Unit-IV - Legal Aspects01
Unit-IV - Legal Aspects01
Unit-IV - Legal Aspects01
36 Material and Relevant Code of ISI specification and of approved type. Permission
Workmanship for using equivalent quality of materials, inspection and testing of
materials and removal of defective ones. Project Architect decision is
final
40 Extension of Under 10 grounds – contractor can request for extension of time
time to be 1. Force Majeure
given for 2. Exceptionally Inclement Weather
completion of 3. Civil Commotion, strikes etc
work 4. Delay on the part of Nominated sub-contractor or Nominated
Supplier
5. Delay on account of artists and tradesmen engaged by the owner
6. Loss and damage due to fire
7. Inadequate instructions from the Project Architect
8. Instruction to carry out extra work
9. Opening up of any work not due to the fault of the contractor
10. The contractor inability to procure certain labour or goods which
he could not have foreseen at the time of signing the contract.
EASEMENT
➢ Easement is the right of a land owner to enjoy limited use of land of
another land owner
➢ DOMINANT HERITAGE & OWNER – The land for the beneficial
enjoyment of which the right of easement exists is called “Dominant
Heritage” and the owner or occupier of that land as “Dominant
owner”
➢ SERVIENT HERITAGE AND OWNER - The land on which the liability is
imposed is called “Servient heritage” and the owner or occupier of
that land as “Servient Owner”
INDIAN EASEMENT ACT 1882
➢ THE INDIAN EASEMENT ACT 1882
➢ 6 Chapter
1. Easement is defined with illustrations
2. Imposition, acquisition and transfer of Easement
3. The incident of Easement
4. The disturbances of Easement
5. Extinction, Suspension and revival of easement
6. Grant of licenses
TYPES OF
EASEMENT
Right of way Right to enjoy light Right to get water Right for drain or
through neighbours and air from the from neighbours sewer pipe through
land adjoining land well adjoining land
EASEMENT RIGHTS
➢ The word land in such cases includes things which are permanently
attached to the land such as buildings, trees, compound walls and
other features.
➢ The word “beneficial enjoyment” includes advantages and amenities
such as water supply, drainage lines, electric cables etc.
➢ Some of the common types of easement are right of way through
neighbours land, right to enjoy light and air from the adjoining land,
right to get water from neighbours well, right drain and sewer pipe,
right to graze cattle etc.
EASEMENT
RIGHTS
BY BY EXPRESS BY IMPLIED
BY CUSTOM
PRESCRIPTION GRANT GRANT
EASEMENT RIGHTS
1. EASEMENT BY PRESCRIPTION – When an owner allows people to
pass through his land without any objection or obstruction for a
continuous period of 20 years or allows the neighbour to enjoy
light and air from his property the easement that is created is
known as easement of Prescription
2. EASEMENT BY EXPRESS GRANT – When an owner permits people to
pass through his with full knowledge and consent or creates some
kind of right through a written agreement it is know as express
grant or convenant
3. EASEMENT BY IMPLIED GRANT – When a owner does some kind of
act which implies creation of certain right over his property it is
know as implied grant. (Sell a blocked land with access facility)
4. EASEMENT BY CUSTOM – When people enjoy certain rights to
make use of a piece of land for a social activity, year after year, as a
custom, it is said to be an easement of custom
EASEMENT
• Easement are either continuous, discontinuous, apparent or non
apparent.
• CONTINUOUS EASEMENT – A continuous easement is one whose
enjoyment is, or may be, continual without the act of man. (Right -
light and Air)
• DISCONTINUOUS EASEMENT – A discontinuous easement is on that
needs the act of man for its enjoyment (Right of way- passing thro
land)
• APPARENT EASEMENT – A apparent easement is one the existence
of which is shown by some permanent sign which upon careful
inspection by a competent person would be visible to him
• NON-APPARENT EASEMENT - A non-apparent easement is on that
has no such sign.
EASEMENT RIGHT
• EASEMENT IN A JOINT PROPERTY – If a land belongs to two or more
owners all have the same rights and privilege of ownership and
enjoyment of the property, hence no single owner can claim an
exclusive easement
• RIGHT TO OVERHANG BRANCHES OF TREES – The right of one
owner to allow his trees to spread branches over the neighbour’s
land is not an inherent right; nor can it be an easement. The
neighbour can trim the branches if he/she want to.
