleared vegetation will be pushed into a series of windrows within the disturbed areas and
generally chipped for reuse. Vegetation identified as potentially valuable habitat e.g. hollow
logs may be stockpiled for use in erosion and sediment control works or on site rehabilitation.
Topsoil clearing up to 300mm (terrain allowing) is encouraged. The top 50-100mm of soil
contains the seed bank and is generally higher in organic matter, microbial activity and
nutrient content. The subsoil located below the topsoil is a source of bulk growth material;
whilst not as biologically active as topsoil, combined with seeding it is suitable as a topsoil
alternative.
The topsoil stockpiles will be no higher than 1.5 - 2m; clearly signposted in the field identified
on a site plan. These soils low in organic matter, <1.5%, when stockpiled will need to be
managed so that the loss of organic carbon is minimised.
Spreading of topsoil will be to an average depth of 0.2 – 0.3m. Erosion control measures will
be implemented where required.
After appropriate surface preparation has occurred as outlined above, disturbed land will be
revegetated as follows:
• Prepare area with fertilisers and other ameliorates, if required, based upon soil
testing;
• Re-vegetation undertaken using a combination of direct and hand seeding;
• Species to be used in the re-vegetation program will be a mixture of endemic woody,
herbaceous and grassy species in a ratio that reflects the existing natural species
density;
July 2016
223
Technical Report on The Sangdong Project
• A weed management plan created to identify local weed species and control methods
for implementation until wanted species re-vegetation is well established.
The final landform design and method of rehabilitation for each type of disturbance associated
with the Project is described below.
The waste rock dump will be rehabilitated by leaving a berm of at least 10m between each lift
once the dump faces have been dozed down to act as a water control structure preventing
erosion of the lower waste dump face. Waste rock dumps will be progressively rehabilitated
throughout the life of mine, as areas become available. The berm between the two lifts of the
dump will be graded to slope back towards the dump to act as a water control structure for
any storm water flowing off the lift above. The top of the waste rock dump will be graded
towards the centre and a drain or bund installed back from the edge to prevent any
overtopping of water from the top of the dump over the face of the dump. The slopes and top
of the waste rock dumps will be covered with topsoil where possible and deep ripped. Native
local grass and tree species, and an appropriate fertiliser if required, will be directly seeded
on to the topsoil cover of the dump.
Dams and sediment ponds across the site may be left for future use by the landholder.
The rehabilitation of building and infrastructure across the site will involve:
20.13.6.4 Roads
Roads will only remain at the request of the community. After decommissioning the haul
roads will be deep-ripped to 0.3m, overlaid with topsoil, if available then seeded.
July 2016
224
Technical Report on The Sangdong Project
All recyclable/reusable materials (machinery, scrap metal, used drums, etc.) will be removed
from the site by the recycling contractors or removed to the local landfill. The landfill areas on
site will be covered, contoured and revegetated.
All sample bags and waste materials will be removed from site and disposed of in an
appropriate manner.
The drill cuttings should be dispersed around the site or returned to the drill hole or sump.
Drill sumps should be backfilled with the excavated material and covered with stored topsoil.
Tracks constructed to access the drill site should be rehabilitated as per haul roads.
All areas disturbed on the Project site will be subject to rehabilitation works that will, at the
completion of the project, result in a stable vegetated landscape, supporting the preferred
land use where possible and having minimal impact on the surrounding environment.
Rehabilitation of the project site will be on a progressive basis as disturbed areas become
available. Exploration areas will be rehabilitated on an ongoing basis if not part of the main
mine activity.
July 2016
225
Technical Report on The Sangdong Project
• Compatibility with agreed post mining land use e.g. monitoring of trends of vegetation
structure, richness and cover;
• Low risk to biota e.g. surface water quality meets water quality standards or
appropriate mitigation in place to minimise risk;
• Contaminated areas to be removed or remediated;
• Revegetation monitoring will be conducted annually after commencement of
rehabilitation. Should monitoring reveal that successful rehabilitation is not being
achieved then maintenance will be performed to promote acceptable cover or to
repair failed areas. If rehabilitation targets have been met for an agreed number of
consecutive years, rehabilitation will be considered successful.
