Cirque - Du - Soleil - Tour - Planning

For the exclusive use of M.
Moreno Miguez
HEC025
Volume 9
Issue 1
t
March 2011
os
Tour Planning at Cirque du Soleil1
rP
Case2 prepared by Professors Marie-Hélène JOBIN3 and Jean TALBOT4
‐ Where?
yo
‐ Istanbul.
‐ What show?
‐ I don’t know. We have to talk about it. The promoters behind the proposals suggested
names of shows, but I believe that the choice of show is open for discussion.
Louise Murray, Vice-President, Tour Planning and Partnerships at Cirque du Soleil, considered
op
the information given to her by Ines Lenzi, the Director of Partnership Management, before
answering: “Let me think about it a little longer. It seems like an interesting project, but we’re not
very familiar with the region. I’m going to take a close look at the proposals you’ve given me and
we’ll talk about it again after the Christmas holidays. By the way, Happy New Year 2009! Ciao!”
She hangs up the phone, deep in thought.
tC
Cirque du Soleil regularly receives unsolicited business proposals. But receiving two serious
proposals for the same city one right after the other could be seen as a strong sign of potential.
Which show would be the most appropriate? Which partner and which partnership model would
allow us to maximize our impact and our profits? There were many aspects to consider before
this project could become reality. Louise Murray thought to herself, “What worries me most are
No
the deadlines. It’s December 23, 2008. So 2010 may just as well be tomorrow! Is it possible to
add a stop in Istanbul5 to our show schedule?”
1
Translation from French of “La planification de tournée au Cirque du Soleil,” case deposited under #9 50 2011 004.
2
This case was produced as part of the 2008 strategic workshop for the development of major case studies at HEC Montréal. We
would like to thank HEC Montréal for its support for the production of case studies. We also thank our colleagues who
participated in this workshop for their helpful comments.
Do
3
Marie-Hélène Jobin is a Full Professor in the Department of Logistics and Operations Management at HEC Montréal.
4
Jean Talbot is a Full Professor in the Department of Information Technologies at HEC Montréal.
5
To protect the confidentiality of the proposals received, the project location and the description of the partners that submitted
proposals have been disguised.
© HEC Montréal 2011
All rights reserved for all countries. Any translation or alteration in any form whatsoever is prohibited.
The International Journal of Case Studies in Management is published on-line (www.hec.ca/revuedecas/en), ISSN 1911-2599.
This case is intended to be used as the framework for an educational discussion and does not imply any judgement on the
administrative situation presented. Deposited under number 9 50 2011 005 with the HEC Montréal Centre for Case Studies, 3000,
chemin de la Côte-Sainte-Catherine, Montréal (Québec) Canada H3T 2A7.
This document is authorized for educator review use only by Miguel Angel Moreno Miguez Universidad Panamericana until August 2013. Copying or posting is an infringement of copyright.
[email protected] or 617.783.7860
For the exclusive use of M. Moreno Miguez
Tour Planning at Cirque du Soleil
Indeed, planning is a long, drawn-out process at Cirque du Soleil. “Over the past few years, we
t
have worked hard to improve our planning process. It may not be perfectly tuned yet and we may
os
be missing interesting business opportunities due to an overly structured, long-term planning
process, but on the other hand, this structure is what allows us to manage complexity. I’ll have to
look at all the angles to see if we can optimize the process even more,” Louise Murray told
herself.
rP
From Street Performers to International Cultural Industry Leaders
Cirque du Soleil began with a very simple dream. A group of young
entertainers got together to amuse audiences, see the world, and have fun
doing it.
Guy Laliberté,
yo
Founder of Cirque du Soleil
Cirque du Soleil’s artists have travelled far and wide on the youthful dreams of its founder! And
over the years, nearly 80 million spectators on five continents have shared in the dreams of the
creators, artists and employees of Cirque du Soleil. The worldwide success of Canada’s cultural
jewel is attested by the numerous prestigious awards it has received, including Emmys, the
Drama Desk Award, the Bambi Award, the ACE, Geminis, the Félix and the Rose d’Or de
op
Montreux. In 2008, the company, which is headquartered in Montreal, presented 18 shows
simultaneously throughout the world. We’re a far cry from the performers on stilts at the Baie St-
Paul1 festival back in the early 1980s, when the idea for Cirque du Soleil was hatched.
In 1984, 73 people worked for Cirque du Soleil. Today, it has close to 4,000 employees,
including 1,000 artists hailing from 40 different countries. Guy Laliberté heads up a company
tC
that is international in every sense of the term – by its composition, its influence and the scope of
its activities – and whose unique signature is instantly recognizable around the world. The
company constantly renews its product offering, but the result is always a feast for the senses.
“Creativity is part of the Cirque culture.2 This creativity is on display in the work of the artists, of
course, but it is also manifested in the exploits of the craftspeople and technicians who work
No
behind the scenes,” Louise Murray points out. It also shows through in the work of the planners
and logisticians who collaborate to find customized solutions to new problems as they arise,
helping to turn Cirque into the Organization – a machine without precedent anywhere in the
world.
The numbers speak for themselves: in 2008, 18 different shows, including eight shows touring
the planet (see Appendix 1); 450 trailers and cargo containers transporting 4,400 tonnes of Cirque
du Soleil material around the world at any one time, and; an average of 400-500 tonnes of
Do
material for each show shipped by land, sea or air to their next destination. Since 1984, Cirque du
Soleil’s touring shows have stopped in over 200 cities the world over. One of the company’s
1
A municipality with a population of 13,000 in the Charlevoix region of Quebec, Canada.
2
We will use the abbreviated form “Cirque” when referring to Cirque du Soleil.
© HEC Montréal 2
greatest strengths lies in the speed with which entire shows are transferred from one site to
t
another.
os
Logistics at Cirque: On Your Mark. Get Set. Set Up, Tear Down! … Then Set
Up Again!
rP
A wide range of administrative formalities and tasks must be accomplished to ensure the transfer
of material and people to a new show site. The tearing down, repacking, shipping and setting up
must all be done in a very precise order. And because each move is to a new site, often in a new
country, the experience is unique every time. A technical problem, customs difficulties, a
breakdown or bad weather conditions can all lead to costly delays, sometimes even forcing the
cancellation of shows.
yo
Moreover, the profitability of Cirque’s business model depends on the density of the market.
Setting up a show involves very high fixed costs and profit is made only if the number of tickets
sold offsets the expenses incurred (see Appendix 2). The cancellation of a show consequently
results in a complete write-off, not only because of the loss of immediate profit, but also because
the show cannot be rescheduled. There is always another city waiting for Cirque, and, as such, it
can neither extend its stay nor return at a later date.
op
The logistics professionals at Cirque have become experts at a skill on which there is currently
little documentation. Through trial, error and a bit of luck, and often at the price of considerable
creativity, they have learned to find custom-made solutions. No two sites or shows are exactly the
same. Their challenge is to derive a science from the unique and the unprecedented in order to
assure the quality of the spectators’ experience, the public’s and artists’ safety and the
tC
profitability of the tour.
The arrival of a show in one city implies that another city has just said its goodbyes to Cirque’s
artists a few days previously. Indeed, because its highly specialized equipment is very expensive,
Cirque only has six big tops at its disposal.1 Therefore, it is not possible to start setting up
equipment before winding up in another city.
No
It normally takes 10 days to move to a new site: three days to dismantle and prepare the material
to be shipped and then seven days to completely set it all up again in a new location.2 There are
many tasks to be carried out, including preparation of the site, setting up of the big top, the tents
for the artists and public facilities, preparation of the technical plateaux, the flooring and the
trapezes, plumbing, mechanical and electrical work, carpentry, lighting and sound systems,
organization of on-site transportation and access to the public transit network, installation of
technology and telephone systems, etc. Everything must be done in a precise order since many
tasks can only be carried out once others have been completed. The four masts supporting the big
Do
top are the last to be taken down and the first to be put up at the new site.3
1
Cirque’s other touring shows are presented either in arenas or in installations provided by the promoter (ex. Fuji).
2
Appendix 3 shows the site plan for the show Varekai.
3
Appendix 4 summarizes the main tasks to be carried out during the 11 days between the last performance in one city and the
first performance in the next city.
© HEC Montréal 3
t
A tremendous amount of information is necessary to ensure the success of this process. The
os
technology is also pushed to the extreme. The main challenge is the frequency and speed with
which these operations must be completed. And since very few companies are required to
repeatedly dismantle and repack all the computer hardware necessary to run a performance site,
there are few models Cirque can refer to. The technical equipment must be available from the
very start of the installation and is often the last equipment to be packed up. It is also tricky to
rP
hook up to the host countries’ communication infrastructures, particularly for the ticketing
systems, which vary from one place to another.
Because of all these constraints, Cirque had no other choice than to create an environment
adapted to its own needs in terms of technology management. The transferred equipment includes
all of the necessary systems to manage and transfer the operating data and transactional
information. Trailers were adapted for transporting the servers and equipment, enabling them to
yo
be set up without being unpacked. By implementing this initiative, installation time was reduced
by 25%.
Portable boutiques with cash registers connected directly to headquarters’ central systems were
also developed, making it possible to manage inventory and track sales in real time and to
complete installation quickly. The box office was also redesigned to be used from a trailer to
minimize the need for connections and system configuration.
op
Optic fibres have now replaced traditional cabling to improve the bandwidth and secure the
network. Cirque is considering using satellite communication in the future to reduce the
accidental rupture of cables during work on the site. Links with the outside world are not only
vital for the transfer of management data, but also for the troupe to be able to keep in touch with
tC
their families while on the move. Realizing that it is critical for the health and morale of its
artists, Cirque ensures constant access to a communication network.
Experience has allowed Cirque to precisely document all setup and tear-down tasks, the
necessary personnel for each day of operation and the employees’ required qualifications. Even
the linguistic competencies required of the teams on site are specified to ensure efficient and safe
work. An estimate is also provided of the personnel needed for each performance.
No
A detailed nomenclature of the required material is produced for each tour. In this way, the exact
nature of everything being transported is known. This document is essential to ensure the proper
packing and labelling of goods, to adequately plan the transport and coordination of shipments, as
well as to settle customs formalities when traveling from one country to another.
It is an understatement to say that international transfers are challenging. When changing