• PROJECTION OF EAVES (PANKH) – If the age of roof of one owner
projects over the land of another for a continuous period of 20
years it amounts to prescriptive easement. The servient owner
cannot compel the dominant owner to remove the projected
portion. He is required to allow him the right without any
obstruction. However such an easement does not give the
dominant owner any other right or title over the servient heritage
EASEMENT – RIGHTS OF PATH
• The right to pass through some one else’s property is acquired either by through
prescription or expressed grant.
EASEMENT BY PRESCRIPTION EASEMENT BY EXPRESS GRANT
When a person uses a portion of land without An Easement of right of way can be
the knowledge and consent of its owner such extinguished if both the owners agree to do
as pedestrian path way or for plying any so in writing. If mutually agreed the size
vehicle for a continuous period of 20 years position of the affected strip of land can be
without even once being prevent from doing altered, so as to allow the servient owner to
so, then the person acquires an easement of develop his remaining portion of land in his
right of way by prescription desired manner.
At times the servient owner is required to pay
financial compensation or make some other
kind of arrangement to extinguish the
easement.
It is rare cases, it will be for limited period. It
is given in perpetuity
EASEMENT – RIGHTS OF PATH
EASEMENT BY EXPRESS GRANT EASEMENT BY IMPLIED GRANT
Right of way through a neighbour’s land can
be acquired through an implied grant
For example, when a person sells a portion of
his land which does not have a direct access
of its own, it is implied that he would permit
the purchaser to pass through his remaining
portion of land. Normally such a right is given
in the conveyance deed itself
However even if it is not expressly written in
the conveyance deed, it is implied, as no
person can sell a portion of land without
giving access to it
PREVENTION OF EASEMENT RIGHTS PATH
• If owner A finds that owner B or other members of public are
passing through his land; he/she must erect a fence around his land
to prevent people from using his land as a thoroughfare.
• In many cases apart from a fence, a sign is fixed at prominent place
to warn people that they may be prosecuted for trepassing
• If despite a fence and warning sign, people persist in passing
through his land, he must lodge a police complaint against the
trespassers and get them arrested
• As an alternative he must provide security staff who will prevent
trepassing
• If the owner A has maintained the record of police complaint and
photographs fence etc, A CLAIM OF EASEMENT CANNOT SUCCEED
EASEMENT OF LIGHT AND AIR
EASEMENT BY PRESCRIPTION
EASEMENT OF LIGHT AND AIR
PREVENTION OF EASEMENT OF LIGHT AND AIR
EASEMENT OF WATER SUPPLY
PREVENTION OF EASEMENT OF SERVICES
SERVIENT
OWNER (B)
PROTECTION OF EASEMENT OF SUPPORT
EXTINCTION OF EASEMENT
EXTINGUISHING EASEMENT
EXTINGUISHING EASEMENT
ADVERSE POSSESSION
PREVENTION OF EASEMENT
LICENCE
LICENCE
➢ Licence is a written permission given by the owner of a land to
another person or persons for doing particular act on his land or
property for a limited period.
➢ Such acts can be gathering of fruit, fishing in lake or well using it as
an open stacking place or some such act
➢ Such licence can be terminated by either party on giving a written
notice even before the expiry of period of licence by making such a
provision in the agreement
➢ A licence is normally given on payment a licence cannot become a
tenant
LEASE
LEASE
➢ Lease of land is quite distinct from an easement or a licence.
➢ Lease – a contract by which one party lets the land or the buildings or the services
to another for a specified time in return for a payment
➢ Lessee – a person who holds the lease of a property, a person receiving the lease
rights
➢ Lessor - a person who leases or lets out a property to other person. A person giving
the lease rights.
➢ In the case of a lease, the owner of the land the LESSOR gives it to a LESSE for a
period of 10, 20 or 99 years on payment of ground rent
➢ A legal lease deed is entered into between the lessor and the lessee, stipulating
various conditions of lease
➢ Depending upon the period of lease, the lesse can build either a temporary or
pucca building on the leased land
➢ A lessee pays a certain amount as ground rent to the lessor during the lease
period, A lessor is required to disclose existence of any easement at the time of
giving lease.
THE CONSUMER PROTECTION ACT 1986
➢ This act protects the interest of consumers and for the purpose it
makes provision to establish consumer councils/forums
➢ The act was applicable to whole of India except Jammu and Kashmir
with effect from 15-4-1987.
➢ The Act was amended and enforced with effect from 18th June 1993.
➢ In the act, the “Consumer” is defined as a person who either buys
any goods or hires any services for a consideration which has been
paid or promised to be paid under any system.
➢ With this definition the persons who receive or likely to receive
plots or houses from any agency are consumers.