Prior to the surrender of the mining leases, a Final Rehabilitation Report will be compiled
which involves a site investigation, risk assessment and a site management plan, as well as
details regarding the rehabilitation status of all disturbed areas.
Should forestry land be used, which is currently not the case, the use of forest land for the
Project, would require the lodgement of surety bonds for asset retirement liability.
The following rehabilitation principles will support mine closure at Sangdong. These include:
July 2016
226
Technical Report on The Sangdong Project
• reshaping disturbed land so that it is stable, adequately drained, and suitable for the
desired long-term land use;
• minimising the long-term visual impacts where feasible and appropriate by creating
landforms that are compatible with the surrounding landscape;
• minimising the potential for erosion by wind and water;
• re-vegetating the area with plant species consistent with the approved post
operational land use;
• meeting all statutory, state, and county requirements;
• making the area safe by removal of all plant, machinery, structures, facilities and
equipment from the site unless agreed otherwise with key stakeholders;
• environmentally sound waste disposal at the site including any radioactive material;
• monitoring and managing rehabilitated areas until the vegetation is self- sustaining
and meets the requirements of the landowner or land manager, or until their
management can be integrated into the management of the surrounding area.
• providing copies of a closure and rehabilitation plan to, and discussing it with key
stakeholders;
• maintaining a line of communication with the key stakeholders by providing annual
updates of Almonty Korea’s environmental and business plans, including
rehabilitation plans and progress through the company website and annual reports;
• providing opportunities to comment on and provide input to the decommissioning and
rehabilitation plan to be provided to relevant parties at least 12 months prior to
closure of the operation.
The mine closure plan will focus on the following major environmental aspects:
• AMD minimisation
• portal and underground mine disestablishment
• groundwater contamination
• surface water management
• surface subsidence expression
• long term management and stability of the tailings dam
• effective environmental management or removal of all facilities
• recycling or reuse of usable assets
• identification and remediation of contaminated soils
• decontamination and rehabilitation of all utilised areas
• maintenance of site security for on-going term during rehabilitation
• maintenance of the site’s weeds free status during the rehabilitation and validation
periods
• consideration given to the local community for public access to farming and social
activities in the region.
July 2016
227
Technical Report on The Sangdong Project
The costs of rehabilitation of the additional equipment, plant, and facilities associated with the
SMP including the portal, underground workings, crushing, processing plant and associated
facilities and miscellaneous site re-vegetation based on estimates of labour, plants seeds,
etc., has been estimated at US$2,000,000.
20.16 Summary
All baseline environmental studies have been completed and no endangered species of flora
or fauna identified, which could adversely affect development of the project.
All environmental approvals for project construction and operation have been successfully
completed. Overall construction permits have already been granted. Permits and approvals
as required to construct specific facilities will be applied for and received as a routine part of
ongoing construction activities.
July 2016
228
Technical Report on The Sangdong Project
• Mine development and rehabilitation, mining equipment mobile and fixed and associated
consumables and maintenance parts for development and infrastructure.
• Direct costs of new equipment for the processing facilities.
• Project infrastructure equipment and materials.
• Construction materials
• Labour.
• Temporary buildings and services.
• Construction support services.
• Spare parts.
• Initial fills (inventory).
• Freight.
• Vendor Supervision.
• Owner’s cost.
• Engineering, Procurement and Construction Management.
• Commissioning and start up.
• Contingency.
Direct costs have been allocated as all costs associated with permanent facilities. These
includes mine development openings, equipment and material costs, as well as construction
and installation costs.
Mine infrastructure costs are those associated with maintenance shops, mine dewatering,
refuge stations, etc. Wherever possible, equipment and materials’ quotes and contractor
installation costs have been used.
Other major equipment expenditure estimates are based on quotes obtained from suppliers
and installation costs estimated as part of this study.
During the pre-production and sustaining development periods, all materials and equipment
pricing are based on quotes obtained from local Republic of Korea suppliers or European and
international suppliers, where Republic of Korea suppliers do not exist. Processing plant
equipment pricing is based on the equipment list, specifications and process flow diagrams.
Budgetary prices were obtained from Vendors of major equipment and in-house data was
July 2016
229
Technical Report on The Sangdong Project
used from similar projects for items not quoted. Estimated costs for plate work were based on
local data, associated with remaining equipment: tanks, bins and chutes. Costs for
installation of equipment are based on unit man-hour requirements.
