The National HIV and AIDS Stigma and Discrimination Index • Summary Report i

Ministry of Health

N A L H IV A N D A ID S
THE NATIO
R IM IN AT IO N IN D E X
STIGMA AND DISC MARY REPO
SUM
RT

www.nacc.or.ke
 Ministry of Health

AT IO N A L H IV A N D A ID S
THE N
IS C R IM IN AT IO N IN D E X
STIGMA AND D SUMMARY R
EPORT

www.nacc.or.ke
His Excellency President Uhuru Kenyatta with Elijah and Michel Sidibé, Executive Director UNAIDS during the
official launch of Kenya’s Fast-track Plan to End Adolescent Aids and HIV situation Room © UNAIDS

Whereas, we had reached over 80% of adults in need of Anti-Retroviral

Therapy, we had only reached less than half of our young people. I made it
very clear in February that this was not acceptable anywhere in Africa. Shared
prosperity will only be achieved, when we have shared responsibility. I am
committed to the future of our young people and I will lead by example.
President Uhuru Kenyatta
CONTENTS

Foreword............................................................................................................................................................ vi
key terms..............................................................................................................................................................x
Executive summary.......................................................................................................................................... 1
Introduction....................................................................................................................................................... 6
Study methodology.......................................................................................................................................... 8
Computation of HIV stigma and discrimination index and summary of findings.............................. 9
HIV stigma and key populations ................................................................................................................17
Impact of HIV stigma and discrimination.................................................................................................18
Appendix..........................................................................................................................................................22
vi The National HIV and AIDS Stigma and Discrimination Index • Summary Report

FOREWORD

Three decades since the first AIDS case was reported in Kenya, there has
been tremendous progress made in the scale up of prevention and treatment
interventions. The number of new HIV infections however remains high with
close to 101,560 new infections reported annually making Kenya the third
largest HIV epidemic in Sub-Saharan Africa with an estimated 1.6 million
People Living with HIV. Evidence has also shown that lack of knowledge of
correct HIV status is the leading cause of continued spread of HIV. It also
leads to high morbidity and mortality amongst people living with HIV. One of
the major barriers identified in access to HIV testing and treatment, care and
support services is stigma and discrimination.

The HIV stigma index 2014 a report of the first The National HIV and
AIDS Stigma Survey in Kenya. It shows that HIV stigma and discrimination
in Kenya is high at 45 with marked regional variations. HIV stigma and
discrimination also varies within population groups with some experiencing
more stigma and discrimination than others. Key populations for example
experience double stigma against HIV and their high risk sexual behaviors.

The Kenya AIDS Strategic Framework (KASF) 2014/2015 - 2018/2019

targets to reduce HIV related stigma and discrimination by 50% by the year
2019. This reduction in HIV related stigma and discrimination will be critical
for the achievement of all the other targets in the KASF.

This document forms the baseline against which we will track and measure
our performance towards ensuring Kenya is free of HIV stigma. In this regard,
therefore, the Ministry of Health through the National AIDS Control Council
is committed to leading and facilitating all efforts towards the elimination of
HIV stigma and discrimination in Kenya for improved health outcomes.

Hon. James Wainaina Macharia

Cabinet Secretary, Ministry of Health
 The National HIV and AIDS Stigma and Discrimination Index • Summary Report vii

It is our hope that this report and the Kenya AIDS

Strategic Framework provide a basis for direct funding
towards HIV stigma reduction interventions in Kenya
Nelson Otwoma - NEPHAK

If we want to achieve SDG3 to ensure healthy lives and

promote well-being for all at all ages, we cannot afford
to leave people living with HIV and those at risk of HIV
behind. We must counter stigma and discrimination, and
adopt a people-centred inclusive approach to Fast Track
the ending of AIDS in Kenya, Africa and globally.
Jantine Jacobi, UNAIDS, Kenya Country Director

At the beginning of the fourth decade of the HIV epidemic,

profound stigma and discrimination is a fact of life for
those with the disease- not just socially but within all
systems of society. We must fight it with all the resources
we have, if we are to achieve sustainable development goals
and ensure healthy lives and promote the well-being for all
at all ages.
Maria-Threase Keating, UNDP Kenya Country Director
viii The National HIV and AIDS Stigma and Discrimination Index • Summary Report

ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS

The National HIV and AIDS Stigma Survey, is a result of efforts by many
individuals and organizations in the country led by The Technical Advisory
Committee.

We wish to thank the following institutions for technical as well as financial

support during the development of the framework; Special thanks to the National
Network and Empowerment of People Living with HIV in Kenya (NEPHAK),
National AIDS and STI Control Programme (NASCOP) and the UN Joint
Programme on HIV and AIDS, led by the UNAIDS secretariat and UNDP; Bill
and Melinda Gates Foundation and the University of Manitoba.

Special thanks to Ruth Laibon Masha, Dr George Githuka and Peter Cheseret for
final design of this summary report. This work is inspired by all the People Living
with HIV in Kenya.

To all of you, Asante Sana!

Special gratitude goes to the following taskforce members who provided

technical leadership throughout the process: James Kamau (NEPHAK/
KETAM), Teresia Njoki Otieno (Community Representative), Dr. Patrick
Murithi (NACC), Joshua Gitonga (NACC), Dr. Bathseba Osoro (NACC),
Ruth Laibon Masha (UNAIDS), Gurumurthy Rangaiyan (UNAIDS),
Ludfine Bunde (UNDP), Onesmus Mlewa (KANCO)

Research Team - Roles-s Management Institute: Dr Stephen Mogere, Dr.

Bon Oirere, Vitalis Akora, Dr. Eunice Nyavanga, Dr. Martin Mburu, Rahab
Mwaniki, Pauline Kamau.

