The Problem: Derris Elliptica Benth, Locally Recognized
The Problem: Derris Elliptica Benth, Locally Recognized
The Problem: Derris Elliptica Benth, Locally Recognized
THE PROBLEM
Introduction
Rice is the staple food for more than 60 percent of the population globally (Gross
and Zhaob, 2014). The Philippines is the world’s eighth-largest rice producer and its
arable land totals 5.4 million hectares and it is the staple food for most of the Filipinos
(Rice Pedia, 2012). Reportedly, Philippines is experiencing vast amount of losses of crops
every year because of the different factors. One of which is the rice black bugs
(Caoyonan, 2014).
from Palawan then Mindanao. For many years, it has been a rice pest in Malaysia
(Catindig and Heong, 2005). Here in South Cotabato, rice black bug is one of the most
persistent pest among rice (Pablico, 2007).Adult one is just around 8-9 mm (OISAT, 2007)
but is very destructive that 10 adult rice black bugs per hill can cause losses of up to 35
percent (Tacio, 2014). Therefore, causes failure in harvest and losses of income.
activity. Its twigs and roots have been used as natural pesticides in artisanal fisheries and
aquaculture ponds in Nigeria. In the study, ethanolic extracts of dried roots elicited a toxic
reaction by fish with discouration, gulping of air, erratic swimming, loss of reflex, settling
at the bottom motionless (Flores and Santiago, 2013). The present study was undertaken
to test the secondary metabolites present and the insecticidal effect of Derris elliptica
Benth ethanolic root extract as applied to rice black bugs (Scotinophora coarctata).
Statement of the Problem
This study identified the phytochemical constituents and determined the insecticidal
activity of Derris elliptica Benth (Tubli) root extract. Specifically, this sought answers to
2. Can ethanolic root extract of D. elliptica (Tubli) kill the adult rice black bug?
3. Is there a significant difference in the insecticidal activity among the 50%, 75% and 100
Derris elliptica Benth (Tubli) root extract as applied against Scotinophara coarctata (rice
black bugs).
This study followed the standard procedures in conducting the insecticidal effect
of the plant extract against rice black bugs. To strengthen this study, the researcher
determined using qualitative analysis and the insecticidal activity through median lethal
dose (LD50). Each treatment was subjected to three replicates (R1, R2, and R3) using film
residue method.
This study used 8-9 mm adult rice black bugs as experimental animals. The
elliptica (Tubli) ethanolic root extract as applied to rice black bugs. Result of this study
could be a great help to the farmers. By this, they will be informed about the effectiveness
of Tubli root extract as an insecticide against rice black bugs. In this way, they can avail
be encouraged to plant more Tubli on their respective backyards and appreciate its
benefit in their living. In addition it can benefit the department of agriculture, they will be
guided and value the usefulness of Tubli as an organic insecticide. More to that, it can
make the community realize how this vine can be helpful to them and they will be
encouraged to make it as a part in their backyard. The university could get concerned
and promote conducting of thesis that contributes to the wellness of the society and is
very beneficial to everybody. The researcher can comply for his master’s degree but more
importantly this gives him a feeling of satisfaction and fulfilment as he helped for the
improvement of the community and his country. Lastly, the future researchers may have
proper and deeper understanding about insecticidal properties of plants and also this
research could serve as their guide or reference for future biological research.
Chapter II
This chapter contains some related literatures and related studies having bearing
on the study. This includes information regarding the phytochemical screening of the plant
secondary metabolites and the insecticidal evaluation concerning Deris elliptica Benth
Phytochemical Screening
principle from plant sources (Sunli, 2017). In addition, phytochemical screening is the first
thing to be done before major discoveries of molecules or drug entities are known. It is
used to provide concrete knowledge and research to what plant active constituents have
Alkaloids
are part of an organism's adaptation mechanism to its living environment. They are not
toxic when stored, but become toxic as a result of cell pH change. Also, these are
compounds needed for cell activity and gene code realization in the genotype. They are
biologically significant as active stimulators, inhibitors and terminators of growth, a part of
Lastly, Wanse and Kuete (2013) termed that alkaloids are one of the most diverse
activities.