continents, Cirque often takes the opportunity to renew material or make adjustments to a show.
Do
In such cases, the equipment may converge from many different places around the world, often
arriving via multiple modes of transportation. The material must be consolidated upon arrival on
the new continent and the precise details of shipments must be known in order to clear customs
formalities.
© HEC Montréal 4
The transfer of Alegria from Santiago, Chile to Seoul, Korea at the end of 2008 offers a good
t
illustration of the complexity involved in organizing these international transfers. In this case, a
os
major shipment was sent from Montreal to replace tents and promotional material, as well as to
renew certain equipment designed or custom-made at the company’s headquarters. The shipment
was sent by land to Vancouver and continued on by sea afterwards. Meeting the deadline was
critical in this case because the cargo contained equipment necessary to begin setting up upon
arrival.
rP
Equally urgent was the dispatching overseas of the canvas from Bordeaux, France, via the Suez
Canal. Also sent by boat was the set of big top masts and other infrastructure equipment from
Buenos Aires, Argentina, where they had been in storage for the Alegria tour. Once again, the
shipping time was critical because the masts are the first items to be assembled. The costumes
and artistic material were delivered by plane to Seoul as soon as the shows in Chile had wrapped
up.1
yo
Finally, part of the equipment that had been used in the Santiago shows was stored in South
America for the Quidam show commencing in June 2009, thus avoiding a costly repatriation to
Montreal.
Thus, it can be seen that Cirque’s equipment executes a complex ballet around the world. The
sequence of city stopovers, the equipment’s points of departure and the tour itineraries must be
op
carefully planned to minimize travel and to maximize the commercial potential of each
performance.
“Even so, there are always offers that are hard to refuse,” remarks Louise Murray. “Cirque is
made up of enterprising people who are overflowing with project ideas. It’s in our nature to be
tC
adventurous and to pounce on opportunities,” she adds.
However, there is a large potential for savings in streamlining tour plans to maximize a show’s
capacity and in proposing itineraries that minimize travel and shipping costs and installation
times. Planning is therefore the key to success.
No
Planning: Reconciling Rationalization and an Entrepreneurial Spirit

It is the responsibility of Louise Murray and her team to achieve a balance between all these
tensions. One could say that her role has grown as Cirque has grown. When she joined the
communications and sponsorship team at Cirque du Soleil in 1992, the company had only
500 employees. Her previous training had left her well prepared to function in an environment
characterized by diversity and to promote difference. Her B.A. in cultural animation and research
had taught her that difference is a valuable asset and that there are more dimensions to cultural
Do
expression than just its artistic dimension.
Louise Murray has a well-integrated vision of Cirque productions:
1
Appendix 5 illustrates the complexity of organizing the setup of Alegria in Seoul in October 2008.
© HEC Montréal 5
Our shows are not produced independently of each other. A synergy must emerge between these
t
different cultural works. We can see them as a strategic portfolio of cultural products. Ideally, we
os
would be able to present several touring shows in succession in a large city in order to establish our
reputation, build an audience and open the way for the establishment of a permanent show. But you
need market depth to do that. Smaller markets require different solutions. For example, shows
nearing the end of their touring career are now revamped as arena shows to reduce costs and
maximize returns in smaller markets.
rP
Today, Louise Murray, who holds an M.B.A. from HEC Montréal, is Vice-President, Tour
Planning and Partnerships at Cirque. She leads a 15-member team divided into three branches
(see Appendix 7). The Tour Partnership Management Department, led by Ines Lenzi, ensures
partnership follow-up and contract management. Ms. Lenzi also coordinates consultations
between the various internal stakeholders for the preparation of contracts. For its part, the Tour
Planning Department is headed by Gera Landmeter. The principal mandate of this department is
yo
to develop the tour schedule, which requires gathering information of the highest quality in order
to support decision making and to ensure that all issues and opportunities are explored. Finally,
Sylvain Guimond is the Director of Touring Sites Development. His team is the largest and is
responsible for knowing and anticipating absolutely everything about the sites visited in
preparation for future show deployments. Team work and intense collaboration with numerous
internal and external stakeholders are required of all members of the Tour Planning and
Partnership team.
op
Louise Murray’s strong interpersonal skills, client-oriented culture and holistic understanding of
the Cirque concept are all major assets that she has put to good use in order to consolidate
partnerships and provide leadership for tour preparation. One of her most valuable contributions
has without a doubt been the rationalization of the planning process, which she successfully
implemented while managing to preserve Cirque’s ability to take advantage of business
tC
opportunities.
“Turkey is definitely an attractive opportunity! Now all we have to do is determine which show
we could present there,” she muses to herself as she opens the application containing the tour
plan (see Appendix 6).
No
Long-range planning
Preparing a tour requires keeping an open mind in the face of business proposals and a systematic
solicitation process aimed at identifying the best sites and the countries with the strongest
commercial potential. As part of her job, Louise Murray regularly meets with promoters, visits
potential sites and closes business deals.
Tour planning requires a methodical approach that involves many different sectors of the
company in a climate of collegiality. Although the planning horizon is very stable for resident
Do
shows, the same cannot be said of touring shows. Five years ahead of time, Cirque is already
planning what continent each show will visit. There is a two- to three-year horizon for choosing
the cities to be visited by each show. At that stage, the number of performances and the length of
the stay in each city still have to be decided.
© HEC Montréal 6
Normally, the tour plan is finalized at least 24 months ahead of the event. “Actually, that’s the
t
target we aim for,” explains Louise Murray. “However, I can say that 90% of our projects are
os
completely locked in two years ahead of time.1 The remainder represents our capacity for
flexibility and the potential to seize business opportunities.”
In fact, Cirque’s organizational capacity to make changes to its tour plan is quite substantial. As
Louise Murray explains:
rP
Thanks to the expertise of our employees, it’s not that complicated to move a tent. We pull up the
stakes and we change sites. We can afford to change a tour plan even with only a few months’ notice,
but the less notice we have, the higher the costs. Technically, it’s possible to make changes if they
involve one of the 80 destinations that are already on the plan. However, it there are too many
modifications, it becomes too complex for us to manage.
Given the extreme complexity of the site installation process and the many formalities associated
yo
with a show’s arrival in a city, it goes without saying that a clearly visible planning horizon is
essential to ensure the sustainability of Cirque and the success of its future projects.
Accordingly, Cirque has made a major effort to reinforce its planning process and, particularly, to
ensure that all members of the organization adopt a structured approach. Figure 1, which was
prepared by Louise Rémillard, Senior Internal Audit Director, presents the outline of this
hierarchical approach adopted by Cirque. As can be seen, the tour plans are established based on
op
a strategic reflection and a search for cohesion with the company’s vision. We propose to take a
closer look at how this process takes shape and at the actors involved in preparing the plan.
The planning process and the actors involved

