Distal Tibia Paper 2
Distal Tibia Paper 2
Distal Tibia Paper 2
ISSN: 2395-1958
IJOS 2017; 3(4): 830-835
© 2017 IJOS Surgical management of distal tibia fracture by mippo
www.orthopaper.com
Received: 22-08-2017 using locking compression plate
Accepted: 23-09-2017
Dr. Vijay Chandar Dr. Vijay Chandar, Dr. Harish K, Dr. Chethan Kumar R and Dr. Vilas BN
Department of Orthopaedics,
Adichunchanagiri Institute of
Medical Sciences, B G Nagar, DOI: https://doi.org/10.22271/ortho.2017.v3.i4l.112
Mandya, Karnataka, India
Abstract
Dr. Harish K Introduction: The following study was conducted to examine the short term clinical and radiological
Assistant Professor results particularly early complications and healing rate of distal tibia fracture treated by MIPPO using
Department of Orthopaedics, LCP.
Adichunchanagiri Institute of Methodology: The study was conducted in patients treated for distal tibia fracture (type A, B & C – AO
Medical Sciences, B G Nagara, classification) at Adichunchanagiri Institute of Medical Science, BG Nagar from the month of Nov 2013
Karnataka, India
to Nov 2015. Twenty distal tibia fracture patients were taken into the study, all were fixed with LCP by
mippo, some with Bone grafting where the distal tibia fractures were associated with bone loss and
Dr. Chethan Kumar R
Department of Orthopaedics, communition. Patients’ age ranged from 27 to 68 years with a mean of 50.
Adichunchanagiri Institute of Results: The sample consisted of twenty patients with 11 males and 09 were female. The patients’ ages
Medical Sciences, B G Nagar, ranged from 27-68 years with a mean age of 50 years. The causes of fractures were motorvehicle
Mandya, Karnataka, India accident in 13 patients and fall in 07 patients. There were no sports or industrial accidents. 12 fractures
involved the right side and 08 involved the left. The average length of hospitalisation was 15 days with a
Dr. Vilas BN range of 10 to 20 days. The average number of days from injury to surgery was 5 days with a range of 2
Department of Orthopaedics, to 10 days. The operative time ranged from 45 minutes to 120 minutes. Patients were followed up from
Adichunchanagiri Institute of 01 to 24 months. Functional outcome was rated as per The modified ankle score of Olerud and Molander,
Medical Sciences, B G Nagar, we got excellent results in 10 cases, good in 07, fair in 02 and poor in one patient.
Mandya, Karnataka, India Conclusion: The LCP is a good implant to use for fractures of the distal tibia by mippo method.
However, accurate positioning and fixation are required to produce satisfactory results. We recommend
use of this implant in Type A, B and C, osteoporotic fractures. Our early results were encouraging but
long term studies are needed to prove definitively acceptable outcomes so that the technique can become
part of the armamentarium of the orthopaedic trauma surgeon.
Keywords: Distal tibia fracture, MIPPO, Distal tibia LCP, Pilon fracture
1. Introduction
Increased incidence of road traffic accidents, natural disasters, industrial accidents claim most
of human mortality and morbidity. Of these fractures distal tibia have historically been
difficult to treat.
Distal tibial fractures often presents a challenge to orthopaedic surgeon. Destot first used the
term in 1911, likening the pilon to a pestle. The tibial pilon comprises anatomically the distal
end of the tibia including the articular surface. Its proximal limit is found approximately 8-
10cm from the ankle articular surface, where the triangular section of the tibial diaphysis, with
its anterior crest, changes direction forming the metaphysis. The three-dimensional
configuration of this region appears to be designed to increase the area of the articular surface,
reducing the stress on the ankle joint.
Tibial pilon fracture represents 5-7% of all the tibial fractures [1]. These are usually the result
of high energy axial compression and rotation forces. They are usually associated with severe
soft tissue compromise. The limited soft tissue coverage, subcutaneous location, poor bone
Correspondence quality, osteoporosis renders the tibial fracture very challenging. The treatment of unstable
Dr. Harish K distal tibia or pilon fracture remains controversial. To achieve union many procedures are
Assistant professor recommended such as closed reduction and cast, open reduction and internal fixation,
Department of Orthopaedics,
Adichunchanagiri Institute of
intramedullary nailing, hybrid or ring external fixation.