Nduku Kilonzo, Ph.D

Director, National AIDS Control Council
 The National HIV and AIDS Stigma and Discrimination Index • Summary Report ix

ACRONYMS

AIDS Acquired Immune Deficiency Syndrome

ARV Antiretroviral
CCC Comprehensive Care Centre
CDC Centers for Disease Control and Prevention
GIPA Greater Involvement of People Living with HIV and AIDS
GNP+ Global Network of People Living with HIV and AIDS
HIV Human Immunodeficiency Virus
ICW International Community of Women Living with HIV and AIDS
IPPF International Planned Parenthood Federation
KANCO Kenya AIDS NGO Consortium
KCPE Kenya Certificate of Primary Education
KEMRI Kenya Medical Research Institute
KETAM Kenya Treatment Access Movement
M&E Monitoring and Evaluation
MSM Men who have Sex with Men
NACC National AIDS Control Council
NASCOP National AIDS and STI Control Programme
NEPHAK National Empowerment Network of People Living with HIV and AIDS in Kenya
NGO Non-governmental Organisation
OVC Orphans and Vulnerable Children
PE Physical Education
PLHIV People Living with HIV
PMTCT Prevention of Mother-to-Child Transmission
STI Sexually Transmitted Infection
TB Tuberculosis
UNAIDS United Nations Joint Programme on HIV and AIDS
UNDP United Nations Development Programme
x The National HIV and AIDS Stigma and Discrimination Index • Summary Report

KEY TERMS

HIV RELATED STIGMA

Stigma is the devaluation of people living with or associated with HIV and AIDS. A person who
is stigmatised is seen as having less value or worth than other people. This usually happens when
someone’s condition is attributed to behaviours that society considers to be improper.

DISCRIMINATION
Discrimination is what happens when someone is treated in an unjust, unfair or prejudicial way, often on
the basis of belonging to a particular group. Discrimination is how stigma is manifested or enacted.

STIGMA INDEX
Stigma index is a tool for identifying and measuring trends in stigma and discrimination. Stigma index
studies provide evidence of the nature and extent of stigma and discrimination. The tools used in this study
were the standard tools used in similar studies globally. The results can therefore be compared with other
stigma and discrimination index levels in other regions and countries that have used the standard tools.

Voluntary Counseling and testing during Nairobi ASK 2010 © NACC

 The National HIV and AIDS Stigma and Discrimination Index • Summary Report 1

EXECUTIVE SUMMARY

Overall composite HIV stigma index for Kenya

in 2014 was high at 45
Three decades on from when the first AIDS cases
became known to the world, the stigma attached to “My husband told my mother he was dying
the syndrome still flourishes despite tremendous of AIDS, and she blamed me for it. My
in roads made through scaled up prevention and children and I were shunned by the rest
treatment interventions. Kenya has the third of the family. Eventually they sent us away
largest HIV epidemic in Sub-Saharan Africa with from my matrimonial home, accusing me
an estimated 1.6 million People Living with HIV of being a prostitute and a woman of loose
(PLHIV) and over 650,000 of them are currently morals.
accessing antiretroviral treatment. This situation
is, however, compounded by the fact that close to I landed up at my sister’s house in Juja. She
101,560 new HIV infections occur annual1. As the didn’t want us to live in her house because,
country grapples with how to reduce the number she said, my children could easily infect her
of new infections, stigma and discrimination own children while playing together.”
continue to disrupt and discourage access to
HIV education and treatment, care and support
services.
The young woman who endured this callous
The National HIV and AIDS Stigma and treatment from her own family was lucky. After
Discrimination Study, was a cross-sectional several suicide attempts, kind neighbours rushed
survey which collected data from the 47 counties, her to hospital where she was counselled and
grouped into 30 clusters selected based on put on antiretroviral treatment. Today she is a
observed regional variations in HIV prevalence, volunteer AIDS counsellor at the same hospital
socio-cultural and economic characteristics. and runs a small business from a kiosk. Many
others have not fared as well according to The
The stigma study, targeted the general population, National HIV and AIDS Stigma and Discrimination
key populations as well as PLHIV is a compilation Study, carried out in 2014 rated the levels of HIV,
of the thoughts and attitudes regarding HIV, and, related stigma and discrimination in Kenya as
far too frequently, painful experiences of people ‘high’ with regional variations.
living with HIV.

1 Kenya HIV Estimates Technical Report 2013

2 The National HIV and AIDS Stigma and Discrimination Index • Summary Report

Stigma and discrimination Index (SDI) was derived and impact. Indicators used for the SDI were each
from five (5) key indicators: Fear of non-invasive scored on a 100-point scale. Based on their overall
contact with PLHIV; Values targeting shame, scores, individual categories of SDI were then
blame and judgment; Enacted stigma; Disclosure calculated and rated on a scale of 1 to 100.

STIGMA AND DISCRIMINATION RATING

<15 15-29 30-44 45-59 > 60

VERY LOW LOW MODERATE HIGH VERY HIGH

High ratings of indicators such as fear of HIV status disclosure, people

fearing to contract HIV from non-invasive contact with PLHIV have
direct impact on access to HIV care and treatment

KEY INDICATORS
Indicators Units Rating
People fearful of contracting HIV from non-invasive contact with PLHIV 18 LOW
People who judge or blame PLHIV for their illness 47 HIGH
PLHIV who think they have experienced stigma in the last year 17 LOW
PLHIV who are concerned about disclosing their status 70 VERY HIGH
PLHIV who experience stigma’s negative effects on themselves, the family, 74 VERY HIGH
the community

The findings of the report show that key Despite the availability of legal and support
populations who include sex workers, men programmes to curb HIV related stigma and
who have sex with men (MSM) and drug users discrimination none of the respondents knew of
experience double stigma associated with their the existence of the HIV tribunal that supports
sexual behaviours, practices and HIV status. access to justice
Children living with HIV were also significantly
affected as a result of stigma which could limit
access to services.
 The National HIV and AIDS Stigma and Discrimination Index • Summary Report 3

KEY HIGHLIGHTS

48% of 61%
respondents fear their think HIV is
children to play with a punishment
known HIV positive for bad
children in schools behaviour

39% said that 44% believed that people living with HIV
are promiscuous
HIV-positive men
and women should
not have children
50% 45% opined that
Consider men who have sex with
HIV infection men and injecting drug
a punishment users deserve to acquire
from God HIV

55% believe that 52% would not buy food in the

HIV is spread by sex market from a known person a living
workers with HIV
4 The National HIV and AIDS Stigma and Discrimination Index • Summary Report