tC
As Figure 1 shows, the planning process comprises four separate plans: the strategic plan, which
has a horizon of three to five years, the long-term plan, with a horizon of 30 to 36 months, the
tactical plan, based on an 18- to 30-month horizon, and, finally, the operational plan, which has a
much shorter horizon of 12 to 18 months.
No
Do
1
Reference here is to the start and end dates of a project (i.e., a show in a city), which do not change in 90% of cases. Additional
performances may be added in advance of the event, but they are added inside the planned weeks.
© HEC Montréal 7
t
Strategic / Operational Continuum - Touring
os
Executive Operational
Strategic Tactical
Long-term Short-term
rP
Strategic Making the
Setting Strategies Setting the Itinerary
Objectives Itinerary Happen
 Provide overall  Analysis of  Goals  Implementation

direction situation
 Targets  Monitoring
 Align the  SWOT
yo
enterprise  Strategies  Adjustment
 Risk analysis
 Define goals and  Measures  Control
objectives (growth,  Specific strategies
 Business Deals
profitability, etc.)  Business Cases
 Link with vision
and mission
Strategic Plan Long-Term Plan Tactical Plan Operational Plan
op
EC members + EP EF members +EP Directors +SGM SGM +TSDir
3-5 years 30-36 months 18-30 months 12-18 months
Figure 1: Tour plan development

tC
Strategic planning
The strategic plan is established by the members of senior management (mainly senior vice-
presidents), the executive producers and the artisans behind the Cirque image.1 This plan sets out
Cirque’s main orientations and ensures that the itinerary is aligned with the company’s vision. It
also fixes growth and profitability objectives.
No
Long-term planning
The long-term plan covers a shorter horizon of 30 to 36 months. The preparation of this plan is
launched at the bi-annual meeting chaired by Daniel Lamarre, President and CEO, and the team
reporting to Jacques Marois, Senior Vice-President of Touring Shows. Louise Murray is
responsible for preparing the initial tour proposals. The scenarios are approved by Jacques
Marois and, based on this preliminary scenario, the business cases for the different options are
developed by the Office of the Chief Financial Officer. The plan is then presented to the
Do
executive board,2 which approves the global, long-term plan and finalizes the company’s
objectives. The long-term plan is then communicated to the various directors.
1
See the company’s organizational chart in Appendix 7.
2
The Executive Board is mainly made up of senior vice-presidents.
© HEC Montréal 8
Tactical planning
t
os
One of the purposes of the long-term plan is to establish the medium-term tactical plan. It
provides Louise Murray with valuable input for an important meeting, the “2TP Meeting,”1 at
which the planning of tours and partnerships is discussed. This meeting mainly involves the vice-
presidents of the different units, who join the teams reporting to vice-presidents Louise Murray
and Jacques Marois. Gradually, the options become clearer and specific cities and partners are
considered.
rP
In the case of a new production, a kick-off meeting is called following the 2TP meeting. Since
everything is new, several elements need to be assembled. A list of essential information is thus
drawn up that includes financial data, potential installation sites and their availability as well as
the contingencies inherent to the new show. Research is then undertaken to gather this
information. The general idea is to obtain, in a timely manner, all the information necessary for
yo
the planning phase, which is then carried out by geographic region.
Approximately 28 months before the deadline, Jacques Marois and Louise Murray’s team are
ready to present all the partnership and itinerary options for potential tours. At that point, a large
meeting, called the work group, is convened, including the directors of the different divisions,
show directors and site and technical operation heads. The purpose of this meeting, which is
conducted in a spirit of collegiality, is to ensure that the full details of the options proposed are
op
examined from every angle. As Louise Murray explains:
Clearly, there will still be many outstanding issues at this stage in the process. The idea is not to
discuss things like transport or visa delivery problems in this or that country. Our overall goal is to
determine the feasibility of our plan, alert all the stakeholders to the wrinkles that need to be ironed
out and tap into everyone’s experience in order to make life easier in the steps ahead.
tC
In the run-up to this meeting, all relevant information on the available site is supplied by the
Director of Touring Sites Development, with additional information being contributed by the
Office of the Vice-President of Marketing, by the Office of the Chief Financial Officer and by the
different departments concerned by the operations.
The itinerary of the cities visited, known as the CSI, for City Show Itinerary, represents the
No
culmination of this step. Several actors are involved in the development and analysis of this
document, which details the cities visited by each show, set-up and closing dates, the
performances spread out over each week and potential options for added performances. The
seating capacity of the big top (i.e., number of seats), sales targets and annual vacations are also
included. This is undoubtedly one of the key documents in the organization of Cirque’s touring
shows.
Once a broad outline of the itinerary has been established, the next step involves a detailed
Do
planning process where each division must operationalize the general plans. This is a pivotal
moment in terms of allocating tasks and making everyone accountable within the collective
project. Everyone puts their shoulder to the wheel to help find solutions to the challenges that
inevitably arise. Work groups are organized, in some cases to track down carriers, locate storage
1
2TP Meeting = Tour Planning and Tour Partnership Meeting.
© HEC Montréal 9
sites or rental equipment, in others to negotiate supplies or custom-made equipment, costumes or
t
sets. Major efforts are also undertaken to obtain authorizations and visas and to complete the
os
administrative formalities necessary to enter, stay in and even leave the countries on the tour
plan.
Over the following months, touch-ups are invariably made to the plan, whether to add a stop-over
city, to remove a city or to alter the amount of time spent in each city. These last-minute changes
rP
are mainly dictated by business forecasts. Logistical constraints are also taken into account in
order to optimize the order in which the cities are visited. All these changes are systematically
reported in the organization’s dashboard.1
Operational planning
Twenty-four months from the deadline, the schedules are set and the show dates are sent out
yo
internally by the Internal Communications Department, which has now become the custodian of
the schedule. The communication of these dates sends a green light to the Marketing Department
to initiate promotional and ticket sale activities. However, to postpone cash outflows as long as
possible, promotional and marketing activities are planned as late as possible starting from the
date on which tickets go on sale. In some markets, the ticket release date is only eight months in
advance, while in others a period of 12 months is common. Based on the ticket release date, the
different promotional, merchandising and sponsorship activities are planned for the latest date
op
possible.
Given all these elements, it is easy to see why the 18-month period is considered borderline for
ensuring a smooth execution. If changes need to be made after this date, a much more extensive
set of measures needs to be deployed. The relevant documents (the City Show Itinerary and the
tC
show schedule) will obviously need to be modified. The Internal Communications Department is
responsible for updating the information on the Intranet. The information is then relayed to all the
stakeholders concerned. If needed, the new shipping dates are confirmed and the availability of
the site validated. If tickets have already been sold for performances that are cancelled, each
ticket purchaser has to be contacted and offered a refund.
No
Business Partners: Precious Allies