All major equipment expenditures include freight only. Applicable taxes and duties have not
been included in the capital expenditure estimates.
Commodity pricing for earthwork, concrete, steel, architectural and piping were provided by
local contractors based in The Republic of Korea. Labour rates and equipment usage rates
used throughout the estimate were provided by the same source as the commodity prices. It
was assumed that rock required for site preparation and the tailings will be provided at no
cost during the preproduction stage. Only costs for placement have been allowed for in
estimates.
Labour rates generally reflect industry-wide Republic of Korea and international levels for the
types of work performed, and in some cases adjusted for locally applied rates. The mine
labour costs are based on three types of estimates:
• Quoted contractor prices for undertaking the tasks associated with constructing a specific
installation;
• Average industry rates a contractor would be expected to charge for performing specific
tasks;
• Lateral and raise development rates, developed and based on expected productivity and
labour, materials and equipment costs for such an underground development program.
All labour costs include local Republic of Korea government mandated contributions and the
costs for company provided benefits.
July 2016
230
Technical Report on The Sangdong Project
The indirect costs cover all the costs associated with temporary construction facilities and
services, construction support, freight, Vendor representatives, spare parts, initial fills and
inventory, Owner's costs, EPCM, commissioning and start-up assistance.
The costs for construction facilities include all temporary facilities, services and operation, site
office operations, security buildings and services, construction warehousing and material
management, construction power and utilities, site transportation, medical facilities and
services, garbage collection and disposal, and surveying.
The costs for spare parts have been factored in, based on equipment costs where Vendors
did not provide cost for spares needed for the first year of operations.
The estimated cost for initial fills of reagents is based on 3 months of operating requirements.
Budget quotations were obtained for reagent pricing.
The freight costs were either provided by Vendors or estimated based on weights and
typically include for containerised and break-bulk shipping, and each are respectively divided
into ocean freight and inland freight. For imported equipment, the cost of freight and export
packing, ex- works to a local port, is included with the cost of the equipment. Freight
insurance is included in the Owner's cost.
July 2016
231
Technical Report on The Sangdong Project
• Sunk costs
• Taxes and Duties
• Deferred capital
• Financing and interest during construction
• Additional exploration drilling
• Escalation
• Corporate withholding taxes
• Legal costs
• Metallurgical testing costs
• Condemnation testing.
The cost estimates are to Feasibility Study level accuracy. All expenditure estimates are in
2015 constant US Dollars. Costs derived from Republic of Korea Won figures have been
converted at a rate of $US 1 = Won 1180.
21.4.1 Mining
All construction work will be executed by local contractors. Mine capital expenditures are
based on Almonty Korea hiring a mine contractor for developing and operating the mine.
Mine capital expenditures are primarily related to underground infrastructure, stope
development and mine services. As existing development can be extensively utilized, the
underground development costs are relatively low.
Mine capital expenditures do not include closure expenses, as it is not expected the project to
be restricted to the actual reserves. They also do not include the value(s) of existing assets.
The total mine pre-production expenditures (including design engineering) are expected to be
approximately $US12.16M (including 5% contingency). The summary capital expenditures
breakdown for the mine is shown In Table 21-1. The mine development capital expenditures
and infrastructure capital expenditure estimates are shown in Tables 21-2 and 21-3,
respectively.
July 2016
232
Technical Report on The Sangdong Project
Total
Component
Expenditures
6
$US x 10
Mine Development & Definition Drilling 7.63
July 2016
233
Technical Report on The Sangdong Project
Total Pre-Production Infrastructure Capital 4,530 160 425 47 293 925 513 3,028 64 - 3,606
July 2016
234
Technical Report on The Sangdong Project
The processing plant capital expenditures are based on equipment costs from METSO (a
major processing equipment supplier), who would provide all major processing equipment
except for conveyors and thickeners from Korean Engineering Consultants Corporation
(KECC) a major Korean engineering firm. These capital estimates cover all remaining
aspects of the processing plant building and installations. Table 21-4 shows the processing
plant capital expenditures breakdown, for a total of $US32.807 million (including 5%
contingency).