➢ The act defines that term “Consumer dispute” that means a dispute
where the person against whom a complaint has been made,
denies/disputes the allegations contained in the complaint.
➢ The central and state consumer protection councils are established
under this act to promote and protect the rights of the consumers.
THE CONSUMER PROTECTION ACT 1986
➢ The council shall meet as and when necessary but at least once in
every year to carry out their objectives.
➢ Provision also exists in the at to establish “Consumer Disputes
Redressed Agencies/District Forums” in each district and “State
Commission” in the state by state governments and also a “National
Commission dispute Redressed Commission at National level”
➢ Any person aggrieved by the order of District forum, may appeal to
the state commission against such order within a period of 30 days
from the date of the order.
➢ He can further approach to the National Commission against the
order made by the state commission.
➢ He may also appeal to the Supreme Court for consideration of
justice
Supreme Court for
District Forum State Commission National Commission
Justice
THE CONSUMER PROTECTION ACT 1986
➢ Every order made by District Forum, State Commission or National
Commission shall be enforced in the same manner as if it were
decree or order made by court.
➢ If person concerned fails to comply the order made by either District
Forum or state commission or the National Commission the person
shall be punishable with imprisonment for a term which shall not be
less than one month and extended up to three years and or a fine
up to Rs. 10000/-
PUNISHMENT – LESS THAN ONE MONTH – MAXI 3 MONTHS & FINE UPTO – Rs10,000/-
THE CONSUMER PROTECTION ACT 1986
➢ The Architects - legal action -buildings or any other built form
collapses -without inquiring their faults and circumstances leading to
the collapse.
➢ Architects have brought disrepute, embarrassment and mental agony
when they are unconnected with reasons responsible for the collapse of
building.
➢ Professional liability of architects for the buildings - designed,
construction and completion is supervised by them and thereafter,
remain under the control and management of owners/ occupants, and
not under the superintendence of an architect who was originally
engaged for the design and supervision of construction. In reality, the
longevity and stability of the building are dependent upon the
observance of safety and maintenance norms.
THE CONSUMER PROTECTION ACT 1986
➢ SERVICE : "Service", as defined under Section 2 (1) (o) of the Consumer
Protection Act, 1986, means service of any description which is made
available to potential users and includes the provision of facilities in
connection with banking, financing insurance, transport, processing,
supply of electrical or other energy, board or lodging or both, housing
construction, entertainment, amusement or the purveying of news or
other information, but does not include the rendering of any service
free of charge or under a contract of personal service. In other words,
rendering professional service by an architect for "consideration" falls
within the ambit of "service". The relationship between the Client and
the Architect is that of recipient and provider of service. The
professional services rendered by the architect mean the services
rendered pursuant to the Conditions of Engagement and Scale of
Charges, entered into between the Client and the Architect.
➢ DUTY OF CARE : Architect – a reasonable degree of knowledge and skill
and must exercise a reasonable degree of care
THE CONSUMER PROTECTION ACT 1986
➢ Duties: The duties that are required to be performed by an
architect for various types of projects have been prescribed by the
Council of Architecture under the Conditions of Engagement and
Scale of Charges for respective areas in the field of architecture.
The documents stipulate the parameters within which the
Architect is required to function. However, the Conditions of
Engagement and matters related therewith for a given project shall
be carried out in accordance with the terms and Conditions of
Agreement executed between the Client and the Architect.
PRECAUTIONS TO CONTROL LIABILITY
1. He/ She should not sign any letter or document which he has not understood clearly. He/
She should take his time, consult a senior Architect or a lawyer to understand its
implication
2. He/She should never promise anything which he/she cannot deliver in time or within its
financial limit.
3. He should inform his client about any change made in the design or work schedule any
statutory order affecting the progress of the work explaining its implication as quickly as
possible
4. He/She should report to civic authorities any violation of rules and regulations affecting
the project under his control, especially safety of building whether it is done by the
contractor or the client himself.
5. He/ She should make sure that the wording of any certificate or a letter he issues fairly
and impartially reflect the limits of his authority
6. He/She must obtain a letter of appointment as recommended by Council of Architecture
so that the scope of his/her services and limits of his/her liability are clearly defined
One must remember that unless one has taken proper precautions against known pitfalls
somebody else cannot bail out a victim completely.
OUT OF SYLLABUS
THE COPYRIGHT ACT 1957
➢ Copyright is the exclusive right granted by law for a certain number of
years to make and dispose of a literary, musical or artistic work.