Concurrently with the show planning processes, the Vice-President of Tour Planning and
Partnerships must develop and maintain relations with business partners and local promoters.
“These actors are important for the success of Cirque du Soleil,” she explains. “A competent
partner that we can trust is a major asset to us when penetrating a new region.” It goes without
saying that forming a partnership with a local promoter can eat into potential profits, but their
knowledge of the territory, consumer habits, local actors and the availability of top-quality sites
Do
in large cities makes it worth it.
Louise Murray uses the example of the show Alegria in Seoul to illustrate this point. An
independent promoter was used for this location, which required negotiating a whole new
1
See Appendix 8 for excerpts of the dashboard.
© HEC Montréal 10
contract and starting the whole process over from scratch, thus eliminating any possibility of
t
economies of scale. On the other hand, an experienced and well-connected promoter makes it
os
possible to cover several projects within a single round of negotiations and their knowledge of
the terrain can spare Cirque a costly process of trial and error. However, profits have to be shared
with the promoter. Louise Murray summarizes the situation thus:
If we go it alone, we reap all the benefits, but we also have to do everything ourselves. Promoters
help remove operational obstacles and reduce uncertainty and, in some cases, they offer the potential
rP
for higher revenue because they are familiar with the local sponsorship community. If we know the
market very well, it’s usually more profitable for us to go it alone. Otherwise, it’s usually better to
partner with a promoter.
However, Louise Murray is very clear on one point:

We look upon our partners as vectors in the fulfilment of our mission. We want to remain in control
yo
of our chain of value creation at all times and there is no question of changing our business model or
losing our soul in a partnership.
She mentions one particular case in which Cirque’s partner, which was responsible for artists’
accommodations on the tour, tried to skimp on the hotel category, provoking a strong reaction
from Cirque management. Such a move cannot be tolerated because the quality of a production
depends on the morale of the artists – how they are fed and housed affects their well-being.
op
The value creation model at Cirque is complex. Promoters are required to fit into this system and
contribute to it. Cirque does not sell its shows to a distributor. It is the partners that team up with
Cirque to deliver an artistic work and offer audiences a unique experience. It is therefore only
appropriate that the lion’s share of the profit goes to the artists – that is, to Cirque. Under no
circumstances would Cirque tolerate a larger portion of the profit going to the promoter.
tC
The process of establishing contracts with promoters involves several internal actors at Cirque,
including the people in charge of marketing, sponsorships, social responsibility, finance, taxation
and insurance. Human resources, technical operations and, of course, the general show managers
concerned also participate. All of them have a say in the process of forging partnerships. As such,
the establishment of a partnership involves multiple points of contact.
No
However, the major players form a smaller circle. This circle includes the Office of the Vice-
President of Tour Planning and Partnerships, of Business and Legal Affairs, and a sponsor who
also serves as chief negotiator. The sponsor can change depending on the circumstances and the
business opportunity. It is usually either Jacques Marois, Senior Vice-President of Touring
Shows, Daniel Lamarre, President and CEO, or one of the executive producers who takes on this
role.
It is this negotiator who initiates talks and defines the framework of the budding partnership. The
Do
baton is then handed to Louise Murray, whose job it is to validate the different aspects of the
contract to be signed with the various actors mentioned above. She is also responsible for
preparing the contract and obtaining the authorization of the key stakeholders in the process.
© HEC Montréal 11
The preparation of the show schedule represents a delicate task for all members of her team, as
t
both operational considerations and the needs of the personnel must be taken into account.
os
The next step is the signing of the contract with the promoter. For the general show manager, this
is the signal he has been waiting for to put the wheels in motion that will transform this
agreement into a magical event.
rP
There are several types of financial arrangements that Cirque can negotiate with a partner. First, it
can always decide to go it alone, in which case it will be responsible for everything from
selecting the site to preparing visa applications and negotiating water supply and security services
around the site. While Cirque gets to keep all the profits, it is also alone in assuming all the risks.
Another solution is to establish a partnership. Several formulas are possible. The simplest is the
fixed show fee formula, in which the partner assumes responsibility for all costs and revenues
yo
and pays Cirque a pre-established, fixed amount for the show. This option eliminates any risk for
Cirque.
The most common formula used, however, is the “Rock & Roll” model, under which the profits
are shared, with a percentage going to the artist (i.e., Cirque) and the remainder going to the
promoter. Typically, a percentage of box office revenue and merchandise sales is also paid to the
artist in the form of royalties.1 The costs incurred by each party are deducted from the remaining
op
gross sales and the profits are divided as per the agreement signed between the two parties.2
Finally, a customized allocation of expenditures and revenues is also possible, but the general
principle remains the same: the artist receives the majority of revenue generated by the work.
tC
In the course of this process, Louise Murray typically meets with the promoters several times in
addition to making contact with several subcontractors in the field, visiting several sites and
installations and travelling a few thousand kilometres.
When selecting a partner and signing a contract, Cirque’s main goal is not necessarily to extract
as much profit as possible, to the detriment of the partner. Rather, its logic is geared toward
establishing a long-term relationship based on shared expertise and mutual growth.
No
Signing contracts that lack precision or fail to cover certain aspects invariably leads to conflict
and losses. Given the number of actors involved in the preparation of these contracts, it is
important to clarify the areas of responsibility of each stakeholder when preparing the schedule
(see Table 1; the grey zones indicate the person in charge).
Louise Murray’s team has also developed a detailed roadmap of the different actions to be taken
in order to ensure that everyone knows what their tasks are in preparing the contract, that
Do
everything is done on time, and that no aspect is omitted. This document is basically a checklist
indicating each critical task in the project process, along with the date on which it was completed
1
Royalties can range from 0 to 25%. In the entertainment industry, a 10% royalty is typically negotiated.
2
Generally speaking, the artist receives a higher percentage than the promoter. The percentage can vary from 51% to 90%,
depending on the notoriety of the artist and the risks associated with the project.
© HEC Montréal 12
or is expected to be completed. In some cases, there is simply a binary indicator to show whether
t
or not the task has been completed. This monitoring tool is updated regularly. Each active project
os
at Cirque has its own roadmap. A project is a combination of a show, a site and a date.
Table 1: Responsibilities of the different stakeholders in preparing contracts