Total pre-production capital expenditures for project infrastructure and surface department are
estimated to be approximately $US13.9M, including a 5% contingency. The breakdown of
expenditures is presented in Table 21-5. Infrastructure expenditure estimates were primarily
provided by Korea Engineering Consultants Corporation (KECC). Major expenditure
components are for power distribution, an office/shop/warehouse complex, camp and catering
facilities and water supply and treatment.
Project indirect procurement and construction management and owners’ costs are estimated
at $US 6.69M over the 20 month pre-production period. A breakdown of these Owner’s costs
is presented in Table 21-6. Owner's costs also include manpower recruitment and training
during the pre-production period and all equivalent General and Administration costs which
would be incurred during the construction phase.
July 2016
235
Technical Report on The Sangdong Project
Year -2 Year -1
Processing Plant Equipment & Machinery 19.94 - 3.66 0.28 3.94 7.88 8.54 3.52 - - 12.06
Crushing Building 0.27 - 0.11 0.05 0.05 0.21 0.05 - - - 0.05
Grinding Building 0.58 - 0.23 0.12 0.12 0.46 0.12 - - - 0.12
Flotation Building 1.31 - 0.52 0.26 0.26 1.05 0.26 - - - 0.26
Water Treatment Facility : FS 2015 Jun 2.70 - - - 0.54 0.54 0.54 1.62 - - 2.16
Laboratory Equipment 0.22 - - - - - 0.22 - - - 0.22
General Overhead Expenses 7.55 - 0.75 0.64 0.97 2.37 2.26 2.92 - - 5.18
Contingency (5%) 0.24 - 0.04 0.02 0.05 0.11 0.05 0.08 - - 0.13
TOTAL PROCESSING PLANT CAPITAL EXPENDITURES 32.81 - 5.32 1.38 5.93 12.63 12.04 8.14 - - 20.18
Notes
. Capital estimates exclude VAT
July 2016
236
Technical Report on The Sangdong Project
Year -2 Year -1
Total Cost Q1 Q2 Q3 Q4 Total Q1 Q2 Q3 Q4 Total
Description
($US M) ($US M) ($US M) ($US M) ($US M) Year -2 ($US M) ($US M) ($US M) ($US M) Year -1
Civil Engineering Construction 3.71 - 0.60 1.20 1.06 2.86 0.58 0.27 - - 0.85
Architecture & Building Facility 1.67 - - 0.75 0.75 1.50 0.16 - - - 0.16
Electric Facility 4.19 - 0.53 0.80 1.90 3.23 0.87 0.09 - - 0.96
Information & Communication 0.15 - - - - - - 0.15 - - 0.15
Instrumentation & Control 2.32 - - 0.02 0.02 0.03 1.14 1.15 - - 2.29
Offices Fittings and Furnishings 0.05 - - - - - 0.05 - - - 0.05
First Aid Supplies & Equipment 0.06 - - - - - - 0.06 - - 0.06
Maintenance Shop Equipping 0.15 - - - - - 0.15 - - - 0.15
Warehouse Equipping 0.10 - - - - - 0.10 - - - 0.10
Catering Facilities Building and Equipping 0.05 - - - - - 0.05 - - - 0.05
Process Water Supply (Natural - settling chamber) 0.40 - - 0.28 0.12 0.40 - - - - -
Fuel Storage Facility (Surface, Incl. Installation) 0.04 - - 0.04 - 0.04 - - - - -
Site Lighting 0.04 - - - 0.02 0.02 0.02 - - - 0.02
Used Oil Storage 0.02 - - - - - - 0.02 - - 0.02
Telecommunications Upgrade (Site Wide) 0.12 - - - - - - 0.12 - - 0.12
Surface Mobile Equipment 0.10 - - - - - - 0.10 - - 0.10
Miscellaneous Small Equipment 0.05 - - - - - - 0.05 - - 0.05
Contingency (5%) 0.66 - 0.06 0.15 0.19 0.40 0.16 0.10 - - 0.26
TOTAL INFRASTRUCTURE CAPITAL EXPENDITURES 13.90 - 1.19 3.25 4.06 8.50 3.27 2.13 - - 5.40
Notes
. Capital estimates exclude VAT
July 2016
237
Technical Report on The Sangdong Project
Year -2 Year -1
Total Cost Q1 Q2 Q3 Q4 Total Q1 Q2 Q3 Q4 Total
Description
($US M) ($US M) ($US M) ($US M) ($US M) Year -2 ($US M) ($US M) ($US M) ($US M) Year -1
Geology Modelling : FS 2015 June 0.110 0.110 - - - 0.110 - - - - -
Mine Design Engineering : FS 2015 June 0.050 0.035 0.015 - - 0.050 - - - - -
Detail Engineering (Plant & Subsidiary Facility) 2.509 0.564 0.943 0.223 0.260 1.989 0.283 0.237 - - 0.520