Medical Sciences, B G Nagara,
Karnataka, India
~ 830 ~
International Journal of Orthopaedics Sciences
The difficulties that arises in the treatment of fracture distal in fracture reduction and towel clip or reduction clamp to hold
tibia are reduction. Varus -valgus angulation < 5° and anterior-
1. Tendency to re-displacement of fracture fragment posterior angulation < 10° and shortening of < 15 mm were
following subsidence of swelling specially in oblique, considered acceptable criteria for reduction. Precontoured low
spiral and comminuted fractures when treated by cast metaphyseal LCP was tunneled into subcutaneous plane and
2. Delayed union due to the precarious vascularity in distal its position was reconfirmed with C arm. Before fixing the
tibia plates with screws, shagging of distal fragment was prevented
3. Functional and cosmetic deformation if rotational or by putting towel roll under the fracture site. Provisional
alignment position of the fragment is not achieved, as it is nonlocking screw was applied to bring the plate on the bone.
important because knee and ankle joints are in same If necessary, interfragmentary compression was achieved by a
parallel axis screw through the plate or outside the plate. Compression
4. Bone loss osteosynthesis was achieved in simple fracture by using
nonlocking screw on proximal to fracture site as a hybrid
Non surgical treatment option is possible for fracture with fixation [51, 52]. With separate stab incision, at least three
minimal shortening, but requires prolonged immobilisation. It locking screws were applied on the either side of fracture
has also been associated with malunion, deformity, shortening under c arm guidance Primary bone graft was done whenever
of affected limb, limitation of range of motion and early necessary to promote union. Skin was closed with
osteoarthritis. Also prolonged recumbency resulted in high nonabsorbable sutures
incidence of thromboembolic disease and pneumonia.
Non-surgical approach with calcaneal traction remained the 3. Results
treatment of choice prior to case series reported by Reudi and The sample consisted of twenty patients with 11 males and 09
Allgower in 1969 with 84 fractures treated with standard open were female. The patients’ ages ranged from 27-68 years with
protocol with 74% of patients reported good to excellent a mean age of 50 years. The causes of fractures were
function. motorvehicle accident in 13 patients and fall in 07 patients.
External fixation can be a useful option in open fractures with There were no sports or industrial accidents. 12 fractures
soft tissue injury, but can lead to pin-track infections, septic involved the right side and 08 involved the left. The average
arthritis, mal-alignment and delayed union. Soft-tissue length of hospitalisation was 15 days with a range of 10 to 20
management has been seen to play a vital role in the days. The average number of days from injury to surgery was
management alongside the bony reconstruction. 5 days with a range of 2 to 10 days. The operative time ranged
Conventional plating techniques if applied to from 45 minutes to 120 minutes. Patients were followed up
multifragmentary fractures, requires anatomic reduction, wide from 01 to 24 months. 6 were closed and 14 were open
surgical exposure and the fractured fragments are stripped off fractures Successful fracture union was defined as complete
the soft tissue attachments resulting in a variety of bridging callus in three cortices, together with painless full
complications like delayed union or non-union, infections, weight bearing Functional outcome was rated as per The
implant failure skin necrosis and wound dehiscence. modified ankle score of Olerud and Molander, we got
Biological plate fixation technique are based upon the excellent results in 10 cases, good in 07, fair in 02 and poor in
principles of limited soft tissue stripping, maintenance of one patient.
