Assessment of Solid Waste Management in Liberia
Assessment of Solid Waste Management in Liberia
Assessment of Solid Waste Management in Liberia
July 2007
United Nations Environment Programme
P.O. Box 30552
Nairobi
Kenya
Tel: +254 (0)20 762 1234
Fax: +254 (0)20 762 3927
E-mail: [email protected]
Web: http://www.unep.org
Table of Contents
1 Background ...................................................................................................................4
2 Mission Objectives........................................................................................................4
3 Study Approach.............................................................................................................4
4 Findings .........................................................................................................................5
4.1 Legal and Institutional Setting ...............................................................................5
4.2 Institutional Capacity and Infrastructure ...............................................................6
4.3 Role of the International Community.....................................................................9
4.4 Potential Role of the Private Sector......................................................................10
4.5 Raising Public Awareness and Community Involvement .....................................11
5 Recommendations......................................................................................................13
Endnotes.......................................................................................................................14
1 Background z The management of hazardous healthcare
waste (HHCW); and
UNEP has been active in Liberia since 2003, initially z The identification of the necessary components
undertaking a post conflict assessment and later, for long-term, sustainable improvements within
in 2005, establishing a field office for providing the waste management sector.
capacity building assistance. During one of the
z Increase awareness by a one-day workshop was
recently concluded capacity building workshops,
conducted for some forty (40) representatives of
it became evident that management of solid
relevant public and private sector stakeholders
waste remains a key issue to be addressed in the
within the waste management field.
country. With increasing population, changing
consumption patterns and economic growth, it is
likely that solid waste generation is going to increase 3 Study Approach
significantly. Already, Liberia’s waste management
sector faces tremendous difficulties, due to various The work was split into three segments:
factors, including: unclear and over-lapping legal
mandates and responsibilities; inadequate institutional A) Pre-mission Data Gathering: This included
framework; poor enforcement mechanisms; extremely collection of all available information on issues
weak technical and human capacity within the associated with waste management in Liberia as
government sector; low level of public awareness on well as similar countries around the world.
health-waste management linkages; and a complete
absence of cost recovery mechanisms. B) During the Mission: Throughout the ten day
mission and the one day workshop, which was
At the request of the Environmental Protection hosted by the EPA, stakeholders from the following
Agency of Liberia (EPA), UNEP conducted a technical organizations were met:
mission to study both the technical and institutional
issues associated with solid waste management z Government Departments: Ministry of Transport;
in Liberia. The mission was hosted by the EPA and Ministry of Internal Affairs; Ministry of Lands,
undertaken between 17 – 27 June 2007. This report Mines & Energy; Ministry of Public Works; Ministry
summarizes its findings. of Health and Social Welfare; Ministry of Labour;
Grand Bassa County Superintendent.
z The public institutional framework for waste z Civil Society: Genisis Ltd; Global Alliance
management; Ltd; Sanitors & Services Ltd; Liberia Marketing
z Existing operational practices and facilities; Association (LMA); JKF Hospital; Liberia
Government Hospital in Buchanan; DUCOR
z Participation of local NGOs and CBOs within
Ltd; International Rescue (IRC); Jurubbal (NGO,
the waste management sector;
Kakata); MSF; Power TV; Clar TV; Real TV.
z Existing cost recovery mechanisms, if any;
In addition, field visits were made to a number of
z Public education initiatives and technologies;
locations with waste management problems, waste
z The capacity of the private sector to deliver management sites, new community and private
waste management services; sector initiatives.