Show Manager Tour Planning Technical Business and
and Partnerships Operations Legal Affairs
rP
Director
Show acts
Show schedules
Specification of sites
Cirque’s equipment
Promoter’s equipment
Deployment and tear-down
yo
Cirque’s personnel
Promoter’s personnel
Transportation service
Sponsorship agreements
Payment schedule
op
Turkey: A Project Worth Exploring
Turkey would be a new destination for Cirque du Soleil. Cirque has received several unsolicited
proposals from promoters1 to set up a Cirque show in Istanbul in 2010, according to the report
emailed by Ines Lenzi to Louise Murray earlier this morning. “Surely that’s a sign that there is
tC
interesting potential here!” she muses.
Two serious proposals have been received. The first is from Turkey’s Minister of Culture and
Tourism (see Appendix 9). The second was submitted by a promoter in the telecommunications
sector (see Appendix 10). As it does for all the proposals it receives, Cirque has responded with a
standard email (see Appendix 11). This response is a first step aimed at framing the potential
business relationship within a commercial logic. “Basically, we ask them to do their homework
No
and to ensure that their proposal is economically viable for Cirque and for them,” Louise Murray
explains. This initial contact generally eliminates proposals from groups or individuals that are
not backed by a solid organization.
In this case, both proposals appear to be supported by serious individuals. In addition, the market
potential is good. After taking a quick look at the market studies at her disposal, Louise Murray
concludes that Cirque can reasonably expect to sell over 100,000 tickets in Istanbul. This is a
realistic scenario. At the same time, she notes that tickets are usually released for sale in this
Do
market eight months in advance.
1
The business proposals presented in this section have been disguised to protect the confidentiality of the parties involved.
© HEC Montréal 13
Turkey’s goal is to boost its visibility on the international stage and it has been courting the
t
European Union for several years. Istanbul was designated European Cultural Capital in 2010.
os
The Turkish metropolis, which hopes to draw 10 million foreign tourists in 2010, has announced
a series of projects aimed at promoting its historical heritage. With a new leg of the Grand Prix
Formula One in Istanbul, Turkey has resolutely set its sights on the West, making it a market
with a lot of potential in the coming years. The timing for launching a show in Turkey would thus
be perfect for 2010, but the big question is: Is there enough time to put everything in place?
rP
The proposal also carries some risks. This is a country that Cirque has never before visited. It has
no tried and tested partnerships in this region. Although Turkey is quite Westernized, it doesn’t
really know a lot about Turks’ cultural interests. Nor is Cirque familiar with the country’s
administrative procedures, particularly in the area of customs and immigration. Many financial
aspects also still need to be clarified. Is it easy to get money out of the country? How do its tax
laws work? Then, there are the questions of the infrastructure necessary to ensure logistics and
yo
the installation of Cirque’s operations. For example, is there a box office network? Will Cirque
obtain a site with good potential?
As Louise Murray likes to say: “Impossible is just a word. For us, it’s a challenge to go beyond
our limits.” Challenges and obstacles will not stop Cirque from coming to Istanbul. “But at the
same time, the desire to go beyond our limits should nourish us, not make us burn out,” she adds.
op
The organization has a motto that Cirque president Guy Laliberté repeats often: “Each
opportunity must offer a choice, a creative challenge that lights a spark in us. That is the first
criterion in selecting our projects. Also, we have to have fun doing what we do.”
For the challenge to become a source of satisfaction, there has to be a good fit between Cirque’s
tC
culture and the host country. Cirque has always refused to compromise on artistic expression.
The fundamental question thus becomes whether the creative work will resonate with audiences.
And the best indicator of that is undoubtedly ticket sales. In short, will the commercial operation
be a profitable one?
Everything is based on the anticipated gross profit margin of the projects, which, simply put,
depends partly on costs and partly on potential ticket sales. The deeper the market, the higher the
No
revenues. However, there is also fierce internal competition to support one project or another.
Ultimately, the projects selected will be those that are the most feasible… or at least those that
Cirque has the most faith in!
It also happens that decisions are made based on a particularly appealing project or for strategic
reasons, with the profit margin criterion being put on the back burner. “I don’t systematically try
to avoid less profitable destinations. However, it’s my responsibility to highlight the cost of these
strategic decisions and to assess whether it’s worth the effort,” explains Louise Murray.
Do
She looks over all the documents spread out on her desk and sums up the decision that lies before
her:
© HEC Montréal 14
First of all, we have to determine whether Turkey is a viable destination and what the potential risks
t
and benefits are. We also have to determine what work we could present there and when. On top of
os
all this, there have to be opportunities to form partnerships.
I am happy to see that we have succeeded in developing a structured planning process that ensures
our long-term visibility. However, by integrating Turkey in our tour plan as early as 2010, we will be
bypassing the normal process. Am I making a mistake in encouraging this project? Should I insist
instead that the organization adopt a disciplined approach to optimize our costs?
rP
yo
op
tC
No
Do
2011-03-14
© HEC Montréal 15
Appendix 1
t
Cirque du Soleil Shows and Destinations in 2008-2009
os
Touring shows
Varekai (Europe)
rP
Dralion (Japan)
Quidam (Mexico, then Europe as of April 2008)
Alegría (South America)
Corteo (North Amerca)
KOOZA (North America)
Arena shows
yo
DELIRIUM (Europe)
Saltimbanco (North America)
Resident shows
“O” (Las Vegas, Nevada)

op
Mystère (Las Vegas, Nevada)
ZUMANITY – The Sensual Side of Cirque du Soleil (Las Vegas, Nevada)
La Nouba (Orlando, Florida)
KÀ (Las Vegas, Nevada)
LOVE (Las Vegas, Nevada)
tC
Macao 2008 (Macao, Chine)

Luxor 2008 (Las Vegas, Nevada)
Tokyo 2008 (Tokyo, Japan)
Seasonal shows
Wintuk (New York, New York)

No
From November to January every year
Other Cirque du Soleil shows since 1984:
Cirque du Soleil
The Magic Continues
We Reinvent the Circus
Nouvelle Expérience
Do
Fascination*
*A collaboration with Cirque Knie
Visit the website at http://www.cirquedusoleil.com/world/fr/be/intro/intro.asp for a

description of the theme of each show.
© HEC Montréal 16
Appendix 2
t
Data Used to Calculate a Show’s Profitability1
os
 Average ticket price: $90
 Revenue from merchandise sales: 2% of box office revenue
rP
 Number of seats in the Big Top: 2,500
 Average attendance rate for shows: 85%
 Number of performances per week: 6 the first week,
yo
7 to 10 the following weeks,
based on demand2
 Average total cost of installation in a city

(including tear-down): 1.5 million
 Fixed costs and amortization of

op
show development costs: 1.5 million
 Cost of a typical international transfer:3 2 million
 Average expenditures per week per show: 1 million

tC
 Additional sponsorship revenue:
 If Cirque acts alone: between 5% and 20% of

box office revenue
 If Cirque acts with a promoter: between 10% and 80% of

No
box office revenue

Do
1
These data are adjusted for the Turkish market.
2
The first week is limited to six performances because it starts with the end of set-up and the dress rehearsal. For the
following weeks, tickets are first released for seven performances per week. If demand is high, extra shows are added, for
a maximum of 10 performances per week. Thus, for a typical stay of six weeks, the number of performances can vary
from 41 to 56.
3
Turkey is not considered as requiring an international transfer if the show selected is touring in Europe, North Africa, the
Near East or the Middle East.
© HEC Montréal 17
Appendix 3
t
Site Plan for Varekai
os
rP
yo
op
tC
No
Do
Source: Cirque du Soleil’s internal document
© HEC Montréal 18
Appendix 4
Procedure for a City-to-City Transfer
Do
Installation
Day 1 Day 2 Day 3 Day 4