➢ Architectural copyright means the right to use Architectural drawings,
sketches etc for building or for publication for profit
➢ The Copyright Act 1957 – governs all matters connected with
copyright
SECTION PARTICULARS
DEFINITIONS
➢ Artistic work means an Architectural work of art
➢ Architectural work of art means any building or structure having an artistic
character or design or any model of such building
2 ➢ Author means the Architect who has designed as building or prepared
drawing
➢ Exclusive License means a license or authority which is conferred on the
license exclusively. It means in other words that if the license is the client or
any person authorized by him will have the exclusive right comprised int the
copyright to the exclusion of all other persons including the Architect
THE COPYRIGHT ACT 1957
SECTION PARTICULARS
➢ Provides that no person unless he/she is authorized in writing by the owner
of copyright can publish any architectural drawings, photographs or models of
any building designed by the Architect
3 ➢ Drawings and Photographs printed and published as a part of architectural
criticism are excluded
➢ Copyright shall subsist in any architectural work of art location in India.
➢ The copyright shall subsist only in the artistic character of the design of a
building
13 ➢ If the process or method of design is sought to be protected, the author will
have to obtain a patent under the PATENT ACT
14 ➢ The meaning of copyright is the exclusive right to reproduce the work in any
material form or to publish the work for profit or gain
➢ It defines the “FIRST OWNER OF COPYRIGHT”. It says that in case the author
of the design is employed or is working as an apprentice his employer shall be
17 the first owner of the copyright
THE COPYRIGHT ACT 1957
SECTION PARTICULARS
➢ The owner of copyright can assign his copyright in writing in an existing work
or future work to any person either wholly, partially, conditionally or
unconditionally
18 ➢ The owner of copyright can make condition that certain payments will be
made to him or that the copyright will be assigned only for a limited period
➢ It can even be restricted to printing it in the form of an article or album
➢ When the copyright is assigned in writing to a person, who is not its author,
he is regarded as the owner of copyright.
➢ This provision applies to the legal representative or successor of such an
assignee after his death.
19 ➢ The assignment of copyright must be made in writing
22 ➢ The period of copyright is restricted to 60 years from the death of its author
➢ There should be a specific provision in the letter of Appointment given by the client that
the copyright in the design will vest in the Architect. Alternatively it should stipulate that
the appointment is as per the conditions of engagement as prescribed by the council of
architecture
COPYRIGHT – ARCHITECTURE PROFESSION
➢ Every drawing should bear the sign with the name of the architect and the date of
preparation of drawings preferably in the right hand top corner of the drawing or
somewhere in the notes written on the drawing
➢ A record of all the drawing issued to contractor should be kept by the Architect. All
these drawings whether intact or mutilated must be returned by the contractor
before the “FINAL CERTIFICATE OF PAYMENT” is issued to him. Two sets of working
drawings are issued to the contractor, one to be kept at the site and the other
which he kept in his/her office for planning execution schedule. Usually the set
kept in the office is not mutilated or disfigured.
➢ Architectural copyright means the right to use drawings, sketches, models etc
prepared by the Architect for building buildings or for publication for profit. This
right belongs to every Architect who produces an original design whether it is for a
client or for an Architectural competition.
➢ The client has a right to keep the drawings for carrying out repairs additions etc,
but he cannot use them for building another building or for any other purpose
without the Architect’s permission
REFERENCE
1. Prof. S. C. Garg and Dr. Yogesh K.Garg, Professional Practice of Architecture, Satya Prakashan, New
Delhi, 2020-2021
2. Ar. V. S. Apte, Architectural practice and procedure, Maharashtra Mudranshala Chhapkhana(offset
Division), Pune, 2008
3. Prof Madhav deobhakta, Architectural practice in India, Super book house, Mumbai, 1997
4. Dr. Roshan H. Namavati, Professional Practice (with elements of estimating, valuation, contract and
arbitration), Lakhani book depot, Mumbai, 2013
5. M. Chakraborti, Estimating Costing Specification and Valuation in Civil Engineering (includes computer
estimation), Monojit Chakraborti published, Kolkata, 2013
6. S. C. Rangwala, Estimating Costing and Valuation (Professional Practice and Quantity Surveying),
Charotar publishing house pvt ltd, Gujarat, 2013.
7. Raj Kumar Oberoi, Handbook of Professional Documents 2020 Council of Architecture, Mittal
Enterprises, Delhi, 2020
• https://www.proeducate.com/courses/FLRE/Section9-7.pdf
• https://www.allbusiness.com/barrons_dictionary/dictionary-dominant-tenement-4963822-
1.html
• https://www.slideserve.com/anika/easement-powerpoint-ppt-presentation