These three authoritative documents all mention 1. The Environmental Protection Agency (EPA)
the waste management sector, taken from is primarily in charge of setting up (develop
different angles. In the Act creating the EPA waste and publish) national guidelines for solid
management is approached as a cross-cutting waste management in Liberia, environmental
issue as this law deals more with institutional quality standards (and related penalties and
settings than with substantive sectoral activity. fines), and ensuring compliance for pollution
Whereas the Act Adopting the Environment control. It should also provide guidelines for
Management in Liberia 5
the preparation of environmental impact (MCC), MCC Ordinances’ Chapters 1 and 7
assessments (EIAs), audits/inspections and (1975), designate various departments of MCC as
environmental licenses/permits for engineered being in charge of municipal waste disposal sites,
landfill sites (as articulated in section 64 of the prohibition of the littering, and requiring residents
Act Adopting the National Environmental Policy to clean in front, and around, their properties
of the Republic of Liberia). The Act creating the up to the sidewalk. Furthermore, Chapter 7 of
EPA also mentions, in section 34, the creation of MCC’s Ordinances stipulates that all residents
an Environmental Administrative Court, which, in Monrovia shall pay various monthly fees for
as of today, is still not established. solid waste collection and disposal. However,
as the charges for the planning, development,
2. The Ministry of Health and Social Welfare operation and maintenance of the solid waste
(MHSW) has, through its Division of
management systems and equipments are
Environmental and Occupational Health, the
largely divided among various MCC departments,
mandate to assess “the environmental health
this, with other contributing factors discussed later,
of the population”. This grants this Division
eventually results in the total paralysis of the waste
the power to conduct sanitary inspections
management in Monrovia.
evaluate compliance with the Public Health
Law. Nonetheless, as of today, no Hazardous An overview of the above mentioned legal mandates
Health Care Waste (HHCW) management demonstrates clearly the overlap and imprecise
guidelines or standards have been established division of responsibilities between the various public
by the Ministry. authorities, as on the one hand between the EPA,
3. The Ministry of Lands, Mines and Energy the MHSW and the municipalities on the monitoring
(MLME) hosts the Liberian Hydrological role, and on the other hand the MLME and the MPW
Service (LHS) whose responsibility is to evaluate on their respective responsibilities for preparing
urban sanitation projects, such as to provide engineered landfill sites.
guidance for the geotechnical investigation
of engineered landfill sites. 4.2 Institutional Capacity and
Infrastructure
4. The Ministry of Public Works (MPW) is in
principle responsible for the installation of In terms of figures, the World Bank Technical Paper
the entire infrastructure required for waste No 426, Solid Waste Landfalls in Middle and Low
management delivery services, including Income Countries, gives a waste generation rate
waste collection and transfer stations, and the of 0.5kg/day/cap, plus a further 0.1kg/day/cap for
construction of engineered landfill sites. commercial waste, which gives an overall figure
of 0.7kg/day/cap4. Thus for Monrovia, with an
5. The Municipalities have been granted, by
estimated population of 1.3 million, the average
the Public Health Law of 1975 (still valid), the
generation rate is of some 780/tones/day.
responsibility of ensuring clean and sanitary
environmental conditions on the territory under their
Waste composition in Monrovia
respective jurisdictions. They are thus responsible
Component % by weight
for sanitation activities including the cleaning,
Paper 10.0
collection and disposal of generated solid Glass, Ceramics 1.2
waste. In theory, they should receive their annual Metals 2.0
operating budget from the Government, through Plastics 13.0
the Ministry of Internal Affairs, but discussions Leather, Rubber 0.2
Wood, Bones, Straw 4.6
with various municipal officials in Grand Bassa,
Textiles 6.0
Montserrado or Margibi Counties confirmed
Vegetable /Putrescible 43.0
that these financial transfers are currently non- Miscellaneous Items 20.0
existent, apparently partly due to the early stage Total 100
of the decentralization reform process. Internal Density 250 kg/m3
regulations of the Monrovia City Corporation Waste Management Plan for Monrovia, UNICEF-DFID, August 2004
Municipalities
Facility Operation,
Maintenance and
Management
Private Sector
Construction,
Management of
Operation and
Maintenance
Management in Liberia 7
deviant behaviors) and of any enforcement forum
(court or judge) makes the “polluter pays principle”
inapplicable within Liberia today.
Management in Liberia 9
The Liberian Employment Action Plan (LEAP;
z it is noted that the ILO project does include a
ILO project component II) that will focus on capacity-building component for private
empowering community based organizations sector operators and communities5.