Mine & Processing Plant Training : FS 2015 June 0.180 - - - - - 0.090 0.090 - - 0.180
Business Travel Expenses 0.200 0.020 0.020 0.040 0.040 0.120 0.040 0.040 - - 0.080
Environmental Impact Assessment 0.012 0.012 - - - 0.012 - - - - -
Water Quality Monitoring Tests 0.024 0.005 0.005 0.005 0.005 0.019 0.005 - - - 0.005
Land Use (Long Term Land Lease) 0.045 - 0.045 - - 0.045 - - - - -
Survey Cost for Temporary Land Use Permission 0.021 0.021 - - - 0.021 - - - - -
Removal of Trees on the Waste Storage Space 0.013 - 0.013 - - 0.013 - - - - -
Removal of Existing Building and Other Cleaning Works 0.270 - 0.270 - - 0.270 - - - - -
Operating Expenditures 3.315 0.276 1.332 0.252 0.326 2.185 0.415 0.498 0.217 - 1.130
TOTAL OWNERS COSTS 6.749 1.042 2.642 0.520 0.631 4.835 0.833 0.865 0.217 - 1.914
Notes
. Capital estimates exclude VAT
July 2016
238
Technical Report on The Sangdong Project
The estimated total project pre-production capital expenditure, inclusive of contingencies and
excluding working capital, is approximately $US65.62M. The total expenditures include
EPCM, contractor overheads and a 5% contingency on all estimated expenditures. A
summary of all project pre-production capital expenditures is presented in Table 21-7.
Total
Component
Expenditures
6
$US x 10
Mine Development & Infrastructure 12.16
Processing Plant (Incl. Contingencies) 32.8
Surface Infrastructure & Mobile Equipment 13.9
Owner's Costs 6.75
Total Pre-Production Capital 65.62
Additional sustaining capital has also been allowed for in the overall cashflow model, of
$US2.99M. This is for ongoing primary development and continuation of the Sangdong
gallery, from years 1 to 5 of the mine life.
July 2016
239
Technical Report on The Sangdong Project
Project operating costs are based on efficiencies and productivities generally achievable in
The Republic of Korea. The overall performance objectives are conservative by European
standards.
The General and Administration (G&A) cost components include the materials and supplies
used by the administration and surface services groups. These costs comprise office
supplies, computer supplies and computer and software upgrades, light vehicle and surface
equipment operating and maintenance consumables, camp accommodation operational
costs, business travel inside Republic of Korea and internationally, fees for consultants and
communications costs.
Labour costs and salaries for all services labour and mine staff have been estimated on a
yearly total cost basis.
Labour costs for the operating period are based on the manpower schedules presented for
each department and the associated labour costs. The costs include a burden component of
approximately 35 percent. Labour rates are based on local rates where available and/or
contractor costs in the region and country, for similar types of work. Where costs were not
available, costs from other similar projects were used. The rates used include all cost and
profit components payable to contractors. All costs are quoted in constant 2015 US Dollars.
July 2016
240
Technical Report on The Sangdong Project
21.5.2 Mining
Individual costs for mining have been estimated for manpower, equipment operating,
maintenance and materials consumptions, based on a mining contractor developing and
operating the mine. The total mining unit cost has been estimated as $US32.33 per tonne of
ore, as summarised in Table 21-8.
Notes
. Average stoping cost above is derived from:
$US/t Ore Prop'n.
CAF 14.20 60%
MIP 24.05 40%
Average 18.13 (Weighted by proportion)
Mines services and overheads costs include all other non-direct stoping costs for the mine.