COUNTY HIV STIGMA INDEX

County stigma index was derived from data

aggregated into regional clusters

60% 46%
Garissa Baringo
KEY
Mandera Bomet
Wajir Elgeyo Marakwet
60.2%
49.2% 49.2% 47.5%
Kajiado 46.7%
Garissa,
Embu Embu, Isiolo, Kilifi,
Laikipia Kwale, Bungoma,
Mandera, Kirinyaga, Lamu, Busia,
Isiolo
Wajir Kitui
Nakuru
Mombasa, Kakamega,
Kirinyaga Machakos, Nandi
Taita Taveta, Vihiga
Kitui Makueni, Tana River
Narok
Machakos Marsabit, Samburu
Makueni Meru, Trans Nzoia
Tharaka Nithi
Marsabit Turkana
Meru Uasin Gishu
Tharaka Nithi West Pokot
45.6%
48% 39.5% 38.9%
40% 34.5%
Baringo,
Kilifi Nairobi Kiambu,
Nairobi Homa Bay,
Bomet, Muranga, Kericho,
Kwale 38.9%
Elgeyo Nyandarua, Kisii,
Lamu
Marakwet, Kiambu
Nyeri, Kisumu,
Mombasa
Kajiado, Muranga Migori,
Laikipia,
Taita Taveta Nyandarua Nyamira,
Nakuru,
Tana River Nyeri Siaya,
Nandi, Narok,
47% 35%
Samburu,
Bungoma
Trans Nzoia, Homa Bay
Busia
Turkana, Kericho
Uasin Gishu,
Kakamega Kisii
West
VihigaPokot Kisumu
Migori
Nyamira
Siaya
 The National HIV and AIDS Stigma and Discrimination Index • Summary Report 5

SUMMARY OF KEY RECOMMENDATIONS

1 Create awareness of existence of legal

frameworks and institutions such as the
existence of the HIV Equity Tribunal’s, that
6 Promote and engage political and other public
personalities to champion anti-HIV stigma
campaigns
promote access to social justice for people living
with HIV
7 Design localised, funded county and
contextualised specific strategies to eliminate

2 Intensify programmes for to safeguard against

discriminatory employment practices that lock
out people living with HIV through strengthening
HIV stigma and discrimination led by county
governments.

mechanisms of legal redress and speedy justice

8 Promote anti HIV-stigma campaigns in schools
and other learning institutions targeted at

3 Create an environment that makes it easier

for newly diagnosed people to disclose their
HIV status especially to their sexual partners and
administrators, teachers and students. There is
need to evaluate existing curricula and eliminate
content that perpetuate HIV related stigma and
families to provide support systems needed to discrimination.
encourage early treatment through community
and institutions education and sensitization
programmes. 9 Design innovative and cost-effective
approaches to improve psychosocial support,
and access to care and treatment tailor made for

4 Provide education programmes for how HIV is

not transmitted such as fear of infection from
mobile populations such as pastoralist.

non-invasive contact with PLHIV and the harmful

effects of stigma and discrimination in addition
to information on comprehensive programs that
10 Conduct regular studies to measure,
monitor the levels and underlying causes
of HIV related stigma and discrimination and
support physical and psychological wellbeing of provide localised evidence based interventions to
individuals such as nutrition and clinical support. address the situation.

5 Integrate HIV and confidentiality and ethical

issues training especially on issues affecting key
population, children and adolescents living with
HIV health care training programmes for HIV
treatment and management
6 The National HIV and AIDS Stigma and Discrimination Index • Summary Report

INTRODUCTION

The Kenya HIV and AIDS Prevention and Control Act (2006)
safeguards the rights of People Living with HIV (PLHIV), promotes
voluntary HIV testing, confidentiality and privacy, non-discrimination in
employment and education, and unfettered access to quality healthcare
services. It also calls for the integration of HIV programs in all sectors

Stigma and Discrimination Index was The specific objectives of the study were to;
conceptualised by the Global Network of
People Living with HIV and AIDS (GNP+); the •• Document the levels of the various categories of
International Community of Women Living with HIV stigma and discrimination
HIV and AIDS (ICW); the International Planned
Parenthood Federation (IPPF); and the Joint •• Identify factors that perpetuate or mitigate
United Nations Programme on HIV and AIDS against HIV stigma
(UNAIDS) in response to the phenomenon of
widespread stigma and discrimination which was •• Document the effects of stigma and
impeding progress in providing access to HIV discrimination on the HIV response
treatment and care for all.
•• Generate baseline information on HIV stigma
The National HIV stigma index study was and discrimination
carried out between March and May 2014. The
broad objective of the study was to generate
strategic information on HIV related stigma and
discrimination across Kenya to guide interventions
and policies to address HIV related stigma and
discrimination to enhance the quality of life of
PLHIV.
 The National HIV and AIDS Stigma and Discrimination Index • Summary Report 7

CA SE S TU DY
STIGMA AT THE WORKPLACE

I didn’t discover my HIV status of my own volition. In 1997 the company I worked for sent me to hospital for
a check-up because I got sick so often. No one gave me any feedback on why I was sick. Eventually, I was laid
off so I went back home and took up fishing to earn money. I continued being sickly. My family wanted to know
what was wrong with me and if I could be helped as it was becoming too much. They were told that I was HIV
positive but they didn’t tell me. Instead they took all my wealth including my goats and my shamba.

In 2002, I got advice but didn’t act on it. The next year I fell sick again and was advised to visit a CCC.
The year after that, in 2004, I decided to start the treatment. In 2005 I began to feel its effects. For the next
six years I’ve been attending workshops on care and support so now I’m well informed. Most people who
thought I’d die are shocked that I’m still alive. They come to me for advice. My children are the ones who
have been affected the most because they are discriminated against in school and also in the community.