osteogenic fracture hematoma and preservation of vascular
supply to the individual fracture fragment while restoring 3.1 Observation and results
axial and rotational alighnment and providing sufficient
stability to allow progression of motion, uncomplicated Table 1: Distribution of sample by age
fracture healing and eventual return to function. As such, the Age (Years) Frequency Percentage (%)
evolution of biological plating technique has led to 18-30 1 5
development of low profile, precontoured implants 31-40 3 15
specifically intended for application in the distal tibia 41-50 7 35
51-60 4 20
2. Materials and methods 61-70 5 25
The study was conducted in patients treated for distal tibia TOTAL 20 100
fracture (type A, B & C – AO classification) at
Adichunchanagiri Institute of Medical Science, BG Nagar Table 2: Distribution of sample by sex
from the month of Nov 2013 to June 2016. twenty distal tibia
Sex Frequency Percentage
fracture patients were taken into the study, all were fixed with Male 11 55
LCP by MIPPO Patients’ age ranged from 27 to 68 years with Female 9 45
a mean of 50 with the duration of follow up ranged from 6
months to 24 months Surgical Technique: Patient in supine Table 3: Distribution of sample by side
position. Initial fibula fixation was routinely done with one
third tubular plate. It restores limb length and helps in the Side Frequency Percentage (%)
reduction of the tibial plafond in the correct position [50] A Right 12 60
Left 08 40
vertical or curvilinear incision was made at the level of medial
malleolus with the utmost care not to injure great sephanous Table 4: Distribution of sample by mechanism of injury
vein and sephanous nerve. Sub cutaneous plane was made
with hemostat without striping periosteum and disturbance to Mechanism of Injury No. of Case Percentage (%)
fracture haematoma. Fracture was reduced under C arm Road traffic accident 13 65
control. where reduction was difficult, we made a small Fall from height 07 35
incision and used a Kirschner wire (3mm) as a joystick to aid Total 20 100
~ 831 ~
International Journal of Orthopaedics Sciences
spectrum antibiotic cover as prevention of infection is the external fixation. Other complication we found was delayed
main aim. If there is significant soft tissue loss after union which of due to primary bone grafting was not done
debridement, adequate soft tissue cover is difficult in this area and due to infection. Primary bone grafting was done in 3
hence skin graft and free flap are viable treatment options [54]. patient where there was communition of fracture fragments
Reports in the literature on ORIF of distal tibia or pilon and bone loss. All patients were returned to work in 6 months.
fractures are plagued by wound infection [55-58]. During high 80 % patients felt pre injury status in 6 months.
velocity trauma the initial injury causes massive soft tissue
damage which devitalizes the tissue around the fracture site, 5. Conclusion
in distal tibia the anterio medial aspect is most risk for wound Locking compression plate by mippo technique is an optimal
infection and wound dehiscense [59]. tool for distal end tibia fracture. It provides rigid fixation in
Open reduction and internal fixation has shown increased the region of distal tibia, where a widening canal, thin cortices
rates of deep infection and wound dehiscence are the major and frequently poor bone stock make fixation difficult.
soft tissue complications. Wound debridement, antibiotics, Surgical exposure for plate placement requires significantly
skin grafting, myocutaneous flap and even arthrodesis have a less periosteal stripping and soft tissue exposure than that of
role to play in management [54]. Studies using external fixation normal plates. Orthopaedic surgeons experience with locking
techniques reported significant reduction in infection rates [53, compression plating technique will find it a useful technique.
60, 61]
. The rate of infection is drastically decreased with the However careful understanding of its basic principles,
use of minimmaly invasive percutaneous plate osteosynthesis identification of appropriate fracture patterns for use of LCP
(MIPPO) in comparison with external fixator and ORIF [53, 62]. is essential to avoid complications like generation of non-
This is reflected in our results, with only two cases of union. To conclude, LOCKING COMPRESSION PLATE BY
superficial wound infection, which completely resolved with MIPPO is an important armamentarium in treatment of
appropriate antibiotics. Reports suggest that intramedullary fractures of distal tibia, especially when fracture is severely
nailing has the lowest infection rates compared with other comminuted and in situations of osteoporosis.
techniques [63] but the technique is associated with other
complications such as malunion, fat embolus syndrome, 6. References
compartment syndrome and anterior knee pain [63]. Angular 1. Topliss CJ, Jackson M, Atkins RM. Anatomy of pilon
malalignment and malunion have been reported with fractures of the distal tibia. J Bone Joint Surg Br. 2005;
intramedullary nailing of these fractures [63]. The studies on 87:692-697.