Flavonoids
Szalay (2015) indicated that flavonoids are diverse group of phytonutrients (plant
chemicals) found in almost all fruits and vegetables. Along with carotenoids, they are
responsible for the vivid colors in fruits and vegetables. Flavonoids are the largest group
phytonutrients that fall into the chemical category of polyphenols. They're perhaps
most famous for their rich diversity of color-providing pigments. The name of these
phytonutrients actually derives from their color-related chemistry, with the Latin
word flavus meaning "yellow." As a group, however, flavonoids are highly bioactive
and play a wide variety of different roles in the health of plants, animals, and human
health.
Glycosides
Kumar (2016) stated that glycosides are natural substances that contain
carbohydrates where glycosidic part of the molecule (cyclic form of sugars) is connected
with organic radical that is not a sugar (aglycone or genin). Pharma Tutor (2016) added
that glycosides are define as organic compound from plants and animal source, which on
enzymatic hydrolysis gives one or more sugar moieties along with anon sugar moiety.
Moreover, glycosides are water soluble compounds and insoluble in the organic
solvents. The glycone part is water soluble, insoluble in the organic solvents. While the
aglycone part is water insoluble, soluble in the organic solvents. And some glycosides
Phenolic Compounds
Phenolic compounds from medicinal herbs and dietary plants include phenolic
anti-inflammatory effects) and also contribute to their inducing apoptosis by arresting cell
binding and cell adhesion, migration, proliferation or differentiation, and blocking signaling
Another characteristic of these substances is that they are presented commonly bound
to other molecules, frequently to sugars (glycosyl residue) and proteins. The existence of
phenolic compounds in free form also occurs in plant tissues. However, it is less common,
possibly because they are toxic when present in the free state and detoxified, at least in
Saponins
Liwa and Nwokocha (2017) affirmed that saponins are naturally occurring
surface-active glycosides produced by plants, lower marine animals, and some bacteria.
They occur constitutively in a great many plant species, in both wild plants and cultivated
crops. Yang and Yu (2014) added that by expressing a large diversity of structures on
both sugar chains and aglycones, saponins exhibit a wide range of biological and
saponins enables them to act as soaps and detergents as they can dissolve membranes;
however, since the saponins can hemolyze erythrocytes they are highly toxic if they reach
Steroids
compounds found in / derived from a variety of different marine, terrestrial, and synthetic
sources. All steroid classes and their metabolites play important roles in the physiology
and biochemistry of living organisms in which these are found (Sultan and Raza, 2015).
classified by a specific carbon structure. Steroids include drugs used to relieve swelling
and inflammation, such as prednisone and cortisone; vitamin D; and some sex hormones,
The term tannin refers to the use of tannins in tanning animal hides into leather;
however, the term is widely applied to any large polyphenolic compound containing
sufficient hydroxyls and other suitable groups to form strong complexes with proteins and
other macromolecules (Ashok and Upaddhyaya, 2012). Bate-Smith and Swain (2007)
between 500 and 3000; besides giving the usual phenolic reactions, they possess special
properties such as the ability to precipitate alkaloids, gelatin and other proteins”.
In nature the tannins are found worldwide in many different families of the higher
plants such as in chestnut and oak wood, Divi-Divi, Sumach, Myrobalaen, Trillo, Valonea
or plant galls; depending on their origin, their chemistry varies widely, having a molar
Terpenoids
in plants, a few of them have also been obtained from other sources. Terpenoids are
volatile substances which give plants and flowers their fragrance. They occur widely in
the leaves and fruits of higher plants, conifers, citrus and eucalyptus (Yadav, Yadav, and
Goyal, 2014).