Dan On’gayi writes HIV messages on rocks in Emuhaya village, western Kenya © Kenneth Odiwuor/IRIN
8 The National HIV and AIDS Stigma and Discrimination Index • Summary Report

STUDY METHODOLOGY

The sampling methodology considered variations and patterns of HIV

prevalence, socio-cultural and socio-economic characteristics of the 47
counties which were then grouped into eight regions

The study was a cross-sectional survey using both and treatment for HIV and AIDS services.
quantitative and qualitative methods for data Qualitative information was collected from 60
collection. The quantitative survey measured HIV focus group discussions conducted with PLHIV,
stigma indices for different forms of stigma and key populations, and the general population. The
discrimination and generated the overall national conversations were recorded and then transcribed.
Stigma Index. The qualitative survey explored the
various forms of stigma by population segments The following are the demographic characteristics
and by region. of those interviewed;

Nationwide data collection was done from 30 •• The age was 15 years and above with majority
clusters – 21 rural and 9 urban. The sampling was being over 30 years (80%)
based on variations in HIV prevalence, socio-
cultural and socio-economic characteristics in all •• Majority of those interviewed has some form of
the 47 counties which were then grouped into formal education (84%)
eight regions
•• 42% were self-employed while 31% had no
The quantitative interviews were conducted formal employment
with PLHIV using standard questionnaires
administered by a trained interviewer. A sample of
3,300 was targeted with a 95% (3,127) response
rate. The PLHIV respondents were sourced at
health facilities providing comprehensive care
 The National HIV and AIDS Stigma and Discrimination Index • Summary Report 9

COMPUTATION OF HIV STIGMA AND DISCRIMINATION

INDEX AND SUMMARY OF FINDINGS

The overall National index was derived from computation of 34

indicators clustered into five key categories. The overall composite
stigma rating for Kenya was 45

The Stigma and Discrimination Index used 34 STIGMA AND DISCRIMINATION

indicators clustered into 5 categories. The index RATING
was estimated on a scale of 1-100. Each category > 60 VERY HIGH
was equal to 20 units. The cumulative scores were
45-59 HIGH
then averaged to yield an overall stigma score. The
extent to which Kenyans demonstrate stigma in 30-44 MODERATE
each category was rated according to the score of 15-29 LOW
each category. <15 VERY LOW

STIGMA AND DISCRIMINATION INDEX BY CATEGORY

Form of stigma Score Unit value Index

PLHIV who are concerned about disclosing 70 20 14.05
their status
People fearful of contracting HIV from non- 18 20 3.60
invasive contact with PLHIV
People who judge or blame PLHIV for their 47 20 9.36
illness
PLHIV who think they have experienced 17 20 3.44
stigma in the last year
PLHIV who experience stigma’s negative 74 20 14.70
effects on themselves, the family, the
communit
Composite stigma rating for Kenya   100 45.16 (High)
10 The National HIV and AIDS Stigma and Discrimination Index • Summary Report

1. FEAR OF CONTRACTING HIV

FROM NON-INVASIVE CONTACT “Since they knew I am positive, they stopped
WITH PLHIV telling me when they are around. My close
Despite the fear of HIV transmission through family and friends leave me out of their
non-invasive contact being low (18), it is still activities. I wonder even if I am HIV positive
far from over. Isolation of children in schools if does it mean they discriminate me from family
their parents were known to be PLHIV and social affairs? One day they will come to realize that
exclusion of PLHIV from community functions what they were doing was completely wrong.”
was reported.
PLHIV discussant - Migori

UNAIDS Deputy Executive Director, Luiz Loures, meets the Kenyan President, H.E Uhuru Kenyatta at the launch of
the All in campaign to end adolescent AIDS in Nairobi © UNAIDS/T.Karumba

I have directed the ministries of education and health to initiate

programmes that will ensure all HIV-positive children are provided
with life-saving medication. The issue of children living with HIV not on
antiretroviral therapy must be addressed without further delay.
President Uhuru Kenyatta
 The National HIV and AIDS Stigma and Discrimination Index • Summary Report 11

CA S E STU DY

CHILDREN AND HIV RELATED STIGMA

I lost my parents to HIV and AIDS 15 years ago when I was seven years old. I was taken in by my
maternal uncle as my father’s brothers and sister did not want to be associated with me.

I was a sickly child, always in and out of hospital. At age 10, I fell sick at school and was taken to hospital
where I tested positive for HIV. My uncle refused to believe it was true and immediately took me back to the
hospital for a second test which confirmed my status.

My life changed dramatically. My uncle banned me from sharing a room, food and utensils with the rest of
the family. He did all he could to separate me from his children, who continued to play with me anyway.
But when I reached class seven, my uncle decided to chase me out of his home. I went onto the streets.

I lived on the street for seven months. I had no access to the medication I had been taking and was not
interested in looking after myself. I used to seek shelter in a church at night. One evening the priest in charge
of the church found me sleeping in a pew. I told him my story, and that is how I got my way back to primary
school. He sponsored me in a boarding school.

The first year there were no problems. The priest and I had decided to keep my status a secret between us. I
passed my KCPE with good marks and was admitted to a boarding secondary school. The school required
a medical examination. Mine showed I was HIV positive, and my admission was immediately cancelled.
The father found me another school, but I was expelled a year later because of my HIV status. At the new
school only the deputy principal knew my status. Even so, it was not long before fellow students discovered
I was taking drugs and started making comments such as, He must have AIDS. They’re the ones who take
drugs like that.

After high school, inspired by my sponsor, I wanted to join the priesthood. I thought it would be safe as I
had no home to go to, and I presumed that priests would not discriminate against me. I was wrong. My
sponsor told me that the Church does not admit people who are HIV positive into the priesthood. This was
really demoralising. I have suffered from low self-esteem ever since.