ACTIONS ACTIONS ACTIONS ACTIONS
Big Top Masts up and Leveled Big Top Raising @ 14:00 Concessions tent up Bleacher day
Cupola in Place Water Available on Site VIP Floor Colimacons
GENERAL
Shops set up Grid Dome Stage structure BS Floor
Artistic Tent up and Floor in VIP tent Lamp check in PM
Artistic Tent Masts & Canvas Big Top Canvas Concessions, Warehouse, Sanitary tents Finish small tents
No
Big Top Masts installed Big Top Raising Finish VIP Tents
TENT
Cupola in position and attached VIP Tent AT & Technical Tunnels
Float cupola BT Walls
Unload containers/Trailers Unload containers VIP floor Bleachers & Stairs setup
Set up shops, shop tents Workshop continue Bleachers Ring Install sound booth platform by 3 PM
SITE
Install Stage managers booth Bleacher prep
Stake painting
Main Water & Sewer connections Sanitary setup Run hoses & place manifolds Continue public sanitary set up
tC
Catering Sink Waste and Water hoses - waste pumps Run plumbing to public sanitary units VIP & FOH connections
PLUMBING
Begin kitchen plumbing
Machinery Inspection Machinery Inspection Machinery Inspection Machinery Inspection

Set up temporary kitchen if necessary Place kitchen trailers Kitchen set up Finish Kitchen set-up
MECHANIC
BT Mast Power Connect water station, laundry, sanitary Cables under VIP floor Concession & VIP distribution
BT & AT lights Install work lights in BT & AT Install mast lights in concession tents Power to box office
op
ELECTRICS/ HVAC
Connect power around site - BT, AT, Shops HVAC Ducting brackets for AT HVAC placement around BT Mast Emergency Lights
Install ground rods Place BT HVAC Install HVAC Ducting in BT Install lightning arrestor
Set up shops, shop tents Install cupola rigging Raise Grid Dome AT Rig
BT Masts with Tent crew Install funicular rigging Install flying man winch Install flying man cable
RIGGING
Raise Grid Dome masts Install aerial camay Install duo trapeze
Assist with Grid Dome arches
Set up shop Unload Grid Dome masts Build stage structure Colimacons
Install Artistic tent flooring Unload/Clean Grid Dome Lay stage panels Backstage floor
CARPENTRY
Assemble Grid Dome Install cyclo truss Cyclorama
Assemble Catwalk Load empty crates
yo
Set up shops, shop tents Unload trailer into Artistic Install Power track cycs Install potonce lights
Position mast collars Maintenance and cleaning of equipment Continue maintenance Clear Artistic tent by end of day
LIGHTING
Hang instruments on BT masts Install dimmers Run under bleacher cables
Hang Grid Dome instruments Light check 8 PM
Set up shops, shop tents Hang Cupola speakers Continue maintenance Install monitors
Unload trailer into Artistic Move monitor equipment under stage in PM Run under bleacher runs
SOUND
Hang Mast Speakers Install FOH
Maintenance and cleaning of equipment Clear Artistic tent by end of day
rP
Unload office trailer, office load in Kitchen operational
PUBLIC/TOUR SERVICES
VIP set up, Concessions set up
IT/PHONE
EXTERNAL
os
© HEC Montréal 19
t
Appendix 4 (cont’d)
Do
Installation
Day 5 Day 6 Day 7 Day 8 Day 9

DRESS REHEARSAL PREMIERE
ACTIONS ACTIONS ACTIONS ACTIONS ACTIONS
Chairs Setup Big top meeting Training with lights Emergency evacuation Training
Artistic set up Technical adjustments with artists Fences and benches Emergency net procedure Final touches
GENERAL
Net focus Tent cleaning Tent cleaning
Light Focus Sound check with band Sound check with singers
No
Big Top Tunnels Water proof Tent Cleaning Install Flags on BT Misc. details as needed
Black out for light focus Install rain flaps Check tunnels & tent installations Final touches
TENT
Artistic Doors finished Begin tent cleaning Wind Meter Site Clean up & rack placement
Clean ground sheets
Chairs Installation Bleacher and chair adjustments Stairs checked & finished Sponsor signage installed Misc. details as needed
Tunnel Stairs and Railings Box Office awning and adjustments Sponsor Signs installed Emergency net procedure
SITE
Finish doors 7 &8 Fix checker plate Handicapped ramps Clean public areas
Install bleacher curtain Install benches & fences Finish & touchup fence installation
Continue VIP & FOH hose runs Misc. details as needed Misc. details as needed Misc. details as needed Misc. details as needed
tC
Connect satellite units
PLUMBING
Disinfect water system in evening
Machinery Inspection Machinery Inspection Generator Maintenance Final touches Misc. details as needed
MECHANIC
Fine tuning of FOH Later call for Electrician Tunnel Lights Late Call Electrician Misc. details as needed
Late call for Electrician Bleacher distros & snakes Wire Toilets & pumps Test emergency lights
ELECTRICS/ HVAC
Install HVAC ducting under bleachers Emergency& bleacher section light installation Small Tent lighting Side Wall lights
op
Electrics & HVAC communications Site Light towers
Adjust flying man winch Flying man adjustments Artistic training Artistic training Artistic training
Install trapeze net Trapeze adjustments Emergency net procedure
RIGGING
Load trailer High Bar adjustments DRESS REHEARSAL PREMIERE
Unload Props and Artistic trailers Dress Backstage & Stage Artistic training Artistic training Artistic training
Set-up props Trampoline adjustment with artists Finish Props installation Emergency net procedure
CARPENTRY Install power track trampoline Road Case storage of empties Painting touch ups DRESS REHEARSAL PREMIERE
Paint backstage floor if needed Clean & mop stage
yo
Training with lights Artistic training Artistic training
DRESS REHEARSAL
LIGHTING
Emergency net procedure PREMIERE
Light check 8 PM Focus details if needed
Connect office televisions Setup Camera & finishing touches on AV Artistic training Artistic training
Sound check 6 PM Set up band stage with musicians DRESS REHEARSAL
SOUND
Singers Sound check Emergency net procedure PREMIERE
Musician's Sound check
Box office open Usher training DRESS REHEARSAL PREMIERE
rP
Public area signage
IT/PHONE
EXTERNAL
os
© HEC Montréal 20
t
Do
Tear-Down
Day 1 Day 2 Day 3

ACTIONS ACTIONS ACTIONS
Big Top & Artistic Walls & Tunnels Artistic Tent down Big Top Down & Pack
Concession Tents Plumbing Strike completed Pull stakes
GENERAL
Bleachers strike Technical Show strike complete & loaded at end of night Finish all loads
Strike & load Artistic, Lighting & Sound
Sanitary Tunnel, Handicapped Tunnels, Big Top Tunnels Artistic Tent down Big Top Down & load
No
TENT Artistic & Big Top walls VIP Tent Cupola down & load
Concession Tent including stakes & Curbs Load trailers
VIP Patio Big top prep
Box Office Awning Strike Artistic tent floor Load containers
Fencing Pull stakes
SITE Big Top Chairs & Tunnels & stairs Load trailers
Bleachers struck & loaded
VIP Floor
Catering Tent Plumbing Complete all of plumbing strike Help other departments as needed
tC
Close sanitary
PLUMBING
Toilets removal & strike of all plumbing
Begin kitchen strike Finish kitchen strike Help other departments as needed
MECHANIC
Remove lights in Tunnels Remove all work lights and emergency lights Remove Big Top mast lights
Strike VIP HVAC Load, Electrical & ducting container, Transformer and SMB Assist with masts
ELECTRICS/ HVAC
Concessions tents & VIP Load Electrical trailer
op
FOH Cam locks Connect Big Top lights for night crew if necessary
Strike Artistic rigging Strike highbar structure Pack funicular cables
Lower lighting rings Strike mast rigging Pack cupola motors, rigging
RIGGING
Strike duo trapeze Lower Grid Dome Assist with masts
Remove rigging from high bar structure Strike Grid Dome masts
Strike trampoline Strike colimacons Load trailers
Remove backstage floor Strike Grid Dome
CARPENTRY
Strike panels and facings Load trailers
Remove upstage and downstage structure
Strike mast rigging Pull feeder Pack mast cabling
Pack under bleacher runs Load trailers as needed
yo
Pack Grid dome lighting and cable
LIGHTING
Load trailer
Strike FOH Pull feeder Pack cupola speakers
Strike monitors Load trailers as needed Assist with masts
Lower and pack mast speakers, surrounds
SOUND
Load trailer
Pack offices Rental equipment return