(CBOs) in order to enhance the sustainability
of the previous clean-up activities. This project Presently, as far as the international community’s
will run for approximately a further 2.5 years. efforts are concerned, sanitation is not an area
Activities will include moving waste from the of focus in the 2007 joint programming exercise
house-holds, possibly in wheelbarrows, to the of the Liberia UN Country Team (see annex 10).
collection points, and discouraging the dumping Furthermore, UNEP should actively engage in joint
of waste into drainage channels and rivers. programmes and seize the opportunity to raise the
profile and catalyse intervention within the waste
These two on-going projects, WB-UNDP and ILO, are management sector.
currently the two main initiatives supported by the
international community in the waste management 4.4 The Potential Role of the Private
sector. However, a few concerns can be identified Sector
with these ongoing international approaches:
During meetings between the UNEP team and
z First of all, they usually target exclusively the representatives of all of the key government
capital (except for a quick-impact project ministries, the future role of the private sector within
of UNMIL in Buchanan) and largely ignore Liberia for the delivery of waste management
communities outside of the capital. Further, out services was endorsed and actively supported.
of necessity, they select certain communities This is in large part due to the chronic failure of the
within Monrovia (as 120 skip-bins and 8 trucks government sector throughout Liberia to provide
will only be able to cater for about 30% of reliable waste management services to the
the waste generated on a daily basis within communities, particularly outside of Monrovia.
Monrovia). Experience elsewhere in West
Africa suggests that this may result in tension Indeed, in many countries of the world, including
within communities who are beneficiaries of Africa, the privatization of waste management
this project and those not catered for. services is often seen as the only viable option,
and potentially offers higher quality of service
z Secondly, these projects can potentially at competitive prices, allowing the government
disturb the emerging markets within the waste sector to focus on the roles of monitoring and
management sector, and as a consequence enforcement of services. On this matter, the
damage the fledgling private sector African Development Bank’s guidelines for waste
involvement. For example, at UNEP’s recent management state that private enterprises
workshop, a number of newly established may play a role in vastly improving solid waste
private contractors complained that they are management services in Africa 6. However, it
loosing clients who will now benefit from the should be noted that compared to developed-
‘free’ WB funded waste collection services country models, the African models require greater
within their neighbourhoods. involvement of the communities in the process.
Community Based Organizations (CBOs) may
Thirdly, the projects aim for ‘quick-employment’
z play a role in providing solid waste management
and, as a consequence, are not able to address services from pre-collection to recycling and
the components of sustainability within the waste composting.
management sector, such as cost-recovery, public
education, and enforcement mechanisms. It is encouraging to note that in spite of the difficult
conditions existing in Monrovia for the establishment
z Fourthly, a crucial element that is missing into of a private waste management sector, there are
these programmes is a capacity-building some very promising developments. It is noteworthy
component, whose beneficiaries among that a small, but significant, number of private
others should be the EPA and MCC in their contractors have commenced operations within
monitoring and coordinating role. Nonetheless, Monrovia. Further, their participation in UNEP’s
Management in Liberia 11
from work, and decreased productivity due to
illness,…) are generally higher than the cost of a
waste management service that would remove the
conditions prejudicial to public health, such as
the presence, accumulation and decomposition
of garbage in close proximity to low-income
housing, in which children often play and relieve
themselves, and public markets.
Management in Liberia 13
Endnotes
1. Article 7 of the Liberia Constitution (6 January 1986): “The Republic shall, consistent with the principles
of individual freedom and social justice enshrined in this Constitution, manage the national
economy and the natural resources of Liberia in such manner as shall ensure the maximum feasible
participation of Liberian citizens under conditions of equality as to advance the general welfare of
the Liberian people and the economic development of Liberia.”
2. Article 20 of the Liberia Constitution (6 January 1986): “a. No person shall be deprived of life…”
3. Section 38 2) “The Agency shall, in consultation with the relevant Line Ministry, issue guidelines for
the handling, storage, transportation, segregation, disposal and treatment of hazardous waste.”
Section 39 1) “The Agency (…) shall develop and publish national guidelines for solid waste
management”.
4. These figures have been confirmed by the ILO and UNICEF-DFID studies.
5. See in annex the programme of an ILO-MCC workshop called “Start your Waste Collection Business”
and the project document of component 2 of the ILO project focusing on “Employment Creation
Through the Involvement of CBOs/micro enterprises in a PPP arrangement for solid waste management
in Monrovia”.
6. Study on Solid Waste Management Options for Africa, The African Development Bank-PSDU, July 2002.
Further technical information may be obtained from the UNEP Post-Conflict Assessment Unit website at:
http://postconflict.unep.ch/