Today I’m a volunteer counsellor and live with friends who have no problem with my HIV status. I am
working towards furthering my education. I’m also in the process of getting back my parents’ property
through the help of a local NGO that deals with legal matters.
12 The National HIV and AIDS Stigma and Discrimination Index • Summary Report

2. PEOPLE WHO JUDGE OR BLAME PLHIV FOR THEIR ILLNESS

Across the country, a cummulative HIV stigma index score of 47 which is

rated as high showed that many respondents judge and blame PLHIV for
their status. HIV infection was considered a punishment from God or a
punishment for bad behaviour
In all regions respondents significantly stated discussions where it was pointed out that places
that HIV was ascociated with promiscuity with of worship branded PLHIV as promiscuous,
scores as moderate as 32 in counties in Central and summarily condemned as sinners. In some
Kenya and as high as 60 in those in North Eastern. churches PLHIV were not allowed to marry and
Similar findings were reported from community wed in the church freely

CAS E STU DY

BLAME, SHAME, JUDGEMENT AND ISOLATION WITHIN FAMILIES

I’m a mother of two living with HIV and I attend a comprehensive care centre in Thika. I lost my husband
eight years ago. He worked as a policeman in the General Service Unit. He’d been sick for several years, but
I didn’t know why until finally he told me he had HIV. This shattered me completely. I was advised to go for
testing and counselling. It turned out I had HIV too.

My husband told his mother that he was dying of AIDS, and she blamed me for having infected him. My
children and I were shunned by the rest of the family. Eventually they sent us away from my matrimonial
home, accusing me of being a prostitute and a woman of loose morals.

I went to my sister’s house in Juja. She didn’t want us to live in her house because, she said, my children
could easily infect her own children while playing together. I was really hurt. Even my own sister was
shunning me. Eventually my sister allowed me to live in a storeroom. I wasn’t allowed to cook or eat with
her family. We couldn’t share the same bathrooms and toilets. My children dropped out of school because
I couldn’t afford to buy the uniforms and shoes. My health was deteriorating so I depended on my sister’s
family to survive. I lost weight and got TB. I was bedridden for several months. I got depressed and tried to
commit suicide several times, twice with poison. On two occasions my children found me in the house in a
dire condition. They raised the alarm and neighbours rushed me to hospital.

The hospital clinic put me on ARVs. I also joined a support group where I met an old widow who agreed
to take in me and my children. Now I help her in her fruit and vegetable business. At the clinic, I helped
other people living with HIV, especially on follow up when people defaulted. Eventually I was recruited as a
 The National HIV and AIDS Stigma and Discrimination Index • Summary Report 13

volunteer and trained to provide counselling services at the clinic. I earn a stipend which has helped me take
care of myself and my children. I now live in my own house and have a small kiosk business which I run
while I continue to be a peer counsellor at the hospital.

Recently my husband’s family invited me to their home and apologised for all they had done. My father
in-law gave me back the land that had belonged to my husband along with the legal documents. It’s like
they got tired of waiting for me to die. God didn’t allow death. He wanted me to be able to take care of my
children.

3. PLHIV WHO REPORTED TO HAVE EXPERIENCED STIGMA

Counties in Coast, North Eastern and Eastern regions reported high

rates for this category with indicators such as gossip, loss of respect and
exclusion from a social gatherings being relatively high

The study respondents living with HIV reported

having experienced instances of isolation and being “…..in my family, once they knew my husband
disowned by their families in the previous year. and I were ailing, they took all our property
Counties in coastal and North Eastern regions had and shared amongst themselves since they
the highest reports of spousal abandonmentrated thought we were going to die. We moved out
at 30 and 31 respectively. Respondents from of our village home and decided to start life
counties in Eastern region reported significantly afresh. I thank God for now we are doing better
high rates (30) of being teased, insulted as a result and we have been able to educate our children
of HIV status. and I can’t complain now, we are happy.”

Married women were blamed for their spouses FGD Discussant- Kitale
HIV positive status without any confirmed
knowledge of their HIV status especially if they
were newly weded. They were branded as ‘killers
who had brought the disease to their husbands’.
More male PLHIVs reported having experienced
stigma at the health facility than the female PLHIV
respondents.
14 The National HIV and AIDS Stigma and Discrimination Index • Summary Report

CASE S TU DY

STIGMA IN SCHOOL
I’m 12 years old and I’m in class six at school. I like my social science teacher, Mrs. Rajab. My mother
died when I was only three. I now live with a stepmother and my sick father. My father has a disease called
bomesa which is making everyone in Isiolo County poor and gradually killing them off. My teacher says
that it’s not the disease but what people think about it that’s killing our people. She says a lot needs to be
done.

I stopped the drugs because the other children pulled me down when my body felt weak after taking them.
But a health officer from the CCC made a follow up so now I’m taking them again.

Pupils often move away from me unexpectedly. I remember once when five pupils joined our class for
interclass PE lessons. They wouldn’t sit with me. One girl told me I smelt of drugs. I’ve lived like this for the
last nine years, and I can’t take it anymore. I feel rejected.

The other children don’t want to play with me. Boys shy away from me. No one wants to talk to me. I live in
desperation, and loneliness has engulfed me. I fear that one day I will just die. My dreams will never come
true. Nowadays I stay alone. No one comes near me. They say I’m weak and sick. Whenever I move close to
them they walk away one by one, even in class. I can’t share textbooks with anyone. Its humiliating. So I’ve
decided not to attend school anymore. They all think I’ll infect them.

The teachers are helpful. They buy me milk and some food and encourage me to take my drugs. I can’t do
that at home. There’s no food for me. These drugs make me feel sick all the time.

HIV STIGMA AND DISCLOSURE

Western
Nairobi

Eastern

Eastern

Central
Nyanza

North
Valley
Coast

Rift

Fear Indicator
I am worried that those who know 55.9 54.0 63.8 52.6 77.0 52.3 49.3 56.7
I have HIV will tell others
I would like my family and close 81.6 72.0 81.7 66.4 93.1 78.5 71.9 79.5
friends to keep my HIV status a
secret
I am very careful to whom I tell 85.3 78.6 87.8 70.8 93.1 85.1 85.3 84.0
that I am HIV-positive
To tell someone I have HIV is very 72.4 63.2 76.8 52.9 87.4 66.6 64.5 66.8
risky
I make a big effort to make sure 77.3 63.0 82.1 53.9 87.4 75.8 70.0 78.5
that my HIV is kept a secret
Total 74.5 66.2 78.4 59.3 87.6 71.7 68.2 73.1
 The National HIV and AIDS Stigma and Discrimination Index • Summary Report 15

4. PLHIV WHO ARE CONCERNED ABOUT DISCLOSING THEIR STATUS

Disclosure of HIV status which is important for HIV pevention care

and treatment programme is largely affected by stigma levels.

