Scribd Logo
Upload

Welcome to Scribd!

  • 538 views

    People Vs Mangulabnan Digest

    Uploaded by

    Russell John Hipolito
    A group of armed men broke into the home of Vicente Pacson and his family in the middle of the night. One of the intruders, Agustin Mangulabnan, was recognized by Cipriana Tadeo. Mangulabnan and the two other unidentified men stole cash and jewelry from the family. When one of the children cried out, one of the intruders attempted to strike the child but was stopped by Monica del Mundo. Before leaving, one of the intruders fired his gun at the ceiling. After they left, Cipriana discovered that her husband Vicente was lying dead face down in the ceiling where he had been hiding. Mangulabnan was

    Copyright:

    © All Rights Reserved
    Download as DOCX, PDF, TXT or read online from Scribd

    People Vs Mangulabnan Digest

    Uploaded by

    Russell John Hipolito
    538 views1 page
    A group of armed men broke into the home of Vicente Pacson and his family in the middle of the night. One of the intruders, Agustin Mangulabnan, was recognized by Cipriana Tadeo. Mangulabnan and the two other unidentified men stole cash and jewelry from the family. When one of the children cried out, one of the intruders attempted to strike the child but was stopped by Monica del Mundo. Before leaving, one of the intruders fired his gun at the ceiling. After they left, Cipriana discovered that her husband Vicente was lying dead face down in the ceiling where he had been hiding. Mangulabnan was

    Original Title

    People vs Mangulabnan Digest

    Copyright

    © © All Rights Reserved

    Available Formats

    DOCX, PDF, TXT or read online from Scribd

    Did you find this document useful?

    Is this content inappropriate?

    A group of armed men broke into the home of Vicente Pacson and his family in the middle of the night. One of the intruders, Agustin Mangulabnan, was recognized by Cipriana Tadeo. Mangulabnan and the two other unidentified men stole cash and jewelry from the family. When one of the children cried out, one of the intruders attempted to strike the child but was stopped by Monica del Mundo. Before leaving, one of the intruders fired his gun at the ceiling. After they left, Cipriana discovered that her husband Vicente was lying dead face down in the ceiling where he had been hiding. Mangulabnan was

    Copyright:

    © All Rights Reserved
    Download as DOCX, PDF, TXT or read online from Scribd
    Download as docx, pdf, or txt
    538 views1 page

    People Vs Mangulabnan Digest

    Uploaded by

    Russell John Hipolito
    A group of armed men broke into the home of Vicente Pacson and his family in the middle of the night. One of the intruders, Agustin Mangulabnan, was recognized by Cipriana Tadeo. Mangulabnan and the two other unidentified men stole cash and jewelry from the family. When one of the children cried out, one of the intruders attempted to strike the child but was stopped by Monica del Mundo. Before leaving, one of the intruders fired his gun at the ceiling. After they left, Cipriana discovered that her husband Vicente was lying dead face down in the ceiling where he had been hiding. Mangulabnan was

    Copyright:

    © All Rights Reserved
    Download as DOCX, PDF, TXT or read online from Scribd
    Download as docx, pdf, or txt
    of 1

    People vs Mangulabnan

    G. R. No. L-8919. September 28, 1956


    Felix, J

    FACTS:

    At about 11:00 o’clock in the evening of November 5, 1953, the reports of gunfire awaked the
    spouses Vicente Pacson and Cipriana Tadeo, the 4 minor children and Cipriana’s mother, Monica del
    Mundo, in their house at barrio Tikiw, San Antonio, Nueva Ecija. Whereupon, Vicente Pacson crossed
    the room and shouted to one Tata Pisio that persons were going up their house and then hid himself
    inside the ceiling.

    In the meantime, someone broke the wall of the kitchen at the back of the house, and a few moments
    later a person suddenly entered the dining room and shouted that the door leading to the living room
    be opened. As no one of the house members obeyed, the intruder removed 3 board pieces in the wall
    and through the opening thus made he entered the living room. The intruder who was armed with a
    hunting knife was recognized by Cipriana Tadeo to be Agustin Mangulabnan, who was previously
    known to her. Agustin removed the iron bar from the door leading to the balcony and after opening
    said door, 2 persons whose identity has not been ascertained entered. Agustin then approached
    Cipriana Tadeo and snatched from her neck one necklace valued P50 and also took from her person
    P50 in the paper bills and P20 in silver coins. Meanwhile, one of the two unidentified marauders
    searched the person of Monica del Mundo and took from her P200 in cash and in gold necklace
    valued at P200. But not contented with the loot, the same individual asked from Monica del Mundo
    to give her diamond ring which the latter could not produce, and for this reason, he strucked her
    twice on the face with the butt of his gun. One of the small children of Vicente Pacson who was
    terrified called to his mother and that unidentified person, irked by the boys impudence, made a
    move to strike him, but Monica del Mundo warded off the blow with her right arm. At this juncture,
    the second unidentified individual put his companion aside the climbing on the table, fired his gun at
    the ceiling. Afterwards, Appellant and his two unidentified companion left the place.

    After they were gone, Cipriana Tadeo called to her husband Vicente Pacson, and receiving no answer
    she climbed the ceiling and she found him lying face downward already dead

    ISSUE:

    WON the homicide be included in the robbery?

    RULING:

    DOCTRINE:

    The crime committed in the case at bar, of which Appellant Agustin Mangulabnan is a co-participant,
    is the crime of robbery with homicide covered by Article 294, No. 1, of the Revised Penal Code and
    punished with reclusion perpetua to death. The commission of the offense was attended by the
    aggravating circumstances of nighttime, dwelling, abuse of superior strength and with the aid of
    armed men, and in consonance with the provisions of Article 63, No. 1 of the same legal body,
    Appellant should be sentenced to the capital punishment, as recommended by the Solicitor General.
    However, as the required number of votes for the imposition of the capital penalty has not been
    secured in this case, the penalty to be imposed upon Agustin Mangulabnan is the next lower in
    degree or reclusion perpetua (Section 9, Republic Act No. 296, known as the Judiciary Act of 1948).

    Wherefore the decision appealed from being in accordance with law and the evidence, is hereby
    affirmed with costs against Appellant. It is SO ORDERED.

    You might also like