external fixator showed complications such as imperfect 2. Moore KL. Clinically Oriented Anatomy. 2nd ed.
reduction loosening, malunion and pin tract infections [60, 61]. Baltimore: Williams & Wilkins, 1985
Open reduction with fixation of plates have reduced rates 3. Mehmet At›f Erol The results of minimally invasive
angular malunion when compared to external fixation [61] or percutaneous plate osteosynthesis (MIPPO) in distal and
intramedullary nailing but disadvantages of high incidences of diaphyseal tibial fractures Acta Orthop Traumatol Turc.
infection. AO distal tibial locking plate using MIPPO 2012; 46(3):161-167 doi:10.3944/AOTT.2012.2597
technique provides a stable and rigid fixation of the fractures 4. Guo JJ, Tang N, Yang HL, Tang TS. A randomised pilot
minimizes the angulation and malunion without wound trial of "locking plate" fixation versus intramedullary
complications as in ORIF. The distal tibia plate is pre- nailing for extra-articular fractures of the distal tibia
contoured to the anatomy of the distal tibia and thus allows Bone Joint J May. 2012; 94-B:704-708.
placement of the plate without distruption of fracture 5. Ghulam Shabbir, Shujaat Hussain, Zulfiqar Ahmad Nasir,
fragments. The distal end of the plate allows placement of Kamran Shafi, Javeid Ahmed Khan Minimal Invasive
locking screws that provide stability where satisfactory bone Plate Osteosynthesis Of Close Fractures Of Distal Tibia J
purchase is difficult. The threaded holes lock to the locking Ayub Med Coll Abbottabad. 2011; 23(2).
screw head and minimise plate-bone interface and maintain 6. Syah Bahari, Brian Lenehan, Hamad Khan, John P.
the vascularity of the fracture site. The proximal combination MCELWAIN Minimally invasive percutaneous plate
holes allow insertion of locking or cortical screws where fixation of distal tibia fractures Acta Orthop. Belg. 2007;
relative or absolute stability can be achieved. Acceptable 73:635-640
tibial aligment was 5° of varus or valgus and 10° of 7. Jens Francois, Geoffroy Vandeputte, Frank Verheyden,
recurvatum or procurvatum. All of our patients were found to Guy Nelen Percutaneous plate fixation of fractures of the
have acceptable reduction and alignment post operatively and distal tibia Acta Orthop. Belg., 2004; 70:148-154.
at union. Fracture healing is defined as mature callus 8. Oliver Borens.Peter Rloen. Jeffrey Richmond. Goetz
formation seen on plain radiograph with pain free full weight Roederer. David s Levine. Minimal invasive Treatment
bearing. Average fracture healing time was 18.8 weeks post of tibial plafond fracture with a low profile plating:
operatively. Assosciated fibula fractures are fixed with one preliminary results of 17 cases.
third semitubular plate As it is a rigid fixation, postoperative 9. Mario Ronga, Umile Giuseppe Longo and Nicola
plaster immobilization was not necessary as ankle stiffness Maffulli. Minimally Invasive Locked Plating of Distal
was not a problem, ankle stiffness was only seen in only 3 Tibia Fractures is Safe and Effective. Clinical
patients reason due to communited fracture, prolong Orthopaedics and related Research. 2010; 468(4):975-
immobilization and delayed weight bearing. 982.
Weight bearing was delayed till radiological callaus was 10. Abid Mustaq, Rizwan Shahid, Muhammad Asif,
visible on post operative check x ray on average weight Mohammed Masqood. Distal Tibia Fracture Fixation
bearing was started on 12th week post operatively and partial With LCP using MIPO: European Journal of Trauma and
weight bearing was started on a average of 6th weeks. Our Emergency
results are comparable to other studies using the MIPPO 11. Blauth M. Bastian L. Krettek C, Knop C, Evans S.
technique [52, 64]. Comparing the results with other methods of Surgical options for the treatment of severe tibial
fixation, our results are better in comparison with ORIF and pilonfractures. A study of three techniques. J Orthop
~ 833 ~
International Journal of Orthopaedics Sciences
~ 835 ~