Mine services operating costs are associated with maintaining underground facilities and
services (power, water supply, etc.), operating and maintaining ventilations fans, supplies for
safety and training including personal protective equipment and mine rescue and operating
and maintaining all support mobile and track haulage equipment used in the mine.
The total estimated unit mining cost shown above is $32.33 per tonne of ore, using the 2
proposed mining methods. The Mechanised Inclined Panel stoping mining cost is $US 24.05
and for Cut-and-Fill is $US 14.2 per tonne. The direct stoping costs above are a blended
cost, assuming relative proportions of 60% Cut-and-Fill and 40% Mechanised Inclined Panel
mining. Table 21-9 shows a breakdown of the mining costs.
July 2016
241
Technical Report on The Sangdong Project
Notes
. Stoping costs from contractor
. All other costs outside of contractor
July 2016
242
Technical Report on The Sangdong Project
21.5.3 Processing
The total processing plant operating cost is estimated to be approximately $US 10.95 per
tonne of ore, as shown in Table 21-10.
The estimates for G&A costs encompass all operating costs associated with operating the
offices and providing materials and supplies for staff functions. Administration operating costs
include costs and taxes for maintaining the property in good standing, land taxes, and
resource usage fees (water, etc.).
The total yearly G&A costs are estimated to be approximately $US 3.2M, as summarised in
Table 21-11. Employee burdens account for approximately 35% of the total salary for each
employee. Camp operating costs are the other large G&A expenditure estimate with a total
cost of approximately $US 1.1M per year.
Annualized site G&A costs, at an annual production rate of 640,000 tonnes per year of ore,
are estimated at $US 4.9 per tonne (including environmental costs) of ore.
The mine management and administration component of G&A correspond with the
employment of 27 people in this area, most of which would be staff positions. They would be
responsible for the management, administration, personnel, accounting, purchasing needs,
and distribution of material to the operation, site security, health and safety, and
environmental issues.
July 2016
243
Technical Report on The Sangdong Project
July 2016
244
Technical Report on The Sangdong Project
The estimated total average operating cost, over the life of mine, to produce a 65% WO3
concentrate from the mine is approximately $US48.18 per tonne of ore, as summarised in
Table 21-12.
For the purpose of this study, value added taxes and other taxes, along with import duty
costs, have not been included. Exploration costs and all costs associated with areas beyond
the property limits have also not been included.
July 2016
245
Technical Report on The Sangdong Project
22 ECONOMIC ANALYSIS
The base case APT price used was $370/MTU, which is forecast to be a reliable scenario for
the period 2018-2025.
The discounted cashflow analysis has been based on 2015 Constant US Dollar values. The
mine production schedule is based on mining at 450 kt for Year 1 and at the steady state rate
of 640 ktpa from Year 2 onwards. The economic model results for the base scenario are
shown in Table 22-2.
Financial results for prices of $US 300 /MTU and $US 440/ MTU are also presented.
The discounted cashflow analysis has been based on 2015 Constant US Dollar values.
A summary of the expected parameters used for the financial analysis is presented in Table
22-2. The tax rate used was 24.2%: the same as in the A-Z Feasibility Study. Sensitivities on
the derived project NPV values, for different WO3 prices, is shown in Table 22-1.