rP
Pack concessions, VIP Close suppliers
IT/PHONE
Artistic loads out and packs trailers
EXTERNAL
Source: Cirque du Soleil’ internal Document

os
© HEC Montréal 21
t
Appendix 5
t
The Transfer of Alegria from Santiago to Seoul
os
rP
yo
op
tC
No
Do
© HEC Montréal 22
2008
SPECTACLE Janvier Février Mars Avril Mai Juin Juillet Août Septembre Octobre Novembre Décembre
7 14 21 28 4 11 18 25 3 10 17 24 31 7 14 21 28 5 12 19 26 2 9 16 23 30 7 14 21 28 4 11 18 25 1 8 15 22 29 6 13 20 27 3 10 17 24 1 8 15 22 29
Do
Alegría Rio (27) 7 Sao Paulo (04) 15 Porto Alegre (08) 20 Buenos Aires (27) 13 Santiago (21) Congé annuel 10 15 Séoul (21) (28)
Monter
Quidam (13) 24 27 Veracruz (16) Congé annuel EUR 18 Lisbonne (25) 5 Malaga (13) 24 Alicante (31) 11 Barcelone (19) 30 Bruxelles (21)
© HEC Montréal
rey (10)
Dralion Congé annuel 25 Tokyo 2 (06) 23 Fukuoka (15) Congé annuel AUS 16 Sydney (12) 23 Canberra [34s] (16) 27 Brisbane
Varekai 7 Londres (17) 28 Amsterdam (25) 5 Berlin (13) Congé annuel 31 Oberhausen (7) 18 Vienne (02) 13 Madrid
Corteo 11 San Diego (17) 1 Portland (13) 24 Seattle (01) CAN 12 Vancouver (20) 31 Calgary (7) 24 Ottawa (26) USA 13 Miami (28)
KOOZA (20) 31 San Jose (16) 1 Hartford (27) 8 Philadelphie (15) 26 Chicago (24) 5 Boston (19) 30 Washington (14) Congé annuel 2
No
DELIRIUM
Saltimbanco Congé annuel
Wintuk
La Nouba Relâche les dimanches et les lundis (cliquez ici pour l'horaire détaillé)
Mystère Relâche les jeudis et vendredis (cliquez ici pour l'horaire détaillé)
tC
«O» Relâche les lundis et les mardis (cliquez ici pour l'horaire détaillé)
Zumanity Relâche les lundis et jeudis (cliquez ici pour l'horaire détaillé)
KÀ Relâche les dimanches et les lundis (cliquez ici pour l'horaire détaillé)
LOVE Relâche les mardis et mercredis (cliquez ici pour l'horaire détaillé)
23
2009
op
SPECTACLE Janvier Février Mars Avril Mai Juin Juillet Août Septembre Octobre Novembre Décembre
5 12 19 26 2 9 16 23 2 9 16 23 30 6 13 20 27 4 11 18 25 1 8 15 22 29 6 13 20 27 3 10 17 24 31 7 14 21 28 5 12 19 26 2 9 16 23 30 7 14 21 28
Appendix 6
Alegría 14 Taipei (22)
Quidam 7 Londres (15) Congé annuel *** Attention *** Projet de transfert en Amérique du Sud (en cours ne négociation) *** Attention ***
Dralion (11) 28 Perth (25) Melbourne (14) Congé annuel Auckland (23)
9 9
Varekai Madrid (18) 29 Séville (15) 26 Bilbao (3) Congé annuel 22 Hambourg (5) 16 Oostende (23) 4 Zurich (25) 5 Munich (20)
Gantt Chart for Touring Shows
yo
Corteo 4 Tokyo 1 (5) 21 Nagoya (12) 29 Osaka (18) 4 Tokyo 2
KOOZA Atlanta (1) 12 Baltimore (5) 16 New York (21) 3 Minneapolis (9) 20 Denver (4) 16 Los Angeles (20) Congé annuel
Cirque 2009 23 Montréal (19) 30 Québec (23) 3 Toronto (8) Congé annuel 27 San Francisco
Saltimbanco
Wintuk
rP
La Nouba Relâche les dimanches et les lundis
Mystère Relâche les jeudis et vendredis
«O» Relâche les lundis et les mardis
Zumanity Relâche les lundis et jeudis
os
KÀ Relâche les dimanches et les lundis
LOVE Relâche les mardis et mercredis
Légende: ( ) indique la date de la dernière représentation – – Transferts: AUS: Australie, CAN: Canada, EUR: Europe, JAP: Japon, MEX: Mexique, USA: Etats-Unis
Note: Pour le plan de tournée détaillé de DELIRIUM et Saltimbanco, vous référer au document électronique.
t
t
Gantt Chart for Touring Shows
os
rP
yo
op
tC
No
Do
© HEC Montréal 24
t
Appendix 7
os
Organizational Chart of the Company and of the Office of Vice-President,
Tour Planning and Partnerships
rP
yo
op
tC
No
Do
© HEC Montréal 25
t
os
Organizational Chart of the Company and of the Office of Vice-President,
Tour Planning and Partnerships
rP
yo
op
tC
No

Do
© HEC Montréal 26
Appendix 8
t
Excerpt of the Company’s Dashboard
os
rP
yo
op
tC

