Module 3 Handson - Solutions
Module 3 Handson - Solutions
Module 3 Handson - Solutions
Problem 1:
Prove the following argument is valid. Show your work step by step.
P: car is full
S: sunny.
L: lunchtime.
1) P S
2) S V L
3) L
-----------------------
P
4) S from 2 and 3
5) S P C.P of step 1
6) P from 4 and 4
Problem 2:
Prove the following argument is valid. Show your work step by step.
1) A (C D)
2) A B
3) B
----------------
C
4) B A C.P of 2
5) A from 3 and 4
6) (C D) from 1 and 5
7) C from 6
Problem 3:
Prove the following argument is valid. Show your work step by step.
1) P Q
2) P (Q R)
3) S R
----------------
S
4) P from 1
5) (Q R) from 4 and 2
6) Q V R from 5
7) Q from 1
8) R from 6 and 7
9) R S C.P. of 3
10) S from 8 and 9
Problem 4:
Determine whether the following argument is valid: show your work step by step.
1) p
2) p q
3) s r
4) r q
----------------
st
5) q from 1 and 2
6) q r C.P. of 4
7) r from 5 and 6
8) s from 7 and 3
9) s t from 8
Problem 5:
If I get my salary raise AND my friends are free, I will take a canoe trip with my friends.
If my friends don't find a job before spring break, then they will be free.
I got my salary raise and my friends did NOT find a job before spring break.
Therefore, I will take a canoe trip with my friends!
S: my salary raise
D: my friends are free,
P: I will take a canoe trip with my friends.
Q: my friends find a job before spring break,
1) S D P
2) Q D
3) S Q
-------------------
P
4) Q from 3
5) D from 2 and 4
6) S from 3
7) S D from 5 and 6
8) P from 1 and 7
Problem 6:
Give a direct proof of the following:
x+y is odd?
2*a +1 + 2*b =2*a + 2*b +1
= 2(a+b) + 1
= 2 * w + 1, where w = a+b
Thus, x+y is odd
X= 2 * a
Y=2*b
X+Y
2*a+2*b
2 * (a+b)
2 * W, where W = a+b