The study reported high scores (70) for the number of people who were concerned about disclosing their
HIV status across the counties. Indicators such as people who made so much effort to keep their HIV
status a secret was higher in counties in North (87) Eastern, Rift Valley (82) and Central (79)

•• More female than male PLHIVs disclosed their •• Male PLHIV encountered disclosure of their
HIV status soon after diagnosis. HIV status without their consent, more than the
female population.
•• Many PLHIVs still delayed to disclose their
HIV status and struggled to have it kept a secret •• Healthcare providers disclosed HIV status of
clients to third parties without their consent
•• Many PLHIVs preferred to have their HIV (against ethical and professional provisions)
status kept secret by their families

I make a big effort to make sure that my HIV

is kept a secret
43.2 56.8
To tell someone that I have HIV is something
very risky
23.7 73.5
I am very careful to whom I tell that I am
HIV-positive
17.7 82.3
I would like it if my family and close friends
keep my HIV-positive status a...
33 67
I am worried thinking that those who know I
have HIV will tell that to others
28.3 71.7
Yes No
16 The National HIV and AIDS Stigma and Discrimination Index • Summary Report

5. PLHIV WHO EXPERIENCE STIGMA’S NEGATIVE EFFECTS ON

THEMSELVES, THE FAMILY, AND THE COMMUNITY

Respondents in Counties from North Eastern, Eastern and Central

reported higher instances where PLHIV lost family ties because of their
HIV status. People living in North Eastern counties reported high (93)
cummulative effects of stigma such as being lonely, weakened family bonds
and regrets

EFFECTS OF STIGMA WITHIN THE FAMILY

Effect of stigma Strongly Agree Disagree Strongly

agree disagree
PLHIV lose family love and guidance. 34.6 36.4 19.3 9.7
PLHIV are lonely. 37.4 39.1 14.5 9
Family bonds are weakened. 33.2 37.7 19.5 9.6
PLHIV create family barriers. 32.4 39.4 18.6 9.7
 The National HIV and AIDS Stigma and Discrimination Index • Summary Report 17

HIV STIGMA AND KEY POPULATIONS

Key populations (Sex Workers, Men who have Sex with Men and drug
users) living with HIV ­were reported to experience double stigma from
being HIV positive and that of moral judgement imposed by society on
their sexual behaviour

Nearly 55% of respondents MSM were reported to encounter stigmatizing

incidences such as isolation, being ostracised
believed that sex workers are and lack of support systems other than those led
responsible for spreading HIV by their peers. Majority of MSM respondents
in the community reported fear of being tested for HIV. Partner
testing for HIV positive MSM was further reported
to draw further judgment and blame. Stigma was
blamed for late presentation of MSM living with
Participants in group discussion reported that Sex HIV resulting to disproportionately higher HIV
workers were commonly labelled as “the walking related morbidity and mortality.
dead” and “HIV carriers” in their communities.
The stigma was also extended to children of known
sex workers. HIV testing was reported to be
significantly affected by the stigma levels for this We get the worst treatment at health facilities.
group. In some cases, health providers break
confidentiality by bringing in other colleagues to
the room to see a gay person. They lecture us on
social and religious values. Sometimes they even
44.8% of respondents include the general public at the hospital when
they’re doing it. We are subjected to testing and
believed that MSM and drug counselling initiated by the provider even though
users deserve to get HIV we have a right to refuse to be tested.

MSM Kisumu
18 The National HIV and AIDS Stigma and Discrimination Index • Summary Report

IMPACT OF HIV STIGMA AND DISCRIMINATION

78% of PLHIV concurred that HIV related stigma

leads to increased HIV spread

The study’s results showed a relationship between One of the major impact of HIV related stigma
levels of education, socio-economic status with and discrimination was abandonment by spouses,
stigma and discrimination index. Those with a family and friends. In all counties, more women
higher level of education and socio-economic living with HIV were reported to have been
status were more accepting of PLHIV. Counties chased out of their homes with with their children
where access to formal education was higher had a than men. Ironically, men living with HIV were
lower Stigma Index. reported to receive support from their families
after learning of their HIV status. Their spouses
PLHIV reported incidences of enacted stigma were accused of having infected the men with HIV
experienced in many aspects of their day to day even when their status remained unknown.
lives. Stories were recounted on how some
respondents had been chased away from their Family and spousal abandonment was reported to
workplace, places of worship, schools and even cause despair, shame and a sense of hopelessness
their own homes through use of direct and indirect among the PLHIV respondents. In addition,
verbalised comments. In some places of worship some PLHIV lost their sources of income, their
those living with HIV were condemned as sinners children often dropped out of school either due to
destined for hell making PLHIV in attendance their parents inability to pay school fees or cases
uncomfortable. of non-acceptance of known PLHIV children in
some schools.
In other instances, PLHIV respondents reported
to be sconned upon when they initiated public HIV stigma lead to low self-esteem and depression
education messages on HIV related issues. Some among PLHIV with three out of four PLHIV
members of the community were claimed to view interviewed reporting they had contemplated
such voluntary efforts negatively with PLHIV suicide at some point in their lives. Nearly 90% of
being blamed to use their status for money. PLHIV interviewed indicated that they suffered so
much stress as a result of stigma.
Blatant discrimination against PLHIV was
reported to affect self perception with a high Overall, stigma and discrimination undermines the
proportion (45.9%) of PLHIV respondents community’s ability to control HIV transmission
reporting that they perceived HIV infection to and care for those living with HIV.
be a punishment from God and (61%) for bad
behaviour .
 The National HIV and AIDS Stigma and Discrimination Index • Summary Report 19

PERCEIVED IMPACT OF STIGMA ON THE COMMUNITY

45%
44

40.9 Because of stigma there is

39.8 increased workload in
40%
38.1
the community
38

36.6

37.1
37
35.2
34.6

35% High death rate in the

33
31.7
community
30.3

30%
Loss of leaders/advisors/
27.6

25.9

people of influence
25%
to the community
20% Increase in number
17.4

of OVCs
16

15%
12.8

PLHIV who are stigmatised

10% may turn violent, e.g defile

7.9
or rape other
7.1

6.1

5% Stigma leads to high

1.6
0.9

rate of HIV infection

0.3

0
Strongly Agree Disagree Strongly
Agree Disagree

CASE S TU DY

ENDING HIV STIGMA THROUGH EMPOWERING OTHERS

I decided to use my experience of living with HIV to give hope to others in the same situation.