No
Do
© HEC Montréal 27
Appendix 9
t
Proposal Submitted by Turkey’s Ministry of Culture and Tourism
os
Full name: Ministry of Culture and Tourism of Turkey, in partnership with the
City of Istanbul
Contact: Attila Yolalane, Deputy Minister of Partnerships and Cultural
rP
Exchanges
Shows considered: Kooza
Proposed dates: Summer or fall 2010
Description of the site: First choice. We propose a site in the port, close to tourist
attractions.
yo
Financial arrangement: Site offered at a price to be negotiated, with municipal services
included. All other expenses are the responsibility of Cirque.
Summary of the proposal:
The Turkish Ministry of Culture and Tourism, in support of the government’s plan for the
integration of Turkey in the European Union, has invested enormous resources in preparing and
op
promoting Istanbul’s candidacy as Cultural Capital of Europe for 2010. The entire Istanbul
community threw its support behind this project and we can now declare our mission
accomplished. The national pride is palpable. The city is getting all spruced up and preparations
are under way for several events. The presentation of a Cirque du Soleil show this year could be
perceived by the international community as the city’s induction into the pantheon of major
entertainment capitals of the world. At least that is the wager that Turkey’s cultural authorities
tC
are making by proposing an association with Cirque. The show being proposed is Kooza. It is
suggested that the Minister saw this production during a trip to Chicago last summer and is very
eager to present it to his fellow Turks.
The proposal on the table is already quite interesting in that it assures that a choice site will be
made available to Cirque. It also offers to provide basic municipal services (roads, transport,
No
water and security) free of charge as well as a preferential rate for electricity. Judging from our
partnerships with other European cities, notably Spain, it is quite plausible that the rental cost of
the site could be completely absorbed by the city and the Ministry. Everything will depend on the
negotiations. We can thus estimate a potential 20% reduction in the fixed costs normally
associated with the installation of a show. This potential partner is not looking for a lucrative
partnership deal. For the most part, only incurred costs would be retained. All profits generated or
eventual losses would thus be borne by Cirque.
Do
However, the agreement is not binding on the government as a whole. It would appear that
bureaucratic red tape and poor communications between the different ministries and departments
are a major concern in this country. There is nothing to suggest that the arrival of Cirque would
be facilitated by other governmental authorities.
© HEC Montréal 28
The proponents of the proposal are inexperienced in event logistics and are not very familiar with
t
Cirque’s organizations. As such, if this proposal is developed, there will be a lot of ground to
os
cover.
rP
yo
op
tC
No
Do
© HEC Montréal 29
Appendix 10
t
TTE Proposal
os
Full name: Turkish Television and Entertainment Society
Contact: Reha Orbay, Vice-President, Entertainment and Major Events
rP
Shows considered: No fixed proposal
Proposed dates: Summer 2010 or later
Description of the site: No proposal put forth
Financial arrangement: Sharing of profits based on the “Rock & Roll” model, but to be
discussed
yo
Summary of the proposal:
The TTE is the largest media group in Turkey. Led by a professional team, this company owns a
leading daily newspaper as well as television and radio stations. It is also a major Internet and
multimedia content provider in the region. Over the past decade, the convergence of media
products has led the group to diversify into cultural production. Over the years, they have become
very active producers of rock concerts and international sports events in the Turkish market and
op
throughout the Caucasus and Eastern European region.
This promoter is not proposing any specific site for the show, but believes it will be able to
negotiate an attractive location at a good price. There is every reason to believe that it is possible
to negotiate advantageous terms for Cirque’s installation in a strategic location with the city of
Istanbul.
tC
The main advantage of TTE’s proposal is without a doubt its strategic positioning in the
communications field. Although the figures quoted by the promoter are much more modest, we
can expect to boost box office revenue by an additional 50% through sponsorships. However, this
amount could be substantially higher – perhaps as high as 80%.
No
Moreover, TTE has expertise in the Turkish market and in the region’s business community. This
represents a major advantage and could allow us to iron out potential problems long before they
arise. It is also a valuable source of knowledge of major local subcontractors.
TTE has already intimated that it is prepared to accept a “fixed show fee” arrangement instead of
a “Rock & Roll-”type partnership if Cirque prefers a less risky formula. They would also accept
any other type of business arrangement that would involve a fair sharing of costs, risks and
benefits. Considering business practices and the size of the Istanbul market, we believe we would
Do
be able to negotiate royalties of 10% and a sharing of residual revenue (after costs) based on 80%
for Cirque and 20% for the promoter.
It is obvious that the choice of the show is not a major concern for the promoter from an artistic
perspective. However, it is concerned about the show’s commercial potential and the draft
proposal received already anticipates a market of at least 100,000 tickets, regardless of the
© HEC Montréal 30
production, for the city of Istanbul alone. The Ankara market represents the potential for
t
50,000 tickets. It is worth mentioning that the figures advanced in preliminary proposals are
os
typically conservative because promoters are not keen to disclose all potential revenue sources at
the outset.
TTE is also proposing to act as a promoter for other destinations in the region. This possibility is
attractive, because TTE has interests in Russia as well as in several former Soviet Union
rP
countries, including Poland and Ukraine, where Cirque is not currently present. These are
potentially enormous markets that have not yet been developed. No hard figures or tangible
proposals have been made for these destinations, which are not directly concerned by this
proposal, but this information warrants consideration when analyzing the project.
It should be taken into account, however, that TTE will need to incur additional expenses
(equivalent to 10% of box office revenue) for the promotion of the production and the procedures
yo
necessary to find sponsors, compared to a project where no effort would be required to involve
business people.
In addition, the number of tickets sold could easily be 10% higher with an effective advertising
campaign led by a major group such as TTE, as opposed to an independently run project.
op
tC
No
Do
© HEC Montréal 31
Appendix 11
t
Standard Email Response to Proposals Received by Cirque
os
Dear……,
Your email has been forwarded to me for proper attention and I am delighted to follow up with
rP
you.
In order for us to understand your goal and help you reach it; we would need to get a bit more
information from you. We already have been contacted by a few of your fellow citizens from
(country) that have outlined in which capacity they would like to partner with us, but we have not
yet defined to what extent or how we would like to partner up for those specific markets.
yo
Therefore, we would like you to provide us with the following information:
- What time of year and what market depth would we be contemplating in relation to your
aim to present one of our productions in your area?
- Provide us with information on your company and experience in hosting such events.
- How many cities are we looking at?
- What would be the average number of performances per city?
op
- What would be the potential sponsorship revenue?
- How many tickets do you think you would be able to sell?
- What would be the average ticket price (regular, VIP)?
From there on, we will need to assess the potential gross revenue of all streams of business and
the entertainment industry.
tC
With this information, we will be able to address your request in our global planning. Please keep
in mind that our planning is usually done two years ahead of time.
Should you require more information about our shows, please note that you can also visit our
Web site: www.cirquedusoleil.com.
No
I truly want to thank you for the interest you have demonstrated towards Cirque du Soleil and we
look forward to hearing back from you at your earliest convenience.
Do
© HEC Montréal 32

Cirque - Du - Soleil - Tour - Planning

Uploaded by

Copyright:

Available Formats

Cirque - Du - Soleil - Tour - Planning

Uploaded by

Document Information

Original Title

Copyright

Available Formats

Share this document

Share or Embed Document

Sharing Options

Did you find this document useful?

Is this content inappropriate?

Copyright:

Available Formats

Cirque - Du - Soleil - Tour - Planning

Uploaded by

Copyright:

Available Formats

For the exclusive use of M.

profitability of the tour.

It is an understatement to say that international transfers are challenging. When changing

adventurous and to pounce on opportunities,” she adds.

Planning: Reconciling Rationalization and an Entrepreneurial Spirit

expression than just its artistic dimension.

Louise Murray has a well-integrated vision of Cirque productions:

The planning process and the actors involved

 Provide overall  Analysis of  Goals  Implementation

3-5 years 30-36 months 18-30 months 12-18 months

Figure 1: Tour plan development

sites or rental equipment, in others to negotiate supplies or custom-made equipment, costumes or

Business Partners: Precious Allies

in large cities makes it worth it.

However, Louise Murray is very clear on one point:

Table 1: Responsibilities of the different stakeholders in preparing contracts

interesting potential here!” she muses.

market eight months in advance.

“O” (Las Vegas, Nevada)

Macao 2008 (Macao, Chine)

Wintuk (New York, New York)

From November to January every year

Other Cirque du Soleil shows since 1984:

Visit the website at http://www.cirquedusoleil.com/world/fr/be/intro/intro.asp for a

 Revenue from merchandise sales: 2% of box office revenue

 Average attendance rate for shows: 85%

 Number of performances per week: 6 the first week,

 Average total cost of installation in a city

 Fixed costs and amortization of

 Cost of a typical international transfer:3 2 million

 Average expenditures per week per show: 1 million

 Additional sponsorship revenue:

 If Cirque acts alone: between 5% and 20% of

 If Cirque acts with a promoter: between 10% and 80% of

box office revenue

Source: Cirque du Soleil’s internal document

Day 1 Day 2 Day 3 Day 4

Machinery Inspection Machinery Inspection Machinery Inspection Machinery Inspection

Day 5 Day 6 Day 7 Day 8 Day 9

Day 1 Day 2 Day 3

Pack offices Rental equipment return

Source: Cirque du Soleil’ internal Document

Source: Cirque du Soleil’s internal document

Alegría 14 Taipei (22)

Source: Cirque du Soleil’s internal document

Source: Cirque du Soleil’s internal document

Source: Cirque du Soleil’s internal document

Summary of the proposal:

You might also like