Notes
. All NPVs shown in $US M
July 2016
246
Technical Report on The Sangdong Project
Revenue Revenue $US M 827 53.85 80.26 89.65 80.89 73.87 69.48 62.61 56.15 50.34 58.98 61.07 56.53 33.77
Costs Mine $US M 255 14.58 20.78 20.82 20.79 20.72 20.73 20.71 20.72 20.81 20.78 20.82 20.80 12.22
Plant $US M 86 4.94 7.04 7.05 7.04 7.02 7.02 7.02 7.02 7.05 7.04 7.05 7.04 4.14
G&A $US M 39 2.21 3.15 3.16 3.15 3.14 3.14 3.14 3.14 3.15 3.15 3.16 3.15 1.85
Total OPEX $US M 380 21.72 30.96 31.02 30.98 30.87 30.90 30.87 30.88 31.01 30.97 31.02 30.99 18.21
Capital Mine development and definition drilling $US M 9.72 3.77 3.86 1.25 0.42 0.42
Additional HW development $US M 11.48 0.54 2.72 2.92 0.42 0.42 4.47
Sangdong Gallery Continuation $US M 0.90 0.90
Mine infraestruture & Services Cap. Exp. $US M 4.53 0.92 3.61
Processing plant capex $US M 32.81 12.63 20.18
Surface infraestruture & mobile equipment $US M 13.90 8.50 5.40
Owners costs $US M 6.75 4.83 1.91
Working capital $US M 1.94 1.94
Mine Closure $US M -
Total capex $US M 82.03 30.65 34.96 3.39 2.72 4.17 0.42 0.42 0.42 0.42 - 4.47 - - - -
Cash flow Project Pre-tax Cash flow $US M 365.02 - 30.65 - 34.96 28.74 46.58 54.46 49.49 42.59 38.16 31.32 25.27 14.86 28.01 30.05 25.54 15.57
Project Cumulative cash flow $US M - 30.65 - 65.62 - 36.88 9.70 64.16 113.65 156.24 194.40 225.72 250.99 265.86 293.87 323.92 349.46 365.02
Tax (calculated using 24.25%) $US M 85.99 13.18 11.98 10.31 9.24 7.58 6.12 3.60 6.78 7.27 6.18 3.77
Project After-tax Cash flow $US M 279.03 - 30.65 - 34.96 28.74 46.58 41.28 37.51 32.28 28.93 23.74 19.16 11.27 21.23 22.78 19.36 11.80
Project Cumulative after tax cash flow $US M - 30.65 - 65.62 - 36.88 9.70 50.98 88.49 120.78 149.70 173.44 192.60 203.87 225.10 247.88 267.23 279.03
5% 234.3
Pre-Tax Net Present
8% 181.9
Value
15% 103.4
5% 178.1
After-Tax Net
8% 137.6
Present Value
15% 76.5
July 2016
247
Technical Report on The Sangdong Project
23 ADJACENT PROPERTIES
The South Korean mining company Omya holds the mining rights for limestone on part of the
Property (coincident with the Se Woo Mining Right 71875) and are currently extracting the
Pungchon limestone by underground mining. This horizon sits approximately 200 m above
the Sangdong deposit which is hosted within the Myobong slate.
The Omya limestone mine adit entrance is approximately 260 m northeast of the Sangdong
adit and the workings are in the Hangingwall Pungchon Limestone situated above the
northeast corner of the Sangdong Mine old Main orebodies mine workings. Omya's closest
mine workings are approximately 250 m away from the Sangdong Hangingwall orebody
(Figure 23.1).
Current Omya mining is taking place between 600 and 663 masl using the room and pillar
mining method. Omya's future plans are to continue mining down dip in the Pungchon
Limestone at a rate of 150,000 t/a.
At the moment there is no protocol between the two mines regarding safety precautions to be
taken during blasting times. This is a situation that should be addressed and it is
recommended that both mines clear at blasting time
Figure 23-1. View of Omya Mine Limestone Workings Relative to Sangdong Old Mine.
July 2016
248
Technical Report on The Sangdong Project
The mine will be technically supported by geology and engineering departments. The
geology department will be responsible for mapping and interpretation, sampling of production
drill holes, grade control and ore reserve estimations. There will be a separate exploration
group to undertake exploration work on the property and to prove up new mineral resources
for potential mining. The engineering department will be responsible for mine planning,
production scheduling, surveying, geotechnical design, collecting and reporting performance
statistics for the mine and any other technical requirements that support the operation.
July 2016
249
Technical Report on The Sangdong Project
The evaluation work was carried out and prepared in compliance with Canadian National
Instrument 43-101, and the mineral resources in this estimate were calculated using the
Canadian Institute of Mining, Metallurgy and Petroleum (CIM), CIM Standards on Mineral
Resources and Reserves, Definitions and Guidelines prepared by the CIM Standing
Committee on Reserve Definitions and adopted by CIM Council May, 2014. The updated
resource estimation is shown in Table 25-1, for 3 different cut-off grades.