I lost my mother and sister at a tender age, and immediately after got married in Makindu.

Three months into my marriage I fell sick and was diagnosed with TB. I was advised to take an HIV test
which turned out to be positive, and also discovered that I was pregnant. I was confined to a TB manyatta
in the district hospital and given TB drugs and ARVs (antiretrovirals). By the time I was discharged, I had
missed out on antenatal care. In my naivety and confusion, I had no clue what awaited me and my unborn
baby. Neither did the hospital staff help me much. I gave birth to a sickly baby boy who died a few months
later, probably due to complications from HIV. Six months after my diagnosis of HIV and TB, my husband
was also diagnosed and put on treatment.

Despite the situation, my husband and mother-in-law continued to care and love me. They both stood
by me while I was in and out of hospital. My mother-in-law was exceptional. She treated me like a real
daughter. She fed, bathed and clothed me when I was sickly. She even supported us financially.

My relationship with my husband was formalised in 2008 and we were blessed with two HIV-negative
children through use of ART and exclusive breastfeeding.
20 The National HIV and AIDS Stigma and Discrimination Index • Summary Report

I joined a local support group at the Kajiado District Hospital. My heart went out to the many HIV-
positive pregnant women streaming into the hospital and quietly delivering HIV-positive babies and
watching them die. Just like me years back, they were left in the dark because of social stigma. Their babies
might have survived if they had received the right information and support.

I started a support group for such women, calling it Nannyor, which is Maa for love.

Drawing from my own experience, we educate and guide positive mothers from conception to birth to help
them deliver HIV-free babies. We teach them about adherence to treatment, proper breastfeeding techniques
and good nutrition. We also do home visits and hold monthly meetings. Our work is done through peer-to-
peer referrals. We follow up the women until their babies are 18 months old.

I am very vocal about the harmful consequences of stigmatising HIV-positive mothers as I have seen the
effects firsthand on Nannyor members. Not only have they been shunned by the community, their marriages
have been annulled or stopped from taking place. And they have been excommunicated from their churches.
So it’s no wonder that anyone who is diagnosed with HIV tries to keep quiet about it. Denial, because of the
fear of stigma, has promoted the spread of HIV within society.

That’s why Nannyor also does advocacy against stigma and discrimination on behalf of HIV-positive
people. We use barazas, churches, social events and other community forums to galvanise community
involvement and support. We are also educating people on the importance of disclosure, family
support and good nutrition.

I’m proud to report that 26 HIV-negative babies have been born to our members who are living with HIV.
We have also become more socially acceptable. Thirty-five men joined the group this year (2014), and more
men are supporting the PMTCT (prevention of mother-to-child transmission) program.

My goal is to reach the unreachable members of society - through mobile clinics, awareness and advocacy -
to fight the social stigma and discrimination caused by HIV and AIDS. I have given myself two more years
of service to the community before I retire to focus on my family. By that time, the Nannyor group will have
prepared the ground for the Beyond Zero Campaign (access to antenatal and postnatal healthcare) should
it come to Kajiado County. Whatever happens, it will be enough to know that I have been a role model who
shows mothers how to live each day with hope for a better future.
 The National HIV and AIDS Stigma and Discrimination Index • Summary Report 21

RECOMMENDATIONS

1 Create awareness of existence of legal

frameworks and institutions such as the
existence of the HIV Equity Tribunal’s, that
HIV health care training programmes for HIV
treatment and management

promote access to social justice for people living

with HIV 6 Promote and engage political and other public
personalities to champion anti-HIV stigma
campaigns

2 Intensify programmes for to safeguard against

discriminatory employment practices that lock
out people living with HIV through strengthening 7 Design localised, funded county and
contextualised specific strategies to eliminate
mechanisms of legal redress and speedy justice HIV stigma and discrimination led by county
governments.

3 Create an environment that makes it easier

for newly diagnosed people to disclose their
HIV status especially to their sexual partners and 8 Promote anti HIV-stigma campaigns in schools
and other learning institutions targeted at
families to provide support systems needed to administrators, teachers and students. There is
encourage early treatment through community need to evaluate existing curricula and eliminate
and institutions education and sensitization content that perpetuate HIV related stigma and
programmes. discrimination.

4 Provide education programmes for how HIV is

not transmitted such as fear of infection from
non-invasive contact with PLHIV and the harmful
9 Design innovative and cost-effective
approaches to improve psychosocial support,
and access to care and treatment tailor made for
effects of stigma and discrimination in addition mobile populations such as pastoralist.
to information on comprehensive programs that
support physical and psychological wellbeing of
individuals such as nutrition and clinical support. 10 Conduct regular studies to measure,
monitor the levels and underlying causes of
HIV related stigma and discrimination and provide

5 Integrate HIV and confidentiality and ethical

issues training especially on issues affecting key
population, children and adolescents living with
localised evidence based interventions to address
the situation.
22 The National HIV and AIDS Stigma and Discrimination Index • Summary Report

APPENDIX
APPENDIX 1: SUMMARY OF SCORES FOR THE KEY
STIGMA INDEX CATEGORIES AND INDICATORS

Experiences of fear of HIV infection from non-invasive contact

Rift Valley

Western
Nairobi

Eastern

Eastern

Central
Nyanza

North
Coast

Experiences
People unwilling for me to cook at 8.6 31.1 19.8 8.8 35.6 28.4 26.7 5.9
functions
People unwilling to share meals at 6.1 27.8 18.8 7.7 40.2 24.8 23.5 5.5
functions
People unwilling for me to serve 6.7 32.0 17.9 8.6 33.3 21.3 23.5 5.5
guests meals
People unwilling to share bedding 8.0 36.6 18.4 12.2 34.5 24.8 21.2 5.2
People unwilling to share soap 9.8 41.8 18.8 13.9 36.8 26.4 19.4 7.5
People unwilling to shake hands 4.9 27.4 11.3 5.2 34.5 20.0 12.0 2.3
Total 7.4 32.8 17.5 9.4 35.8 24.3 21.1 5.3