Insecticidal Activity
Gilbert (2014) quantified that insecticides are pesticides that are used against
insects. Most modern insecticides act by poisoning the nervous system with a dose large
enough (relative to the insects' size) to be lethal. They can be of two types: organic and
organic. Organic are those that contains carbon while inorganic are those that do not
have (Bennett, 2012). Film Residue method (Amin et al, 2012) and LD50 determination
(Khaluquzzaman and Sultana, 2006; Overgaard, 2014) is usually the way used to
Flores and Santiago (2013) described Derris elliptica Benth (Tubli) as a rambling
climber, with branches covered with brown hairs. Leaves are pinnate and 30 to 50
centimeters long. Leaflets are usually oblong, 9 to 13, when matured smooth above, and
subglaucous and silky beneath, 10 to 15 centimeters long, and about half as broad.
Racemes are lax, 15 to 30 centimeters in length, with reddish flowers in stalked clusters.
Pods are 5 to 8 centimeters long and contain 1 to 3 seeds, flat and reniform, olive, brown
or black.
This plant is used as a pesticide. A compound obtained from the roots has been
used as a fish poison for quite some time, but more recently, it was discovered that it
(2005) described the eggs of rice black bugs as round, greenish or pinkish in color. The
eggs are laid in groups of 15 in parallel rows on the lower leaves near the water surface,
Tacio (2014) asserted that a black bug is only as big as a "black bean" but it is very
destructive. It sucks the juice from the midrib of leaves and panicles at the milk stage. In
most cases, it feeds on the basal part of the tillers most often at night. In addition, Catindig
(2015) reported that the insect is common in rained and irrigated wetland environments.
Damages are observed more frequently in dry season rice crops and densely planted
fields. Staggered planting of the rice crop and excessive nitrogen also favor the build-up
of the pest.
RELATED STUDIES
This section presents the local and foreign related studies for the better
understanding of this research. It may also present findings that can be used to strengthen
this study.
Foreign Studies
A study entitled “Screening for Larvicidal Activity in Some Thai Plants against Four
six ethanolic extracts from various parts of 84 Thai plant species were tested for their
tuberosa and Acorus calamus possessed high larvicidal activity, with LC50 values
between 16.0 and 48.2 mg/l. Petroleum ether (PE) and methanol (MeOH) extracts were
tested for their larvicidal activity against 4 mosquito vector species. The PE extract of R.
Anopheles dirus and Mansonia uniformis with LC50 values between 3.9 and 11.5 mg/l,
while the MeOH extract gave LC50 values of between 8.1 and 14.7 mg/l. D. elliptica PE
extract showed LC50 values of between 11.2 and 18.84 mg/l and the MeOH extract
Another study entitled “Effects of Some Herbal Plant Extracts against Pharaoh Ant,
The research was to evaluate the efficiency of three Thai herbs, i.e., tuba root (Derris
elliptica Benth.), yam bean seeds (Pachyrhizus erosus L.) and tea seed cake (Camellia
sp.) against adult worker of the Pharaoh ant (Monomorium pharaonis L.) The results
showed that the tuba root extracts exhibited LC50 against adult worker ca. 0.22 % w/v
whereas yam bean seed extracts showed LC50 against adult worker ca. 0.35 % w/v and
tea seed cake extracts showed LC50 against adult worker ca. 0.55 % w/v after 24 hours
exposure, respectively.
Additional study was made by (Akinbulumo, Fagbenro and, Fasakin, 2010) entitled
Fingerlings” where six graded concentrations of 0 (Control), 93, 139.5, 186, 232.5 & 279
mg/litre of Derris elliptica were used as treatments. These were applied in the form of
“A” served as the control). Ethanolic extracts of dried roots of D. elliptica were tested for
Toxic reaction exhibited by the fish includes discouration, gulping for air, erratic
swimming, loss of reflex, slow opercular movement and settling at the bottom motionless.
Tubli plant (Derris elliptica Benth.) root extract as mosquito larvicide compared to a
commercial larvicide (Abate 10SG). The experimental group treated with 100% Tubli
(Derris elliptica Benth.) root extract showed a perfect number of deaths (30 wrigglers).