Notes
. Bed models diluted to a minimum thickness of 2.2m
. Resources shown are inclusive of reserves
. 50m surface pillar material removed
. Indicated HW material based on all samples,
with a maximum search of 35m x 50m (along-strike x down-dip)
. Indicated material in all other beds are based on only PO-P6 samples,
with a maximum search of 50m, and sample grid required
. Inferred material based on all samples, up to a maximum search of :
105m x 150m in HW
100m x 100m in all other beds
This Technical Report has identified a Proven and Probable Reserve of 7,896 Mt grading
0.45% WO3. This Reserve will sustain a mining operation for approximately 12 years, at an
annual capacity of 640 kt of ore.
Based on the forecast operating parameters and capital and operating costs estimates, for
the Sangdong project, the returns from the project are very positive and project economics
are extremely robust to potential reasonably expected variances from the base case
assumptions.
July 2016
250
Technical Report on The Sangdong Project
26 RECOMMENDATIONS
In order to enhance the resource and reserve base, the following steps are recommended:
• Based on this updated Technical Study's results, it is recommended that Almonty Korea
and its partners progress the Sangdong project to detailed engineering and construction
budgeting. This would be immediately followed by construction, according to the
approximate 20 month schedule presented as part of this Feasibility Study. The budget
for proceeding is the capital expenditures estimate total presented in this study, of
$US65.62M over 20 months.
July 2016
251
Technical Report on The Sangdong Project
27 REFERENCES
Min Sung Lee (Department of Earth Sciences, College of Education, Seoul National
University, Seoul (Republic of Korea), 1982. Tungsten Deposits of the Korean Peninsula.
Moon K J, 1983. The Genesis of the Sangdong Tungsten Deposit, the Republic of Korea,
Unpubl. Ph.D. thesis, Univ. Tasmania.
Kuehnbaum R M (Watts, Griffis and McOuat), 2006. Technical Report on the Sangdong
Tungsten Mine, Republic of Korea for Oriental Minerals Inc.
Sennitt C M, 2008. Scoping Study Sangdong Project, Gangwon Province, South Korea.
Tetra Tech/Wardrop, 2012. Report to Woulfe Mining Corporation: Sangdong Project Mineral
Resource Estimate, Technical Report.
Fowler A P (AMC Consultants Pty Ltd), 2014. Sangdong Resource Estimate, Woulfe
Mining Corporation.
Turner Mining and Geotechnical Pty Ltd, September, 2014. Underground Geotechnical
Study, Sangdong Mine.
A-Z Mining Professionals, June 2015. Technical Report on the Feasibility Study for the
Sangdong Tungsten Project, Republic of Korea, Prepared for Woulfe Mining Corporation.
July 2016
252
Technical Report on The Sangdong Project
1. I am an independent mining consultant, based at, Cambrose Farm, Redruth, Cornwall, TR16 4HT,
England.
3. I am a registered Chartered Engineer (C. Eng and Eur. Ing) with the Engineering Council (UK). Reg. no.
371572.
4. I am a professional fellow (FIMMM) in good standing of the Institute of Materials, Minerals and Mining.
5. I have worked as a mining engineer in the minerals industry for over 30 years. I have experience with a
wide variety of mineral deposits and reserve estimation techniques.
6. I have read NI 43-101 and the technical report, which is the subject of this certificate, has been prepared in
compliance with NI 43-101. By reason of my education, experience and professional registration, I fulfil the
requirements of a “qualified person” as defined by NI 43-101. My work experience includes 5 years at an
underground gold mine, 7 years as a mining engineer in the development and application of mining and
geological software, and 19 years as an independent mining consultant, involved with evaluation and
planning projects for both open pit and underground mines.
7. I am responsible for the preparation of the technical report titled “Technical Report on the Mineral Resource
and Reserves of the Sangdong Project” and dated July 31st, 2016. I visited the mine site on August 24th –
26th, 2015.
8. As of the date hereof, to the best of my knowledge, information and belief, the technical report, which is the
subject of this certificate, contains all scientific and technical information that is required to be disclosed to
make such technical report not misleading.
10. I have read the National Instrument and Form 43-101F1 (the “Form”) and the Technical Report has been
prepared in compliance with the Instrument and the Form.
11. I consent to the filing of the report with any Canadian stock exchange or securities regulatory authority, and
any publication by them of the report.
A. Wheeler, C.Eng.
July 2016
253