Shame, blame and judgement Western

Nairobi

Eastern

Eastern

Central
Nyanza

North
Valley
Coast

Rift

Shame, blame and judgement

HIV is a punishment from God 43.6 39.5 51.8 51.8 41.5 62.1 55.2 32.9
Some people think HIV is a 49.1 55.2 66.8 57.3 82.8 70.5 68.2 41.0
punishment for bad behaviour
Most people with HIV deserve 35.0 37.2 39.3 34.5 51.7 45.3 41.0 19.2
what they get
It is sex workers who spread HIV 44.8 56.6 58.5 50.2 72.4 60.9 62.7 38.8
in the community
People with HIV are promiscuous. 37.4 37.0 49.5 40.9 59.8 50.1 49.3 31.9
People with HIV should be 36.8 29.4 36.6 27.5 42.5 41.3 31.8 21.5
ashamed of themselves
Men who have sex with men 50.9 52.6 41.2 39.7 52.9 52.1 50.7 33.6
deserve to get AIDS.
HIV+ women should not have 39.9 31.7 42.0 35.5 46.0 43.1 40.6 24.8
children
Total 42.2 42.4 48.2 42.2 56.2 53.2 49.9 30.5
 The National HIV and AIDS Stigma and Discrimination Index • Summary Report 23

Perceptions on the cumulative effect of stigma

Western
Nairobi

Eastern

Eastern

Central
Nyanza

North
Valley
Coast

Rift
Cumulative effect
PLHIV lose the family’s love and 18.4 66.2 70.3 55.2 92.0 80.2 79.7 79.8
guidance
PLHIV become lonely 89.6 83.9 76.2 53.3 93.1 82.9 86.6 85.7
Family bonds are weakened 85.9 68.5 70.7 50.5 97.5 78.7 82.5 82.5
Many PLHIV wish they had never 70.6 61.1 66.9 49.8 90.8 57.6 70.0 63.2
married
Total 66.1 69.9 71.0 52.2 93.4 74.9 79.7 77.8

Stigma around disclosure

Western
Nairobi

Eastern

Eastern

Central
Nyanza

North
Valley
Coast

Rift

Type of fear
I am worried that those who know 55.9 54.0 63.8 52.6 77.0 52.3 49.3 56.7
I have HIV will tell others
I would like my family and close 81.6 72.0 81.7 66.4 93.1 78.5 71.9 79.5
friends to keep my HIV status a
secret
I am very careful to whom I tell 85.3 78.6 87.8 70.8 93.1 85.1 85.3 84.0
that I am HIV-positive
To tell someone I have HIV is very 72.4 63.2 76.8 52.9 87.4 66.6 64.5 66.8
risky
I make a big effort to make sure 77.3 63.0 82.1 53.9 87.4 75.8 70.0 78.5
that my HIV is kept a secret
Total 74.5 66.2 78.4 59.3 87.6 71.7 68.2 73.1
24 The National HIV and AIDS Stigma and Discrimination Index • Summary Report

Experiences of enacted stigma

Western
Nairobi

Eastern

Eastern

Central
Nyanza

North
Valley
Coast

Rift
Experience of stigma
Excluded from a social gathering 4.3 21.6 9.8 7.2 28.7 22.4 15.2 4.2
Abandoned by spouse/partner 8.0 29.9 17.4 13.2 31.0 22.0 11.1 9.8
Isolated in the household 5.5 22.5 11.1 7.2 31.0 22.2 10.6 6.2
No longer visited or visited less 8.6 29.0 19.8 9.9 32.2 32.1 14.3 10.7
frequently by family and friends
Teased, insulted or sworn at 11.0 37.2 18.5 17.1 39.1 30.1 23.5 16.0
Lost retail/wholesale customers 6.7 27.4 9.8 6.4 33.3 20.2 16.6 4.6
or lost job
Lost housing or not able to rent 3.1 20.0 5.4 3.3 27.6 12.1 6.5 6.5
housing
Denied religious rites/services 1.8 14.0 3.3 3.3 24.1 8.1 3.2 1.3
Property taken away 8.0 9.7 6.2 4.4 20.7 16.7 11.1 5.9
Subject of gossip 23.3 61.8 36.7 31.1 50.6 51.9 50.7 25.7
Lost respect/standing within the 12.3 43.2 18.7 13.2 35.6 33.0 24.0 11.7
family and/or community
Treated violently 5.5 17.5 8.7 6.2 19.5 16.7 11.1 5.9
Quality of health services declines 4.3 18.4 6.4 3.6 13.8 11.4 5.1 3.6
Physically assaulted 4.3 26.2 7.3 5.7 17.2 16.0 9.2 2.9
Denied promotion/ training 2.5 21.9 4.2 4.9 28.7 14.3 8.3 5.2
An increase of visitors “to see how 10.4 37.2 20.4 16.3 27.5 43.3 25.3 13.0
you’re doing”
Abandoned by family/expelled 6.7 9.9 9.5 4.1 28.7 18.0 12.9 6.5
from village
Delayed or inferior healthcare 4.9 16.3 6.6 4.7 23.0 11.0 7.9 4.2
Partner refuses to touch me after 6.7 30.8 15.9 16.8 26.4 22.2 9.2 6.2
disclosing my positive status
Partner departs after disclosing my 8.6 32.4 15.9 12.9 17.2 19.3 12.4 8.1
positive status
Total 7.3 26.3 12.6 9.6 27.8 22.2 14.4 7.9
 www.nacc.or.ke

NATIONAL AIDS CONTROL COUNCIL

Landmark Plaza, 9th Floor, Argwings Kodhek Road | P.O. Box 61307 - 00200 Nairobi, Kenya
Tel: 254 (020) 2896000, 2711261 Fax: 254 (020) 2711231, 2711072 | E-mail: communication @ nacc.or.ke

Empowered lives.
Resilient nations.