The positive control group treated with the commercial larvicide also showed a great
number of deaths (26-29 wrigglers). The negative control group with only rain water
showed no deaths of larvae. Based from the data gathered, the researchers concluded
that extract from Tubli (Derris elliptica Benth) was more effective than the commercial
larvicide.
THEORETICAL AND CONCEPTUAL FRAMEWORK
The study basically exhibited the important relationship between the two variables:
the independent and the dependent variable. The phytochemical screening result of
Derris elliptica Benth was correlated with the dependent variable which is its insecticidal
property. The graphical representation of the Conceptual Framework of the study is show
on figure 1.
Screening
1. Derris elliptica Benth (Tubli) root extract does not exhibit insecticidal property.
Definition of terms
This section provides the significant terms that were used in the study provided
with their conceptual and operational meaning for the better understanding of the
research.
isolation of active principle from plant sources (Sunli, 2017). Operationally, it is the first
test in the study used to determine the secondary metabolites present in Tubli root extract.
or control their growth (Perveen, 2012). Operationally, it was the second test that was
branches covered with brown hairs. Leaves are pinnate and 30 to 50 centimeters long.
Leaflets are usually oblong, 9 to 13, when matured smooth above, and subglaucous and
silky beneath, 10 to 15 centimeters long, and about half as broad. Racemes are lax, 15
centimeters long and contain 1 to 3 seeds, flat and reniform, olive, brown or black.
Operationally, it was used as the sample plant and its insecticidal effect against rice black
obtained by removing the active constituents of the drug using ethanol as solvents
(Farflex, 2012). Operationally, it was the form of the Tubli root extract used in the study.
among rice (Pablico, 2007). Operationally, it was used as experimental animal subjected
in the evaluation.
Chapter III
METHODOLOGY
This chapter contains the procedures that were used in conducting the study. It
gave details on the progress of the study that were done in a step-by-step method. The
following were included: Research Design Materials and Methods, Experimentation and
Research Design
This section covers the design on how the procedures or the methods of the study
were done. The first test was phytochemical screening for the root extract’s existing
secondary metabolites. The second test which is the most important was the insecticidal
property evaluation that were tested in rice black bugs, the experiment animals.
The researcher used lethal dosage lethality test in the study for the evaluation of
the insecticidal activity of Derris elliptica Benth root extract. It was used in measuring the
results on the insecticidal experiment because it is suited to the experiment that contains
(Avocado Bark)
bbn
Plant Root
Extract
Phytochemical
Insecticidal Activity
Screening
Evaluation
Alkaloids R1
T1 R2
Flavonoids R3
R1
Glycosides T2 R2
R3
Phenolic Compounds
R1
T3 R2
Saponins
R3
Steroids
Tannins
Terpenoids
specimen undergone rota evaporation and the crude extract was subjected to test the
presence of secondary metabolites and insecticidal property of the plant’s root extract.
qualitative analysis.
Lethal dose (LD50) method was used for the evaluation of the second test, the
insecticidal property of Derris elliptica Benth (Tubli) root extract. Lethal dose (LD50)
method was also used in measuring the results because it is suited to an experiment
involving only small number of treatments. The insecticidal activity of Derris elliptica Benth
(Tubli) was studied against rice black bugs (Scotinophara coarctata) using residual film
method. There were five treatments for the test; T1= 50% concentration, T2= 75%
concentration, T3= 100% concentration root extract. Each treatment had three
replications.
Research Locale
Plant materials were gathered from Purok 7, Brgy. Kinilis, Polomolok, South
Cotabato. The phytochemical screening analysis and the insecticidal activity evaluation
The samples of this study were 150 adult rice black bugs (8-9mm taken from a rice
field situated at Brgy. Lumakil, Polomolok, South Cotabato. For the insecticidal activity
evaluation, the samples were separated in three groups with three replication each which
Photo credit to: Google map Brgy. Lumakil, Polomolok, South Cotabato
Research Procedures
This section shows the procedures followed by the researcher in conducting the
study. The flow chart was used to show how the study can be done and served as the
researcher’s guide in conducting the study. It demonstrated how the two tests were
directed, the following are: phytochemical screening and the insecticidal activity
evaluation.
Gathering of Plant
Samples
Plant Extraction
Phytochemical Insecticidal
Screening Activity Test
Film Residue
Method
Calculation of %
Mortality
Probit Analysis
(LD50)
The materials that were used in this research are the; micropipettes, disposable
gloves, test tubes, beaker, stirring rod, filter paper, rotary evaporator, Erlenmeyer flask,
funnel, Petri dish, test tubes, cling wrap, rice black bugs.
Preliminary Procedures
This gives information about the equipment that were used in conducting the
experiments. It also include the processes on how the plant specimen were gathered and
prepared, which were used in the experiment. In addition, it contains standard methods
or protocols for the following tests of phytochemical screening and the insecticidal
property activity evaluation. This supported the researcher in conducting the study in an
organized manner.
Fresh roots of Derris elliptica Benth (Tubli) were collected from at Brgy. Domolok,
Alabel, Sarangani Province. The gathered roots were freed from any external stimuli like
insects.
The collected roots were thoroughly washed with distilled water and weighed at
exactly 1 kg. After drying, the roots were pounded using mortar and pestle until powdered.
The powdered material was soaked in the 80% ethanol for 8 hours. The mixture was
filtered using the filter paper, funnel, and beaker to separate the solid residue from the
supernatant. The supernatant was placed in the beaker and was transferred in the rotary
evaporating flask and placed in the rotary evaporator to evaporate ethanol. The crude
Phytochemical Screening
The procedures for the phytochemical screening were adopted from Chichioco-
distilled water added with 3 drops of Wagner’s reagent (2 g iodine and 6 g potassium
iodide in 100 mL water). Formation of a blue black precipitate confirmed the presence of
alkaloids.
NaOH, followed by the addition of HCl. A yellow to orange solution with NaOH that turned
To test for tannins, about 2 mL of the extract was dissolved in 5 mL distilled water
water. The mixture was then cooled and shaken vigorously. Frothing would indicate the
presence of saponins.
CHCl3 followed by layering with H2SO4. The formation of a reddish brown coloration in
experiment. First, is the addition of one drop of 15% FeCl3 to 2 mL extract. Afterwhich
was the layering of the solution with 1mL concentrated H2SO4. Formation of a brown ring
The presence of phenolic compounds was tested by adding 1% FeCl3 to the 2mL
extract. Formation of a green, purple, blue or black solution implies the presence of
phenolic compounds.
This method was used to determine if the plant specimen Derris elliptica Benth
(Tubli) root extract is possible as an alternative insecticide. The researcher used the film
A total of 150 8-9mm adult rice black bugs were collected from the rice field of
Brgy Lumakil, Polomolok, South Cotabato. The rice black bugs were placed in the
sterilized glass jar and were covered with nylon mesh held in place with rubber bands.
100% mortalities. Then, Derris elliptica Benth root extract were dissolved in 5 ml of
corresponding solvent to get concentrations of 50%, 75% and 100%, respectively, which
were as stock solutions. 1 ml of various concentrations for each sample were applied on
Petri dishes (9 cm diameter) in such a way that it made a uniform film over the Petri
dishes. For solvent evaporation, the Petri dishes were air dried leaving the extract on it.
After drying, 10 rice black bugs were released in each Petri dish with three replications.
A control batch was also maintained with the same number of insects after preparing the
Petri dish by applying and evaporating the solvent only. The treated black bugs were
placed in an incubator at the same temperature as reared in stock cultures and the
mortality of the black bugs were counted after 2 hours post-exposure (Islam et al., 2004).
Statistical Treatment
analyzed using median lethal dose. LD50 were determined from the counts of different
doses in different time of exposure. With Probit analysis method also described by Finney
(1971). Mean percent mortality of rice black bugs was subjected to one way analysis of
there is a significant difference among and between treatments in terms of the plant